Reviews

These Broken Stars by Amie Kaufman and Meagan Spooner

cover image

The Starbound Trilogy, bk 1. Allen & Unwin, 2013. ISBN: 9781743318522.
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended. Lost in space. The nightmare of a society ever curious about space travel.
Stranded on what appears to be an abandoned planet after the Incarus, luxury space-liner falls out of hyperspace mid-journey, Tarver Merendsen must once again prove his worth as a soldier in order to survive and keep Lilac LaRoux, daughter of the leader of one of most influential corporations of the age, safe from harm. The planet appears to be in the final stage of terraforming but something is different, the usual flora and fauna introduced during terraforming are supplemented by unknown, and possibly dangerous plants and creatures. Tarver Merendsen has his work cut out for him as he attempts to lead Miss LaRoux across jungle and mountains to the site of the Icarus's crash where there are surely rescue teams scouring the wreckage for survivors. Despite her airs, Tarver soon learns that Miss LaRoux is more than just another dainty upper-class girl as she uses her ingenuity to keep both herself and Tarver alive. Their fate rests on a desperate hope of rescue before the madness of the planet can set in.
Written for a mature audience These Broken Stars is a romantic science fiction with remarkably vibrant descriptions and sophisticated language use. I would highly recommend this to young people over the age of sixteen with even a remote interest in either genre. Focusing on the main idea of trust in oneself and others, it also conveys a message of doing what is right despite the consequences.
Kayla Gaskell (age eighteen)

World after by Susan Ee

cover image

Hodder and Stoughton, 2013. ISBN 9781444778533.
(Age: 15+) Fantasy. Angels. Dystopian fiction. In this sequel to the bestselling fantasy thriller, Angelfall, Penryn is back with her mother and sister Paige with other survivors of the angel apocalypse. Paige is attacked by a group who believe that she is a monster, and she disappears after a massacre. Penryn follows trying to find her and her search leads her to the angels' hotel where she discovers just what they plan for the world. Meanwhile the angel Raffe, who believes Penryn is dead, continues in his search for his wings and his place as a leader of the angels.
The first in the series, Angelfall, was self-published by the author and was a bestselling e-book. The second has less romance (Raffe and Penryn are separated for a large part of the book) but there is plenty of action, lots of bloodshed, sibling angst and a major fight against angels, all of which combined to make this an escapist read. The characters are rather scary, Penryn's mother is obsessive and schizophrenic, Paige has razor-like teeth and the angel Uriel is evil, and it appears as if the local inhabitants are on the verge of cannibalism. Penryn puts her family before everything else and this leads her into many dark adventures in her search for her sister and her attempts to survive in terrible circumstances.
This books picks up immediately where Angelfall ended, so it doesn't read as a stand-alone and should be read in sequence. Action packed and gritty, it will appeal to fans of the angel genre who will look forward to a third book in the series.
Pat Pledger

Girl of nightmares by Kendare Blake

cover image

Anna, Bk 2. Orchard, 2013. ISBN 9781408326121.
(Age: 14+) Ghosts. Death. Horror. Supernatural. The second book following Anna dressed in blood, finds Cas Lowood grieving the disappearance of Anna into hell. He is unable to move on, even though his friends tell him that it is no use mourning a ghost girl who has gone. He keeps seeing her in his dreams and when he is awake. Anna seems to be tortured every time he sees her and he knows she doesn't deserve that. He is determined to find a way into Hell and save her.
Darker and more sinister than Anna dressed in blood, there are many exciting moments as Cas struggles to find out what is happening to Anna. Blake's descriptions of Hell are quite terrifying, although they are lightened by her ghoulish sense of humour which fans of the first book will appreciate.
This was a rivetting read which will appeal to readers who like the macabre and enjoy ghost stories leavened by a dark sense of humour.
Pat Pledger

Boys are dogs by Leslie Margolis

cover image

Bloomsbury Books, 2009. ISBN 9781599903811.
Well recommended for early adolescents. A clever, humorous approach to the troubles of growing up! Annabelle's mother has taken her to live with her boyfriend Ted whom Annabelle calls 'Dweeble' (to herself) and to start at a new school in year six in America. To help her adjust Annabelle is given a puppy and a dog training book which she follows studiously. Jason lives across the road and teases her with names like 'Spaz' and 'Spazabelle'. Initially, Annabelle recoils and retreats into herself but then she takes the puppy training advice in dealing with boys! She changes the word dog to boys and comes up with examples such as 'Understanding Boy Speak'.
Written with young girls in mind, with their issues of friendship, jealousy and learning to deal with boys, this book has many practical approaches and useful hints and suggestions along with a good dose of self-evaluation.
Sue Nosworthy

On my way to bed by Sarah Maizes

cover image

Ill. by Michael Paraskevas. Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9780802723666.
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Picture book, Bed time. A companion volume to On my way to the bath (2013) this very funny tale has Livi being exhorted to go to bed by her long suffering mother. The voice outside the pages of the book gives the instructions, Bedtime!, then the cajoling 'Come on Livi, time for bed', to the instructive, 'Don't forget to brush your teeth', then the reminder about school tomorrow and so on, until Mum comes in to find another layer of excuses, a story to read, a glass of water, the door left open.
Children will laugh out loud recognising the age old excuses given not to go to bed just yet, and Mum's recurring instructions about what to do.
The illustrations again give another story, as Livi's imagination goes into overdrive as she plays with things in her room, rather than go to bed. The expressions on the toy's faces are priceless, and the little snippets of detail make this a fascinating book to peruse the illustrations over again. The detail of the bed lamp, the recurring frog, the line up of toys on her bed and so on, all add a delicious layer of interest to the reader.
There are a several books about going to bed, and the routine of sleeping. This book underlines the things which must be done before going to bed, the interaction of mother and daughter, the repetition of things done before retiring that all give a clear image of routine and its importance in a child's life.
Fran Knight

Arclight by Josin L. Mcquein

cover image

Electric Monkey, 2013. ISBN: 978140526394.
(Age: Teens) Science fiction. Humans have a natural fear of the dark and the unknown, they like to live in the light, finding it safe and comforting.
In a warped future the human race has been reduced from billions to hundreds living in the safety of a compound known as the Arclight. They fear the dark and sleep in the light, controlled by colours and their every move tracked by tracer bracelets worn for their own safety a small number survive. An alien race known as the Fade have brought darkness to the world depicted having a human form and gleaming eyes these are the creatures which hide in the depths of every child's nightmare stealing the bodies of those foolish enough to fall into the Grey. As the Dark and Grey expand, slowly and inevitably encroaching on the Light, the people begin to hope. A girl rescued from the Dark lives among them, her memory lost but she lives, breathes and functions just as a human should. The girl, Marina, feels lost and alone in the compound of her own people, told that she remembers little as she was taken young. When the Fade begin an assault on the Arclight, Marina's past begins to reveal itself to her, bringing with it unimaginable chaos.
This is a sci-fi novel with a quaint mix of teenage drama and conspiracy, written in first person and set in the microcosm of the Arclight the novel portrays how lies feed lies until they finally tangle together to reveal the truth. I would recommend this novel for young adult readers with an interest in science fiction.
Kayla Gaskell (age eighteen)

The Road to Gundagai by Jackie French

cover image

HarperCollins Australia, 2014. ISBN 9780732297220.
It's 5.00am and I've just spent the last hour finishing reading The Road to Gundagai, the third in Jackie French's Matilda saga. Circumstances have meant that I haven't had to opportunity to read it one sitting as I did the previous two, A Waltz for Matilda and The Girl from Snowy River but with my new focus of reading in the gaps - all those spare minutes while you wait in hospitals or doctors' appointments or nursing elderly relatives through the night - meant that I'd made a little progress and so this morning I set the alarm for birdsong determined to devote time to finish it because, as with the others, I was so swept up in the characters' lives, I needed to know what happened.
Those familiar with Australian Children's Laureate Jackie's historical novels know of her magical ability to weave real times, places and events into enthralling fiction that takes the reader into those times and allowing them an insight into the life that is not possible through drier, factual texts, and The Road to Gundagai is no exception. In this, we follow newly-orphaned and suspiciously-crippled Bluebell Laurence in her journey as a make-do circus performer as she becomes a member of the Magnifico Family Circus, which, like many others of its kind, travels the roads during the Depression, bringing a little light and fun into lives of families living on the edge of poverty as hard times take their toll. The Boldini Brothers, Madame Zlotsky, the ringmaster and the hunchback, the clown, the bearded lady, the 'only mermaid in captivity' and the Queen of Sheba, a trickster elephant are all rich characters who bring the circus to life and will make you wonder about what really is happening at the next circus you visit.
But it's much more than a story about the behind-the-scenes illusions of a circus and a physical journey that inevitably leads to Miss Matilda and Drinkwater. Each character has a critical part to play, not only in the telling of this story but in the telling of the story of life in those times, particularly for women and girls, so while the along-the-lines reader will be greatly entertained by a grand tale, the between-and-beyond-the-lines reader will get so much more and want to know more. And Jackie provides a taste of that in her notes at the end, particularly about equal pay and jobs for women. Your female students may not realise just what their grandmother's generation were faced with and what we/they did to change things so their lives are what they are. As a public servant in the times, I well remember how many friends lost their jobs just because they chose to marry.
Those who know my reviews know they come from the heart, and those who know me know a little of my life lately and so they will also know that to find a book that can allow me to escape into another world, even for a little while, has to be one that is totally absorbing with a powerful plot that is crafted by a master writer. The Road to Gundagai, indeed the entire Matilda saga is just that and I can't wait for the next two, even if it means the saga will be over. This is a series that needs to be right by the circulation desk to greet your students as they return to a new year's reading journey and I thank Jackie for sharing it with us.
Barbara Braxton

Dr Maniac will see you now by R.L. Stine

cover image

Goosebumps Most Wanted Series. Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9780545418027.
So ghoulish, horrible and superficial that it's hard to take the story seriously. Readers of any of the Goosebumps series would be familiar with the style: fast moving, and frightening situations. But then the outlandish becomes humorous! Young boys' sense of horror is well satisfied here. Richard has a sneezing allergy and is given an injection by Dr Root. He loves comic books and spends a lot of time in the Comic Book Museum where he chooses to do a school project with Bree, who is has been chosen to partner Richard. She's neither keen to work with Richard but agrees when he says he'll do all the research and writing. This leads to many extreme situations in the Museum with Bree and his brother Ernie. Dr Maniac and many characters from the comics come to life but Richard, from his reading, remembers how they were overcome. Dr Root opens a door between two worlds and when questioned by Richard says, 'Because . . . I'm the Root of All Evil' p120. Hence the twisted humour!
The series has been around for a long time and still new titles appear. Perhaps children read these books and then move onto other quality books.
Sue Nosworthy

After Eden by Helen Douglas

cover image

Bloomsbury Publishing, 2013. ISBN: 9781408828694.
(Age: Teens) Highly recommended. Science fiction. Ryan Westland, mysterious foreign student, begins Perran School half way through term in year eleven, a novelty among the students he quickly becomes the gossip of the year eleven girls. Claiming to be from America Ryan is the perfect student and manages to be rebellious responsibly. Seemingly unaware of his growing fun club Ryan flirts unashamedly with Eden, a relatively plain vegetarian who lives just down the road from his house in Penpol Cove. He befriends first her and then her friends, accompanying her to a beach party for Amy's birthday; he is particularly interested in Connor, Eden's best friend, as they each share a passion for astronomy.
As Ryan falls for Eden he becomes less and less private, even allowing her into his home after she pays an unexpected visit. By accident Eden takes one of Ryan's books, a book that by all rights should not exist yet, it is the biography of her best friend, Connor Penrose's life after discovering the planet Eden. Eden demands an explanation and Ryan gives her one, putting them both at risk. Together they must prevent the discovery of Eden (the only life supporting planet other than earth) in order to save the human race from its future extinction.
After Eden is highly recommended for teenage girls with a passion for drama and science fiction. Aimed at a young adult audience the novel is engaging and easy to read as it well written using colourful descriptions that allow the reader to visualise the story.
Kayla Gaskell (age eighteen)

How they Met and Other Stories by David Levithan

cover image

Text Publishing, 2014. ISBN 9781922147769.
The last review I wrote was for another book written by David Levithan, the spectacularly moving Two Boys Kissing, and now I review How They Met and Other Stories.
Upon researching this author, it seems there is a theme of love that runs through his work, and in my experience reading his work, his meditation on romance is always fresh and intriguing. I am particularly glad to see that David Levithan is inclusive of same-sex relationships in his writing, which are often overlooked in popular fiction. This work is no exception of this socially aware approach.
This anthology sets out to chronicle love of all kinds, and the many other emotions this one can conjure. In doing so, as always, Levithan is beautifully honest and unpretentious, and it the truthful nature of this work that makes it so compelling - Mills and Boon this certainly is not! Here, love is unvarnished, unglamourised, and presented to us in the messy and wholly recognizable game that we play in our own realities. We can relate to the tales of trial and triumph, where we understand and relate to each character. Rarely has there been such a variety of characters that I have so profoundly connected with in a book.
This work is, as the title suggests, a collection of short romantic fiction, but unlike many other writers in this genre, Levithan strives to and seemingly prides himself on his socially inclusive approach. And he should be praised for this.
It is refreshing to see written work for young people that is accessible and avoids the tired and expected trite, cliched approach. I hope to see more work coming from David Levithan, as in my eyes he is the most in-touch, and emotionally touching, young adult fiction author of the moment.
Henry Vaughan (Student)

The Dark by Lemony Snicket

cover image

Ill. by Jon Klassen. Orchard Books, 2013. ISBN 9781408330029.
Picture book. Laszlo is afraid of the dark. But he lives in a big house with a creaky roof, smooth, cold windows and several flights of stairs so there are many places that dark can hide. But mostly, dark lives in the basement waiting in a distant corner during the day and then coming out at night to spread itself against the windows and doors of Laszlo's house. But Laszlo thought that if he visited the dark in its room, it wouldn't come and visit him in his room so each morning he would peek at it in the basement and say hello. Until one night, it did . . .
The power of this story lies in Snicket's ability to personify the dark as a real entity as it leads Laszlo on a journey through the house and down, deep into the basement. It talks to Laszlo as though it is a real character, and Laszlo's calm response, both expression and action, helps convey the message that there is nothing to fear. Then just as the climax is almost reached, Snicket provides an explanation of the need for creaky roofs and blank windows, almost as though he is trying to defuse the suspense to make it manageable for the young reader.
Jon Klassen's illustrations help build up the suspense - a limited palette, the use of shadow, shade and light, bare walls, uncovered windows and empty rooms all add to the atmosphere and feed a little boy's imagination - and, in the words of one reviewer, this is an 'inspired pairing'. This is a perfect example of a picture book where text and illustrations work so well that each would be diminshed without the other.
The Dark appeared regularly on the best-of lists for 2013, particularly those in the US, and it is a gentler Snicket at work than the one we are accustomed to. Both the US and UK publishers have book trailers and you can listen to an audio clip by Neil Gaiman.
This would be a great introduction to introducing the science concepts of light and day, day and night, the rotation of the earth and so forth so that young children begin to understand more and fear less - another way to support the curriculum beyond the traditional English perspective.
Barbara Braxton

A very singular guild by Catherine Jinks

cover image

City of orphans, bk 3. Allen and Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743313091.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Ned Roach is now Alfred's chief apprentice, luring out child eating bogles with his use of verse, so that Alfred can kill them. Before working with Alfred he was a mudlark, scavenging for a living in the mud along the Thames. Now he is employed alongside of Alfred who has been paid by the London Sewers Office to rid London of an infestation of bogles. As well as facing the evil bogles, Ned and his friends, Jem and Birdie, face deadly danger from an enemy from their past.
In this the final story in the City of Orphans trilogy, following A very unusual pursuit and A very peculiar plague, Jinks relates the tale of Ned, who is a very likeable hero. He is intensely interested in machines and is fascinated by the steam engines and new machinery that he encounters in his travels with the employees of the London Sewers Offices and would love to work with them. However, he is very loyal to Alfred who has taken him away from the insecurity of scrabbling for a living in the mudflats, and believes that he must help him to entice the bogles out even though he is really afraid of them. His loyalty and steadfastness even when terrified as well as his powerful curiosity about machines make the story very enjoyable.
The setting of Dickens' London and the beginning of the machine age are all cleverly mixed with the superstitions of a people who believe in strange creatures who capture children. Jinks subtly draws the reader into the life of poor orphans in the 19th century and will leave them empathizing with the drawbacks of not being able to read and having to earn a living at a very early age. The descriptions of London's underground tunnels and sewer systems, the wickedness of some of the slum dwellers, the contrast with the wealthy and the frivolity of the actors in the theatres of Drury Lane bring a wonderful feel to the story.
Beautifully written, Jinks manages to tie up the fates of her characters in a very satisfying and atmospheric conclusion to an outstanding series which should grace every library shelf and would be a great read aloud in the classroom as well.
Pat Pledger

Two trickster tales from Russia, retold by Sophie Masson

cover image

Ill. by David Allan. Christmas Press, 2014. ISBN 9780992283803. Audio book ISBN 9780992283810.
(Age: All) Highly recommended. Picture book, Folk tales. The illustrations in this beautiful book impelled me to open the book to read, the front cover indicating the style Allan has used to compliment Masson's words. He uses a combination of black and white, and sometimes coloured images. For emphasis some images coves a double page, but more often, images are smaller and framed, with the frame sitting in front of another image, giving a three dimensional effect. Panels are used at the top and bottom of the page, and sometimes down the side, which along with the black outlined pictures, gives a wood block printing effect harking back to books of old. The illustrations draw the eye in to look at the detail encased within the borders, and readers will love the effect given.
The two stories retold by Sophie Masson, one of a girl, Masha, outsmarting a bear and the other about a preening rooster. In the first Mash goes out picking berries but soon becomes lost, walking into a house where porridge sits on the stove. She eat some with her berries only to find the owner, the Bear comes in and keeps her there to do his cooking. Eventually she convinces him to take a basket of pies to her parents and hides inside the basket, she has become so thin.
In the second tale a fabulous rooster is tricked repeatedly by the fox. He is always rescued by his friends, the thrush and the cat, until one day he is almost eaten. The animals trick the fox and she runs away. Two well told stories made even more interesting with the stunning illustrations should make a useful addition to the school library. Christmas Press is a new publisher set up by Sophie Masson, David Allan and Fiona McDonald in Armidale NSW, more information can be found at christmaspresspicturebooks.com
My review copy came with a CD for listening to the two stories.
Fran Knight

The Great Fire of London Unclassified by Nick Hunter

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408193037.
(Age: 9+) Recommended. Picture book, Fire, History. Published under the auspices of the National Archives and filled with an array of photographic evidence, pictures, maps, drawings, copies of written documents and many other primary sources, this book will fit the History curriculum when children study the Modern World within the curriculum for years seven to nine.
Both the Plague of 1665 and Great Fire in 1666 fire children's imagination at the sweep of such things four centuries ago. They will gasp at the lack of communication, lack of equipment to fight each disaster, lack of knowledge and the unstoppable nature of the fire, ponder at a conflagration just waiting to happen.
With London built cheek by jowl, the small but tall wooden houses needed only a spark, and when a bakery in Pudding Lane was not quite dowsed for the night, the fire began. The Mayor of London, refused to pull down the houses which would have halted the fire for fear of being blamed for the loss of the buildings, and so the fire spread taking in the churches, waterfront, St Paul's and much more, until over the three days, over three quarters of the city was lost. With no fire insurance, people simply had to start again.
I loved reading every page, looking at every photograph and map, along with the primary source material, comparing this fire with the ones that have destroyed parts of Australia recently.
Kids in upper primary and lower secondary will enjoy reading of this time in Britain's history along with the last part of the book dedicated to its rise from the ashes to become what it is today.
A sound glossary matched with a compact index and further resources to peruse, make this a must for libraries.
Fran Knight

Fools' gold by Philippa Gregory

cover image

Order of Darkness, bk 3. Simon and Schuster, 2014. ISBN 9780857077394.
(Age 14+) Recommended. Historical. Counterfeiting. Philosopher's stone. Luca's master directs him to go to Venice to investigate a gold coin counterfeiting scheme. Together with his companions Isolde, Ishraq, Frieze and Brother Peter, they arrive in Venice at Carnival time. The city is aglow with masked revellers and speculators are frantically buying up gold coins. Isolde's brother has set men on her trail and Venice has its own laws that make it a dangerous place to be. When the group meet the Alchemist and discover that he plans to create the Philosopher's Stone and with the flood of gold coins appearing in Venice, it looks as if there is even more danger than they had imagined.
In this, the third in the Order of Darkness series, following Changeling and Stormbringers, once again provides an impeccable and fascinating glimpse into history. Her descriptions of Venice, its canals, palaces and churches and the celebrations of the Carnival provide a beguiling background to the mystery surrounding the appearance of gold coins into the financial world of the traders. The Alchemist and his assistant are strange figures and their laboratory and what is in it make for an gripping insight into the Middle Ages belief that ordinary objects could be turned into gold and that the Philosopher's Stone could give immortality.
The romantic interest between Isolde and Luca is ramped up in this book although both seem to realise that their circumstances will make their love for each other difficult to sustain in the world they live in. Luca is the son of a farmer who has been taken into slavery on the galleys, and is also bound to the Church, while Isolde is a lady of quality.
With a website to support the series and an author note at the end of the novel about Medieval Venice, the role of Jewish moneylenders and alchemy, readers will have much historical information to feast on.
Pat Pledger