Reviews

Malcolm and Juliet by Bernard Beckett

cover image

Text Publishing, 2009. ISBN 9781921520327
(Ages 14+)Recommended. A group of 16 year olds in various schools, all with some connection, each with their own idiosyncrasies, are mixed up with Malcolm, intent on winning this year's science prize with his research into the first sexual experiences of his peers. What you get is rather wry, but very funny novel about teens and their activities. Beckett hits just the right note of humour in this look at teenage conduct and his mix of a range of adolescents is masterful, as the climax swings into view.
Kevin lusts after Brian who lusts after Charlotte who lusts after Malcolm, who thinks he has no show of seeing Charlotte, but his friend Juliet who is being blackmailed, tries to setup a sex talk line and lands Brian, who finding out who the voice on the end of the line belongs to, is chasing her. Complicated? No the novel glides along smoothly and wittily, making me laugh out loud as Malcolm asks the oddest of people to be interviewed. At one stage his mum consents to be interviewed and we hear of her first sexual experience, and Charlotte, who is a virgin, details what she hopes to be her first experience, and Malcolm, knowing he could never match her description, gives up on her. Very funny, lots of witty looks at teenage culture, hits at education, principals, predatory males, and culture.
So Romeo, sorry Malcolm, must avoid all the pitfalls of blighted love to reach his goal. His inexperience, combined with his goal of winning the science prize, makes him an amiable protagonist, one we all want to succeed. A marvelous novel for teens of all ages to read and share.
Fran Knight

Sharp Shot by Jack Higgins and Justin Richards

cover image

Harper Collins, 2009. (Series: Danger runs in the family)
(Ages 12+) John Chance on a dangerous mission in Iraq in 1990, sets the scene for an equally danger filled operation today as his two children are kidnapped by an old enemy, blackmailing him to return a statue left in the desert all those years go. The stage is set for a thrilling, fast paced adventure as the twins, Jade and Rich must make some fast and decisive decisions while their father is away.
Escaping a group of highly armed and dangerous killers, Jade and Rich throw in their lot with the stranger who came to their door asking for help. They realise that he is not what he seems when Rich is taken by the pursuers, and Jade, left with McCain, comes to understand that she is being held. Their father, in an effort to free Jade, complies with McCain's requests, and in coming to the desert to swap the statue for the girl, is left with his small party alone and bereft of anything which may save their lives. But in the manner of all good thrillers, they are rescued, and can then fight back.
A credible, page turning adventure, this story, one in a series about the Chance twins, will please high spirited upper primary and lower secondary readers, wanting something closer than World War Two, and complete with descriptions of the weaponry and technology now used in war and peace.
Fran Knight

The absolutely true diary of a part-time Indian by Sherman Alexie

cover image

Anderson Press, 2008. ISBN 9781842708445
Highly Recommended. Humour belies the undercurrent of poverty and despair tugging at the heels of the diarist, Arnold, as he tries to alter the accepted path for boys like him. He enrolls at a more academic school, twenty miles from his homeland. That the school is a white middle class institution in a town where Arnold and his people from the nearby Spokane Indian Reservation are not wanted makes for some cutting and deft observations about racism. Drawing heavily on his background, Sherman Alexie is able to nimbly circumvent political correctness and tell it like it is. Arnold's teacher gives out the geometry books on the first day of high school. Arnold is keen to get stuck into this new subject, and when he opens the book to find it was used by his mother, 30 years before, he knows that he will never break out of the mold. Opportunities given to Indigenous kids are just not there. At the nearby white school, he finds himself the only Indian student in a sea of white faces. The customs at his last school must be unlearned, his culture put behind him and his loyalties divided between the two worlds he inhabits. Some people on the 'rez' avoid him, his best friend deserts him, but some are proud, and his uncle calls him a warrior for doing something so brave.
In different hands this book could have been cheesy and even insulting, but Alexie's intimate knowledge of the reservation makes this a uniquely powerful read. The story cries out for recognition of the Indian plight. Moved to reservations with little opportunity for employment or activities, poor education and blighted by racism, Arnold speaks for his generation. The path he chooses is burdened with pitfalls however, in having to live a divided life, being seen as a traitor on one hand, and a curiosity on the other.
The debate over indigenous people writing their own stories flourishes, none more vocal than the website hosted by Debbie Reese in USA. She applauds the writing of indigenous people, particularly American Indians, and deplores the writing of non indigenous writers using an indigenous point of view. Her views are widely used and her website often quoted. The recent issue of Fiction Focus, an adolescent fiction journal from the Western Australia Education Department, outlines some of the current debate about indigenous writers writing their own stories, in an article called Whose Story? Indigenous Peoples in Fiction, and gives information about some of the books written by indigenous writers, including the excellent, The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian by Sherman Alexie.To find out more about Sherman Alexie's background, go to http://www.fallsapart.com/. And to find out about the reservation he grew up on, visit, the official website for the Spokane Tribe in Washington.
Studying this novel in the classroom would be a knockout for lower secondary kids. It will turn their faces to the reality of living in an indigenous community whether in Australia or USA or New Zealand. Stories written by other indigenous authors could be studied, and some written by non indigenous authors could be looked at to compare the tone. As part of a unit of study about racism or prejudice or specifically North American Indians, this novel has all points covered. I would expect that many schools will buy this as a class set.
Fran Knight

Nina of the dark by Ken Catran

cover image

HarperCollins, 2009. ISBN 9781869506650 (Age 11+) Recommended. A gripping fantasy called Nina's Saga is told by Bard the Restless. A slave called Nina is the heroine. She is the one who must overcome the darkness and the multitude of evil creatures which threaten to kill her and her companions, a thief and a giant, for she is a thumb hurter. The plot is dense with unusual creatures and the Rut army wanting to outwit Nina and her allies. The plot moves swiftly for Catran uses imagery beautifully and the poetry foretells the coming battles. Nina becomes an awe inspiring leader who rejects the treasure and finds Lightskin, a costume of silver chain mail which fits her perfectly and Brightsong, a sword with a red-braided hilt and ruby set scabbard, damaged but with no pommel stone. The minor characters are strong and believable and add to the intensity as the drama unfolds. There is scope for a sequel.
Sue Nosworthy

A Midsummer Night's Dream by William Shakespeare. Retold by Robert Swindells

cover image

A & C Black, 2009. ISBN 9781408104361
Swindells has taken on a task which would daunt many people: retelling Shakespeare's stories for a young audience in the twenty first century. Using contemporary language, but with a sprinkling of the Bard's words still intact, Swindells captures the essence of this funny play with ease.
Divided into the same five acts, the story of love and desire meets the play within the play, as Oberon, playing a trick on his love, Titania, has a potion poured onto her eyelid so that she will love the first person she sees on waking. He has the same thing done to Demetrius, in the hope that the first person he sees is Helena, who loves him passionately. But his scheme fails, and both Lysander and Demetrius spy Helena, and follow her blindly, leaving poor Hermia to wonder where her love, Lysander has got to.
In the meantime, Titania has woken and spies Bottom, one of the characters from the play within the play, dressed as an ass. She falls hopelessly in love with the ass and they wind flowers through their hair in her bower. Oberon must turn around the night's fun to regain Titania's love and put the lovers together again.
Within the 70 pages the story of one of Shakespeare's best loved comedies is presented, along with a list of characters, and drawings by Tomislav Tomic. Middle to upper primary readers will love this easy to digest introduction to the 400 year old story, or have just a great tale to read for themselves. Swindells has rewritten a number of other plays as well in this series for A & C Black of London. For those classrooms tackling Shakespeare, then this series will be a great introduction to the storylines of these plays, and help acquaint the students with settings and characters.
Fran Knight

The sea-wreck stranger by Anna Mackenzie

cover image

Text Publishing, 2009. ISBN 9781921520361. (Ages: 11+) Recommended. A half drowned, battered man washes up on the shore of a closed island community, one where its inhabitants risk death if they walk near the sea. The community turned its back on the sea years before after many of its people died after eating fish. Nes, more spirited than most, feels drawn to the sea and so finding Dev amongst the seaweed, patches his wounds and hides him in the cave she often visits.
Her life however is unsettled, only vaguely linked to the people she lives with, she is closest to a woman who lives alone close by, but who falls under suspicion for possibly breaking the taboos of her village. This dystopian world, a small remnant of a civilization now decimated by environmental pollution, has become closed and male dominated, suspicious and wary.
The claustrophobic feeling when reading this book is overwhelming, as you read of this young girl, trying to capture something of the outside through the man she rescues. She is intrigued by what is there, a place her father visited before he died, and resents the ominous presence of the next door neighbours, especially after being told that marriage between she and his son would unite the two farms.When other members of the village become aware of the man's presence, the search is on, and Ness must try to rescue him before he is discovered and her part in his survival known.
A breathtaking, very scary story, which I hope will have a sequel.
Fran Knight

The Soul Trade by E. E. Richardson

cover image

Corgi Books, 2009.
Searching desperately for a gift for his stepmother, Nick stumbles upon a shop in a unfrequented alleyway, called Bargains. Here he is intrigued with the array of glass orbs, and knows his step mother will like one. The sinister shopkeeper asks Nick for one of his drawings as payment for the orb, and Nick, without much thought, tears out a page in his sketch book and gives it to the man. Next day when at school in his favourite lesson, Art, he is despondent to find that he can no longer draw. His passion for art was leading him to find a place at an art school, and so devastated at the loss of his kills, seeks out the shop again to resolve what it happening to him.
But here he makes another bargain with the shop keeper: he will do some debt collecting work for him in exchange for his drawing and his skills. So Nick sets out on a perilous mission, one fraught with an ever present feeling of danger and fear. What he finds in recalling debts owed to the shopkeeper unsettles him even further as he is drawn into the world of Bargains.
A scary story sure to thrill those horror readers in your school: it will make them rethink the consequences of bargains.
Fran Knight

By Royal Command by Charlie Higson

cover image

Puffin, 2009.
(Ages 11+) Recommended. The fifth in the series, Young James Bond, sees James rescue one of his schoolmates from certain death on the slopes of the Austrian Alps, where Miles, an arrogant and disliked young man, falls after drinking before skiing. James puts himself at incredible risk to rescue him, and when the two are hospitalized, James sees something he perhaps shouldn't have, a raving von Schlick prior to surgery. It is a few years before World War 2, and Higson includes the future king of England, Edward and Wallis Simpson along with some nasty Communist spies and Nazis to mix together an amazingly readable plot. James sees von Schlik again in Miles' home, when his parents thank James for rescuing their son. Following him amongst the hallways, he stumbles upon Edward and Mrs Simpson, who are then joined by von Schlik and several other men. The conversation turns to the sympathy shown by Edward towards Hitler, and the downturn of Britain's fortunes. James leaves and taking his aunt on a tour of the school for King George's birthday, realises that the huge load of garden fertilizer delivered to the school the day before, could be used as a bomb to kill the king, Edward's brother. Sure to be a hit with middle school readers By Royal Command has all the elements of a gripping read. James is involved in a life and death plot, one which could change the course of history. His cunning and skills save the day of course, and along the way the brutes from his school get their just deserts. The episodes where James is abused at the hand of the older boy at school are tough to read, and recall Tom Brown's Schooldays and others in exposing the stupidity of the class system, and the lessons he learns from his experiences there certainly underpin the morality of the spy, James Bond in Ian Fleming's stories.
Fran Knight

Far from home by K.M. Peyton

cover image

Usborne, 2009. ISBN 9780746090886
(Ages 10+) Minna has followed Theo, her childhood friend, now captain of a Roman cohort in central Britain, on his march to destroy the Celtic barbarian, Kimbelinus and his ragged army of savages. She has her friends, Dracos and Benoc to keep her cheerful, as she is seen as a camp follower by the other women trudging behind the cohort. Her brief conversations with Theo, centre on their horses, and what will happen when they meet the opposing forces. Minna is mortified to think that she will be sent back with the women, out of harm's way, and talks Theo into allowing her to spy with Draco.
She feels proud that she is helping, but when the battle finally begins, she is overcome with grief at the death and dying around her. She finds that her brother is one of the dead, and learns that the taciturn Draco has deserted to the other side, but when her horse, Silva is captured by some of the fleeing Celts, she takes action.
An exciting and informative sequel to Minna's Quest, any reader will easily further their knowledge of Roman Britain reading this adventure. Minna is headstrong, and often blurts things out without thinking, landing herself in trouble. Her love for Theo holds strong, despite the death which surrounds her at the end of the battle, and she forlornly remains with Benoc, when Theo takes his cohort on further skirmishes, keeping the Celts at bay. A third novel, No Turning Back completes the trilogy. A stirring trilogy of historical novels from a fine writer.
Fran Knight

The forest of hands and teeth by Carrie Ryan

cover image

Orion, 2009. ISBN 9780575090859
(Age 14+) Mary's life is confined to the village where she lives. In her constricted post apocalypse world the Sisterhood control all knowledge and lay down confining rules. The Guardians protect everyone from the Forest of Hands and Teeth. The village is surrounded by a fence to keep out the Unconsecrated, zombies who relentlessly push against it, trying to get in. One bite from them is enough to turn a normal person into a walking undead. As the Unconsecrated crowd in, Mary has difficult choices to make. Should she chance the forest path and hope to find the sea her mother has spoken about, or should she stay and fight the undead?
Told in the first person, this is a coming of age story. Mary is on the verge of becoming an adult and is a strong determined character who holds onto her dreams of a bigger world beyond the fence. She is in love with Travis, who is betrothed to her best friend, Cass. The Sisterhood command her to marry Harry, but she is torn with doing what she has been told to do or trying to follow her heart. When the Unconsecrated take over her village, she sets out with Travis, Harry, Cass and an orphaned boy Jacob, to try and escape. The love triangle will appeal to romance fans who like their love interest entwined with some horror.
There is plenty of action for fans of horror with the Unconsecrated determined to kill everything in sight, and both Mary and her brother being forced to kill people they love or else see them turn. The suspense is quite rivetting after the first 100 pages or so with the zombies in hot pursuit of the little group. Although there is a satisfying conclusion there are enough unresolved issues to ensure that the reader will want to read the sequel.
Pat Pledger

Dance of the sugar plum fairy by Sue Whiting

cover image

Ill. By Sarah Davis. CD narrated by Antonia Kidman.
New Frontier, 2009. ISBN 9781921042621
(Ages 5-10) Recommended. Sue Whiting has written a fascinating story around the music of The Sugarplum Fairy from The Nutcracker ballet by Tchaikovsky. Marcus and Mary are the finest candy makers in the kingdom. Their sugarplums are so delicious that the greedy king is overjoyed with them and orders 50 jars to be delivered by sun-up. Even though it is an impossible task they do their best to make them. After working frantically and using up all their sugar, they only have 25 jars. They go to bed exhausted and in the morning discover to their delight that there are many jars full of sweets. A sugarplum fairy has come to their rescue, and keeps helping them out.
Sarah Davis' illustrations are a delight. She made all of the characters seemed come alive for me. I loved the little sugarplum fairy. She is a gorgeous mixture of ordinary little girl in leggings and magical fairy with stunning wings. Her smiling face and gleeful expressions brought a smile to my face. The music on the CD is wonderful and an unforgettable way of introducing children to classical music. As well as being a good story for parent or teacher to read aloud, children can also listen to the narration by Antonia Kidman. Notes about the composer and The Nutcracker ballet can be found at the back of the book.
This is a lovely story that young children will enjoy both for the tale and for the accompanying music.
Pat Pledger

They told me I had to write this by Kim Miller

cover image

Ford Street, 2009.
ISBN 9781876462840 (Age 12+) Highly recommended. What an emotional roller coaster ride for Clem, and all who read this absorbing and challenging book. Kim Miller's knowledge and understanding of angry and unhappy youths comes through very strongly as he writes with emotion and candour through an adolescent's voice. The title implies an unhappy youth, yet throughout the novel hope shines through. Clem believes his mother's death at his birth is his fault. He and his father have a tumultuous relationship made more difficult from a sexually abusive teacher! He writes to his recently dead grandmother at the behest of the school counsellor called 'the Rev'. The language is that of a teenager at war with himself and the world, (he's in a school for toxic teenagers), but wonderful pieces of wit and humour and growing self awareness are laced throughout the letters and gives the reader a real sense of hope for the 'Clems' of this world. Clem finds peace within himself, a first love and a strong bond between father and son.The topics are tough and of our time but the enduring strength given by the teachers in Clem's school is a reminder of the positive effect teachers can have on each child's development. A fast paced novel well worth reading no matter who you teach.
Sue Nosworthy

Second star to the right by Deborah Hautzig

cover image

Walker Books, 2008. ISBN 9781406315493.
(Age 13+) Recommended.A hauntingly distressing book, made all the worse for it's a reality to anyone suffering anorexia nervosa. Leslie at 14 thinks that her life would be perfect if she was thin but as she says on page 69: 'I'll know when I'm thin because I'll be happy.' She has very high expectations of herself, well loved by her family and has a supportive good friend in Cavett. This is a revealing emotional ride for us all, especially as this is partly biographical. The sad journey takes Leslie from home to hospital where we leave her with others in a similar position, struggling to be able to eat again. The stark cover will draw many adolescent readers to look inside. It's a novel to share and discuss with young people
Sue Nosworthy

Oddly by Joyce Dunbar

cover image

Ill. by Patrick Benson. Walker Books, 2009. ISBN 9781844280322.
(All ages) What a strange but memorable picture book! Three weird creatures, Lostlet, Strangelet and Oddlet, are roaming in the woods. The Lostlet is going around in circles and doesn't know what he is hoping for. The Strangelet asks himself, 'What am I?' and doesn't know what he is dreaming of. The Oddlet asks, 'Who am I?' and wonders what he is wishing for. A little boy, who is also lost, comes along, and doesn't know who or what he is. The four get together and discover that love is what makes you better.
This tale looks at identity and self-perception in a warm and loving way. The three strange creatures are very appealing especially when they evolve into Huglet, Snuglet and Foundlet. The little boy has a wonderfully expressive face, each emotion clearly depicted by the beautifully illustrations by Patrick Benson. Indeed, it is the illustrations with their gorgeous sweeps of pale orange and blue backgrounds that bring this story to life.
I can imagine reading it aloud to very young children who will be reassured that love is still waiting even if they get lost or feel strange or odd.
Pat Pledger

A finder's magic by Philipa Pearce

cover image

Walker Books, 2008. ISBN 9781406309225
(Age 7-12) Highly recommended. Reminiscent of Philip Pullman's The Scarecrow and the Servant, this beautifully crafted novel is a joy to read. Till's dog Bess is missing and Till is shattered. He meets a strange man who calls himself Finder who offers to help find Bess. Finder gently teaches Till to believe in himself and to ask questions of a mole, a heron, a cat who talks in riddles and the two old ladies, Miss Mousy and Miss Gammer. It's a mystery with Finder subtlety suggesting ways to look for Bess. It is written by Philippa Pearce for her grandsons and illustrated by Helen Craig, the boys' other grandmother, who painted and sketched the delicate pictures which enhance the already evocative text. Till's full name is an anagram of the grandsons' names. This is a story to be shared with a child, so together the finer points of language and illustration, can be talked through and enjoyed. The paper is smooth with a silky touch and the embossed cover makes this a special and delightful reading experience.
Sue Nosworthy