Reviews

My name is Lizzie Flynn: A story of The Rajah quilt by Claire Saxby

cover image

Ill. by Lizzy Newcomb. Black Dog, 2015. ISBN 9781922179913
(Age: Primary and Secondary) Highly recommended. Picture book. Historical. Convicts. Resilience. Quilts. Based on the true story of a quilt made by convict women on board The Rajah, bound for Australia. Young Lizzie Flynn, sentenced for seven years transportation to Van Diemen's Land for stealing a shawl, arrives on the ship, The Rajah with nothing and knows that she will never return to England. She meets Molly another young convict who takes her under her wing. On board The Rajah, the female convicts are each given a bag, containing a bible, fabric and needle and thread. This has been supplied by the Ladies of the Convict Ship Committee, who when discovering that the convict women and girls had nothing to occupy themselves with on the long sea voyage thought that it would be helpful for them to have something useful to do. Lizzie has a good eye for colour but doesn't know how to sew and Molly teaches her.
This book is a fascinating look at transportation and convict life aboard a ship. The story is told in Lizzie's words and the horror of the trip comes to life as the reader follows the dangerous voyage. With Saxby's descriptive and emotional prose and Lizzy Newcomb's illustrations, it is easy to see the convict women and girls' lives in the hold, how vulnerable girls have to endure bullying, all the while facing storms and the deadly threat of disease. Lizzie says 'I do not want to pass from this world as if I had never been here', and continues to stitch the quilt for Molly as well as herself.
There is a gorgeous photo of the quilt, now housed in the National Gallery of Australia in Canberra, at the back as well as the inscription on it and information about what happened to it. According to an article found on Trove the quilts that the convict women made would have a ready sale and would help to provide them with much needed funds when they arrived in Australia.
I have returned to this picture book a number of times. It is a fascinating story in itself, and the scope for learning about convict life, the dangerous voyage to Australia and the work of Elizabeth Fry and other women make it ideal for using in Australian history lessons.
Pat Pledger

Life or death by Michael Robotham

cover image

Sphere, 2015. ISBN 9780751552898
(Age: Upper secondary to adult) Highly recommended. Crime fiction. USA. Capital punishment. Corruption. Robotham will please his wide audience yet again with this tightly plotted, explosively written novel as Audie Palmer, a ten year prisoner in a hell hole in Texas decides to escape the day before his release. His journey drags us through the events of his life bringing us up to the day he escapes and the reasons behind it. Along the way, another prisoner, a lifer who befriended Palmer in jail, is released by a powerful group of men to find Palmer and hand him over. The corruption is palpable, Moss must not only watch his own back and find Palmer, but also work out why Palmer is so necessary to these people's plans and how he can keep them both alive. The botched theft of seven million dollars, eleven years before, left Palmer in a life and death coma, but pulling through he admitted the crime and was sent to jail. But this money was never recovered, so many people are after it. And of course, as with all good crime stories, the hero is a hero, not the villain he is portrayed and we know that he is not what he appears. All is tied up with his family and a stepson he vowed to care for, now adopted by the very sheriff who arrested Palmer in the first place. Layers of coincidence pile on each other as links between powerful law officers and state politicians crowd into the story, making the reader assess, try out then throw aside theory after theory about what is actually happening. It is a rivetting read, one that carried me along its whole length to the nail biting conclusion.
The setting is part of the story with small isolated pockets of civilisation and the sad people he met a necessary part of Palmer's life on the run, while the corruption within the police force and their methods of law enforcement made me shudder. I was involved from page one.
Fran Knight

The Evertree by Marie Lu

cover image

Spirit animals bk 7. Scholastic Australia, 2015. ISBN 9781743620045
Finally, the last in the Spirit animals series where the fate of Erdas will be revealed, not to mention that of the amazing four young protagonists who have endured so much since they discovered their spirit animals were the famous Fallen Ones. As the series ends there is an even stronger message that the survival of our world depends on a balance between man, the animals and the environment.
The Greencloaks have gathered their allies for a final battle as Conor is beset by visions of a final confrontation with Kovo and the Conquerors. The outcome is uncertain and there is fear that their spirit animals may not survive this battle. Melin is still imprisoned by the power of Gerathon whilst still hoping that her friends will succeed in their quest.
On their way to stop Shane setting Kovo free, they travel through the dry devastated and desolate lands of Stetriol, all the time battling the strange weather and armies of Conquerors. They are also hoping also to find Tellun the Elk, last of the Great Beasts who has yet to surrender his talisman, and enlist his help.
Too late to stop Kovo escaping, they head to The Evertree, the legendary place where all life began, for a last stand against the power hungry Kovo and his allies Gerathon and Halawir. With all the great beasts present and willing to save Erdas at all costs it is up to Tellun and the children to succeed in their final battle.
As with the other books in the series there is hardship, bloody battles, death and destruction interspersed with moments of tenderness and beauty as the power of friendship helps overcome even the darkness of the Bile. The final act of forgiveness in letting Shane escape is not without its reward with a spinoff three part novella series by Nick Eliopulos in e-book form available, telling his side of the story.
Sue Keane

You choose (series) by George Ivanoff

cover image

Random House Australia Children's, 2015.
Night of the creepy carnival. Bk 5. ISBN 9780857986696
Alien invaders from beyond the stars. Bk 6. ISBN 9780857986719
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. When I received my first copies of books from this series I road tested them on my grandson who is somewhat of a reluctant reader. In fact, he was staying at my place, picked them up and didn't put them down until he'd finished each. To me that's a pretty fair indication of how they will be received in your library. These latest two have gone to another young man who might enjoy them and I await his response eagerly. I know I'm pretty hopeless - I couldn't get past 3 choices until I was exterminated so I hope he does better!
George has cleverly taken all the great aspects of gaming and transformed them into book form where readers can challenge themselves to achieve the end goal. While primarily aimed at Middle Primary to Upper Primary these can be enjoyed by readers of all ages and certainly, if you have readers who struggle these would be a superb choice as the level of engagement and the appeal of the subject matter are perfect. Readers will persist with their reading quite naturally as they attempt to navigate their way through all the pitfalls of each story.
Clowns are considered very sinister in our family so the Night of the creepy carnival is well named and I didn't like being caught out by them at all! Aliens are marginally less scary but still enough to appeal to those readers who like a good safe fright.
I remember so well how my own girls used to love the 'choose your own adventure' format (especially The famous five series!) and think the timing of bringing this style of fast paced interactive reading back to the attention of a new readership is perfect.
Highly recommended for readers aged around 9 and up. Do you have what it takes?
Sue Warren

The toy fairy by Stephanie Thatcher

cover image

Starfish Bay Publishing, 2015. ISBN 9780994100733
(Age: Preschool-6) Recommended. Compassion. Selfishness. A young boy who does not tidy his room before he goes to bed is warned that the toy fairy will take them away. The worldly-wise young man is sceptical about this explanation, believing his father to be complicit in the disappearance. Eventually (after toys do indeed disappear), the young lad sees the toy fairy in person and is himself 'stolen' by the toy fairy. After rediscovering his missing toys, he is then relocated with his missing pirate ship to a home of a classmate who is living with no toys. The experience awakens compassion in the boy.
This book is beautifully illustrated and the discussion possibilities of addressing selfishness and caring for others could make this a good book to include in Values Education. It is suited to Preschool or Junior Primary children.
Carolyn Hull

Teacup by Rebecca Young

cover image

Ill. by Matt Ottley. Scholastic, 2015. ISBN 9781743623848
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Journeys, Friendship, Sea, Refugees. One day the boy sets out in his boat. He must leave and takes a teacup of soil with him to remind him of home. He sails across the ocean, through storms and calm seas, times when it is blackly dark, or when the sky is full of cloud. He sees animals in the water below him. The albatross reminds him of flying a kite, the whales' songs remind him of his mother calling him for tea. He is searching for land. During his voyage his teacup of soil sprouts an apple tree which gives him food, shade, rest and a vantage point. Finally he finds land and is able to plant his tree, and wait for the girl to arrive with her eggcup and pear tree.
The illustrations for this story are superb, Ottley's depiction of the sea in all of its moods, scary and charming at the same time. The stormy days feel cold and threatening, the calmer days give solace and comfort. Most of the time the child in the boat feels safe as will the readers of this story, wanting to know why he is there and where he is going. All sorts of ideas will spring to mind, especially with Ottley's addition of things in the background of the pages: a range of animals and toys, both fanciful and real, the huge tree with a boat stuck in its branches, the girl finding her way to the island as well. Each image suggests answers to the puzzling story and readers will love to muse on what is happening.
A story of new beginnings, of hope for the future, of friendship, of adversity will appeal to those adventurous children ready to broaden their imaginations and think about ideas.
Fran Knight

Because you'll never meet me by Leah Thomas

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2015. ISBN: 9781408862629
(Age: 11+) Recommended for able readers. Themes: Disabilities; Coming of age; Genetic experimentation; Science fiction; Friendship; Bullying; Loneliness. In this well-written debut novel by Leah Thomas, the two central characters write to one another to overcome the isolation of their lives that are debilitated by unusual physical conditions. Ollie lives a virtual electricity-free existence with his mother, isolated from the community around him because of his 'allergy' to all things electrical (we discover later, that his condition influences him negatively, but that he impacts electrical devices too). He is quirky and honest, and makes an effort to be positive in all things; his life has always been in this non-electric bubble - no phones, television, internet, so effectively he is living a virtual-Amish lifestyle. Initially there is only one visitor - a medico-scientist who links him to another teen living in Germany, to whom he connects honestly via letters. The German teen, Moritz, was born with no eyes and yet is able to 'see' using echo-location, he also has a Pacemaker to overcome his cardio-myopathy. His angst and distress with his life is expressed honestly and with some pathos as he deals with a school bully and his social isolation. Ollie and Moritz will never meet . . . the electricity from the pace-maker would be mutually destructive and their differing perspectives of life are impacted by their culture and experience, so initially the 'friendship' appears to be completely one-sided.
When Ollie is visited by a local girl, Liz, whose friendship changes him, he shares the impact of her life and 'spark' into his life with Moritz. Tragedies happen for both boys, but eventually the history of some 'experimentation' that has created their unusual physical expressions becomes the focus of the book as Moritz reveals the drama of their shared history.
The circumstances of this book are not realistic, but the characters express real emotional responses to difficult circumstances, and their normal teenage concerns will connect with a young adult readership. Readers who enjoy John Green fiction will enjoy this book. It has light-hearted moments, and pathos, and although the circumstances are not real, it is easy to identify with the two lonely and isolated teens and empathise with their pain, but also to see that there is some hope for their future.
Carolyn Hull

The cloudspotter by Tom McLaughlin

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2015. ISBN 9781408854969
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Clouds, Imagination, Daydreams, Friendship. Franklin is a cloudspotter. He spends the day with his binoculars and backpack spotting all the clouds in the sky. He imagines them to be all sorts of things and then imagines himself to be part of them, in them, on them or driving them. One day a scruffy dog begins to hang around Franklin. Franklin has no friends and decides that he does not need any so when the dog stays around more often, becoming part of his daydreams, he does something about it. He makes a hot air balloon and puts the dog into the basket and sees him off.
But he soon realises that he misses the dog, the dog had become his friend. Fortunately the air balloon snags on a tree and the two are reunited. They can now watch the clouds together and have adventures together.
This is a lovely story of friendship, of not seeing a friend nearby until it is almost too late, of doing things together.
I loved the soft illustrations, conjuring up the feel and look of various clouds in the sky, drawing them to suggest the images the child sees in them.
As a lovely tale of friendship or as an introduction to a group of lessons about clouds and their formation, or lessons outside looking at clouds this book will prove to be most helpful.
Fran Knight

Dragonfall Mountain by Paul Collins and Sean McMullen

cover image

The Warlock's Child bk 2. Ford Street, 2015. ISBN 9781925000931
(Ages: 10+) Fantasy. Following on immediately from the first in the series and beginning in the middle of a battle, it is wise to have read the first book which introduced the main characters, including the dragon, with suggestions of unknown forces at play, magic and traitors yet to be discovered.
Dantar, the son of Dravinian Battle Warlock Calbaras is heading to shore having been flung from his sinking ship. He is captured by the Savarian sailors and set to work cleaning the prison castle believing his status as an officer will keep him safe.
Dantar's sister Velza, having also escaped as the Dravinian fleet is destroyed by the Savarians with a little help from the marauding dragon, is determined to rally the survivors and continue their mission to destroy the port.
The death of the dragon Dravaud, Calabaras alive and well and seemingly welcome in the Savarian castle, and the reappearance of Marko who assists Dantar to escape via the sewers, add to the action and intrigue. The confrontation between more dragons and the King leaves the reader anxious for the next instalment to find out who 'the creatures of forbidden magic' are dangling from the dragon's claws, and what is really going on in this word of power, treachery and magic.
Once again there are more questions than answers but the easy to read, fast paced text keeps the reader interested as alternate chapters follow the fortunes of Dantar and Velza telling the story from their different situations and viewpoints.
Sue Keane

Escape from Wolfhaven Castle by Kate Forsyth

cover image

The impossible quest series. Scholastic, 2015. ISBN 9781743624067
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Historical, Fantasy, Bravery. This highly detailed novel, the first in a series of five, introduces four characters quickly: Tom, the pot boy in the kitchen of the castle, the squire, Sebastian, Eleanor, daughter of the lord, and Quinn the witch's apprentice. When their castle is infiltrated by bog-men, the four flee before they too are captured or killed. This unlikely crew must work together to survive, even of Elanor has been brought up on books of courtly manners befitting her station, and the knight in waiting israther too aware of his station in life, while Quinn has not yet got all her powers, their rubbing together makes great reading as they must overcome some great impasses.  
Brimming with medieval setting of knights and battles, rush floors and castles, the story is easily read, moves along very quickly and grabs at the readers' throats as the four must overcome some very odd difficulties.
The Grand Teller at Wolfhaven gives them all a gift which can be used in emergencies and as they leave their birth place, they find that these gifts are not the stuff of folk lore but actually help them.
With Tom's dog, Fergus making up the five, they learn their way around each other, showing bravery against all odds and learning above all to survive. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and look forward to the next in the series.
Fran Knight

The Burning Sea by Paul Collins and Sean McMullen

cover image

The Warlock's Child bk 1. Ford Street, 2015. ISBN 9781925000924
(Ages 10-14) Fantasy. This is the first of new fantasy series written in collaboration by two well known writers who are adept at building a fantasy world where dragons and magic are commonplace. Students will recognise the cover art by Marc McBride from the Deltora Quest covers and accompanied books.
Lazily circling above an invasion fleet of Dravinian ships, Drvaud the dragon is aware of a hint of something dragon-like on board one of the ships. For Dantar life as a cabin boy is not easy, especially as the son of the Emperor's Battle Warlock, bought up in the royal palace. His older sister Velza is a very competent officer who is keen to prove herself in the male dominated world of the navy.
As the fleet draws closer to Savaria there appears to be someone prepared to sabotage the success of the invasion as Dantar overhears talk of traitors and a fire is lit in the oil store. When the fog bank that they had been sailing behind disperses, their element of surprise is lost. With their secret weapon, the Deathlight which employs mirrors and the sun's rays to set fire to the sails, the Savarians attack.
Survival seems impossible for Dantar, who cannot swim, as he is flung into the ocean but the timely arrival of Velza and a piece of drift wood, fill him with hope as he heads towards shore.
The scene is set for the next book in the six part series with more questions raised than answers given. This is a good example for getting readers to predict what will happen next, and with a short time frame between each book's release, there will be a ready audience for book two.
Sue Keane

Skink No Surrender by Carl Hiaasen

cover image

Orion Children's Books, 2014. ISBN 9781780622194
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Themes: Internet dangers; Environmental issues; Adventure. A young teen meets an unusual environmental warrior while waiting on the beach for his cousin who is due to go away to boarding school. This girl does not show up and eventually it is revealed that she has run away with someone she met on the internet. The environmental warrior who lives as a virtual hermit, but who is also a returned soldier and former governor and is also apparently 'dead', decides to help Richard find his cousin. They embark on an amazingly risky search through the alligator populated swamps and rivers of Florida.
This is an exciting rescue and although it stretches believability on many occasions, is still an engaging adventure story. Hiaasen introduces environmental themes that are linked loosely through the story, with references to a presumed extinct woodpecker and the protection of loggerhead turtles laying their eggs on the beach.
Carolyn Hull

Operation Code-Cracker by John Townsend

cover image

Black Cats Series. Bloomsbury, 2015. ISBN 9781472906816
(Age: 8-10) Recommended. Themes: Codes, Spies, Mystery, Adventure. The Black Cats series written by popular British authors targets the newly confident and high interest-low reading age audience. The chapters are shorter, some illustrations are included and the novels are structured to build reading confidence.
John Townsend's Operation Code-Cracker is filled with spies, action, adventure, clues, codes and car-chases. Max is staying with his father in his old run-down house in London. When his football disappears into the neighbour's yard, Max is caught up in a spy network. The creepy man Max calls The Child Catcher has been watching the father and son, knows all their routines and recruits the ten year old boy to help in a situation of national security. The reader is drawn into the action with codes and puzzles to solve, Max's special skills help to save the situation. Max enlists his Gran's help they hop in her pink Morris Minor convertible, and race across London to save Miya who has been kidnapped. A surprising ending brings this story to a thrilling conclusion.
Rhyllis Bignell

A Wonderlandiful World by Shannon Hale

cover image

Ever After High Series. Hachette, 2015. ISBN 9780349131870
(Age: 9-12) Shannon Hale's Ever After High trilogy comes to an exciting conclusion in A Wonderlandiful World. This fairytale world is filled with aptly named, colourful characters, overflowing with fairy puns and unique language. With embellished borders and flowery phrases, themes of good and evil, magic and mayhem, this is definitely a story the fans will enjoy.
This story shifts the focus to the Wonderland characters, Maddie Hatter, Lizzie Hearts, Kitty Cheshire and Cedar Wood who is Pinocchio's daughter. There is a mysterious force overpowering Ever After High and everything is badly affected. The evil Jabberwocky has been released from prison and is determined to destroy Ever After. As the Ever After students magically change into objects - Apple White's face turns rosy red and a branch sprouts out of the top of her head, the Wonderland characters become real - Cedar's body transforms from wooden to human. Other students change into animals, the furniture comes alive and the school grounds fade to black and white. There are mad chases, unexpected events and even the Narrator has problems continuing the story. Maddie is forced to become the narrator and her friends are caught up in the evil magic, as this fast-paced and crazy adventure comes to a surprising end.
For fairy tale fans from 9-12.
Rhyllis Bignell

Better Nate Than Ever by Tim Federle<br>

cover image

Walker Books, 2015. ISBN: 9781406361537
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. The warmth and humour of the main character, Nate, make this book a really great read that will appeal to all ages.
Nate, has big aspirations, but is trapped in a small town. His best friend, Libby helps him plan an escape to Broadway where he hopes to make his dreams come true by winning a role in a musical version of ET. This story waltzes you along with the adorable Nate and surreptitiously feeds the back story of love, relationships, family, forgiveness and hope.
The story gently and thoughtfully touches on the small town response to a young man who wants to sing on Broadway.
'My sexuality, by the way, is off-topic and unrelated. I am undecided. I am a freshman at the College of Sexuality and I have undecided my major, and frankly don't want to declare anything other than "Hey jerks, I'm thirteen, leave me alone. Macaroni and cheese is still my favorite food - how would I know who I want to hook up with?"
The reader can't help smiling and laughing and completely relating to the main character, Nate, as he bravely negotiates New York City and the cut throat world of Broadway auditions, ably supported by Libby, Freckles and Heidi.
Linda Guthrie