Reviews

Circle of Fire by S. M. Hall

cover image

Maya Brown Missions. Francis Lincoln Children's Books, 2011.
(Age 11+) Fifteen year old Maya Brown is living with her grandmother because a threat has been made by a terrorist group to kidnap her. Pam, her mother, is a British security chief and is obviously too close to the truth about planned attacks. However, in a bizarre twist, it is Pam who is kidnapped and Maya decides to rescue her.
This quick moving story delivers 'mystery, intrigue and danger', as promised on the cover. Along the way it briefly introduces other themes.Maya, we find, has been adopted after terrorists had killed her entire family in Kosovo, for being Muslim.  Ironically now she is chasing a Muslim extremist group and we learn some of their traditions and views along the way. Jamila, a teenage girl whom Maya befriends wants to be a doctor but her father declares: 'she doesn't need a career to get married. Her husband will provide.' The causes of terrorism and race conflict are touched upon.
Having a female role model in an adventure or crime story should appeal to both boys and girls alike. This book is a fast, easy read aimed at young adults from 11+. It is the fifth novel from Sylvia Hall, who uses her teaching background to good effect in using appropriate language and content. It lacks a little realism and depth but meets its target audience. Circle of Fire will appeal to readers who like Robert Muchamore and Anthony Horowitz books.
The book also includes the first chapter of the sequel, Breaking the circle, which will be released in early 2012.
Kay Haarsma (Salisbury East HS)

Forgotten by Cat Patrick

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2011. ISBN: 9781921690624.
Highly recommended for ages 12+. Every morning, when London wakes, she peruses the notes she has written the previous day. These give her information relevant to the new day ahead and brief her on events from her past. Although she can 'remember' things yet to happen in her future, her memories of previous days are erased from her memory at 4:33 every morning. When she meets Luke, a new boy at her school, she is concerned that she cannot see him in her future. As her love for him grows, she tries desperately not to forget him and find a way to slot him into her memories. She ponders whether or not to include him from her notes at night. At the same time, she tries to uncover the truth behind some of the memories with which she is plagued on a daily basis and continue to unsettle her.
This truly is a book which one wishes to devour in a single sitting. London, as the main protagonist, appears fragile, troubled and sincere, filled with love for Luke but confused as to whether or not they can possibly share a future. Luke is reliable, strong, consistent and determined in his concern and love for London. As a reader, one can hardly help but want to become involved in trying to find a way to see the relationship flourish and help explain the mystery which is unearthed by London's memories. This is a truly engaging novel, one to re-visit and read more slowly the second time.
Jo Schenkel

Excalibur, the legend of King Arthur a graphic novel by Tony Lee and Sam Hart

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 978 1 406321593.
(Ages 9+) Warmly recommended. Each book about King Arthur is so different! In this one, Arthur the boy is taken by Merlin to Avalon where over two nights in real time but 2 years in Avalon time, he develops the skills needed to defeat his father's killer, Ulric, and take his rightful place as King of England, Albion. Here he falls in love with Vivianne but his memory of her is erased so that he will marry Guinevere and so set in place the events which are foretold. Lancelot, a cousin of Vivianne, vows his life to Arthur, but seeing Guinevere falls for her and the two cause an enormous rift in the relationships at court. In the meantime, Arthur's half sister, Morgana is plotting and things come to a head towards the end of the book when Arthur must meet his enemies head on.
An exciting take on the Arthurian legends, the plot dives and twists, keeping the reader alert and involved. The illustrations are breathtaking. Huge men dominate the pages, striding across the landscape, holding weaponry which is sure to make the reader's blood run cold. Excalibur is a huge golden sword, often held aloft, noisily making its presence felt in the bloody battle scenes. The movement, intricate design and boldness of the illustrations will entertain and excite the readers as they follow Arthur's fight for Albion.
Fran Knight

Don't wake the beastie by Dawn Casey

cover image

Ill. by Kirsteen Harris-Jones, Bloomsbury, 2011. ISBN 978 14088 00027.
The animals spy a hive at the top of the tree, full of lovely dripping honey. But it is too high for any of them to climb up and get, and there is a beastie asleep beneath the tree that none of them wishes to wake. What to do? Each tries in turn, the one climbing up on the shoulders of the one before. The donkey, pig, the lamb, the dog and the chook all climb onto each other's backs in an attempt to get the honey but inevitably their tower collapses, waking the beastie.
A wonderful tale of co-operation, endeavour and achievement, this book will be well used in classes in the junior primary school as a lead in to discussions about those values. The repetition of the sentences will encourage children to predict what is going to happen next as well as multiply their involvement and interest in the story and the words. I loved the way the words are not prescriptive, the author using an array of words, some of which will be unfamiliar but will help create an atmosphere where new words can be discussed. She also uses words about the animals which will be used by the astute teacher in talking about animals in the classroom. The illustrations are infectious, funny and fluid, with the words spaced across the page underlining the movement of the animals and the story.
Fran Knight

Ransom by David Malouf

cover image

Ages: Senior students and adults. Fiction. Highly recommended. The story of the Greeks besieging the city of Troy is an age old legend, part of the group of stories which make up The Illiad and The Odyssey. Many versions of the tales have been published but none like this. Malouf's retelling of the story of the ransom paid for Hector's body is captivating, the frailties and inconsistencies of those involved revealed for the reader, their back stories told with understanding and sympathy. 
When Achilles takes umbrage at Agamemnon claiming his prize, the enslaved girl, Briseis, he retreats to his tent, refusing to fight alongside his leader. As a result, his best friend and companion, Patroclus dons Achilles' armour to lead the field, losing his life as a consequence. Achilles' grief is overwhelming and his resultant fight with Hector, sees Hector being killed. Instead of allowing the Trojans to retrieve the body of their king's son, their hero, for a proper burial, Achilles ties the body to his chariot and every day for eleven days, drives it around the walls of Troy. Each day the gods renew Hector's body, making it seem recently killed.
King Priam, desperate to bury his son, has a humble cart loaded with treasure and rides out to meet Achilles and beg for his son's body. The carter, a day labourer from the market place, is unsure of how to treat his king, but his natural instincts take over as he realises that the king is an innocent, used to such a different life that he must take some leadership and direct his moves with sympathy and thoughtfulness.
The story of the reason for the ransom being paid, the debate within his household for Priam to do such an unheard of thing, the journey to the Greek encampment and the bargaining between Priam and Achilles is given a fresh retelling in this book. As Malouf says in his afterword, some of the stories he uses in this book take only a few lines in The Illiad, but he fleshes out the story to give us a narrative rich with the thoughts and actions behind the deeds.
The reader falls into the windy plains of Troy to listen to the motives behind some of the events which although thousands of years old, have resonance in today's world as the events of September 11, 2001 provided the impetus for this writing.
Fran Knight

Judy Moody, Girl detective by Megan McDonald

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 978 1 4002 27435.
(Ages 9+) Humour. Warmly recommended. Judy Moody passionately following the stories of Nancy Drew, finds herself developing the skills needed to be a detective, through finding things lost at home. But when the local policeman, Officer Kopp and his police dog arrive at school for a show and tell, Judy's imagination takes over. She is invited onto the stage to hide something for the dog, Mr Chipps to find and gives him a sound workout trying vainly to trick him.
And the very next day, when Mr Chipps goes missing, Judy sees it as a personal mission to find the dog and return it to Officer Kopp. She and the members of her club, Rodney, Frank and Stick decide on action. They go to Officer Kopp's house and offer their services and are asked to put up posters around the district. Judy and her crew investigate the scene of the crime and from there much mayhem and fun ensues and the quartet go about their business. All good fun, a light read with easily identifiable characters, this will be a popular choice amongst middle primary readers, especially those already entranced with Judy Moody.
Fran Knight

I am Thomas by Libby Gleeson and Amin Greder

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 978 1742373331.
(Ages 8+) Highly recommended. Thomas is different. He is very aware of his difference. He tells us in the first few pages that he is nor like his brother nor the other students in his school. He retreats to his headphones as all around him tells him that he will be a failure and not amount to anything. He is told that people are ashamed of him and this is in the same page as the order to clean his room, brush his teeth and show respect. All the instructions given to kids are listed as he watches the array of grey people around him who offer him a place to go. The army offers serving his country, religion offers forgiveness of sins, a politician offers being part of a democracy, but they are all the same, grey and the same, expecting him to be the same as they are. The bleak view of the world is an amalgam of all that is nasty, the cloying religious zealot, the braying army personnel, the priest offering him the seat next to him, the leering politician, the overwhelming teachers, the dictatorial father and yet the crying, impassive mother. A fascinating mix of a world which is absolutely nasty. Rejecting all the pressures to conform, he boards a bus, taking his life in his own hands.
The illustrations of Thomas' journey to retain his individuality are amazing. The grey suited men who surround Thomas with promises and exhortations create a claustrophobic atmosphere on many of the pages. The men and the few women are remote, removed, emotionless, and often portray a dictatorial approach when trying to deal with Thomas, the outsider. The first few pages show us what Thomas likes, the model of a plane, a globe, an atlas, but as the pages progress the colours become more grey, the things depicted more redolent of authority and rules, just as the last few pages revert from rules to freedom on the bus, as colour becomes more obvious. As Thomas rejects the sterile paths offered to him, colour returns once again. And watch out for the contrasting items on the pages. On one page is depicted Thomas' sandshoes, lying almost together, open with laces askew, but further up the page in black and white is a pair of shoes, neatly laced, side by side with the boot polish and brush neatly next to the shoes. On another page, a man is rejecting the musical instruments in the corner, the chess set is left awry and so on. Little gems are there to be explored and savoured.
A most interesting book, readers will have much to discuss with their teacher or parents as they sit together and read both the words and the illustrations, discussing authority, rules, institutions, free will, fitting in - the list is endless, and the bleak world portrayed too will be the cause of discussion about what there is to be thankful for.
Fran Knight

A bit lost by Chris Haughton

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 978 1406333831.
Picture book. When the baby owl falls from the top of the tree where he is perusing the forest with his mum, he becomes lost. Not just a little lost, but lost. He must ask the other animals for help, and in describing his mother through a few words, augmented by actions, is taken to a variety of other animals in his search. Because he says she is big, he is taken to a bear, when he describes his mother's pointy ears, he is taken to a rabbit, and so on, until finally he is taken to the right mother, who is searching for him.
A warm book about family and the relationship between mother and child, this story will be told and retold in the early childhood units. Read aloud, the story will serve the purpose of reinforcing the relationship, of introducing animals and their offspring or of simply telling a tale, inviting the students to share their knowledge. The warmth of the mother and her baby both looking for each other, the positive tale of the animals helping each other with the owl inviting the animals to her perch as a thank you resulting in a twist in the tale, is charming. The bald, block colour illustrations hide things which children can search for, while the bold colour is refreshing in its simplicity.
Fran Knight

Twelfth grade kills by Heather Brewer

cover image

Dutton Children's Books, 2010. ISBN 9780525422242.
This is the fifth and final book in The Chronicles of Vladimir Tod series. Vlad is about to face his final year of high school, but only if he lives long enough. There are so many people trying to kill him that it is by no means certain he will even make it to his last year at high school or survive it if he does.
In this last book, the author draws together all the strands and unanswered questions from the previous books. The prime one as to whether Vlad's father is still alive is finally answered.
As usual Vlad is having a hard time deciding just who to trust although he can always rely on his friend and drudge Henry and Nelly his guardian. There is also the question of whether Vlad is as the prophecy suggest, the Pravus and if so will he really enslave the human race.
I have enjoyed the series and this book is no exception.  Vlad has grown in each of the stories as have the other characters.  Here everything that he has been hoping for appears to be happening but not everyone is what they seem and Vlad finds himself doubting even those he trusts the most. To the author's credit all of these issues are resolved and at the end Vlad finds himself sadder but wiser. I think that readers will want more and perhaps there is room for more Chronicles as Vlad moves on from high school.
David Rayner

The girl with death breath and other naughty stories for good boys and girls by Christopher Milne

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2011. ISBN: 978 19211690563.
Highly recommended for children aged 8 and above. When Doris is teased about her bad breath, she decides to make it even worse to pay back those who have been cruel to her. Penny and Michelle Dyer want to help their family make millions by collecting the kerb-side recycling and aim to re-sell the goods they find. The kids in the Underground Cubby Club are sick of Bulldog Brown being such a bully so they team up but what will they do to stop him? Steven Everett has been told he is useless so he decides to run away from home. Is there anything that would make him go home or feel better about himself?
All seven of the short stories in this book tell of kids who aren't quite perfect. Milne's sense of humour and memories of being a child are evident in this collection as he shows children in everyday situations. Each story has elements of the 'good boys and girls' as well as showing their faults. No matter what the scenario, one can draw a moral or lesson from the story. This series originated some time back, with Milne self-publishing. The very formal looking covers of the original books hid the true contents but, once introduced to the series, children devoured them. With the new look covers and illustrations, these will continue to be on loan instead of on library shelves. Readers visiting Milne's website are greeted with rude noises and illustrations from the books, a great marketing tool for attracting the disinclined reader!
Jo Schenkel

Dead Certain by Sally Gould

cover image

Lightning Strikes series. Walker, 2011. ISBN: 9781921529900.
Max's uncle Jack has died and, during the funeral service, Max discovers that the body is about to be cremated. This goes directly against Jack's wishes to be buried alongside his father. The problem, now, is that Max is the only person who seems to have heard Jack's final request. How is he going to stop the cremation to help his much loved uncle, when no one will listen to him? Thus follows a series of events in which Max tries to tell Dad the truth and, when Dad won't listen, he enlists his brother Charlie to help set things to rights.
Max shows determination, persistence and loyalty to his uncle as he endeavours to fulfill his uncle's wishes but not everything goes exactly to plan. This adds a touch of humour to what could otherwise be a rather more serious story. Containing less than 80 pages of print and with a clear double spaced font, this title provides an easily accessible and relatively entertaining tale, within the reach of even the most reluctant reader.
Jo Schenkel

Entice by Carrie Jones

cover image

Bloomsbury Publishing, 2011. ISBN: 9781408810446.
Nick and Zara are soul mates. They are meant to be together, forever. However Nick is gone, he has been taken to a place for warriors, Valhalla. There is a chance that Zara can get him back, but will he want to? Zara has been turned Pixie, worse she's a Pixie queen. Will Nick still love her?
This novel falls into the fantasy genre and carries the theme of getting back someone you have lost, as well as doing almost anything to get them back. The style of writing uses a fair amount of imagery and symbolism. Incorporated are complex sentences that give you a complex story which isn't always easy to process, but it all comes together at the end and makes sense. The plot is not straightforward, it is complex like the story. Some things you will see coming, then it will change or something will unexpectedly happen.
The book is mostly set in the vicinity of the town of Bedford, UK and in Iceland, as well as in Valhalla. The story appears to take place over about three weeks and you don't always know straight away what time of day it is. The characters themselves are not the kind of people that you would actually meet in reality, but they are very believable and in some ways they act like regular people.
I would recommend this novel more for girls than boys and for the 15 - 25 age group. It is a great book and I think it deserves 10/10 stars.
Amelia Kelly (Student)

The wilful eye, Isobelle Carmody and Nan McNab (editors)

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 978 1 74237 440 6
(Ages 14+) Fantasy, Recommended. The first group of short stories in the series, Tales from the Tower, promised much when reading that 6 authors were given the task of revamping a fairy tale to give it a more up to date tweak. But unsurprisingly, looking at the talents of the authors represented here, Carmody, Harland, Mahy, Murray, Lanagan and Borelli, the stories are fresh and fantastic.
The reworking of stories by the Brothers Grimm and Hans Christian Anderson give us a remarkable array of tales to provoke fear, wonder and warnings.
Catastrophic disruption of the head by Margo Lanagan is an unsettling take on Andersen's The tinderbox, one of the scariest fairy tales of all time. The story bludgeons the reader into thinking about warfare. Eternity by Rosie Borella a reworking of The Snow Queen, tells the tale in a modern, drug-taking scene. Margaret Mahy's Wolf Night has a gang of Headloppers chasing her hero and heroine in suburban Woodlands, changing the scene from known to the unknown, and getting under the readers' skin. Richard Harland's Heart of the beast, was fascinating with its take on Beauty and the beast, but this time extolling the virtues of love and the family. I found the story by Martine Murray disturbing with the boys kept as prisoners in the tower in One window. And of course, Isobelle Carmody's take on Rumpelstiltskin was original and frightening.
The book includes a fascinating introduction by Isobelle Carmody, and an afterword follows each story with the thoughts of each author outlining their writing process and inspiration. These tales are not for the young. They are frightening but also challenge the readers with their universal themes, black humour and parallels to known stories. Volume 2 will be just as enjoyable. Other authors who write using this method of reworking fairy stories include Shannon Hale, Laini Taylor and Robin McKinley.
Fran Knight

Death in the Desert by Jim Eldridge

cover image

Egmont, 2011. ISBN 978140525194.
Recommended. Fast paced and action packed, Death in the Desert is an absorbing read. Delta Unit, a group of 6 elite soldiers, travel to Afghanistan on a mission which takes them deep into Taliban territory. Delta Unit which is led by Mitch, is a covert unit comprised of UK and USA soldiers. Their mission is to escort a negotiator to a meeting with an Afghan warlord. Under no circumstances can they disclose their mission and under no circumstances can they ask for help.
They enter Afghanistan under the guise of a group of renegade soldiers who are now drug dealers. Their arrival is noted and they are immediately under attack. No one wants them there, not the drug dealers, not the Taliban and especially not the British soldiers on deployment. Afghanistan is a dangerous place and they will need their wits to not only complete the mission but to stay alive.
Mitch's team are resilient, tough and resourceful. They improvise, stay focused and support one another. They must complete their mission. Failure is not an option.
Sue Mann

Sir Edward 'Weary' Dunlop by Hazel Edwards

cover image

Ill. by Pat Reynolds. New Frontier, 2011. ISBN: 9781921042706.
(Age: 9+) The life of Edward 'Weary' Dunlop gives a tremendous history lesson of 20th century Australia. He rose from humble beginnings in 1903 to be an iconic Australian war hero, surgeon, sportsman, and community leader. In 1976 Dunlop was named as Australian of the Year, and in 1986 his famous War Diaries of World War 2 were published. He was held in such respect that when he passed away in 1993 over 10,000 people lined the streets to farewell him.
This book is the second in a series of Aussie Heroes, with one about Dame Nellie Melba already published and ones about Fred Hollows and Mary MacKillop to appear later this year. Aimed at 9 years+ the small size of the book coupled with the large font size makes it child friendly.
The text is broken up with colourful illustrations and a comprehensive time line provides a good summary. I would have liked a photograph or two of the subject, but that could well be an adult perspective.
Modern day children will be astounded by the difficulties described in the POW (prisoner of war) camps and the medical innovations that Sir Edward created by his 'make do' attitude.
The fact that Edward and his wife Helen took 8 years to get married and corresponded by mail will also intrigue those born in the electronic age of immediacy.
The obvious discussion point of this book is just what makes a hero. There is a geography lesson simply in mapping where Sir Edward went during the war years. Other related curriculum study ideas are in the teacher resources provided at New Frontier and on the author's website.
Kay Haarsma