Reviews

Good knight, bad knight by Tom Knight

cover image

Five Mile Press, 2016. ISBN 9781760402921
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Knights, Friendship, Dragons, Humour. Bad Knight is not enjoying his Knight school: he is failing at everything. He has really strict teachers and finds the work very hard, so much so that the other kids laugh at him. He is building a catapult in school while others are making nesting boxes, but he is waiting for his cousin to arrive. Good Knight will be a friend. But Good Knight turns out to be just as good as Bad Knight is bad. He can talk to his mother about cooking, is terrific at swordsmanship, goes into the haunted forest with aplomb, and has even mastered tapestry making. During his visit he comes top of the class while his cousin lingers at the bottom rung. The teacher plans a tournament with the pair playing each other, with rather predictable results, that is until a dragon arrives and target Good Knight. But cousin Bad knows just what to do, luring the dragon away so that he can use his invention to the satisfaction of everyone, except of course, the dragon.
A funny read, children will learn lots of information about medieval times as well as courage and friendship. The humorous illustrations will further entreat the readers as they read through the book, and they will pore over the endpapers with their intricate drawings designed to tickle everyone's funny bone.
Fran Knight

This is a circle by Chrissie Krebs

cover image

Random House Australia, 2016. ISBN 9780857988058
(Ages: 2-5) Rhyme. The back cover says 'This is the cover that wraps around the book. Inside is funnier - just take a look'. That says it all really - it is unashamedly silly! Don't be fooled by the title, this is not a 'name the shape' book. It's a fun rhyme with a great flow, featuring 1990s cartoon-style illustrations with lots of block colours and crazy looking animals with big teeth and bulging eyeballs. The cat is a little reminiscent of Leigh Hobbs's Old Tom.
The story is about a wild-looking one-eyed bear, a tap-dancing goat, a song-singing cat and a pant-wearing fox and the fun they have with a ball, a box, a scarf, a hat, a car and a boat. For example, 'The goat climbs the box while wearing the hat, which frightens the fox and angers the cat.' Needless to say it all gets a bit crazy and the end of the book sees them& stuck on top of the box with no way to get down.
The main subject and object words of the book (bear, cat, goat, fox, ball, box, hat, scarf, car, boat) are repeated often and are in a larger text size which shows the reader where to add emphasis, inserts fun into the act of reading and makes for enjoyable listening. The textural front cover, with a circle cut out in the hardcover, will appeal to young children.
This is a rollicking, fun ride that children will want to hear repeatedly and will love to join in reading. It has the potential to encourage early literacy development because of the use of simple, phonetic words and to promote conceptual understanding of rhyme.
Nicole Nelson

The Love Pug by Jennifer Sattler

cover image

Chick 'n' Pug series. Bloomsbury, 2015. ISBN 9781619636729
(Age: 4+) Chick and Pug are best friends, they enjoy playing and spending time together. Unfortunately a pretty young pug called Daisy appears and she falls for the very handsome Wonder Pug. Chick welcomes their new friend, and shares stories of Pug's heroic deeds. Images of Pug in a superhero cape flying through to air to rescue poor Chick accompany the easy to read text. Pug is not impressed, all he is interested in is taking a nap. The little yellow bird hops into action supporting Daisy in her quest for love.
Jennifer Sattler's bright illustrations bring the characters to life - Daisy saves Pug from the buzzing bee and Chick's expressive actions and a range of emotions as she assists her new friend.
A fun story to read aloud to a young audience.
Rhyllis Bignell

A soldier, a dog and a boy by Libby Hathorn

cover image

Ill. by Phil Lesnie. Lothian Children's Books, 2016. ISBN 9780734416377
(Age: 7+) Recommended. Animals in war. Children in war. War. Dogs. Refugees. Fighting at the Somme in Northern France during World War One, a young Australian soldier spies a stray dog, and adopts it, promising it will eat grandly: bully beef bourguignon. He tries to do some tricks with the animal, but the sad-face dog does not understand him. They walk on together, the young man wanting to adopt him as his company's mascot. In the background the luminous illustrations reveal aspects of the war in which the young man and his fellow Anzacs are involved. Eventually a young boy approaches them and he tells the soldier that the dog is his. He is able to get the dog to do the tricks the soldier tried, but when the soldier suggests the boy go to an orphanage he realises that he must sleep rough, the dog by his side, as the orphanage will not allow a dog.
The soldier asks the boy if he can have the dog, but the boy refuses. The soldier then gives the boy money for the two of them and bids them farewell. As we see the soldier moving off through the field of red poppies, the boy chases after him, exhorting him to take the dog back to Australia. So the soldier walks off with the dog wrapped around his shoulders. But this is not the end. The end of the story will make readers think hard about what happened to the other children like this one, what happened to the animals involved in war, as well as the story of a young boy smuggled back to Australia, which actually happened.
Hathorn's research into her own family's history at Gallipoli gave rise to this story, and the illustrations by Lesnie give an incredible back drop to the tale. Readers will gain some insight into the effect of war on the landscape, as well as the populace and feel some of the privations felt by the soldiers through the illustrations. The names given to the dogs by the two will engage the attention of the reader, and they will be able to think about some of the words associated with World War One.
This is an interesting and thought-provoking addition to the collection of picture books about Australia's participation in war which have appeared in the last few years and will be a wonderful inclusion for any library, classroom or home.
Fran Knight

Be Frank with me by Julia Claiborne Johnson

cover image

Corvus, 2016. ISBN 9781782399179
(Age: Adult - Discerning secondary students) As you know, I don't seem to get around to reading grown up books often but there was something about the blurb for this one that begged me to read and review it.
Thank you thank you Allen and Unwin for allowing me the unmitigated pleasure of doing so! Charming, funny, poignant, realistic and with a cast of unforgettable characters, this has been an absolute joy for my night time reading of the past week.
The reclusive and reputedly eccentric author M.M. Banning has been shamefully victimised by a fraud which has left her penniless. Her literary fame which rests on a single perfect novel now studied in schools all over America burns as brightly as ever but the funds have dwindled desperately.
Banning's publisher, Isaac Vargas, despatches his most able young assistant Alice Whitley from New York to the East Coast to monitor Banning's progress with a promised new novel. Despite having not published a word since 'The pitcher', Banning's contract for this new book is her financial salvation but the progress is not without obstacles. Alice's mission is not just to deliver reports on the book's progress but to 'manage' both Banning's domestic life and her nine year old son, Frank. If M. M. Banning is considered eccentric then her son Frank has not only inherited her genetic makeup but taken oddity to a whole new level.
A nine year old boy addicted to old movies, with a remarkable intelligence and a wealth of trivia hoarded away in his brain, Frank dresses in a range of outfits that transform him from a mini Teddy Roosevelt to a Clarence Darrow with equal ease and completely lacks any awareness of social mores. Needless to say, this does not stand him in good stead with other fourth-graders and indeed, many adults are taken aback by Frank's rather unnerving personality.
Alice's initial surprise as this strange household assaults her senses gradually turns to an unconditional acceptance of Frank and she becomes to a huge extent a surrogate parent for him.
Throw into this mix, the devastatingly attractive Xander whose presence throws Frank into paroxysms of joy, has a soothing effect on Mimi (M.M.) and thoroughly unnerves Alice.
This book has so much to offer the reader in terms of pure joy but has also a great deal to say about our acceptance of others, and society's definition of 'normal'.
You will not be disappointed if you look out for this one. While primarily aimed at an adult audience there is nothing in this that would prohibit being a delightful addition to a secondary library for discerning readers.
Sue Warren

True stories of polar adventures by Paul Dowswell

cover image

Usborne, 2015. ISBN 9781474903820
(Age: Upper middle primary) One of the first places on this planet little children get to know about is the North Pole, that legendary, mythical home of Father Christmas, aka Santa Claus. Marked by a red and white striped pole and inhabited by the man himself and his wife, industrious elves and magical reindeer, it is a place of mystery, intrigue and imagination. It is hard to believe that just over a century ago that that was exactly the aura that shrouded this place as expedition after expedition tried to uncover its secrets for over 500 years. Perhaps that is why it was designated as Santa's home - it was so remote and unattainable that no one would ever discover the truth. From Sir Edward Willoughby's unsuccessful attempt to find the northeast passage in 1553 until the still-disputed claims of Frederick Cook and Robert Peary in 1908 it, with its southern equivalent, was considered to be the Holy Grail of exploration.
This book, written for middle-upper primary readers, contains the stories of some of the most intrepid Arctic and Antarctic explorers - those who succeeded and those who didn't; those who went for the adventure and those who went for other reasons - and introduces a new generation to the hardships, trials and tribulations of what such a short time ago was the last bastion of exploration before the age of flight and radio let alone satellites and GPS.
Included are the stories of Roald Amundsen, the first to the South Pole and who beat my own personal hero Sir Robert Falcon Scott by five weeks, but whose story is often over-shadowed by that of Scott's because of the circumstances surrounding the deaths of Scott and his companions. As I re-read the stories of the conquerors of the south, once again I realised the impact that their journeys have had on my own life all these years later as my mother was determined to visit Scott's Hut (and did so in 1968 as the first female journalist to go south) and Scott's story The worst journey in the world by Apsley Cherry-Garrard was as familiar to me as The famous five!
Illustrated with maps of the various expeditions but sadly no photos, True stories of polar adventures could serve as just the introduction to the exploration of these unique, hostile lands and spark an interest in what it is that drives people to put their life on the line to go where none has gone before and to delve deeper into these tales of 'hardihood, endurance and courage'. This is but a taster of an extraordinary smorgasbord of adventure stories linked by the most hostile environments on the planet.
Barbara Braxton

A bump in the night by Amberin Huq

cover image

Five Mile Press 2016. ISBN 9781760068820
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Bravery. Bedtime. Fear. Imagination. 'Things that go bump in the night' is an old adage which is turned to good use here as the young girl confronts what she believes to be outside her bedroom door. She hears bumps, noises and knockings and assumes something very bad is going on. She thinks of pirates with cutlasses drawn, of giants and angry gnomes, but knows that these do not exist. She tells herself so, albeit with a question mark at the end of her sentence, but still determines to open her bedroom door and confront what is there.
Readers will love the recognition of fear that sometimes dogs their bedtimes, will laugh out loud at the things she dreams up to explain the noise, and stand with her as she opens that door, even though they stay behind her.
On opening that door, she finds a monster, but not your usual type of monster. This gentle giant lives under the bed and loves to eat. Mr Snuffles turfs out the other monsters that hide in her room, settling down under her bed once again.
She has confronted her fear and found it to be baseless, well, almost! What an interesting way to introduce the idea of feeling safe, of not putting up with things that make you unhappy, but checking them out and putting them behind you. Some classes will have great discussions after reading this book, and will take the opportunity to talk about safety issues, but most will take it as a very funny read about 'things that go bump in the night'.
Fran Knight

The lovers by Rod Nordland

cover image

Hodder and Stoughton, 2016. ISBN 9781473607002
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Journalist Rod Nordland's biography about the Afghan lovers Zakia and Ali is an engrossing tale about survival against all odds. The forbidden lovers' lives are changed forever by Ali's foolhardy declaration of love.
Like many Afghan woman, Zakia lived a sheltered life under the watchful eyes of her father, brothers, and male cousins. For Afghan pride however, they were not watchful enough. Zakia falls in love with the Hazara boy next door. The couple's courtship begins with just a handful of words in stolen moments but soon it progresses to scandalous secret phone calls and night-time visits in which Ali stands outsider Zakia's window, risking discovery just for the chance to talk with her. People just don't marry for love in Afghanistan, let alone marrying across ethnic groups (he was hazara and she was tajik). Before long Ali asked Zakia to marry him, despite their opposing ethnic groups - they would have to elope, a concept that was dangerous and would put both of them at risk of honour killings. Once the couple had run off together Zaman, Zakia's father, and his sons and nephews left their farm to hunt the couple down. Zakia had dishonoured her father and her family. The only way to regain that honour was for them to kill her. Zakia and Ali spent the next few years of their lives running from Zakia's family. Their plight received international attention with Rod Nordland's articles posing them as the Afghan Romeo and Juliette, not only did he write their stories for the New York Times, but he became the go-between for foreign assistance for the couple. He played an important role in their survival and continued international interest.
This novel is an eye-opener to the cultural differences between Afghanistan and the western world. It is certainly a testament to the luck of women living in a westernised world that they can voice their opinions, study, work, fall in love, and leave their house unattended without fear. Highly recommended for young people, in particular girls aged fifteen and up.
Kayla Gaskell (University student)

The Endermen Invasion: An Unofficial Minecrafter's Adventure by Winter Morgan

cover image

Bloomsbury Publishing, 2015. ISBN: 9781408869666
Themes: Games; Minecraft; Adventure. Imagine a popular computer game that inspires the text for an adventure . . . .collecting of treasure and 'building' while retaining the uncertainty and randomness of attack and defence within that game, and you have The Endermen Invasion. Young Minecraft devotees may enjoy this opportunity to read a game scenario, but the narrative lacks character development and the plot complications rely on knowledge of Minecraft strategies and game play. The fantasy element involves fighting ender dragons, and three-headed withers while competing in a 'building competition' which is under attack, while remembering the need to restore energy levels by collecting mushroom stew by milking 'Mooshrooms' to ensure energy supplies. This will be understood by game aficionados and just seem bizarre to any who have managed to miss the Minecraft world.
Not highly recommended for its literary quality, but if you have a reluctant reader who loves to play Minecraft, you might be able to entice them to read this book. Its quality is in 'getting them reading'.
Carolyn Hull

We're going on an egg hunt by Laura Hughes

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN: 9781408873861
(Age: 2+) Recommended. Paperback with flaps to lift. Themes: Easter, Poetry, Rhymes.
We're going on an egg hunt.
We're going to find them all.
We're REALLY excited.
Hooray for Easter Day!

Laura Hughes's lively Easter picture book is based on the traditional rhyme 'We're going on a bear hunt.' Four young rabbits start out with their wheelbarrow on the search for ten hidden eggs. The farm setting provides plenty of tricky obstacles, through the sheep enclosure, in the chicken coop, passed the busy bee hives, even at the duck pond there are eggs to collect. The eggs are hidden under logs, flowers, bulrushes and even the milk churn. Each brightly coloured egg is collected in the wheelbarrow, their baskets, buckets and a butterfly net, until they find the biggest egg of all. Hiding behind this flap is a surprise - the big bad wolf. The bunnies hurry and scurry back through the ducks, bees, chicks and lambs dropping some Easter eggs along the way. Of course, they arrive safely back at their house just in time to enjoy the chocolatey treat. Even Mr. Wolf enjoys Easter, munching on the eggs dropped in haste.
This engaging story is just right for sharing with youngsters this is an exciting read-aloud story, with counting, familiar things to find and animals to name. The pastel, watercolour wash backgrounds, rustic settings and charming animal characters make this an entertaining picture book.
Rhyllis Bignell

Zoo Zoom by Candace Ryan

cover image

Ill. by Macky Pamintuan. Bloomsbury, 2015. ISBN 9781619633575
(Age: 3+) The animals are off in a rocket to the moon, the monkey, puffin, cockatoo, even the buffalo are ready for a big adventure. The rhyming text questions which tasks need to be undertaken to launch the rocket - using the keys, gear and dials. As the animals are strapped in, even the kiwi, the hippo notices the sleeping rhino has caused a major problem.
Manny Pamintuan's vibrant and lively computer generated scenes filled with the more unusual zoo animals carry the story.
Rhyllis Bignell

The sidekicks by Will Kostakis

cover image

Penguin, 2016. ISBN 9780143309031
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Death, School, Same sex relationships, Friendship. When Isaac is killed, his three friends, Ryan, Miles and Harley find that with him gone, their relationship has no substance. They were Isaac's sidekicks and each must now work out their future without him. This riveting book is divided into three as each of the boys explains what Isaac and the group means to them.
The first section narrated by Ryan, shows the school machinery being put into place; grief counsellors called in, the school counsellor hovering, staff ready for the students' reactions, the principal handling the year eleven cohort at an assembly after Isaac's death. Excruciatingly real, the observation of the teachers including Ryan's mother, a staff member at the Catholic College Ryan attends is mesmerising.
But Ryan is bereft for another reason that no one else knows. Isaac was the one person who knows he is gay, the one he could rely upon to talk to, to discuss his latest love.
But after the assembly, Miles takes Ryan to Isaac's locker, asking him to get a bolt cutter. Opening the locker, Ryan sees that the red purse Miles desperately wants is full of fifty dollar notes. Money Isaac and Miles made by selling essays: another secret.
The first part, Swimmer, leaves the reader with a mass of questions around Isaac's death and Ryan's hesitant steps to coming out. Time moves slowly in the second part, Rebel, told by Harley as we are taken into his world, one that is surmounted with the footage he has taken of his three companions, footage which Ryan watches, looking for hints about what he may have revealed about himself and the Isaac he didn't know. But through his conversations we see more of what happened to Isaac before he died, and see Harley run away to his father's house out of the city leaving behind the many questions he may be asked. He supplied the drugs that night and when Isaac's mother asks him to gather some of the friends together to talk to her, he is very much afraid.
Miles is the focus of the third section, Nerd, as he continues the questions about how close he was to Isaac. He is peeved that the article in the newspaper did not mention him, and talks of Isaac as the film maker in the group. Miles retrieves the footage of the film made in the pervious year by the four, and rewinds the out takes, looking for clues about their relationship.
This is a very involved story, the plot line developing around the three sections from the three points of view makes fantastic reading as questions are posed and then partly answered as we read. All the time Isaac's voice looms large, and the reader sees all their stories dovetail together satisfactorily as they all realise how much they mean to each other, as each has done something for the other, something only a friend would do.
This is a masterful tale of coming of age with three young men at once horrified at their friend's death but also searching for who they are. The design of the plot and the up to the minute language are sure to appeal to a young adult audience.
Fran Knight

Bella and the wandering house by Meg McKinlay

cover image

Ill. by Nicholas Schafer. Fremantle Press, 2015. ISBN 9781925162301
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Humour, Moving house, Grandparents. Bella steps off her verandah one morning just as she has always done, but this morning, unlike every other morning, she steps onto her mother's violets. The path is not in its usual place. Curious. She speaks to her grandfather about it and in his sea salt wisdom tells her to watch the stars as they will always tell her where she is. Each day she wakes and the house has moved again, not only a few paces further along but once to a lake, then to a dam.
Bella comes to see the legs the house grows in its attempts to find a suitable resting place, and when her parents tell her the house will be cut in half and transported back to where they came from, she develops an idea. After all her grandfather was a boatbuilder and has put a porthole in her bedroom window made from the last boat he built, complete with the board with the name of his last boat, so she realises what the house is looking for. All ends happily and Bella has learnt a lot about her grandfather, his boats, the difference between a house and a home, and living where you need to live.
This is a delightful story for all ages, full of wisdom and humour and displaying a delightful relationship between a girl and her grandfather. And all is wonderful illustrated giving a Magic Pudding effect to the house and its running away legs.
Fran Knight

And Tango makes three by Justin Richardson and Peter Parnell

cover image

Ill. by Henry Cole. Simon and Schuster, 2015. ISBN 9781481448840
(Age: 3 - adult) Highly recommended. Animals, Chinstrap penguins, Family, New York. This tenth anniversary edition deserves a place in every library. The true story of two male penguins in the Central Park Zoo in New York is enough to bring tears to the eyes in its affirmation of what makes a family and what constitutes love.
The two penguins did everything together after meeting in 1998, so much so that when the female penguins formed partnerships with the males and made nests of stones ready for their eggs, Roy and Silo did too. They even found a stone to put in their nest to sit on and hatch like all the others. But it did not hatch.
The keeper, Mr Gramzay noticed that another pair had laid two eggs, and knowing that they were never able to raise more than one chick, moved one egg to the nest of Roy and Silo. They did everything the other penguins did: they sat on the egg, moving it to keep it warm, they slept on the egg, changing places when they needed to, until finally the egg hatched. And it was named Tango.
The trio became a most loved family amongst the penguin colony at Central Park Zoo, Silo and Roy teaching their chick to dive and swim, snuggle into their warmth at night and sing for its food.
This life affirming book confirms the place of family and the love that brings two together to make a family. Children need to see their own family make up in the books they read, and this goes a long way towards redressing the dearth of such books in the past.
An afterword of this anniversary edition tells us of the history of this book since it was first published. It makes salutary reading that in this age of Western freedoms, authorities seek to restrict some voices. The work of the parents in Singapore in stopping this book being pulped is wonderful and needs greater publicity, happening so recently (2014) A post script from the two authors telling us that they now have a daughter is a joyous end to a wonderful read.
Fran Knight

The emperor of any place by Tim Wynne-Jones

cover image

Candlewick, 2015. ISBN 9780763669737
(Age: Older teens) During the Second World War, Oshiro, a wounded Japanese soldier finds himself on a small and remote Pacific island, after having escaped by raft from the Island of Tinian where U.S. forces were crushing all resistance. Gradually he recovers and lives a peaceful existence, living off the land and utilising a range of supplies from debris washed ashore following battles at sea.
The soldier's simple quest to survive the war and return alive to his beloved new wife is threatened when he discovers a recently crashed American transport aircraft loaded with rifles and ammunition, in the island's interior. Evidence reveals that one of the crew has survived in a seriously injured state but has escaped to an unknown hiding place. Fearing discovery by the enemy soldier, Oshiro carefully searches the island for him and a series of bizarre events lead to his capturing Derwood, the American. Language difficulties limit the pair's communication but in time, both come to understand that it is simply impossible for Oshiro to confine Derwood as a prisoner and the pair live an agreeable and cooperative existence on the island, posing no threat to one another and further, coming to depend on each other for survival.
Fifty years later, Evan, a Canadian teenager is distraught when his father, whom he loves dearly, dies unexpectedly from a heart attack. Evan's ninety year old Grandfather arrives to tend to his son's and Evan's legal affairs. Evan has never met Griff, a Marine veteran from World War II and fears him, based upon warnings and tales from his own father who fled from Griff and ceased all contact with him as soon as he was old enough.
At this time, Evan discovers a manuscript detailing the wartime experiences of Oshiro and Derwood among his father's effects and learns that Griff (somehow a part of the events), is doing his best to suppress publication of the story. Despite his age, Griff intimidates Evan who struggles with his rigid military ways and threatening behaviour.
The mystery of what happened to Oshiro and Derwood, and their connection with Griff is gradually uncovered by Evan and enables an intriguing plot to develop. Much of the wartime narrative however involves supernatural beings which play a significant role in the events on the island. Aside from the notion of ghosts representing souls yet to be born into the physical world, the supernatural elements seemed out of place and I couldn't help thinking that the tale suffered for their inclusion.
Rob Welsh
Editor's note: This book was on YALSA's 2016 Best Fiction for Young Adults, is one of School Library Journal's Best Books 2015, and is on Horn Books Fanfare list.