Reviews

The True Tale of the Monster Billy Dean Telt by Hisself by David Almond

cover image

Puffin Books, 2011. ISBN 9780670921096. 255 pages.
Senior Fiction. This is the story of Billy Dean brought into the world on a day of death and destruction and kept in a room for 13 years, protected from the world outside by his nurturing mother. He is visited occasionally by Wilfred, his violently unpredictable father, who wishes to teach Billy how to read and write. Bringing to the boy his own confused interpretation of the world outside, this learning process for Billy is demanding and throws his tiny world into disarray, though he tries to please his father as best he can. When Wilfred disappears, after almost killing his son, Billy's mother brings him out of the room and, with the help of two neighbours, he is introduced to the world outside. Billy Dean is considered an angel child, a mystical, Christ-like figure who has the power to help and heal. He is preyed upon for this reason, as this world is full of sickness and suffering and looks to someone for salvation.
This immediate world is a monstrous place and it takes time for Billy to realise this.
We are reading Billy's story; the book that he is learning to write as he pieces his life together.
This is an extraordinary tale, multi-layered and suspenseful, with unforgettable characters. David Almond explores what can happen to an innocent boy, when dramatic events take hold of a community, engulfing it in devastation and violence.
The title has been marketed as Almond's first adult novel but the publishers obviously intend the book to be read by children as well. Reading this book takes time and considerable concentration, as it is written in phonetic prose.
With its post-apocalyptic theme, there is much to discuss for senior students. Comparisons can be drawn with the novel, Room by Emma Donoghue.
Julie Wells

The Jewel Fish of Karnak by Graeme Base

cover image

Penguin, 2011.
(Ages: 5-11) Reminiscent of The Legend of the Golden Snail this newest Graeme Base book takes us on a visually stunning journey through Ancient Egypt where Jackal and Ibis are taught an important lesson about theft and greed. While pleasant the plot takes backseat in this book (as they often do when Graeme Base is involved) to the striking illustrations and the 'mystery' that needs to be solved. To solve the mystery one must work out the true appearance of the precious Jewel Fish. Heading to Graeme Base's website will inform you whether you have solved the mystery and reward you with a printable Jewel Fish template. I was quite disconcerted when I began reading this book as I was never very successful at cracking Graeme Base's codes but I didn't have much trouble with this one at all (are they getting easier or am I getting smarter?!) The dust cover has some added value in that it contains some interesting factual information about Ancient Egyptian life and tells us more about some of the more obscure words used in the story such as 'coracle' (an Egyptian boat made from papyrus reeds). Overall, the illustrations are spectacular and I had a surprising amount of fun going online to see if I had cracked the code (there are also hints available if you are struggling) but the story is ultimately unremarkable. But can you say no to Graeme Base?!
Nicole Smith-Forrest

Learn with Maisy by Lucy Cousins

cover image

Walker Books, 2011.
(Ages 2-5) Recommended. A fun, bright, lift-the-flaps book, Learn with Maisy explores colour, weather, number, size, movement, touch, days of the week, sound, pattern and more and there are cheeping yellow chicks around every corner! On first glance the format is the same as your usual first concepts book but this Maisy book really reaches above and beyond that. The interaction encouraged between adult and child is beyond counting and letter sounds with discussion prompting questions such as 'who is spotty?' and 'what kind of weather do you like?' It differs in a dramatic way from other concept books of this type in that it doesn't just ask us to count or name but encourages involvement and engagement. The reader is asked for example, 'Can you make these noisy noises?' (lawnmower- bruummm, trumpet- tooty-tooty-toot) and 'Can you jump like a kangaroo?' Children are also encouraged to engage in more complex thinking such as being presented with 2D un-textured pictures of things such as a porcupine, an egg, an icy-pole and a cat and being asked, 'what do these feel like?' Also explored are comparisons and opposites in ways that support children in making these connections rather than just being informed, such as when they are asked 'who has a big tail?' which encourages them to explore various animals and their attributes. This is a fantastic book to share with children who are curious and eager to share their developing knowledge of the world. Learn with Maisy is a refreshing concept book that doesn't underestimate children and breaks free of that same predictable format. It is clear to see that a lot of thought about how children develop conceptual understandings has gone into this book. Most of all it is fun and bright and children will love it!
Nicole Smith-Forrest

If kisses were colours by Janet Lawler

cover image

Ill. by Alison Jay. (Board Book Edition). Templar Publishing, 2011.
(Ages: 0-5 ) This is a delightful board book filled with charming metaphors for a parent's kisses and enhanced by Alison Jay's unique illustrations. This may be a familiar title as it is a board book edition of the 2003 publication which Janet Lawler describes as a 'mother's love poem'. For those unfamiliar with it the text is rhythmic and lyrical, each page beginning 'If kisses were . . .' and entwined with whimsical imagery such as 'If kisses were acorns, a forest would grow of beautiful oak trees in row after row'.Kisses are also likened to comets, pebbles and sparkling snowflakes of silver and white. If Kisses Were Colours is one of those heart-warming books that is as much for the parent reading the story as for the child although I have no doubt the colours and the magical illustrations along with the poetic prose would hold the attention of any child. The pictures themselves are warming and comforting, much like receiving a big cuddle or snuggling up in bed on a rainy day. This is an absolute gem of a book for sharing with a young child plus one that they would be happy to sit and thumb through themselves for the pleasure of the pictures alone.
Nicole Smith-Forrest

The Mary Quinn Mysteries by Y.S. Lee

cover image

Walker Books, 2011.
A Spy in the House. ISBN 9781763652890. The Body in the Tower. ISBN 9781406315981. The Traitor in the Tunnel. ISBN 9781406315974.
(Age 13 +) Highly recommended. Set in Victorian London these mysteries feature the intriguing and entertaining character of orphaned Mary Quinn. Rescued from prison at the age of twelve and placed in a children's home, she is recruited at age 17 to work undercover in a secretive women's detective agency. The books vividly recreate the historical times and in particular illustrate well the inequity in living standards between both rich and poor and men and women in those times.
All three books feature the charming character of James Easton as a love interest and the storylines are all well plotted with twists and turns to sustain interest. My favourite story, The Body in the Tower, authentically describes the building of Big Ben as the final addition to the British Houses of Parliament. These books will be a very welcome addition to school libraries for readers of historical fiction and the detective genre. Teenage girls will identify strongly with the courageous and ingenious Mary.
Chris Lloyd

Wicked warriors and evil emperors by Alison Lloyd

cover image

Ill. by Terry Denton. Puffin Books, 2010. ISBN 978 0 14 330434 0.
(Ages 10+) Warmly recommended. Humour. History. The inventive drawings of Terry Denton litter each page and tell the story of the fight for Ancient China, between an array of amazing emperors and warriors each intent on building his strength and defeating all comers in the bloodiest of ways. For readers, especially boys this is an instant winner, as weapons abound, armour is put on, heads chopped off, and rightful places achieved. From the first emperor, a young boy of 12, who had an impressive Prime Minister, Lord Shang, to the last emperor, the Qin province remained in power. This province took control after the period of the warring states and kept it for many years, before the Han Dynasty took over in 202 BC.
Lloyd gives some very funny and bloodthirsty stories in this potted history of China, and with Denton's drawings adding to the humour kids will read the book form beginning to end. Pages are interspersed with information about the weaponry used by the armies, other pages give easily absorbed outline maps and drawings of the soldiers, while chapters are divided up with lists and columns containing information given in an interestingly diverse way. All designed to hook the reader, the whole achieves this with ease. Some of the stories will have kids recalling and repeating them to their friends, while I am sure this book will be passed around the classroom for others to read.
A quiz on the last few pages will ensure the fun is continued, and a time line and list of the powerful ends this most entertaining book.
Fran Knight

Froi of the exiles by Melina Marchetta

cover image

Book Two of the Lumatere Chronicles. Penguin, 2011. ISBN: 978-0-670-07608-6.
After reading the first two books of the Lumatere Chronicles I have discovered that the chronicles are much more than just books, both Finnikin of the Rock and Froi of the Exiles are epic fantasies of the kind that are rarely seen today. Both have, I believe, the genius of something similar to The lord of the Rings and Harry Potter. The only books I've read by Melina Marchetta have left me with a hunger for more.
Froi of the Exiles follows three years after its predecessor in the kingdom of Lumatere of Skuldenor. The curse of Lumatere has been lifted and trade is just beginning between Lumatere and its neighbours. But all is not well. The Mont valley suffers an 'infestation' of sorts; Charynite's have come to beg sanctuary from their own. They bring with them wild talk of plague, curses and plots to kill a king. In order for peace to return to the Valley Froi is dispatched on a mysterious mission to Charyn; but what he finds there amidst the anarchy will leave him questioning his home, his heart and even his way of life.
This richly woven tale is guaranteed to keep the reader on the edge of their seat and while some concepts may be frightening and confusing to readers younger then fourteen I would easily recommend this novel to anyone with a thirst for fantasy. I have to add that I thoroughly enjoyed every page of both books of Lumatere and I'm sure we will soon be hearing of awards won by Froi of the Exiles. The next instalment is expected in October this year, entitled Quintana of Charyn.
Kayla Gaskell, (Student, 15)

Guess How Much I Love You by Sam McBratney

cover image

Pop-up ed. Ill. by Anita Jeram. Walker 2011. ISBN 9781406327977.
(Age 2-5) Highly recommended. A pop-up edition of a well loved picture book, Guess How Much I Love You is sure to please young readers. It features two hares, one very small, Little Nutbrown Hare and one very large, Big Nutbrown Hare. Little Nutbrown Hare is going to bed and wants to get the attention of Big Nutbrown Hare so he pulls his ears and asks, 'Guess how much I love you?' Little Nutbrown Hare throws out his arms, reaches as high as he can go, goes upside down to his toes, hops high, but each time Big Nutbrown Hare can go further and higher.
This is an endearing book that beautifully demonstrates the love between father and son and ends in a perfect confirmation of just how much the father loves his little son. Anita Jeram's illustrations in soft washes of browns, greens and blues are beautiful. The pop-up sections and flaps of the book are fabulous, but I would advise that parent or teacher carefully supervises the wheels as little fingers could easily pull them apart.
This is a book that will become part of a cherished collection for my grandchildren.
Pat Pledger

Relics of the dead by Ariana Franklin

cover image

Bantam Books, 2009. ISBN 978 0553820324.
(Age: Senior school) Highly recommended. Crime, Medieval.1176 and bones have been discovered at the Abbey at Glastonbury, one is small in stature, the other larger, like a warrior. In a country in turmoil, with the Welsh trying to hold back Henry 11 of England, the idea that these bones are those of the Once and Future King, Arthur and his wife Guineverre, is enough to give strength to the Welsh cause. Henry 11 wants them identified preferably not as those of the king, Arthur and Guineverre, but the monks, in desperate straits, want a reason for people to make pilgrimage to their abbey, desperately short of funds. Into this maelstrom of conflicting interests, Henry 11 sends Adeliar Agular, his 'mistress of the art of death', to find out exactly whose bones they are. She in turn is angry that he has once again been able to circumvent her own wishes and send her on this perilous mission, one in which she is yet again exposed to the whims of the men in her life.
A fascinating story follows, firmly entrenched in its setting of the medieval township and abbey, with wholly credible characters moving around each other, often belligerently, sometimes with love and understanding, but always capturing the readers' interest and eagerness for the story to unfold.
Adelia is a wonderful character, a trained doctor in a time where few had scant knowledge, and women not at all, she must move about England with her trusted servant, Mansur, a Moor, to whom in public she defers, taking on the role as his translator to defray knowledge of her abilities. Added to this problem, she has a daughter, and the father of this child, Adelia's former lover, is now the Bishop of St Albans, who regularly intrudes on her life.
This the third in the series of books about Adelia, is a book to savour and keep to reread. Its setting is masterful, the attitudes and lifestyle of the times impeccably revealed, and the crime to be unravelled, complex and involving. Ariana Franklin, the British author, Diana Noonan, died in 2011. Her marvellous creation, Adelia has lived through four books, Mistress of the art of death (2007), The death maze (2008), Relics of the dead (2009) and a fourth, A murderous procession (2010).
Fran Knight

Knuffle Bunny free by Mo Willems

cover image

Walker, 2011. ISBN 9781406336498.
(Age 2-5) Recommended. Trixie and her family are off to Holland to visit her grandparents. They have a wonderful trip on the plane, and it is not until the next day that Trixie realises that Knuffle Bunny has been left on the plane. When her father rings the airport, he discovers that the plane is on its way to China.
Pictures of Trixie, Knuffle Bunny and her family are superimposed on black and white photos from around the world and this makes for a wonderful opportunity for children to explore both the real world and use their imagination. I was captivated with the portrayal of the trip, the taxi ride to the airport, going through security, the waiting around and finally the plane trip itself. For parents who are planning going on a holiday by plane this would make a perfect book to familiarise young children with what to expect and also to help them to remember to get all their toys from the plane's seat pocket. The photos also give a great background to the Netherlands and the centre page foldout shows all the wonderful places around the world that Knuffle Bunny could be visiting.
The story itself is a wonderful example of family love and a young girl beginning to grow up a little and realising that she may have to part with beloved toys. I loved the ending and so will people who are reading this story to young children.
Pat Pledger

Pegasus by Robin McKinley

cover image

Puffin Books, 2011. ISBN 9780141338095.
(Ages 10+) For thousands of years the humans and pegasi have leaved peacefully in the beautiful green country past the wild lands. Their only means of real communication is through pegasi shamans and human magicians and that's the first thing either species learns about the other. So when Sylvi is bound to her pegasus, Ebon, on her twelfth birthday it is a big surprise when they can understand each other. Within a few weeks they become best friends, but some people do not like that they can understand each other and believe it's dangerous. As their bond becomes more powerful it does become dangerous and their friendship could threaten to destroy the peace and safety of their two worlds.
I enjoyed this book heaps. I would recommend this book because not only is it a good book, it also had an amazing friendship in it, Sylvi and Ebon, that would just about be impossible to break.
Tahlia Kennewell (Student)

Daughter of smoke and bone by Laini Taylor

cover image

Hodder and Stoughton, 2011. ISBN 9781444722635.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Karou keeps two lives in balance. On one hand she is an art student in Prague, on the other she travels around the world collecting teeth from endangered animals and criminals for Brimstone, a monster who is family to her. She was raised half in Elsewhere and half in the normal world. When the doors to Elsewhere begin to close, Karou is forced to choose between the human world and the strange and dangerous place behind the doors.
Taylor has created a fabulous world for this highly original fantasy. The beautiful city of Prague is brought to life, with its intimate coffee shops and narrow alleyways. Then there is Elsewhere, a frightening but compelling world, where Brimstone concocts strange beings and the land is being torn apart by war.
Karou's normal life as an art student is vividly described. She has blue hair and is immersed in the art scene in Prague, drawing unusual fantasy creatures that no one guesses are her family. She is strong and independent, careful of her friends, but hiding secrets. When Brimstone sends a message via the almost crow, she drops everything to do his bidding. The reason that Karou collects teeth is a wonderful device used by Taylor and kept me guessing until all was revealed. Other twists and turns were introduced as well that kept the suspense of the story quite enthralling.
For those who like romance with their paranormal fantasy, Akiva, an angel who loves Karou, will be a satisfying partner as the tragic events that surround him provide Karou with clues to her real identity.
Taylor has created a rich world world that will ensure that readers eagerly await the next book in the series. The ending, which is a cliff-hanger, is also sure to both frustrate readers who longed for a satisfying conclusion and entice people into reading the sequel.
Pat Pledger

Going Underground by Susan Vaught

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2011.
(Ages: 15+) Highly recommended. This novel opens with the main character, 17 year old Del, digging a grave and pondering his life in the 'deadzone' a place 'without life, without feeling, without air'. He has no prospects, despite still being at school and a good student, is not permitted to apply to college and the only job he can get is working for an alcoholic cemetery caretaker.
What could this boy, who was bright, funny and friendly, a child that any parent would be proud to call their own, have done that was so dreadful as to ruin his whole life? His story is told in a series of flashbacks to the time three years ago, when his world was turned upside down. The account is cleverly accompanied by Del's own musical soundtrack, that reflects his thoughts and feelings. When the circumstances are slowly and painfully revealed it comes as a surprise and a shock, but not for the reasons you think.
Del falls for the beautiful Livia, seeing her when she visits her sister's grave. She is sweet and lovely with her own tragic background, and he faces the dilemma of having to tell her his secret without losing her. The matter is further complicated by the Goth girl Cherie who has taken a shine to Del, despite knowing his past, and cannot take the increasingly strident hints that he is not interested.
The characters are appealing, quirky and well rounded, even Fred the foul mouthed and cheeky African gray parrot who is Del's  constant companion. It is especially pleasant to see that the majority of adults are thoughtful, compassionate and kind, not the cliched villains or clueless stereotypes that feature in so much YA fiction. There are of course exceptions to the rule in the cynical and hypocritical DA who appallingly uses the situation to further his own career.
This is an engaging and rather lovely novel, that deals with the topical themes of teenage sexuality and sexting as well as friendship, love and loss with sympathy and understanding.
Alicia Papp

Assault by Brian Falkner

cover image

Recon Team Angel, Book 1. Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 9781921720543.
(Ages 14 +) Recommended. When the story begins it is 2030 and most of the world has been taken over by an alien race called Bzadians.  We are introduced to a highly trained multinational group of teenagers who are part of an elite fighting squad, Recon Team Angel. They have learned the Bzadian language, how to operate their weapons and have been disguised through surgery and skin dying to resemble the enemy. This team of six is dropped into the centre of Australia to break into the Bzadian top secret facility under Uluru and destroy it.
One of the six teenage soldiers is a traitor and solving this mystery is an important element of the story. The main character of Ryan Chisnall is well developed and the bravery and inventiveness of his team leads to some exciting battle scenes. The teenage fighters are forced to make some thought provoking ethical decisions and these would be interesting to explore with readers in a class or individual discussion. For example, how many lives can be classed as just collateral damage?
This book is the first of a planned sci fi series documenting the war to defeat the Bzadians. It is recommended for boys who love adventure and war novels.
Chris Lloyd

Stink and the ultimate thumb-wrestling smackdown by Megan McDonald

cover image

Ill. By Peter H. Reynolds. Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 9781406334586.
(Ages 6-11) Recommended. In the 6th title of the Stink Moody books, Stink is excited about receiving his school report, and looks forward to seeing a long list of O's for Oustanding Achievement. He is horrified though, to see a U for Unsatisfactory beside Physical Education. Stink has never enjoyed sports, as he thinks he is so small he'd get hurt too easily, but now it looks like he'll have to find a sport to play if he wants to regain his status as the perfect student. After ruling out bike-riding, skateboarding, golf and badminton, Stink discovers the best sport of them all - Thumb Wrestling! He makes a costume for his thumb and dubs it Shark Hammersmash, but even such an awe-inspiring name cannot help him win. Deciding that perhaps he's not cut out for the world of thumb wars after all, Stink finally decides to try Karate, and finds he is very good at it. The confidence he gains from achieving his yellow belt might even give him the boost he needs to defeat T.Rex Wasabi, the school's thumb-wrestling champion.
There's a lovely message in this book, that while nobody is good at everything, everyone is good at something. Students already familiar with the characters of Stink and his sister Judy will enjoy seeing Judy feel quite proud of her brother for a change, and those new to the series will find themselves wanting to read more.
Donella Reed