Reviews

Tom and Tilly by Jedda Robaard

cover image

Black Dog Books, 2013. ISBN 9781 742032 48 1
(Age: Pre-school) Warmly recommended. Pre school. Picture book. Bath time. Delightful water colour illustrations follow the story of Tom having a bath with his bear, Tilly. Tom makes a paper hat and together they sail through the water on an adventure. They take care to avoid pitfalls: a large yellow duck, a busy city, several fearsome frogs, a storm, a whale and a whirlpool, until safely out of the bath and ready for bed.
The simple story line makes this an ideal read aloud for young children at bath and bed time, settling them into a routine of doing these things before bed, bathing, reading a story and then falling asleep. At the end of the story is a double page spread with instructions for making the paper boat in which the boy and his bear sailed through the story. This is an ideal story at bedtime, with instructions for a craft session the next day.
Fran Knight

Stories for 5 year olds ed. by Linsay Knight

cover image

Ill. by Tom Jellett. Random House Australia, 2012. ISBN 9781742756660.
Stories for 6 year olds ed. by Linsay Knight
Ill. by Tom Jellett. Random House Australia, 2012. ISBN 9781742756660.
Recommended. These collections of short stories are from well known authors including Robin Klein, Dianne Bates, Victor Kelleher, Bill Condon, Vashti Farrer and Sophie Masson who all write with flair and are sure to keep the reader's interest. As an adult I found myself starting from the beginning and not being able to put the books down until the end such was the quality of the stories. I am certain that children of the selected age will equally enjoy these engrossing stories, all in big print for the beginning reader, but equally good to read aloud as a bedtime story or as a short story for a class reading. My copies will be stored for my grandchildren.
In Stories for 5 year olds I was particularly taken by the story of The two gorillas by Ursula Dubosarsky, where a little girl decides to give the toy gorillas a bath. From then on, lots of things happen as Becky plays with the toys; some quite scary including a gorilla burial and cutting off a gorilla's arm. All ends well. Pets also feature in some of the stories and children will get a giggle out of Duck down by Janeen Brian.
Pat Pledger

Made on earth by Wolfgang Korn

cover image

Sub-title: What we wear. Where it comes from. Where it goes. A&C Black, Bloomsbury, 2012. ISBN 9781408173916.
(Age: 11+) Is it possible to write an engaging, informative book about globalisation? Wolfgang Korn has proven that it can be done. Without illustrations, Made on earth offers only text, a map, a glossary and an index, yet it takes its readers on an imaginative, enlightening and disturbing journey.
The author has turned the manufacture and distribution of his red fleece jumper into a narrative. Readers follow the production and manufacturing process through three countries until the garment is purchased then discarded, recycled and shipped overseas again. At each stage of the jumper's existence, the people who work in the oil fields, factories and retail outlets, as well as those who crew the tankers and cargo ships, tell their stories. The result is a compelling overview of the complex economic web that is the global economy. The impact of Made on earth stems from its interweaving of a mass of information with fictitious but convincing characters. The use of the present tense for immediacy and a brisk, journalistic style owe much to Wolfgang Korn's experience as a writer for newspapers and magazines. His command of the subject may be due to an interest in political science and history. The author has been well served by the translator. Readers are unlikely to be aware that the text was originally written in German. The diary structure is effective but the use of dates in 2005 and 2007 may undermine the urgency of the message, while text boxes that range over one and a half pages can be visually disconcerting.
Authors of non-fiction face the challenge of knowing that their work is not always as engaging as fiction. Wolfgang Korn has met that challenge with a fast paced, wide ranging narrative that will open the eyes of many older children and young adults to the system of international trade in which we are all enmeshed. Some may even forget that they are reading an information book.
Elizabeth Bor

The diviners by Libba Bray

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012. ISBN 9781742375229.
(Age: 15+) Recommended. Evie O'Neill has a secret, a power that has gotten her into trouble in her boring hometown where she uncovered the secrets of some powerful party goers. Bundled off to live with her Uncle Will, curator of The Museum of American Folklore, she is thrilled to be in New York City, with its shopping, parties, alcohol and speakeasies. She meets a fabulous Ziegfeld Follies girl and a handsome pickpocket, but when brutal murders occur, seemingly occult based, she finds herself investigating with her Uncle.
The glamorous atmosphere of the 1920's New York, with parties, dancing girls and gambling comes to life in the hands of Printz Award-winner Bray, who has the well-honed skill to write dialogue and describe scenes that are indelibly marked on the reader's mind. This background is absolutely fascinating and beautifully described, with the research going into making it feel very authentic. The mysteries of the occult are dark and threatening and seem even worse when contrasted with the partying, fashions and fun that flapper, Evie craves.
Evie meets up with a strange group of people in her quest for fun and her dangerous attempt to uncover the beast, Naughty John, who is murdering innocent people in a horrendous fashion. There is a large cast of characters to remember, all interesting with strange backgrounds and strange powers. Memphis Campbell is a numbers runner, whose healing ability has failed him. Jericho works for her uncle and has secrets of his own, and Sam, the pick pocket, is searching for his family who were involved with Project Buffalo. Theta dances for the Ziegfeld Follies and lives with Henry, a talented, gay musician. Together they have to face the evil of the beast.
Aimed at the mature young adult, (there are references to drinking, drugs and gambling), this large tome (578 pages), the first book in a series, is a gripping paranormal thriller full of historical detail. Libba Bray answers five questions about the book for The Horn Book
and there is a site for the series with a trailer and author information.
Pat Pledger

Quiet Queenie by Susannah McFarlane

cover image

Ill. by Lachlan Creagh. Little Mates series. Scholastic, 2012. ISBN: 9781742833316.
(Age: 3-6) This Little Mates series is beautifully Australian. Each one focuses on a different letter and a different Australian animal. In this case the letter is Q and the animal is Queenie who is quite possibly the quietest quokka in Queensland. Filled with 'q' words many of which are quintessentially Australian this book will help to extend vocabulary, assist with phonemic awareness and help beginning readers in letter knowledge and identification. The dedication of each book to a single letter sometimes results in strange choices of vocabulary and seems to dictate the path of the storyline which in the case of Quiet Queenie is more of a sequence of vaguely related information and events rather than a plot. As an alphabet and vocabulary book however Quiet Queenie is a delightful small picture book with beautiful Australian and uncommon words such as quartz, quaint, quoits, quandong, quail, quoll, quarry, quad bike, quince, quell and quipped.
Depicted in these books is the beautiful Australian landscape amid gorgeous soft and detailed illustrations which children will love searching through for other 'q' things and will delight in the cute Australian animals. These books are a great platform for initial sounds games with emerging readers and encourage the reader to relate elements of the story to their own life, thereby making some of the rich vocabulary meaningful. Each of these titles ends by posing a question to the reader, in this case 'Are you quiet sometimes too?'
Nicole Smith-Forrest

The Voyage by Murray Bail

cover image

Text, 2012, ISBN 9781921922961.
(Age: Adult - Senior students) The main character of this novel for adults and senior readers is Frank Delage who manufactures pianos to his own revolutionary design. Accompanied by a piano he travels to Vienna from Sydney, where his workshop is based, to publicise his wares in one of the cultural centres of Europe. What follows is a Jamesian juxtaposition between the old rich and traditional culture of Vienna and the gauche clumsiness of the colonial who has travelled to show them a new way of making 'their' instrument. In drawing rooms where Strauss played and Schoenberg had visited Delage tries to awaken the Viennese to his new ideas, but with little success. The Viennese salesmen do not need more piano designs and dislike even the colour of the Australian timbers he has used, and the Viennese aristocracy seem rather amused by the oddity of a new style of piano. Frank is aware of himself as a man with little charm, a quality he does not trust, and little business acumen. He does attract attention from the aristocratic and cultured Amalia Marie von Schalla who may have had doubts about his piano but liked him enough to show him her breasts. Unfortunately for her, Frank has by now also attracted the attentions of her daughter Elizabeth who decides to accompany Frank on his less than triumphant return home. He does sell one piano, but it has little chance of converting listeners to its radical design as it has been chosen to be centre piece of a conceptual work in which the piano is totally destroyed. Oddly for a maker of pianos Frank likes silence and particularly dislikes the chatter of the drawing room and his sister, and all women, it's tempting to conclude. He had hoped for a silent sea voyage home, but has to engage with Elizabeth and the few other passengers. His reflections on his experience and his reactions to that experience are expressed in a stream-of-consciousness style that jumps from subject to subject, often mid-sentence. Frank is not a believable character and the style is clumsy. Fortunately this book is short as it never springs to life.
Jenny Hamilton

The Interrogation of Ashala Wolf by Ambelin Kwaymullina

cover image

Walker Books, 2012. ISBN 9781921720086.
(Ages: 14+) Recommended. Ashala Wolf is the leader of a tribe of illegals hiding in the Firstwood. Now she has been captured by Chief Administrator Neville Rose. He is intent on destroying all illegals especially Ashala's tribe. To avoid getting caught she tried to kill herself and almost succeeded but instead she is now injured and vulnerable. And with her Sleepwalker ability blocked she has no way of escaping. Ashala is forced to give up her tribe's secrets to a machine that can pull the memories from her mind. While her betrayer, Justin Connor, is right beside he, watching her every move.
Ashala loves her tribe and the Firstwood, it hurts her to think that because of this machine she is betraying them. This is a great new series. With unexpected twists and a continuous sense of suspense it kept me reading till the end. I would recommend reading this book and I hope the future books in this series are just as good as this one.
Tahlia Kennewell (Student)

Every day by David Levithan

cover image

Text, 2012. ISBN 9781921922954.
(Age: 15+) Recommended. Named only as A, every day is a different life in a different body. Sometimes A wakes up in the body of a boy and sometimes in the body of a girl, but always A applies the guidelines: Never get too attached. Avoid being noticed. Do not interfere. But then A wakes up in the body of Justin and meets Justin's girlfriend, Rhiannon and discovers that he wants to be with her every day.
This is a challenging book that is very difficult to classify and to describe. I had it on my shelf for a very long time, but when it starting coming up on best lists for 2012, I knew that I would have to read it and I am so glad that I did. Levithan has delved into what love is by using A's experiences in different bodies. He explores love that is casual and complacent in how Justin treats Rhiannon; he looks at a very caring, accepting love between two young women and ultimately we see how A looks at love and what A does to make sure that Rhiannon is happy.
After the initial period of getting used to the fact that A goes from one body to another - and it is never explained how or why - I found that A's voice was so authentic that I felt that I knew and really liked and respected the character that A maintained even while in different bodies. It is never clear if A is a boy or a girl, but is just a caring, thoughtful individual who is trying to take the best possible course in a terrible predicament.
The ideas in this book will be challenging for many as Levithan looks at love, sexuality and relationships of all kinds, but ultimately it made me examine the selflessness of real love, no matter where it is found. It is a book that is sure to promote much discussion.
Pat Pledger

Croak by Gina Damico

cover image

Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2012. ISBN 9780547608327.
(Age: 13+) Recommended as a humorous paranormal read. Lex's behaviour has become violent, so her parents have sent her off to live with her Uncle Mort to try and get her to calm down. She thinks she is going to be staying on a farm, but when she gets there she is shocked to find that her uncle is a Grim Reaper and he is going to teach her the family business. She discovers that she fits in really well in the town of Croak, but her sense of justice doesn't allow her to disregard the action of murderers.
I picked this title up from a best book of 2012 list and really enjoyed its originality and humour. Damico has the ability to write not only very funny dialogue but she keeps the reader grinning with her descriptions and the names of the town of Croak, its streets and surrounds. Her conversations with Edgar Allan Poe and the games of US presidents in the Afterlife are also hilarious. However there is also a dark side to the story and the mystery surrounding the unexplained deaths is riveting and there is also some heartbreak that will bring a tear to the eye.
Lex is a fabulous heroine. She is smart and fits in well with the Reapers, but finds that she cannot subdue her sense of justice. It becomes imperative that she discovers the killer who leaves victims with strange eyes but no cause of death. This of course gets her into trouble in the town of Croak and her adventures with Driggs and a group of young misfit reapers are a great read. The love interest with Driggs will keep young readers interested but it is her character, her forthright manner and her quirky sense of humour that will remain in the reader's mind.
This is a good book to offer teens who would like a break from the saccharine paranormal romances that abound at the moment.
Pat Pledger

Racing Car is Roaring by Mandy Archer

cover image

Ill. by Martha Lightfoot. Busy Wheels series. Scholastic, 2013. ISBN: 9781742835112
(Ages: 3-6) Recommended. Rabbit loves racing around the track with Racing Car. The big race is about to take place and as the mechanics do some final checks on Racing Car Rabbit zips up his overalls and puts on his helmet. VVRROOOMMM goes Racing Car as Rabbit steers it onto the track and WHOOSH go the cars as they screech around the bend. But what's that up ahead? The crowd gasps. There's an oil spill on the track! Can Rabbit and Racing Car get safely around and will it be Rabbit standing on the winner's podium?
The great elements of this book are its simplicity of story, the relaxed way it introduces new and technical language and the fun way it encourages interaction with its readers. The technical language or terms associated with cars and car racing such as 'pit stop', 'skids' and 'marshall' are printed in bold print allowing young readers to pick them out and consider them. The illustrations themselves are clean and bold with primary colours and are very accurate in their representation of the machinery and its parts and the race track itself. The last couple of pages dedicate themselves to factual information about race cars. There is a labelled diagram of a racing car and labelled pictures of different types of racing machines, eg. Motorbike, Formula 1 car, rally car.
This is not only a fun and engaging story but is highly factual and informative - a perfect story to share with those curious machine-loving preschoolers and young school-age children. Not only will children pick up a lot of new language and concepts but it provides ample opportunities for questions and discussions around what these concepts mean, examining similar terms eg. 'marshall' and 'umpire' and looking at the discourse and symbols of the car racing world, eg. 'Lights out' means 'go'.
Nicole Smith-Forrest

Sammy and the skyscraper sandwich by Lorraine Francis and Pieter Gudesaboos

cover image

Book Island (NZ), 2012. ISBN 978 0 9876696 0.
(Age: 4+) Board book. Picture book. Endeavour. This unusual board book expounds the tale of a young boy gathering together a whole range of food items from the kitchen cupboard and the fridge, to make a sandwich. He piles stuff on top of each other until it reaches the second floor of the house, passing dad in the bath. Then on until it reaches the roof, going through the roof to go ever upward until he needs a crane to add things to the top. The twist at the end takes Sammy back to reality.
This board book is unusual as it has a large number of words to read out to a child wanting it read aloud. As it is a board book, it is one that a child can hold and be rough with, but its size (about 40cm by 25 cm) takes it out of the range of a very young child. It will need adult supervision because of its size and the number of words, and children will need help with the story as it is most unusual, telling a tale about a child using up all the food to build a sandwich which he then does not eat.
Younger kids will love it being read to them and they will love finding all the food mentioned in the text, as well as following Sammy's adventure and mum's patience. Each page has a variety of things to look at and talk about.
Fran Knight

October Mourning: A Song for Matthew Shepard by Leslea Newman

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2012. ISBN 9780763658076.
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended. Matthew Shepard was a 21 year old gay student who was savagely beaten, tied to a fence and left to die; all at the beginning of Gay Awareness week at his college in 1998. And the guest speaker for Gay Awareness week was Leslea Newman, the author of this verse novel which is a moving and powerful response to a shocking crime of hate.
It is a slim volume of 68 poems which unfold chronologically; the first part focuses on the night Matthew was attacked, the second part on the subsequent trial. Surprisingly perhaps, given the subject matter, this is not a difficult book to read. Indeed there is a certain beauty and elegance about the volume which makes the story it tells even more shocking. And this dichotomy is nowhere more apparent than in the cover: a seemingly peaceful pastoral scene which takes on new meaning with the prologue poem The Fence (before).
Cleverly, the author offers us unique perspectives on events: from the fence which held Matthew to the moon looking down upon him, from his cat waiting anxiously at home to the shoes he wore on that fateful night. The one voice we do not hear is Matthew's. Yet the humanity of his tale is more imaginatively evoked by revealing how many were touched by his death.
Newman weaves her tale with a variety of poetic forms, some quite simple (haiku and rhyming couplets) and some more complex (pantoums and villanelles). Often it is the sheer simplicity of form that will strike a chord with the reader whilst the variety complements the varied voices. Newman's 'explanation of poetic form' at the end of the volume, only adds to the value and depth of the work.
Newman's sympathy clearly lies with Matthew and she openly labels his attackers as 'monsters'. However, extensive notes at the end of her collection outline her sources and the context of each poem and if readers are concerned about her bias, there are also several pages of resources for further viewing.
If October Mourning is A Song for Matthew Shephard, it is also a song of hope: that we can learn from his death. This is not just a lesson in humanity, it is an extraordinary achievement.
Deborah Marshall

Granny Grommet and me by Dianne Wolfer and Karen Blair

cover image

Walker Books, 2013. ISBN 978 1 921720 16 1.
(Age: 5+) Highly recommended. Picture book. Overcoming fear. Grandmothers. The child in this delightful picture book fears the water. Often going with Granny to the beach with her friends, the Granny Grommets, she sees them riding the waves, ducking, diving, twisting and turning as they surf in the bay. The child stays on the shore with the dog, watching. Sometimes she ventures into the edge of the water, but jumps back to shore when something touches her legs. Slowly the grandmothers urge her to take to the water. First they sit in the shallow rock pool, making sure she feels safe and comfortable, then the larger pool that is the ocean is braved, when with goggles and the four women nearby she looks at what the ocean offers.
The child in the story is not given a name and could be a boy or girl,  so will be accepted by all readers: a child fearing something and being helped to overcome that fear gently and with support.
The superb illustrations carry the text beautifully, the use of water colour with chinagraph pencil, aptly showing the beach and its movement as the child and the older women tackle the problem. The four women in their various swimsuits and then wet suits are just wonderful, their lolly legs striding the sand with confidence, their belief that the child will come in too, paramount. There are touches which I really enjoyed: the larger sized print on each page, the four colours used to differentiate the four women, the observed animals, the seagulls, the dog and the life beneath the waves. Both the story and its illustrations are just lovely and will be used by both parents and teachers to tell of someone else's fears, and how they were overcome and to showcase a day at the beach. And above all that, to tell a great story and share the luminous illustrations.
Fran Knight

Birthday bonanza by Aleesah Darlison

cover image

Ill. by Serena Geddes. Totally Twins series, Bk 4. New Frontier Publishing, 2012. ISBN: 9781921928208. 188 pages.
(Age: 7-11) Recommended. This is the fourth 'fabulous diary of Persephone Pinchgut' and strange names, witty musings and humorous family drama are what you will find hidden within. This is one of those books that you feel like you've read a hundred times before but is nevertheless indulgently fun to read. Young girls will love 'sensible' Persephone and her love-hate relationship with her identical twin sister Portia. Bossy, self-obsessed Portia is completely different to Perse who is kind and sensitive. Just back from a fabulous holiday in Fiji Perse and Portia are busy planning for their 11th birthday party. Well Persephone is planning - Portia is scheming how to have a birthday extravaganza complete with disco ball and hundreds of guests. It seems that the birthday party is all the twins have to worry about or look forward to . . . until numerous bombshells are dropped and all pandemonium breaks lose. Engagements, surprise house guests, lots of babies and one princess party ensues. In between all this there is Portia attacking baby possums, yoga classes in the house, cake obsession, wet undies being thrown around, happy dances over white bread sandwiches and many un-received 'secret signals'.
This is a lovely book which deep down is about two sisters who may be different but love each other dearly. It also deals very lightly with issues of divorce, step-parents and coping with family change. Full of wit and humour and funny family happenings and conversations this diary story flows easily, is well written and has some fantastically amusing black and white illustrations scattered throughout. A classic pre-teen read that girls will simply love.
Nicole Smith-Forrest

The Burning Library by Geordie Williamson

cover image

Text Publishing, 2012. ISBN 9781921922985.
(Age: Mid secondary - Adult) Recommended. Is 'greatness an attribute that we value in authors anymore'? In The Burning Library: Our Great Novelists Lost and Found, Geordie Williamson takes the provocative stance, particularly against Australian academia, that students are not exposed to enough of our greatest writers. Of course, 'greatness' can be subjective but Williamson believe that the Australian literary canon has been dismantled by academics 'in the name of greater inclusiveness and democracy' - hence the perceived equal value of a bus ticket and Moby Dick, for example. Williamson is knowledgeable and erudite and his book will hopefully generate, if not 'Literature Wars', but a powerful petition for study of Australian classics.
About fourteen authors and their works are analysed in dedicated chapters, although there is overlap between these writers and also those not featured, such as Thea Astley. Williamson focuses on his chosen authors' most important works, or those that advance his own thesis. Even though Williamson explains why he has selected these authors, it would be interesting for readers to add to his list. Thomas Shapcott and David Foster come to mind. And conversely, how can Williamson justify including Thomas Keneally and Patrick White as overlooked writers, even if White may not be read as much as expected? Female writers form about fifty percent of the content - a laudable but unforced effort by Williamson. They include Elizabeth Harrower, Christina Stead and Amy Witting (who, incidentally, worked at Sydney's Cheltenham Girls' High School).
The Burning Library is a useful resource to scaffold close study of the chosen authors and their texts in secondary and tertiary institutions. Quotes from great writing are also analysed. But will this book tempt young readers to read any of the featured literature? I think it could be the catalyst for a fascination with Australian literature but, of course, nothing beats reading the books themselves.
Joy Lawn