Reviews

Too small to fail by Morris Gleitzman

cover image

Puffin Books, 2011. ISBN 9780 14 330642 9
(Ages 10+) Recommended. Yet again Gleitzman has distilled the financial crises besetting the world at the moment down into bread and butter terms. Oliver's parents own a bank and from the outset we know that things are not doing well. There are disgruntled investors knocking at their doors, media conferences to get through, staff being laid off and then packing a bag and running off in the middle of the night. Oliver has tried to do his own financial dealing at school, promising that for every $50 invested, he will return $100. Not usually good at maths, it seems a real earner, until he realises that with so many wanting to be involved he will soon owe millions. A little lesson at schoolyard level gives the reader a small insight into the financial doings of the world.
But meanwhile, Nancy has told Oliver of her predicament with her camels. Expecting a large payout of her investment with his parents to save her camel farm, has now seen the camels near death as the investment fell sour. Oliver runs away from his parents as they prepare to leave for Europe to avoid scrutiny, and drives with Nancy and her daughter, Rose across Australia to the camel farm, his dog, Barclay, in his arms. An accident sees the trio make do with part of the camel float and they limp back to the farm to be greeted by the police and Oliver's parents. Oliver has some decisions to make.
An informative story about the machinations of big business and their impact at the grass roots level, Gleitzman has managed to make some sense of the words heard everyday in the media, making this an exciting, involving story about business by showing the impact the bank has on its smallest investors.
Fran Knight

Dangerous to know by Katy Moran

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 978-1-4063-1729-9.
(Age 14+) Recommended. When Jack sees Bethany for the first time there is an immediate connection and both believe that it is true love. But Jack's older brother, Herod, has had an issue with drugs and has been hospitalised and Jack comes from a broken home, so Bethany's mother is certain that Jack is a bad influence. She is determined to separate them, especially when she discovers that they are sneaking around to see each other and going off to music festivals.  Bethany's father is terminally ill with cancer and she is torn about her relationship with Jack and keeping the peace at home. When Jack's brother disappears from the Peace Centre where he has been staying, and his very rich father arrives from the States to take over, things begin to get very difficult for Jack.
The front cover states: 'You can't choose who you fall in love with', and Moran explores the theme of first love and whether it can be lasting in an engrossing way. Jack, the narrator of the story, is a very likeable character and he tells his story in a very vivid manner, bringing to life the personalities of his friends, their strengths and weaknesses, fears and dreams. His family relationships, the estrangement from his father, separation from his older twin brothers, and the difficulties of living in a broken family are also fully realised.
The theme of drug taking and its consequences is also handled in a non-didactic, sympathetic way. Moran clearly describes the effects that drugs can have on certain individuals and the devastating consequences that can have on a family. However this is all tied in with the main theme of Bethany and Jack's growing relationship and the difficulties that the young couple face trying to keep their love alive.
When I read in Katy Moran's biography that she 'has worked the graveyard shift at many festivals', I realised why the setting of music festivals felt so authentic. This added immensely to the appeal of the book.
This is an easy to read book, which I read in one setting and the first and only one true love theme is sure to appeal to teens. However the author has given them much more than romance to think about and it has a perfectly wonderful ending.
Pat Pledger
Editor's note: This review first appeared in Fiction Focus.

Forgotten by Cat Patrick

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont. ISBN: 9781921690624.
(Age: 16+) For London Lane, life is a mystery. She can the future in flashes like memories but yesterday has gone just like the days before. Her only memory of the day before is the journal entries she leaves herself the night before. London is able to remember what she will wear tomorrow and a funeral that won't happen until years to come but the boy she loves today has evaporated from her mind. She can't see Luke in her past or her future but today she loves him and that's what matters.
London is also able to see her best friend, Jamie, getting it on with one of the teachers at their school. She can see him breaking Jamie's heart and London sets herself the difficult task of changing Jamie's future before he is able to hurt Jamie.  
This novel has a bit for everyone with romance and mysteries that surrounds London and Luke. When you think you know what is going to happen, something different happens. This novel was really well written and once I started I couldn't put it down making the end of the story come too quickly. I would highly recommended Forgotten to anyone that is looking for a great read. The author was able to make me feel sorry for London at times and other times were able to express London's feelings that I was able to feel what she would be feeling.' I would reread this book again and again.
Lauren Pfeiffer (Student)

Operation Eiffel Tower by Elen Caldecott

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2011. ISBN 978 1 4088 2573 2.
(Age 11+) What happens to children when their parents separate? How do children cope? Elen Caldecott tackles this sensitive topic in Operation Eiffel Tower. Lauren, Jack, Ruby and Billy have been listening to their parents argue for a long time and finally, in the summer holidays, their Dad moves out. The children come up with a plan to try and get their parents back together and with the help of Lauren's fashion magazine they decide to save and send them to Paris. Their hope is that their Mum and Dad will fall in love again as they won't have the kids to worry about!
As the holidays progress, they try several ways to make the money - from busking to winning a mini golf tournament - but they just don't get enough. Finally, after one of the children is hit by a car, they get their parents together under the Eiffel Tower at the Mini Golf Course where Jack works. With the help of some older family friends, the children have finally gotten their parents to talk about what happens next instead of arguing and while the parents aren't getting back together, they are starting to think about the effects on the children as well.
Elen Caldecott handles this tricky topic with seriousness and comedy. Many children today will relate to the story of this family and hopefully they will understand they have a voice as Jack bravely stands up to his parents and asks if they know what he and his brother and sisters want. Due to the sensitive nature and descriptive language used, I would recommend this book to independent readers aged 11+.
Kylie Kempster

Thea Stilton and the Star Castaways by Thea Stilton

cover image

Scholastic, 2011. ISBN 978 0 545 22774 2.
(Age 9+) Thea Stilton and the Star Castaways follows the same layout as the popular series Geronimo Stilton. Thea is Geronimo's sister and is off on her own adventures. This story is part of a series but you don't need to have read others to know what is happening as the book has an introduction and profiles and pictures of the characters. Thea Stilton is the narrator and she tells the story of our main characters - Nicky, Colette, Pamela, Paulina and Violet. They call themselves the Thea Sisters and are learning to be journalists. The girls are chosen to go on the first space flight to a resort on the moon and after much preparation, the team including investors, the girls and other journalists, set off for the moon resort. Despite the excitement, things go wrong at the resort and the girls are left to solve a mystery. Who is sabotaging the trip and the resort? Why are the robot servants attacking? Will they get back to Earth safe and sound?
The best part about this series is all the characters are mice and they use a lot of language relating to that eg.' . . . his mind is sharper than a block of cheddar', 'Fabumouse' and ' . . . chuckling under his whiskers . . . ' The larger font used throughout the story makes it interesting and eye catching for younger readers too as many of the adjectives are written in colourful font to match the action and the colourful cartoons add to the enjoyment. I would recommend this book to girls who are independent readers aged 9+. A great way to get reluctant readers reading longer stories.
Kylie Kempster

Gamerunner by B.R. Collins

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2011. ISBN 978 1 4088 0648 7.
Rick is a Gamerunner. Daed is his guardian from the corporation, Crater. Rick's job? To test The Maze for bugs and glitches. This game is much more than normal games.  Physically you become your avatar in The Maze. You run, fight and loot, all the while avoiding deadly traps. Rick's life is The Maze. When Rick accidentally finishes the game, Daed and Rick are faced with being thrown out into the world with acid rain and gang's right out the door. Rick has to work hard to stay.
The storyline is well written but I felt it was lacking something to lighten the mood at times. There was little hope through the story. Rick and Daed's relationship seems odd but Daed seems committed to keeping Rick safe but Daed doesn't seem to mind that Rick suffers in the process. I was shocked when the only character who shows some compassion meets an untimely end halfway in the book. I found it hard to get into but I eventually got into the book somewhat. I found it hard to follow the emotions of the characters. Overall I found the book all right but a bit hard to get into at the beginning.
Cecilia Richards (Student)

Strays by Ron Koertge

cover image

Walker Books, 2008. ISBN 9781406316124.
Ted is a teenaged boy who must deal with the death of his parents, subsequent entry into the world of foster care and life in a new school as a potential victim. The individuals with whom he interacts in the context of the drama have often been damaged and hurt by other people and life itself.
This is by no means a bleak story which dwells upon misery or abusive themes as so many contemporary narratives do. Instead, the characters involved in the welfare system and foster care are realistic in their essentially good intentions but imperfect makeup. Ted himself is a resilient soul possessing a mature outlook, a philosophical rationale and the capacity to silently communicate with animals.
The roles of animals are symbolic of human experiences, ranging through suffering due to abandonment and neglect to flourishing from compassion and loving care. It is soon appreciated that Ted is no Dr. Doolittle but he is a lonely and scared boy who has learned to seek solace and companionship from animals when humans have failed him. Anyone who has hugged a friendly dog will understand and identify with this.
Ted's predicament could reasonably have been the start of a spiral descending into dysfunction, disengagement and withdrawal from structured and meaningful life. Instead, the acts of kindness, the instances of loyalty and the moments of support from his peers influence this child and provide him with a sense of hope and fulfillment.
This story is simple and affirming yet I was left feeling disappointed by the fact that it deserved greater detail and expansion than is possible in a novel which is pitched at teens who won't read more than two hundred pages. There is nothing wrong with this book, however it might have been a great one if Koertge had allowed his marvellous idea to develop by doing justice to the narrative and characters. The clipped episodic events and compactly summarized characters tended not to contribute to a narrative flow and left me feeling that I was reading a heavily edited version of the larger story which had been published for less capable readers.
Rob Welsh

Star League Series by H. J. Harper

cover image

Random House Australia, 2011.
Robot Reboot (Book 6), Box Office Smash (Book 7), The Final Cut (Book 8).
(Age 8 - 12 years) These 3 books continue the story of 6 young characters that all possess a different superpower. As The Star League they battle evil, especially their arch enemy Professor Pestilence. The leader of the group is Jay who is a movie star in his daily life. In each chapter a different character from the group tells a part of the story, this includes Connor a werewolf, Asuka a Ninja, Roger a zombie, S.A.M. a robot, Leigh an animancer and of course Jay. There are black and white illustrations throughout the book that add to the understanding of the story.
Robot Reboot, concentrates on the character S.A.M. the robot, Box Office Smash introduces the Shadow Six, 6 evil kids with superpowers, while The Final Cut reveals information about Jay's long lost parents.
These quick reads are full of excitement and action and will appeal to 8 to 10 year olds and older reluctant readers.
Jane Moore

There is no dog by Meg Rosoff

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 9780141327181.
(Age: 16+)Imagine if the creator of the world is a typical teenage boy, Bob, self-obsessed, thoughtless and sex mad. His mother is a gambler and hard drinker who loses Bob's pet Eck, a strange penguin like creature, at a card game with the mighty Emoto Hed who decides that he will eat it, much to the horror of his daughter Estelle. And then there is long suffering Mr B who tries to clean up after Bob's messes and finds it depressing to attempt to answer all the prayers for help. Lucy, the beautiful young girl that Bob falls in love with works at the local zoo, and Bob, head over heels in lust, plays havoc with the weather while he courts her. Floods and droughts cause chaos in the world.
Rosoff has come up with a hard hitting idea to why the world is in trouble today with floods and famine, whales and other species extinct or endangered. It is because Bob is too careless to spend time on his creations or to think through the implications of what he does. Bob is a totally unlikeable character, or god, with no apparent good features except for the occasional brilliant creation. The anagram in her title There is no dog, is a further hint to what Rosoff is thinking, although her little group of gods appear to be more like the gods of Olympia rather than the God of Christianity.
As I read the book I kept thinking that the themes were more of an adult nature rather than ones that would appeal to teenagers. Certainly her premise of Bob being God, and only interested in beautiful girls, is one that will not go down very well in Christian schools. However I couldn't stop reading it, the inclusion of the last Eck in the world under threat of being eaten was a suspense maker, and I had to find out what would happen to him in the end!
Rosoff has written a challenging and uncompromising satire that is sure to be a discussion starter among adults who read adolescent fiction. It is definitely a book for older, experienced readers,  because of the content and the complexity of the ideas.
Pat Pledger

Meet Poppy by Gabrielle Wang

cover image

Ill. by Lucia Masciullo. Our Australian Girl series. Penguin, 2011. ISBN 978 0143305323.
(Ages 9+) Australian history. Recommended. Poppy, living in an orphanage, a mission for children with an Aboriginal background, happens upon a letter in the head sister's office. It says that her brother Gus is about to be removed to another place, one where his habit of wandering off can be curbed. Fearful, Poppy tells Gus and he takes off that night. When the same woman then tells Poppy that she is about to be adopted by a Christian family from Sydney, she too, follows her brother, cutting off her hair and donning a boy's clothes to cover her tracks. The time is 1864, and Poppy and Gus are of Aboriginal and Chinese backgrounds, and both want to find their parents.
A lively adventure, Poppy is the main character in a quartet of books about this girl of Aboriginal and Chinese parents, finding her way in the gold seeking world that is Victoria in 1864. This character is one of the girls in the series, Our Australian Girl, giving modern readers a look at how girls lived in Australia's past, an engaging addition to books which will support the new Australian Curriculum with its emphasis on history. Much information is added to the readers' knowledge of Australia's past through reading these series.
Each of the books is about 100 pages long, with large clear print and they are easy to read. The stories are gripping and characters lively and likeable. Each book has information at the end of the story underlining that given in the story, and has a teaser, the first few pages of the book following this one, to get the readers interested in the following book.
Fran Knight

Poppy at Summerhill by Gabrielle Wang

cover image

Ill. by Lucia Masciullo. Our Australian Girl (series). Penguin, 2011. ISBN 978 0 14 330533 0.
(Ages: 9+) Australian history. After Poppy runs away from the mission, she falls into life at Summerhill, a station where Aboriginal stockman Tom, has a fair idea of just who she is in her boy's disguise. He helps her as she catches her ankle in a dingo trap and taking her back to the station, nurses her back to health, all the while teaching her some of the bush crafts and lore of the local Aboriginal people. At the station she is befriended by a young girl of her own age, Noni, but her brother Joe is very suspicious and bullying in his behaviour towards her. Poppy is a lively, fascinating character, as are the others she meets in this story, and although credulity is a little stretched and the incidents do pile one on top of the other, it is eminently readable and will be highly appealing to the middle primary audience it is aimed at.
This is the second in the quartet about Poppy, a girl living in the gold rush era of Australia, with factual information at the end of the book along with a teaser leading the readers to the next in the series of four, part of the Our Australian Girl series.
Fran Knight

Poppy and the thief by Gabrielle Wang

cover image

Ill. by Lucia Masciullo. Our Australian Girl (series). Penguin, 2011. ISBN 978 0 14 330534 7.
(Ages: 9+) Australian history. Poppy hears about Jimmy Ah Kew from the owner at Summerhill Station, when he spies her letter with his seal. She leaves the place headed for Wahgunyah, the town where Jimmy lives, again alone on the road, where many adventures befall her. She shares a meal with a man she meets, and later finds he is the notorious bushranger, Harry Power, and she finds a friend in Jimmy Ah Kew, as well as a dog she calls Fisher.
The third in the quartet about Poppy, a gold rush era girl living through the mid 1860's, a time of great change for Australia. The perspective of an Aboriginal Chinese girl gives it a different point of view of many other stories set in this time, and the facts given at the end of the book will help students understand the times more readily. As with the others in the Our Australian Girl series, there is a teaser leading readers to the fourth book in this series within a series.
Fran Knight

Poppy comes home by Gabrielle Wang

cover image

Ill. by Lucia Masciullo. Our Australian Girl (series). Penguin, 2011 ISBN 978 0 14 330535 4.
(Ages 9+) Australian history. In an ending which ties up all the strands from the three before, Poppy comes home, sees our hero finally reaching Beechworth, where she is working with a travelling salesman and his crew, selling entertainment and then medicines to the beguiled public. While performing she spies Blossom in the crowd, but is distracted when the bushranger, Harry Power is brought to justice. Talking to a man in the crowd, she finds he is the bookshop owner who sensing her love of books, takes her on as his assistant. She then introduces Blossom to the owner and she is adopted by his family. Searching for her dog, Fisher, lately stolen and sold by the professor from the travelling show, she comes across some people who tell her that Gus is buried in the local cemetery. But all is not lost, it is not Gus but another boy, and the family is reunited.
An easy to read story, it gallops along with plenty of adventure, coincidences and happenings for middles primary readers to enjoy. Poppy is engaging, and readers will want to know that her family is complete, while reading of this girl in the Our Australian Girl series.
Again lots of information is given in the background of the story adding to the readers' knowledge of Australia in the gold rush era, and information is given at the end of the book, before two pages showing the next two girls in the series, Nellie, 1849 and Alice, 1918.
Fran Knight

Come down, cat! by Sonya Hartnett

cover image

Ill. by Lucia Masciullo. Penguin. Viking. 2011. ISBN978 0 670 07475 4.
(Ages: 3+) Recommended. Picture book. Just as the sun is setting, and early evening draws near, Nicholas becomes concerned for his cat. She is on the roof of their house, and refuses to come down for the night. No matter what Nicholas says or does, the cat just says, 'Marl', and moves further back onto the roof. The cat, of course, is mercurial and independent, a large white Siamese, with eyes that shine on her owner. The 'Marl' which Hartnett puts into the cat's mouth is just right, reminding generations of cat owners just how their cat sounds. But Nicholas cannot sleep knowing his cat is still on the roof and imagines all sorts of awful things happening to his cat. He finally sleeps but is woken in the night by the sound of rain. He leaps out of bed and climbs the tallest ladder to rescue his cat,  which this time is very willing to leap safely into Nicholas' arms.
A charming story of bravery, the illustrations reflect the two main characters beautifully. Nicholas is in his pyjamas, ready for bed, he climbs the huge ladder, trying to get to the roof of this enormous house to fetch down the cat.
The cat, so tiny for most of the book, cowers on the roof,but when the rain falls her face fills the page with anguish until Nicholas climbs up and she leaps happily into his arms. I love the illustrations, from the Art Deco house, to the owls and bats flying over in the night, to the wonderful sequence of illustrations showing differing perspectives, that of the act on the roof, looking down, or the boy looking up at the cat, or the owl's view of the cat on the roof. All the different perspectives encourage the reader to see things from another's points of view, not just to focus on the boy and what he feels.The discussions about just who is the bravest will keep many readers thinking for a long time after the book is read.
Fran Knight

Alaska by Sue Saliba

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 9780143206118.
(Age 15+) From blurb:
mia's heart made a sound that no one heard
except for mia
late one night when she woke from dreams into darkness.

ethan was asleep beside her, and em was a forest away.
outside it was night and dark and alaska.
the sky was upside down.

Mia has left behind an alcoholic mother to live with her sister Em in Alaska. Em had always been the older sister, the one who protected her and helped her to survive their single parent family. However when Mia arrives in Alaska, she finds that Em has new priorities, her domineering husband, Terrence and baby Christian. Beguiled by the beauty of the forest surrounding Em's house she spends much time there and it is there that she meets a young engineer, Ethan, who she feels she may love. But does she know what love is?
Saliba's prose is lyrical and sparse. The omission of capital letters for sentence beginnings and names was difficult for me at first, but no doubt teens will have no problems with that! Once I became used to that I found the writing wonderful. Indeed, the forest almost became a magical entity for me. With a few words, Saliba paints the glory of the forest landscape, the fascinating deer and the horror that it all might be defaced by the pipeline that a corporation wants to run through it.
Saliba  delves deeply in the lives and motivations of Mia and her sister Em. It is essentially a beautiful coming of age story as Mia comes to grips with the fact that her sister has grown away from her and that she too has responsibilities and challenges to face on her own. Ethan is a shadowy character and little is known about other secondary characters, leaving the readers to come to their own conclusions about them. This leads to a surprising conclusion.
Older readers will find much to think about in this book. The themes of coming of age, of responsibility, of compromise, and of protecting the environment will linger for a long time in the minds of thoughtful teens.
Pat Pledger