Reviews

Naomi and Ely's no kiss list by Rachel Cohn and David Levithan

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2008
(Age 15+) Ely and Naomi are soul mates. They both live in the same apartment block in Manhattan and have been best friends forever, sharing their clothes and music and living through Naomi's father having a brief affair with Ely's lesbian mother. They have even compiled a no kiss list of boys that neither will kiss, to ensure that their friendship lasts. But what happens when Ely, gorgeous and gay, kisses Bruce the Second, Naomi's boyfriend?

Although this book is written from several viewpoints, both Naomi and Ely as well as several friends, Cohn and Levithan juggle the different voices adroitly, compelling the reader on to see if Naomi and Ely's friendship will survive. Naomi is devastated when Ely kisses Bruce the Second and she has to come to grips with the fact that Ely is gay and that their friendship will never develop into anything more. She needs to decide what is really important to her. At the same time promiscuous Ely takes a look at his lifestyle and also asks himself what he really wants.

Teens will love this witty story, with its sophisticated but vulnerable characters and will identify with the search for love and exploration of their sexuality. The New York setting, music and pop icons will attract and the writing style is fun to read.

Strong language and sexual themes make this a book for older teens.
Pat Pledger

Little ballet star by Adele Geras and Shelagh McNicholas

cover image

Orchard Books, 2007.
(Age 5+) What little girl wouldn't want to go backstage to meet the ballet dancers performing in The Sleeping Beauty? Tilly's aunt is a ballerina and is giving her a wonderful birthday treat, showing her what happens before a ballet performance. Tilly sees the dancers put on their makeup and tries on a costume in the wardrobe department; explores the wings and the stage and watches the orchestra tuning their instruments. Then she excitedly sits through the show and gets a wonderful surprise at the end.

This is a sparking story, full of warm, loving people who are willing to share the joy of dancing. The delightful illustrations bring to life the rapture and wonder that Tilly feels about dancing. Happiness beams from every face in the book.

A keeper - this book is sure to delight the reader who will find out about the intricacies of a ballet performance and will identify with a little girl who loves ballet. It is the sequel to The ballet class, but can be read alone.
Pat Pledger

The sleepwalker by Robert Muchamore

cover image

Hodder Children's Books, 2008
(12 +) I am a huge fan of Muchamore's The Recruit, but haven't read others from the series until now. I was looking forward to The Sleepwalker, and in many ways it didn't disappoint. Gritty, exciting, realistic and fast moving, it ticked all the boxes you would expect for an appealing teenage read. However it is most definitely a teenage read and that's where I came in for a bit of a shock. I recommended The Recruit to my nephew when he was nine and he loved it. I'd be in deep trouble with his Mum if I encouraged him to read The Sleepwalker! Muchamore has moved on and so have his characters. James Adams, aged ten in The Recruit is now fifteen and like many fifteen year old boys is preoccupied with sex, swearing, alcohol and his looks.

To be fair Muchamore's books all include the warning 'Not suitable for younger readers' on the cover and they are located in the teenage section of most book shops and libraries, but I was still caught out, and I know of at least one Year 6 teacher who has been recommending The Cherub series to the boys in her class based on how much her 11 year old son enjoyed The Recruit. You read one book in a series and you assume the rest will be similar. I won't be doing that again!

Robert Muchamore is fulfilling a need for realistic, action packed reads for the 'fight club' generation who enjoy military style action and violence, but are not quite ready for James Patterson and Andy McNab's adult books. The Sleepwalker is violent, opening with a stomach churning description of a fatal air crash. Tragedy and pain are dealt with 'manfully' - you laugh about it and you get on with it. However, the idea that an agent, having just lost his entire family in said air crash, becoming one of the main investigators is somewhat irritating in a book that purports to be 'realistic'.

The story turns on Fahim, an English boy with Arab background who believes his father may be responsible for the air crash. Cherub agents Jake and Lauren are sent in to investigate and find themselves up against Fahim's chillingly violent father and uncle.

The Sleepwalker's downside is the sub-plot covering Cherub agents James' and Kerry's two week work experience in a fast food outlet. Through the entire book I was waiting for this to somehow link to the main storyline, but it never did. In the end it petered out like a damp squib and seems to have no other purpose than padding and offering a tension building break from the main plot. None of Muchamore's readers appear to mind this rather lazy writing technique and The Sleepwalker has been awarded a universal five start rating by Amazon reviewers. He is obviously hitting all the right buttons with teenage readers, so who am I to quibble?
Claire Larson

Murderer's thumb by Beth Montgomery

cover image

Text Publishing, 2008.
(Age 13+) How would you feel if you uncovered the body of a girl in a silage pit? Adam Statkus is a newcomer to the small dairy community of Falcon Ridge. Fleeing from his abusive father, Adam and his mother settle into a house on a dairy farm and it is while he is helping out with farm chores that he makes the gruesome discovery. He is intrigued by the mystery and decides to uncover the identity of the murdered girl. Is she one of the teenage girls who went missing six years in the past? The discovery of a cryptic clue to a lost diary sets him a quest to find the diary, which he hopes will reveal the identity of the murderer.

This is a perfect murder mystery to introduce the genre to teenagers. Montgomery has created a story that has all the elements of a compelling who-dunnit. There is an interesting young detective who is tenacious and loves to decipher puzzles, a couple of villainous older footballers, a strong young girl who won't let anyone put her down, and a fascinating trail of clues and red herrings.

The rural setting where everyone knows everyone else and where outsiders are viewed with suspicion gives an added dimension to the story. Adam gets accepted into the local footy club, but wonders whether he can trust the other players. He is afraid to give out his telephone number because his father might trace him, and worries about the safety of going shooting with two of the older players. He is also perplexed by the behaviour of the Thackeray family, and their attitude to the missing girl Emma.

The tension mounts as Adam cleverly works out a succession of clues leading to the diary, and the reader is forced to continue with the story to find out whether he will be safe and to discover who committed such a dire murder.

I thoroughly enjoyed this mystery, loved its pace and allusions to cryptic crosswords and was kept guessing the murderer's identity to the end.
Pat Pledger

Perry Angel's suitcase by Glenda Millard

cover image

Ill. by Stephen Michael King. ABC Books, 2008. ISBN 9780733322556
(Age 9-12) This is the third instalment in the Kingdom of Silk series which began with The Naming of Tishkin Silk, then Layla Queen of Hearts and now this wonderful new story involving the Silk family. This touching story is about finding one's place in life and the journey involved in reaching that place. Perry (short for Peregrine) Angel, an orphan, arrives one day to stay with the Silk family carrying only a small shabby suitcase with the initials PMGDA embossed on the front. For Perry this case holds all the treasures of his life so far. Perry is very quiet and is enthralled by the daily rituals of the Silk family, taking in their quirky traditions and day-to-day routines. As with the other titles in this series life is not always as straight forward as we hoped and many secrets often remain untold. Perry slowly begins to trust the Silks and develops a special relationship with Ben. However a misunderstanding makes for a climatic ending until calm is restored and new life stories unfold.
Tracy Glover

The red leather diary by Lily Koppel

cover image

Harper Collins, 2008. ISBN 9780061256776
(Age 15-Adult) Lily Koppel, the author of this book and also writer for the New York Times, discovered a red leather diary among other treasures during a clean up in the cellar of her New York apartment building. The author of the diary - Florence Wolfson - had not missed a single day's entry from 1929 (when she received it as a birthday gift) until the end of 1934 (the lifespan of the diary). What unfolds is a fantastic insight into the Bohemian life of America during the 1930's and the life experiences, through intimate thoughts and emotions, of Florence during those five years. Intrigued, Lily set out to try and find information about Florence and in discovery her still alive proceeded to meet with her to discuss the diaries entries. Florence added insight to the entries and what transpires is a reflective look back on those times and the unfolding of a true story of a woman who dared to follow her dreams.
Tracy Glover

George's secret key to the universe by Lucy and Stephen Hawkin

cover image

Corgi Books, 2008. ISBN 9780552559584
(Age 7+) Highly Recommended. George Greenby's parents are eco-warriors, preoccupied with global warming, recycling and baking broccoli muffins. George is more concerned with trying to persuade his parents to buy him a computer, but as their electricity comes from an ancient generator, he would struggle to plug it in.

During an escape bid by the family's pet pig, George meets his new neighbours, ten year old ballet fanatic, Annie and her scientist Dad, Eric. George is also introduced to Eric's computer, Cosmos, the most intelligent computer in the universe, who is rather snooty (Think Orac in Blake's Seven) but clever enough to conjure up a portal into outer space. Add into the mix George's teacher, the sinister Mr Reeper, who is determined to kidnap Cosmos for his own dastardly plans, and you have all the makings of a thrilling adventure story.

What makes this book stand out is the skilful way that Hawking slips fascinating facts into an exciting storyline. During Annie and George's adventures through the portal into outer space we learn some amazing facts about our galaxy. Fact-boxes intersperse the story, providing information about subjects such as matter, exoplanets, neutron stars and black holes. There is also a selection of high quality colour photographs dubbed 'Cosmos's Picture Files'. Garry Parsons deserves a special mention for his delightful illustrations which appear on every page and add to the book's appeal.

George's Secret Key To The Universe has been short listed for the Stockport School's Book Award and has proved extremely popular in my school, and not just among the boys either. A minority of readers found the fact boxes irritating - and they do just appear - sometimes in the middle of a sentence (presumably because of paging constraints) which can be a little off-putting. However, George's Secret Key To The Universe hits just the right balance with a lively adventure story anchored firmly in the fascinating world of science and space. Here is a story that explains the nature of Black Holes so that primary school children can understand it - an impressive achievement!
Claire Larson

Ratwhiskers and me by Lorraine Marwood

cover image

Walker, 2008. ISBN 9781921150395
(Age 10+) Highly recommended. Fleeing from a fire on the goldfields, desperately afraid, the 'Boy' follows his dog, Ratwhiskers, and stumbles into a tent town, where he is grabbed by two miners, Baldhead and Gingerbeard, and forced to work for them. A kind and helpful young Chinese boy shows where to find wood and water, and how to manage to survive the brutality of the miners. Then Ellery, a cold-hearted villain, threatens both the Chinese and the 'Boy', and it is a struggle to stay alive.

A touching verse novel, Ratwhiskers and me takes the reader into the goldfields of the 1850's, making that time come alive with vivid descriptions of the hardships, the violence and greed of some of the miners and the prejudice and fear that the Chinese people faced. Marwood's poetry is wonderful.  With very few words she is able to conjure up the emotions of Lin, who tells the story of her loss of family, flight from danger and the frightening people she meets on the way. It is a story about being alone and learning whom to trust in a time of danger. Marwood has created a cast of distinctive characters including Sassy, who died in the fire, the bullying miners, Sun Song and the Chinese, each brought alive through colourful descriptions. As well as describing the difficult life of the miners and the cruelty faced by the Chinese during the goldrush, the first person narrative sweeps the reader along on a thrilling adventure of treachery and survival.

This wonderfully descriptive story begs to be read aloud and will leave the listener and reader satisfied with a tale beautifully told while pondering the role of the Chinese on the goldfields.
Pat Pledger

Crash by J.A Henderson

cover image

OUP Oxford, 2008.
What do a missing oil rig, a Romany, fishing boats, memory loss and the Tay Bridge have in common? Well, nothing, until the day that Bobby's dad, Gordon, passes out when they're stuck on a train and see a worker fall to his death from the bridge. Gordon wakes up believing he is someone called Dodd Pollen, 15, and hunted by the police.
At first, Bobby thinks it's great. He can do what he wants, when he wants. However, his dad's confusion becomes paranoia, and Bobby turns to his friend Mary and her grandma for help.
When a stranger comes looking for Gordon, informing him that his Lazarus Project, a disaster prediction that he can't remember anything about has become a reality, he decided to leave his son in case his presence could cause him any harm. Bobby and Mary go to find him, and Mary's grandma follows. Meanwhile, all hell breaks loose and a tsunami floods part of Scotland.
This is a great book, and was not what I expected at all. If you enjoy Artemis Fowl and any Alex Rider style books, you will love this!
Nikki Heath

Cat on the island by Gary Crew and Gillian Warden

cover image

Angus and Robertson, 2008.
Gary Crew demonstrates just how powerful a picture book can be in getting across an environmental message to all ages in this new book, beautifully illustrated by Gillian Warden. When the boy asks his grandfather to tell him a story, he hears about his forebears, sent to an island to take up the position of lighthouse keeper. Moving, the family takes their cat, and when she gives birth, the kittens eventually travel all over the island, feasting on the small wrens which live there.

When one of the cats brings in a dead bird in its mouth, the lighthouse keeper wraps it up and sends it to the museum. This attracts the interest of the naturalist but when he arrives at the island to trap some of the birds, the only flightless wrens in the world, he cannot find any. They have all been hunted to extinction.

The island is real. Stephens Island off the coast of New Zealand hosted the family and its cat in 1894. Within two years, no wrens were left.

The seemingly simply told story is explosive in its message. Any person reading or hearing it cannot help but be dismayed along with the little boy who asked for the story to be told. The illustrations serve the story well. At first calm and liquid, getting increasingly menacing as the story progresses, the eyes of the cat become larger, until the double page spread of a heavily clawed and nastily toothed cat looms up in red, ready to attack the reader.
Fran Knight

Evening is the whole day by Preeta Samarasan

cover image

Estate, 2008.
Preeta Samarasan's Rajasekharan's family story is told through Aasha's eyes, and is set against the newly emerged state of Malaysia. Woven through the disintegration of this Indian-Malaysian family is the birth and struggle of a new country fresh from the colonial rule of Great Britain.

The Rajasekharans are a wealthy family; Appa is a successful criminal barrister and his wife, Amma has come from humble beginnings and is very aware of her social standing and works hard to make the coffee morning set. Poati is the mother in law who indulges all but Amma and her unfortunate servant, Chellan. The children of this loveless and soulless marriage are Unna, a precocious child and now an intelligent young woman about to go to study in an Ivey league university in the USA, Suresh and indulged younger brother and the youngest, Aasha, whose only support, Unna, is about to abandon her.

Ghosts are the only friends for Aasha after Unna suddenly and inexplicably no longer includes her in her world. She observes her family almost as an outsider, from her refuge point on or behind the green PVC couch. Through her we see the family moving further apart. Appa has his mistress and he spends most of this time with this family. Paati, who seeks favour from all, sets all against her daughter in law, who she considers an unworthy match for her son.

All the stories, the secrets and lies come spiraling together at the point of Unna's departure. And these are all symptomatic of the complexity that is Malaysia.
Mark Knight

Saltwater moons by Julie Gittus

cover image

Lothian 2008. ISBN 9780734410290
(Age 15+) Invited to spend the weekend at a shack owned by his parents, Sun agrees without hesitation, as she can see that Tycho is as interested in her as she is in him. But despite the sentimental cover, making this appear to be a schmaltzy romance, this book concerns the growing realization of Sun's betrayal by Tycho's friend, Mark. At the party Tycho is diverted by his former girlfriend, and the drunken Sun goes down to the beach with Mark. Here they have fumbling sex, Sun for the first time.
Sun is in year 12, and so feels she is in control of her life and where she is headed, but her decision to be with Mark, changes her view of life. Her relationship with Mark causes incredible friction between Sun and her best friend, and when Sun stays away from school through illness, on her return the spite towards her has consumed most of the year group. She turns more and more to Mark, despite the interest from Tycho still being there, and so she must resolve what is happening in her life. Most realistic, the behaviour and language of senior students is most real. Senior students will relish this story.
Fran Knight

The twisted citadel by Sara Douglas

cover image

Voyager, 2008.
(Age 15+) This is a quest fantasy in which the central protagonists Maximillian and Ishbel have to organise the people of their world to defeat the immediate threat of the Screalings (a swarm of monsters from the cold north) and an ancient evil from the south. To do this, our heroes have to regain their heritage of power in the twisted citadel. Unbeknown to them Ishbel and Maximillian have been groomed through painful childhood experiences by the devious snake and frog gods. Further complicating events is the fact that they love each other but events have parted them, leading to mistrust and misunderstandings on their reunion.

The Twisted Citadel is a great read for Sara Douglas fans as she brings back characters from the Axis books who escaped the destruction of Tencedor. The previously stand alone books that Douglas has tied in are Threshold which occurred 2000 years in the past and Under the Hanging Wall, which is in the recent past for the hero Maxim. The story refers to previous action but understanding is not dependant on having read earlier books. However to make sense of The twisted citadel reading The serpent bride is essential as most of the characters' actions are dependent on events in The serpent bride.

Whilst this is not as strong a book as The Serpent Bride, it carries the story along and I look forward to a rip roaring finale with our heroes saving the world. The size of the book and themes make this an adult read or an older teen read. I would recommend it for this audience.
Leanne Marjanovic

Bunker 10 by J A Henderson

cover image

(Age 10 +) Highly Recommended. Seven teenagers have been sent to live on a military base, apparently because of their superior intelligence, although none of them seem to know quite why they are there. All are about to be annihilated in a huge explosion on Christmas Eve - and this story is the countdown to their destruction.

Cheerful stuff! The uncompromising bleakness and violence in Bunker 10 is shocking enough, but hovering above it is the stark suggestion that these are not actually real children, but extremely sophisticated computer programmes.

Simulations are a specialty of this military base and it appears that a team of intelligence experts have been sent into the base to test the ultimate in simulation - computer programmes that can think and act independently and who believe themselves to be real human beings.

There is so much double crossing and ducking and diving that you have to really concentrate while reading Bunker 10, but this outstanding book more than repays the effort. On one level there is enough tactical action to satisfy the most ardent paint-ball fanatic. The speed of action is breathtaking with plenty of shooting and gore. On another level I found the whole story quite unsettling. We know simulations are an important element of the plot and I spent the entire book wondering whether the children were real or not and whether the massive explosion (we are told at the start there are no survivors) would really happen.

J A Henderson is a master. His use of the 'countdown' (each section starts with the time, adding to the sense of urgency) builds the tension until you are racing through, desperate to find out what happens. There are some great touches of humour - I loved the reference to Star Trek. Characterisation of all seven children is engaging - their idiosyncrasies add to both the realism and the humour and while the plot is wildly beyond the realms of reality (I hope!) who cares? This is a fantastic story which should impress the boys. Quick J A Henderson, write another one!
Claire Larson

Give me truth by Bill Condon

cover image

Woolshed Press, 2008. ISBN 9781741663310
(Age 13+) Two stories overlap in this new novel by Bill Condon. I loved No worries (2005) and felt that the voice of the adolescent boy in that story, trying valiantly to help his mentally ill mother was just prefect. I'm not so sure here, but kids will love the story about the breakdown of marriage and family.

Caitlin's mother has just found out that her husband has been having an affair. Caitlin tries to comfort her and is willing to keep quiet for the sake of her younger brother. But she has trouble talking to her father, and feels the whole family is about to erupt. David's family has had a major argument ending with David being hit by his father. His mother and the two children leave the house and move in with their grandmother. David feels he wants to talk to his father but his mother is adamant that he does not see him.

The two stories of Caitlin and David intersect when both teens and their friends audition for a school play. Both the protagonists are angry with their parents but have to hold some sort of secret within themselves while outwardly behaving normally. It puts an incredible strain on their friendships and time spent at school. Condon cleverly contrasts the two situations; Caitlin's where her parents are reasonably controlled and civil, David's where his parents are antagonistic and the father is out of control. The reader can see for themselves the choices being made by each family in a situation not conducive to making informed and reasonable decisions. It is at times a scary read, but adolescent readers will see themselves and/or many of their friends in this story.
Fran Knight