Reviews

The snow Womble by Elizabeth Beresford

cover image

Ill. by Nick Price. Bloomsbury, 2012. ISBN 9781408834244
(Age: 3-7) Picture book, Environment, Christmas. Elizabeth Beresford died in 2010, and her famously inventive and ground breaking stories about the Wombles are now being reprinted. The Wombles, conceived initially to clean up Wimbledon Common, first appeared in 1968 when environmental themes in children's literature were sparse. A television series followed and the Wombles became very well known in the United Kingdom with a song that most people can sing or at least hum. With their theme, 'make good use of bad rubbish' they proved to be a herald of good behavour.
In this book, The snow Womble, first published in 1975, only a hint is given of the original intent of the series of books. When the Wombles emerge from their burrows on a very wintry morning, the whole of the common is under snow and so very white and very clean. The young Wombles decide that they do not need to tidy up today so take some time off. Three decide to build a snow Womble, but while Bungo builds the model, Orinoco sleeps and Tamsk snowboards. The finished product is made to look like Great Uncle Bulgaria so that when Tamsk snowboards down the hills he calls out to uncle to move, which of course, he does not. The inevitable happens, and several valuable lessons learnt, especially when Great Uncle Bulgaria emerges from his burrow to hear the little Wombles talking about him.
At the end of this fun filled book is a sheet of stickers for kids to use, showing each of the Wombles.
Fran Knight

Picnic at Hanging Rock by Joan Lindsay

cover image

Penguin (Australia) 2012. First published (Australia) Cheshire, 1967. ISBN: 978067007685.
Recommended. 'Whether Picnic at Hanging Rock is fact or fiction, my readers must decide for themselves.' - Joan Lindsay.
My first impression of the text Picnic at Hanging Rock was that it would be an English story about well-behaved girls at a boarding school who went on a picnic; however I soon found that this classic is much more than this. The children's novel is a hauntingly atmospheric tale which has wormed its way into the hearts and minds of Australians providing an unsolved mystery of whether the story was indeed fictional. Our story starts at Appleyard College for Young Ladies where students and teachers alike are revelling in the holiday of St. Valentine's Day. The girls set off (with two governesses) on a long anticipated picnic to Hanging Rock and spend a lazy afternoon at the picnic grounds. However, while exploring; three senior girls disappear without a trace leaving their companion, Edith delirious with terror. The incident soon sets off a magnificent series of events.
A dramatic mystery without a conclusion Joan Lindsay shows a previously unknown devotion to her work. The novel was written over a period of four weeks and as much mystery surrounds the story as the publication (the novel was published purposely without the final chapter). Although the more pressing mystery of this novel is whether or not this is truly fiction? The author bids the reader to decide for themselves however I remind the reader that there is a grain of truth in every work of fiction.
Kayla Gaskell (Student, age sixteen)

Time between us by Tamara Ireland Stone

cover image

Doubleday Children's Books, 2012. ISBN 9780857531155.
Time between us begins in San Francisco, 2012, and moves backwards into a main setting, Chicago, 1995. Anna is a 16-year-old girl who dreams of travel and adventure, but these dreams are smothered by hum-drum teenage life.
Bennett is 17 (in 2012) and is trying to find his sister Brooke, who is lost travelling in the past. Destiny pulls the two teenagers together in their search for Brooke, and their struggle to face their doomed love affair.
Along the way, the couple are faced with a series of obstacles preventing them from fulfilling their two goals, and towards the end Anna is faced with a difficult and potentially like-changing decision.
The characters have been written before: the relationship in the center of the book echoes overtones of Stephanie Meyer's Twilight saga, and Bennett provides a mysterious, brooding Edward-esque figure. Tamara Ireland Stone weaves an intricate and involving set of scenarios to test her characters individually and as a unit. While the relationship between Anna and Bennett can be similarly found in many already existing novels, there is a sense of freshness and vibrancy injected into this typical romantic plot. The presence of time travel creates a quasi-science fiction mood, while the reality of the characters and their emotions brings it back into dramatic territory without letting the fantasy get too out of hand. The situation of the characters remains fixedly unrelatable, but the protagonists are fairly average and easy to identify with.
Tamara Ireland Stone is clearly a seasoned writer, as she weaves different locations and time periods cleverly and effectively.
Time between us is an unconventional and gripping love story, bound to challenge existing notions of romantic young adult fiction.
Isobel Davies (Student)

Possessed by Niki Valentine

cover image

Sphere, 2012. ISBN 9781847444561.
(Age: 15+) Possessed is the story of Emma Russell, a young woman from a simple working class environment who is a talented musician. Her abilities have resulted in the opportunity to study music at a prestigious university and it is here she meets identical twins Sophie and Matilde. For some reason they befriend Emma and introduce her to a life of champagne, parties and social status. Emma is naturally drawn to the quieter twin, Matilde and is devastated when she unexpectedly commits suicide. Bewilderingly, Sophie seems to thrive after the death of her twin but her relationship with Emma becomes increasingly bizarre.
Things begin to happen to Emma that border on the supernatural. She wakes up in strange places, loses great chunks of time and appears to have participated in events that she has no recall of. Sophie also begins to behave erratically, at times warm and loving and on other occasions cruel and spiteful. How much of these strange happenings can be attributed to grief? Emma becomes more and more fragile as the story progresses to the dark climax.
This book has been described as a psychological thriller, reminiscent of Black Swan and this description is probably the most apt. The reader has to grapple with many questions such as why the popular, affluent twins are attracted to wallflower Emma in the first instance and why Emma becomes so heavily invested in them so early in the story, particularly when the price of the friendship seems so high. However, like shifting sands nothing is quite what it seems and reality is continually distorted. The reader must draw their own conclusions as to where the truth lies.
Tina Cain

The Enormouse Pearl Heist by Geronimo Stilton

cover image

Geronimo Stilton Series, bk 51. Scholastic, 2012. ISBN 9780545341035.
(Ages: 7-10) Highly recommended. This series is the most popular in our library; the novels hardly spend any time on the shelf! Each book is a fabumouse, fast-paced adventure featuring Geronimo Stilton the editor of The Rodents' Gazette. The readers love the colourful word-art, bright illustrations and cheesy puns.
This book stays true to type as Geronimo and his friends embark on another exciting escapade. Petunia Pretty Paws an environmentalist and TV reporter (who is Geronimo's crush), invites him to go scuba diving in the South Mousific Ocean, staying on Shell Island. Whilst diving for the first time, Geronimo discovers a giant blue oyster with a huge glowing pearl inside. This leads to a rollicking adventure with plenty of problems from the Provolone family. When Geronimo publishes a special feature about the pearl in The Rodent's Gazette more difficulties occur. Luckily Aunt Sweetfur, Benjamin and Bugsy Wugsy help to save the day.
This series is a great for boosting the independent readers' confidence. They are written in the first person making it easy to empathise with Geronimo and his quirky character traits. He sometimes lacks in self-belief and has a great support network of friends and family. This book starts with a colourful illustration of all of Geronimo Stilton's colleagues, family and friends in his office at the Gazette and ends with a detailed map of Mouse Island.
I would highly recommend this book as a great addition to the series. Reading them with a class can lead into some cheesetastic learning activities: rebus stories, writing a new adventure for the characters, mapping skills, develop class newsletters adding different font styles and types as embellishment.
Rhyllis Bignell

Kicking and dreaming; a story of heart, soul, and rock and roll by A. and N. Wilson (with Charles R. Cross)

cover image

Harper Collins, New York. 2012. 279p.
(Senior secondary - adult) Autobiography. I have to confess that I have no predilection for biography, where selected omissions can invent an entirely different portrait. The travelogue of the two sisters fronting American rock band Heart is penned by Charles R. Cross but written as if alternating the voices of Ann and Nancy Wilson.
Kicking and Dreaming proves to be a typical name dropping memoir and as such will appeal. A lifestyle of free love and drugs seems glossed over and the girls surprisingly conservative, all things considered. Whether any seamy events remain unselected or not, these women share a strong sense of family - a lifelong devotion to parents, siblings, childhood friends and to each other. Yet both sisters despite their recurring insecurities about body image, infertility and relationships; share a passion for music and a dedication to the band they joined in Canada in 1972.
The most striking theme of the autobiography of the Wilson sisters, is their exploration of sexism in their industry. Fame provides a vehicle for Nancy, and Ann in particular, to confirm firsthand the insidious male domination of Rock music both on-stage and off. Fully aware that their performing and recording careers, though purporting to be unconventional, directly reflected society in this respect; the sisters nevertheless earned considerable respect as musicians, lead vocalists, song writers and as co-authors. And on cue, almost in affirmation, Heart will finally be inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in April 2013. Only three bands fronted by women have received the honour - Jefferson Airplane, Fleetwood Mac and the Pretenders. Frequently lauded as an inspiration for more well-known musicians, featured often in Rolling Stone magazine and with 40 years of good record sales, this acknowledgement is certainly overdue.
The alternating voices of Ann and Nancy Wilson keep the perspectives fresh and the impression of autobiography credible. No 1 hits such as Crazy on You, Barracuda and Magic Man are impressive enough but anecdotes involving most of the great folk, pop and rock musicians of our time maintain our interest, most notably Elton John, Lynyrd Skynard, Pearl Jam and Paul McCartney. I know one die-hard Led Zepplin fan on campus will be checking out this one!
Deborah Robins

The Glass Forest by Andrew Peters

cover image

Chicken House, 2012. ISBN 9781906427474.
(Age: 12+) Arborium is a kingdom that exists in the towering canopies of ancient trees, presided over by King Quercus and protected from afar by Corwenna, Queen of the Ravens. Steeped in ritual and tradition it is home to Ark, who despite being only fourteen years old, has been bestowed with special powers which make him the principal defender of Arborium. The kingdom is under threat from Maw, an artificial, technology driven civilization characterized by towering structures of glass and steel. Maw wants Arborium because wood is a scarce and valuable commodity and whoever controls the forests wields enormous financial and political power.
Ark and his friends become aware that Maw has developed highly sophisticated weaponry which it plans to use to destroy the tree dwellers. Ark and his trusty ally, Mucum decide to enter Maw as spies to collect information which will enable them to thwart their enemy. It is a highly dangerous mission and time is against them. The envoy of Maw, Fenestra, is orchestrating the invasion and invites senior officials for a briefing. Mucum is able to trick her daughter, Randall, to plant a spying device but when they are uncovered all three are in immediate danger. Will they make it back to Arborium alive and how can they find a way to match the mighty resources of Maw?
This book is a sequel to Ravenwood and will delight fans and those who enjoy dystopian or alternate world fiction, such as Lord of The Rings. It is exciting, fast paced and sophisticated. Mucum provides tension relief with his comical banter and hints of a special connection between Ark and Randall add another dimension to the story which perhaps the author intends to explore in a further book. Although the book stands alone, it would be worthwhile reading the first one for greater background knowledge.
Tina Cain

Diary of a Wimpy Kid: The Third Wheel by Jeff Kinney

cover image

Puffin, 2012. ISBN 9780143307334.
The life of Greg Heffley becomes complicated when a Valentine's Day dance is organized for the middle school. He doesn't want to be the only one without a partner because that would look really uncool. Greg becomes preoccupied with ways to make himself seem more attractive, but there are more boys than girls in his class and the competition is fierce. Uncle Gary tries to dispense some helpful advice but Mum seems intent on humiliating him in front of classmates. Greg and his best mate Rowley decide to accompany Abigail to the dance as a group date but Greg is secretly confident she will be his partner before the night is out.
This is one of a popular series for upper primary children, written in a warm, easy to read style. Every page has entertaining illustrations that break up the text making reading a less daunting experience for the reluctant reader. Children will be able to relate to the dilemmas Greg finds himself in but best of all, they will laugh out loud at his witty asides and observations.
Tina Cain

Troggle the troll by Nick Falk and Tony Lowe

cover image

Random House Australia, 2012. ISBN 9781742756011.
(Age: 4-6) Picture book. Troggle the troll is unhappy. He lives with his family under the bridge in a hole in the ground, and each night when dinner is about to commence, he finds something to dislike. Postman Pie and Teacher Tart just do not appeal, and so he goes hungry. His siblings and parents however tuck in. When it is his turn to catch dinner, Troggle leaves the house in some despair. Waiting under the bridge he waits for someone to venture along. When Tom is that person, he cannot capture him to take him home for tea, and the two come to a mutually harmonious solution.
This is a very cute story, full of laughs about poor old Troggle's dilemma, but equally funny when the meals are served up at his house. The luminous illustrations carry each page beautifully, reflecting what is happening in the easy to read text. And when Troggle and Tom find a happy common ground with vegetables, then the tables are turned for the meals to be served at Troggle's house.
For classes looking at meals and vegetables in particular, this will be an easy lead in to the discussion.
Fran Knight

Ketchup clouds by A. Pitcher

cover image

Orion Publishing Group, 2012. 296p. ISBN 9781780620305.
(Age: 14+) Highly Recommended. Realistic. In My Sister Lives on the Mantelpiece, Annabel Pitcher described the breakdown of a family after a child's death. This subject matter is sustained in her last book, Ketchup Clouds. However, the narrator's role in the tragedy is pivotal even if less circumstantial than in McEwan's Atonement. In both, the confusion of young love evokes a palpable absolution in readers despite calamitous consequences.
Retold from Zoe's perspective, we can understand how she unintentionally came to be playing two brothers at once by seeing Aaron behind Max's back. We see how she struggled with both her kindness and her true feelings, to change the spiralling tragedy. Why didn't she simply invent a gross habit and get herself conveniently dumped? But Zoe's guilt, exacerbated by the boys' grieving mother, leads her to enter into a correspondence with a murderer on Death Row in Texas, who was convicted of a crime of passion. The letter format works well for a slow reveal confession and the exercise of unburdening, not to a psychologist or priest but to a kindred spirit, is believable. Whether she actually sent the letters to Stuart Harris or not is unclear but she certainly never received a response or never wanted one given her fictitious return address.
The double tragedy is that our decisions sometimes mean that there is no going back, condemning the penitent to a half-life of compromise and suppressed memories. Pitcher has written another engaging cautionary tale - this time in the epistolary tradition. Young adults will not easily forget it.
Deborah Robins

Seven Little Australians by Ethel Turner

cover image

Penguin group 2012. First published by Ward Lock, 1894. ISBN 9780670076871.
It was my first time reading this Australian classic and I soon found myself engrossed in the story of these unruly children as they got up to all kinds of mischief. At first the numerous children were confusing but as each personality became more defined the characters took on a life of their own as they shared a story from the past.
This distinctly Australian story tells us about the mischief of the seven Woolcot children at their home of Misrule. After leaving The General at the barracks with their father, Judy Woolcot, the ringleader and instigator of the seven's mischievous enterprises is sent away to boarding school. While she is gone her brothers and sisters become somewhat tamer and less mischievous however when Judy returns from boarding school she is in ill health and makes her siblings promise to keep her return a secret from their father and inexperienced step-mother. However it isn't long before The Captain discovers Judy in a disused loft in a state of utter vulnerability, the doctor is called and a holiday is suggested. However this is a holiday which is to have disastrous results for the Woolcot family.
Throughout the novel a number of issues are observed including the implications of irresponsibility, vanity and selfishness, and while the author states that Australian children are never good she wrote in the hope that they might become aware of the consequences which accompany them. I would recommend this book for children and families as it is full of life lessons and cautions as well as being one of those uniquely Australian novels.
Kayla Gaskell (age 16)

Brave squish rabbit by Katherine Battersby

cover image

Brave squish rabbit by Katherine Battersby
UQP, 2012. ISBN 9780702249433.
(Age: 3-5) Picture book. Bravery. With an enticingly tactile soft cover and piercing blue background to the little picture of brave rabbit and his soft toy, children will love to pick up this book and have it read to them. Inside they read of the rabbit, called Squish and the list of things he is frightened of: storms and lightning, chickens, and especially the dark. Each page shows Squish as a small drawing in the bottom corner of the page, cowering with fear. But as he develops more strength to overcome his fears, his image increases in size. Looking for his friend Twitch, he is bereft when she has gone, so he searches in the dark for her, gradually gaining more confidence.
While this book reprises the cute character of Squish, it may not win the recognition received by the first book, Squish rabbit, which won an award from CBCA in 2012. The story will capture the attention of younger readers, and help them think about some of their fears, while providing a book both at home and in the classroom for fears to be discussed. The illustrations are a mixture of found objects, collage, line drawing and digital collage thus further exciting interest in the way the book is presented.
Fran Knight

Unforgotten by Tohby Riddle

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012. ISBN 9781742379722.
(Ages: 10+) Picture book. Memories. Caring for others. With the plethora of novels written with angels as the main characters, it is not surprising to see a picture book for older readers reprising that theme. Many novels contain fallen angels, and in this one, fallen is physical not a state of mind. Divided into three sections, the bare bones of this picture book can be outlined as follows: the first reveals what angels do for humanity, the second shows an angel which has been overwhelmed by the work it must do, while the third exposes a group of children and animals reviving the angel enough for it to return home. All done in spare prose, the illustrations entreat and seduce the reader to dwell, to admire, and to muse.
The angels oversee the human population in Europe, soaring overhead, watching, being there, comforting, warming and mending. Their coverage is enormous: there are wars to contend with, poverty, homelessness, hunger, loneliness. But the angels keep on, until one day, one angel can no longer go on. It falls to the ground, exhausted. And there it stays, unnoticed and unloved, forgotten and alone. It is found by workers who surround it with safety markers and then carry it away to make a plinth for it to stand on.
With the plinth and the statue installed in a public place, it lingers for years, unloved and dying, until a group of children and animals take notice of it. They take it back to their dwelling, and there nurse it back to health until, noticed and loved, revived, it travels back to where it came from. The kindness of strangers has overcome its forgotten state.
With acres of black space, the illustrations, made up of collage and filled in pictorial work, draw the eye in to notice the detail. And what detail! Photos from the turn of the century European cities are juxtaposed with photos of New York, warehouses and lifts; pictures of people in Victorian dress stand alongside those in more modern clothing, or those of the 1930's; cars from the early part of the twentieth century stream along the roads, bridges and buildings highlighting the ever passing traffic, both of people and cars, ignoring the angel. People have statue heads, bodies are part statue and human, emphasising their indifference, watching as a statue might, with unseeing eyes. Metaphor abounds in this richly layered book, and will be looked at with awe by someone intrigued with the symbolism of the illustrations. Not for everyone, this sumptuously produced book will find a willing home amongst more discerning middle school readers.
Fran Knight

Exposure by Mal Peet

cover image

Walker, 2012. Pbk. ISBN 9781406340914.
For decades, writers and teachers alike have tried to find accessible ways of teaching Shakespeare to high school students. Over the years, the Bard's work has been translated into graphic novels, prose and short story form, and of course deconstructed with York's Notes.
Here we find an approach which manages to explore the themes and ideas within Shakespeare's plays, but retain a modernistic approach. Mal Peet's Exposure takes one of Shakespeare's lesser known plays, Othello, to a modern setting, and in doing so creates a fathomable and more accessible guide to the play.
Peet is clever in utilizing theatrical writing and elements of play format to establish characters and situations for the reader. This approach may also ease students into the form of playwriting.
While this traditional style can be found in the novel (for another example, each part of the book is labelled as ACT 1, 2, 3... ), the story-telling oozes with a gritty, urban mood and a lingo to match. The prose is hard-hitting, powerful and frequently moving, delving into mature territory which many YA authors leave untouched.
The dialogue is dramatic and the social commentary scathing - Exposure is a book crackling with intensity, wit and drama, which finds a voice speaking the truth of Shakespeare's work and the truth of our own times.
Henry Vaughan (Student)

Burning Blue by Paul Griffin

cover image

Text Publishing, 2012. ISBN 9781922079145.
What's not to like about Nicole Castro? She's smart, popular and dates the best looking guy at school. She rides horses in her spare time and drives a flash car because her daddy is rich. Did I also mention she is drop dead gorgeous? Sometimes you just want to hate that kind of girl and somebody does! One day at school in a quiet corridor, someone throws acid at Nicole's face, scarring that perfect face forever.
Nicole is forced to take a break from school while she undergoes treatment but she returns regularly to meet the school counselor. In the waiting room she befriends fellow student and computer geek, Jay Nazarro. He has problems enough of his own. It's hard to recover from the humiliation of suffering an epilectic seizure complete with soiled pants in front of the whole school assembly, particularly when it's uploaded on YouTube. His mother has died and when his dad is not at work he escapes from grief with heavy drinking. However Jay decides to find out who is responsible for the attack on Nicole which sets him on a dangerous path where suspicion falls in the most unlikeliest of places.
This book is a satisfying thriller that haunts the reader to the very end. Griffin ensures that our loyalties are constantly shifting as the characters are manipulated to reveal more of their true selves. As a computer hacker, solitary and wary, Jay is reminiscent of Lisbeth Salander in The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo, with his ability to uncover relevant data to move the investigation forward. This book will appeal to anyone fascinated by understanding the motivations of those that commit crime.
Tina Cain