Reviews

The third door by Emily Rodda

cover image

Omnibus, 2012. ISBN 9781862919143.
Highly recommended for ages 10+. This third and final adventure in the trilogy, The three doors, begins with Rye, Sonia, Dirk and Sholto having destroyed the skimmers at the Harbour. Believed to be spies, the four have rescued some prisoners from the Nanny's Pride Farm, and are now heading back to Weld. With the gifts of the Fellan, the magic creatures who live in the forest, Rye's magic bag continues to help the group as they progress in their quest to remove the threats to their home. Despite facing many problems on their way, they fight to overcome amnesia and upsets from other quarters and the team continues its journey to put things to rights and end the reign of terror in Weld.
Although this title could be read as a stand-alone, I would certainly encourage readers to begin the series with The golden door and read sequentially, to enable them to fully appreciate the changes and development of each of the characters and their roles within the story. As a fantasy quest, the themes of friendship, trust, loyalty, personal development, magic, science and history are all explored. The tale of the brothers is somewhat echoed in the words of the book with which Rye has been entrusted. Only at the end of their journey are secrets revealed and things returned to rights.
Rodda continues to write prolifically in the fantasy genre and her following likewise grows with the release of each new book. These are great adventures which entertain and engage readers of varied ages.
Jo Schenkel

Little elephants by Graeme Base

cover image

Puffin, 2012, ISBN 9780670076475.
(Age: 4-7) Recommended. Kindness. Farm life. Life is tough on the wheat farm. Jim's mother tells him that he can't keep a pet mouse because it might encourage other mice to come and the farm is always being threatened by plagues, not just of mice but of weevils and locusts. Jim understands and let Pipsqueak go far from the farmhouse. When Jim sees a stranger picking some wheat, he tells him he is welcome to have it. Later when he finds a strange looking trumpet on the gate post, and blows it, he hears a trumpeting sound and lo and behold under his bed that night is a herd of little elephants.
It is rare to see a traditional fairy tale telling in an Australian setting. Usually the good fairy (or in this case the good swagman), is set solidly in a European world and it is one that I was familiar with. Initially, (and as a farmer's daughter), I found it difficult to visualise the happy ending but on reflection I began to appreciate the risk that Base has taken putting a fairy tale ending in a bleak Australian setting. With his wonderful illustrations, Base brings to life what it is like to live on a farm. The worry that the farmer, Jim's mother, carries constantly with her is illustrated through her worried face and bent head and readers will be able to emphasise with the hardships that farmers face with plagues of insects and mice. Jim is depicted as an optimistic child who is kind to strangers and wants to really help his mother.
The world that Jim discovers under his bed is a rich, imaginative one. The little elephants are lots of fun, riding in Jim's truck and cars and having a wild time out in the yard. The exuberance of the fight between the locusts and the small elephants is exhilarating. The dark illustrations beg to be viewed again and again to see the detail of the elephants faces, the expressions on the faces of the people and tiny details like a soldier's picture on the mantelpiece that gives a clue to who Jim's father is.
Farmer's children will wish that an act of kindness could save a wheat crop! All children will have a better understanding of life on a farm and will rejoice in the flights of imagination that Base so beautifully brings to life.
Pat Pledger

Greek myths: stories of sun, stone and sea by Sally Pomme Clayton

cover image

Ill. by Jane Ray. Frances Lincoln Children's Books, 2012. ISBN 978 1 84780 227 9.
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Greek myths. Another beautiful retelling of ten Greek myths enhanced with luminous illustrations, will be eagerly picked up by all who see the book, wanting to read something new, read aloud some favourite stories or reacquaint themselves with stories known from their childhood. Whatever the reason this book will have broad appeal.
The ten stories include the Creation story, the story of Pandora, Athena and Poseidon, Perseus and Medusa, Pan and Midas, Pegasus, Atalanta, Orpheus and Eurydice, Apollo and Midas, Arachne and Athena. Each is given a fresh retelling, and several have some difference in the detail which makes them more intriguing. Pandora for example, does not have a box, but a pottery jar, given her by the gods with the order that it not be opened.
Most of the stories are most familiar, and even though people may think they know nothing of Greek myths, some recollection will occur when reading these, be it a whole story, a snippet, or a name. Everyone has heard of Medusa and her crown of snakes, but not all will know of Perseus' method of destroying her or of what he did with the head afterwards. The vibrant illustrations reflect the style often used with books of myths and fairy tales, employing a flat almost embroidered look to the pictures, often edged with borders and not allowing perspective to get in the way of a good picture. Children will love seeking out what is mentioned in the text, and scour the map and glossary, as I did for further information. A further list of books will not escape people's attention as they seek more myths to read.
This wonderful retelling held me intrigued for the whole book, and will no doubt be one that will grace children's shelves, as well as that of the local and school libraries.
Fran Knight

Feed by M. T. Anderson

cover image

Walker, 2012 (2002). ISBN 9781406345209.
(Ages: 12+) Recommended. Dystopian fiction. Future. About to be released as a film, this republication of the award winning novel by American author, M. T. Anderson, Feed will engage a new generation of readers as they like me are amazed at the predictions shown in a dystopian future written 10 years ago. Uncannily many of these are now part and parcel of the Y Generation's lives. Feed, is a word describing the constant marketing material pumped into their brains through an implant inserted at birth. Some 'unlucky' ones have this done later in life, and so Violet, who was home schooled and has odd parents, is outside the usual thirst to be connected 24 hours a day. It is she who when her implant begins to fail, see things differently from the friendship group she has just formed and as an outsider, pulls Titus along with her.
On the moon for an experience, the group is invaded by a virus which makes their feeds malfunction. It is fascinating to see them all cope without the feed, just as Generation Y today cannot cope without their mobile phones and internet access. Anderson was certainly right on target with his prophecies about the future, and his darkly ironic story is most engaging. For an older spectator like me, the images created along with the ideas of a whole society simply being fed information, music, advertisements 24 hours a day was alarming, but to many not so. Being 'tuned in' or wired, is given a whole new level of meaning in this stunning book.
Not only advertisements and information, but a transference of texts rather like emails is sent and received between the teenagers, allowing them to chat to each other without a third person knowing. It is incredibly unnerving, foretelling an appalling future. An informative web site gives further facts about the book and background information as well as a discussion of its impact. The book won two major awards in the US in 2003.
Fran Knight

The finger-eater by Dick King-Smith

cover image

Ill. by Arthur Robins. Walker Books, 2012. ISBN 978 1 4063 4186 7.
(Age: 7+) Recommended. Humour. 60 pages, large print, pages broken up by funny drawings, a story split into easy to read chapters, make this a great read for those beginning chapter books, as well as those who want a quick and funny read. There seems too few of these, so with Dick King-Smith as the author, people will eagerly pick it up to read. First published in 1992, it is a welcome return of this book, aimed at the early chapter book readers.
The troll, Ulf, is a finger eater. He traps unwary people along the road with his bright and friendly approach, putting out his hand to shake. This is most unusual for trolls, and so people are happy to oblige, but then Ulf eats one of their fingers. Consequently, many of the people in the village are missing their index finger of their right hand, or in some case, the little finger. But Gudrun, living with her family in their tent as they herd reindeer, will not be so easy to trick. She has been warned by her parents with their seven fingers, and so will not shake hands with the troll. When he asks for some of the milk she is carrying to get her to have a hand free for him to eat, she squirts it into his mouth, rather than release one hand. When the reindeer shed their antlers, she has an idea, and when the troll bites her finger, he is in for a nasty surprise.
This is a lovely story of one girl thinking about how to trick the troll, but it is the background of the reindeer herders that sticks in my mind. The illustrations will amuse and delight readers as they read through this highly enticing story of one troll and his tricks upon the unwary only to be outwitted himself.
Fran Knight

Kizzy Ann Stamps by Jeri Watts

cover image

Candlewick, 2012. ISBN 978 07636 5895 3.
(Age: 9+) Warmly recommended. Integration (USA History). Racism. Dogs. It is Kizzy's first time in a white school after years in a black school where all students sat together under the watchful eye of one teacher, a woman beloved by her community. But it is 1963 and integration is now law and Kizzy, worried about what may happen, writes to her new teacher to introduce herself. Surprisingly her new teacher writes back and through Kizzy's letters to her we see her life and times laid out for us. For readers in 2013, Kizzy's is an astonishing life, one richly detailed, but one confined by segregation and racism. The hopes she and her teachers express for the future are like beacons of light, ones readers think on as they read this story. This is an astounding tale, engaging, often amusing and a sobering story of one young girl, one which reveals life as it was and impels us to question life as it was then for millions of people.
But these are not Kizzy's concerns, she is more worried that the awful scar running across her face will cause embarrassment and teasing, she is worried that her outspoken nature will upset her new teacher, she is concerned that the boy who bullied her before will do so again - grass roots concerns set against a momentous time in the history of the USA and its call for equality.
This story is worth searching for. I had initially put it aside but reading it was a pleasure. The letter format makes it most accessible, and readers will become embroiled in the life of Kizzy, marvelling at her tenacity and loving her dog, as we read of the inseparable pair. The dog becomes the impetus for some sort of communication between the groups in her town and the reader is left with the hope that this will have a wider reach.
Fran Knight

So much to tell you by John Marsden

cover image

Lothian, 2012. ISBN 9780734413291.
At Warrington boarding school, girls in the English class taught by Mr. Lindell are invited to record their thoughts and feelings in a journal. For Marina, this becomes a means to express her fear, pain and memories and the narrative of the tale is developed through these diary entries.
It is soon revealed that Marina does not speak and that she has shut down from the world following a traumatic event, the details of which are explained only gradually. The reader pieces together clues to finally understand the specifics of Marina's lasting physical and emotional injuries, however during the early stages of the novel, it is easy and reasonable to accept that this teen simply does not speak.
The characters of the girls who cohabit Marina's dormitory are recognisable from life and she gains the reader's sympathy as she copes with their foolish fun, emotional outbursts and juvenile behaviour. Tentative gestures of friendship are offered however and much of the novel is occupied with perceptive portrayal of the breathtaking fear associated with trusting others and taking the plunge in reaching out to them.
This 25 year anniversary edition includes the author's recollections of the writing process in which he assumed this young girl's character. Marsden's portrayal of this injured soul, struggling to exist In a world where she is silent and sometimes even invisible is honest and realistic, without wallowing in excessive emotion. I like the relative simplicity of this novel because there is an interesting story being told using a range of plausible characters drawn with appropriate depth, yet peripheral details, events and unnecessary description have been pared away.
This story features many instances of kindness extended by individuals who expect nothing in return. This lends a sense of hope and faith in the decency of everyday people which is lacking in some contemporary teenage literature which is bleak and cynical.
Setting, style and language will not betray to modern readers that this was written twenty five years ago and I believe that it will be equally enjoyable and moving today as it was then.
Rob Welsh

Princess Betony and the Unicorn by Pamela Freeman

cover image

Walker, 2012. ISBN: 9781921720239.
When Princess Betony's mother disappears into the Dark Forest, a place humans are forbidden to enter, she cannot obey the rules and attempts to follow her mother, the dryad, to ensure that she returns to her family. To add to the challenge, the Princess must first catch a unicorn. Will she be successful in her quest?
Pamela Freeman has proven herself to be a competent and engaging author, able to attract the attention of her younger readers and the format of this delightful gift book, styled after Beatrix Potter's original titles, is bound to delight. With the addition of some simple illustrations by Tamsin Ainslie, this holds much appeal and intrigues the reader with the promise of further stories to follow.
Having searched for the author online, I was quite taken by her website on which she includes some of the beautiful illustrations from Princess Betony, a book trailer and games and puzzles which are bound to appeal to young girls as well. This clever aspect to the marketing of books is bound to lead a few more readers to investigate Freeman's books.
Jo Schenkel

Cold Days: The Dresden Files by Jim Butcher

cover image

Orbit, 2012. ISBN 9780356500898.
Cold Days is another installment in the popular contemporary fantasy series which comprise the Dresden Files. Set in Chicago, Harry Dresden, the main character and narrator, pits his wits and talents as a wizard and private eye against dark forces that conspire to dominate the world. It's a complex society where fairies, ghouls, vampires and other spirits co exist alongside humans but interests often compete.
In this book, Harry has been forced into the service of Mab, Queen of Air and Darkness and she sets him an almost impossible mission: kill an immortal. Powerful forces are already working against him, threatened by his new role as Winter Knight. Harry has to find out why Mab seeks to destroy this target while constantly dodging plots against his own life. His investigations reveal the existence of a catastrophic threat and Harry must race against time and his own dark impulses to avert tragedy. He is joined by an assortment of friends and unlikely allies in this rollercoaster ride against evil.
Harry Dresden has an established legion of fans and this book will obviously delight them. The action is relentless and the stakes are always high. Harry is portrayed as an Indiana Jones type character in a contemporary Lord of the Rings setting. The book stands alone but familiarity with the strange world he inhabits is enriched by an awareness of the preceding books
Tina Cain

Kimono Code by Susannah McFarlane

cover image

EJ12 Girl Hero. Scholastic Australia, 2012. ISBN: 9781921931154
Emma Jacks, also known as Special Agent EJ12, battles with a fellow SHINE agent, the mean girl, Nema, on a regular basis but especially when they are taking part in karate classes. EJ fails to understand why Nema is so cruel and yet never seems to be caught out by the adults. When she receives her orders for her next mission, EJ needs to focus on the job at hand and not her friends and classmates. She soon finds herself in Japan, entrusted with the task of saving the cherry blossoms from being destroyed by the members of the evil agency, SHADOW.
With this being the 14th title in the series, it would appear that young girls have embraced the EJ12 books as being accessible and entertaining reads. These can perhaps be seen as the girls' alternative to the Zac Power books which have won over many young boys. Kimono Code contains some positive messages about the environment and addresses the topic of bullying with its causes and consequences in a thoughtful manner. Acceptance of oneself and others, despite their insecurities is another theme which could be teased out. This is another series which is rarely on the shelves in school libraries so has obviously struck a chord with the younger independent readers.
Jo Schenkel

The convent by Maureen McCarthy

cover image

Allen and Unwin, Sydney, 2012. ISBN 9781742375045.
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended. This is a delightfully engaging novel about four women tied together by family and setting: the Abbotsford Convent, Melbourne. The novel opens in contemporary times with Peach, a 19 year old university student seeking a summer job at one of the convent's cafes. She flags at the outset that this story will be about the past, about the impact of the lives of three other women on her own... but she doesn't yet know the missing link - the convent itself.
And so the reader moves back and forth between Peach and the stories of Sadie (whose child was taken from her in 1915), her daughter Ellen (brought up in the convent in the 1920s) and Cecilia (a young nun at the same convent in the sixties). It is not only the setting that ties these women together, it is also religion and babies. And their stories have a modern echo in Peach's own life, for her dear, damaged friend Det, is pregnant - will she keep the baby or give it up for adoption? And how will her plans impact on Peach, herself an adopted child? As Det is an artist with a studio in the convent, the ties of place and birth are even stronger.
This novel is written with warmth and intelligence. The characters are very real, their personal struggles are sympathetically evoked and so their lives are immediately engaging. With only one first person narrator (Peach) the reader is able to learn more about her back story than Peach herself, so our interest in the mystery of this family saga is constantly being tweaked. On one level, this story is about a young girl coming to terms with her history, her identity and her sense of family; it is about the ties of friendship and romance. But layered over this is the broader and richer story of changing times, of opportunities for women, of the impact of motherhood and religious conviction and love. It is a story with warmth and heart and style; a winning combination from well-known author, Maureen McCarthy.
Deborah Marshall

Again by Emily Gravett

cover image

Again by Emily Gravett
Macmillan Children's Books, 2012. ISBN 9780330544030.
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Picture book. Reading. It's not often you see a book that successfully appeals to both children and adults alike, but this one does. A treat for all readers, especially those long suffering parents and carers who read and reread a book to their impatient charges, again and again. In this delightfully illustrated book, baby dragon just adores his nightly read with his mother. The story in his favorite book concerns a red dragon called Cedric, just like him. The Cedric in the book never goes to bed, but goes out at night tormenting trolls and grabbing princesses to make into pies. An increasingly frustrated baby dragon wants the story read to him again, and as he blusters about prodding his mother to read the tale over, he becomes redder and redder, until finally his anger gets a little too much. And the story being read to him changes as well, as the Cedric in the story is changed by Mum to be one that does go to sleep, a hint to her charge that rather falls on deaf ears.
Beautiful touches appear on every page: the look on the baby dragon's face, the snuggle blanket, the motifs on the blanket, the increasingly tired mother as her image becomes more and more prone, the increased demands of the baby; all are instantly recognisable by the adult reading this book to the children, and parallel what happens in their homes. The climax of the story will bring hoots of laughter from the very willing audience, and the last few pages will intrigue and delight all who read this tale.
Oh, and the endpapers are a treat as well - it's always an extra surprise to see endpapers so well incorporated into the story rather than be left blank.
Fran Knight

Hard nuts of history by Tracey Turner

cover image

Ill. by Jane Lennan. A and C Black, 2012. ISBN 9781408171882.
(Age: 9-12) Non fiction, Biography. Humour. Subtitled Who's who in hard nut history, this attractively presented book outlines potted histories of many famous and not so famous gutsy people, starting with Blackbeard, and then trawling through the lives of such people as Nelson, Boudica, Wu Zetian, Charlemagne, Attila the Hun, Abraham Lincoln, and Scott of the Antarctic, along with a smattering of women, Gracie O'Malley, Cleopatra and Mary Kingsley. A few nods to non British people are included, as are a few indigenous people, like Sitting Bull.
Each is given an outline of their life and times, with a ranking about their toughness. Often a double page offers the person's biography with more information about his times. For example, Nelson's double page is followed by information about the British Navy, while the pages about Ulysses S. Grant are followed by two pages about the American Civil War.
The book relates to a website which can be accessed via the Bloomsbury site (see page 7) which links to cards for downloading to make a game of the book and its contents. At the end of the book can be found a questionnaire asking how hard a nut you are, and a timeline of the hard nuts in the book, with an excellent glossary and comprehensive index. All designed to get kids involved in learning about history through the people who have some notoriety, the book makes history and its fact finding element fun and involving, and uses the internet to further engage the modern reader.
Fran Knight

Stories for 7 year olds ed. by Linsay Knight

cover image

Ill. by Tom Jellett. Random House, 2012. ISBN 9781742756622.
Stories for 8 year olds ed. by Linsay Knight. ISBN 9781742756808.
(Age: 7+) Recommended. Short stories. With authors like Jacqueline Harvey, Phil Cummings, Deborah Abelah and Vashti Farrer contributing stories to this series (and there are two more, one for 5 and one for 6 year olds), Random House can't go wrong. Short stories are always sought after: a teacher wanting a five minute filler before the bell, or wanting to model a story writing exercise in the classroom, or parents wanting a short story to read before bed, or a child wanting to read something within their operating range, these books contain a wide range of stories designed to please.
For 7 year olds, the range includes a very funny story by Phil Cummings inspired by the pool in his home town where one of his classmates decided it would be a good idea to take a surfboard. Another by J. B. Thomas tells us why the crow's feathers are black, another by Michael Pryor shows us a group of disappearing goats, while another by Morris Gleitzman cleverly parallels a science experiment to raise lots of laughs amongst the readership. Each is distinctly different and funny, and the book includes information about each of the authors at the end, as well as a page about when the story was first published, revealing that some have been published before and some are new. We are lucky that some of these hidden gems have been given a second outing.
For 8 year olds, the range of authors include Paul Jennings, Andy Griffiths and R. A. Spratt, with stories as strange and different as they could possibly be. Both of these books will be a hit in the school library.
Fran Knight

We love school illustrated by Lucie Billingsley

cover image

Hachette (Lothian) 2012. ISBN 9780734411570.
(Age: 4-6) Recommended. Picture book. School. Through a gaggle of dogs, the story is told of the first day at school. The routines are followed throughout the story, taking all young readers along with it. For the very young the experience of school and its routines is neatly outlined, allowing the child to assimilate all that happens in this place. The dogs allow a distance and give a comforting introduction to school procedures.
In rhyming couplets, the story develops as each animal prepares for school, unsure of what to expect. Once at school, they play with their own toys, paint some pictures, and then go out for a break, relieving themselves together except for one dog. They go for a walk, noticing all around them then take time out for lunch. Playtime ends with water play, then the dogs all settle down to sleep until they are picked up to go home with their art efforts for the day.
Each dog is given a different personality through the endearing illustrations. They are shown doing a range of activities which introduces the reader to the sorts of things to expect at school.
As a read aloud, or simply to look at by themselves, or as a classroom share book, this book has possibilities in lessening the anxieties of younger children hearing about school or about to start school.
Fran Knight