Reviews

This side of home by Renee Watson

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2017. ISBN 9781619639300
(Age: Teens) African Americans. Identity. Love. Friendship. Student activism. Identical twins Nikki and Maya are in their final year at Richmond junior high school in a predominantly African American part of Portland. Their best friend, Essence, lives across the road and they hang out with three boys, Malachi, Ronnie and Devin. The friends notice a change in their neighbourhood as more white people move into the area. Shops are changing hands and being reopened as cafes and fashion outlets that seem to favour the more affluent white population. Essence's family have to move out as the landlord renovates their house and puts it on the market. It is bought by a white family with two kids of similar age; Nikki befriends Kate while Maya reluctantly gets to know Tony who is in their year at school. Kate and Nikki spend their time fashion shopping and visiting the new cafes much to Maya's annoyance. She feels her sister is abandoning their old friends and their heritage and the sisters grow apart. Richmond school is actively trying to project a more multicultural image which Maya, the student body president, feels is abandoning the school's African American heritage and she starts a campaign to celebrate African American high achievers. She feels there is no point lamenting the negatives without emphasising the many positives in their community. During the campaign she grows close to Tony and has to face her own prejudice and admit to having a white boyfriend.
This is a coming of age story of change, friendship and love underpinned by a thoughtful examination of African American identity which is relevant for all cultures trying to make their way in a changing world without losing what it means to part of their own community. The first person narrative makes the story very accessible as do the short, sometimes very short, chapters. A light touch which will appeal to teens discovering their own identity and seeking love.
Sue Speck

The butterfly dance by Suzanne Barton

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2017. ISBN 9781408864845
(Age: Pre-school - Year 1) Recommended. Caterpillars Dotty and Stripe are good friends and do everything together. One day, as caterpillars must, they spin cocoons and begin their journey as butterflies. How wonderful to rediscover the world as a blue dotty and a red stripy butterfly. Sadly, they are separated when they join different butterfly groups that match their own colours. Can they ever be together as friends again?
This is a delightful story about friendship and following your own beliefs. Dotty and Stripe learn that their colour and patterns do not make a difference to their relationship. Although they enjoy the company of others, they share a bond that makes their companionship special. Children will understand the importance of 'the special friend', which is a theme in many pre-school books.
Illustrations show the ideal beautiful world Dotty and Stripe live in. Collage is used throughout the book and I particularly love the use of lace for each caterpillar's cocoon. The double page meadow scene has lots for the child to enjoy and they will delight in trying to find both butterflies. Suzanne admits to a love of Japanese prints and papers and this is evident on each page.
Dotty and Stripe are very appealing characters and it is easy to identify with their problems and emotions. Children will be keen to see how their difficulties are resolved and will be sad when they are not together.
I would recommend this picture book to both pre-school children and reception, year 1 students.
Jane Moore

Yvain - The Knight of the Lion by M.T. Anderson

cover image

Ill. by Andrea Offermann. Candlewick Press, 2017 ISBN 9780763659394
(Age: 11+) Recommended. Themes: Chivalry, Knights, honour, medieval. This graphic novel version of Chretien de Troyes twelfth century epic poem vividly retells the Arthurian legend of Sir Yvain, who travels to the magic fountain in the forest of Brocceliande to avenge the honour of his cousin Sir Calogreante. The knights at the court of King Arthur love adventure especially if it involves bravery and chivalry and Yvain wants the glory all to himself. He succeeds in defeating the owner of the fountain, Sir Esclados, chasing him into his castle where Escaldos dies but Yvain's horse is killed and he finds himself on the wrong side of the portcullis. He is helped to escape detection by a servant, Lunette who remembers him treating her kindly at King Arthur's court and magically renders him temporarily invisible. While in hiding he falls in love with the bereaved Lady Laudine who Lunette contrives to persuade to make a political decision to marry Yvain on the understanding he will defend the magic fountain and her lands against all men. When King Arthur and his men arrive at the fountain Yvain defeats one of his knights in a joust and then reveals his identity and invites them to be entertained in the castle. Laudine grants Yvain leave to go on a year's adventuring with Arthur's court. When he fails to return after a year Laudine sends a message telling him never to return. Yvain goes a little mad at his failure, hating himself for his disloyal behaviour and he wanders aimlessly in the wilderness until he rescues a lion from a dragon regaining some self-esteem and finding a loyal companion in the lion. The rest of the story involves brave deeds, chivalry, magic and monsters as Yvain fights to regain his honour and his lady as an anonymous knight fighting for the good of others.
It is a ripping tale of the age of chivalry where men are warlike and women clever and politically astute. The images graphically convey the action and we are immersed in the medieval world. The rhythms of storytelling and poetry are conveyed in the pictures, some reminiscent of illuminated texts and the Bayeux tapestry. The edition I reviewed was let down by the cover, a swirl with a red blob which conveyed no clue to the story and its setting. The author and the illustrator notes at the end of the book are insightful and I got a lot more out of the book on a second reading. Recommended for middle school fans of King Arthur and a rewarding read for senior students from non English speaking backgrounds.
Sue Speck

How to outsmart a billion robot bees by Paul Tobin

cover image

Genius factor bk 2.Bloomsbury Publishing, 2017 ISBN 9781408881804
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. How to Outsmart a Billion Robot Bees starts with a bee attack. Delphine and her friends are under attack. To escape, the girls run into the street but the bees seem to want Delphine. A few pages in and readers will already be laughing. Delphine is then kidnapped. Next, she is rescued by her genius friend Nate. This book seems to be on fast forward, there is so much happening and it is very fast paced. The two friends are then chased by The Red Tea Society (and it is not even lunch time yet!). We then read about a car chase and Nate explains some of his more unusual inventions. Before you know it, a wetsuit is flying and saving the day. Keep reading to find out why The Red Tea Society is after Delphine and Nate. Why does Delphine need to argue with a talking car? Can you really make friends with a robot bee?
How to Outsmart a Billion Robot Bees is the second in the series following How to capture an invisible cat and it is recommended that readers read the series in order. This is an extremely busy and active story. It will keep independent readers engaged and giggling at the antics.
Kylie Kempster

Horizon by Scott Westerfeld

cover image

Scholastic, 2017. ISBN 9781743817605
(Ages 11+ - Middle School) A group of Tech Savvy teens are heading to Tokyo for a Robotics competition when their plane crashes somewhere in the ice and snow of the arctic. While they mourn their mentor, trying to find remaining passengers and scavenge what they can from the plane, they group together to realise that of the 500 plus people onboard there are only 8 survivors. They also find themselves in the middle of a hostile jungle with flora and fauna which does not want them there.
The first in a 7 part multi-author series, Horizon sets the scene for a multi-perspective story of survival which borrows aspects of many stories before it. There is some good character development, but characters are also cliched stereotypes ie the bossy one, the reluctant scaredy one etc. As the teenagers learn survival skills, they also learn that working together and cooperation will be key elements in finding their way home. The more they explore, the more questions they have. Westerfeld gives readers only a taste of what is to come in further stories. The story is a fast-paced adventure with some very technical sci fi elements.
Clare Thompson

Butterfly we're expecting you! by Libby Hathorn

cover image

Ill. by Lisa Stewart. Lothian Children's Books, 2017. ISBN 9780734416995
(Age: 3-6) Recommended. Written by Libby Hathorn and beautifully illustrated by Lisa Stewart, Butterfly We're Expecting You is an adventure for children as they explore backyards finding an array of creatures.
In the story a brother and sister explore the area around their house and speak to each of the creatures that they find.
With its textural front cover and illustrations expanding across whole pages, this is a delightful and gentle story that will make children get outside and explore for themselves.
Keely Coard

Chook Doolan: Let's do Diwali! by James Roy

cover image

Ill. by Lucinda Gifford. Walker Books, 2017. ISBN 9781925381597
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Festivals. Anxiety. Bravery. Friendship. Chook is paired with Praj to research a festival and give a talk and they decide to investigate the Hindu festival Diwali, especially as Praj and his family are going to the festivities. They invite Chook to go along but he is nervous in big crowds. However Praj and his family make him feel comfortable and give him a deep red kurta to wear. Initially he is worried but he overcomes his fears and he has a wonderful time, eating delicious food and watching the fireworks.
Written in short chapters with its large font and easy sentences, this is ideal for the emerging reader. The information given about Diwali, the clothes worn and the food and celebrations is quite detailed and any child reading this will gain an excellent insight into the Hindu festivals and the customs surrounding it.
This is highly recommended for its focus on the fears that young children can have when facing new experiences and the friendship and help that Praj and his family offer is inspiring.
Pat Pledger

Cinnamon by Neil Gaiman

cover image

Ill. by Divya Srinivasan. Bloomsbury, 2017. ISBN 9781408879238
(Age: 5+) Highly recommended. Speech. India. Cinnamon was a princess who didn't talk. Her parents the Rajah and the Rani were determined to find someone who could teach her to speak and offered a mango grove, a portrait of the Rani's aunt, a parrot and a beautiful room in the palace to the person who was successful. But no one was able to get her to speak. Then one day a fierce and hug man-eating tiger appeared at the palace and said that he was there to teach the girl-cub how to talk. She was left in the room with him and there she experienced pain, fear and love. It was love that woke Cinnamon's voice and she told her parents that she had nothing to say before but now the tiger has told her of love and the world she has decided to go away with him.
This is a witty and fascinating story told by the award winning Gaiman. The illustrations are outstanding. The palace of the Rajah and Rani is depicted beautifully with peacocks strolling in the gardens and swans floating in the lily pond. The saris of the women are in gorgeous purples and greens Cinnamon comes alive with pearl eyes, beautiful hair and nose ring beautifully drawn. The colours are pastel and soft until the tiger comes along with his bold black and orange stripes, wide mouth and sharp teeth, terrifying enough to make the reader fear for Cinnamon and wonder just who he will eat.
Perfect for reading aloud, this fabulous tale is sure to become a favourite with children who will be enthralled by the idea of a talking, man eating tiger who can teach about love and entice a princess to leave with him.
Pat Pledger

Really weird by Anh Do

cover image

Weirdo 8. Scholastic Australia, 2017. ISBN 9781760276768
(Age: 8-12) Highly recommended. Superb! Anh makes Weir Do feel like your best pal. He has, as always, brought his many readers another thoroughly entertaining read in this, the 8th book in the series about the highly likeable Weir Do.
Oink-a-Doodle-Doooo! From pigs that aspire to be roosters, or run away to join the ballet (pigs in tutus), or Poppy knitting a mini beanie for Brian, the cactus, all Anh's usual appealing characters are here, including Bella, Grandma Do, Henry, Mullet and Wendy, who all keep the reader tickled and smiling until the last page is all-too-soon reached.
With wonderfully simple sketched illustrations, Really weird is carefully crafted, delightfully droll and should definitely appeal even to the most reluctant reader in the 8-12 years bracket.
Joan Kerr-Smith

Double take! a new look at opposites by Susan Hood

cover image

Ill. by Jay Fleck. Walker Studio, 2015. ISBN 9781406377293
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Opposites. Perspective. Points of view. More than a look at opposites, this interesting picture book is also a challenge for the reader to ponder and delve into what an opposite really means and to think about different points of view. Hood has written an engaging, thought provoking text in rhyme, looking not just at what a simple opposite can mean but how it relates to who wants to know and the perspective of the person asking:
Who knows what's BIG
    unless there's SMALL?
Does SHORT mean a thing
    except next to TALL?

The illustrations done in a retro style by Jay Fleck are evocative and add much to the text. The one on the back of the book with the blurb was particularly engaging showing a tall flower in a small pot with a bird looking at it and a short flower in a big pot with a mouse looking at it. Another that caught my eye was the elephant lifting a large weight that contrasted with the boy trying to lift a small one:
Who's STRONG
    and who's WEAK
is hardly perplexing

Then the reader turns the page to see a double page spread with a giant whale and the text:
But STRONG can look WEAK
    when a new champ is flexing.

The use of different styles of print to highlight the point being made also adds to the fun of the book and would lead to easy emphasis when reading aloud.
This would be a very useful book to have in the classroom, and its easy rhythm and fun illustrations will engage both readers and listeners.
Pat Pledger

Where's Wally? The totally essential travel collection by Martin Handford

cover image

Walker Books, 2017. ISBN 9781406375718
(Age: 7+) Recommended. For thirty years, British illustrator Martin Handford's Where's Wally books have delighted fans of all ages. From the original Where's Wally to The wonder book, his Hollywood adventures and The incredible paper chase, these popular seek and find puzzle books are now available in one handy travel compendium. With a flexible sturdy cover and a stretchy elastic bookmark, this is perfect for a young explorer to take on a long journey, plane ride or car trip. Six postcards tucked into the front and back pocket are included, ready to colour in and send via snail mail to someone special at home.
Each double page spread contains the familiar detailed settings with hundreds of colourful people and animals busily engaged in a vast array of activities. Wally with his red-and-white striped shirt, bobble hat and glasses is sometimes hard to find amongst all the other cast of characters dressed in similar colours. Two checklists are included for each of the seven books. These add to the fun of finding Wanda, Woof and lots of crazy people and animals hidden on a space station, performing in the Wally Musical or fighting with the Battling Monks.
Where's Wally? The totally essential travel collection is a wonderful way to introduce historical events, inspire creativity and engage with a real book instead of a screen.
Rhyllis Bignell

Cowboy Pug: the dog who rode for glory by Laura James

cover image

Ill. by Eglantine Ceulemans. Bloomsbury, 2017. ISBN 9781408866382
(Age: 5-7) Recommended. Humour. Dogs. Cowboys. Horses. Fear. Following on the success of Captain Pug the dog who sailed the seas by Laura James comes Cowboy Pug the dog who rode for glory. Here the reader finds the long suffering Pug dressed up in a cowboy hat and bandana, forced to trail behind Lady Miranda as she goes off horse-trading. They find a very tall horse Lady Miranda names Horsey and off they ride, meeting Frank on the way and being carried off in a horse trailer to the local horse show.
Cowboy Pug is a most reluctant hero. He would much prefer to lounge in his chair, having snacks and dozing, to adventuring with Lady Miranda. However when circumstances force him to be brave, he rises to the occasion and saves the day.
Beautifully illustrated in reds, yellows and greys, the reader will delight in the expression of fear on Pug's face and long suffering on Horsey's face. The scene when they gallop around the show jumping ring is brilliant. Lady Miranda is depicted as an impetuous young girl and the two footmen Running Footman Will and Running Footman Liam, who carry the sedan chair are hilarious.
The newly independent reader will sympathise with Pug as he is forced into uncomfortable situations by Lady Miranda and circumstances, cheer as he overcomes his fears and look forward to the next in the series, Safari Pug.
Pat Pledger

Where is the very hungry caterpillar? by Eric Carle

cover image

Picture Puffin UK, 2017. ISBN 9780141374352
The world was first introduced to the very hungry caterpillar as he munched his way through a menu of goodies almost 50 years ago! Now he is back, hiding somewhere under the flaps waiting to be discovered by little fingers.
With the bold colours and readily recognisable illustrations of the wondrous Eric Carle who has a gift of turning the mundane into the extraordinary, it's time for little ones to have even more fun with the little caterpillar that so many of them already know and love. And as well as recognising the familiar foods from the original story and perhaps even being able to read the words for them because of that, they can also learn what other tiny creatures inhabit the world beneath their feet and maybe tread a little more gently on this earth.
This ticks all the boxes about helping our first readers to understand the basic concepts about print that are so vital to their reading success, particularly making connections between this new story and the one they know as they learn to carry that knowledge and apply it to a new situation. Brilliant from what might appear to be a humble board book!
Barbara Braxton

Storm whale by Sarah Brennan

cover image

Ill. by Jane Tanner. Allen and Unwin, 2017. ISBN 9781760293642
(Age: Primary middle years) Hardcover, 32 pages. Themes: Whales- fiction, Conservation, Siblings.
Bleak was the day and the wind whipped down when my sisters and I walked to town . . .
Sarah Brennan's narrative verse is a powerful, driven story of three sisters who try to rescue a whale stranded on a windswept beach. Her beautifully evocative phrases filled with alliteration and colourful descriptions are crisp and clipped. They need to be read aloud. She builds the tension driving the story forward as the three sisters battle the elements to save the stranded whale - scarred old mariner, beached in hell, far from the cradling ocean swell. Brennan's memories of Tasmania summer holidays on wet and windy beaches provided the inspiration for Storm Whale.
The story celebrates the close bond of sisterhood as each draws strength from the other, to frantically keep the whale bathed in seawater. They show resilience and dogged determination fighting an epic struggle in the stormy conditions. Without any adult intervention, they finally return home, nearly defeated, unsure about the large mammal's fate. They find comfort in each other, wrapped in warm blankets by the glowing fire and wait for the morning unsure of the outcome. Their freedom to explore the storm-ravaged beach on their own and search for the whale, without a parent, might be confronting to some readers.
Jane Tanner's powerful illustrations, changing from pencil sketches to sweeping painted scenes powerfully enhance Brennan's emotional tale. From hope to near despondence, her textured paintings bring to life the sisters' elemental fight against the driving rain. She creates the moodiness, the contrast of darkness and light, of cold and warmth perfectly depicting Brennan's story.
Storm Whale is an ideal picture book for older readers who enjoy rhyming narratives. The rich, emotive language and wonderful illustrations are suitable for Middle Years classes studying styles of poetry, identifying how language choices and imagery build emotional connection and engagement with this story.
Rhyllis Bignell

One of us is lying by Karen M. McManus

cover image

Penguin, 2017. ISBN 9780141375632
(Age: 15+) Recommended. Mystery. Five students are sent to detention for having a phone in class. Only four walk out. One of them lies dead from anaphylactic shock, having drunk water that was contaminated by peanut oil. All of them have secrets that they wanted hidden from Simon, the dead boy who had a vicious gossip app that was followed avidly by everyone in the school. And his death wasn't an accident - who is telling lies and who is the murderer?
McManus has written a very suspenseful, high interest mystery with all the ingredients that readers could wish for to maintain their interest. The four student suspects' characters and secrets are gradually revealed as each gives their story in separate chapters, showing their strengths and weaknesses and their perspective on what has happened. Bronwyn is the brain and normally wouldn't break a rule; Addy is the homecoming princess, who clings to Jake, Mr Popular; Nate is the bad boy on probation for dealing drugs and Cooper is the all-star athlete. When it is revealed that Simon intended to reveal their secrets they all become suspects and as the police focus on one and then another, their secrets are revealed and they decide to gang together to get to the truth.
Seasoned mystery readers may not be confused by the many red herrings and work out the end, or at least part of it, but the novel is engrossing and the suspense continues to build right to the very end. The characters are well rounded and not just the stereotypes that could be expected from the brain, the jock, the bad boy and the princess, and the plot is twisted enough to keep most readers totally enthralled.
This was a quick read and it is easy to see it being produced as a movie. It has all the elements to attract teens, a theme of the problems of social media, a little romance and a strongly plotted mystery.
Pat Pledger