Reviews

Sue Lawson, Blending reality and fiction: an interview by Fran Knight

cover image

Sue Lawson, a children's writer of some twenty books, is in Adelaide for a month, writing and editing her latest novel.
The May Gibbs Children's Literature Trust has awarded Sue the time away from home, a time to just write. To this end she is working on her current novel, one set in 1965, concerning the Freedom Ride of Aboriginal people in their demand for equality in Australia.
Having just written a non fiction about protests, to be published by Black Dog Books early next year in the Our Stories series, Sue has created a fictional story about the 1965 incident which will expose the times for young adult readers. This tale she is fleshing out during the fellowship in Adelaide as well as putting the finishing touches to the Our Stories book.
Like several other of her books, the mixture of fact and fiction encapsulates a time which is real for the reader. Finding Darcy (2008)used her knowledge as a researcher of an unknown family member to recreate a story of one young girl researching the man in the photograph at her Gran's house, someone never spoken of. The book not only gives the reader an involving account of a deed in Australia's past where a Japanese prisoner of war ship was sunk by an American submarine, killing all those on board, but gives a riveting tale of one girl's search for her ancestor, finding herself as she ploughs more deeply into her family's history.
Similarly Forget me not (2012) is based on the small personal items seen at the Titanic exhibition in Melbourne in 2010. A story is woven around some of the small objects Sue saw at this exhibition, and while thinking that no one could write anything new about this incident, she saw the disaster from a fresh perspective.
Other books that Sue has written include the Diva series, a group of eight shorter novels for mid to upper primary readers about a group of girls and their efforts to win the competition for young talent. Friendships and fallings out, high fashion and family relationships all figure in this well received series, published first in 2006, and republished in 2010. And the amazing, You Don't Even Know (2013) about a young adult critically injured after a walking under a bus, sharing a room with a terminally ill cancer patient, is based upon Sue's own bout with cancer and knowledge of hospital wards.
A longer article about Sue Lawson and her work has been written for Magpies (2015), and her website gives more information about Sue and her writing.

Meanjin Crossing by Ian Hamilton

cover image

Xlibris,2014. ISBN 97814909006094
(Age: Senior secondary - adult) This is a story is about the thread that binds us to past and place. For Will, the narrator, it is a thread back to his city's earliest white settlement. This, he relates through the reading of his manuscript to his old friend Mary. In it we hear the story of Jabiru, or Jacky, as the white men call him. Initially his coming to manhood and visit to the Bora Ring, which fascinated Will as a young boy and thence his wandering life. He develops some friendships, in particular with James Bolan, one of the more reasonable and compassionate early settlers.
But this is also the story, even a memoir of Will's life. His childhood in a place he later calls 'a hole called Brisbane' p71, his escape to London and the eventual realisation that no matter how long he stayed, it was a place 'he'd never be part of' p71. And like Jabiru he eventually returns to the place of his birth.
In the present, he visits his old friend who is now suffering from cancer and together they reminisce about a life of fun in the 60s, which Hamilton reveals with accuracy.
That Hamilton knows his place is evident in the plethora of street and place names which so abound in this novel and anyone who has even just visited Brisbane will recognise many of them. But this is integral to the thread of the story. Some places have remained: those physical aspects which Jabiru also gazed upon and those which belong firmly in the modern day but are a strong part of Will's history.
Hamilton also invites the reader to reflect 'about how all our lives are journeys and that they all come to an end' p168, but through his narrative suggesting that perhaps there is still a part that carries on.
Meanjin Crossing clearly recreates a sense of time and place, of innocence and experience but does not lapse into the maudlin or self indulgent. It is just what happened.
Barb Rye

We Were Liars By Emily Lockhart

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781760111069
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. This well written page turner chronicles a distinguished family, the Sinclairs, from the point of view of Cadence Sinclair Eastman. The 'lies', skilfully rendered from the very first page continue through to the unexpected and disturbing revelations in the ending.
Cadence's voice is imaginative in its very compelling turn of phrase that can be both shocking and unexpected. It is difficult at times to determine whether Cadence is lying, hallucinating, or mentally unwell:
'My father put a last suitcase into the backseat of the Mercedes (he was leaving Mummy with only the Saab) and started the engine. Then he pulled out a hand gun and shot me in the chest. I was standing on the lawn and I fell. The bullet hole opened wide and my heart rolled out of my rib cage and down into a flower bed.'
Cadence unveils the joys and sorrows that befall the Sinclair family as they pass their summers on a private island (Beechwood Island) in Massachusetts. Cadence, Johnny, Mirren, and Gat refer to themselves as 'the liars' and as their story develops Cadence tries to fill the two year gap in her memory caused by an injury she cannot recall.
This work is highly recommended as not only a great read but also as a literary text. The author has invited opportunities to discuss and compare her novel with Wuthering Heights,King Lear, and fairy tales involving daughters. In the novel Cadence states 'I do not suffer fools', yet the book leaves the reader struggling to process the consequences of a tragedy derived from a foolish act and this will provoke a range of perspectives and opinions in the reader.
The E. Lockhart website provides links to support materials, a video of Emily reading the opening to the book, and a tumblr page of images.
Linda Guthrie

Belzhar by Meg Wolitzer

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2014. ISBN: 9781471123764
If life was fair for Jam Gallahue she would still be living at home with her parents and spending time with her British boyfriend, Reeve Maxfield. But life isn't fair. Reeve is dead and Jam is sent off to the Wooden Barn, a therapeutic boarding school. Jam is placed in Special Topics in English where the previous students placed in this class are miraculously stable once more. Jam and four other students are the only people to be enrolled in this class and given journals that they are to write in everyday. Jam must face her past and the mysteries that are hidden there.
I found it difficult to read Belzhar and even harder to actually keep reading except for the fact that I really wanted to know what happen to Reeve and see if Jam would get better. I felt for Jam, really I did, but I could not sympathise with her. I did love the way Wolitzer wrote the relationships with the fellow students and Jam at the boarding school and that made the book in my opinion.
Cecilia Richards

Possum Games by Michelle Worthington

cover image

Ill. by Sandra Temple. Rhiza Press, 2014. ISBN 9781925139136
(Age: Early childhood) Every night, on a rusty tin roof the possum family hold The Possum Games. They jump, run, hop and skip, have a tug-of-war, strap soap to their feet to slide down the roof and play all sorts of ball games using mangoes and melons, until the stars fade and it's time to pack away the trophies and medals till the next night . . . What fun they have. All except Riley. He is the youngest and the shyest and he can't keep up. The noise frightens him and when it comes to needing a partner, he never has one. Even in team games he isn't very good. Until one night the humans emerge from their house bleary eyed and not in the mood for fun. Suddenly, Riley finds what he is good at and invents a whole new game in the process!
Miss 3 loved this story when I shared it with her. She empathised with Riley because she knows what it's like to try to keep up with her older sister and cousins. Even though they are very patient with her and include her in everything, just as Riley's family includes him, there are times when being three and little just aren't quite enough.
The beautiful illustrations by Sandra Temple are in a style that is realistic without being too "biological" for this audience (she is a wildlife artist and has won a number of awards for her work) and the expressions on the possums' faces and the humour in their actions really bring the text to life. Every picture of Riley mirrors that of a young child wanting to be part of the action but now quite there yet. (You can have a sneak peek at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z3IRZcftyMU)
However, apart from the charm of the story for the story's sake, there is also an opportunity for a conversation about including everyone in activities and introducing the concept of compassion. How do you think Riley feels? Is it more important to win a trophy or make sure that everyone has some fun? Can everyone be the best at everything or do we all have things we are not-so-good at? Children know their strengths and weaknesses and those of their siblings and peers and they are quick to apply negative labels to others so they can build their own self-esteem. But those labels can stick long after they've been applied. This could be opportunity to help them look for the positives in others so even the Rileys feel comfortable about joining in - even if "the watermelon splatters in soft red chunks" when they try to catch it! A great story for all those who would like to be a teensy bit older!
Barbara Braxton

Plenty by Ananda Braxton-Smith

cover image

Black Dog Books, 2014. ISBN 9781742032429
I would highly recommend this novel for competent readers from 9 -12 years. Themes: Identity, Family life, Friendship, Dementia, Fairies, Botany. Ten year old Maddie's life is ordered, she is the Keeper of the Street, Queen of the back Lane and Friend to Dogs. She loves her life, her school and has wonderful friends, including Sophie Rose, who has been a friend since birth. Her eleventh birthday celebrations are marred by her parents revelation they are moving to the country. Maddie's world, her stability, her identity, her friendships are all under threat. Written with a depth of understanding about the feelings of homelessness, Ananda Braxton-Smith gives Maddie's feelings of anger, isolation and disbelief a powerful voice.
Their move to the small town of Plenty, on the slopes of Mount Disappointment on a road called the Deviation is a difficult adjustment for Maddie. Her Nana Mad's greenhouse and love for native orchids helps to slowly bring Maddie's life around. Her new friendship with Grace a Sudanese refugee helps Maddie transition as well.
This novel is a wonderfully rich, honest portrayal of a young girl's search for identity. Her feelings of anger, upheaval and uncertainty as well as love and are written with real insight. Underpinning the narrative are the gentle stories of magic, belief in fairies, aboriginal dreaming and the stories of the formation of the constellations. Grace's story of her acceptance of life in a Sudanese refugee camp and Maddie's mother's story of fleeing from the war in Cyprus add depth to the themes of identity and our place in the world. Nana Mad's dementia and the way her family copes with her illness are also written with a special empathy. Teacher's notes are available.
Rhyllis Bignell

Crash by Sean Williams

cover image

Twinmaker series, bk 2. Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743316474
(Age: 16+) This sequel to Jump sees Clair Hill infamous - as the girl who killed d-mat. D-mat is the technology that can create, replicate and teleport any object (clothes, food, humans) and that not only eliminated famine and pollution but was also permitting self-improvement and enhancement.
Clair, a reluctant hero, is reunited with Jesse at a time where Earth is in crisis. Clair is conflicted by seemingly incompatible (pro- and anti-d-mat) philosophies that complicate her decisions and demand the taking of sides.
'Once the law makers and peacekeepers started dividing people up into different types, regardless of what they had done, couldn't people then get away with anything just as long as they belonged to the right type?'
Claire is caught between Peacekeepers, dupes, RADICAL (activist group) and WHOLE (anti-d-mat terrorist group) who all have their own agendas and are intent on capturing Q (an artificial intelligence) to achieve their ends. Claire struggles with ethical and moral dilemmas as the world around her erupts in violence and her life is put at risk.
Sean Williams presents an opportunity to explore the ethical and moral consequences of technological innovation and the use of violence. It lends itself to comparison with other novels (such as The giver) that explore societies that have eliminated aspects of our current society in the pursuit of a perfect and convenient life. Crash has its own Twitter hashtag (#crashland) that readers can follow and this sequel also attempts to present the challenges and benefits of a world of individuals linked in instant communication. There are no definitive answers given throughout the story, so there is scope for genuine philosophical discussion.
While the technologies discussed in the novel are not part of our current scientific landscape, the Baikal Superdeep Borehole and Mesaieed (Qatar) are places mentioned in the novel that do exist. Mesaieed will host the World Cup 2022.
The Twinmaker website allows fans of this series to learn more about the books, comment on blogs and enter competitions.
Linda Guthrie

Amelie and Nanette: Snowflakes and fairy wishes by Sophie Tilley

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408836644
(Age: Preschool - Yr 2) Best friends Amelie and Nanette are really looking forward to Christmas. Together they make paper chains, write Christmas cards, wrap presents, make yummy scrummy snowflake fairy cakes and decorate the tree. But even better than doing all those things that mean Christmas is coming, is doing them with your best friend. The girls are so busy that they don't notice that it is snowing, but when they do discover it they're outside in a flash having so much fun making the biggest snowman, jumping and rolling around in it, throwing snowballs and making snow angels. Nanette is so excited that she goes out without her winter woolly warms on. And sadly, instead of making her fairy costume for the school Christmas play, she ends up in bed with a cold, too sick to take part in anything. But what are best friends for?
This is an enchanting story about friendship and the joy of having a best friend. Tilley's illustrations are as gentle and subtle as the story offering a package that all young children will relate to. Why can't you put cardboard antlers on your dog when you're in need of a reindeer?
This book is about what really is the true meaning of Christmas - celebrating love and friendship and being there for those who really matter. And with other Amelie and Nanette stories coming (Sparkly shoes and picnic parties) the girls are likely to become favourite characters of this age group.
Barbara Braxton

Corn field by Gary Crew

cover image

Ill. by Aaron Hill. Windy Hollow Books, 2014. ISBN 9781922081377
(Age: 10+) Recommended. Picture book for older readers. Fear. Bravado, Mystery. Mystery is too tame a word for the events Crew gives us in this eerie and unsettling story. Malevolence permeates every page as the narrator bribes his friend Micky into going into the cornfield with him. The narrator's father is a crop duster and owns a helicopter, which Micky would love to try out. Reminders are given about what happened to Reg Pinchly, another friend from school who approached the field and was never the same again. And as they move closer to the centre of the field, they spy a scarecrow with a scythe. Spooked already, the sight of this image scares the two of them and they try and run out of the field, with varying results.
The image of the boy on the first page sitting staring at the window is repeated at the end, but this time the glass is shattered. Hints abound in the story of being unbalanced, of being an object in a glass jar, of being watched and spied upon.
The illustrations add another stunning dimension to the story: with its cut out pieces, some images cut up and placed back together inexpertly, of thought bubbles with no words, of images sometimes seeming like they are seen through misty glass. All underline the supernatural elements of the story, adding tantalising ideas which could explain what is going on. Or maybe not. Whatever the tale, the whole is mesmerising, enfolding the reader into a story with hints of what it is about, forcing the reader to produce a story of their own based on the scant evidence given. The text and illustrations serve up a tantalising dish of maybes and what ifs to ponder.
Fran Knight

Mix it up! by Herve Tullet

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781760110956
(Age: 3+) Warmly recommended. Painting. Colour. Interactive does not only apply to computers, as here is an interactive book to keep children amused for ages. Mixing colours by pressing on each page will enthrall, delight and inform as kids turn the pages of this book with solid covers and shiny paper filled with colour inside. The reader is asked to tap the first dot, and on turning the page finds a few coloured spots have appeared. Over the next few pages the reader is asked to tap again and more coloured spots appear. Then a hand outline covers the spots, and the readers will not be able to resist putting their hand on the page. Over the page again, more coloured dots appear and the reader is asked to mix them, each time finding a new colour appears after mixing one or two colours. Not only is the child having fun with the pages of the book, but they are learning how colours mix to make other colours. A fun time will be had reading through the book, and imaginations soar as they see the possibilities beyond the pages. Paper and paint will need to be available at the end of reading for them to further explore what they have leant and wish to discover.
The interactive nature of the book will enthrall younger readers, who without knowing it will absorb the names of colours and the idea of mixing colour to create another, and at the same time, follow instructions, a skill which is very handy for young people to learn.
Another book by Tulet, Press here! (2010), is just as fascinating in teaching children that books can be interactive and using this book will again encourage them to follow instructions.
Fran Knight

Meet Nancy Bird Walton by Grace Atwood

cover image

Ill. by Harry Slaghekke. Random House, 2014. ISBN 9780857983879. ISBN 9780857984883 ebk.
It seems amazing that less than 40 years ago a woman wanting to be a commercial pilot became the first sex discrimination in employment case contested before the Australian Equal Opportunity Board, and that it wasn't until 1980 that a female pilot took the controls of a commercial flight in Australia, albeit as a co-pilot on a Fokker F27 from Alice Springs to Darwin. What is even more amazing is that this was not a new scenario for this was Deborah Wardley fighting Ansett Airlines and Reg Ansett's belief that women were not suited to be airline pilots, not Nancy Bird Walton. Nancy Bird Walton had fought that battle nearly 50 years before that!
Born in 1915 in Kew NSW and growing up in what is known as the Golden Age of aviation as flying went from strength to strength from that first 'controlled, powered and sustained heavier-than-air human flight' in December 1903, Nancy Bird knew at a very early age that her destiny lay in the skies. Despite her father's disapproval she began having flying lessons at the age of 17 under legendary pilot Charles Kingsford Smith.
'My days went by in a sort of blur. I might have only 20 minutes in an aeroplane during the day but I went out to the aerodrome every morning and stayed there until the fading light put a stop to flying for the day.'
Such was her passion and determination, in 1934 she became the youngest female pilot to have a commercial licence in the British Commonwealth. Just a year later she flew from Melbourne to Adelaide in record time and went on to become known as the 'Angel of the Outback' for her work with the Far West Children's Health Scheme. During World War II she was the Commandant of the WATC and in 1950 founded the Australian Women's Pilots' Association - thirty years prior to Reg Ansett declaring that passengers felt safer with men; that pilots needed strength; that the unions would object; women's menstrual cycles would make them unsuitable; and that pregnancy and childbirth would interrupt their careers and create extra costs for the company.
Such an incredible life cannot be encapsulated in one 32-page picture book, but Grace Atwood and Harry Slaghekke have combined perfectly to create a wonderful insight into the first chapters of Nancy's early flying career. They examine her desire to know how planes fly and her willingness to do all the dirty mechanical jobs because everything she did taught her something new about them. They provide an insight into her fear as at last she is ready to fly solo and move on through getting her licence, buying her first plane - named Vincere meaning 'to conquer' - and her amazing flight covering 22 000 miles around NSW with her friend Peggy McKillop in the 'Ladies Flying Tour' to promote aircraft flying while using road maps, a compass and landmarks to guide them.
The Meet... series is a picture book series designed to celebrate extraordinary Australians who have shaped the country's history, and, in my opinion, this is the best of the series so far. Perhaps it's because Nancy Bird Walton has long been a hero of mine, but there is so much packed into this story, including a timeline, and the pictures are so evocative with their subtle colouring that I'm inspired to re-read Walton's two books Born to fly and My God! It's a woman which may be suitable for your biography collection.
As we look to introduce younger students to Australians who have had a significant impact on our lives, those featured in the Meet... series, and Nancy Bird Walton in particular, are very strong candidates. These sorts of biographies in their uncomplicated yet fact-filled format not only meet the reading needs of the newly-independent reader but can also support those who are older but struggling as well as whetting the appetite of others to investigate further. In the case of this one, it would also be the perfect springboard into examining attitudes towards women in a men's world and how they have changed - or not!
Barbara Braxton

The scarecrow's wedding by Julia Donaldson

cover image

Ill. by Axel Scheffler. Scholastic, 2014. ISBN 9781407144412
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Humour. Farms. Scarecrows. Betty O'Barely and Harry O'Hay invite you to their wedding. In rhyming stanzas with a repeating last couplet, the tale rolls along with a rollicking pace, a marvelous story to read aloud to small and large groups.
Harry and Betty make a list of what they will need for their wedding. Each of the items is ticked off as one by one they are gathered from their friends. The cows bring the bells, the geese give their feathers for the dress, the mice find two rings in the rubbish bin and the crab brings along a necklace of shells.
Harry goes off to find the last thing needed for their wedding, the pink flowers. Several animals help him find them, but the snail is so slow that Harry takes all day and night to get there. Meanwhile the farmer makes a new scarecrow to replace Harry. Reginald Rake spies Betty and woos her, but she remains true to Harry. When he arrives back with the flowers they have their wedding
'The best wedding ever, the best wedding yet,
The wedding that no one will ever forget'
with all the items made and brought by their friends.
Children will love the story and its bright illustrations. They will delight in looking for the things mentioned in the text and laugh at the different animals represented. And along the way learn something about hay and fire, as well as noting the play on words. The paper cover turned inside out presents a poster of the wedding day.
Fran Knight

Augustus and his smile by Catherine Rayner

cover image

Little Tiger Press, 2006. ISBN 9781845062835
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Tigers. Happiness. Perseverance. Award winning Rayner has done it again in this wonderful tale of a tiger searching for his smile. On waking the tiger finds he has lost his smile and so goes off to look for it. He searches high and low, the birds in the trees, the insects amongst the leaves on the ground, the fish in the sea, the sand in the desert, until finally it rains. The incessant rain fills puddles in the earth and at last he can see that he has a smile, and so is happy.
He has wandered across deserts and mountain ranges, across forests and seas, seen a multitude of animals, birds and fish, to find that it is all of these which make him happy. And he realises that happiness is everywhere.
A wide reaching tale of finding happiness wherever you are, reading this with children will fill their heads with delight as they see the scope of amazing things in our world, and marvel with the tiger as he finds that happiness is all around.
The illustrations with the swatches of colour overlaid with black ink representing the tiger and its stripes, are stunning. The tiger stalks across every page, sometimes partly hidden by the forest, sometimes climbing across a jagged mountain range, sometimes swimming with the fish. Rayner drew her tiger after watching and sketching the tigers at the Edinburgh Zoo, and this first hand experience is obvious to the reader as they delight in the different poses struck by the tiger on turning the pages.
At the end is information about the Siberian Tiger, an animal in danger through loss of habitat, and addresses are given for children to find out more information.
Fran Knight

Good night, me by Andrew Daddo

cover image

Ill. by Emma Quay. Hachette, 2015. ISBN 9780734415851
(Age: Toddler) Recommended. Board book. Night time. Sleep. Encouraging a small child to go to sleep is made easier with this reprint of Daddo's winning story of bed time. Used as the focus book in the 2006 National Simultaneous Storytime, Andrew's website gives information about how the story came to be.
The simplicity of its evolution is matched by the deceptive simplicity of its telling, as the child going to bed must say goodnight to each of its body parts. So goodnight is said to its feet, then knees, then legs, tummy and so on, until its nose is reached and then finally good night. Each part drops off to sleep shown beautifully by the pencil and watercolour illustrations, beginning with an enthusiastic moving child to one bedded down with a sheet over the top, ready to sleep until morning.
Reading this tale will encourage a child to hunker down with the story and be part of the illustrations as they go from movement to stillness, from alert to drowsy, then sleep.
The use of a baby orangutan is wonderful as young children will immediately be enthralled at the contrast of an animal and a baby, noting the clothing, the sheet and pillow. The illustrations give the story another level of interest to readers as the orangutan is shown in all sorts of poses in its bed.
First published in 2005, this publication as a board book will ensure it is read over and over again by the target audience.
Fran Knight

Sam and Dave dig a hole by Mac Barnett

cover image

Ill. by Jon Klassen. Walker Books, 2014. ISBN 9781406357769
(Age: 5+) Warmly recommended. Endeavour. Friendship. Quest. One day Sam and Dave decide to dig a hole. They set out with shovels and the dog, and begin their work to find something spectacular. They dig and dig, eventually digging a hole that is over their heads needing to stop for a break to drink their chocolate milk and animal biscuits. They decide to go sideways. Later they decide to split up and join later. Just when they are tired out, the dog digs, sensing a bone nearby and the trio falls down deeper and deeper until they are back in their garden.
The illustrations tell the story of their near misses, as they bypass large exciting looking precious stones time and time again. The little dog senses something is nearby but the boys keep on digging, taking no notice of his actions. Children will love watching the dog and the near misses, calling out to the boys in the story telling them what they cannot see. The mystery behind their quest and their attempts to find something spectacular will speak volumes to younger readers for whom adventures are what they have everyday. The fun of trying to find something wonderful drives them on, their dog with them, spectacularly more aware than they.
For children learning the concept of down and up, as well as sideways, this book is a treat, bringing in the idea of adventures, hidden gems and striving for something out of reach. The illustrations are magnificent, brown swathes of watercolour fill the page, with white patches contrasting with the colour of the earth. Astute younger readers will ponder the small differences between the last pages and those at the beginning of the book, and laugh out loud at the antics of the boy and the all knowing dog.
Fran Knight