Reviews

Stormswept by Helen Dunmore

cover image

HarperCollins, 2012. ISBN 9780007455416.
(Age: 11+) Highly recommended. Morveren lives with her parents and twin sister Jenna on an island near Cornwall, a place that is completely surrounded by the ocean except at low tide. One day, Morveren finds a teenage boy in a rock pool down by the sea, stranded after a storm. Going to his rescue, she is amazed to find that he is not human, but a Mer boy. Her sister Jenna, the sensible one, refuses to face the truth, until their Air and Mer worlds collide.  
This is the fifth book in the award-winning Ingo Chronicles, although it doesn't begin where the last book left off. Instead, it involves exciting new characters in the same world. This is good, as it makes the story more refreshed while keeping the same familiarity of the past four books. Helen Dunmore has a knack for writing beautifully lyrical prose that suits the themes of the book perfectly, as most of this story takes place in or around the ocean. This is the main thing that will draw you into the book: incredibly vivid descriptions of majestic underwater worlds. It's an excellently written novel.
The book is a little hard to get into at first, but once the fascinating underwater world of Ingo is introduced, it's a book you simply cannot put down. The author has managed to weave a very convincing and utterly enchanting world that will have you guessing what really lies in the depths of the ocean.
A fantastic read from a very talented author, this is a book that will cast a spell over you with beautifully vivid descriptions of another world.
I highly recommend this book.
Rebecca Adams (Student)

The Horse Road by Troon Harrison

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2012. ISBN 978-1-4088-1935-7.
(Age: 10-16) Highly recommended. The Horse Road is the first in a series of three equestrian adventures. Set in Ferghana, Central Asia in 102 B.C. we follow the story of Kallisto, a brave and passionate young 14 year old who has inherited her love of horses and her horse riding skills from her nomad mother.
After racing her horse with her friend Batu, Kallisto spied the Chinese Army approaching her city on a horse stealing mission. On her return to home, she discovers her beautiful white horse Swan has been captured and she must plan to rescue him.
With an absent father and a seriously injured mother, Kallisto must discover her inner strength and rely on her own bravery and problem solving skills. She is a young female who stands up for her rights and beliefs in a time when women were expected to follow rather than lead.
This story is based on historical fact as the Chinese did go into battle to gain the unique horses described in this book. It is obvious that the author has thoroughly researched the historical background to the story and has a wide knowledge of horses herself. She is able to take the reader along with her 'on horse-back' in this fast paced novel. I am not a 'horsey' person myself and do not willingly choose fiction in this area but I was engrossed in this exciting story and the time frame Kallisto had for rescuing her beloved horse Swan.
I will definitely be reading the next books in this series, Cold Freedom, set during WWII and Red River Stallion which is based in the Canadian fur trading times of the 1830's.
An exciting story for readers aged 10 to 16 years, highly recommended.
Jane Moore

EJ 12 Girl Hero: Fashion Fraud by Susannah McFarlane

cover image

Scholastic Australia, 2012. ISBN: 9781921931147.
As another addition to the EJ12:Girl Hero series, this book will again will be popular with the 8+ readers. This series is definitely aimed at girls who are keen on adventure and see themselves as capable of saving the world. Set largely in Paris and with a focus on fashion what girl will be able to resist reading it?
EJ 12, Emma Jacks in real life, is concerned about what to wear to a dance party on the week end when she is summoned, by the secret agency she works for SHINE, to investigate the theft of the Mona Lisa. This of course has been somehow organised by the enemy evil agency, SHADOW.
A trip to Paris during fashion week, clues hidden in delicious eclairs and references to major art galleries and specific paintings by Monet and Delaunay add some exotic elements to this spy adventure for EJ12. The villains Madam Ombre, proprietor of the Salon du Chocolat, and Alicia Noir, fashion designer extraordinaire, are the focus of the investigations.
With the aid of some James Bond like gimmicks EJ12 and her friend EK12, not only regain the stolen master pieces, but participate in a fashion show wearing the centre piece dresses and also manage to rescue 3 cute poodle puppies.
The message on the cover 'Reste toujours toi-meme', gives a clue to the authors' message, reiterated in final chapters when EJ12 realizes that she has the confidence to be true to herself and not be intimidated by the opinions of others.
Girls will not only be attracted to the attractive pink cover but will enjoy the challenge of deciphering the messages hidden in the eclairs and the thought of participating in a Paris fashion show whilst learning a little basic French.
Sue Keane

Night beach by Kirsty Eager

cover image

Penguin Group Australia, 2012. 315 pgs., p/b. ISBN 9780143206552.
(Age: 15+) 'Imagine there is someone you like so much that just thinking about them leaves you desperate and reckless.'
Night beach is a dark and mysterious story narrated by Abbie, a normal 17 year old girl who lives with her mother, stepfather and her 21 year old step cousin Kane. Abbie has three main obsessions; Surfing, Art and Kane. There is something cagey and different about Kane since returning from a surfing trip to Indonesia. Abbie wants to know what happened whilst Kane was away and why he is so different. Abbie's Art project is an important part of this book and her obsessive thinking about Kane combined with her need to create an art project is intertwined by the author to create a sequence of disturbing experiences for Abbie.
The story started well, having me hooked in the first chapter because of the surfing. With Eager herself a surfer, the dialogue is very descriptive, setting the surfing scenes superbly. The plot is generally plausible and easy to follow. It lost me a little in the middle but kept me wanting with the mystery of Kane and what happened while he was away. The way Eager doesn't reveal too much early in the story keeps you hanging, making this book difficult to put down at times.
Night Beach is a great read for ages 15+ and although this coming of age story is targeted at teenagers it also suits an adult audience. Abbie's powerful infatuation and yearning for a boy is a typical storyline for the intended age group, and the ensuing issues and language usage is suitable. If you enjoy mysteries and paranormal stories and are interested in surfing and art you will find this book very appealing. The story did leave me with some uncertainty but it does do well in luring you in and forcing you to think.
Michelle Thomson

The girl who could silence the wind by Meg Medina

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2012.
The girl who could silence the wind, the favourite of god, the girl who can answer prayers.
Sonia is an angel, the saviour of her people in the poor mining town of Tres Monte. Born during one of the worst storms ever seen Sonia is the girl who could silence the wind. Sonia lived her life carrying the burdens of her village in the form of little prayer charms called Milagros which were pinned to her ever-present shawl. Sonia's prayers were always answered. That was until Luis's body was recovered, and in confusion and misery Sonia herself prepared his body for rest. A tiny seed of doubt planted itself firmly in her mind. Perhaps she wasn't an angel and maybe god listened to her no more than any other. Full of self-doubt Sonia finds herself working at Casa Mason having realised the dream of all young people to escape to the city. It is only there, weeks later, that Sonia learns that her brother is missing. Sick with dread and having seen an apparition of her dead mother Sonia telephones Pancho asking for his help. Can the pair save Sonia's brother in time? Or will all of their efforts be in vein? And who or what is this mysterious Iguana?
The girl who could silence the wind is a excellent fantasy story about breaking free of the restraints of a small town and finding oneself. This compelling story is easy to read and perfect for young people of all ages. Intoned with magic and sadness this superb novel is one to read again and again on a cold winter's night.
Kayla Gaskell (Student)

Freak Street : Meet the Supersons by Knife and Packer

cover image

Scholastic, Australia: 2012. ISBN 9781741699180.
Recommended for readers 8+, especially boys, who are interested in illustrated, or graphic style, novels.
As a series Freak Street has appealed to those who are attracted to something different . The vibrant colours of the cover and  illustrations are appealing and, with a mix of illustrated novel and cartoon picture boxes throughout, this story continues to introduce the families who live on Freak Street.
The Supersons join the Zoombiesons, Wizardsons, Aliensons, Vampiresons and Humansons as residents of this unique street and are introduced in this adventure. Each of the family of five has a super power ranging from 'Tasty Transformer Power' for Mrs Superson to 'Bite Power' for baby Samson. Even the family pet, Captain Hamster, is able to hover if not fly.
Grandpa Superson calls in the family for a refresher course to hone their skills at Superhero School. Seth, the son, is only interested in drawing comics and meeting his hero, Zane Gotham, comic creating genius, who is due to appear at the City Comic Convention. With the aid of Grandpa Superson and Seth's cartoon villain Principal Clownman, the Supersons save the day from Zane and his real life villain.
Ending with a set of morals of the story, albeit of a dubious and humorous quality, this book will definitely be a favourite with Freak Street fans and students who have an interest in creating their own cartoons featuring their school Principal, or have visions of world domination by bringing their cartoon creations to life.
Sue Keane

Dreamless by Josephine Angelini

cover image

Starcrossed. Macmillan, 2012. ISBN 9780330529747.
Strongly recommended. True love can never really die, can it? As the only scion that can enter the Underworld to complete a seemingly impossible task, When Helen Hamilton sleeps, instead of dreaming she wonders through Hades, trying to end the cycle of revenge that curses all scions. Not dreaming is putting a toll on her mind and trying to fight fatigue during the day is wearing her out. Without Lucas Delos, her true love, Helen doesn't know if she has the strength to continue. But when she finds someone in the Underworld, someone who cannot be there, she has something to keep her going. Funny and brave Orion keeps Helen company in the Underworld when no one else can. The Fury's call for blood is getting louder and harder to ignore. Helen needs to find a way to end the Fury's call for blood and soon. But is forgetting Lucas the hardest task of all.
After reading this I was speechless. Helen has evolved so much in this book; her character is strong and is powerful in all she does. Even with Orion being introduced I knew she would love Lucas more. The love triangle made the book intriguing and was having me hang onto every word. The relationships between all the characters are really tight and like no other, really.
Cecilia Richards (Student.

Into the darkest corner by Elizabeth Haynes

cover image

Text, 2012, ISBN 9781921922541.
(Adult and mature senior students). This is a confronting and disturbing novel about sadistic domestic abuse and murder. It begins with a transcript; the defendant has been accused of violence towards his girlfriend. The second chapter describes a murder. The action then follows two trajectories four years apart. In the earlier Cathy is a confident, attractive and risk-taking young woman supported by friends and on the lookout for attractive men. In the second a fragile, obsessive-compulsive sufferer clings to routines that she believes will help her to survive. This is Cathy, four years after she meets the exciting and mysterious Lee. She has been traumatized by Lee, then by the police, by the court system and by psychiatric hospitals. In the earlier story Lee's behaviour follows the pattern of the classic domestic abuser in many ways. He attempts to persuade his victim, Cathy, that she is at fault; he shows remorse for over-reacting and tries to compensate; he also isolates his victim, in this case by persuading her friends that she is self-harming. Lee is more than an abuser; he is a sadistic murderer. Cathy is no easy victim and attempts to escape, but in a frightening scene she is recaptured and serious abuse begins. Fortunately this grimness is balanced by the later story in which Cathy has met a psychologist and starts treatment for her OCD. Lee has been in prison but is released and Cathy is convinced that he will come to find her. He does, and begins abuse of a former friend. Cathy is able to control her fear and plans to confront Lee. The book concludes with another court case. The description of falling in love and being with a man whom all her friends admire is convincing. The scenes of helplessness and paralysis induced by fear are riveting. The conclusion is compulsive reading. There is little attempt to explain the actions of Lee or why Cathy's friends so easily abandon her, and it is unbelievably lucky for her that a psychologist moves in upstairs. However, the novel is ultimately a celebration of survival against the odds. Unfortunately the language and some of the action make this not suitable for general use in schools.
Jenny Hamilton

The tainted throne by Alex Rutherford

cover image

Empire of the Moghul. Headline, 2012. ISBN 9780755347612.
(Age: Senior students, 15+) The Tainted throne is the fourth in the Empire of the Moghul series which explores the history of the Moghul conquerors of India. Jahangir, heir of Akbar, has finally come to power as the fourth emperor. His first challenge is to suppress a revolt led by one of his sons. This he does, brutally, and attempts to form closer relationships with his other sons. Another significant act is to order the murder of a nobleman whose wife, Mehrunissa, would then be free for Jahangir to marry. Mehrunissa quickly discovers that she can control Jahangir and therefore the empire by both feminine wiles and the careful addition of opium to his wine. She alienates Khurrum, his most capable son, who is forced to flee with his family. Jahangir anoints a less able son as his heir but is little concerned with the fate of his empire. On the death of Jahangir Khurrum mobilizes nobles unhappy with the control of Mehrunissa and seizes the throne. He will be known as Shah Jahan. A lot of bloody battles and gory punishments are described in some detail, as are the banquets, often following the battles, and other celebrations. A sense of the sweep of history and time is given, as the emperors remember the actions and advice of their forebears. The flow of people across the subcontinent, Persians, Armenians, Portuguese, English attracted to this most wealthy empire indicates the power of the empire. The many battles are described colourfully and realistically. The clothing, the buildings and the jewels could not be more lovingly depicted by the Moghuls themselves. The account is based on some historical records, but there is no analysis of the political or economic realities of an empire of this size and wealth. This is a novel of derring-do, full of men of action who do a little regretful musing on the burden of power but who mostly celebrate the ruthless, and two wives who although supposedly in purdah are strong influences on those men and their empire.
Jenny Hamilton

The Mapmaker's Apprentice by Peter Cooper

cover image

Scholastic, 2012.
(Age: 10+) Recommended.This is the second book in the Tales of the Blue Jade series. Dillen, Koto and Tajni are free of their cruel masters and ready for their next adventure. Dillen is drawn to a respected mapmaker's appeal for an apprentice and hopes to be chosen. But many others want the job, and the test for them all is to undertake a journey to a mountain pass haunted by a fearsome creature said to be the size of a barn and to move like a hunting snake. Dillen and his friends soon discover they have an even more perilous mission on their hands, one that could be the end for all of them . . .
Right from the start, this book grabs your attention. Opening with a particularly exciting scene involving the aforementioned monster, it sets the mood for a standard but fun fantasy novel. It continues right where the last book left off, with the three main characters finally free of their cruel masters. They're likeable characters, good for this type of children's fantasy novel, engaging enough to keep children reading. This book isn't really aimed at older readers, as one can tell from the writing style and lack of stronger themes, but it's still very enjoyable. It's a standard fantasy book, e.g. going off on a quest, battling evil monsters and the like, but it manages to still be a lot of fun to read.
Fans of fantasy will enjoy this little treat of a novel. It's aimed at younger readers but older people will enjoy it as well.
I recommend this book.
Rebecca Adams

Operation Trinity by Clifford Riley

cover image

39 Clues. Cahill files 1. New York, Scholastic, 2012.ISBN 9780545431439.
Recommended for readers 8+, who will appreciate the link between the online world and books.
The Cahill Files are an offshoot from the 39 Clues series which feature the Cahill and Vesper families and have been very popular with many 8+ readers. This book stands alone and does not rely on information gained from reading the previous books.
The Cahill files trace the secrets of this most powerful family over the past 500 years. Operation Trinity tells the story of a famous art work the Van Eyck Altarpiece from the first attack on it in Ghent in 1566, through its rescue from the Nazis in 1945 to a modern attempt to steal it in 2008.
The three eras introduce members of the family charged with protecting the art work and give the modern members of the family Ian and Natalie Kabra their first solo mission. The appearance of Grace Cahill to help resolve this attack on the altarpiece links the middle episode in which she features as the heroine.
The different historical eras and locations add interest to the narrative and develop the story of the quest for power between the Cahills and Vespers over the centuries. They also introduce readers to historical events, the beginning of the Dutch revolt which led to the formation of the Dutch Republic and the collection of art pieces by the Nazis during World War 2.
With its link to the internet not only will readers new to the series be able to access the website and catch up with the original storylines, but fans will be able to continue their interaction with the books as well as the games and online forums.
Sue Keane

Dead, actually by Kaz Delaney

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012.
(Age: 12+) Willow Cartwright is an ordinary seventeen year old, but at the moment she's having a bad week. When the A-list queen of Willow's high school, JoJo Grayson, dies, everyone is shocked. But now the ghost of JoJo is haunting Willow, and she's determined to find out what happened. But the mysteries keep multiplying. There's a missing phone, an anonymous blackmailer, and dirty secrets that won't stay buried. And now the blame is being pointed at Willow. Can she find out what happened to JoJo before it's too late?
This book has an intriguing story, and one that's very original. It's layered with mysteries, pop culture references and unusual characters, and there's enough humour to get you giggling every so often. Admittedly, it's not a very serious read. It's more of a 'tongue-in-cheek' novel, with lots of little side-jokes and smart comments. The main characters are well-developed, but one can't help but wish that some of the side characters - some of which are very funny - got a little more time in the novel to really shine. Teenagers will definitely like this novel, if just for the constant pop-culture references and intriguing male characters.
The story is interesting, the characters are amusing, and it's the perfect novel to read if you're bored because it'll certainly make you laugh.
Rebecca Adams

Under a silver moon by Anne Fine

cover image

Ill. by Lotte Klaver. Walker Books, 2012. ISBN 9781 4063 1924 8.
(Ages: 7+) Highly recommended. Early chapter book. Fable. A beautifully told story of two boys who grow up together in a palace, but one is the prince of the household and the other the gardener's son. Haroun, Lord of the Rolling Deserts, Mirror of Stars and Heir to all Gifts and Wonders, is cossetted and pampered until one day when he goes into the garden, he spies Akil the gardener's son and begins to play with him. Together they laugh and play but when the Sultan and Sultana find their son dirty, on his hands and knees in the garden, they take him away, admonishing the gardener. But Haroun becomes bored without his friend, so bored that he eats all day, until he can hardly walk. The family and the doctors are at a loss as to what to do.
In the garden Akil has a plan and comes to the palace dressed in a black robe. He tells the Sultan that buried in the garden is a magic key and that if the prince digs the garden and finds the key he will be saved. Eventually the prince realises that there is no key, but his old friend has ensured that through exercise and outdoor living, he has become fitter and healthier than he was before and so is saved from his life of idleness and eating.
A delightful fable for our times, Anne Fine has written a handbook for getting children out of doors and exercising to ensure their long term fitness and health. The illustrations are magnificent, showing the increasing size of the prince as he lies about eating, then slimming down through exercise. The billowing robes of the Sultan and Sultana as well as the handmaidens are a pleasure to look at, as is the growing garden created by the boys. This book would make a wonderful read a loud and discussion starter as well as a great book just to sit and read.
Fran Knight

When you were mine by Rebecca Serle

cover image

Simon and Schuster, London, 2012. ISBN 9780857075161.
This book is meant to refocus our perception of the love story of Romeo and Juliet: as the cover suggests, what if the greatest love story ever told was the wrong one? However, the story itself doesn't quite live up to the expectations of the blurb.
It is certainly a clever idea to focus the story on Rosaline, the girl Romeo claims to adore at the beginning of Shakespeare's play, the girl he forgets immediately he meets Juliet. Serle has also kept the structure of a play: with Acts and Scenes and even a Prologue and Epilogue. However, due to the relocation of the action to a Californian high school, Serle's story feels more like a west coast Gossip Girl, with the kind of heartbreak wrought from bitchy behaviour - not from everlasting love.
The reason Romeo and Juliet is considered to be such a great love story is the tragic irony of their situation; the fact that these young lovers are kept asunder by a family feud. But this dramatic tension is missing from the novel; there is indeed a family feud but it is between Rosaline's dad and Juliet's father, so does not immediately impinge on the young lovers. Rob (Serle's Romeo) doesn't even know about his family's link to the feud till very late in the story.
Serle's Juliet is manipulative and deliberately cruel, seeking revenge on Rosaline for the sins of the fathers. In her effort to make Rosaline's story seem more powerful, Serle has simply weakened the original sense of passionate love between Romeo and Juliet and thus weakened her own endeavours. Rosaline's story, as told by Rebecca Serle, is nothing more than jilted first love and falling for the wrong guy. So instead of vying for the role of 'the greatest love story' - it is really nothing more than Mills and Boon on campus!
Readers who simply want a love story with plenty of heartbreak and a happy ending will be satisfied with this novel. But those who want to view the Shakespearean tragedy with fresh eyes are likely to be disappointed.
Deborah Marshall

The Drum: The Games: The extraordinary history of the modern Olympics by Carole Wilkinson

cover image

Walker Books, 2012. ISBN 9781742032221.
Recommended. This book is a new edition of a 2008 publication - just in time to cater for Olympic fever in the build-up to the 2012 London Olympics. The author, Carole Wilkinson is an established and highly skilled author of both fiction books eg the Dragonkeeper series and non-fiction books eg Fromelles.
The summer Olympic Games is the subject of this book. The focus is very much on human interest stories, but also included are historical facts, high profile events and results eg. :

The black power salute at the 200 metres track medal presentation ceremony in 1968;
The bruising affair between Russia and Hungary in their water polo match in 1956;
The absence of the Olympic Games in 1940 and 1944 as Hitler rampaged across Europe;
An 11 hour 40 minute Greco-Roman wrestling match in 1912;
A marathon in which the winner hitched a ride by car for part of the race and the runner-up was given small doses of strychnine and brandy as stimulants throughout the race in 1904;
Golf and croquet played only once in 1900.

This paperback offering of 150 pages has small black and white photographs, and in each chapter fast fact boxes and tables. The tables enumerate the participating countries, sports offered, male athletes, female athletes and final medal tally. There are extensive quotes from Olympic athletes, officials and spectators as diverse as Jesse Owens in 1936 and Princess Mary of England in 1908. Frequent sub-headings, which break up the text, make this book useful for research purposes or attractive for a good read.
The book includes Contents, Map of host cities, Acknowledgements/References and an Index, which has been well-designed. It includes the participating countries with each such entry listing the athletes discussed in alphabetical order.
I enjoy Carole Wilkinson's writing style - personable, clear, concise and precise. She is able to draw attention to quirky facts and tales in a very natural manner. Her writing moves along at a good pace; it is easy and pleasurable to read. This book should have wide appeal to young people.
Margaret Strickland