Reviews

Landing with wings written and illustrated by Trace Balla

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2020. ISBN 9781760296957.
(Age: 7-12 years). Highly recommended. Landing with wings is a beautifully written book which draws the reader in with a delightful story, gentle caring characters and wonderfully detailed graphic illustrations. It is set in Dja Dja Wurrung Country and throughout the story, reference to places, plants, animals and birds is often made in the language of the traditional owners. Landing with wings is the story of Miri and her mother who have moved once more - this time from the warmth of the north to the goldfields of Victoria. Miri is tiring of moving and leaving things behind especially the tea-tree that she writes to in her journal and shares her new life experiences with detailed observations. Miri makes friends with her neighbours, Wingo and Swee Ling, who give Miri and her mother the start they need to become a part of the local community. Wingo and Miri spend time together building a larger pond for the resident frog which they learn is a Bibron's toadlet and through this collective task they learn more about each other. Swee Ling gives Miri an old, rusty bike and with Wingo she is able to explore the local landscape. Wingo is descended from the traditional owners of the land and shares his deep knowledge with Miri.
Throughout this story the reader has the opportunity to learn new and fascinating facts as well as being able to look intently at each page to fully appreciate the finely detailed images. The author shares her absorbing journey with this book in notes at the end. Endpapers at the beginning of the book also give the names of birds, plant and animals in the local language. The imagery and words by Trace Balla communicate a poignant and thoughtful story which will resonate with audiences both young and old. Teacher's tips and activities are available. Themes: Friendship, Australian wildlife, Aboriginal culture, Moving, New communities, New experiences.
Kathryn Beilby

Jacinda Ardern, a new kind of leader by Madeleine Chapman

cover image

Nero, 2020. ISBN: 9781760641818.
(Age: Senior secondary - Adult) Highly recommended. A book about Jacinda Ardern - Yes! I want to read it! For readers who feel like me, this book sets out her life in orderly chapters, from her early childhood in small town Murupara as the daughter of the local policeman, her time as student representative in the slightly larger Morrinsville, and her career moving through the hierarchy of the Labour Party; but while it is all faithfully recorded with an often slightly amusing twist of words, for someone who wants the inside on this world renown leader, I have to say, it does disappoint a little. But maybe that is not the fault of the biographer, for whilst the book is the result of extensive research, listed in the sources at the end, there is no intimate revelation from the subject or anybody close to her. Jacinda Ardern remains a private person; we have to work it out for ourselves.
However it is interesting that Ardern was raised as a Mormon. Her friendships with LGBTQIA+ people in her later student years led her to break from the theology, whilst still retaining family and community ties. Perhaps it was that mix of moral values and discovery of social justice issues that marked the beginnings of the person she is today, and the values of kindness and fairness that she espouses.
In her chapter on 'Helen and Jacinda', Chapman leads us into a thoughtful exploration of the world of politics for female leaders, comparing the stern and brusquely efficient style of Helen Clark 'beating men at their own game', and Jacinda Ardern, initially described as a 'pretty little thing' or 'babe', combining a natural warmth and empathy with a determination and dedication to achieve Labour Party goals. Chapman suggests that Ardern's style benefitted from her ability to communicate via social media as well as her steady focus on the important issues.
And of course, Ardern's response to the Christchurch terrorist attack in 2019 stands as an example of compassionate and caring leadership, attracting worldwide praise. Churchman examines the highs and lows of Ardern's time as Prime Minister, and whether she has delivered the transformation that she promised. Ultimately it will be up to the next election as to whether New Zealanders want to continue with this 'new kind of leader'.
Senior secondary students of politics will find interesting chapters in this book suitable for thoughtful discussion, particularly the challenges for women in politics, the idea of wellbeing at the centre of government policy, and the model of leadership that expresses empathy and compassion in a world where many leaders embody the opposite. And there is the bonus of two key Ardern speeches included in full - NZ National Statement to the United Nations General Assembly, 2018, and the Statement on Christchurch Mosque Terror Attack, 2019.
Themes: Biography, New Zealand, Women in leadership, Politics, Terrorism, Kindness.
Helen Eddy

I don't want to be quiet by Laura Ellen Anderson

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2020. ISBN: 9781526602442. 32pp.
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. The heroine of this uproariously funny tale loves to be noisy. She chats, laughs and claps in school despite being asked by the teacher to listen. She stomps down stairs, drums with the spoons and hums when Mum has asked for quiet. She cannot help herself: clanging, stomping, slurping, crunching, splashing and even burping. She and the class go into the library where everyone else sits down to read a book, but she interrupts, complaining it is too quiet. When everyone tells her that she must be quiet, and the page has a row of 'shh' across the top, she takes down a book like the others and finds herself spellbound.
In rhyming lines, the story of the girl's change of heart unfolds. Reading out loud would be thrilling for the audience, involved in the tale of this too loud girl and the words which describe the noises she makes. Kids will love the rhymes, predicting the rhyming word at the end of each pair of lines, deciding what noise will go with each word, standing up to make the stomping or clapping or slurping or clanging words along with the reader.
And the illustrations too will entreat younger readers to look at the young girl, surrounded by illustrative techniques which show noise.
No child can be quiet when her mouth is wide open, or sit surrounded by exclamation marks, or jumping down stairs, or sploshing through puddles: each page reflects the noise of the child, just as the last few pages reflect the quiet time as she reads a book. A playful list of rhyming words, enhanced with wonderfully apt illustrations will make this a favourite read aloud and join in book. Themes: Quietness, Noise, Reading, Read aloud, Family, Verse.
Fran Knight

Isla's family tree by Katrina McKelvey and Prue Pittock

cover image

EK Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781925820379. 32pp., hbk.
Isla's family is about to grow and she is not happy. "This family is full", she declares.
So her mother sits her down and explains how families are like trees - they have a trunk that is formed by the grandparents, branches formed by their children and then the leaves are the children of those children like Isla and her cousins. Isla begins to understand but when she learns that her mum is to have two babies, then there is no room for any more leaves on her branch and the family is definitely full.
The prospect of a new baby entering an already tight-knit family is very common and can be very confronting to a child who is used to being the only one, so this approach to explaining the upcoming event is one that will appeal to many parents. Promoting it with your parent community would be a great way to promote the school library's relationship with that community.
However it would also have a valuable place in the early childhood classroom as children investigate their families and their structure. Not all of Isla's family have the traditional formation of mother, father and children so there is scope for each child to make their own tree and show and share that families can have all sorts of shapes, just as trees and their leaves do, perhaps bringing comfort to those who might see themselves as being different.
Investigating their own origins is always a surefire winner with young children because it deeply connects to their own lives and there are as many branches to explore as there are in the family tree. The concepts of birthdays, naming, physical appearance and genetics, development and maturation, vocabulary building . . . the list is almost endless with lots of other stories that can be shared as well. There are teachers' notes available.
It also helps children understand that their trepidation when faced with the same sort of news and change is normal, that sometimes we have to change a little ourselves so we can adapt to that change but that's what people do and it can help us grow too.
Another example of how what appears to be a simple picture book for young readers can open up a world of possibilities.
Barbara Braxton

Old enough to save the planet by Loll Kirby

cover image

Illustrated by Adelina Lirius. Magic Cat Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781916180529.
(Age: 8-13) Highly recommended. Old enough to save the planet by Loll Kirby is a thoughtfully presented non-fiction book which clearly gives an easy and understandable insight into many aspects that are contributing to climate change. Each of the twelve child activists have chosen a different facet of climate change to focus on and through their efforts encourage other children and adults to be aware of pressing issues which can be addressed in very simple and worthwhile ways. Three of the activists include Himangi from India who is a campaigner for reducing the effects of traffic pollution outside her school, Eunita from Kenya who is the founder of a community garden that promotes the natural process of pollination, as well as Shalise from Australia who protects the ocean by cleaning up human pollution from the shore.
Each activist has a double page spread which gives a brief introduction to the issue and how they are working to help solve the problem. The detailed and beautifully drawn illustrations by Adelina Lirius are interspersed with relevant and interesting facts. In the final pages of the book is information about how you can help to save the planet as well as ten things you can do to make your voice heard.
This is an important book that may inspire more children to follow in the footsteps of these young climate change activists. A great resource for teachers with the opportunity to do further research on this very significant and serious topic. Themes: Child activists, Climate change, Environmental issues, Conservation, Sustainability, Working together.
Kathryn Beilby

Between two evils by Eva Dolan

cover image

Zigic & Ferreira. Bloomsbury, 2020. ISBN: 9781408886441.
(Age: Senior secondary, Adult) Highly recommended. Between two evils is the parallel stories of abuse. One takes place within the locked precincts of a female immigration detention centre, the other evolves from the overturning of a case of rape due to DNA evidence being brought into question. DS Ferreire and DI Zigic are tested ethically and morally as this team from Peterborough sort through a maze of secretive bureaucracy and downright manipulation to get at the truth and a conviction.
The murder of Dr. Joshua Ainsworth in his home just outside the detention centre where he works in the medical clinic is brutal, and it seems connected with his job. Ainsworth is an enigma. Some speak highly of him, as a caring, ethical doctor working in a difficult situation. Others, like the demonstrators outside the centre, see him as part of an evil and repressive government regime. The privately run Long Fleet detention centre was not exactly forthcoming with information, putting a wall of data protection and privacy legislation as excuses.
The other blow to the investigative team came when news broke that Lee Walton a serial rapist and murderer had been released due to problems with the examination of DNA evidence. It had been a long and difficult case which now seemed all for nothing. But Walton then begins to threaten Ferreire to reestablish his contacts with his wife and son who had been moved away for their own protection.
It seems the only way to put Walton away is to reopen an old case. A case which on the surface was watertight being finalised with a confession. A confession that was given after a series of interrogations by their current superior. A clandestine investigation carried out without knowledge of most of the team and always with the threat of it blowing up in their faces.
With the background of racism, bigotry and politics this is a story of the present not just applicable to the United Kingdom and Australia, but universally where conservatism and misplaced nationalism are on the rise.
This is the first of Dolan's Ferreira and Zigic novels I have read. There four others in the series; Long way home, Tell no tales, After you die and Watch her disappear. It may be helpful to have read others in giving a background to the protagonists, which coming in cold did assume prior knowledge. However Dolan's writing hauls you into the narrative and the 468 pages seem to fly by. Themes: Crime fiction, Detention centres, Rape, DNA.
Mark Knight

Lola Dutch I love you so much by Kenneth Wright and Sarah Jane Wright

cover image

Bloomsbury, ISBN: 9781547601172.
(Age: 4-6) Kenneth and Sarah Jane Wright's third picture book Lola Dutch I love you so much is another delightful, creative story based on the five love languages.
Lola's friends aren't having a very good day. Gator is feeling cold and cranky, while Crane's favourite picture book is lost, and Pig is just positively peevish. Lola always brims with positivity and creativity; she knows the perfect solution for their problems. Using resources from around their house she sews a bold yellow stripe outfit for Gator, tidies up books scattered everywhere and creates a special book nook for Crane. Pig feels a little left out until Lola packs up a picnic and they all set off for the park. What about friend Bear? Of course, there is something special for her friend. Lola too, is not forgotten and all her friends show their love with a special party.
What a charming story to share with youngsters; Lola Dutch is a caring friend, thinking of others and always wanting to make her friends happy. This is based on the Wright's own family as they share the message of thinking about others, being creative and using home resources to cheer others up. Sarah Jane Wright's soft watercolour scenes add to the charm and joie de vivre expressed in the easy to read text. The jacket cover includes a cute party scene, two puppets and special note to share, with additional resources available online. Themes: Love, Friendship, Creativity.
Rhyllis Bignell

Wildlife rescue by Meredith Costain

cover image

Illus. by Danielle McDonald. Ella Diaries book 18. Scholastic, 2020. ISBN: 9781743832301.
(Age: 6-9 years). Wildlife Rescue is the eighteenth book in the very popular Ella Diaries series. The books are all centred on Ella's diary writing where she shares her day-to-day activities and personal thoughts. She writes with humour, and not so correct spelling at times, but her diaries are entertaining and keep the reader engaged. In this particular book Ella and her best friends, Ammy and Zoe, discover an abandoned baby possum in the local park. Ella immediately wants to help the possum and with support from her Dad finds the Wildlife Rescue Centre which sends out a wildlife carer, Michele, to collect the baby possum. Overnight Ella imagines all the terrible things that could befall the possum and persuades her father to take her to the Rescue Centre. There she meets Michele's granddaughter Harper who shows Ella around the Centre. Both girls have a great deal in common and become firm friends. Meanwhile Ammy has an important soccer game to prepare for and Zoe is busy with dance and Ella feels her friends are not being as supportive as usual. There is a misunderstanding surrounding the Open Day at the Wildlife Rescue Centre but eventually the girls resolve their friendship issues.
The bright green colour is predominant throughout this book and the simple comic style drawings by Danielle McDonald keep the reader focused on the story and help support young readers who can easily comprehend the text. Themes: Diaries, Friendship, Wildlife Rescue, Australian Animals.
Kathryn Beilby

Taking down Evelyn Tait by Poppy Nwosa

cover image

Wakefield Press, 2020. ISBN: 9781743056974.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Always getting into trouble, temper flaring and hyperactive, Lottie reacts and says things she shouldn't and invariable ends up in the principal's office. Not that she cares, she has developed a free and easy manner with Jerry, or Mr Virk as the other students know him, and enjoys her time on the couch in front of his desk. She doesn't understand how everyone in the school seems to be sucked in by Miss Perfect, Evelyn Tait, the girl intent on undermining her and turning her life upside down. Now Lottie faces suspension - unless she can work out a plan, turn the tables, and become more perfect than Miss Perfect. Her long-time childhood buddy Jude, the boy across the balcony from her apartment building, encourages her to become nicer and kinder than Evelyn, and expose Evelyn's insincerities.
Lottie is a very loveable character, she charges through this story, unaware of her impact on others, the long suffering Jude, her steadfast best friend Grace, even her own family, in disarray following her parent's divorce and father's remarriage. The challenge from Jude, originally motivated by Lottie's vengeance towards Evelyn, gradually becomes a new way of behaving, and perhaps Lottie will finally discover the true meaning of 'sonder', the realisation that others have a life as complex as one's own.
I read this book in one sitting; the main characters drew me in so easily, and I wanted to know what happened. While some of the themes are very familiar - vengeance against the mean girl, rebellion against the step-parent, the childhood friend who turns into a boyfriend - the way they are explored in this novel seems very true to life, and it is so well written. This is not a thriller in the style of The twin by Natasha Preston, though the two books share many themes, Taking down Evelyn Tait is very grounded in real life, sharing more with the loveable You must by Layla by Yassmin Abdel-Magied.
Nwosa's book is a sympathetic study of divided families, LGBQTI+ relationships, and developing teenage identity learning to negotiate relationships with others. I thoroughly recommend this book for adolescent readers.
Themes: Rivalry, Divorce, Kindness, Friendship, Love.
Helen Eddy

B is for baby by Atinuke

cover image

Illus. by Angela Brooksbank. Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781406390872. 40pp.
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. With the letter B as its main spring, this seductively charming tale of a baby in a West African community sings with the sights and sounds of life in the village. The baby climbs into a basket of bananas, hiding from her brother as he gets onto his bicycle, en route to see his grandfather, Baba. The bumpy ride takes him past a baobab tree as he sees a number of things beginning with B: a butterfly, bird, bus and bridge amongst the sights. On reaching Baba, he reaches into the basket to get a banana and finds the baby!
All great fun as the baby and her brother are given biscuits by Baba and over the next two pages the B words are reiterated.
This is a wonderful read aloud: children will marvel at the words beginning with B in the village, and see the world in which the baby and her brother live. The African background is there for all to see: from the beads used to plait the baby's hair, the basket woven by Mum, the bananas picked from the garden, the baobab tree, baboons, bougainvillea, banana palms and Grandfather's bungalow.
Brooksbank is inspired by the playful spirit and energy of children and these characteristics are replicated in her illustrations in this book and her previous book, Baby goes to market (2017) her first picture book with Atunike. The colourful, lively illustrations portray life in the village as a vibrant, closely knit, family centred life, full of humour. Themes: Africa, Baby, Family, Alphabet, Humour.
Fran Knight

Wayside School: Beneath the cloud of doom by Louis Sachar

cover image

Illus. by Tim Heitz. Bloomsbury, 2020. ISBN: 9781526623423.
(Age: 7-10 years). Recommended. Louis Sachar has written the fourth book in his popular series, Wayside School after a twenty-five year hiatus. Beneath the Cloud of Doom is complete with familiar characters, both teachers and students, as well as an impending Cloud of Doom hovering above Wayside School. Wayside School is 30 storeys high with one class on each floor. All sorts of unusual sounding bells ring every day with different meanings to keep both teachers and students on their toes. Throughout the short chapters the characters on the thirtieth floor and their idiosyncrasies are reintroduced in a humorous and entertaining way. Their teacher is Mrs Jewls who has a DISCIPLINE board in her classroom where students must write their names if they do something wrong. There is Kathy who has a bad case of oppositosis and always appears to be rude. After she visits the on-site school medico Dr Pickle, changes occur in her manner. Terence who counts up the number of things he can kick during the day. Dana who can make funny faces but one goes mysteriously wrong with unusual consequences. Mrs Surlaw is the Librarian who organises both fiction and nonfiction books into the number of pages collection. Jason has chosen one with 999 pages as he tries to outdo another student. All of the students must face the Ultimate Test which has some amazing events such as upside down singing, blindfold smelling plus Jump Rope Arithmetic and Stairway Quiz. Added to the general day-to-day goings on in the busy school is a huge black cloud suspended over the school which causes anxiety and major complications for everyone. Louis Sachar himself features prominently in the book as the PE teacher who helps support the Principal and the students.
Students in the middle primary years will enjoy the humour and fast paced storyline. Clever illustrations by Tim Heitz are spaced throughout the book and add to the overall appeal of this easy and entertaining read. Themes: Humour, School, Teachers, Classmates, Mysterious happenings.
Kathryn Beilby

10 little figs by Rhian Williams and Nathaniel Eckstrom

cover image

Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781921977312. 32pp.
Recommended. 10 little figs is a sweet rhyming picture book by Rhian Williams and Nathaniel Eckstrom. It centres around a little boy who is desperate to pick and eat the 10 figs that are ripe and ready on his tree. Much to his dismay, a range of Australian animals come along and one by one steal a delicious fig. Luckily his Dad comes along and picks the last one, just in time!
The book is great for a number of reasons. Firstly the illustrations; they are colourful, lively and enjoyable to look at. They have hidden clues for the following animal and also made us jealous of the wonderful backyard this little boy has. Secondly, I really loved that you can work on counting down numbers from 10 to 0 which is always a bonus for young children 5 and under. Lastly I loved the range of Australian animals showcased. There were the popular ones such as the echidna and wombat but also ones we were not as familiar with such as the leaf-curling spider and Hercules Moth. The final page gives a simple visual of 10 to 0 figs plus the animals who stole one! We used this page for counting, recall and as a reference for what numbers look like. Teacher activities are available in Walker's Story Time kit.
Overall we give this book 4 out of 5
Lauren Fountain

Run, rebel by Manjeet Mann

cover image

Penguin, 2020. ISBN: 9780241411421.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Written in short verses on each page, this novel thrums with the beat of spoken poetry that captures the intense feelings of a young girl, Amber, who loves to run, but whose dreams of being an athlete look like they will never be realised. She is bound by the built in fears of family and community - fear of a father who is most often drunk and violent, and fear of the punishment meted to those who offend the family honour, like the girl who died at the hands of her father just across the street. It's an oppression carried through generations. Amber's parents are illiterate, her mother was beaten and taught submission, Amber's sister Ruby was married off young, and Amber knows that she also has to obey.
Mann's choice of verse form gives her the ability to go straight to the heart of the matter, to express intense feelings with minimal words. We live Amber's thoughts and fears. We feel the fear build up, the anxiety about being seen in the street with a boy after school, the violence that erupts when her father comes home drunk and angry. And we also see how her own anger turns her into a bully at school.
Amber actually asks herself the question of whether she is the same as her father - angry and violent. It is a question also explored in Rafi Mittlefehldt's What makes us (2019) - do genetic inheritance and environment combine to make children inevitably repeat the patterns of their parents? For Amber, as with Eran, in Mittlefehldt's novel, it is a teacher who makes the difference, as well as the loyalty of good friends. Amber has a teacher who encourages her athletic aspirations, and a history teacher who with his enthusiasm opens her eyes to ways to make change. The principles of revolution become the phases that she goes through toward self-assertion and independence.
The way this book is written, with its headings, succinct verses and highlighted words makes it very accessible to the generation who enjoys slam/rap poetry and the short burst interaction of social media. It is very powerful, raw and honest, and no doubt its immediacy and the themes it illuminates will resonate with young adult readers.
Themes: Domestic violence, Cultural expectations, Identity, Bullying, Anger.
Helen Eddy

Meet Eve in the outback by Raewyn Caisley

cover image

Illus. by Karen Blair. Aussie Kids series. Puffin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760894108. 64pp.
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Another in this fine series offering easy to read chapter books for the newly independent reader in junior school. Each of the eight books, set in the different states and territories of Australia, presents a family in a situation not quite known to the reader. The familiarity of the family situation give the books a solid foundation with an overlay of adventure.
Eve lives in a roadhouse on the Nullarbor Plain and cannot wait for her cousin, Will to arrive from the city. A postcard to the reader on the first two pages shows us where Eve lives and she tells us a little of her unusual life.
When Will arrives they explore the area, meeting kangaroos, and Wally an old digger who teaches them how to make billy tea and damper and tells them about the camel train, once an important part of the travel regime of outback people. Through easy to read short chapters, Eve's life is revealed to an admiring audience, the story full of interest and delight.
The others in this series are listed in the back of the book and will prove a hit with early readers and teachers looking to keep them engaged, while learning a little of Australia as well. Themes: Outback, Western Australia, Desert.
Fran Knight

Meet Katie at the beach by Rebecca Johnson

cover image

Illus. by Lucia Masciullo. Aussie kids series. Puffin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760893675. 64pp.
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Eight stories, each one set in a different state or territory around Australia will please younger readers looking for a series of books for their emerging competency with reading. Each book is short, with copious illustrations, divided into six or so chapters, with a level of reading suited to the newly acquired skills but not in any way watered down. The language is engaging and some longer words are included to stretch the new readers. Each book contains a map to locate the story, some interesting facts that come out of the story and a list of the others in the series. Each story is placed within a family and children will feel some familiarity with the setting.
Meet Katie at the beach has a family living in a high rise apartment near the beach in Queensland, packing their towels and esky for some time at the beach. Katie has some pain in her mouth as one of her teeth is very wobbly and she is unsure about going. But once on the beach she and her siblings build a castle and play in the water, body surfing with Dad until Katie notices there her tooth is missing. A search follows.
All comes together nicely and readers will have absorbed a lot of information about being safe on the beach and how one group of Australians live. Themes: Australia, Queensland, Humour, Beach.
Fran Knight