Reviews

The butcher's hook by Janet Ellis

cover image

Two Roads Books, 2016. ISBN 9781473625129
(Age: Adult - Mature readers) Georgian England. Gender roles. Sexual maturation. Violence. Murder. Grief.
This is not a Jane Austen-style gentle and romantic exploration of life in Georgian England, but the voice of the central character Anne is full of the pain of a young and intelligent girl who lives in a patriarchal world and lives with limited opportunity - except that offered by a man. The 'butcher's hook' catches her, whichever way it, or she, is turned, and as we read we feel the slow and inexpressible pain of powerlessness at the hands of others. Anne's early family life is scarred by the repeated loss of her siblings, either in miscarriage or early death, and there is a heaviness that pervades her family life. In a world before good medical knowledge and care, and even less psychological support for the grieving, we are led into a series of overwhelming situations and potential problems as Anne matures into a woman of marriageable age and attempts to independently explore her growing interests. Her intelligence was at one time fostered by a family 'friend', who displayed interesting methods of arousing her curiosity about the world, but his means of explaining her questions about life and birth change her direction for the future and awaken more than understanding. A connection to the local butcher's apprentice rapidly escalates, and her means of clearing her path to enable her desires to be fed reveals more than just her lust for the young lad. The story is tragic and macabre, and displays none of the lightness of an Austen tale.
The background of the Georgian world, with its distinct social and gender class separations and the mire of poverty always in the background, is a fascinating setting for this absorbing tale of the unfolding carnal and worldly sensibilities of an adolescent woman who transforms in a way that we wish we could halt. This is not a gentle coming-of-age book for teenagers. And for those who might be squeamish and a little uncomfortable in a 21st century butcher's shop, there is a raw and visceral unpleasantness in imagining the equivalent literary dismembering of life in the 1760s. The quality of the prose will keep you reading though, despite some unpleasantness along the route.
Recommended for Mature readers only. (Adult text)
Carolyn Hull

Grandma wombat by Jackie French and Bruce Whatley

cover image

Wombat series. Angus and Robertson, 2016. ISBN 9780732299590
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Wombats. Grandparents. Each day sees similar things happening in the lives of grandma and her grandson wombat. Sleeping makes up much of each day, but some days there are carrots to be had, or small naps to be made, or itches to scratch. While grandma sleeps more soundly her grandson watches the world go by. The kangaroo that hops over the pair sometimes wakes grandma wombat, but one day as grandma lies sleeping, the kangaroo's joey is replaced by the smaller wombat. He bounces away, taking a ride in the ute on top of the bales of hay, then onto the back of a motor bike, then into a parcel truck which delivers baby wombat to the airport. There he joins a rather startled looking group of skydivers and sits on one as they sail to the earth.
Once again he is back with grandma, sleeping, scratching and eating but with a little eye that looks out at the reader, sharing what he has done with the audience.
Grandma is impervious to her grandson's outing, saying what a well behaved grandson she has, but the audience knows what he has done, and laughs along with him and his loving grandma.
French's pared back text gives all that is needed, and the illustrations by Bruce Whatley add another level of humour to an already funny tale. This is the fifth in the series of books about wombats by these two and will be very welcome in all libraries.
Fran Knight

Granny's Place by Allison Paterson

cover image

Ill. by Shane McGrath. Big Sky Publishing. ISBN 9781925275636
(Age: 4-6) Highly recommended. Themes: Grandparents; Family Life; Australia - Social Life and Customs - Twentieth Century. Granny's Place is a nostalgic story that celebrates the loving relationship between a young girl and her grandparents. Memorable visits to the family farm are beautifully described; the simple joys of bouncing on the springy beds, sharing freshly baked bickies and cakes around the wooden kitchen table and stamping through carpets of pine needles. Packing up the farm and moving to the city after Pa's passing, brings new challenges. When Granny's welcomes the family to her purpose-built red brick bungalow, the mood changes, no pine needles, ducks, hens or geese, no shrieking metal gates. Granny's love is constant, she still bakes for her family and welcomes her grandchildren.
Shane McGrath's engaging illustrations encapsulate rural and city life in the 1960's. The evocative narrative is enlivened by the earthy palette of greens, reds and browns, energetic characters, detailed vignettes and large sweeps of white space that focus the eye. Take time to explore in the old mudbrick farmhouse, there's Pa's World War 1 memorabilia, the old pump organ ready to be played and treasures hidden in old suitcases.
Alison Paterson's sensory descriptions bring these warm memories to life. This is a delightful picture book to share with grandparents and great grandparents. A great resource for the Early Years History and Social Sciences, comparing how family life and places change over time.
Rhyllis Bignell

A very normal man by Vincenzo Cerami

cover image

Translated by Isobel Grave. Wakefield Press, 2015. This is an English translation of Un Borghese piccolo piccolo, 1976. ISBN 9781743053713
(Age: 17+) Highly recommended. Themes: Revenge; Italian Society; Purpose; Hope and hopelessness.
A Very Normal Man is a translation of the first novel of Vincenzo Cerami who is also renowned for his co-authorship of the screenplay for Life is Beautiful (La vita e bella) with Roberto Benigni. With the same deft touch, he lightly deals with a harsh topic as he tiptoes through the tragedy of a normal life that sinks to extreme measures to grasp at retribution for a terrible family disaster. At the beginning of this carefully crafted story we enter the humble circumstances of the central character and his less than stellar career as a civil servant. His pre-retirement drudgery is brightened by the prospect of providing more for his son than was possible in his own life. In order to facilitate this rise above drudgery and relative working servitude he is enticed to explore a position within the local Masonic charter and the reader sees the implicit corruption that follows. On the brink of hope for his son, tragedy falls and the 'Normal man' sinks into functioning despondency and a whirlpool of despair that drags him down and plants the smallest of seeds of revenge into the heart of the simple man. From this point the black tragedy of the normal life takes on a secret existence that is almost quirkily humourous, and yet is in essence, darkly evil. The heart of this story is to reveal the very easy path that a normal or average man might take in becoming the worst kind of man. There is irony in the title that this is not a 'normal man'; even though to the world he is a small, insignificant, 'good' man. To the reader who is capable of self-examination, there is an opportunity to consider their own hidden potential. The characterisation within this text is subtly revealed, but incredibly powerful.
The translation of this text has brought this cleverly crafted story to our attention and this is worthy of study, despite its macabre aspects, and the journey into Italy in the period post- 1969, with its potential for corruption at even the most basic level is intriguing.
Highly recommended for Mature readers aged 17+ (predominantly an adult novel, but accessible by younger readers.) Note: some macabre detail included - a 'black' text!
Carolyn Hull

Choosing Xaverique by Karyn Sepulveda

cover image

Vivid, 2016. ISBN 9781925442281
(Ages: 11+) Fifteen year old Gabby Valis has an ordinary life, just like any other. Until she is catastrophically hit by a swerving van, and her heart stops beating . . . at least, it does for several minutes. Gabby is a Xaverique, a non-human species who are bestowed with powerful abilities. A Xaverique's powers can be used for good or for evil, and it just so happens that the most powerful Xaverique to have ever lived, Zlanythe, is concocting a hideously evil plan that Gabby finds herself (and her newly awakened powers) tangled up in.
Gabby, and the love interest, Noah's relationship is unfortunately, completely insta-love. After knowing each other for only a few weeks, they are professing their love for each other. Yes, they are both teenagers but even teenagers do not fall in love that quickly. After their very first meeting, Gabby thought she was in love with Noah. This definitely impacted on my enjoyment of the novel.
A second issue I had with the novel was the length. At only 149 pages, insta-love is going to be imminent and the climax of the story seemed both rushed and anti-climactic. Choosing Xaverique definitely would have benefitted from being a longer novel and therefore having more time to explore the relationships of the characters and strengthen the storyline.
Unfortunately, the novel also proved to be predictable in some aspects. However, the ending, whilst it did not surprise me, left me interested to know what would happen next. Overall, Choosing Xaverique is an easy, quick and light read that young teenagers (who can handle mature content including descriptions of blood and injuries) can enjoy.
Breanne F. (Student)

Princess of the Sands by Karen Wood

cover image

TrickStars series, bk 6. Allen and Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781743319093
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Themes: Courage; Overcoming difficulties; Horse-riding; Television acting.
In this next instalment in the life of the TrickStar triplets - Ruby, Lexie and Kit, the girls become Television extras in an episode of Princess of the Stars. With the wonderful ponies who allow them to demonstrate their trick-riding skills (and their slightly magical) personal characteristics they also solve the problems of the main child star whose horse is causing problems in the shooting schedule. While this is a story about all the triplets, it focuses on Lexie's battles with overcoming her fears as well.
This is a gentle, easy chapter book for a young female audience who enjoy reading about horses, trick-riding and girls as they express themselves within a supportive family. The series is worthy of a place in a school library.
Highly recommended for aged 7+.
Carolyn Hull

Maresi by Maria Turtschaninoff

cover image

Red Abbey Chronicles. Pushkin Children's Books, 2016. ISBN 9781782690917
(Age: 12+) Highly recommended. Fantasy, Dystopian story, Women. Maresi is sent to the Abbey when her sister dies during the HungerWinter, her parents no longer able to feed her. Here her thirst for knowledge comes to the fore as she is able to go to the Knowledge House after she finishes her chores. Here she learns of the place where she lives, the Red Abbey, first settled by the sisters many generations ago, to protect them from the violent male dominated world outside. And she learns of the ancient skills and feels the power of the Crone, one of the three that make up the core of the Abbey, the Crone, the Rose and the Mother.
Her idyllic life is interrupted by Jai, a waif brought to the Abbey for protection, after a brutal father kills her sister. Her mother has risked death herself to get the girl away, and she finds peace within the walls, with Maresi to guide her.
But Jai's position within the walls attracts her father's revenge and he and his friends come to get her back, forcing the women to use the ancient skills to keep them all safe.
Allegorical in tone, the first in the The Red Abbey Chronicles impels readers to see parallels in their own world, the brutal nature of the world outside the walls similar to any regime which aims to keep women subservient, using brute power and fear to keep them repressed. The religious basis of the Abbey is fascinating again encouraging readers to see parallels with religions within their own communities. The island keeps out invaders, the walls and gates make impregnable with magic but Jai's father is more determined than most and the women must take greater risks in defending their island.
This is one of those reads that grabs you and drags you along, wondering what will happen next, all the while hoping they will survive. The background from the arrival of the First Sisters, setting up the Abbey and the way they live earning money from harvesting the bloodsnails, develops a strong base for the story.
Translated from Finnish, there are two more books to be published: one a prequel telling how the First Sisters set up the Red Abbey and the next, a sequel, showing Maresi out in the world. The Red Abbey Chronicles has been sold to thirteen countries, while an American publishing house has brought the rights to the trilogy for a six figure sum. The book has been awarded the Swedish YLE Literature prize for Young Adult works by a Swedish-Finnish author.
Fran Knight

You have my heart by Corinne Fenton

cover image

Ill. by Robin Cowcher. Five Mile Press, 2016. ISBN 9781760401917
(Age: 3+) Family. Love. Mental health. Mothers' Day. Based around Parrot's classification of the six emotions, joy, sadness, fear, anger, surprise and love, this charming book will give a range of language to young children to describe their feelings. The words used by Fenton have immediate appeal as they describe in short phrases exactly what it feels like to be joyous or angry, fearful, sad, surprised and loved. The tripping lines of words will be a treat to read a loud to a child or class, and will encourage children to read it for themselves. Each child listening will be able to talk about those days when they are happy or sad, but knowing that in the end they are loved, there is someone there to make them overcome those days that might not be the best, there is someone there who has their heart. This is a book to read and reread, encouraging young children to see that there are days where things might not be as good as they hoped they would be, that everyone has 'tears-tumbling down days' and 'the world doesn't like me days', days when they need a hug and be reminded that there is always someone there that will make them stronger and has their heart. For discussing mental health issues with a younger class this would be an admirable introduction to talking about good days and bad days, encouraging children to see that they are not alone.
Originally conceived as a Mother's Day message, the book has much wider appeal, showing children that they are not alone in times of need. The illustrations with limited colour compliment the words beautifully, using line drawings, greys and red to show the six different emotions felt by the girl, and using a red balloon to reflect the way the child is feeling.
Fran Knight

The gutsy girl: Escapades for your life of epic adventure by Caroline Paul

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781632861238
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. The gutsy girl: Escapades for your life of epic adventure is an amazing book for all readers. The author, Caroline Paul, describes her adventures from milk carton making to climbing the Golden Gate Bridge, showing all readers that their life can be an adventure. Throughout the book are quotes from a variety of female adventurers and heroes to help promote adventurous thinking and remind readers they can think, do and achieve anything.
The stories are descriptive and inspiring as well as a variety of other texts; from procedures showing readers how to tie different knots to explanations and diagrams about clouds and tools. There are blank journal pages for readers to add their own adventures, procedures and favourite quotes.
This book is highly recommended to readers aged 9+. Each chapter is a different story which means it can be picked up at anytime and read in any order. There is also something quite appealing about the solid and exposed cardboard cover with the orange spine and shiny blue text. It reminds me of a journal or memoir and adds to the overall appeal of the book
Kylie Kempster

My life and other exploding chickens by Tristan Bancks

cover image

Random House, 2016. ISBN 9780857985316
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. My life and other exploding chickens is about the life of our main character, Tom Weekly, and is written from his viewpoint. Tom recounts hilarious stories of his life, from a crazy dentist visit to funny dot points about his cat. We find out about the crazy girl who has a crush on Tom as well as the girl he is crushing on. Read about Tom's friend who had a knitting needle stuck in her bum cheek and how Tom fears the library ninjas!
This is a hilarious novel aimed at and highly recommended for boys aged 9+. Each chapter is a short story in itself so even the most reluctant readers will find themselves engaged in each descriptive and 'giggle' moment! There are even a few gross moments - like the nits that grow and grow because of tomato sauce! What child won't like to read about that!
Kylie Kempster

Take Ted instead by Cassandra Webb

cover image

Ill. by Amanda Francey. New Frontier, 2016. ISBN 9781925059533
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Bedtime. Prevarication. Family life. Bedtime for many families cause some headaches, as the child works all sorts of tricks to forestall going to bed. Many books have been published which give a lovely story of the process of going to bed, culminating in a final goodnight, encouraging the listener to see the action of going to bed as part of their routine.
This book takes a different tack, using the excuses offered by the child in a funny way to get him finally off to bed. The very tired child asks Mum to take anyone but him. He offers his dog, Red, the baby, Seb, the cat, Fred, his older brother, Jedd, his toy, Zed, even Ned, the next door neighbour, until finally Mum uses the bear, Ted as the reason for the child to go to bed.
This lovely rhyming story has the same line at the end of each couplet, encouraging the child to join in and predict what the next words will be. The simple rhyming of words with 'instead' gives scope for predicting of people's names which rhyme, adding another layer of interest for the reader. The funny illustrations of a family at bedtime enhances the text and gives things for the child to spot and laugh about. Mum's lovely slippers, the tired look on many faces, and the final page with everyone in the bed, not quite going to sleep.
All will intrigue and delight younger readers and the book adds to those to read at bedtime to encourage that routine.
Fran Knight

Brave Bess and the ANZAC horses by Susan Brocker

cover image

HarperCollins, New Zealand, 2010. ISBN 9781869507916
(Age: 11+) Highly recommended. Subjects: New Zealand. Army - History; Cavalry - History, World War; 1914-1918 - New Zealand. When the call to arms came in 1914, young New Zealand lads bravely joined up to support their King and Country. In the early stages of this epic war, 3700 horses were also dispatched to support the troops in the battlefields. Between 1914 to 1916, 10328 horses were sent on treacherous sea voyages with the Mounted Rifle Brigade into the Middle East. Only four horses returned to their home soil after the war, one of these was Brave Bess. New Zealand author Susan Brocker's historically accurate and insightful account is narrated from this jet-black mare's point of view. Her style of writing with rhythmic and alliterative descriptions, drives the fast-paced narrative, empathetically dealing with the harsh realities of war both for the soldiers and their horses. Told in chronological order, each chapter begins with a brief account of the location, battle and engagement, followed by Bess's story fighting against her natural instincts to flee from the noisiest and most frightening of situations. The lesser known battles in the Bible lands of Palestine, at Beersheeba, Jaffa and Moab, fighting the Turkish Army, provide the reader with further understandings of the spirit, courage and dogged determination displayed by the ANZAC soldiers, their horses, camels and their supporters.
Black and white photographs taken from trooper's albums, add further insight into this story that celebrates the important role undertaken by these warhorses. An excellent historical resource for Upper Primary and Lower Secondary students.
Rhyllis Bignell

The beach they called Gallipoli by Jackie French and Bruce Whatley

cover image

HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9781460752265
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. World War One, Gallipoli, War, Environment. Kitted out with army uniform, great boots and a bayoneted rifle, fifteen year old Alec Campbell stares out at the reader from the front cover of Jackie French's latest picture book. People who have read about this war will know that he was one of the underage boys who enlisted, but unlike many others, he survived. Reading this book the reader can only wonder how anyone survived this particular battlefield.  Each page has French's brief words, encapsulating what happened at Gallipoli on the dates highlighted. Pared down to sentences, phrases, and sometimes single words, these give an account of the events that occurred on this beach and in its hills. The background, first appearing on the cover, of the low hills of Gallipoli beach, begins with the villagers who fished there prior to the outbreak of war. Their use of the sea and the beach is in stark contrast with what happened only a few months later, when thousands of soldiers were landed with orders to take the high ground where the Turkish Army waited. On each page, Whatley has a drawing of the scene in the top left hand corner, then drawings and photographs on what appears to be torn paper, underlining the transient nature of the engagement. The mix of different media, makes the reader search out each picture, taking in the detail and the message underpinned by the image. Maps, artifacts, images of dead soldiers, munition, trenches, headstones, animals and barbed wire cover the pages, leaving readers in no doubt about the changes made to this little beach. French takes us forward to the beach today, a place of rest for the nearly nine thousand Australians killed (and 80,000 Turks, 44,000 Allies, 2,700 New Zealanders), a site of pilgrimage for many, a place where everyone can reflect upon the utter futility of war.
This review is for the hardback edition published in 2014, and still stands for the new paperback edition.
Fran Knight

Forward march by Christobel Mattingley

cover image

Ill. by David Kennett. Omnibus, 2016. ISBN 9781742990804
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. War, Anzac Day, World War One and Two, Vietnam. The panorama of Australia's involvement in war is shown in its entirety in this handsomely produced, beautifully illustrated homage to the marchers on Anzac Day. Mattingley's spare prose introduces the marches, held each Anzac Day all over Australia, in every town and city, remembering the people who gave their lives in these wars: fathers and grandfathers, sons, mothers, grandmas and so on. And all remembered by a diverse range of people as large numbers march by.
Using a photographic style of illustration Kennett presents a sombre vision of men waiting, ready for the slaughter ahead. And then on the battlefields, using an increasingly sophisticated range of weaponry and machines designed just for war.
At the start, Matttingley tells us of the marches around Australia, marches where people remember those who served, her minimalist prose listing the work men and women did at the various theatres of war. From the predominance of horses and cavalry at the Boer War, to the use of submarines and camels in the First World War, motorcycles and airplanes in the Second World War, ships, tanks and helicopters in the Vietnam War, we come around again, back to the marchers remembering the dead. The picture book begins and ends with the marches, recalling the lives lost at war, the marchers recalling their lost comrades, friends, family. And the last double page zooms in on the graves, the rows and rows of graves so evocative of the sacrifice made by these people, now buried in foreign fields, marked out for their contribution to our nation.
This is one of those books that will have readers thinking about the act of remembrance at Anzac Day when Australians come together no matter where they are to spare a thought for those who fought for their country.
Fran Knight

The Obsession by Nora Roberts

cover image

Piatkus, 2016. ISBN 9780349407760
(Age: Adult) Recommended for fans of Nora Roberts and the romantic suspense genre. Naomi Bowes was just a young girl when she followed her father into the woods one night and discovered that he had a young woman trapped in the cellar there. She waited until her father left and then freed the woman and struggled with her to the police station. She now lives under the name of Naomi Carson and is a successful photographer, who has finally decided to settle in Sunrise Cove where she meets Xander Keaton who disturbs her solitude. Pursued by the notoriety of her infamous father, she is afraid that her past has caught up with her when women begin to disappear and bodies are found.
I am a big fan of Nora Roberts and The obsession is another entertaining suspenseful romance. It starts out with a disturbing and vivid description of the life that Naomi has led with a weak mother who has been totally dominated by her husband, who turns out to be a serial killer. Even at a young age, Naomi is a morally strong child, who knows that her father's actions at the root cellar are wrong and with great courage she manages to rescue the young woman that he abducted and then tell the police about it. She also looks after her younger brother. Roberts always find a new occupation for her heroines, in this case Naomi is a photographer. The information given about her work and the different ways that she makes a living from it also make for interesting background to the character.
As an adult, Naomi has not settled down either into a location or into a relationship, but when she finds the house at Sunrise Cove, she knows that this could be a home for her. The residents of the small town are friendly and she finds that not only is she spending lots of money on having her house renovated but has become the owner of a dog and has the persistent attention of Xander. The gradual easing of the emotional constraints that she has imposed on herself contrast with the growing terror of the murders that start happening very close to her.
Reading a Nora Robert's novel is always like returning to an old friend. Often the plot feels familiar and certainly the romance path is very recognisable, but the background to the serial killer and the feelings and plight of the family left behind by a serial killer, gives The obsession a fresh feel. Fans of both Nora Roberts and romantic suspense will not be disappointed with this novel.
Pat Pledger