Reviews

Come count with me! by Marika Wilson

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743313435
Come count with me! is the first picture book produced by Indigenous artist Marika Wilson. Published in conjunction with the Little Big Book Club it will be a popular book to share with younger preschoolers.
The joyous picture on the front cover of an older bird and a young chick dancing encourages the reader to meet the characters within. There is Nana, complete with spectacles, being encouraged to count with her young grandchild who is so proud he can count. But when Nana tries to count
'1,2, and 7,8, and 9?'
The chick is horrified!
'No! Nana! No!
You've got it all wrong... '
The little chick gives Nana a lesson in counting but when she still gets it wrong, he is angry,
'Nana! Nana!
Are you listening to me?'
But becomes more sympathetic as Nana reminds him of her age.
'I'll help you,
It was hard for me too, Nana.'
He proceeds to show her the numbers one to five culminating in the joyous picture from the cover as they dance around surrounded by five bees.
The simple stylised birds are full of character and love with the bright yellow of the chick and the more subdued colours of Nana washed over the ink outline.
This is a good introduction to counting for parents to share with their youngsters as they grasp the concept of numbers and one to one relationships. The parents will be amused by Nana's antics as she encourages her chick to teach her whilst he counts himself.
Sue Keane

Wrestling Trolls: The Giant Rumble by Jim Eldridge

cover image

Ill. By Jan Bielecki. Hot Key Books, 2014. ISBN 9781471402630
Whilst I am not a wrestling fan, I am a fan of the idea that students can see their suggestions, as strange and interesting as they can be, combined into a funny story and published by a successful author. What a great way to promote reading and writing!
The Giant Rumble is the third book in the Wrestling Trolls series but, as a story, easily stands alone. Written in collaboration with students contributing through 'The Story Adventure' website, the wild combination of characters and events featuring throughout add to the fantasy.
The Wrestling Trolls team, Big Rock, The Masked Avenger and their support team, Milo, Jack, Meenu and the horse Robin, are tricked by the villainous Lord Veto into a Giant Rumble with his Wrestling Orcs. Unfortunately the challenge requires both teams to provide ten wrestlers each which is easy for Lord Veto to assemble but means the Trolls need to go on a road trip, in their trusty caravan pulled by Robin, to recruit more wrestlers.
A series of adventures follow as they travel around the country. There are troll hating Billy goats and villainous wrestlers, spiders whose bite is deadly to Trolls, piranhas, a very angry wrouse and an army of gnomes protecting Mediterranean Brussell Sprouts that scream on being picked.
Evil Lord Veto conspires with kings and others to keep them from attending the Big Rumble. However with a motley collection of taco eating, garden loving and bendy friends, not to mention the phoenix Blaze and shy Jack who when angry transforms into the giant troll Thud, the Trolls are just in time for the contest.
Whilst you are never quite sure what will happen next, the reader can be confident that the Trolls will triumph against their obviously evil, cheating opponents.
Sue Keane

The mystery of the midnight crunch by Simon Mitchell

cover image

Ill. by James Davis. Five Mile Press, 2014. ISBN 9781743467251
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Crime. Mystery, Animals.
Mrs Hopper is convinced that she has a monster in her house. He comes out at night, and raids the kitchen eating the food, and leaving the room in a dreadful mess. The monster is big, green and furry, with huge feet and a long nasty claw. And it goes crunch in the night. She goes to Sniffy the mouse for help, after all he is a renowned detective. He and his offsider, Cooper, go to Mrs Hopper's house and inspect the damage, accumulating clues as they go. They decide to hide themselves in a cupboard for the night to catch the monster, all the while, Sniffy reassuring Cooper that there is no such thing as monsters.
But falling asleep they are both scared when one does appear and they run to the door, only to find Mrs Hopper coming in. She turns on the light to reveal the 'monster'.
A goodhearted story about a monster, ridiculing the fear some children may have about monsters, but adding a large dose of humour to the underlying message. Sniffy is a cute little mouse full of confidence which subsides when confronted by the monster, and his efforts to solve the case will further entrance the reader. The illustrations are full of life and colour, covering the whole page, full of little things to point out and find, small points to further amuse and intrigue. And I love the end papers, with their Hopper style of illustration showing an empty street in a city with streetlights lighting up small areas of the pavement. A world of discussion is presented here about city life, and the rodents that we share the space with. And a wonderful read aloud as well.
Fran Knight

Macavity by T. S. Eliot

cover image

Ill. by Arthur Robins. Faber & Faber, 2014. ISBN 9780571312122
(Age: All) In 1939, T.S. Eliot wrote his iconic Old Possum's book of practical cats which became the foundation for Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical 'Cats'. Within that collection, is a poem which begins...
'Macavity's a mystery cat
He's called the Hidden Paw.'
It's a tale that stays in your head forever and begs to be shared with others, read aloud with its rhyme and rhythm savoured as they roll off the tongue. So when I read this 75th anniversary edition to a group of six-year-olds, I was not surprised that they loved it and begged to hear it again. They didn't need to know the exact meanings of some of the phrases to enjoy it and understand that here was a cat of most devious tricks who is also a master of disguise and alias-building. They used words like 'cunning' and 'mischievous' and 'naughty' to describe him showing that Arthur Robins has illustrated it perfectly to underscore the concepts of 'a fiend in feline shape' and 'a master of depravity'. They then delighted in sharing their own stories of the dastardly deeds their own cats have got up to, and what was going to be a five-minute filler when I popped it in my bag for the day became a fun-filled thirty minute sharing session!
Yet, at the other end of the scale, it's just as much fun for older readers and a group of Year 6 students had great delight in exploring the language choices and appreciating how such a complete story with its come-to-life description can be told in just 400 words, proving that great writing transcends all age groups!
Definitely one to put in your collection and promote!
Barbara Braxton

Escape from Wolfhaven Castle by Kate Forsyth

cover image

The Impossible Quest : bk 1. Scholastic Australia, 2014. ISBN 9781743624067
(Age: 9-12) Recommended. Escape from Wolfhaven Castle is the introductory book in this new series from Scholastic. Set in a fantasy world of castles, lords and ladies, knights and squires not to mention bog-men and unicorns, Kate Forsyth's opening
'Tell your lord to beware,' the wild man said, gripping Tom's arm with a dirty hand. 'The wolves smell danger in the wind.'
immediately creates an expectation of action and drama, encouraging the reader to ask questions and read on.
We are introduced to castle life as Tom, the cook's son, attempts to pass the message on. When he helps win a game of mob-ball against the squires, he incurs the wrath of Sebastian, one of the squires, in the process. Whilst escaping Sebastian, Tom happens to meet Lady Elanor in her tower room.
The castle folk assemble to celebrate midsummer with a feast and are joined by Lord Mortlake, from the neighbouring Frostwick Castle, who is keen to broker a deal Lord Wolfgang. During the evening Arwen, the Grand Teller, also dramatically foretells of death and danger but her warning is not acted upon except by Quinn, Arwen's apprentice, and Tom who decide to keep watch.
Tom, Quinn, Lady Elanor, Sebastian and Tom's trusty wolfhound Fergus are the only ones to escape Wolfhaven Castle three weeks later when it is overrun by a mysterious leader and his army of Bog-men. Arwen entrusts them with some strange but obviously useful gifts and the spell which will save the castle, before they escape.
The adventure begins. All they need to do now is find a Unicorn, Griffin, Sea Serpent and a Dragon, a seemingly impossible quest.
Whilst at times the story line and character interaction appear a little predictable, Kate Forsyth's descriptive, easy to read style and the continuing action within the story keeps the reader interested. The encounter at Frostwick Castle with Lady Mortlake and the children's escape with her final threat ringing in their wake, leaves the reader keen to follow the story in the next book.
Sue Keane

The Nights Before Christmas ill. by Tony Ross

cover image

Koala Books, 2014. ISBN 9781742761404
As December begins what better way to herald the coming of Christmas than to share, each night, or day, a classic story of the season as each door of the Advent calendar is opened.
The Nights Before Christmas collection features a variety of traditional stories, poems and songs as well as extracts from newspapers and letters with a forward by illustrator Tony Ross. His intention in assembling this collection is to remember the preparation for, and anticipation of, Christmas Day through sharing stories from the past, illustrated in his easily recognised style.
Beginning with Clement Moore's classic A Visit from St Nicolas, the collection features a German folk story and Hans Christian Anderson's Fir Tree celebrating the Christmas tree tradition, though Professor Branestawm's Christmas Tree features a far from traditional tree.
The King James Bible version of The Nativity reminds us of the origin of the Christmas Story. Tolstoy's Papa Panov's Special Christmas , Good King Wencelas and an extract from Little Women, celebrate giving to the poor whilst an extract from Dickens' Christmas Carol features Scrooge at his cold hearted best. The extract from The New York Times, reporting the Christmas truce between soldiers fighting in the trenches in Northern France during World War One, reflects the Christmas message of peace and goodwill.
The cold and frozen northern winter features in stories from The Snow Queen and The Little Match Girl as is the wintery garden created by the selfishness of The Selfish Giant.
Of course no Christmas collection can ignore the presence of Santa who is celebrated by the quirky Letter to Suzy penned by her father, Samuel Clements, Baum's A Kidnapped Santa Claus and the iconic Yes Virginia, There is a Santa.
Whilst the compendium has a definite European traditional focus, adult readers are sure to be reminded of Christmases past as they share with the younger generation.
Sue Keane

The Ministry of Ghosts by Alex Shearer

cover image

Hot Key Books, 2014. ISBN 9781471403880
Do ghosts exist? Can it be proven? The Ministry of Ghosts is on the case . . . or is it? This is an adventure that 'creeps up on you softly and taps you on the shoulder'.
In an obsure building, in an out of the way place called Bric-a- Brac street, is the Ministry of Ghosts where four civil servants, and a cat, attend to the serious business of investigating the existence of ghosts and reporting their quarterly progress, to the government, as they have done since 1792. Unfortunately they have not produced any evidence of ghostly existence in all that time.
Enter Mr Beeston, from the Economies Office, unofficially known as the Department of Cuts, bent on closing down this, in his opinion, time and money wasting Ministry and relocating its employees to Ministry of Sewage. With only three months to prove what they have been unable to in over 200 years, a plan of action is put in place.
For a small wage Thruppence and Tim, students from the local primary school are employed to search out ghosts, as it is well known that children are more likely to be aware of their presence.
As the children investigate and learn more, they become anxious to save the Ministry of Ghosts and its employees. Will they find a ghost in time and if not how will they convince Mr Beeston to allow the Ministry to continue? Or is the answer to their problem in plain sight?
Written in the formal style of older times, reflecting the times and values of the older characters and the formality of English government departments, this story moves slowly but is entertaining in its descriptions of the inner workings of the Ministry. The introduction of the young investigators contrasts with this formality as they bring light, life and a modern touch to the language and to the Ministry.
Sue Keane

The Raven's wing by Frances Watts

cover image

Harper Collins, 2014. ISBN 9780733332913
(Age: 13+) Set in Imperial Rome under the reign of Caesar, this story opens with Claudia, the central character and narrator being abducted during the night before her wedding day.
Consideration and analysis of power is evident on various levels within this story. Senators jostle for political influence by cultivating friendships and marrying to acquire wealth and noble attachments. Women have limited influence within the patriarchal society beyond what respect is accorded them by their wealth and familial connections. Slaves acquired from defeated colonies are at the mercy of masters who purchase them like animals and as such, they could be treated humanely, leading a tolerable existence or they could be abused and tortured by unfeeling, brutal owners.
Claudia had been living happily with her Aunt and Uncle in a small provincial town and was betrothed to marry a sweetheart when her plans fell suddenly awry with the arrival of a messenger from Rome. News is delivered that her absent and completely unfamiliar father, a wealthy Roman Senator commands her presence and she complies, accepting the ignominy of breaking off her engagement and enduring the distress of leaving her beloved Aunt and Uncle.
Claudia's father had remarried to a new wife with grown children, a son with Senatorial aspirations and two daughters, the eldest being independently wealthy as the widow of an elderly aristocrat. Claudia is distinctly aware that she is considered rough and uncultured, possessing unrefined clothing and adornments, but equally from being ignorant of the complex social intricacies and expectations in the capital city. Whilst she is naive, Claudia is intelligent and beautiful, and soon discovers that her situation is being manipulated by her stepmother who desires that she marries her son, in order to secure a noble pedigree via adoption, and wealth from her Senatorial father. Claudia's romantic feelings for a man betrothed to her widowed stepsister causes her angst and confusion, as does her awareness that as a woman, she has no say in how her future is decided whilst she is treated as a commodity in marital plans which value the acquisition of power and influence over love and happiness. An unexpected death sees Claudia trying to unravel a mystery whilst having to tread carefully as she determines who deserves her trust and affection.
13+ readers who have a specific interest in Ancient Rome may enjoy this historical mystery.
Rob Welsh

State of Grace by Hilary Badger

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2014. ISBN: 9781760120382
Recommended. Wren lives in utopia. Her world is perfect. The trees laden with fruit and the water in the lagoon is crystal clear. Wren and her friends live in paradise, what more could they want? Wren starts having strange and somewhat disturbing visions and all she wants is them to stop. Flashes of another world and people that she doesn't know but it all seems familiar. Beautiful and mysterious Blaze knows something about the flashes that Wren is having. What are the lies that are hidden in these flashes and what will Wren uncover. Is the truth easier to face than being blissfully ignorant?
A captivating read. Instead of the dystopia we have a utopia and it was great to have something different from the many books I have read based on dystopia and utopia. Badger explained this new utopia extremely well and it was easy to follow the storyline. I was immersed in this story and was lost in it. The characters are complex and fascinating, their relationships with one another was interesting to read.
Cecilia Richards

The Wild One by Sonya Hartnett

cover image

Ill. by Lucia Masciullo. Penguin/Viking, 2014. ISBN 9780670076970
(Age: F-12) Charlie met the wild one when he was young. His kite got stuck in the branches of the tree and there, sitting on the bough beside it is a barefoot, slightly dishevelled little boy - looking remarkably like Charlie himself. All day they did things that little boys liked to do running, jumping, splashing, playing in the water, rolling in the mud, hanging from trees and scattering the leaves of autumn. At the end of the day, it was time for Charlie to collect his kite and he was surprised to find that his new friend didn't have to go home. 'Here is where I live,' he said.
Whenever he could, Charlie visited the wild one and played and explored the wonders of nature. They caught tadpoles and saw the tiny legs; they watched caterpillars spin cocoons and spiders weaving webs; and they hooted to the mopoke who stared at them through feather goggles. But such an idyllic life cannot last and Charlie had to go to school to learn mathematics and history and science. Every now and then Charlie visited the wild one and he had not been forgotten but as life intervened the visits became fewer and fewer, until one, day, with his own son in his arms, he cannot find him at all. Is he lost forever?
This is a most gentle story of a boy who finds another side to himself, but loses it as life intervenes but as the sun rises and falls and the moon circles the earth, he discovers it again in time to share it. Beautifully illustrated by Lucia Masciullo - this is the third partnership between the pair - it celebrates the joys of childhood and shows that the magic never quite leaves us, even if we cover it with layers of adult life. The passage of time and the cycle of life are inexorable but deep down we never lose the wonder of our earliest days, and the need to replicate it for our children and our grandchildren.
Like all excellent picture books, this appeals to so many ages. It's perfect for helping the very young understand that time passes and things change, yet at the other end of the scale it would also be a perfect addition to a more abstract, conceptual theme of belonging or journeys or discovery. The more you read it, the more you discover.
Barbara Braxton

Afterworlds by Scott Westerfeld

cover image

Penguin, 2014. ISBN: 9780143572046
I tore through Afterworlds faster than any novel I've read in the last six months. It was irresistible and I could hardly bear to put it down. This novel takes every writer's dream and shows them how it could play out . . .
Darcy is an eighteen year old that has just finished high school and, with it, her very first novel,Afterworlds. On a spur of the moment decision she sends her book to an agent and lands herself in writer's paradise with a two book contract and a year for re-writes. The publishers love her novel and they pay her an enormous advance which she uses to make the biggest leap-of-faith decision of her life: moving to New York to become a full-time writer. Darcy quickly blows her budget and looses herself among the fame of the authors she meets. While Darcy explores her new life as a writer in New York, her protagonist Lizzy, tells her story on the pages in between. Lizzy is the only survivor of a terrorist attack in a Dallas airport, in the attack she crossed over to the flipside where the good and the evil of death lurk. Meanwhile Darcy finally gives herself in to the inevitability of rewrites and struggles to find the happy ending for Lizzy and her lover Ramaraj (a Hindu death god) as the publishers demand. While she struggles, Lizzy uses her new found psychopomp abilities to investigate the murder of her mother's childhood friend, Mindy, whose ghost had been haunting her mother ever since Mindy's death. As Darcy's writing nears the end so does Lizzy's investigation; with the final three chapters Darcy opens her ears and does her best to type out an ending which is true to her characters and their story.
Highly engaging, Westerfeld uses his novel to tell a fantastical dual story which any aspiring writer would love. He talks about the relationship between a writer and his/her novel and much of what was written will resonate familiarity with any writer. It is the perfect novel for writerly discussion and tips when other writers are scarce.
Kayla Gaskell, age eighteen.

Timmy Failure: We Meet Again by Stephan Pastis

cover image

Walker Books, 2014. ISBN 9781406356748
(Ages 6 -12) Recommended. His name is Failure, Timmy Failure. He doesn't drive a fancy car or travel by limousine; he gets around on his mother's Roomba. (Robotic vacuum that roams across his mother's carpet in a pattern Timmy is yet to understand)
Timmy is the founder, president and the CEO of Failure Inc. a detective agency which is on the verge of global domination, global riches and global fame. He claims openly that the agency has solved most of the world's crimes. He also has his own polar bear who sleeps 20 hours a day and declares hibernation if you attempt to complain.
From an uneducated eye the incredible accomplishments that Timmy has achieved must look like everything goes his way. This is however not true. Timmy is constantly being met by roadblocks in life like the academic probation that his horrible Principal has put him on. Considering the small crime of throwing a tree stump through the principal's window Timmy believes he is being singled out and unfortunately Timmy's lawyer (also a polar bear) can't save him.
The coveted Miracle Report is the key to everything, including a good grade. It's dirty business. It's best you know nothing. But one thing is for sure: Timmy Failure will be triumphant again!
A naive adult (must be an adult) could be forgiven for thinking that this is just a Captain Underpants book with a new cover and focus. Its absurdity and ridiculousness is very similar. The main characters in both series also bare similarities. It evoke laughter through situations that often leave an adult saying 'what the', but a child in fits of laughter.
Any school library should invest in the Timmy Failure series. It will be continuously borrowed. The series is funny, ridiculous and a great option for children who loved the Captain Underpants style but need a new story in their life.
Steve Whitehead

The adventures of Autumn Day: My big fat hairy lies by Melinda Wills McHugh

cover image

Ill. by Amy Borrel. Silver Wood Books, 2014. ISBN 9781781322093
(Ages 8-10) Recommended. What happens when you tell a small lie? It grows and grows. Autumn Day is the same as any nine year old who wants to be liked however she realizes that owning up to her mistakes and telling the truth easier in the end.
Autumn Day just wants two things: To be best friends with Aimee and get a pink mobile phone for her ninth birthday simply to impress the other girls in her class. For a girl who has to endure being called all the other seasons or, due to her hair, Carrot Top, Flame Brain or Tomato Head, Autumn thinks this is not too much to ask for.
Unfortunately despite telling Aimee on the school bus that she had received the pink phone she in reality received a rag doll with red hair like hers and a jewellery box. Of course everyone wants to see the phone and Autumn has to think up more lies to keep her friends from knowing the truth.
Later in the day when she had to talk about her pets in front of the class, Autumn tells them that she has 'One dog, two fish and a pony'. The pony is a complete fabrication and means Autumn has to maintain two lies. Life becomes more and more complicated for Autumn until she decides it is time to come clean and admit the truth to her friends.
The author has given Autumn an authentic voice especially as we are privy to her innermost thoughts and feelings as she tries to justify her lies to herself. We are just as relieved as she is when she finally realises that she doesn't need to lie to have friends.
Sue Keane

Bubbay: a Christmas Adventure by Josie Wowolla Boyle and Fern Martins

cover image

Magabala, 2012. ISBN: 9781921248726
Highly recommended for Lower/Middle Primary children. With themes about loneliness/friendship/hope and Christmas, this is a timely book for this time of the year. Bush magic is always special and when it comes at Christmas time, it's even more special.
Bubbay is a little boy who lives alone in the desert, looking after his herd of goats. The only human with whom he has contact is Mrs Timms. He swaps goat's milk for eggs and while he is generally happy in his own company there are times when he does get lonely so he always enjoys his visits with Mrs Timms. This Christmas Eve is different though. Bubbay feels sad when he thinks about everyone else getting ready for festive celebrations in their homes and suddenly, more than anything, he wishes he had a Christmas tree, presents, a home and a family. Imagine his surprise when a streak of shimmering light swoops down from the sky before him and a little Christmas tree appears. Even more surprising is that the tree talks to him! It tells him that if he can find five very special items for decorations on its branches, he will have a very special Christmas! A stone, a feather, an egg and a seed might not be too difficult to fin but a shell? In the desert? How will he ever manage such a task?
Suddenly, the glow of his own little fire reveals old grandmother Gubarlee appearing to the sound of tapsticks and singing. Throughout the rest of the magical Christmas Eve Gubarlee guides Bubbay to find each of the special decorations and they finish just in time for sunrise. As the desert dawn floods the landscape with light, Bubbay sees Mrs Timms approaching, her arms wide open, inviting him to come and be her own little boy.
Truly this is a very special Christmas for both these characters, finding comfort, company and love in each other's presence. A lovely and gentle tale about reaching out to others in the real and the spiritual worlds, lavishly illustrated with vibrant colours depicting the desert and it's animal inhabitants.
Teaching notes can be found here
Sue Warren

Go to sleep, Jessie! by Libby Gleeson

cover image

Ill. by Freya Blackwood. Little Hare, 2014. ISBN 9781742977805
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Sleep, Siblings, Family. The young girl cannot sleep, because her new sister, Jessie screams when put to bed.
She goes down to see her parents and asks their help, and Mum comes upstairs to check on the baby. She changes her nappy, pats her on the back and whispers a song, then creeps back downstairs. But still Jessie screams. Dad comes upstairs and tells them a story and leaves the music box on as he creeps back downstairs. But still Jessie screams. The girl decides that she no longer wants Jessie in her room, so father takes Jessie off in the car to try and get her to sleep. The girl watches from her window, she is alone, and she cannot sleep. A wonderful twist occurs at the end of the book when Jessie is returned to the bedroom.
With Blackwood's engrossing illustrations redolent of family life, of the disruption caused by a new member of the household, the beautiful words are paralleled on every page. Freya's drawings range from small rows of pictures to full page, with many framed images reflecting a range of episodes within the family. The text layout and use of white is wonderful, ensuring readers are aware that this is deliberate, making them look more closely at the words and pictures on each page.
Fran Knight