Reviews

The Moth Diaries by Rachel Klein

cover image

Faber, 2010. ISBN 9780571259489.
The Moth Diaries by Rachel Klein is a book set in the nineteen sixties in an all girl's boarding school. The narrator is asked permission to publish the diary written by herself at 16 by her psychiatrist, and so the journal begins with her return to boarding school. This is probably a form of abandonment by her mother as they both try to deal with the suicide of the father, a noted poet. The journal records her emotions as her close friendship with Lucy is disrupted by the arrival of a new boarder. The girl's story slips in and out of reality, where dreams might be real and observations a form of jealousy, obsession or even delusion. Over time, the narrator comes to believe that Ernessa, the interloper, is a vampire draining the life and energy from Lucy. Through strange events, such as the violent death of a teacher's dog, then a student and a teacher, the narrator believes that Ernessa's consumption of Lucy is the true reason for the tragedies, and can only end when Lucy dies. The paranoia and introverted voice of the narrator is confusing and disturbing, and the fascination with death and suicide suggests its suitability for mature senior female students. With a movie about to be released, it would make a challenging senior study.
Margaret Clarke

Norris, the bear who shared by Catherine Rayner

cover image

Orchard Books, 2010. ISBN 9781846163098.
(Preschool - Year 1) Norris loved plorringes, and the plorringe on the tree was very nearly ripe. So, being wise, he lay down under the tree waiting for something special to happen. But the something special isn't quite what you guessed it would be when you saw Norris lying on his tummy under the tree because Tulip the raccoon and Violet the mouse also loved plorringes so they climb the tree to investigate it. While Norris watches and waits, they do much more than that, until -
Many authors for very young children explore themes of friendship and sharing through animals and toys as characters, but this one has that extra something that makes it stand out. It is very simple, but there is so much scope for interaction between reader and listener that will draw the child into a cosy, rewarding experience. It's not all there in the text - the illustrations are an integral part of the text in true picture-book style. And just what is a plorringe? And if you were to lie in wait under a tree, what do you think would be worth waiting for? Miss Almost-5 and I had a lot of discussion about that one. We decided it would be a rasbanango.
Catherine Rayner has a unique style of illustration, for which she was awarded the Kate Greenaway medal in 2009. (For more information about her work, see here). This is the first of her works that I've reviewed but I shall be on the lookout for more.
Barbara Braxton

Mr. Badger and the Difficult Duchess by Leigh Hobbs

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 9781742374192.
Mr. Badger and the Difficult Duchess is a quirky story where the main character is a badger and he is the Manager of Special Events at the Boubles Grand Hotel. Mr. Badger is in charge of organising events and looking after special guests. He is the most patient creature you will ever meet. It is the day of the Philatelic Society's Annual Dinner and Mr. Badger's patience (and the rest of the hotel staff) is put to the test when an unusual royal guest arrives unannounced. The difficult duchess ends up being the most demanding guest ever!
I love how the author has used an animal as the main character and how the human characters treat him as an equal (plus he talks!). I would recommend the book for readers aged 8-10 years. It isn't a long story but there are black and white illustrations on each page to match the text and add visuals for the reader. There is also a lesson or two to be learned concerning the importance of patience and keeping calm because amazing things can happen no matter what goes wrong!
Kylie Kempster

Kisses for Lula by Samantha MacKintosh

cover image

Egmont, 2010.
(Ages 13+) Tallulah (Lula) Bird is 15 years old and has never been kissed! With five days until her birthday that is not her only problem. Her dad is sneaking out of the house at night with a lady's handbag, some one's stalking her, every boy in town thinks she is jinxed and the documents that could save Coven's Quarter, Lula's favourite place, have been stolen. When her friends go away for a few days Lula is left to find someone to kiss without hurting him like she has hurt every boyfriend she has ever had. Unfortunately her first choice doesn't like her and her second choice likes someone else. When she attempts to help Arns get a date with Mona he ends up getting hurt by her sister's dog Boodle the Poodle.
This book is great. I would recommend this book to anyone. You get to see all the problems Lula faces in her last few days of being 15 and how she solves them.
Tahlia Kennewell (student)

Zac and the Dream Pirates by Ross Mackenzie

cover image

Chicken House, 2010.
(Ages 7+) Zac has always felt like an outsider and is forever defending his Grandmother when kids his own age accuse her of being a witch. Imagine Zac's surprise when he follows Granny one night and tumbles into another world on the other side of sleep. The land of Nocturne is full of powerful magic that spills from peoples' dreams. However, the Dream Pirates are trying to take control of Nocturne through dark magic which is slowly poisoning the dream world. Only the three Knights of Nod can save the day but their identity remains a mystery.
It is up to Zac and his new friends to try and free Nocturne from the evil grip of the Dream Pirates. With an airship pilot to help them (shades of Less Scoresby in Northern Lights) and Vampires and werewolves on their tail, they face Shadow, leader of the Pirates in a thrilling adventure.
By the end of the story we know that Zac himself is one of the Knights of Nod, but who are the others? A tantalising glimpse is offered when a mysterious young werewolf (who should really be one of the bad guys) helps Zac escape a sticky situation. Readers will have to await the next in the series to learn more.
Some say that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery and Zac and the Dream Pirates has certain parallels with Harry Potter and His Dark Materials. However, this is a story aimed at a younger audience. The unusual setting, magical realism and twin plot lines are very appealing and it's especially good for youngsters who crave vampires and werewolves, but are not quite ready for the likes of Darren Shan. Already on the Long-List for the Stockport School's Book Award, I predict this will be a strong contender for top prize in the 7-11 category.
Claire Larson

Spork by Kyo Maclear and Isabelle Arsenault

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2011. ISBN 9781921759741.
(Age Yr 2+) Spork was neither a spoon or a fork, but a bit of both. On the surface, this story explores Spork's attempts to fit in with the other kitchen utensils because of the loneliness of difference and exclusion until he finds his niche. But it also works at so many other levels of difference - racial, sexual, medical - and its presentation of a smaller-than-usual font and subtle colourings suggests that this was what both author and illustrator intended. Indeed the author dedicates it to "all the amazing sporks and misfits in my life". On the surface, it is a picture book, but the text opens up many opportunities for talk.
If it were being read to a younger age group, it would be a perfect vehicle for exploring the surface story of being and feeling different and how others do and should respond to that, but there is also scope for using it as a springboard for thinking about those deeper issues. Its audience will respond to it at their own level of development and understanding, and if it is read by a spork, it will even offer comfort. There is a perfect place for you in this world - it just might take a little while to find it.
This book is like its title - a little bit regular, a little bit different and a little bit difficult to define. But it definitely has a place on school library shelves.
Barbara Braxton

Press here by Herve Tullet

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2010. ISBN 9781742375281.
(Age 2-6) Highly recommended. Wow! What a wonderful picture book. Press here is an original interactive book that is sure to have children clamouring to follow the simple instructions and work out what is happening on each page. The book begins by asking the reader to press on a yellow dot and turn the page. This makes a second dot appear. The reader keeps following instructions to press and rub the dots, tilt the page and tap the dots. All sorts of wonderful things happen to the dot when the book is manipulated. The book ends by asking if the reader wants to do it all over again, and I am certain that there will be a resounding yes to that question.
Reminiscent of touching on an iPad, this book is very interactive and will have lots of appeal to children who are obsessed with digital toys and those who haven't been exposed to them. It is equally as engaging as looking at a digital book and has the added bonus of the reader being able to feel and turn the pages. The joy of blowing, rubbing, shaking, clapping and tapping and seeing what happens is amazing. The book has a very sturdy cover and thick shiny pages so it is sure to stand up to lots of treatment by eager users.
It is an excellent book to stimulate the imagination and to have fun with. In addition, the very young reader will learn new vocabulary and have counting from 1 to 5 reinforced. The colours, red, yellow and blue are introduced as well as size and order.
This is a magical picture book, which is sure to win awards as well as lots of appreciation from its young readers.
Pat Pledger

Prom and prejudice by Elizabeth Eulberg

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 9780143294572.
(Age 13+) Ideal for a quick, easy read especially for those who enjoy a romance, Prom and prejudice gives Jane Austen's Pride and prejudice a modern feel. Lizzie Bennett, a musical prodigy and scholarship girl, finds the elitist attitudes of Longbourn Academy difficult to take. However she knows that she has to put up with the cruel antics of the snooty girls there in order to gain the place she wants in a prestigious university. Everyone is obsessed with the upcoming prom but Lizzie knows that she wouldn't be able to afford an expensive designer dress and shoes even if she had a partner to accompany her. Meanwhile Lizzie's friend Jane is desperate to have Charles Bingley, from the nearby Pemberley Academy, as her partner. Lizzie likes Charles, but is not so impressed with his moody friend, Will Darcy, whom she believes is a snob. There is however a spark of attraction!
I felt very familiar with the story having read Austen's wonderful original and watched many film and television adaptations. I really enjoyed the way Eulberg adapted it for a current teen audience and had fun comparing the original scenarios with hers. Of course, there is only one outcome for Austen's heroines and that is marriage. This is a far cry from having a partner for a prom. In the original, Elizabeth Bennett's birth and social class is not high enough for Darcy, whereas not having enough money is the stumbling block for Lizzie in today's world. Darcy is still the brooding, gorgeous hero who manages to rescue his friends from disaster. Lydia is just as embarrassing to her sister Jane in the 21st century as she was in the 19th while Charlotte is content to have the boring Collins as a partner as long as she goes to the prom. Wickham continues to ply his wicked wiles with Georgina and Lydia, lying to get what he wants.
The novel examines today's emphasis on wealth and material goods and having the right connections. It also looks at the importance of getting to know people and their motivations before making judgments.
I really enjoyed this engaging romp, which is sure to be popular with girls, who may go on to read the much more demanding original.
Pat Pledger

Just a Dog by Michael Gerard Bauer

cover image

Omnibus, 2010. ISBN 9781862918870.
(Age: 9 - Adult) Highly recommended. Mr Mosely, nicknamed Moe, is not just any dog, he is the beloved dog of the Ingram family. He is not a pedigreed dog, but he is the one that protects and loves his family. In this story, Corey, the eldest child, tells of Moe's escapades and adventures while giving an insight into the joys and hardships of the Ingrams.
In 29 short chapters, Corey relates tales about Mr Moe, some very funny and some very sad. He is a heart warming narrator, telling the story about Mr Moe as he sees it, often missing things that are happening around him. The more mature reader will pick up on these family nuances; his father's anguish about being unemployed and the shortage of money for the family and the fights between his parents. I felt I knew the Ingram family very well by the time I finished the book and was immersed in their story. As a dog owner, I identified with the joy and frustration of owning a dog, but this book is one for everyone, not just dog lovers.
I always find outstanding books to be very hard to write about. How can a review convey the way that a book grabs your heart and makes you cry and think about the world and the way it operates? Just a dog should be on every library shelf. It is a book to read aloud to children, to recommend to individuals and to have as a class set. But be sure that you have a box of tissues handy!
Pat Pledger

Hugless Douglas by David Melling

cover image

Hodder Children's Books, 2010. ISBN 9780340950630.
Picture book. Recommended. When Douglas, a young bear, woke up from his long winter's sleep, he needed a hug and went in search of one. He tried the biggest thing that he could find and then the tallest, but they didn't feel right. He kept on searching until a kind rabbit lead him to the best hug ever - from his Mum of course!
Douglas went on his quest for love in a most amusing way and children will delight in the funny adventures that he has trying to find the right thing to hug. The humour in this book stood out and I had a grin on my face as I read it. Rhythmic prose also ensured that this was a delightful picture book to read out loud.
Melling beautifully drew Douglas as a gorgeous cartoon-like bear, which has lots of appeal for the young child. The illustrations provided enormous amounts of humour as Douglas tried to hug a stone, a tree and a flock of sheep.  I particularly enjoyed the two page spread at the back of the book, with their cute drawings of the rabbit trying out lots of different hugs: a sandwich hug between two sheep, a group hug, a come-and-get-it-hug and many more. I can imagine families sharing a lot of love and laughter as they try these out!
This picture book is certainly a worthwhile addition to a library or home collection because of its humour and moving story line. As an additional bonus it could also be used for displays for Mother's Day and comparisons of sizes.
Pat Pledger
Editor's note: Hugless Douglas is on the CILIP Kate Greenaway Medal longlist 2011 and the Sheffield Children's Book Award 2011 shortlist

The King of Tiny Things by Jeanne Willis and Gwen Millward

cover image

Puffin, 2009. ISBN: 9780141502380.
Picture book. When two little girls stay with their Nana and Grandad, they are allowed to camp out in a tent in the backyard only to find that, when bed time comes, neither can sleep. The noises of the night keep them both awake. When 'Something mothy crept in through the flap' they were ready to kill it, until it sings them a lullaby, introducing itself as the King of the Tiny Things. Nervously, the girls follow and are introduced to slugs, worms, caterpillars, daddy-long-legs, weevils, grubs, badger cubs and baby bats. When they fall behind the King of Small Things, they get a big shock when they catch up.
This is a delightfully written and illustrated picture book for all children from the very young to those in older classes at school. Its environmental themes are strong enough to provide a good basis for talking about our responsibilities and regeneration in nature, whilst its rhyme and rhythm are gentle and accessible enough to help younger children overcome their fears of the night. The illustrations are similar to some works by both Stephen Michael King and Alison Lester and this title could be used as one in a series of comparative texts as students are encouraged to look at the styles of different illustrators.
Jo Schenkel
Editor's Note: This is on the CILIP Kate Greenaway Medal longlist, 2011.

Lost by Colin Thompson

cover image

The Floods: Book 10. Random House, 2011. ISBN: 9781864719468.
Here, we find the Floods having returned to Transylvania Waters as the rulers of the country. Considering that the area has never before been mapped, it is decided that Maldegard, Winchflat's wife and Edna Hulbert, who are both 'outsiders from the world of humans',  having previously been in a position to use maps, would be the ones to undertake such a task. The only place names having been used to date are more descriptions of the various locations and applicable to multiple places in the country, hence, the women have a large task ahead of them. Whilst the women are off exploring and mapping the land, King Nerlin is endeavouring to set up a Parliament back at home. Both tasks prove to be filled with their own sets of issues and difficulties.
Thompson's attitudes are hilariously expressed throughout the story as he talks about the ban on cardigans, his opinions on politics and the importance (or lack of it) of technology and social networking. 'Wizards are intelligent enough to realise that going to the toilet is a lot more interesting, rewarding and important than anything to do with politics.' Likewise, given his attitude toward reality TV, one can only wonder whether the choice of Transylvania Waters as the setting for this book is in any way related to the 1992 series Sylvania Waters.
The Floods titles are definitely written with humour as a key element and should appeal to children who enjoy fantasy, gross snippets and humour, although a certain amount of the humour would perhaps be more applicable to older readers.
Jo Schenkel

Neighbours by Colin Thompson

cover image

The Floods Book 1. Random House, 2005. ISBN: 978142751009.
(Ages 10+) Definitely not an ordinary family, The Floods are more than just a little different - a family of witches and wizards, living in a suburban neighbourhood. Having had six very unusual children, Mordonna convinced her husband, Nerlin, she would like a 'normal pretty little girl she could do cooking and sewing with.' This lead to the arrival of Betty, a normal looking girl possessing magical powers which don't always work as planned.
Unfortunately, the family in the house next door leaves a bit to be desired and much of what they do irritates the Floods and upsets their everyday activities and routines. Gradually, the actions of the Floods bring about the demise of the Dent family, thereby restoring order to their own lives.
In this title, Thompson has echoes of his picture book The Short and Incredibly Happy Life of Riley. As was Riley, the rat, the Floods are happy with the simple life and don't feel the need to be constantly trying to outdo other people to have the 'biggest and best' of everything, despite the fact they could go and create anything they desire for themselves. Having only previously read and enjoyed The Floods Family Files, I found this to be incredibly amusing and was thoroughly entertained by the cleverly written footnotes. Thompson's attitude toward reality television programs made me laugh out loud. The addition of his clever illustrations, including tombstones announcing 'Here lies Chapter',  small sketches and full page drawings, add to the humour and take away the need to rely on one's own imagination to visualise the different characters. Thoroughly enjoyable.
Jo Schenkel

Crown of acorns by Catherine Fisher

cover image

Hodder Children's Books, 2010. ISBN 9780340970072.
(Age 14+) Recommended. Three stories weave their way in this fascinating mystery by Catherine Fisher. A 17 year-old girl has arrived anonymously in Bath. Giving herself a new name, Sulis, she goes to stay with a new foster family, but lives in fear of being discovered by a mystery man from her past. A parallel story in the 18th century tells of Zac, the teenage apprentice to architect Jonathan Forrest, who dreams of building a circle of houses based on druidic principles. Working only because his father has gambled away their family fortune, Zac is destructive and consumed with envy. Then there is the voice of Bladud, a mythical figure, who has been cured of a leprous disease by the healing waters of the sacred spring of Sulis.
Fisher gradually builds up the suspense around the teen, Sulis, who is convinced that someone is following her. She is very frightened and I was intrigued by the mystery surrounding her fear, never being sure if she was delusional or actually was being stalked by the person who murdered her young friend. There is suspense too in the relationship between Zac and his employer, Forrest, and I was kept on the edge of my seat, hoping that Forrest's great architectural dreams would be fulfilled and not foiled by Zac's mean machinations.
It was interesting that one of the main protagonists, Zac, is not an attractive character at all and this added spice to the story. However, Josh, Sulis' co-worker is a wonderful caring person and her foster parents are portrayed very sympathetically.
The magical setting, Bath, will enthral anyone who has ever visited that wonderful city with its golden stone. Those who are new to the setting will long to visit it. An afterword by Fisher gives information about John Wood, architect of the King's Circle in Bath.
Pat Pledger
Editor's note: Crown of acorns is on the CILIP Carnegie Medal longlist, 2011.

Across the Universe by Beth Revis

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 9780141333663.
(Age 14+) Recommended. In this thought provoking science fiction book, the reader is taken on a trip aboard the vast spaceship Godspeed, as it goes in search of a new planet to colonise. Seventeen-year-old Amy leaves her life on earth behind and joins her parents, as part of the 100 specialists who are frozen and stored aboard the ship.  She expects to be woken up after a 300-year journey, but is traumatised when she is thawed too early and discovers that someone has tried to kill her. Not only that, but life aboard the ship is strange and frightening. Eldest, a Hitler-like dictator, leads the ship and is training a young man named Elder as his apprentice. The behaviour of the ship's inhabitants is passive and weird.
Told in alternative chapters by Amy and Elder, Revis builds up a fascinating picture of life aboard a spaceship and the dilemmas that face the people who live there. Interspersed is the mystery of who is trying to kill the people who have been frozen. Amy is an intelligent young woman and together with Elder and his friend Harley, set out to discover who is taking out the frozen bodies and leaving them to die.
At the same time Revis explores the morality of the ways that leaders have tried to keep people hopeful about their chances of survival and the use of drugs to keep them compliant. Elder is challenged by Amy's approach to people and what is happening on the ship. She is a strong independent young woman who is not intimidated by authority and who makes Elder look at his actions in a different light. The responsibility of leadership and the right of people to know the truth are explored.
Teenage girls will be attracted to this book because of its beautiful cover. The engaging characters, exciting plot and a touch of romance will keep them reading.
Pat Pledger