Reviews

Bridie's boots by Phil Cummings

cover image

Ill. by Sara Acton. Working Title Press, 2014. ISBN 9781921504723.
(Age: 4-8) Highly recommended. Weather. Age. Compassion. Bridie adores her red boots and during the winter she turns five they do all sorts of things together, having many adventures, sloshing through puddles, braving storms and crossing wild rivers.
Putting them away when winter finishes, she goes on with her life but when winter comes around again, she takes them out ready to renew their friendship, but they are too small.
Bridie and Mum decide to let someone else share her adventures with her boots.
This is a deceptively straightforward story but full of wonderful things which young children will notice and want to talk about: changing shape and size, growing older, weather and the change of seasons, charity shops and helping those who are less advantaged and of course, having adventures.
Bridie is a fun loving, adventurous child who tries many different things with her new boots, and all is reflected in the stunning illustrations, full of verve and energy.
The illustrations readily capture Bridie prancing around with her boots, or in a small tissue paper boat, sailing on top of high waves, or the home of the new owner across the other side of the world. The ebullient illustrations suit the child admirably. Sara Acton has recently illustrated The unexpected crocodile, and Daisy and the puppy, both of which are among my favourites, and Phil Cumming's work includes the beautiful, Anzac biscuits. I like the end papers with their small illustrations, and the binding reflecting an older style of book, which along with the design of the book, makes it a pleasure to hold and read.
Fran Knight

To this day: For the bullied and beautiful by Shane Koyczan

cover image

Walker Books, 2014. ISBN 9781925081510.
(Age: All ) Recommended. Bullying. The author of this poem about bullying is described as a spoken word artist who claims to have been bullied as a child. This print version features thirty different illustrators' responses to the text which has become a global phenomenon via the internet; garnering millions of views for the animated version, spawning phone apps, and anti-bullying movements. Here the thoughtful, funny and heartbreaking words from the point of view of the bullied are augmented by some wonderful images. The illustrations deepen the meaning and enhance the message that the bullies are wrong when they make you feel worthless and that while the damage might be permanent victims are not alone and survival is possible. There are links to the animated version of the poem and a resources page for support organisations. As a discussion starter for anti-bullying programmes or just as a life raft for the bullied the book will fit in any school library. It might also be useful for senior graphic design students.
Sue Speck

The Rapunzel dilemma by Jennifer Kloester

cover image

Penguin, 2014. ISBN 9780143571087
Recommended for ages 12+ (middle school). Lily de Tourney lives a charmed and affluent life despite the death of her mother. So when she's offered a place in the London Drama Academy, Lily's dream school, she becomes surprised when nothing goes her way. Lily has her own skeletons in her closet and when her so-called friends make life difficult for her, she discovers a secret refuge in one of the Academy's towers. But not everything can keep her safe and when her place in the Academy is threatened, Lily must do whatever it takes to pursue her dream and maybe, get the guy in the end.
Jennifer Kloester's The Rapunzel dilemma is a classic tale of mystery and romance packaged into one enjoyable book. The plot thickens as the story continues on, which makes the novel such a fun read. The writing is not too complex and easy to read which really defines it as a fresh weekend read. But what really took me by surprise was the plot twist! No one could have expected it to take place which just makes this book better!
As each page was turned, Kloester keeps us wanting more of the hush-hush romance as she masterfully weaves an intricate relationship that defies all odds. The novel surprised me. I am not one to read books based on drama academies but I am glad that I have read this novel and generally liked it. Books of the likes of this story embrace the Anna and the French kiss series by Stephanie Perkins and A little something different written by Sandy Hall.
Samantha May (Student)

The land of stories: A Grimm warning by Chris Colfer

cover image

Hachette, 2014. Bk 3. ISBN 9780349124377.
(Age 10+) Highly recommended. Smoke filled the sky above the treetops in the distance. A horrible screeching noise erupted through the air. Everyone standing at the palace covered their ears from the dreadful sound.
Alex and Conner Bailey are special. Their grandmother is the Fairy Godmother! After their first two adventures in the Land of Stories, Alex stays behind to train to become Fairy Godmother and Conner returns to the Otherworld. But when another disaster rises in the Land of Stories, Conner and Alex have to band together to defeat whatever it is threatening their kingdom.
The twins are put to the test as they struggle to save the Land of Stories from destruction once again. Will Alex become Fairy Godmother? Will Conner ever be able to return to the Land of Stories? And what secret will Alex uncover that will make the twins doubt their whole life?
I would recommend this book to children 10 and over as some scenes' details are described thoroughly and anyone younger might find it too gruesome. I would also recommend reading this book after you have read the first two: The land of stories: The wishing spell, and The land of stories: The enchantress returns.
Chris Colfer is a very well-known actor and author and this book is proof of that. The Brothers Grimm are most probably two of the world's most profound authors and this novel is a great classic with a twist.
Jazmin Humphries (Student Year 7)

The monster who ate Australia by Michael Salmon

cover image

Ford St, 2014. ISBN 9781925000542
(Age: 5-10) Recommended. Picture book. Australia. Humour. Journeys. The thirtieth anniversary edition of this book will find a place in Australian schools where it will be used as an adjunct to the emphasis now given to Geography in the curriculum.
Burra the Boggabri, a monster which lives in a small cave behind Uluru is being kicked out of house and home by the many tourists now visiting the centre of Australia. He decides it is time to find another home and spends some time wandering around Australia looking for just such a place.
He visits every capital city, looking at some of their famous places deciding that each place is not for him. Some are too cold or wet, others do not taste very nice, eating Blue Poles in Canberra meant that an alarm goes off, the noise sending him to the next city. In Sydney, horror of horrors he is captured and placed in a cage at Taronga Park Zoo, where he is besieged by hundreds of tourists coming to look at him, point at him and take photos. This is the final straw, he nibbles his way out of the bars and returns to central Australia, but not before many readers have had fun following his ventures around the country as shown on the map on the title page.
Salmon's funny illustrations add to the laugh out loud humour of the book which is suitable for early to middle primary students.
Fran Knight

Funny bunnies (series) by David Melling

cover image

Hachette, 2014.
Rain or shine. ISBN 9781444919127.
Up and down. ISBN 9781444917840.
(Age: Preschool) Board book. Preschool. Weather. Two books in this series Funny bunnies, Rain or shine, and Up and down, are designed to be held by young hands and used without a care for the niceties of reading a book. In hard board ready to take any treatment dolled out by children still unable to appreciate how to handle a book, these will be used within early childhood centres and in the home.
Each shows the funny bunnies on their pogo sticks in situations which reflect the terms, up and down, or aspects of the weather in rain and shine. Each is told in rhyming phrases, encouraging the child to develop a sense of the rhythm of words, and help them to predict what the next word might be.
In Up and down, the bunnies demonstrate two words which mean the opposite. So we have the bunnies pulling a cow, and then pushing a cow, or a bunny going fast while the next bunny goes slow, or some bunnies play while some fight. Each double page shows the opposites and so lends itself to discussing words and their meanings.
In Rain or shine, each double page illustrates a different aspects of weather, including hail and snow, fog and storm.
Both books will provide a strong book for younger readers which will teach them new aspects of their language and environment.
Fran Knight

Panic by Sharon M. Draper

cover image

Simon & Schuster, 2013. ISBN 9781442408975.
(Age 14+) Sexual exploitation and abuse. Family issues. Teenage issues. Dancing. Relationships. The cover of this book displays a beautiful tropical butterfly pinned sadly by one wing. This is a metaphor for what is to follow in this sad tale of the abduction of a young dancer named Diamond, who is exploited by a predator who makes films for the prurient interests of internet viewers. The ease with which the character allows herself to be led into the abductors 'net' by the promise of fame is sadly frightening. Intertwined with this distasteful plot line are the stories of the dancers from her troupe that are left behind grieving and dealing with their own teenage, school, friendship and relationship issues. The abuse of one of the characters by her aggressive, but attractive boyfriend, and ultimately the sexting of images that creates great pain also added another agonising plot line. Set in an undisclosed US locale, the dialogue is peppered with uniquely American teenage slang and some bizarrely chosen character names. The incongruity of the horror of the central plot line with the fragility and innocence of the male and female dancers as they practise for an approaching performance is almost painful.
This book reminded me of the unpleasantness of the adult novel by John Fowles, The collector, or of Emma Donoghue's, The room, but without the quality of writing. Attempting to make this into a teenage text perhaps creates the discomfort, although the author has obviously endeavoured to make this more about teenagers and the way they deal with contemporary personal difficulties. Because this book has a younger target audience (in the 14+ bracket), I am not sure I would actively promote this book. Older readers (17+) who can cope emotionally with the horrors of sexual exploitation in an abduction scenario would be better to read the previously mentioned adult books.
Carolyn Hull

Emus under the bed by Leann J Edwards

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 978743313459.
(Age: Preschool) Recommended. Picture book. Indigenous themes. When the narrator visits her Aunt Dollo on Saturdays, she not only connects with family, but her Aboriginal culture. Aunt Dollo is an artist. She collects feathers from all sorts of birds and makes flowers with them. Aunt Dollo tells her niece where she gets the feathers, and together they make a headband for the girl. At lunch they sit outside with Uncle Rex who makes them damper to eat under the gum trees. But Aunt Dollo has a surprise and asks her into the room to lift the quilt. Under the bed are six emu chicks. What a marvellous day.
During the day the reader assimilates much about Aboriginal culture, and can relate the birds that live close by, the sorts of trees to be found in their community and what the family eats. The passing on of culture is shown as the aunt teaches the girl about using their environment to make an art piece.
The illustrations reflect the story, with swathes of colour crossing each page, and the stylised images recognisably from an Aboriginal pen. This book is one of a number produced under the auspices of the Emerging Indigenous Picture Book Mentoring Project, with the support of the Little Big Book club, Allen & Unwin and the Australia Council.
Fran Knight

Hana's suitcase: a true story by Karen Levine

cover image

Anniversary edition, Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743317679.
(Ages: 10-14) Highly recommended. There would be few people who remain unaware of the poignant story of Hana's suitcase and the diligent unravelling that brought a young Holocaust victim back to the living. After the successful radio documentary, numerous awards, film documentary, years of touring and travelling and speaking, by the author Karen Levine, the determined Fumiko Ishioka, Hana's brother Georg as well as his daughter Lara, this tenth anniversary of the book republishes the original text and adds a wealth of updated information and images.
The main participants in sharing Hana's ill-fated story with modern children, in their stalwart endeavour to spread the message of peace, each add their reflections on the past ten years. There is also much additional material in the messages, images and poetry from children all around the world.
'From little things, big things grow' is very apt in this instance. When Fumiko, curator of the Japanese Holocaust Education Centre, requested a child's artefact from the Auschwitz Museum, to be the focal point of an educational program and exhibit 'The Holocaust through the Eyes of a Child', she little thought that her group of dedicated students would spur her on to uncover the truth about Hana Brady's fate in the darkest days of human history. When Hana's suitcase arrived from Auschwitz, bearing only her name and the information that she was an orphan, there was scant evidence to piece together the rest of the puzzle. How fortunate that this remarkable young woman refused to be daunted and kept on digging until she was not only able to piece together Hana's history but become connected with Hana's brother and in a small way help him heal after sixty long years.
I can only say if you have not yet read this - you must - and share it with all young people who are able to appreciate the enormity of both the atrocity and the challenge to restore Hana to her living family.
Visit the Brady Family museum online.
And view the trailer of 'Inside Hana's suitcase'.
Sue Warren

Our village in the sky by Janeen Brian

cover image

Ill. by Anne Spudvilas. Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743318140.
(Age: 7+) Recommended. Poetry. Himalayas. Village life. With short poems reflecting the lifestyle of those who live in the village and its setting in the Himalayas, this book is a treat. Each poem shows another aspect of the children's lives, all contrasting with the lives of our students, while some show unexpected similarities. The watercolour illustrations of these children are absorbing as Spudvilas manages to get so much detail into a wash drawing, entreating the eye to look at the pots and pans, clothing, footwear and housing of these villagers, all the while surrounded by the mountains.
Each poem and illustration shows a different aspect of life in this remote village. The opening double page shows a young girl sitting with her village and the mountains in the background, just losing their wintry white cover of snow. The opening pages introduces the reader to a place not well known, and through the book, it becomes more tangible. Then we see the child using the water tub as a drum on the way to the pipe, then struggling to bring the full tub home. And over the pages small children are helping their parents build their house. They must dig mud out of the ground and take it to their father who moulds it with clay and straw and dung before putting it into moulds to make bricks. On another page the young girl is cleaning her brother's clothes, and on another, they mind the goats or wash the dishes, or use a ladder as a seesaw, all with smiling faces, all using the experience to draw some fun out of the work.
Janeen's poems are delightful, adding nuances to the children's play which is poignant and affecting. Her imagery is controlled, and reflects a deep understanding of village life. As a read-aloud or a class story, as a model for their own writing, this book will have a multitude of uses in the classroom, where looking at other countries, particularly in the Asia Pacific region is part of the increased emphasis on geography in the curriculum.
Fran Knight

How to babysit a grandma by Jean Reagan

cover image

Ill. by Lee Wildish. Hachette Children's Books, 2014. ISBN 9781444918120.
(Age: 4-6) Picture book. Grandmothers. Babysitting. Family. If a child has any concerns going to stay overnight with Grandma, then this book will ensure they are all dissolved as the task is turned on its head with the child babysitting Grandma, showcasing a close and companionable relationship between the girl and her grandmother, as well as the parents as they leave the girl to look after the older woman.
The pair engages in a range of different activities including going to the park, feeding the ducks, cooking together, watching for the first evening star, using charades to tell the woman how much she is loved, then going to bed after making sure the front light is on.
Each activity is one which grandparents do with their grandchildren, but done the other way allows for some very funny lines as well as humorous illustrations in which the child is the leader.
A companion for the New York Times bestseller How to babysit a granddad, this one will also win hearts as the young girl allays all her fears of being away from her parents by helping her grandmother fill in her time with a basket of activities.
Children will easily recognise situations where they have a babysitter and involve themselves in the things the two do together, comparing them with what they do when staying with someone else, and look forward to doing them themselves. The close ties of the family are stressed all through with the child saying I love you to her grandmother several times, with the illustrations reflecting all the good things that make up a happy and close relationship.
Fran Knight

The astrologer's daughter by Rebecca Lim

cover image

Text Publishing, 2014. ISBN 9781922182005.
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Avicenna never wanted to become an astrologer as her mother, Joanne, was. Avicenna knew the trade, understood it, but never wanted to be one herself. However, when her mother disappears she is forced to follow in her mother's footsteps to uncover the truth. When one of her mother's clients seeks out Avicenna's help to find the truth behind a cold-case murder, she discovers a connection to Joanne's disappearance. With the help of Simon, her rival for the R. M. Tichborne Prize, she pieces together the facts.
The astrologer's daughter was not what I was expecting in any way. A compelling read, one that hooked me from the beginning, I was taken straight into the story and felt compelled to complete Avicenna's story with her. Mesmerized by the way Rebecca Lim wrote the novel, I could not put the book down. The chapters flowed on in a way that keeps the reader captivated, wanting to help Avicenna with her mystery. I love that Avicenna is strong-willed throughout the novel, even after her mother's disappearance. While the ending was vague, it left thoughts of how Avicenna will now continue on and allows the reader to create their own thoughts of what will come next in her life. A wonderful 'coming of age' novel set in Melbourne, Australia.
Cecilia Richards

Sonoma meets Miss Mouse by Di Morrissey

cover image

Ill. by Julie Sydenham. Harbour Publishing, 2014. ISBN 9781922134400.
This is the first children's book written by popular Australian author Di Morrissey. With experience spanning over two decades in publishing, Morrissey is known for her adult fiction that covers themes including personal relationships, the environment, Aboriginal reconciliation, identity and Australia's relationship with its South East Asian and Pacific neighbours. Dedicated to her granddaughter, Morrissey's first foray into children's literature tells a tale of friendship and compassion. The main character, Sonoma, is a brave young girl who is not fearful of darkness or being alone at night. As she awakens one night, she hears the sound of a soft and sad whimper. Sonoma hears the whimper turn to crying, and she is concerned because she does not like anyone to be sad. When she discovers that the source of the crying is a little mouse, Sonoma is surprised but she is quick to befriend young Miss Mouse. The story continues as Sonoma goes out of her way to help small Miss Mouse find food.
The way that Sonoma shows empathy towards Miss Mouse and is able to consider the world from Miss Mouse's viewpoint would prove to be a good discussion point for young readers. The theme of friendship is strong throughout as Sonoma offers her friendship unconditionally but is greatly rewarded in return by Miss Mouse.
The illustrator, Julie Sydenham, displays her strength in working with colour and texture through the beautiful illustrations that accompany the text. The dark colour palette features rich purples and blues with pops of orange and pastel highlights.
Children will enjoy this book being read aloud to them and will fall in love with kind Sonoma and whimsical Miss Mouse. It is a good prompt for discussions about being caring to others as well as giving and receiving help. I can imagine this becoming a favourite at bed time.
Stephanie Bell

A secret safe to tell by Naomi Hunter

cover image

Ill. by Karen Erasmus. JoJo Publishing, 2014. ISBN 9780987587916.
'He said I would get into BIG TROUBLE if I told anyone... I never wanted to be bad.'
'He said I would UPSET a lot of people if they knew what I had done... I didn't want to make anyone cry'
'He made hurts in places where Band-Aids could not reach... '
'I tried to heal the pain but I wasn't strong enough.'
'I thought about TELLING... but he said I'd be a LIAR... and no one would ever believe me.
One in five children will be sexually assaulted in some way before their 18th birthday.
I remember being told that stark fact at a staff meeting in 1990 and, like many of my colleagues, didn't really understand it, let alone grasp its reality. That sort of thing didn't happen to kids at our school, to kids we knew. But as we undertook courses in protective behaviours and mandatory reporting the reality started to hit. Sadly, it would seem that nearly 25 years later the statistics haven't changed according to Bravehearts but the awareness has. Sadly, given the Royal Commission and the prosecution of some high profile personalities, it is clear that this does happen to kids in our school and kids we know. But, because of that Royal Commission and those prosecutions, there is a greater awareness of the problem and children are finding the courage to tell and adults are taking the time to listen.
A secret safe to tell, written by someone whose dedication makes it plain that she was a victim, is a step in helping empower young children to tell, and if the first person doesn't listen then keep on telling until someone does. Tenderly capturing the thoughts and emotions of someone who has been abused - 'My heart felt BROKEN. ... I think it started to CHANGE COLOUR' - this story will speak to the child and perhaps give them the courage to speak too, so they too can break his power and swing HIGH into the sky where his hands cannot reach. At the end of the book there is a list of numbers a child can call and know there is someone who will listen and act on what they have to say.
On September 12, Bravehearts will host its annual White Balloon Day and is asking the question, 'Who are you protecting?' (#whoRUprotecting) and encouraging each of us to snap a #whoRUprotecting selfie: Answer the question 'who are you protecting' by writing a name on your palm and display the answer in a photograph.
When Tom from Int Books sent me this book to review, I read it and put it aside knowing there would be a perfect time to share it. This is that time. Difficult though this subject may be and difficult though this review has been, the children in your school deserve to have access to this book - you just never know whose life it might change.
Barbara Braxton

Magisterium: The Iron Trial by Cassandra Clare and Holly Black

cover image

Doubleday, 2014. ISBN 9780857532503.
(Ages: 11+) Themes: Magic, Family, Boarding Schools, Disability, Orphans, Grief/Loss, Good v Evil. The Iron Trial is the first book in a new series which will appeal to middle school readers who love Harry Potter. Unfortunately, some reviewers are already casting it in a negative light because of its similarity to the Rowling books, however, it does have enough differences to make it worth a read.
Callum Hunt is a broken boy. Physically, as a baby his leg was twisted beyond repair, so now at 12, he limps and is considered weak by his peers and his teachers. But there is also damage to his psyche. He's been traumatised by his mother's death, which happened at the same time as his leg was ruined. His father has raised him to hide his magical ability, and even as he is about to sit for the examination that will allow him to enter The Magisterium, he knows his father's expectations - Cal must fail.
All this is set up in the first few chapters. It's clearly aimed at middle graders, but since we know there is a plan for five books, each one following Cal through a year at the school, we can predict a couple of things: Cal will grow up and age, and developmentally so too will his readers. And I am betting the books will progress into darker territory.
There is a range of supporting characters, and we don't know who to trust. The narrative moves at a reasonable pace. There are clues left scattered so readers can foreshadow horrible masters, jealous peers and potential love interests. Due to his impairment, Cal is used to being treated badly and left alone. But he never uses his limp as an excuse. He wants to be given the same opportunities as everyone else, and it is gratifying to see him find some friends and start to feel a part of a group.
There are a couple of unexpected, but welcome plot twists. They are probably signposted a little too obviously, but for readers who simply get caught up in the story, and don't question motives or hints, the story does play out unpredictably.
Okay, back to Harry Potter. I know people bemoan how derivative some books are, but I have to say I have kids in my library who still call Harry their favourite read, and are searching out for something similar. The Iron Trial might just fill that void.
I found it absorbing and tense, especially the concluding chapters.
Trisha Buckley