Reviews

1917 by Kelly Gardiner

cover image

Australia's Great War series bk 4. Scholastic, 2017. ISBN 9781743622506
(Age:12+) Recommended. The fourth in Australia's Great War series and published on the 100th anniversary of 1917, this novel concerns Alex, a young airman making reconnaissance flights over the trenches in Belgium.
I really like this series because these novels tell plausible stories based on historical fact, using authentic characters who reflect the real people revealed in the letters and documents researched for the story. Gardiner continues the style, creating a solid, captivating story which educates young Australians and allows them to feel proud of those who served, without ever glorifying war.
Alex and his comrades are heroes, but they are very much afraid of dying horribly in the ghastly war which seems without end. Flying above the trenches and photographing everything in detail for military analysis, the airmen observe the hellish conditions endured by the infantry even though they return to relatively clean, safe and warm billets upon landing. Their lot is no safer however as the life expectancy of airmen was measured in days as they fell prey to the enemy fighters flown by the likes of the famous Manfred von Richthofen (Red Baron), and the anti-aircraft fire from the ground. Sadly, a great many of their number also perished in flying accidents, either in training or during active service on the front.
The narrative is carried along via letters between Alex and his sister Maggie but this is balanced by descriptive passages in the author's voice. Alex's family are pacifists who actively protest Australia's continued participation in the war and particularly the campaign by Prime Minister Billy Hughes to introduce conscription.
The family's aversion to the war places them in a vexing position when Alex enlists for service, yet they of course share the same fear for his safety experienced by every other family of soldiers, sailors and airmen of the time.
The novel presents the Australian homefront very well. Civilians are jaded and completely fed up with the war and suffer from shortages and restrictions. Most of all, the population is sick of the endless call for men to serve the war machine which kills so many and returns the rest broken in body and spirit.
Content is not too gruesome for younger readers and I recommend the novel for twelve years and over.
Rob Welsh

What not to do if you turn Invisible by Ross Welford

cover image

HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9780008156350
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Genres: Fiction, Comedy, Magic. There are many reasons to love this funny, playful, yet emotional book. Some may know the author of this book through another of his creations; Time Travelling with a Hamster. This book undeniably conforms to its reputation. Its light and adventurous themes didn't fail to entertain me, as much as it would a middle grader, or for that matter - an adult. The reader follows a girl who has 'horrendous' zits, and who just wanted a way to cure them. With a sunbed and a mixture of untested medicines to cure her acne, she may have found the secret to invisibility (You'll have to read it to believe it). You cannot help but love the protagonist, Ethel, as she develops in many ways through the book.
Ethel has come from a rocky past and lives with her Grandmother in London. She is bullied for her excessive amounts of acne and deals with many matters in her search for identity. She makes close friends with a boy named Elliot, which is a testament to her personality. Only through this cautionary tale, does she uncover a mystery and discover her enlightened self.
I became consumed in the predicaments that you can imagine follow a girl who can become invisible. I was constantly torn between anxious suspense and guilty cries of laughter. The journey of the Ethel was very fast paced, but the author didn't fail to carry me through each scene and surround me with all of his heart-warming characters. The character development was definitely a dominating feature, and overall sold the story to me. The ending wrapped the story up perfectly, without being too heavy, or conversely unstated.
The character of Ethel has certainly earned a place in my heart. I would recommend this book to anyone from ages 10 to 100. You can only benefit from enjoying this tale.
Ethan Russell (Student)

The ABC book of places to go by Helen Martin and Judith Simpson

cover image

Ill. by Cheryl Orsini. ABC Books, 2017. ISBN 9780733334283
(Age: 3-6) Recommended. The new addition to the ABC picture book non-fiction series explores all the places families love, from the backyard, library, to faraway lands. There are 'all kinds of different places, some you know and some are new.'
Helen Martin and Judith Simpson's easy to read verses use familiar words, alliteration and animal sounds as the text flows up and down or follows the curves of paths travelled. The story is fun to read aloud, and to share as a family, discussing each scene, the different ages, lifestyles and situations presented.
Cheryl Orsini's lively scenes are bright and colourful, while different characters, from young to old and family groups, make the story visually appealing. The scenes are presented from different viewpoints, above the action - bird's eye views, the medical centre's open walls, the close-ups and picture maps.
The ABC Book of Places to Go is an excellent resource for Foundation Geography, where students learn about familiar places and build connections to them.
Rhyllis Bignell

Happy Campers by Yvette Poshoglian

cover image

Ill. by Danielle McDonald. Ella and Olivia series, bk 18. Scholastic Australia. 2017. ISBN 9781760157210
(Age: 5-7) Recommended. Ella and Olivia are sisters and best friends. Ella is seven years old and Olivia is five-and-a-half years old, they live with their mum, dad, and little brother Max. The girls are very excited about their big summer camping trip. They are sharing their fun holiday with their identical twin cousins, their aunty and uncle, even Bob the puppy is included.
When the family car is packed to overflowing with the tent, bags, camping gear, fishing rods and the totem tennis equipment, Dad realises they need a bigger vehicle. Luckily, Nanna and Grandad have a kombi van big enough for the family and all the gear.
After a long drive, Ella and Olivia help set up the tent and unload the van then it is time to play with Josh and Charlie. Climbing tall trees, sausage sizzles, toasting marshmallows, playing jokes and fun games of totem tennis make this a great start to the holiday.
The Ella and Olivia series are written specifically for young readers who are beginning to read enjoy simple plots and relatable characters. The extremely large font and line drawings support the transition from picture book to beginning novel. This is the eighteenth book in this popular series.
Rhyllis Bignell

Frazzled: Everyday disasters and impending doom by Booki Vivat

cover image

HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9780062663665
(Age: 9-12) Recommended. Themes: Confidence, Brothers and Sisters, School Life, Emotions. Booki Vivat's debut novel Frazzled introduces the emotion-charged writings and drawings of Abbie Wu, a Chinese-American girl about to journey into the great unknown - Pointdexter Middle School. Abbie suffers from middle child syndrome, Peter her older brother is good at everything and he has all the trophies to prove it. Sweet six-year-old Clara is her confident little sister, a wonderful artist who is all ready to start kindergarten. Then there is Abbie whose anxiety is overwhelming her life; she believes 'nothing good ever happens in the Middles.' Even her mother brushes off her daughter's concerns, busy with being a single parent she does not really understand Abbie's anxieties.
Even her best friends are looking forward to middle school: actress Maxine is excited to join the drama elective and Logan is excited to hone his skills as part of the computer gaming and programming group. Abbie however is so concerned with her lack of talents - she is uncoordinated, prone to stage fright, tone-deaf and technologically confused, she believes that everything is hopeless.
Abbie's hopes and dreams of delicious school cafeteria lunches are crushed. While the eighth graders enjoy tasty meals, the rest of the school lines up to receive standard soggy vegetables and bland mystery meat meals. Without an elective choice, Abbie joins all the loners and troublemakers in study hall. Here, Abbie finally discovers her special abilities.
Vivat's fun pencil and ink illustrations perfectly display Abbie's emotional lows and highs. They are complimented by the expressive text sizes and styles ranging from bold and vibrant to tiny-labelled diagrams. The contrast of black and white explodes off the pages, especially when Abby pictures her school life as a gigantic black hole.
Booki Vivat's enjoyable novel develops well-being themes including self-esteem, growing in confidence, discovering your own talents and finding your own place in the world around you.
Rhyllis Bignell

The shark caller by Dianne Wolfer

cover image

Random House, 2016. ISBN 9780143780557
(Age: 11+) Highly recommended, Sharks, Papua New Guinea, Mythology, Westernisation. Fourteen year old Izzie is on her way back to her island near Papua New Guinea with her twin brother's ashes to be scattered in the lagoon near their family business, the Sea Star Resort. She longs to see her home again, but is dismayed when she sees her old school closed, the resort looking a little worse for wear, the rainforest on a nearby island cut down. The scar left by logging has meant that tourists are less evident, the community now cannot afford a teacher and the kids must board each week at a nearby school, returning on the weekends. Later that evening she overhears the men talking about the sharks. The community's life is bound with the sharks. The men can call them and Izzie finds out that her brother was the last of the shark callers.
Her father from Broome is wrapped up with his new life and his family's pearl industry and Izzie has had little to do with him since her parents separated. Noah, her islander cousin tells her of the stories around the shark callers, letting her know that they are relying on her to do what her brother would have done, diving into a deep cave to bring back an artifact which will ensure the islanders will be able to catch more sharks, and secure the long term viability of the reef which surrounds their home. Izzie is torn. He parents had taken them away because of the myth of the shark caller, but now back, she is being besieged with the idea that she and only she can ensure the island's survival.
Noah trains her in the skills needed to get into the cave to fetch the piece of obsidian so needed for the community's survival, and so follows a breath taking account of Izzie's dive, where some things are solved but questions are left lingering.
It is wonderful to see a story set in one of our near neighbours, full of the sights and sounds of that nation, their beliefs and customs woven into the story, with a glossary at the end to acquaint readers with their language. The problems of this nation seem to replicate problems worldwide: logging of rainforest, reliance on tourist dollars, the drain of the younger people and stress on the fishing industry. A marvellous read for middle school people.
Fran Knight

Mopoke by Philip Bunting

cover image

Omnibus Books, 2017. ISBN 9781742991658
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Reading aloud, Australian animals, Humour, Word play. The opening line, This is a mopoke. states baldly what the book is about, showing the reader that there will be no excess of words and introducing a complimentary pared down colour palette for the illustrations. Readers will be enthralled and immediately begin to wonder what story lies inside. Turning the page children will laugh out loud as the author plays with the bird's name. He becomes a highpoke, then a lopoke, a poshpoke and a poorpoke, each new word encouraging the reader to tease out its meaning. On each page the mopoke stares out at the reader from his branch set (usually) in the middle of the page, inviting the reader to notice his plumage, large round eyes, clawed feet, the time setting and his environment. And a small paragraph is given on the publication page giving further details about this Australian bird.
Mopokes love peace and quiet but as the tale unfolds, he is beset with morepokes, ones that play with a yo yo, ones that play tricks, some that wear a moustache or an affro, some that wash and find they can't do anything with their hair, until crossly he disappears to make a nopoke. Readers will love the simplicity of the humour and laugh out loud when it is read to them, or take it away to read for themselves. I love the blocks of colour, reminiscent of stencils or block prints, simply placed on each page, only the mopoke's eyes betraying what he feels about all the interruptions.
A funny read aloud, the story introduces the idea that some like to be alone, and shows what one Australian animal is all about.
Fran Knight

Duck gets a job by Sonny Ross

cover image

Five Mile Press, 2017. ISBN 9781760405359
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Work, Following your dream, Humour. When Duck realises that he needs to get a job, he looks at his friends, all of whom have jobs in the city. They love their spreadsheets and encourage him to apply for a job like theirs. So he follows their lead and applies for a job and getting an interview must decide how he will look. After several swaps, he puts on a hat and takes a briefcase with him, opting for the professional look. Following advice from his friends, he gets the job and begins his work in the city. But he finds the work boring and falls asleep and so decides to quit.
He thinks hard about what he should do. He has always loved art and done well with his art work, so he puts his work into a portfolio and applies for a different job. The interviewer hires him and so he has work which he loves, and he never falls asleep.
This delightful story based firmly on the author's own experiences, will have younger children loving hearing it read aloud, or read themselves, absorbing the message of following your dreams, of not being influenced by others. The tale will be a wonderful springboard for children to share ideas about their own likes, dreams, abilities and futures. I love the illustrations, with humour for kids to find and laugh about, offering differing visions of city life, showing an obvious delineation between the job that Duck hates and the one he loves. The colours reflect Duck's mood and the duck motif is repeated in the glorious endpapers. With deceptively simple but beguiling text I loved working out just how the author had achieved his aims through the text and his illustrations.
Fran Knight

Words in deep blue by Cath Crowley

cover image

Pan Macmillan, 2016. ISBN 9781742612386
(Age: Adolescent - Adult) Recommended. This delightful novel is about the joy of writing, of love, of families, of the angst and joy of adolescence, of stories and of the place of books in today's world. Situating her story in a country town, Cath Crowley centres her story on one family who own a bookshop, who are passionate about books and reading, and who live above the shop. The struggle to survive as booksellers in today's world, is at the heart of the narrative, particularly given the threat to books, and by inference, to reading, that is potent in the novel.
The quirky and charming aspect of this shop is that many people write notes to loved ones, to friends, to those who are no longer living, or just to anyone who might, one day, find the note. Some write back, their reply encouraging friendship or relationships, and others just read the notes. The simple love of reading, of the welcoming of readers who come into the shop just to read the notes, is at the core of the novel. We know from the start that the bookshop's role in the town is threatened, and we are caught up in the underlying note of sadness - that with the demise of the shop, their lives will change drastically.
Crowley captivates her readers, inviting us into the intimate world of people's thoughts and relationships through the letters, the little love stories, the stories of those who part, and the stories of deep friendship, of loss and of recovery. Crowley has included some thought-provoking little messages at the start of each chapter, and these reflect the emotions and lives of the characters. The letter-narrative is told in the first person from a number of note-writers, while the narrative itself is told by various characters, of different ages, told in the first person. Somehow, once we get to recognize who is speaking, this quirky structure works and we begin to understand the characters in their sometimes confessional, sometimes angry, sometimes puzzled narratives. Despite the presence of change and of incipient loss, the feeling of possibility is potent, as we are caught up in the small worlds of the adolescents and the adults who live, for a brief time, in this quirky story. It is suitable for both adolescent readers and adults who are happy to read about life as experienced by adolescents, with all its angst, joy and potency.
Liz Bondar
Editor's note: This is a CBCA Notable for older readers, on longlist for the Inky Award.

Where's Wally by Martin Handford

cover image

30th Anniversary edition. Walker Books, 2017. ISBN 9781406375695
(Age: 5+) Highly recommended. Wow - 30 years ago Where's Wally first appeared and the book has lost none of its appeal over the years. When it arrived on my desk I immediately spent quite some time going through and finding the picture of Wally on different pages as he travelled around the world. I was thrilled when I did find him, but needless to say I had a few pages that completely baffled me and even returning again couldn't find the little figure with the red striped jumper and hat.
After the initial browse I went back and read the new letter from Handford to his fans and discovered some more things that the reader could search for, including the tail of Woof, making the book even more enjoyable. As the search goes on, there are lots of fascinating and humorous little figures, details and scenes which are so enjoyable that hours could be spent perusing the pages.
This is a wonderful book to give children as a gift and it will also keeping the family occupied for hours. In the library make sure that no one marks where Wally is and spoils the fun!
Pat Pledger

The fix-it man by Dimity Powell and Nicky Johnston

cover image

EK Books, 2017. ISBN 9781925335347
Dads can fix anything - that's what dads do. Kites, kennels, teapots - whatever is needed. He can even cobble together a rug made of rainbows and old hugs for mum - but he can't fix mum. Not even with his special peach and honey brew. Even the doctors and lots of rest can't fix mum. Not even all the love in the world. And no matter how hard they try, little girls can't mend broken hearts - not hers, not dad's and not Tiger's. Well, not with sticky tape or glue or needle and thread. But dad has one more special thing up his sleeve and together they start to mend.
This is a poignant story of loss and one that will resonate with many children who have lost a parent or other loved one. With its gentle text and soft palette, even though it is sad, it is not gloomy because the love between this family oozes from the page and from that, the hope is tangible. And the threads that bind the family are stronger and more enduring than nails, glue, sticky-tape or any other kind of man-made adhesive or fastening.
Grief is a natural part of life and while we might like to protect our children from it, nevertheless it happens and we often struggle helping them to cope with their loss. This book allows conversations to start and explores the way it is an emotion that we each express and deal with in our own way. Dad's lap is cosy and warm but his face is crumpled and wet; pieces spill out from Tiger's heart and little girls try to do what they can to paper over the cracks - but they are too wide. But together...
Whether shared as a 1:1 or as a class, it offers children the opportunity to talk about losses in their life and to learn that they are not alone in feeling lonely, lost, scared and even betrayed but there is love and it does get easier.
Barbara Braxton

Freeks by Amanda Hocking

cover image

Pan Macmillan, 2017. ISBN 9781509807659
(Age: 15+) Freeks by Amanda Hocking is an exciting and fast paced novel about a young girl called Mara and her life in a travelling circus alongside her mother and friends. Set in 1987, Mara's colourful travelling companions are desperate to find their next short stop as they scrounge for their livelihood going from town to town and looking to attract large crowds. Their main appeal to the public is their one-of-a-kind circus performances which includes fire dancers, tigers, magic tricks, a house of horrors, the sideshow, a Ferris wheel and more. But these are not the ordinary attractions of just any circus, half of the population whom live with the travelling show have abilities that breach the border between the natural and supernatural. On their way to their next stop (like it or not for Mara and company), many members of the troop get bad feelings about the upcoming town which put many at unease, and these feelings worsen when one of their own wanders from the camp for longer than her usual spells of absence. It's up to Mara to interpret the signs shown to her and take care with the inhabitants of the town, and find if the town brings out more in Mara than she first anticipated.
Freeks is a captivating story that indulges its readers to the engaging internal dialogue of Mara which helps add to the mystery and thrill of the story as we interpret the events that unfold both through our own eyes as well as hers. This novel is better suited for an older teenage audience due to both adult and violent themes. Overall, Freeks is an exciting read that is refreshing and leaves the reader looking for more fantastic writing by Amanda Hocking.
Sarah Filkin (University student)

My brother is a beast by Damon Young

cover image

Ill. by Peter Carnavas. UQP, 2017. ISBN 9780702259579
(age: 4+) Highly recommended. Siblings, Family, Rhyming story, Read aloud. From the creators of My sister is a superhero, comes an equally funny sequel, where her brother is a beast. In a series of eight line stanzas, the first three double lines tell of what other brothers do:
Some brothers scrub with sponges
to clean glue from dirty doors',

each set of six lines ending with the refrain,
'But my brother is a beast . . . '
The repetition is infectious and the repeated last two lines will have kids in gales of laughter, working out what the rhyme will be, following the antics of the beastie brother.
Each page is filled with colour and laughter, movement and music as the brothers show their skills at playing drums, or the bassoon, or harp, or clean the stables, or make a table, or row a canoe. But towards the end of the story, the children are tiring out as the brothers sleep in a hammock, or laze in an armchair, while the beast of a brother makes a cave of sheets for his sister to sleep in.
Carnavas' watercolour and ink illustrations suit the mood of the story beautifully as he repeats the round eyed children motif, and children will watch out for the array of animals he includes on each page. Children will love to read this book aloud, reading along with the older reader, predicting rhymes for themselves. The book lends itself to making up lines using the model given in the book, and drawing the children in different situations, using Carnavas' drawings as a template. I can imagine lots of brainstorming of lines, 'Some brothers . . . ' and 'But my brother . . . ', encouraging younger readers to learn about rhyme, rhythm and metre at an early age.
Fran Knight

Silver in the blood by Jessica Day George

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781681190242
(Age; 13+) Recommended. In the peak of youthful society of 1890's New York, two young cousins, Lou and Darcia, are at their social prime with constant attention turned on them as they are the mixed blood of a wealthy New York family and an ancient Romanian line. With vague warning, both girls are caught up in a whirlwind trip to finally engage with their Romanian relatives and connect to their ancient heritage. The trip is long and with it, more questions and strange situations appear and are discussed in letters and journal entries from both girls. Once in her home country, Darcia is frustrated by her Aunt Kate's sudden change in personality; what could make someone go from being like a mother, to a prison guard. Darcia demands to find out what is the real reason they were suddenly brought back to Romania and why everyone she knows and loves is starting to act incredibly strange. By the end, neither girl will ever be the same again.
Jessica Day George writes Silver in the Blood in such a way that captures the reader's attention and really makes the 1890's in America, Paris and Romania burst with life, painting a very relatable and realistic scene for her characters to interact. With reference to another well-known novel from the time, Silver in the Blood is exciting for readers of fantasy and mystery. This novel is recommended for an teenage audience (13+) due to themes of violence and romance. A fantastic read that leaves readers hoping for more stories about the two cousins, Darcia and Lou.
Sarah Filkin (University student)

This is Banjo Paterson by Tania McCartney

cover image

Ill. by Christina Booth. NLA Publishing, 2017. ISBN 9780642278982
(Ages: 4-8) Highly recommended. Tania McCartney and Christina Booth's beautifully crafted picture book celebrates one of Australia's most iconic legends, Andrew 'Banjo' Paterson.
The descriptive narrative focuses on his rural upbringing and the people who influenced his life's journey. Young Barty as he was known enjoyed his bush childhood, helping on the farm, riding his horse Banjo to school, watching polo matches and horse shows. He enjoyed listening to Jerry the Rhymer's tales about his bush life. His grandma loved poetry as well and she shared her love of language and rhyme with her grandson, whilst he boarded at her Sydney home. His teenage years were filled with school, sports, and his creative writing as well. This picture book tells of these special people in his life and the influences and events that moulded his life and developed his journalism career. He also worked in the legal field, as a farmer, vet, jockey and most famously as a writer. Tania includes special moments, the inspiration for 'Waltzing Matilda', his marriage and his children. The story ends with the beginning stanzas of 'The man from Snowy River'.
What sets this book apart from other biographies written for younger children, are the beautiful watercolour illustrations by Christina Booth. Here is a duality of storyline pictured visually, each vignette shows today's children dressed in summer clothes acting out the scenes. There is backyard cricket, Barty with a bush hat riding his hobbyhorse and sharing picnics under the clothesline with family and friends. Speech bubbles add to the commentary, rhymes, statements and exclamations, as well as witty thoughts by his dog who just wants a walk or to play catch.
Sharing these with a class, with a young audience at kindergarten or preschool is a wonderful experience, opening up conversations about life, changes, growing up and people who are important in their lives. Even the scenes of leaving for war and the time when Paterson went missing in France during World War 1 are sensitively illustrated.
Tania McCartney has included a description of Banjo Paterson's life in a newspaper format - 'The Snowy River Times'. Photos, copies of original illustrations and the music to 'Waltzing Matilda' provide additional information. This factual material and additional poetry are a great beginning for research topics. Dressing up and acting the scenes, making a wooden and bark hut, singing along to 'Waltzing Matilda' and unpacking the text are all wonderful learning opportunities. This is Banjo Paterson is an exciting collaboration by McCartney and Booth, perfect for sharing at home and in an education environment.
Rhyllis Bignell