Reviews

A Little Treehouse Story series by Andy Griffiths and Terry Denton

cover image

Pan Macmillan Australia, 2015.
Barky the Barking Dog. ISBN 9781743532980
Ten Unlucky Pirates. ISBN 9781743532973
Recommended for readers from 6-8 years. Barky the Barking Dog originally appeared as a chapter in the Andy Griffiths and Terry Denton's popular The 13-Storey Treehouse. In a simple to read rhyming format for beginning readers, we follow Barky as he barks at everything from a rose to a gorilla's big hairy toes. He even barks at Terry and Andy and of course you!
Ten Unlucky Pirates was a chapter from Andy and Terry's bestselling The 26-Storey Treehouse. This rollicking rhyme is loosely based on the song Five Little Monkeys. Terry Denton's illustrations showcase his wicked sense of humour; there's a quirkiness to each colourful pirate predicament. Each meets a different fate - electrified by the sound equipment, attacked by the pirate tattooing machine or bucked off Kevin the mechanical bull.
Seven unlucky pirates making a rockin' pirate mix
One got a great big shock and then there were six
.
This new series from the Treehouse collection are just right for the beginning reader, a great introduction to the winning combination of Andy Griffiths and Terry Denton.
Rhyllis Bignell

The adventures of Beekle the unimaginary friend by Dan Santat

cover image

Little, Brown, 2014. ISBN 9780316199988
Highly recommended for readers from 4-7 years. Caldecott Picture Book Winner 2015. Dan Santat's award winning picture book told in the third person, explores the world from the imaginary friends point of view. He introduces a small creature sadly waiting on the island of unimaginary friends, wanting  'to be picked by a child and given a special name.' He watches as other creatures are beamed away into the starry night sky, off to enjoy a world of friendship and adventure.
With courage and determination, Beekle sets sail to find his real friend. He crosses the deep green ocean in a tiny boat, encountering a huge, colourful sea serpent and a giant whale on his journey. When he lands in the real world, he is unhappy. His little, chubby white body and golden crown, stand out in the gray and sepia-toned adult spaces, the restaurant and subway train where everything is both distant and daunting. 'No kids were eating cake. No one stopped to hear the music.'
When all seems lost, Alice a small girl with large spectacles appears, she's waving a hand-drawn picture of him perched high up in a tree filled with star-shaped leaves. He truly is her imaginary friend.
Santat's emotive use of colour stands out in this picture book . The grey tones for the world without friends, brown and orange for the first meeting of his real friend and rainbow hues for the island and sea serpent. Glowing yellow circles light up the cartoon style scenes when Alice names him Beekle. The bright hues of the children's playground lift the narrative as Beekle searches everywhere for his friend.
To win a Caldecott Medal a picture book needs to provide the young reader with a uniquely visual and emotional experience that respects their understandings and abilities. The Adventures of Beekle The Unimaginary Friend by Dan Santat is distinctive and engaging, share this with a young child or a junior primary class.
Rhyllis Bignell

A Scarlet Novel: Lady Thief by A. C. Gaughen

cover image

Walker Books, 2014. ISBN 9780802736147
(Age: 12+) Imagine if everything Robin Hood did had been done by a woman . . . Well this book isn't quite THAT controversial, however it does morph both the legendary Maid Marian and Will Scarlet into the same figure.
Set in Nottingham after Robin Hood's escape and the sheriff's subsequent demise, the novel follows Scarlet as she returns to her loveless marriage under the lure of an annulment, which can only be achieved if both she and her husband petition the church. Unfortunately, her return pairs with Prince John's arrival and not only is she back at the mercy of Lord Gisbourne, but of Prince John as well. The Prince was summoned to choose a replacement sheriff, however it soon becomes apparent that that isn't his only agenda. Will he get his way when he has Scarlet to contend with?
Although written in a dialect, the writing style appears to be confusing. Not only is the dialect employed, but the writing is fairly modern which clashes both with the vernacular and the setting used.
One of the most outstanding things about his novel is it's characterisation of Scarlet (A.K.A Marian) being a strong, yet wilful, woman who is more than capable of making decisions for herself and for the good of others. Presented as a nobleman's daughter, Scarlet escaped to join Robin's merry band where she then fell in love with the legendary Robin Hood. A good hand at knives, Scarlet places herself in danger by loving Robin, both with the hopeful sheriffs, with the prince himself and even with Robin. She is a great role model for girls and for this reason I would recommend to girls aged twelve and up.
Kayla Gaskell (Age nineteen)

You wouldn't want to be in the trenches in World War One by Alex Woolf

cover image

David Antram. Book House, 2014. ISBN 9781909645226
(Age: Yr 5+) Subtitled A hole you'd rather not be in this is an ideal introduction for younger students to World War I. The reader is given the persona of one Tommy Atkins, an underage but enthusiastic English lad determined to do his bit for King and Country and then in a chatty commentary which is filled with facts and accompanied by appealing cartoon-esque illustrations is led through the process from joining up to training to being in the trenches on the Western Front. Life in the trenches is exposed for what it was - rats and lice, bully beef, bread and biscuits, cold and wet and being under fire.
While remaining factually true the presentation is one that tells what happened but without the gory bits, the parts that we as adults know but kids don't have to yet. For example, Tommy is wounded at Messines but the next part is about being back in England with family. Scattered throughout are handy hints such as "To detect enemy tunnelling, drive a stick into the ground and hold the other end between teeth to feel any vibrations."
This is an ideal addition to your WWI/ANZAC collection, just right for the reader who wants to know what happened but for whom fiction doesn't appeal. While the guide suggests this as suitable for Yrs 5-8, a mature Yr3+ reader with an interest in the topic would handle it well.
For an extensive list of texts to help primary students understand ANZAC, Gallipoli and World War I you might like to check out my Pinterest board Remembering Gallipoli I've gathered over 200 resources.
Barbara Braxton

13 words by Lemony Snicket

cover image

Maira Kalman. HarperCollins, 2014. ISBN 9780061664670
(Age: K-3) Word Number 1: bird. The bird sits on the table Word Number 2: despondent. The bird is despondent. In fact, she is so sad that she hops off the table to look for something to cheer her up. And so begins this new story from Lemony Snicket (A Series of Unfortunate Events) that continues his penchant for quirky but thoroughly engaging stories. Bird hops off the table to explore the cake (Word Number 3) that is in the box under it and is joined by dog (word Number 4). Together they eat the cake and then while Bird gets busy (Word Number 5) Dog goes off in his convertible (#6) and meets Goat (#7) and together they look for things that might cheer Bird up. They decide on a hat (#8) and so continues a wonderful tale that compels the reader to make connections between words like 'haberdashery', 'panache' and 'mezzo-soprano'.
Giving life to the words are the amazing illustrations of Maira Kalman which have been described in the Kirkus review as 'gorgeous, Matisse-like, gelato-colored'. They force the reader to engage with them, drawing you in to discover a range of unexpected delights that are just as original as Snicket's storyline. It's as though Snicket and Kalman have decided to take the iconic format of a children's basic word book and turn it upside-down. Not only have they used words that kids know and are common in traditional word books, but they've also chosen some of those that they love to learn and let roll of their tongue in delight. What kindergarten word list contains 'panache' and 'despondent'? Add to that, instead of the words being isolated and disconnected, they've turned them into a story that puts them in a context that demonstrates their meaning and makes a most appealing story.
This book works on so many levels apart from just being plain fun. Students could make a list of the most delicious words that they love to say; they could make their own list of thirteen words and try to weave them into a story; they could make a chart of all the different types of hats and classify them as sunsmart or not; and given that Bird is still despondent at the end of the story they could speculate on what might make her happier. It's a book that keeps on giving and has something for each age group you share it with.
For a sneak peek, there's a trailer at http://youtu.be/VI1HZFrijeU
Barbara Braxton

Fearless: sons and daughter by Colin Thompson

cover image

Ill. by Sarah Davis. ABC Books, 2015. ISBN 9780733330872
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Dogs. Animal behaviour. Babies. Fearless is a dad. Coming indoors one evening he finds Primrose with five writhing little pups beside her. They ponder together about where they came from, and Primrose settles into grooming them. Fearless tries to remember what life was like when he was a pup, and wonders what sort of dad he will be. At first the pups ignore him, but when he explains that he is their dad they all get along well, doing the things that dads do with their offspring. He plays with them, models behaviour, tells them of the dangers that lurk in the garden. The pond is a target of further explanation as sharks lurk in there so it is a place to stay away from.
Over the weeks four of the puppies go to other homes and the remaining puppy and Primrose thinks that they may have fallen into the pond and so investigate. Fearless saves the day, showing the protective nature of fathers within the family as Fearless overcomes his fear of the water to save Primrose and Eric.
This is a delight as Sarah Davis has produced a set of pictures which reflect the behaviour of parents towards their children, modeling the sorts of behaviour expected, showing the sorts of things fathers do with their babies, and they are varied, funny and cute.
Throughout the book, the text subtly shows the family interacting, and how the father is part of the family unit, guiding, modelling, telling and protecting. His role is tantamount to the pup's safety as it grows up. This is a lovely book about nurturing to share in the classroom and at home.
Fran Knight

Shimmer by Paula Weston

cover image

The Rephaim bk 3. Text Publishing, 2014. ISBN 9781922147974
(Age: 15+) Recommended. Gaby has started to become accustomed to the thought that she is one of the Rephaim, a half angel and that her brother Jude is still alive. But her world is torn apart with the capture of Rafa and Taya, who are being kept in a horrible prison, an iron-lined room, by Gatekeeper demons. She must get all the Rephaim to work together to try and rescue them and that is not an easy job.
The third in the series, Shimmer, concentrates on the relationships within the Rephaim, and the machinations that occur between gaby and her close confederates, those loyal to the Sanctuary and the Outcasts. There is a handy Who's who at the front of the book as a reminder of the characters and Gaby recounts what has happened in earlier books at the beginning of Shimmer, all of which is helpful when books only come out once a year. The reader begins to get to know all the characters in depth and Weston keeps the tension taut as Gaby does her best to get the Rephaim to unite and go to Rafa's rescue. There are some surprise moments that shock and leave the reader wondering just who is loyal and who is betraying the half angels.
Gaby's leadership skills are beginning to develop and it is interesting to see her operate through the anxiety about Rafa, with determination and strength. She seems to be combining both her skills as a half angel and the skills that she learnt when she thought she was just human and this makes for a fascinating read.
Weston's tight prose and great character building, as well as her creation of a fascinating world, make this a very readable book and the cliff-hanger at the end means that the last in the series will have to be read. This series is a worthwhile read for fantasy lovers, especially those who like some half angels involved.
Pat Pledger

Ever After High: Once Upon a Time: A Story Collection by Shannon Hale

cover image

Little Brown, 2014. ISBN 9780349132020
(Age: 10+) Recommended. This is a collection of 12 short stories that turn traditional fairy tale characters on their heads. At Ever After High, the students are beginning their Legacy Year, the time when they will sign the Storybook of Legends and pledge that they will repeat the stories that their parents have become famous for.
People who love fairy stories will be charmed with this collection that is both quirky and very funny. My favourites were the stories of Dexter and Darling Charming, Dexter Charming and the yellow-eyed changeling and Darling Charming and the razor eel. Their adventures and antics in the home of their father Prince Charming were very amusing, but also poignant as Darling wished she didn't have to pretend to be just a beautiful maiden, while Dexter often stands out in his family as he is not as brave or as daring as his brothers. Maddie Hatter, the daughter of the Madhatter, works in a tea shop with her father and her story is fascinating as well. There are also fun stories about Apple White, Lizzie Hearts, Raven Queen, Briar Beauty, Ashlynn Ella and Hunter Huntsman.
Underlying them all are themes of accepting yourself and your strengths and weaknesses, even if like Cedar Wood, you are made of wood; of standing up to bullies and of cherishing friendships.
These stories made me smile and feel good and could prove to be an interesting and challenging read for young girls especially.
Pat Pledger

Obsession in Death by J.D. Robb

cover image

In Death bk40. Piatkus, 2015. ISBN 9780349403656
(Age: Adult) Mystery. Romance. Eve and Roarke are back in the 40th book of the series. In Death showcases what it would be like to be a celebrity and to have a killer focus all their attention on you. Eve is used to the media attention especially after a video had been made of her exploits but it is very upsetting to find a message 'FOR LIEUTENANT EVE DALLAS, WITH GREAT ADMIRATION AND UNDERSTANDING' painted behind a murdered barrister. Her admirer is convinced that they have a special bond and that Eve would approve of this and subsequent murders that take place.
I found the expose of a stalker/vigilante murderer to be quite interesting. This was not so much a mystery where the reader had to uncover clues and try and work out who the killer was, rather the emphasis was on the psychology of the murderer. Of course, Eve, with the help of Peabody, the cop team and Roarke, using smart team work and intelligence, do discover just who is killing off people who may have annoyed Eve, or indeed trying to kill people close to her.
I didn't find this as fast paced or as clever with the dialogue as some of the others in the series, but it is still a good solid read that fans will enjoy. It fleshes out the characters and background well enough for a stand-alone read as well, which is good when there are so many in the series!
Pat Pledger

The Last Thirteen series by James Phelan

cover image

Scholastic, 2014
Book 1: ISBN 9781742831848
Book 2: ISBN 9781742831855
Book 3: ISBN 9781742831862
(Age: 10+) Recommended. Adventure, Thriller. Adventure and thrills aplenty in this serving of a series for boys about Sam saving the world. Sam has been seeing a psychiatrist since the death of his best friend, Bill in a fire destined to consume the two boys. And yet he still has shocking nightmares, ones that disturb his sleep and make him drowsy. But at school one day, the impossible happens. Just like a movie, helicopters appear, dropping men from the sky, lasering those who get in their way. Their target is Sam, who they take with them, and as they do he hears his science teacher, call out, 'we'll find you'. What an opening. The twists and turns in this breathless adventure will keep readers turning the pages to see if Sam, one of the Thirteen Dreamers, can save the world. The thirteen books in the series show the gathering of the thirteen together in a place in Switzerland, and with 13 written boldly across the front cover, the books can be easily spotted on the library shelves or in the bookshop. The next in the series, 12, follows Sam and his new friends as they must find Solaris, something from one of Sam's dreams. And 11 sees their enemies growing stronger as Sam must unlock the puzzle in the ancient journal.
Scholastic has a terrific trailer for this series, and a website that supports the stories with games along with more information about the books and their characters.
Fran Knight

Egg and Spoon by Gregory Maguire

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2014. ISBN 9780763672201
(Age: 12+) The author is best known for his story Wicked, which inspired the musical of the same name. Along with a special interest in the Brothers Grimm and Maurice Sendak, Maguire harbours a fascination for Russian folklore, reimagining and retelling stories which are familiar to many of us. Egg and Spoon brings a vast cast of characters and stories together on a sprawling Russian canvas. To begin, the reader is introduced to the storyteller who is locked in a tower on the outskirts of the Tsarist Russian empire. He has an amazing tale to tell, beginning with the chance meeting of two girls in their early teens. Elena is from a poverty-stricken family in a rural area ravaged by bad harvests, cold and tragedy. Ekaterina is wealthy and noble of birth, destined for betrothal within the Tsar's family. Entirely by accident the two girls end up swapping places and the adventure begins. How reminiscent is this of numerous folktales we know! Even though the setting is Russia around 1900, Maguire combines the historical with the fantastical. We meet the Firebird, Baba Yaga and the Ice Dragon. We meet a prince travelling incognito and we share in the beauty of the Faberge egg. He invites us to follow him on this magical journey, holding our attention with wonderful asides and an overlying sense of humour. There are important lessons to be learned along the way about wealth and inequality, the fragile nature of the environment and the importance of individuals seeing beyond themselves.
Overall the book is too long and often quite complex, but the story is engrossing and beautifully and cleverly told. There is something for everyone in this book, strange and fanciful as it is, and it would work well as a book to share and read aloud.
Julie Wells
Editor's note: It was on ALA best fiction for young adults 2015 and on Kirkus best books 2014 list.

Hunger Town by Wendy Scarfe

cover image

Wakefield Press, 2014. ISBN 9781743053362
(Age: Young Adult) Wendy Scarfe has been writing for over four decades, with many of her published works highlighting her special interests in history, and social and political issues.
The desperate days of the Great Depression form the backdrop to Scarfe's novel Hunger Town. It is the story of a city caught in a cycle of 'unemployment, hunger, protests and police reprisals', and a country poised on the cusp of political and social change, driven by a generation with new ideas.
Set on the Port River in Adelaide during this turbulent era, Hunger Town is primarily an historical narrative. Scarfe inveigles the personal dilemmas of Judith and Harry Larsen and their compatriate working class people into this narrative of Australia's political history. Her vignettes tell of Judith's unusual upbringing on a coaling hulk moored on the Port River, of widespread unrest, a burgeoning communist party and its attempt to establish a presence in Mildura. Finally, a misguided foray into the fascist politics of Europe and Spain, and Judith's race against time to rescue Harry from both himself and the spreading disease of fascism, hint at the unrest of those times.
Hunger Town spotlights an Australia many of us are too young to have experienced. Although Scarfe uses her historical knowledge to evoke those dark, desperate days, her sweep of characters sometimes does not allow them to grow within the context of the story.
Colleen Tuovinen

Cinderella: stories around the world, retold by Cari Meister

cover image

Picture Window books, 2015. ISBN 9781479554492
(Age: 5+) Cinderella. Fairy tales. Four of the world's store of stories about Cinderella will be a good read aloud for younger readers. The stories include a French version of Cinderella, a Canadian story called Little Burnt Face from the Micmac tribe, Yeh-Shen a Chinese Cinderella tale and Rhodopis, an Egyptian Cinderella story.
Each of the girls is poor, the lowest ranked child in the house, cleaning and sweeping for her board and lodging. There is always a prince looking for his true love, a ball or test, a slipper and finally a wedding. All four are astonishingly similar from such disparate parts of the world.
Read aloud and discussed with a class looking at fairy tales, these four will provide a basic understanding of the Cinderella motif, and give a wider view of the story.
I love the Grimm Brothers version and this would be a great contrast to the sweeter offerings here.
The French version is very similar to the well known version, paralleling the Disney film from 1950. The Canadian version of the girl whose face is burnt by her stepsisters surprised me, as it brings in the degree of cruelty offered in the version by the Brothers Grimm. Rhodopis certainly adds another flavour to the tale, as it is set in Egypt and Yu-Shen will intrigue those readers with its different setting and names.
The illustrations presented by four different artists reflect a Disney style common amongst books for this age group, although the illustrator for Little Burnt Face, Carolina Farias has attempted to emulate the stylised drawing techniques of North American groups and her illustrations present a different view.
This is one of a series of books comparing different fairy stories around the world.
Fran Knight

The last of the spirits by Chris Priestley

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408854136
Suggested for age 11 upwards. Moderate horror themes. Utilising Dickens' Christmas Carol as a framework, Priestley brings forward the characters described by the original author as 'Ignorance' and 'Want' presenting them as the desperately poor brother and sister, Sam and Lizzie.
Their existence is one of true survival where failing to gather sufficient pitiful scraps of food through foraging and begging may result in death from malnutrition and exposure in the freezing conditions endured by homeless children on Victorian London streets. Sam is understandably bitter, outraged by social injustice and faces the world with a hot headed belligerence which impedes his wisdom and capacity to show sensitivity to his sister whom he clearly loves and protects.
Scrooge is loyally portrayed as a mean and callous miser who is completely indifferent to the suffering of others as he suggests that the poor should be sent to prison. He further expresses the repugnant opinion that those who would rather die than suffer the horrifying workhouses should do so in order to decrease the population.
The spirits and ghosts from the original tale naturally make their appearance to bring about the drastic change in attitude in Scrooge which is achieved by essentially terrifying the life out of him.
Importantly, Sam is similarly affected by the revelations produced by the Ghosts of Past and Yet to come. He is moved by being able to watch a happy scene from his childhood where he lives safely in the company of his mother and sister and is shocked and distressed when able to view the eventual downfall of both himself and Lizzie if he maintains his current destructive path.
The brutal conditions described by both authors are historically accurate and Dickens wrote from personal experience in a bid to make his contemporary readers appreciate how miserable life was for the poor, especially children. Equally important in this tale is the emphasis on redemption and the ability to change one's path in life by rejecting what is undesirable or destructive by choosing a way forward which fulfills others and the self in return.
Rob Welsh

Please Mr Panda by Steve Antony

cover image

Hachette, 2014. ISBN 9781444916645
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Humour, Animals, Manners. Mr Panda has an armful of donuts and many other animals come by when he offers the donuts to them. The penguin wants the pink one, the skunk wants the blue one and the yellow one, but Mr Panda turns his back. His offer to the ostrich is rejected (she is a ballet dancer), but the orca wants them all. Finally a lemur asks if he can have a donut, 'Please Mr Panda', and so the riddle of how to get a donut is solved. You need to use your manners, with a please and then a thank you.
The story of using your manners will have resonance in classrooms and at home where manners are being taught and discussed, and the humour in the story will make sure the lesson is taught with fun. Children will enjoy recognising the animals drawn and be able to discuss them further. Steve Antony's The Queen's hat (2014) is a very funny story about her hat blowing away in the wind, and would be worth getting from the library to compare with this story and its illustrations.
There are very few books about manners to use in the classroom, and those that are available are didactic and teacherish. Talking about manners with a large dose of humour makes the lesson far more palatable.
The illustrations are noteworthy with their use of the grey page and the placement of the animals. I love the upside down panda and lemur towards the end of the story and this will draw questions from the audience. The use of the endpapers too adds another dimension for humour and discussion which I for one appreciate as I am sure younger readers will notice as well.
Fran Knight