Reviews

The whole caboodle by Lisa Shanahan

cover image

Ill. by Leila Rudge. Scholastic, 2016. ISBN 9781743629321
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Dogs, Pets, Counting, Word play. One dog wakes his owner to go for a walk. As he dresses and has breakfast, a tea cosy in the shape of a poodle can be seen on the table. He asks his dog who they will see in the park today, perhaps 'one itsy-bitsy poodle?'
Readers will love the rhythm of the phrase and love practicing it when they reread the book, while searching for the poodle on the page. Turning the page the question is asked again, 'two lovey-dovey bolonoodles?' but with a number two this time and a different set of dogs. On the page somewhere they will find the bolonoodles. One the next page, 'three fuddy-duddy Irish Troodles?' and three somewhere on the page, and so on until the last page when they all come together in the park. A wonderful read a loud, an amazing prediction text and a marvelous way with words will greet all readers. The play on words begins with all the names for the designer dogs based around poodle, so adults and children alike will have a lot of fun working out the mixture of dog breeds and working some out for themselves to add to the story.
The coloured pencil and wash illustrations are most attractive, giving lots of detail for the eyes to peruse and take in. There are many funny moments on the pages offering incidents which dog owners will recognise immediately all culminating with a double page full of dogs to drool over.
Fran Knight

Let's play by Herve Tullet

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760292980
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Following instructions, Wordplay, Humour. A companion to Press here and Mix it up, this board book offers great fun to both reader and listener, as little fingers follow the instructions on each page.
The single line and yellow ball draws people's eyes across the page and the simple question,'do you want to play?' invites the reader to turn the page to see what will happen. Over the next few pages the reader is invited to press the page and again follow the ball on the line. The line becomes wavy with the ball jostled about, it does loop the loops, and increases in number, and then colour, each time with an instruction, but soon things become more complicated and the ball goes into a black cave, then we see a double page of colour wash, then colours and squiggles again.
The reader is lead through a whole range of words describing what is happening: so they might use press, or middle, top or bottom, there might be words to describe the path they re traveling, or green and red traffic lights to obey.
All of it is highly amusing, involving the reader in play with each page as it is turned, regaling them with things to do, instructions and things to see. Children will laugh out loud as they move through the book, each page evoking a response. Children will participate in the actions asked by the book and be a willing player either by themselves, with a parent or group.
The simple line drawings will encourage children to try things out for themselves and some may use the idea to invent their own 'Let's play' images.
Fran Knight

The one in a million boy by Monica Wood

cover image

Headline, 2016. ISBN 9781472228369
An amusing and warm friendship develops between an eleven year old boy scout and Miss Vitkus, a one hundred and four year old lady, when he volunteers for yard work to earn a badge for service. The lad's obsession with Guinness World records, his quirky outlook and impeccable manners appeal to the woman who has no time for the shallow time wasting of other well - wishers in her mature years.
The voice of the boy is never heard despite his interviews with the woman about her long life experience which are recorded in chapters for a school project. Clever authorship reveals the disarmingly honest questions he asks by the style of the responses which the old lady voices with equal honesty and candour.
For reasons revealed early in the book, Quinn, the lad's father presents himself to Miss Vitkus to continue the yard work and odd jobs on the boy's behalf until the end of the agreed period. The boy's parents have been married and separated and Quinn has spent so much time away from his family whilst touring in music bands that he has become estranged from his son.
Guinness World records are important and recurring in the narrative. By their nature they are superlative, yet the categories include the mundane, the pointless and the ridiculous. One old lady's relatively unremarkable life is shown to have had highs and lows of joy and suffering (leading to hard earned wisdom) which are as meaningful to her as that experienced by the most famous or accomplished individual. Miss Vitkus' trust and friendship must be earned and Quinn works hard in many senses to build a relationship with her, partly to establish an emotional connection with his son who is only ever referred to in the text as 'the boy'.
Regret, particularly due to inaction rather than mistakes presents often in this story and characters in various situations are revealed to agonise over whether failures may be amended and disasters salvaged. Everyday decent people are the characters playing out their lives in this book and I liked that the author refrained from including unrealistic or uncommon elements which would have detracted from readily identifiable normal life.
Whilst I did not find the tale particularly moving or captivating, I suspect that it may be deeply meaningful to many.
Rob Welsh

Happily ever after: The ugly duckling ill. by Annie White

cover image

Happily Ever After series. Scholastic, 2016. ISBN 9781925059526
(Ages: 3-6) Classic fairy tale, belonging, differences. This is a simple version of the classic tale about a mother duck who is disappointed when one of her ducklings is not as pretty as the others are. The duckling doesn't feel that he belongs anywhere, and his new family certainly don't want him. But when he finds a family of swans he realises he has found where he is supposed to be. The book uses simple, almost old-fashioned illustrations that show the stages of the duckling's journey perfectly. The large text is perfect for emerging readers who will be able to pick out words they know and use the pictures to assist them in reading along. This is the first in the planned Happily Ever After series, which now includes The Princess and the Pea. This is a pleasing version of an old classic perfect for sharing with a new generation of young children.
Nicole Smith-Forrest

The stars at Oktober Bend by Glenda Millard

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781743315897
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. The stars at Oktober Bend by Glenda Millard is a beautiful and realistic novel about a girl called Alice Nightingale, a 15 year old who wants to be normal and accepted by the people in her home town. Alice struggles to communicate in the everyday, her thoughts and feelings are presented to and shared with the reader through her internal dialogue as she struggles to write and talk like other people her age. Alice lives with her grandmother and her brother; both have fiercely protected her since the day of her incident which left her introverted, ashamed and isolated from the normal world. Alice is not the only person running from a horrific past full of trauma and pain, Manny James, the running boy is also in his own internal isolation, withholding the fear of his past from his adoptive parents and everyone he knows, except Alice; somebody whom understands his situation. Manny and Alice meet one night as Alice stands on her roof, among the stars, wanting to be free to soar on the wings of clear words and coherent speech. Manny spies this lonely figure and is instantly captivated by her and her poetic statements and questions left all over town.
Written in a way that is different from the generic first-person novel format, The stars at Oktober Bend allows poetry, symbolism and emotion to show through to the audience as the intertwined stories of Alice and Manny charm the reader, making this book hard to put down. Because of the symbolic content, themes of violence and the tragic histories of both the main characters, I would recommend this novel to an older audience of 14+ so that they may engage in the story to the fullest extent. This novel truly is an eye opening read which presents an astounding view of the world through a relatable style of writing making this an unforgettable work of fiction.
Sarah Filkin (University student)

One life. My mother's story by Kate Grenville

cover image

Text, 2015. ISBN 9781925240962
Highly recommended. Kate Grenville, the author of The Secret river and Sarah Thornhill amongst other novels, explains this biography of her mother as an attempt to describe the life of an individual who was part of a social class that is largely ignored in historical writing. However, Grenville needs no excuse or rationale; the story is beautifully told and gives her mother, Nance Gee nee Russell, 1912-2002, the dignity she deserves. It is also a very enjoyable read. There is no authorial voiceover or explanatory commentary, but this is clearly the story of women whose aspirations were stifled by societal expectations. Nance was born to Dolly and Albert Russell, an unhappily married couple who made a career from hotel keeping until the Depression hit in the early 1930s. Nance and her older brother were boarded out for a number of years, Nance at first with a very rigid and unloving Catholic spinster and then in a convent, despite not being Catholic. She was fortunate to have several years of excellent schooling in Sydney before being forced back to a country school where few boys and even fewer girls stayed past leaving age, and standards were low. Nance wanted to be a teacher but this was emphatically rejected by her mother, and instead was sent to Sydney to train as a pharmacist. She was apprenticed to a martinet and struggled to understand the university lectures. No-one had money, because of the Depression, and Nance, lonely and poor, at times thought life too hard to be worth living. There were very few girls studying and the attitude to them was disparaging. When Nance qualified she was paid less than male graduates and she missed the bonds of family life. However, she had met inspiring young women and had learnt that she could have some control over what happened to her. She ran a pharmacy and had a love affair with its owner. She could have married any one of several young men but eventually chose an inspiring young communist lawyer. When war broke out she was disillusioned by his attempts to evade service and she realized that secrecy and subversion were essential parts of his character. She saw too that while despite his evasions she loved him he admired her rather than loved her. They had two children and Nance daringly planned to run a pharmacy again. The business was a success but in the early fifties there was no child care available; her mother failed her despite offering support and her husband could not imagine doing more than he did about the house. Nance sold the pharmacy, built a house with the money and had another child, Kate. Nance tried again later to have a business but even in the late fifties child care was not available.
Love of family was a dominant theme of her life, despite a difficult relationship with her mother, and her children were a constant delight to her. Another theme is the necessity to make the most of one's talents. She believed that the unexamined life is not worth living and this is a theme of her later life in particular. The writing is engaging and the character of Nance believably established. The social history of the times is accurately reflected. This book is highly recommended.
Jenny Hamilton

Supermum by Leah Russack

cover image

Ill. by Anil Tortop. Scholastic Australia, 2016. ISBN 9781760158545
(Age: 3-5) Highly recommended. Themes: Mothers, Family Life. Supermum is a celebration of a mother's special powers, her amazing abilities that help her cope with the daily challenges and delights of motherhood. On waking she stretches and yawns, strategically placed next to television heroes from the Secret Superpowers copying her movements on the screen. Outside the rain may be lightly falling, but inside the house Mum is ready to play with her ginger, curly-haired boy. As an eagle dressed in her super cape, scarf and special silver belt and M buckle she uses her x-ray vision to find her child hiding in a box. Supermum 's octopus tentacles carefully hold; bags, bottles, keys, a bunny and a large green umbrella protect her little one. Supermum's mouse ears are just right for super-hearing and Supermum penguin is there for special first aid treatment and a kiss for a grazed knee. She can sniff out smelly socks, read her child's mind and even tell when someone is telling Porky Pies. The loving hugs she gives are the best, what a wonderful mum.
Leanne Russack's gentle, caring story is delightful to read aloud, why not think of some new super powers for Mum or Dad? Anil Tortop's colourful digital illustrations creatively capture the happiness of a day spent with Supermum and her son.
Rhyllis Bignell

Percy and his amazing box of disguises by Sally Anne Garland

cover image

The Five Mile Press, 2016. ISBN 9781760400682
(Ages: 3-7) Recommended. Homes, disguises, pets, perspectives. This book sets itself apart with wonderfully unique vintage illustrations. Even the font and the rich colour scheme of greens, browns and reds have a Little Golden Book quality, making it fit it with the slightly retro 'master of disguise' theme. The story revolves around the gloriously named Percy Pimpernel, a rabbit who loves being free (the illustrations perfectly portray his joy of living and his excitable personality). When he sees that there are some animals living in a house nearby he feels sorry for them: they have to wait for their food to be served, go for walks on a lead and live in cages! Percy, wishing for them to be free like him, orders The Big Box of Clever Disguises and hatches a cunning plan. The cat, the dog and the hamsters are happy to be rescued by Percy and have a great day playing in the outdoors, but soon after they miss their little home.
This heartening tale warmly shows that home means different things to different people and that what one person values isn't necessarily the same as another. Young children will love the humour instilled in the story because of Percy's numerous disguises and crazy plan, and will enjoy the fast-paced narrative. This is the first in a planned series of books all about Percy.
Nicole Smith-Forrest

My cool plastics cupboard by Maggie Dent

cover image

Ill. by Linda True-Arrow. Pennington Publications, 2015. ISBN 9780975845684
(Ages: 1-3) Maggie Dent is a parenting writer and speaker so it is no great surprise that this seems to target parents more so than young children. It is written from the perspective of a two-year-old boy who has his own plastics cupboard filled with things that he is allowed to play with while remaining close to his Mum in the kitchen. The little boy tells us about what he can do in the plastics cupboard (sorting, stacking, exploring shapes, investing new and unusual objects and making noise), emphasising to parents the skills that children can practice through free play with the world around them (rather than expensive toys). The watercolour illustrations, while not particularly beautiful to look at, are realistic and highlight the child's wonder in the objects he finds in his cupboard.
The voice of the child is informal (with an oft repeated - but not suited to the target audience - 'How cool is that?') but it doesn't prevent it being rather bland. This is probably due to its length (it is a long story for the target age group - which is very small as older children will have no interest in a baby playing in a container cupboard) and the many subliminal 'parent messages' (eg., 'I like playing in the plastics cupboard with my mum close by' and 'My mum came over and explained that it was a whisk'). However, it is a fantastic idea to write a picture book about the container cupboards that most young children enjoy as it is such a relatable experience for them.
Nicole Smith-Forrest

Blue and Bertie by Kristyna Litten

cover image

Scholastic Australia, 2016. ISBN 9781742761800
(Ages: 3-7) Recommended. Differences and similarities, belonging, trying new things. Colour is used to tell the story of these two giraffes who are both similar and different. It is also a main illustrative feature. Bertie is an average looking yellow giraffe. Blue is a blue giraffe. Bertie's life with the other giraffes is monotonous: they nibble leaves, they drink water and they snooze. That is the way they like it. The colour palette showing Bertie and the herd is grey and yellow. When Bertie oversleeps and wakes up all alone he doesn't know what to do or where to go. He has never had to think for himself before! When he meets Blue, the world comes alive with colourful creatures and flowers that Bertie has never noticed before - he's been too busy doing the same old thing every day. In the end, Bertie convinces Blue that he belongs with the herd even though he is blue, and with Blue's new perspective the herd start doing things a little differently each day.
This is a simple, heart-warming story about stopping to smell the roses and finding a place to belong. It emphasises that being different is not so bad and that different perspectives can even make the world a more interesting place. Told primarily through the dialogue of the two giraffes (along with beginning and end narration), the text is concise, simple and undetailed. Bold and enlarged text tells the reader when to add emphasis and there are many sounds for young children to join in with ('crunchity-crunch, sip, slurp, snore, snore, snore'). The illustrations are delightful, managing to capture the emotions of the giraffes in the movement and shape of their long bodies as well as in their facial expressions.
Nicole Smith-Forrest

The first third by Will Kostakis

cover image

Penguin, 2013. ISBN 9780143568179
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. Greek Australia, Immigrants, Humour, Relationships, Food, Homosexuality. Bill's Greek grandmother is a larger than life figure, prominent in the day to day routines of their lives, and he recounts her entanglement with an excruciatingly real and very funny eye for detail. One of three brothers with a single mother, Bill goes with Yiayia to church on Easter Sunday, part of the Greek tradition which neither of his brothers observe. Here he has arranged to meet a girl he first saw twelve months ago and they race off to a prearranged date. But returning to church they find that Yiayia has fainted and so Bill must go to hospital with her, trying desperately to phone for help but knowing that mum is at a speed date evening. Yiayia pushes dome money into his hand and tells him to go to an address in Melbourne and taking Sticks along for company, he finds it is the house of someone he has not seen for a long while, his father. They flee.
Back in Sydney the two find solace in a pub where it becomes obvious to the reader that Sticks has hooked up with another man, but when he realises that Sticks is disabled, the link evaporates. At their next meeting Yiayia gives Bill a list of things she wants done. At first he is dumbfounded, but with the help of his friends finds that this is a bucket list, things Yiatia wants done before she dies. Yiayia's bucket list is not your usual bucket lists of flying off somewhere or eating at a top restaurant, Yiayia's bucket list is all about family.
The reader is always made aware of the importance Greeks place on family, and Yiayia's quest to make her family happy once more is tantamount to all the action that follows. She wants her grandsons to see their father again and have relationships that make them happy, her daughter to remarry and find happiness, and her bucket list tells Bill what he must do for her.
This is a wonderful story of family and tradition, of the Greek culture that is so much a part of the Melbourne scene, of multiculturalism and diversity. Humour underlines much of the action, as Bill finds ways to satisfy all that his beloved Grandmother wants to achieve and along the way that includes himself and his friend, Sticks.
I loved this book, and Kostakis displays Yiayia with all her eccentricities so endearingly, with such love and humour that all readers will feel wrapped in the warmth of the family life that she so values.
Fran Knight

Freddie Mole: Lion tamer by Alexander McCall-Smith

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408865859
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Humour. Circuses. Adventure. Lions. Freddie wants to help out his parents. His mum works on ships and is often away months at a time, and dad works hard but it never makes quite enough to cover the needs of his family and those of his injured brother. So when Freddie is offered a holiday job at the circus he accepts wholeheartedly. Here is the answer to his family's problems. He is well able to help out around the circus, but when he realises that the work involves being the understudy for some of acts, he is dumbfounded. But his 'can-do' attitude overcomes his fear and he succeeds where those before him have given up. So he climbs the ladder to reach the platform where he is to be swung between the trapeze artists and braves the lions in the lion taming act.
Readers will have their hearts in their mouths as he realises that the net has not been activated beneath the trapeze artists, or that he must be the lion tamer in the lion's act when the lion tamer runs off to Peru. But all works out well in the end, with the lions so old that they have lost their teeth and their claws worn down with age, and a proud mum and dad in the audience.
Freddie is an exuberant, positive young lad, and easily engages the reader with his fears which must be overcome for the good of the family. The illustrations add to the fun of the tale and a conservation message lies beneath some of the circus details. A stress on being positive is a winner in this charming story for middle primary people.
Fran Knight

Tricky twenty-two by Janet Evanovich

cover image

Headline, 2015. ISBN 9781472201652
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Crime fiction. Humour. Biological warfare. Stephanie Plum is back for the umpteenth time, solving crime while looking for bail absconders in Trenton, New Jersey, the home of her birth. She is an amazing character, seriously flawed, unable to make up her mind between high school sweetheart, Morelli, beloved of her family, and the outrageously cool Ranger, a security expert.
In this laugh out loud episode, Stephanie is called to take a young man to court but instead finds him dead. He is one of a college hall called Zeta, one that some of the powers at the school would like closed down. But looking further, Stephanie becomes aware of a locked cellar where experiments with fireworks have been going on, and breaking in finds aquaria full of fleas.
Blood in the fridge sends Lula into hysterics, and the links between blood, fleas and a top security biological warfare laboratory now closed down, becomes clear.
There follows a heart-stopping ride as Stephanie is kidnapped by the insane professor, seriously upset that his plans were not funded, and handcuffed and drugged to allow him to take her blood.
What the blood is for will make some readers squeamish, but as Ranger has a tracking device on all of his cars, he is able to find her, but only after she has managed to get free.
The relationships between Stephanie and her family as well as Morelli and Ranger are enough to keep the reader reading and laughing, while the plot line of the mad professor is an added bonus to keep the pages going over. Each of the main characters is quite engrossing, and the background characters, Lula, Vinnie, Stephanie's parents and grandmother have developed lives of their own in this escapist series. Grandma always finds some gossip relevant to the work Stephanie is doing at the time, while at one of her funeral home viewings, and somehow the streets of Trenton always find their way into the book. The background setting is always clearly delineated and Evanovich talks of it with a sound knowledge and affection which is enthralling.
Fran Knight

The midnight possum by Sally Morgan

cover image

Ill. by Jess Racklyeft. Omnibus Books, 2016. ISBN 9781742991047
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Possums. Adventures. Suspense. When possum climbs across the tree tops, and into the forest red gum tree covered with blossom, he eagerly anticipates his meal. It is dark, midnight dark, his favourite time, but he hears a cry from the rooftop nearby and going off to investigate finds a mother possum with a young possum on her back. She tells him that her baby is missing, the twin has disappeared. Possum checks the surrounding area, and the last place he looks, down the chimney, finds the baby possum clinging to a ledge. He climbs down imploring the little fellow to jump onto his back, but in doing so both tumble to the floor below. Inside the house they must navigate some obstacles until they find the cat flap and escape. After an enthusiastic thank you from mother possum, possum can now satisfy the cries from his own tummy and get to that blossom.
This delightful story, full of suspense will have children eagerly listening to see how the possums escape the house, and hear how the baby is reunited with mum. The story is full of Australia's environment, many animals litter the pages alongside fauna of the Australian bush. Some hints are given about how man has encroached upon the animal's habitat, with dangers lurking for the unwary.
The illustrations are done using digital collage, giving an effect of cut out and mixed media, adding a level of interest to the story.
Some of the double page spreads stand out: the second double page reprises the trees of the title page, standing starkly against the white background, and the double page showing the attic of the house, too is wonderful. The end papers reflect the flowering gum that the possum eats and encourages readers to look at the flowers of the trees around them.
Fran Knight

My dog Dash by Nicki Greenberg

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760110673
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Pets. Dogs. Snails. Ownership. Responsibility. Humour. The irony of the name, Dash, for her pet, becomes obvious when the first double page is turned to reveal a snail. Kids will laugh uproariously at the young girl and her pet snail, taking it off to puppy school, introducing it to her friends and relatives, taking it for a walk, teaching it to sit and stay. All the things a child does with a pet dog are portrayed in this story, teaching younger children about the responsibility of having a pet but using humour and wit to press home the points being made. Without being obvious, the humour behind the story will display the things a child can do with a pet dog and make them aware that there are times when a pet can cause mayhem, like sliding up a visitor's nose, or leaving a mess, or stealing food from the table. Or worst of all, eating through a pile of books!
But one night Dash disappears. The images of the whole sleep-deprived family out searching for the lost snail will cause readers to laugh out loud as they sympathise with the family forced to search through the night with their flashlights for a snail. And the surprise ending will cause more fun. The illustrations are just wonderful, with the little snail meandering across most pages, living its own life, oblivious to the work going on about it as the young girl tries to keep it as a pet. Kids will engage with this book, opening up discussions about their pets and pet ownership, the joys of keeping a pet and perhaps some of the downsides, the keeping of snails, and the role of parents when there is a pet in the house.
Fran Knight