Reviews

The promise by Vicki Bennett and Tull Suwannakit

cover image

Maiogaru loved to fish in the waters near her home in Papua New Guinea. She and her sisters caught sailfish, tuna, trout and shark, then took them home for mother to cook. She had been trained as nurse at the mission. Huge noises alerted her to the fact that the Japanese forces were close by. One night a Royal Air Force crash boat was leaving Milne Bay when it was sunk by a Japanese warship. Five survivors clutched pieces of the boat as they drifted away. The next day,  Kidilon pulled an injured airman from the sea where he was fishing. He gave him a coconut to drink and them turned the man over to Maioragu who hid him in a deep cave. Here she dressed his wounds, waiting until he was better able to be moved.

Unusually understated illustrations reveal the story on each page, reflecting the text and its equally unusual story. We rarely hear stories about Papua New Guinea and this one links Australia and our closest neighbour with fortitude and courage associated with links made during World War Two.

Maioragu knows she must get the airman to hospitals and to cross Milne Bay; she covers John with banana leaves and fruit and vegetables. Her perilous trip across Milne Bay between Japanese warships ended when she was able to deliver John to help. She had epitomised her nurse’s promise.

At the end of the war she was awarded the Loyal Service Medal.

This neatly told story of one woman’s courage, will encourage students to ponder how they might cope in similar circumstances. They will be encouraged to look at other stories of selfless courage, and particularly the stories of the Kokoda Track. And of course the story gives teachers the opportunity to look at a map and pinpoint the scene of this action.

Themes Courage, World War Two, Papua New Guinea.

Fran Knight

The Spellshop by Sarah Beth Durst

cover image

The Spellshop is a lovely feel-good cosy cottage fantasy, perfect to read on a cold winter’s day, or when the reader is feeling down. Kiela is a librarian at the Great Library of Alyssium, content to live in a small cubicle with her sentient spider plant, Caz. She rarely speaks to anyone, happy to catalogue the spellbooks in her collection. When rebels set fire to the Library, she and Caz, with crates of precious books, set sail for the distant island where she was born. Arriving there, she realises that she will have to make a living for herself. The nobles of the city have been draining the island’s magic for years and using the spells from the stolen spellbooks she quietly sets up a jam shop and tries to improve the islanders’ lives. With nosy and helpful neighbours like the good looking Larran, she discovers that self-imposed isolation is not always possible.

The Spellshop initially reads like a slow burning romance, but once I become immersed in the story the fantastic setting and fabulous creatures took over. I loved Caz the sentient spider plant, who makes funny and helpful comments and is the best of friends. The merhorses that frolic in the bay are delightful and the idea of cute, winged cats lounging on rooftops brought a smile to my face. It was easy to understand why Keila decided to research her stolen spellbooks to help the island’s inhabitants. The portrayal of the shop, with Keila’s delicious raspberry jam and Bryn’s baked goods, was mouth watering and it was delightful to see Keila gradually emerge from a solitary young woman to a helpful, kind neighbour.

Keila knows that sharing magic with common people is punishable with death, but their need is so great that she does so under the guise of selling herbal remedies that heal trees and make plants grow. When danger comes from the imperial capital the islanders’ ingenuity will be tested as they try to keep their home safe.

Perfect for fans of Travis Baldree’s Legends & lattes, fans may also like to read Durst’s Queens of Renthia fantasy series, starting with The queen of blood.

Themes Cosy Fantasy, Adventure, Friendship, Romance, Mythical creatures, Books, Jam.

Pat Pledger

All about the brain by Dr Gabriel Dabscheck. Illus. by Kim Siew

cover image

All About the Brain, written by Dr Gabriel Dabscheck, a paediatric neurologist at The Royal Children’s Hospital in Melbourne, is the second book in the All About the Body non-fiction series. In this latest release readers are introduced to the brain as the boss of the body. It controls our senses, out movements and our thoughts. The brain stores our memories and gives us our personality.

Most living creatures have a brain with the octopus having a mini brain in each of its eight arms. Sponges and jellyfish do not have a brain but the sperm whale has a brain that weighs about 9 kilograms. Our human brain weighs about 1 kilogram and is the size of a grapefruit. Throughout this engaging book are interesting facts that young readers will enjoy hearing, especially about what makes up our brain, what it looks like and how it works. The information about our senses and how the brain triggers each one to play a different role is fascinating.

The highly accessible information presented on each page is in large font and well-spaced. It is surrounded by vibrant images and diagrams using a consistent colour palette of green, purple, orange, pink and white. There is short glossary at the end looking at challenging key words such as hippocampus and cerebellum.

This is a wonderful companion to All About the Heart, CBCA 2024 Eve Pownall Notable book, and a perfect addition to library shelves.

Themes Brain, Science, Human Bodies.

Kathryn Beilby

Tornado by Jackie French and Bruce Whatley

cover image

Another in the fine series written by Jackie French and illustrated by Bruce Whatley will inform readers asked to follow its path of destruction. Starting with the willy willy, then on to a twister, the places that the tornado hits are various, from Bangladesh to Sydney, Missouri to Beenleigh.

But each has the power causing flying debris to strike with powerful rain and wind. Do not try to outrun them, because they travel at 400 kilometres an hour. And after the chaos is the widespread rubbish, houses overturned, cars upside down, people in shelters not knowing what they will come back to. The destruction made by the tornado is monumental, and one thing that it is known is that it will return.

Powerful words, presented in four lined rhyming verses, will take the breath away as they are read. Each verse presents a detail of what a tornado is. At the end of the story is a page of facts that will inform and interest readers, and they will be able to link those facts with the story they have just read.

Stunning illustrations cover the pages with images of the tornado and what it looks like in its many guises. The pages where it changes from the wind itself to the destruction it causes will stop readers in their tracks, as they see the mishmash of furniture, household goods, books, toys, cars and building materials all mixed up together.

We often see this mayhem on the screen, but Whatley’s masterful images of the destruction make it far more real. The child coming out of the shelter could be them, surviving after a tornado. It could be them trying to outrun one, it could be them whose house and everything inside is tossed about into a mess of concrete, wood and things once held dear.

Themes Tornados, Distraction, Natural disasters.

Fran Knight

Tennis Camp diaries: Doubles disaster by Ash Barty with Jasmin McGaughey and Jade Goodwin

cover image

From the team that created the very popular early readers Little Ash series comes a new series that is sure to engage young middle grade readers. The first book in the Ash Barty Tennis Camp Diaries has the title Double Disasters and is full of fun, worries, diary writing, talent quests, outdoor activities and lots of tennis.

Ten year old Ash is at her first ever tennis camp for two weeks. She is feeling nervous but finding out her roommate is Zia, an opponent from tennis competitions, helps her to feel at home. Ash and Zia make friends straight away with Richie, Nat and Ollie and Ollie is even chosen to be Ash’s doubles partner. They do not particularly gel well as doubles partners at first but work hard to make progress on how they play.

Each day, Ash writes in her secret diary about many of the things she has done and said, and how she learns something new each day. She has difficulty with a boy called Max but out on the water without one of their oars she and Max sort out their issues. Zia and Ash perform a dance at the Talent Contest and unfortunately Ash is involved in a rather abrupt ending to the contest.

This engaging and entertaining read is perfect for readers who love sport, tennis, going on camp, making new friends and having fun. Written in a similar format to other popular diary-style books, it has illustrations throughout as well as highlighted key words and phrases. Ash Barty Tennis Camp Diaries #2: Superstar is coming soon.

Themes Ash Barty, Tennis, Secret Diary, Camp, Tournaments, Sport.

Kathryn Beilby

General Waste by Michael Streich

cover image

General Waste has a house full of stuff. He uses a different tooth brush every day, dries his hair on a number of hair dryers, and has a collection of potions and lotions. His house is so full of stuff he has no idea of what was actually there. He lives on the top floor, and beneath him lives Gram-Gram. She saves every bit of food she can, all preserved in her enormous pantry. General Waste on the other hand never eats everything down to the last bite, because he thinks that the first bite is the best, so throws away the rest.

Gram-Gram rides everywhere on her bicycle, while the General loves his huge four wheel drive car. Gram-Gram reuses and mends her clothes, while Genera Waste loves nothing more than buying new clothes.

But comes the day when he has not more room. He calls out help and Gram-Gram is there to help. She puts many of his things into boxes to go to the charity shop and keeps back just what he needs. Then she shows him how to reuse and mend things. She shows him how to cook and preserve what he needs. Then they use some of his rubbish to make art and music. She helps him plant trees and garden so he will be able to eat food he has grown.

Cute illustrations dot the pages, with an emphasis on all the rubbish the General collects. The illustrations contrast the life style of the two people and how one of the characters changes his way of living. This is a wonderful presentation of the lifestyle of those who care about our environment. Much discussion will come out of the story as it show’s very clearly what is best for our surroundings, and how we can all learn to recycle, reuse, reduce and grow.

Themes Recycling, Environment.

Fran Knight

Liberty's daughter by Naomi Kritzer

cover image

An Nebula Award Nominee for Middle Grade and Young Adult Literature (2023), and Lodestar Award Nominee (2024), Liberty’s daughter is a fascinating foray into a near future where separatists escaping the taxes and rules of the US have set up seasteads - old cruise ships and platforms to make a country. Beck Garrison lives on Min, short for New Minerva, a seastead in the Pacific Ocean She is a finder - she finds articles that people want and when she is hired to find a missing woman, an indentured worker, she uncovers things that she did not expect. Her father, a powerful man on the archipelago, is not happy with these discoveries which lead her into danger.

Liberty's Daughter is divided into seven parts and appears to be based on a series of short stories, some previously published. The parts hang together to form a coherent whole and make it easy to read. Beck is an intrepid young woman, who is very skilful at finding things. What she uncovers about the worlds of the seasteaders is shocking. There is a biotech world, a sin city and bond workers are chained to desks performing highly dangerous work. The world that Kritzer describes is well fleshed out and it was easy to picture the different places, especially those built up on cruise ships. 

A coming-of-age story, Beck faces the task of freeing bond slaves that have been tricked into signing contracts. She becomes an advisor for a reality TV show based on the seastead and connects with illegal workers' fights organisers as well as facing a pandemic that threatens everyone lives. With a dysfunctional family setting and some difficult choices for Beck, Liberty's daughter is a thought provoking and intense read.

Readers who enjoyed this might like her award winning Catfishing on CatNet, and try others in the Lodestar Award shortlists for Best YA Book 2024 like Unraveller by Frances Hardinge and The Sinister Booksellers of Bath by Garth Nix.

Themes Dystopian fiction, Artificial islands, Missing persons, Private investigators, Working class.

Pat Pledger

Something special by Emily Rodda

cover image

Well-known award-winning Australian author Emily Rodda has been writing for 40 years. Her debut novel Something Special was written in 1984 and was a CBCA Book of the Year in the Younger Reader Awards category in 1985. To celebrate the 40-year anniversary, HarperCollins Publishers have re-released this short novel for a new generation of readers.

The story is centred on the school fete and Sam and her mother Lizzie are involved in organising the second hand clothing stall. There are bags of clothes spread throughout the house with Sam’s younger baby brother Toby causing some mischief. When the clothes are finally tidied and packed away in boxes ready for the fete, Sam falls asleep in the large chair. When she awakes she finds that some of ‘The Special’ items are being worn by their previous owners. Sam is bewildered by how this could have happened and interesting conversations take place between Sam and the visitors. When it begins to get out of hand, Sam wakes up screaming and is soothed by her mother. All is as it was in the room. Was Sam dreaming? At the fete, the second hand clothing stall does very well, with those items known as ‘The Special’ all going to the right fit person. But there is one particular customer who has a connection to Sam and Sam is left wondering if it really was just a dream.

This is an engaging story with a touch of fantasy and magic but was written 40 years ago and some of the references to children’s discipline may not be what would happen now. Teacher's notes are available.

Themes School Fete, Second hand Clothes, Dreaming, Fantasy.

Kathryn Beilby

Milly's mind: a peek inside autism by Colin and Milly Armstrong. Illus. by Jo McGivern

cover image

Milly’s Mind: a peek inside autism, is a refreshing and engaging explanation of how a child with Autism Spectrum Condition (ASC) sees their world. Written by Milly and her dad Colin in clever, carefully constructed rhyme, the reader is taken on a journey that explores how Milly lives with ASC on a day-to-day basis. She explains how her brain responds to things, how sometime her words do not come out how others would like, how she reacts to situations, and how she struggles socially at times.

ASC is a natural variation in how the brain grows
It affects how I think, learn and, I suppose,
It probably explains why I have no filter.
And why sometimes I seem a little off-kilter

Milly is an energetic and vibrant child with a winning personality who has wonderful support and understanding from family and health professionals but more importantly provides those in her life with immense joy. Milly also has a vital message to share with others to enable them to show kindness and acceptance of those with ASC. As all children struggle with emotions, often those are heightened for those with ASC. As Milly says:

When something goes wrong, or I make a mistake,
I get gripped by emotions I cannot shake.
The wave of feelings can build up in me quickly,
I get lost in the anger rolling in thickly.

Those who are quick to judge children who may not always ‘fit society’s norms’ are just being themselves on their own journey and deserve our respect and understanding.

Milly’s Mind is an essential book to share with both children and adults and has a place in all libraries.  

Thank you Milly for being so open and honest. You are incredible and have an amazing story to tell. Visit Milly’s website for further information.

Themes Autism Spectrum Condition (ASC), Family, Humour, Neurodivergent.

Kathryn Beilby

The Crayons love our planet by Drew Daywalt and Oliver Jeffers

cover image

Our planet is a colourful place...white ice caps, green trees, blue oceans and skies, brown soil . . . and more! And each crayon is delighted to share their part in keeping it colourful, especially Beige who pops up constantly to highlight his contribution, like a little toddler desperate not to be overlooked.

This is a funny addition to this series for young readers, as they are encouraged to look at the world around them and its colours and begin to develop an appreciation for their environment and their responsibility towards it. It opens up opportunities for some elementary data collection as natural elements and objects are classified according to colour as well as art appreciation as they discover the myriads of tints, tones and shades of the hues of the colour wheel represented in Nature.

As well as being lovable characters in themselves, the Crayons always have adventures and experiences that can lead to greater learning, and this one is just as promising as all the others in the series.

Themes Colour, Environment, Conservation.

Barbara Braxton

The wrong hands by Mark Billingham

cover image

The wrong hands sees the return of Detective Declan Miller following his first appearance in the Sunday Times bestseller The last danceThe wrong hands is London based detective crime writer Mark Billingham's twenty-third crime novel. Billingham is well known, for the Detective Inspector Tom Thorne series (two of which were made into a hit TV series on Sky 1) and another series broadcast on BBC1 based on the novels In the dark and Time of death. Billingham has twice won the Theakston's Old Peculiar Award for Crime Novel of the Year and has also won a Sherlock Award for the Best Detective (Tom Thorne) created by a British writer. Detective Declan Miller is a new and different central character. The crime writing remains in good hands. Be prepared - one of the greatest aspects of this book is the play on words. The twists, turns, false trails and false assumptions of the plot lead the reader on a merry ride. The clues are made available to the reader but concentration is needed or they will be missed. (This reader missed them). 

Detective Declan Miller is a larger-than- life character. He is described by the omniscient authorial voice as having a 'butterfly mind'...'easily distracted'.This is irritating for both his colleagues and the crims but it points to an unusually active mind - capable of making connections that others don't see. And of course this is exactly what makes him the unashamedly, not-so-humble best detective. Probably, one could think that he is 'on the spectrum' because of his single-minded crashing path through social situations. He is abrasive, rude, says what he thinks and is inclined to operate solo with scant regard for his offsider and/or any of his colleagues. He has a big mouth and unpredictable responses and the reader learns to wait in trepidation for whatever he will say or do next.The storyline is drenched in dry and hilarious English idiomatic dialogue that is liberally sprinkled with swearing and rough banter - the language of the police and criminal underworld in Blackpool. Miller is the funniest of all.. 'you dozy donk', 'Bloody Nora'. There are many laugh out loud scenarios and conversations. If you open this book at any page the wit is there. However Miller has a softer side. Real friends in his ballroom dancing group understand him. He regularly describes his ongoing casework to them. This parallel retelling is a clever authorial strategy as it aids reader understanding of the multiple characters and strands.  Crucially, Miller's detective wife has been recently murdered, and though he is officially banned from the case, he cannot help himself from intervening, using his trademark unconventional and unsanctioned methods. 

Blackpool is an English coastal town which has its fair share of low-skilled, disaffected people. Billingham's descriptions of the overcrowding, the sleazy guesthouses, the homeless druggies, the down-market dance halls, the late night drinking and the criminal network are drawn from real life. Blackpool, which in The wrong hands, follows rival criminal kingpins morphing from operating sleazy burger joints to drugs and paid killers, has in real life a crime rate that is 155% compared to the national crime rate so this detective/ crime novel is set in the perfect location. 

A briefcase figures large in this story. In the briefcase is a pair of severed hands - proof of a contract killing. A host of characters enter the plot: local shonky business owners, criminal gang leaders and their disenchanted wives, a hitman, petty thieves, homeless druggies, a psychotic welder, various police officers and detectives and more. The briefcase is wanted and people are killed in the collateral damage caused by the search. Stakeouts are arranged and fail until the startling finale.

The crimes are significant and on-going. A killer must be caught. Miller is memorable - a fully drawn character complete with flaws. Despite his idiosyncrasies he has greater powers of observation and a superior mind compared to the police with their unsuccessful, possibly past-caring investigation of his wife's death. The clues are there; the red herrings are there. Both the reader and the investigators trip up and follow false trails but the ride and the denouement are worth it. The action is so visually evocative that it is no wonder that Billingham's books are of great interest to screenwriters. Until Detective Declan Miller launches onto the screen though, he will inhabit your mind for a while.

Themes Police detectives, Crime.

Wendy Jeffrey

Always was, always will be by Aunty Fay Muir & Sue Lawson

cover image

Always Was, Always Will Be is a book that shares the powerful story of both the injustice for First Nations People that began from the time of the arrival of the first European settlers in the 1800s and the subsequent battle for respect and a voice in Australia today. This is their story. A story of what happened in the past, what is still happening in the present and what may happen in the future. White settlers used power and force to dominate the traditional owners of the land and coerced them to adapt to the ways of the Europeans. This began the long process of truth, equality and the legitimate fight for justice that First Nations People continue to strive for today.

Beginning with a foreword where the authors stress that great care was taken to source material written by First Nations People, but also mention that it is still a work in progress as history is complex with many layers to it. The contents page follows and the chapters are set out in chronological order beginning with European Arrival and ending with the Voice Referendum and Conclusion. In the final pages is the Glossary, as well as Picture Credits, References and information about the authors.

Throughout the book are mentions of historical figures such as William Barak, a Wurundjeri leader, who wrote letters asking for better treatment of First Nations People. He actively protested about how his people were treated and desperately tried to find better solutions. Torres Strait Islander Eddie Mabo fought to have his home island of Mer (Murray Island) to be taken out of the hands of the Australian Government and given back to the people who had lived there for thousands of years. This court battle took over ten years to be resolved in favour of Eddie Mabo and the people of Mer. Then there is the story of AFL footballer Michael Long and the Long Walk from Melbourne to Canberra to raise awareness of the appalling conditions in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities. Accompanying the highly accessible text and evenly spread all through the book are many photographs from the period of time being discussed and these add to the engagement for the reader.

Always Was, Always Will Be has a place in all libraries. It is an honest and important resource to be shared and discussed, not only for upper primary and secondary students but also older Australian non-First Nation adults who grew up with a completely different version of Australian History.

Teacher notes linked to the Australian curriculum will be available soon on the Magabala website.

Themes Australia, First Nations People, Justice, Activism, Campaigns, Colonial History.

Kathryn Beilby

Giovanni by Crystal Corocher. Illus. by Margeaux Davis

cover image

This book gives a fascinating insight into one of the lesser known waves of migration to Australia, that of the Italians. This picture book by Corocher examines the story of her great grandfather, using extensive research and family memories. Giovanni’s family left Italy in 1881, along with dozens of other Italian migrants, lured by the promise of paradise in Australia as part of the Marquis de Rays expedition. But the organiser was corrupt and these people were part of his scheme of making money from a group of hopeful people and their families. An early people smuggler, the ship he put these families on was less than seaworthy and they were not carrying enough food for the journey.

When their plight became known, they were helped by Sir Henry Parkes, then Premier of New South Wales, who helped them finish their journey.

Courage and resilience shine through this dual language outline of Giovanni’s journey. Told in English alongside the Italian, and interspersed with words from the family, this well produced book gives a new face to Australia’s story of migration.

The illustrations give a bright, detailed  background against which the story is set. The olive trees at the start in Italy, are revised at the end of the book as they settle into their farms in Australia with olive trees heralding their agricultural prowess. Many smaller groups of migrants have been almost ignored by writers, and it is great to see this family’s story presented to a young audience, not only showcasing the story of Giovanni and his family, but underlining the enormous journey early settlers took. The expanse of the sea and the little boat, in the middle of the book made me shiver.

The detail of the illustrations will enthuse younger readers as they spot the rats, the storage of food, the clothing and seeing all on the map at the end of the book. More information is included at the end.

Themes Australian history, Immigration, People smugglers, Italian migrants.

Fran Knight

Words Between Us by Angela Pham Krans and Dung Ho

cover image

Felix and Grandma have always lived oceans apart - until the day Grandma arrives in the city from Vietnam. Felix is so excited to meet Grandma and spend time with her. But it's tricky when he speaks no Vietnamese and she speaks no English. They get by with both showing each other special things like Felix's pet iguana Pete and Grandma showing him how to care for the garden but one day, when Felix and Grandma are visiting a big festival, Grandma gets lost and doesn't know how to ask for help. It is then that Felix decides to teach her English, and by working together and teaching each other, they bond closely as they learn to share words as well, culminating in their shared love of pizza.

With end papers that have flashcard translations of common words, (and Grandma's recipe for pizza), this is another story like  I Hear a Buho and Giovanni that allows us to share and celebrate the languages spoken by our students as they take the opportunity to teach us the common words for the things that unite us regardless of our heritage. Having bilingual books in our collections and actively promoting them is a way that we can build bridges and open doorways for those who are not native English speakers by showing them that we value what they can bring to the teaching and learning experience.

For many newcomers to this country not speaking the common language can be a very isolating experience, compounding the difficulties of what must have already been a difficult decision, but if we can reach out to families through stories - perhaps even inviting them into the library to share the stories of their childhood in their own language to encourage those of the same background to hear them and learn about them - we show the parents, particularly the mothers, that we care and that their child will not be lost. And, in return, we all gain so much!!!

Themes Grandmothers, Communication, Vietnamese language.

Barbara Braxton

Local icons by Sally Heinrich

cover image

South Australian author, illustrator and artist Sally Heinrich, has had her stunning hand-created lino prints of influential SA icons displayed in a beautifully presented new publication. Each double page spread showcases one of these well-known, and not so well-known icons, with both accessible well-spaced text and a detailed striking image.

This perfect ‘coffee table’ book begins with a brief introduction to Sally, followed by the contents page, a delightful forward by Tracy Crisp who writes… ‘through her art, Sally shares with us her wonderful sense of curiosity about the world…’ and then poignant words from Sally describing her journey to appreciate what she has found in South Australia.

Each of the local icons considered and celebrated by the inticate and colourful lino prints has a compelling story to tell. The first one is Don Dunstan resplendent in pink shorts, followed by Humphrey B Bear with whom Sally had a strong childhood connection. Other influential people mentioned are Julia Gillard, Gladys Sym Choon, Dr Andrew Thomas, Mahomet Allum, Paul Kelly, Dame Roma Mitchell, Jack Oatey, Nora Heysen, Iparrityi, Kate Cocks, Colin Thiele, Mary Lee, Koolbiri, George Hubert Wilkins, Po Chun Fung aka Bobo, Mary MacKillop, Max Schubert and Anne Wills.

Some of these icons will be more familiar than others but their own individual stories have played an important role in shaping South Australia in so many different yet connected ways. Local Icons deserves a place in a home, school or public library, and would also make a fabulous gift.

Themes South Australians, Influential People, Biographies, Art, Lino-Print making, Achievements.

Kathryn Beilby