Reviews

Louise builds a house by Louise Pfanner

cover image

Walker Books, Australia, 2012. ISBN 978 1 921977 75 6.
(Ages: 5+) Highly recommended. Picture book. Humour. Seemingly simple, this tale of Louise building herself a house and following her construction through to the end is most appealing. Each verso (left hand side page) shows the plan of attack, and the recto (right hand side page) shows her using the part she has built. Each double page shows a step in the building's construction, with Louise at its centre, building something she wants to build and the reason for its being built.
The large white pages on the verso plan out her building, while the colourful recto show the results of her efforts. Each page adds another piece to the building: each page shows her abilities and interests, until finally the house is built, shown in all its glory towards the end of the book, and reflected on the front cover.
Readers will thrill at the efforts Louise goes to build her house, adding many features they will want to discuss, while talking about the things they would want to include in their houses. They will love to look at the variety of clothing she dons for specific parts of the building process, and this too will initiate discussion amongst the readers about the clothing's significance. Her choice of building materials is another point of interest and the last image of what she does with the house too, will intrigue readers.
Walker Books has added editorial comment from Libby Gleeson, as well as the author, giving her reasons behind writing the book, so adding another level of interest to a class where this book is read. Walker Books has again republished another Australian classic, one which deserves to be looked at again and again.
Fran Knight

Of Poseidon by Anna Banks

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2012. ISBN 9781742972817.
(Age: 12 +) We've had angels, vampires, demons and werewolves attracted to teenage girls and now it seems mermaids, or rather mermen (despite the protagonist's objection to this description of himself) are the new angels. Galen is a Syrena - one who has human form on land but grows a fin and swims at incredible speeds when at sea.  He feels an electrical connection to Emma and her white hair and violet eyes would indicate she, too, is a Syrena. Although she discovers she can swim underwater for a long time when Galen takes her into the deep, her legs never morph into fins. He is a Prince but she is a commoner, unaware, until puberty, that she has the Gift of Poseidon. Furthermore, as the only living heir of Poseidon, she is destined to marry Galen's brother Grom and produce offspring for Royal House of Triton.
This is a glorified teen romance with the requisite hot male, hostility with intense mutual attraction on meeting , a controlling male and reacting female, break-up and make-up. There is violence, an arranged marriage and even a visit to the wreck of the Titanic. The device of alternating chapters of Emma's first person voice contrasting with Galen's story told in the third person allows for the inclusion of the stories of the minor characters. This archetypal Cinderella plot is slow-moving but has humour in Galen's adjustment to human life. There are underwater descriptions and concerns about overfishing. The cliffhanger ending sets up the sequel, Of Triton. The target audience will love it but it seems a missed opportunity to learn much more about sea life and sea mythology.
Kevyna Gardner

Night Beach by Kirsty Eagar

cover image

Penguin, 2012; 315 pages; p/b; rrp $19.95. ISBN 9780143206552.
(Age: 16+) Here is a novel that whets the appetite for the paranormal. Night Beach in the hands of Kirsty Eagar is thrilling. As it transitions from the normal to the paranormal, Eagar injects her 'night beach' with eerie credibility, ensuring this compelling scenario is certain to capture its adolescent readership. Night Beach contains many of the elements that fire the imagination of the modern young reader - surf, the opposite sex, cars, art and the supernatural. Eagar's knowledge of surfing glows throughout this narrative, as she creates mesmeric images of the power and awesomeness of the ocean, and its addictive hold over the surfing culture.
Kirsty Eagar's strengths are indisputably in imagery, dialogue and imaginative plot creation. It is easy to feel the fear, as seventeen year-old Abbie struggles to remain afloat in the real world; even as she is drawn into the shadowy darkness of something not quite normal.
Abbie is quickly spinning outside the safety net of family, school, art assignments and into the darkness of Kane's brutish world. Kane has just returned from a surfing trip away, but something sinister has returned with him, and only Abbie can see it. Poised on the crest of the dark and dangerous, Abbie's obsession for Kane gnaws away at her. Her obsession, and his disinterest both fuel her recklessness. She cannot understand what happened while he was away, that has resulted in the return home of a different Kane, but she is determined to find out. With her mother and stepfather away, Abbie finds herself alone in the house with Kane, who lives downstairs.
Kirsty Eagar has created a broad cast of supporting characters providing depth to the canvas of this novel. However, the reader will always want to know if Abbie gets her beau, and escapes the shadows of the 'night beach.'
This novel includes sexual references, and imaginatively portrays the dark side of the paranormal. It should interest girls in the 16+ age group.
Colleen Tuovinen

My home Broome by Tanzyne Richardson and Bronwyn Houston

cover image

Magabala Books, 2012. ISBN 9781921248467.
(All ages) Warmly recommended. Picture book. Aboriginal stories. When 10 year old Tanzyne was kept at home with a bout of swine flu, she decided to write a poem about why she liked living in Broome. Two years later after an established artist worked with 12 students selected from the schools in Broome to be trained and mentored in their work, this happy, fun filled, brightly coloured book is the result.
On each page is a stanza from Tanzyne's poem, surrounded by detailed illustrations of the things mentioned. Each stanza takes on a different aspect of Broome life, the Yawuru people, bush tucker, pearl divers, animals, birds, big industry, fish, playing with other kids, the trees and flowers on the cliffs and beaches. Each stanza is richly illustrated by the large group of children who worked with Bronwyn Houston. Their detailed illustrations give an impression of Broome running parallel to the words. So the reader can pick out a myriad of features that make up Broome today: middens on the beach showing the longevity of the Yawuru people int he area, a baob tree, the diversity of cultures, the festivals, markets, the staircase moon, the humpback whale and the housing.
The book closes with a thumbnail sketch of the 12 illustrators and an outline of those who helped Tanzyne and Bronwyn in their task.
Magabala books is producing a range of fascinating material about a part of Australia rarely seen in written form, so giving students across the country a wonderful opportunity to know it better.
And this book, written and illustrated by children will have an immediate appeal to primary school people intrigued both by their introduction to Broome and the work that can be produced by their age group.
Fran Knight

Divine Clementine by Hayley S Kirk

cover image

Random House Australia, 2012. ISBN: 9781864718997.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. On the second page of Divine Clementine, Clementine is witness to the tragic and abrupt death of Stella, her best friend and aunty. We then journey to a very dark place with Clementine as she struggles with trauma and denial. For the first part of the novel, this narrative is often uncomfortable, often heart-breaking, yet always genuinely poignant. Clementine lashes out at everyone with cruel, cutting declarations, and scary, harmful actions. We hang on, and hope something will occur that lets her see her life is worth it.
The secondary characters are built beautifully: Clementine's parents, Theo the confused boy-next-door, Stella's siblings and parents, and even Stella who is flighty, unpredictable, and mysterious. Stella has totally coloured Clementine's perception of the people who love her. Only when Clementine has access to Stella's journals do we see Aunty Stella was not always truthful or fair to the other members of her family. These big reveals impact further on Clementine, and she sinks still deeper into depression, and distances herself even more from those who love her.
In the last third of the book Clementine is forced to spend her summer holiday with her aunt and uncle on their farming property. Here I found myself questioning the plot devices used by the author. Although it unfolds slowly and realistically enough, Clementine's growing affection for Thom, the young man from the next door farm, seems to have an almost too-good-to-be-true cathartic effect on her. Some time has passed since Stella's death, and the introduction of gorgeous nieces and nephews whose innocent and nonjudgmental attitudes soften her hardened heart, but chiefly it is Thom who swoops in and saves the day. And I worry about Clementine replacing one person with another, so quickly, and so completely. I know I said earlier in the review that she needed someone to show her life can be good, but this just seemed a little too easy.
However, it is the character of Clementine who holds this book together. Her voice is strong and feisty, and she is portrayed beautifully as honest, funny, and clever. So it's quite easy to dismiss these little niggles and accept Clementine has emerged with a clearer head, and a greater understanding of the fallible nature of people.
Unfortunately Divine Clementine might be overlooked since it deals with topics that seem to be everywhere in YA Lit this year: Death, grief, loss, mental illness, and family dysfunction. However, it holds its own in the company of others.
Trish Buckley

Shakespeare makes the playoffs by Ron Koertge

cover image

Candlewick, 2012. ISBN 9780763658526.
Highly recommended. Shakespeare makes the playoffs is the sequel to Ron Koertge's very well received young adult novel, Shakespeare bats cleanup. Once again Koertge tells a tale of baseball and poetry and (not quite) first love in an American Middle School setting; and once again the entire work is told in verse. Like all great books, this novel transcends its subject matter to dig away at the really big questions; life, death, love and betrayal.
The whole is carefully wrapped in a finely crafted email correspondence between Kevin, the Shakespeare of the title, and Amy, his newly found poetry buddy. At no stage does Koertge get too sentimental or overly clever as he manages to draw realistic and sympathetic teenage characters struggling with the highs and lows of teenage love. Though strictly a sequel, this novel can be read as a stand-alone book easily with the main characters' backstories adeptly slotted into the narrative.
Kevin, the poetry writing first baseman of the title struggles with himself, his brain a churning mixture of emotions. His loyalty to his current girlfriend, the beautiful Mira and his growing realisation of the intellectual possibilities of the poetry writing Amy jostle, each slight shift in his feelings described in a poem.
Shakespeare makes the playoffs stands out as a shining gem in the miasma of derivative dystopian writing that makes up much of what we have lately been offered as 'Young Adult Literature'. You don't have to know or like baseball or even poetry to thoroughly enjoy this gentle, poignant story of growing up. Dare I say Ron Koertge has hit another homerun?
Stephen Bull

Silhouette: Ambition is everything by Thalia Kalkipsakis

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2012. ISBN 9781921759659.
Silhouette: Ambition is everything by Thalia Kalkipsakis, is an intriguing novel. Teenager Scarlett seems to be the typical obsessed ballet student on a higher plane than most ballet dancers as she is studying dance at a high school, the Academy, dedicated to dance. Almost relishing the pain and wear-and-tear on her body, she pushes herself to the limit physically and emotionally.
Absolutely supported by her mother and close friends, Scarlett seems to be destined for a brilliant career, except that she makes one unexpected decision - to audition for a music clip knowing that she is not eligible until she has completed her secondary school academic and dance course. As a typical teenager, she persuades her best-friend to go along with her, but it is Scarlett who wins the place and wows the singer and everyone else. This single decision will send her life spiraling out of control, plunging her into an affair with a bored young rock star, involving her in sex, alcohol and drugs, and academic failure.
A salutary lesson for young girls, this realistic narrative is captivating and, like all of its kind, lets her off with a warning, so that her life is changed but not ruined. Satisfying, true to its genre, and rewarding honour and loyalty over rebellion, Silhouette will entertain young readers and give pause for thought.
Liz Bondar

Come into this poem by Tony Mitton

cover image

Francis Lincoln Children's Books, 2011
Recommended. Tony Mitton is a well established, highly skilled poet and children's author, with many books to his name. This book of poetry demonstrates his versatility and literary skill. Combining high level literary skills as well as whimsy and appeal to children these poems make good poetry accessible to all ages.
 I loved reading The road I tread is hard and long/ And now my heart beats not so strong, a serenade to sleep; while Invisible ink is reminiscent of Shel Silverstein's wacky humour. There is also pathos in an ode to Glengorm, presenting a brief picture of the Highland Clearances, alongside awe-inspiring observations on the simplest natural features found in a garden. Note Seed Spell : 'Bury me dark, bury me deep./Let me lie a while asleep . . . Let my root stretch out, uncoil/ sifting nurture from the soil'.
On the other hand I can just see young children performing Big red boots at school assemblies or having a go at describing Dark after reading this poem. Then there are the poems based on folklore from Chinese, Japanese and Celtic sources.
This slim volume is a treasure trove of ideas for teachers and models of great writing. Above all it's just fun to read to children and will help them develop a love of language and poetry.
Diana Warwick

Champions read. Book Week 2012 book trailer presentation by Jane Moore

cover image

Book Bubbles, 2012. 1 DVD. 25 mins. $35.00. Order form.
Recommended. The enticing Champions Read book trailer contains highlights of all the books for the Early Childhood, Picture Books, Information Books and Younger Readers in the 2012 short lists for Children's Book Week. It is a very useful tool to promote the short listed books in a primary school and is sure to attract attention and comments. The Picture book and Information sections would also be useful in a secondary school, as would some of the books in the Younger readers section, like Crow Country by Kate Constable, Nanberry: Black Brother White by Jackie French and Brotherband: The Outcasts by John Flanagan.
Champions read starts with many images of champions and children enjoying reading. Then each book is introduced with some interesting and pertinent questions. For example the introduction to The runaway hug by Nick Bland asks the question, 'Who do you give your hugs to?' and has more questions with some gorgeous illustrations that made me want to read the book again. In fact really good illustrations have been selected to go with each book (a long bibliography is available at the end) and appropriate music sets the mood for the individual books.
I particularly loved the trailer for Crow Country by Kate Constable, with its stark black and white images and eerie music, and believe that it would certainly entice a child to want to read the book.
The site licence allows the loading of the DVD onto as many computers on the school campus as is desired. Because the DVD is able to be viewed in sections, it is ideal for the whole of the primary school, with the older children watching the Younger readers section and the Information section and the younger children could watch the Early childhood and Picture book section. Classroom teachers could run it before school and while the children are having their lunch. Having the whole DVD run before and after school in the school library on a whiteboard is sure to get children wanting to read the books and it would make an excellent introduction to the books. In fact I would suggest that this DVD will stimulate a lot of requests for the books, so be prepared to have multiple copies, or short loans!
Pat Pledger

Changeling by Philippa Gregory

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2012. ISBN 9780857077318.
(Age 13+) Recommended. It is 1453 and 17 year old Luca Vero is expelled from his monastery, accused of heresy. He is taken up into a mysterious secret group, The Order of the Dragon, members of which are sent out to investigate rumours of good and evil. He is sent to find out the truth behind a nunnery, where the nuns have strange visions and some even have marks on their hands. Here he meets Isolde, who has chosen to go to a nunnery to avoid marrying a man of her brother's choosing.
Told from two different viewpoints, that of Luca and Isolde, the reader is swept into a strange medieval world where superstition is rife and where women have little power over their lives. With this novel, the reader knows that Gregory has an impeccable background with her historical research and the details are rich and fascinating. The life of Isolde is vividly described. The fact that she can't inherit her father's wealth and castle because she is a girl will be fascinating to today's readers, as will the life that she chose instead of an undesirable suitor. The mystery surrounding the strange happenings at the nunnery is well constructed with enough action and strange occurrences to keep the reader involved.
Luca is equally a fascinating character. He is careful and clever in his deliberations and finds himself involved with finding out the truth about Isolde and whether she should be burnt as a witch. Freize, Luca's companion adds a dash of humour to the stories, as well as pointing out that it is love that is all important. Ishraq, Isolde's friend and a young woman with special powers, is also a person that the reader will find fascinating to follow.
Gregory 's story of medieval werewolves in the second half of the story will appeal to today's readers who seem to be fascinated with these creatures. Once Luca has solved the mystery at the nunnery he meets up with Isolde and Ishraq again, and with Freize is summoned to resolve a matter concerning a strange beast that has been captured and which the villagers believe to be a werewolf.
My only quibble with this story is that while it deals with often complex themes, making it unsuitable for younger readers, the language and descriptions are not as complex. This however, does make it suitable to use as an easy to read introduction to the historical genre for older readers.
Historical maps add depth and the author note gives a historical viewpoint. There is a website for the series and  and a book trailer.
Pat Pledger

We are one village by Nikki Lovell

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012. ISBN 9781742378367.
Highly recommended. We Are One Village follows the journey of ex-Adelaide school girl Nikki Lovell who, at the age of 18, went to work as a volunteer aid worker in the small Ugandan Village of Namwendwa.
Nikki, unaware of the extent of poverty and disease in Namwendwa and its neighbouring villages, witnesses and is subjected to some very confronting situations. AIDS, unclean water, lack of basic necessities and a monotonous daily diet of tasteless porridge are the harsh everyday realities that these people face.
Throughout the book, Nikki's cheerful presence impacts the villagers significantly, making her a popular figure amongst the younger children. She and her colleagues assist in teaching the villagers the basics of good health and hygiene practices, as well as building up a school library stocked with books from Australian donors.
Written as a personal diary, we as readers, are given an insight into her thoughts, feelings and the labours that need to be undertaken by her and the villagers on a daily basis.
Not only do we see her struggle between her Australian upbringing and her new spiritual home, but we also see her coming to terms with a relationship breakup, missing home and the choices she is forced to make regarding her dreams and passions.
I highly recommend this book because despite its sometimes bleak subject matter, nearly every page still manages to provoke a smile. Each carefully written chapter is symbolic of her perseverance, optimism and her desire to make a difference. It is a real eye opener for those of us who take for granted our privileged and safe life, and also to how much of a difference one person can make in so many people's lives.
Nikki is commended for her past and continuing work (she has created her own aid organisation called One Village ) and remains an inspiration to all.
This book is captivating and a true reflection on Nikki's love and care for others.
Courtnie Caldinez (Student)

The glimpse by Claire Merle

cover image

Faber and Faber, 2012. ISBN 9780571280537.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. This is a compelling dystopian novel. At first, this dystopia may seem miles away from our present world; for in Merle's future, the world is divided into Pures and Crazies. A simple DNA test determines an individual's likelihood of mental illness, thus determining their 'Purity'. As one of the characters suggests, this is a world based on scientific racism. However, as we learn more about the events which led to this new world, this dystopian future may seem all too possible. References to a Global Depression and Petrol Wars will sound familiar whilst a world where people can be tracked by their online presence, may seem all too close for comfort.
And the protagonist, Ana, is caught right in the middle of the moral dilemma created in a world where the Pures have it all and the Crazies are at the mercy of the Psych Watch, who may swoop in at any moment and cart Crazies off to a 'loony bin'. Whilst the Crazy world might seem threatening to any right minded Pure, what if the DNA test that lies at the heart of this new future was not all it seemed?? For Ana this question is critical. Firstly, because it is her father who designed the test. Secondly, because of the doubt surrounding her Pure test results. And thirdly, because the young Pure she was betrothed to has mysteriously vanished as he sought to uncover the truth about the DNA test.
In her quest to rescue Jasper, Ana finds herself deep in the heart of the Crazy world where she learns that many of her prejudices were unfounded. On top of this, she just might be falling for a young man who may be Jasper's only chance for freedom . . . or who may be intent on destroying her world. Not only is Ana fighting for Jasper's future she is also fighting for her own. And as the plot twists and turns, this smart young woman, will find her courage and determination is put to the test. Her adventures will have the reader on the edge of their seats to the final page.
Deborah Marshall

Endure by Carrie Jones

cover image

Book 4. Bloomsbury, 2012. ISBN 781408821190.
'Zara is back from Valhalla after successfully rescuing Nick. Bedford needs their best warrior now more than ever, as the evil pixie regime is causing mass destruction and chaos everywhere. Though Nick's job is clear, Zara's role is a lot more uncertain. She's not just fighting for her friends - she's also a pixie queen. And to align her team of pixies with the humans she loves so much will not be as easy as she hopes. Especially since she can't even reconcile her growing feelings for her pixie king . . .' Publisher.

Comment from reviews of the first 3 books in the series:
Need by Carrie Jones
If you thought that pixies were cute little things with pointed ears, then you are in for a surprise. (Pat Pledger)

Captivate by Carrie Jones
Light, easy to read paranormal. (Pat Pledger)

Entice by Carrie Jones
It is a great book and I think it deserves 10/10 stars.
Amelia Kelly (Student)

Hist! by C. J. Dennis

cover image

Ill. by P. J. Gouldthorpe. Walker Books, 2012. ISBN 9781921977749.
(All ages) Highly recommended. A new edition of one of my favourite poems, Hist! by C. J. Dennis and beautifully illustrated by Peter Gouldthorpe, is a real treat. I loved this poem as a child, taught it to many classes when a teacher, and now will introduce it to my grandchildren, who are certain to love it as well.

Hist! . . . Hark!
The night is very dark,
And we've to go a mile or so
Across the Possum Park.

The rhyme and rhythm of the poem flow beautifully and it is one that is easy to read aloud and easy to memorise - just right for performance poetry in the classroom and great for scary fun when reading it aloud to a small group or one or two children.  
Peter Gouldthorpe's linocut illustrations are an inspiration for the imaginative child. Torchlight gleams up at the faces of the three children who go exploring at night . Mist swirls through black trees and mokes and possums huddle in the trees. Black images of witches, skeletons, spiders, birds and bats lurk on an aqua border on every page. Written in a time when children had more freedom, Gouldthorpe's last picture of the trouble that the children are in for going out at night is a lesson for children as well.
This edition has a commentary written by Dr Robyn Sheahan-Bright and information about C. J. Dennis.
Peter Gouldthorpe writes about his inspiration for the book and his realisation that the poem 'Wasn't really about what actually happens, but how the imagination can run wild in the dark'.
This is a beautiful addition for any library and a great gift for children.
Pat Pledger

Department 19: The rising by Will Hill

cover image

HarperCollins, 2012. ISBN 9780007455409.
(Ages: 13+) Highly recommended. Adventure. Fantasy. A stunning opening takes the reader into the world of the Loop, an unknown base housing Department 19 within the most secret place of the British Intelligence system, where a group of people, selected almost as a birthright, seek out and kill vampires, the modern scourge within world communities. Heroes, Larissa, Jamie and Kate retrieve two vampires, taking them back to the Loop, where a group of scientist are working on an antidote. But along the way, the words, 'He Rises' are seen as graffiti, chilling the very essence of many of the vampire hunters.
In the first book, Department 19, the premise for this exciting story was given as Jamie a witness when his father was killed by a group of black suited unknown assailants and his mother kidnapped. He eventually found out that his father was a member of this department but both his parents had turned, causing a moral dilemma amongst the group, which included Frankenstein and descendants of Van Helsing. Jamie joins the group, despite their having murdered his father, and is surprisingly joined by Kate, a vampire, but one who wishes to help destroy the evil overtaking the world.
This second novel is absolutely full of incident and adventure as the trio pit their wits against the vampires, often locked in blood soaked battle with them. Within the story, the relationship between the trio is stretched to the limit as Jamie and Kate begin a romance, and Larissa is also befriended by another hunter who Jamie does not like. The trio keep their secrets and this causes tension between the group, adding to the fascination of the story.
Jamie is at once a likable hero but arrogant and selfish, often treating his two friends badly, putting his own demands first. His position within the facility too, gives cause for concern as he is seen as someone who has gained seniority through influence not talent, and is treated scornfully, often with suspicion.
In three months, Dracula is said to be ready to take over the world again, as his servants from his past have stolen his remains and found a way to revive him. So the countdown is on. The first part of the book, 91 Days to zero hour, will keep readers on track to get through the 700 pages full of action to find they still have 85 days to go! But no worries, it is a great read, with the promise of much to come.
Fran Knight