Reviews

The cardturner by Louis Sachar

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2010. ISBN 9781408808504.
(Age: Secondary) Highly recommended. When told by his avaricious mother to be the card turner for his elderly blind Uncle Lester, Alton is made aware that the fate of his family rests upon his 17 year old shoulders. His father's retrenchment adds even more cachet to his mother's aggressive mantra 'tell him he's your favourite uncle', but going along one Saturday turns into an almost daily trip. He is to tell his uncle what cards he has in his hand for the 26 boards of bridge, and then table the ones he is told to play. Alton is not impressed with his job, but comes to know more about the man and his relations as the strange girl, Toni, takes her place as the man's partner. Alton has been brought up to believe that this side of his family, particularly Toni, is crazy, and that they are also interested in Lester's will. Alton's mother has fed him all sorts of stories about Toni and her mother, and these stories colour his view of the family, particularly Annabel, who he believes could be Toni's grandmother, as she was Lester's bridge partner many years before.
But when Lester dies before the National Championships, Toni and Alton decide to enter in Lester's and Annabel's names, to play out the championship which led to her incarceration in an asylum, resulting to her eventual suicide.
As Lester and Annabel, they play the event, and as Toni and Alton, their relationship becomes a lot closer.
Alton is immensely likeable, torn between his mother and the needs of his family, and those of his Uncle Lester, to whom he is increasingly drawn. Alton's foibles are quickly documented, his cooling relationship with his best friend, Cliff and his new girlfriend, Katie, once Alton's girlfriend, his relationship with his family and particularly his sister, Leslie, all are created with absolute ease. The story flows like nothing else I have recently read, and to think that much of it revolves around a game of cards makes it even more impressive. Sachar infiltrates the rules and niceties of the game of bridge with a deft touch, making it understandable to all readers. And for those not interested in learning the rules of this game, then he allows readers to skim over those sections, using a ploy which further maintains the readers' interest and enjoyment. A very funny story for secondary readers.
Fran Knight

Skylarks series by various authors

cover image

Evans, 2010
(Age: Middle Primary to Upper Primary) This series has an appealing set up: smooth pages to feel, larger font and short chapters will appeal to readers who can read and for whom many extending texts are so important.
Josie's garden by David Orme. ISBN 978 0237538934.
Well recommended. Modern coloured illustrations regularly support the story line. The plot may well appeal to middle and upper primary students who, like Josie live in a high rise apartment with a beautiful view but no garden or place to run and play in. The resolution is well played out. Set in England and with a hedgehog to see, the text still enables the reader to identify with Josie and her dream of a garden to play in. A well rounded story.
The Emperor's new clothes retold by Louise John. ISBN 978 0237538958.
Well recommended. An honest retelling of an old story. The illustrations, although modern, give the sense of another older time and so the atmosphere of the story is not wholly lost. They are colourful and the facial expressions are cleverly drawn. The age old story is told with sensitivity and accuracy and to hear the little boy say 'Daddy, look, the Emperor has nothing on!' must encourage the young reader to discuss the whole bizarre scenario.
Carving the sea path by Kathryn White. ISBN 9780237538903.
Well recommended. Joining a new community can be difficult and Samuel certainly struggles to adjust to his new environment. He has been provided with all the mod cons that should make his new life in the Arctic pleasant in his home, but he struggles with the outside environment. Irniq, a local lad, befriends Samuel and tries to talk to him about the beautiful wildlife which swim in these waters. As with all stories, the change occurs when a trapped humpback is caught under the ice. It's a good story for friendships under unusual circumstances and to the people who brave the outer reaches of our planet to help our amazing water creatures. The coloured illustrations are very ordinary but the text and font and the feel of the paper are well presented.
Sue Nosworthy

Oathbreaker: A prince among killers by S. R. Vaught and J. B. Redmond

cover image

Random House, 2010. ISBN 9781864719864.
Highly recommended. This continuation of Assassin's Apprentice finds Aron still fighting to come to terms with the loss of his family and how he can use his grail safely both within the codes of Stone and his own highly developed sense of honour. He is also developing feelings for Dari and this adds to his confusion and anger.
Readers who enjoyed the first book, will not be disappointed by this fast paced sequel. The characters are well developed (faults and all) and the setting comes to life. I liked the way that each chapter is written from the point of view of Aron, Dari or Nic. This way you really feel like you are understanding them and their often conflicting thoughts and feelings as they deal with the many problems facing not only themselves but Stone and Eyrie as well.
Like many fantasy books this one deals with big issues like good and evil but what I particularly like is the way that personal issues are interwoven with this so that you can feel the pain that Aron, Nic and Dari feel. The other characters are strongly drawn and live up to their names like Stormbreaker and Snakekiller, but others like Zed and Raaf also come to life. The non-human creatures such as the mockers, rock cats, manes and Talons help in rounding out the book. In fact I think this is what I like most about this book, it comes to life with a setting helped by maps and characters that you really care about. I finished this book wanting more and I think those who enjoyed Assasin's Apprentice will not be disappointed.
David Rayner

Calamity Jack by Shannon and Dean Hale

cover image

Ill. by Nathan Hale. Bloomsbury, 2010. ISBN 978 0 7475 8742 2
(Ages 10+) Highly recommended. Steampunk meets Jack and the beanstalk, with Rapunzel thrown in for good measure, making this graphic novel a cut above the rest. Jack, a Native American, leaves home in disgrace after he buys some beans with his mother's remaining money and then cuts down the stalk with disastrous results. Her bakery is in ruins and she is taken in by the giant, Blunderboar. Fleeing to the west, Jack meets Rapunzel, who seeing his courage and determination, returns to New York with him to make amends. Here they discover that Blunderboar is in league with a colony of Ant People, and they are destroying the city. They befriend Sparksmith who is defending his newspaper against the onslaught and together the three save the day.
Told in its bare bones, the humour of the story does not come to light, but the story is very funny, nodding to many old stories and tales as it goes along. A whiff of romance between Sparksmith and Rapunzel is enough for Jack to realise how much he cares for the girl. The graphic novel format suits this story beautifully and the full coloured illustrations are wonderful to look at, seeking out the array of things drawn in each frame. The city of New York is spectacular, and the steampunk element inventive and practical. As someone who was addicted to comics when a kid, these are a delight to read. Full of fun and adventure, Calamity Jack, with his nose for getting into trouble will appeal to all ages.
Fran Knight

The named by Marianne Curley

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2010 (c2002). ISBN 9781408804483.
(Age 13+) Recommended. A re-issue of the first in Marianne Curley's The Guardians of Time series is a welcome addition to the fantasy genre. Ethan has seen his sister attacked by a monster and has trained as a Guardian, one of the Named who fight against the chaos that would occur if history was changed. At the same time he has to pretend that he is just an ordinary schoolboy. Then he is told that Isabel, the sister of Matt, his once best friend, is to be his apprentice and that he has only weeks to train her. Will he manage to teach her the skills necessary to survive when they go back in time to fix the mess that the Order of Chaos is trying to make?
Told in the first person by Ethan, I was drawn once again into the magical world of the Guardians and the everyday life of the main characters, Ethan and Isabel. Ethan's family is dysfunctional after the death of his sister, his mother falling into depression and his father unable to cope. The arrival of a new girl Rochelle creates rivalry between Ethan and Matt, and has destroyed their friendship. Matt certainly doesn't want Ethan anywhere near his sister. Meanwhile Ethan is desperate to win his wings in the world of the Guardians, but even his friend Arkarian, who has electric blue hair and violet coloured eyes, has a difficult time convincing the court that he is mature enough. Curley keeps the reader in suspense about the relationships between the teenagers, wondering about the notion of soul mates and whether the romances will flourish.
The action is gripping and the time travel to different historical periods adds an extra dimension to the story. There is a mysterious prophecy that foretells what is going to happen. I was challenged to try and work out who was mentioned in it and who was to die.
I enjoyed this compelling story when it first was published and found that it still has a timeless appeal. It would appeal to both boys and girls.
Pat Pledger

The firefighters by Sue Whiting

cover image

Ill. by Donna Rawlins. Walker Books, 2010 (c2008). ISBN: 9781921529498.
Recommended for Preschool - Early Junior Primary. Picture book. The bell rings and the story begins. Three young children transform themselves and some cardboard boxes into a firefighting team with speedy fire engines to save the Ice-Creamery.
A surprise visit of the real firefighters at the end enables fire safety facts to be intertwined into the fictional fantasy. An important fire safety message is conveyed in a fun and unobtrusive way. There is a great use of onomatopoeia to add an interesting element to the text.
Beautiful bold pictures compliment the story superbly, the use of fabulous primary colours and strong lines enable characters to come alive. The Firefighters is a lovely story full of imaginative characters that will spark imagination in those who hear it.
Walker Books also have great supporting activities .
Zana Thiele

The House of the Mosque by Kader Abdolah

cover image

Translated from the Dutch by Susan Masotty. Canongate, 2010. ISBN 9781847672407.
(Age: Year 11 to adult). Recommended. Set in Iran in the years before and following the 1979 Islamic revolution against the Shah, the novel demonstrates the changes in traditional Muslim life caused by that event. The family of Aqa Jaan has lived in the house of the Mosque for eight centuries, and controlled the appointment of imams to the mosque. The traditional life of a prosperous and well-respected family is described in deceptively simple prose, language that suggests there are few uncertainties in this life constructed around ritual and traditions strengthened by the power of beautiful and comforting surahs from the holy texts. However, the lives of the family and their small town are brutally disrupted by the growth of political movements, the radical Islamist movement brought to the mosque by a new Imam, and the Communism embraced by several sons of the family. The revolution comes, and, as with dictatorships anywhere, the power of the ruling ayatollahs is cemented by brutal repression of any who are suspected of dissent. A sister-in-law becomes an inquisitor, a son is executed, the daughters leave to work in Iran and a nephew flees from Iran. The head of the family sees his family dispersed and is left with his faith and the 'treasury' of the mosque, the treasure being the memories collected through the changes of past centuries.
Simply but beautifully written, the writer captures the secure pattern of pre-industrial lives and the confusion that both political and industrial change brings. Himself a political refugee from Iran, the writer also clearly shows the terror and helplessness experienced by both participants and victims of the revolution. It is told from a mostly male point-of-view, but the role of women is clearly illustrated. It is recommended for senior students and would make an interesting comparison with other books set in Iran at that time.
Jenny Hamilton

The sky is everywhere by Jandy Nelson

cover image

Walker, 2010. ISBN 9781406326307.
(Age: Teens) Recommended. The blue cloth type cover and the blue bookmark cleverly attached to the back cover give this a book a different feel. All the type is blue and at the commencement of each chapter is a colored photo of a poem written on a variety of bits of paper.
Lennie (short for Lennon, as in John Lennon) is grief stricken following the sudden death of her sister Bailey. Lennie's mother walked out sixteen years ago leaving her two young daughters in the care of their grandmother, Gram and her pot smoking, many times married, brother, Big. Gram loves painting and caring for the roses in her garden. A half finished portrait of her daughter dominates a wall in the house. Gram has always told her granddaughters that one day their mother will come back.
Ryan, Bailey's boyfriend, is also devastated following her death. Ryan spends time at the house and with Lennie. As the comfort and solace they provide each other becomes more intimate, Lennie feels confused about her feelings for Ryan. Lennie is also falling in love with Joe, the gorgeous new boy at school. One day Joe finds Lennie and Ryan kissing. Lennie is devastated and with the help of her friend Sarah commences a quest to win back Ryan's love and affection.
Joe's revelation that Bailey was pregnant at the time of her death and that they had planned to marry adds to Lennie's grief. Gram reveals some home truths about the disappearance of her mother all those years ago and Big gets married yet again. At the end of the story, Ryan reveals that the poems that are photographed at the beginning of each chapter have been collected by him coincidentally as he has been walking the streets. The poems have given Ryan an insight into how much Lennie is grieving for Bailey.
This is a story about love, grieving the sudden loss of a sibling, the loss felt after being abandoned by a parent and growing up.
If you need another teenage romance, set in northern California, at the kind of school that has 'optional morning meditation in the gym' (pg 17) then this title is for you.
Jenny Brisbane

Toby and the secrets of the tree by Timothee De Frombelle

cover image

Translated by Sarah Ardizzone. Walker Books, 2010. ISBN 9781406325454.
(Age: Upper Primary and early Secondary). Well recommended. This engaging fantasy adventure novel is written in the style of good overcoming evil, love overcoming hate and true friendship. Elegantly translated, the reader follows Toby as he tries to defeat the tyrant Leo Blue now his enemy, but once his best friend. There are many branches of people who become intertwined in the story.
The double page illustration at the beginning gives the reader who hasn't read Toby Alone, an idea of the multitude and complexities of the characters. Set in the great oak tree which is on the brink of devastation, these diminutive people play out their own stories, many horrific for fear and brutality is Leo's world. Charming Sim and Maya try to give hope while tunnelling their way to freedom.
The many twists and turns make this a fascinating and wonderful read.
Sue Nosworthy

Pen pals forever (series) by Lenny Pelling

cover image

Random House, 2010.
Junior primary. This series of small books aimed at junior primary school people (the target audience says beginner reader) will have appeal to young girls who have recently begun school, and so making new friends and finding out about writing. The two girls in these books, Polly and Jez, are great friends because their mothers were pen pals, but their separation means writing letters to each other to tell their friend what is happening to them. Each volume has things for the reader to do at the end of the book; recipes, craft ideas and ideas for letter writing.
In Summer days (ISBN 9781864719000) the girls are introduced to the reader. Polly is about to go on a caravan trip around Australia with her grandparents. Her letters and postcards to Jez are full of the sights she sees, while Jez replicates some of the things Polly talks about in her own home.
In School days (ISBN 9781864719017) the girls are off to school, but while Jez goes to a conventional school, Polly is taking classes over the internet with a class which spreads over Australia.
In Olden days (ISBN 9781864719024) the two girls relive the past through Polly's Gran's stories, and Jez's mother's letters. This book involves recipes and stories of the past. Fran Knight

Stravaganza: City of ships by Mary Hoffman

cover image

(Age 12+) Recommended. Imagine what it is like to be Isabel, the twin who is always on the sidelines, who never quite shines like her brother Charlie. Isabel is so unhappy that she makes up an imaginary twin for herself named Charlotte, who was born 10 minutes after her and about whom she can feel a little bit superior. But one day she finds a velvet bag full of silver tesserae, beautiful mosaic tiles that transport her back in time to the sixteenth century. In Classe, a seaside town in the country of Talia, an Italy in a parallel dimension Isabel discovers that she is to play a vital role in saving the town from being overtaken by the Gate people, encouraged by Fabrizio di Chimici, the Duke of Giglia.
I loved the setting of Talia, which has all the richness and intrigue of 16th century Italy. The descriptions of pirate attacks and the land and sea battles were amazing. I found the map of Talia and the pictures of the ships used in the Sea Battle of Classe (1580), the historical notes and family tree really interesting as they added to an understanding of the historical period. Isabel's heroism in helping to save the Classe ships was rivetting as was the role that Andrea, the handsome pirate, plays.
As a Stravagante, Isabel discovers that she has strengths not just in Talia, but in 21st century London. The others in the Stravagante group, Lucien, Georgia, Sky and Matt, invite her to join their group and her confidence about herself and her ability to make friends grows. After her journeys to Talia, where she is greeted as a saviour of Classe and meets Arianna and Luciano who are also Stravagante, she finds that she is able to tackle things like swimming and manage to do them well. Even Charlie is impressed with the group of friends that she has and there is a growing romance with Sky.
This is the 5th book in the Stravaganza series following City of Masks, City of Stars, City of Flowers, and City of Secrets. It can be read as a stand alone, as Hoffman gives enough background about previous characters for the reader to understand what is going on. However reading the whole series from the beginning would obviously be an advantage. Recommended for readers who enjoy adventure, history and a touch of romance.
Pat Pledger

Pretty monsters by Kelly Link

cover image

Text Publishing, 2010. ISBN 9781921656361.
(Ages 13+) Recommended. Short stories. Horror/Fantasy. If you are after something unusual and thought provoking then this set of five short stories will fit the bill.
Kelly Link's stories are highly original with strange plots and surprise endings. Even when you think that you have worked out what has happened, there is an unexpected twist and all your problem solving goes awry. What really occurs in Pretty Monsters, the most memorable of the stories? I am still trying to work it out! Are there really werewolves? How could the girls be so monstrous to a classmate? Who is really recounting what happens? All these questions could lead to a great class discussion.
The Surfer is another memorable, short story with a young boy who thinks he is terrific at soccer, trapped in a refugee camp, waiting for aliens to arrive. His only refuge is reading his father's science fiction books, which are a good introduction to classic sci-fi titles for teen readers. It is more plot driven than Pretty Monsters and as such is easier to understand.
The Cinderella Game is a spooky story of a young boy who plays Cinderella with Darcy, his new stepsister. It also had an ambiguous ending that left me trying to puzzle out what was really going on.
Each story has a unique illustration by Shaun Tan that gives an introduction to what the tale could be about. It was fun looking at the drawings and making some predictions about the stories from them and the titles. I found myself going back to the illustrations and getting a whole new perspective on what the story may have been about.
Each of these stories is a challenge and one that the reader will find different and stimulating.
Pat Pledger

Jameela by Rukhsana Khan

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2010. ISBN: 9781742372594.
Suitable for 10 years and above. This book is set in war-torn Afghanistan after the American intervention and shows some aspects of the effects of war on civilians. In this case the narrator is Jameela, a young girl whose life is turned upside down when she finds her invalid mother dead. Jameela and her father move to the city of Kabul hoping that he can find work there. She is employed as a domestic help for a wealthy family and is envious of the daughter who has a tutor to teach her English.
Her father begins a relationship with another woman who convinces him that life would be cheaper and better without Jameela. So her father abandons Jameela in a city street and she ends up in an orphanage. In many situations she repeats the mantra, 'don't become angry, don't become angry. '
Jameela's mother once told her, 'If you can't be beautiful you should at least be good'. Being a devout Muslim and thus having her face covered by a 'porani,' it is only half way through the book that we realise that she has the deformity of a cleft palate. However she is relatively happy at the orphanage as she is taught English and becomes a quick learner. Jameela grows to understand that people are all different and have both good and bad characteristics.
The story is fiction but based on true incidents. It does a great job of introducing the reader to another culture and religion and the complexities of life. It would be a good text to illustrate childhood resilience and parental neglect. The author was born in Pakistan and has written extensively on Muslim themes, which is a core component of this book also. A glossary of Arabic terms enables the reader to fully understand many of the words and phrases integrated into the text.
Kay Haarsma
(NOTE: It appears that an earlier edition was published by Groundwater in 2009 under the title Wanting Mor.)

Noah's Garden by Mo Johnson

cover image

Ill. by Annabelle Josse. Walker Books, 2010. ISBN: 978 1921150159.
Highly recommended. Picture book. In Noah's garden, anything is possible. He flies seaplanes, bathes with tigers, rides on camels, dances with penguins, fights with pirates, spies on helicopters and wishes with Grandad. The most important wish Noah makes is to have Jessica come to play in his garden but this dream never seems to be realised. 'Surprises come suddenly in Noah's garden', however, and finally his wish comes true.
A simple, touching story, suitable for the youngest of readers, this is based on the experiences of a family whose daughter was born with Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome. Noah continues to dream while he waits for his sister to come and join him in the hospital garden. Josse's beautiful watercolour illustrations alternate between realistic and imagined scenes and depict the garden as a place of beauty, wonder and peace. The doctors and nurses and the interior of the hospital are sensitively and realistically portrayed, as are Noah's emotions. According to the blurb at the back of the book, Jessica's seven month stay in hospital provided the inspiration for this story which has the capacity to melt many a healthy adult heart. It speaks of 'courage and resilience in the face of adversity' and acknowledges the gardens which are part of many hospitals, as well as those who create and care for them. With royalties being donated to the Royal Children's Hospital Foundation, Melbourne, and its gentle and thought provoking content, this is a book which is definitely to be highly recommended.
Jo Schenkel

Somme Mud by Private Edward Lynch

cover image

Edited by Will Davies. Random House Australia, 2010. Abridged Edition.
(Age 14+) Highly recommended. This gripping and memorable account of Private Edward (Nulla) Lynch's experience of the French battlefields during the First World War is highly recommended for students. The story begins with Nulla's departure by ship from Sydney and training near Stonehenge in England before the baptism  of mud and horror in the area of the Somme River during the winter of 1916-1917. Soldiers sink to their knees in mud and have to use blankets to stand on.  Action in the trenches is described in horrifying detail as soldiers are pressed into hand-to-hand combat in a stark landscape full of noise, stench and fragmented bodies. Warfare's effect on the Australians and their enemy, physical courage, psychological disintegration, bravery and acts of mateship are vividly described. Private Lynch is wounded and briefly describes his recuperation back in England before once again going into battle. The reader is amazed at how luck influences life and death situations right up to the German surrender in 1918.
Each chapter is accompanied by a brief introduction that puts the action in appropriate context. Excellent photographs enhance the text which includes attitudes and vocabulary used at the time. A glossary is included as well as maps showing the battlefields and a discussion guide for History students.
Paul Pledger