Reviews

The goblin and the empty chair by Mem Fox

cover image

Ill. by Leo and Diane Dillon. Puffin, 2009. ISBN 9780670074211.
(Age: 5+) Highly recommended. Mem Fox has crafted a memorable story in the classic fairy tale tradition, telling the tale of a kind-hearted goblin who is convinced that he is too ugly to be seen by anyone. He hides away in his castle, until one day he sees desolate farmer, who doesn't seem to be able to cope with his chores. The farmer's wife and daughter are also suffering from some unspecified loss. The goblin, working at night, helps them out, believing that the darkness will hide him. However the family members do see him and invite him into their home.
Fox's beautiful text is studded with memorable phrases, imagery and repetition. It is a delight to read aloud, slowly with emphasis. Beautiful framed illustrations by award winning duo, Leo and Diane Dillon, draw the reader into the story. Each page has a border strip showing what is happening before the text, and a larger picture that illustrates a key emotion of the story. A tiny gargoyle face on both sides of the picture is fascinating and adds to the reader's understand of the feelings that the text is expanding. Although the family's despair is not explained in the text, there are clues in the illustrations. It is these tiny pictures and clues that bring the reader back again and again to discover more richness in the book.
Both the text and the illustrations emphasise that appearances are not all important and that beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Compassion and caring for other people have the power to help heal a terrible loss and to join people together.
Pat Pledger

Dreamdark series by Laini Taylor

cover image

Blackbringer. Firebird, 2007. ISBN 9780142411681.
Silksinger. G. P. Putnam's Sons, 2009. ISBN 9780399246319.
(Ages 10+) Recommended. The first two books in the Dreamdark series are an absolute delight. Once I started Blackbringer, I was unable to put it down, as I followed the adventures of Magpie Windwitch, a tiny feisty fairy, who rides on the backs of a clan of cigar smoking crows. She is on a quest to rid the world of devils that have escaped back into the world and are threatening the fairy world. When the Blackbringer kills Talon Rathersting's father and brothers, he too joins the hunt to rid the world of darkness. After finishing Blackbringer I immediately picked up the sequel Silksinger. In Silksinger, Whisper is a tiny fairy with a magical voice, who has to protect the Azazel, one of the creators of the world. Joined by Hirik, and aided by Magpie Windwitch, Talon and the crows, she faces a dangerous adversary in her quest to keep the Azazel and the world safe.
Taylor has created a unique but totally believable world peopled with spunky fairies and evil villains. This world is vividly brought alive by beautiful descriptive writing and splendid dialogue, including slang especially created to suit Magpie.
Her characters are really well developed, each with their own strengths and weakness, and having a wonderful range of skills. Magpie can weave the Tapestry that keeps the world together. Talon, a non stereotypical Prince, is able to knit himself a wondrous pair of wings so that he too can travel the skies on adventures with Magpie and the crows. Whisper Silksinger can translate glyphs into song and Tirik wields a magical sword. Individuals in the crow clan provide a source of laugh out loud humour, with their cigar-smoking habits and play acting antics.
I found myself flicking through the books to look at Jim Di Bartolo's gorgeous illustrations of the little fairies with their soaring wings, tattooed faces, pointed ears and wind swept hair. They perfectly complemented the characters of the fairies and added greatly to the enjoyment of the book.
This is an original and highly enjoyable series with plenty of edge of the seat adventures to hold the reader's interest. I can't wait for the next book to be published.
Pat Pledger

Seven Sorcerers by Caro King

cover image

Quercus, 2009.
(Age 10+) Nin had never liked Wednesdays, but this one was terrible. When she woke up she discovered that her brother Toby had disappeared. No one else remembered him and none of his belongings existed either. She remembered him being afraid of the Bogeyman that he thought was lurking in the corner of the cellar. When she found his Monkey toy discarded under a tree in the garden she knew that he had been taken. Eyes seem to follow her and then the worse happened, Skerridge the Bogeyman, tried to take her and erased all the memories of Nin from her family and friends. Determined to rescue Toby and aided by Jonas a boy from the Drift, a strange land where everything seems to be dying, Nin set out on a dangerous quest out to find him.
What child hasn't imagined monsters hiding in closets and dark corners, or thought of skeletons rising out of graves? King has peopled her world with a frightening array of fantastic and terrible creatures, many drawn from the stuff of these nightmares and childhood fears. Nin has to face the tombfolk, mudmen, Gabriel hounds, not to mention Mr Strood and the Terrible House where all the stolen children are given to Strood's Death to eat. The plot is action packed and the suspense is built up really well as Nin and her companions face one adversary after another on their perilous journey to find Toby and discover what had happened to the Seven Sorcerers who once lived in the land.
King has made her characters come alive. Nin is always steadfast and loyal. Almost single minded in her determination to find her brother, she still comes to the rescue of Jonas in an amazing feat against the Gabriel Hounds and ensures that the mudman, Jik, is kept alive. Skerridge the Bogeyman, is a terrific character and provides many touches of humour that helps to relieve the tension of the scary adventures that occur. The author also uses him to provide much of the background of the alternative world that Nin has found herself in. Jik the mudman with his strange vocabulary is a memorable invention. Black and white illustrations of Nin, Jonas, Jik and Skerridge give an extra dimension to the characters.
With its combination of fast paced plot and a wonderfully inventive, magical world, King has written a story that is clever, scary and memorable. It can be read as a stand alone as it comes to a satisfying conclusion. Readers who enjoyed it will be happy to know that on the spine, it says Book one, and will look forward to further adventures of Nin and her little band.
Pat Pledger

Shapeshifters: tales from Ovid's Metamorphoses retold by Adrian Mitchell

cover image

Ill. by Alan Lee. Frances Lincoln Children's Books, 2009.
(Age 11+)Metamorphoses has inspired writers through the ages. The Roman poet's tales about interaction between the gods and humans have been adapted as plays, poems, music and stories.
Shapeshifting, or metamorphosis, is a common theme in legends and folklore. Adrian Mitchell has used it as a metaphor for the inevitability of change, bookending his adaptations of ancient Greek myths with his thoughts about the subject of transformation. The result has a satisfying unity, beginning with the creation of order out of chaos and ending with the creation of art, represented by the work of the boastful weaver Arachne, who was changed into a spider.
Writing styles vary from prose poems and rhyming verse to conventional storytelling in prose. Readers can view the resulting anthology as a whole work or use the table of contents to dip into the tales of their choice. At times, the writing is evocative. At times, it disappoints. Occasional facetiousness and colloquial expressions seem out of place. Tense changes mar the storytelling. A glossary of the gods and a guide to the pronunciation of Greek names are welcome but a brief 'Note on Ovid' seems offhand at the end of a book which includes his name in the title. Readers are left to deduce the connection between the terms 'shapeshifters' and 'metamorphoses'.
Alan Lee's vivid watercolour illustrations wrap around the text on every page. The heroic, dreamlike images enhance this large print, quality hardcover publication.
Despite its unevenness, Shapeshifters is a visually arresting and effective retelling of some of the world's best known myths. The author's reflections about their meaning are sincere and thought-provoking.
Elizabeth Bor

Watch me throw the ball by Mo Willems

cover image

Walker Books, 2009.
(Ages 2-7) Recommended. Another charming book in the Elephant and Piggie series, Watch me throw the ball has careful Gerald convinced that throwing a ball is very serious business while happy Piggie is thrilled to just have fun. Gerald is determined to show Piggie the right way to throw a ball, but Piggie is quite happy with her meagre throws, convinced that she is Super Pig!

The simple line drawings are an absolute delight, the expressions of the serious Gerald and the frivolous Piggie exquisitely drawn with a few strokes. Laugh aloud humour, simple sentence construction, a few words to each page and repetition make this story an ideal first reader.
Pat Pledger

Gibblewort the goblin series by Victor Kelleher

cover image

Illustrated by Stephen Michael King
Random House Australia, 2010.
(Ages 7-10 years) This year sees a new edition of the popular series of stories featuring an ugly, disgruntled and mischievous goblin, Gibblewort, who originally posts himself from rainy, soggy Ireland to Australia, in the hope that life will improve. It does not take long for things to go wrong as he confronts the climate and wildlife of Australia; life is better in Ireland he decides!
Throughout the series, Gibblewort makes numerous trips home but is soon posted back to various parts of Australia by his goblin friends. For the likes of this goblin, nowhere makes him happy. His looks, smells, habits and his generally unfortunate nature, mean that he experiences all sorts of tricky situations and surprising adventures.
The author uses this cleverly constructed early chapter book series to show the abundance of interesting wildlife, weather and landscapes making up Australia. Stephen Michael King's delightful black pen and wash drawings give life to Gibblewort's adventures and add a good deal of humour and anticipation. The human characters are especially quirky - snow skiers, surfers, greenies, zookeepers and city folk - all with their own way of dealing with this menace!
The descriptive writing is excellent, and the style and language will extend the new reader. The adventures of Gibblewort are sure to please.
The books are Goblin in the Bush; Goblin on the Reef; Goblin in the City; Goblin in the Rainforest; Goblin at the Zoo; Goblin in the Snow; and Goblin at the Beach.
Julie Wells

The Red Piano by Andre Leblanc

cover image

Ill. by Baroux. WilkinsFarago, Victoria 2008. ISBN 9780980607017.
(Ages 6-19) Picture book. The stunning front cover draws the reader into the text immediately, as a small Chinese girl walks across a cold barren landscape, carrying buckets on a pole, but with scraps of music flowing overhead. Straight away the signals are there for repression and struggle. And so it is, for this is the story of one of China's international concert pianists, Zhu Xiao-Mei.
Sent to the country during the Cultural Revolution during Mao Tsetung's time, Zhu was not allowed to practice her piano, as this was seen by the regime as decadent and foreign. But after many years of practicing 8 hours a day in Beijing, this did not come easily, so she had her mother send a piano to her on her commune. There with the help of her friends and an older woman, each day, after many hours working in the fields, and then hours of re-education, she secretly went to he place her piano was kept hidden and practiced her craft.
One evening after being discovered, she was held up to mockery and denunciation, while the piano was smashed. Her re-education now meant doing the lowliest tasks in the commune, collecting and disposing of the waste in the latrines. But all the while she kept her music alive in her head, until, one day when the leadership changed, she was summoned to Beijing.
For older readers, the story of one girl and the effects of the Cultural Revolution will add to their study of China. Facinghistory has a free study guide for classes looking at Red Scarf Girl and Mao's Last Dancer, and this guide has sections which could be useful when talking about The Red Piano, giving students some of the background. For younger reads, the story of bravery and resilience will be a wonderful book to have on hand in the classroom or library when looking at other stories that encourage compassion.
Fran Knight

The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins

cover image

Scholastic 2008. ISBN 9781407109084.
(Ages 12+) In a future not too far away, when global warming has destroyed much of North America, the people left huddle between the Rockies and the Appalachian mountains, vying for food and water. When one group wins over the rest, they divide the country into 13 districts around the capitol, where they live. To stop future wars, a reaping is held each year when 2 children, one boy and one girl, are chosen by ballot from the names of all 12-18 year olds in each district, to fight to the death.
This reality game show taken to an appalling level has the children taken to a studio where they are preened and plumped for the television show, beamed over all districts continuously while the game is on. Let loose into the stadium after some training, they are on their own, having to survive and fight to live. Several of the districts have an advantage, being career fighters, with money in their backgrounds, education and cunning, but many are from poorer districts where survival is a daily grind.
16 year old Katniss sees her sister, 12 year old Prim, chosen, and without hesitation, Katniss leaps forward to exchange places with her. She knows her sister will never survive such an ordeal, let alone kill someone. So the cat and mouse game begins. Television cameras beam what happens live, and so Katniss becomes aware that she msut play the audience, fo they will support her and send her gifts when her food and water runs out. Part way through the game, the rules change and she is allowed to team up with the boy form her district, Peeta, and together they are able to outwit some of the others.
An engrossing tale, well told, The Hunger Games was one of those rare books that I could not put down. To have children put in this position was heart wrenching, knowing that eventually they would have to kill people they know. Surviving with them in the arena made my hair stand on end, as you realise exactly what they must do to keep alive themselves. Each character is individual, all 24 combatants recognisable and different. The heart stopping moments come thick and fast, but the reader is never aware of being manipulated or pandered to. It is a most ingenious book, and I was thrilled to get to the end to find that this is part of a trilogy.
Fran Knight

The Enemy by Charlie Higson

cover image

Penguin, 2009. ISBN 9780141325026.
(Ages 11+) Arran, Freak, Ollie and Achilleus are limping back to their home after a failed scavenging raid. They have trawled the area, finding nothing but a dog they killed when a pack attacked them. But they are missing one of the group, and must explain to the other children what has happened to Deke. The group at home, an old supermarket, fortified against attack, also has news: another youngster, Sam, was taken that day. Sam and Deke have one thing in common; they were taken by the grown-ups, the rampageous, disease ridden remnants of those left alive after the plague.
So begins this breathless story where things have got out of hand. Those under 14 are generally alive and fighting for survival, where survival means scavenging for food as well as being always on the lookout for the grown-ups who take them to eat. When a boy is rescued, he tells them of life at Buckingham Palace, which he and his group of kids have called their own. They need more though to keep the gardens going and he invites Arran's group to join them at the palace.
So begins a journey for the group, and that of their neighbours, to find a better place to live, a place of safety. But along the route they struggle to survive against the seemingly concerted efforts of the grown-ups. Some of their number is killed but they reach the palace with high anticipation. Here they find that the leader, David, is not all he seems, and when they are asked to kill another group of kids in his way, splits develop in the group.In one horrific scene, a fighter from each group, face each other in a duel to the death. Gladiatorial in its scope, the end result will see Arran's group stay or find somewhere else to live.
A winning story about right and wrong, survival and friendship, this dystopian novel will intrigue upper primary and lower secondary readers, intent on an adventure novel with an overlay of moral questioning. Higson wrote the Young Bond series of books, and this has a similar level of violence. A most enjoyable read, with echoes of The Lord of the Flies, it is the first in a series, and has its own website which will further excite the readers.
Fran Knight

The Society of S by Susan Hubbard

cover image

Walker Books, 2009. ISBN 9781406314977.
(Ages: Secondary) Ari lives alone with her widowed father in a Victorian house set away from the town. There she is home schooled in the morning, and left to her studies in the afternoon when her father retreats to the basement to continue his work with blood samples. When their housekeeper suggest that Ari is too isolated, she is given permission to take the girl into her home, where she meets her two children, Kathleen, a girl of Ari's age, and Michael, several years older. Through these two Ari learns more of the outside world. Both teens are stretching the boundaries imposed by their family, and when Kathleen takes Ari to her meetings with her friends, where they play at being vampires, Ari feels odd. One night, after Ari goes home because she feels ill, she is shocked to find that Kathleen has been murdered, and when the police interview Ari and her father, she realises that suspicion is falling on them.
Eventually Ari's father explains that yes, he is a vampire, and suggests that she too, may be headed that way. The Green Cross van that comes to the house every week, brings blood for him, as he and his group, do not kill for blood, taking vitamin supplements and blood from the mortuary. She wants her mother, and goes off to search for her, pursuing the vague clues left by others in the household. Her quest leads her to Florida, where she finds that things are not as they have been described.
Full of Gothic romance and horror, The Society of S will have wide appeal to those lower secondary girls taken up with the idea of vampires and lonely teenage girls growing up without a mother. Odd house servants, strange happenings, a father with heroic looks, a mother no one mentions, suspicions about a dead cat and then a murder along with blood samples brought to the door, all have an airing in this scary tale. But it is not the vampire tale of old. When Ari's father finally tells her who and what she is, the stress all the time is about controlling the urges and taking precautions against killing. The vampires in this story must choose.
Fran Knight

Magenta McPhee by Catherine Bateson

cover image

Random House Australia, 2009. ISBN 9781741664089
(Ages 10 to 14 years) Highly recommended. Magenta sends off a letter to Sammi magazine outlining how depressed her Dad has become after his divorce. Thrilled that her letter is published, with a commendation about her writing style, she decides to confide in her best friend. Polly is convinced that Magenta will make a writer one day, but, in the meantime suggests that internet dating may be the answer for Magenta's Dad! The two girls take this on without telling him!
Lianna is the lady who replies to 'Dad's' emails and a meeting is arranged, with the consequences proving very interesting! The human interest in this story will make it a popular read. Character backgrounds discovered along the way keep the reader involved.
Magenta is writing a fantasy story and we are given snippets of this as she uncovers new material for her novel.
I enjoyed viewing the interactions between the variety of realistic characters and sharing their disappointments and laughter. Catherine Bateson has a great turn of phrase; an easy, relaxed writing style, and her storyline is captivating.
As we have come to expect from Catherine Bateson's novels, the dialogue is appealing and the themes pertinent to today's teens.
Julie Wells

Fran's dozen (baker's) 2009 (a selection of what I have read and enjoyed in 2009) by Fran Knight

cover image

Picture books
Cummings, Phil Wang Wang and Funi (How can anyone pass up Phil's picture book with his familiar rhyming story inviting small readers to look for the pandas at the Adelaide Zoo. The illustrations by Adelaide artist Shane Devries, add to the excellence of this lovely book, a far cry from the usual book published as part of a merchandising campaign.)

Thompson, Colin Free to a good home (Thompson's unusual look at family life had me laughing at loud. Instead of an animal following them home, the children have a granny. She is adamant that no-one is looking for her, and makes herself cheerfully useful in this house. A wonderful multi layered story to enthrall all kids, big and small)

Middle school
DiCamillo, Kate The magician's nephew (Conjuring of an elephant which falls into the audience, devolves into a story about family and obligation, and where a person, or animal, fits into the scheme of things. Peter knows that his sister is alive and has been told by the fortune teller that her discovery will be linked to an elephant.)

Flanagan, John Halt's peril (The ninth book in the Ranger's Apprentice series, this one is deliberately mystifying. Flanagan took great glee in setting up a story which had people guessing as to who might die, and whether Halt would survive this episode, and just whose funeral is taking place. See my interview with him on Readplus.)

Millard, Glenda A small free kiss in the dark (A marvelous futuristic story shows war demolishing Sydney and a young girl, Tia, having to find a safe refuge, along with several strangers who become like a family. A survival story out of the ordinary, finding positives where none should be.)

Westerfeld, Scott Leviathan (SteamPunk at its best with the story of the beginnings of World War One, with the assassinations of the Archduke and his consort and what may have happened to their young son. The creatures created by the author are fantastic, the intrigue believable, and the history in the background, most credible. And with all that it is a romp, with plenty of adventure and a brush of humour.)

Teens
Collins, Suzanne The hunger games (Imagine a future where there are nor wars! But each year two teens are chosen from each district to fight to the death on behalf of their home area. Usually the result is a forgone conclusion as one from the warrior district, with heavy support and advertising rights, and well trained comes out on top, but this year is different, as Katniss, a skilled hunter, takes her sister's place. An amazing story of survival and determination, along with a sly dig at reality TV.)

Henderson, Don Keepinitreal (an entertaining story concerning the oddest collection of people coming together to save the local greyhound race course. Set in the western suburbs, the characters are very real, without being caricatures, the setting tangible and the action, hilarious.)

Murray, Kirsty Vulture's gate (Bo and Callum come together by chance and survive together in a hostile world where women have all but died out. Callum has been used as a trained gymnast doing daring tricks on motorcycles to get money for the men that own him and Bo has hidden since her grandfather died. Australia in a near future where Bo has a roboraptor to keep her company and help her survive, but the pair must move across hostile territory to make it to the city where they expect to find safety.)

Larbelestier, Justine Liar (Micah's friend Zach has died, torn apart by dogs in the park. Micah must search her very being to work out whether she was the culprit, and the story, divided into three parts, Telling the truth, Telling the true truth and The Actual real truth, will have readers agog as they try and work out how reliable the narrator really is. I still don't know.)

Rai, Bali City of ghosts (The Amritsar Massacre in 1919 was one of those incidents I read about in Yr 11 British Commonwealth History (albeit from one point of view) but reading about it in this astonishingly realistic historical novel, where both sides of what happened are shown through a group of quite different characters makes this one to read and reread.)

Sedgwick, Marcus Revolver (Sedgwick is one of my favourite authors, and here he tells a survival story with a difference. A boy is cornered by a man who wants to kill his father, but father's body is lying on the table in this tiny cabin, snowbound near Nome. A life and death struggle between the man with the gun and the lad captures your attention to the end. If anyone wanted something for those kids hooked on Hatchet, then this is it.)

Valentine, Jenny The ant colony (Fleeing to London Sam finds himself getting involved with the lives of the others in his building of run down flats. Without realizing it he begins to reveal parts of himself that he wants to keep hidden, and people begin to care about him and him about them. A stunning climax sees Sam returning to the rural area where he was born to confront the reason he fled.)

And of course, several goodies have been missed out, so I must suggest Anna McKenzie's The sea wreck stranger and Catherine Jinks' hilarious take on the vampire genre, The reformed vampire support group. And I read several that have been published before 2009, The giver (Lois Lowry) and Here lies Arthur (Philip Reeve)
Fran Knight

Conspiracy 365: January by Gabrielle Lord

cover image

Scholastic, 2009. ISBN 9781741690330.
(Ages 11+) Walking home one night, Callum is chased by a disheveled man who warns him that he must stay hidden for 365 days, or else he would be killed like his father. Dismissing him as stupid, he watches as the ambulance takes him away, but when over the next few days things happen which alert him to the possibility of his being targeted by persons unknown, he recalls all that the man told him, and strives to keep himself safe.
A clever idea, Callum has to remain hidden for a year, and so Scholastic is publishing a book a month for the year in 2010, following Callum's desperate survival as he tracks down his would be killers and those of his father and strives to find out why this is happening. Fast paced, action packed, with a likeable hero, Conspiracy 365 is a winning formula which will be widely read by upper primary and lower secondary kids. A website,(www.conspiracy365.com) accompanies the book and kids will find that they can win prizes by accessing the website.
A breathless, easy to read series of novels for the middle school, there are some intriguing differences used in this series to make it stand out. The pagination starts at 188 and counts down: the font used is more administrative adding to the feeling of a police report and the pages are almost diary entry style, with times as well as dates heading each entry, all of which add up to an enjoyable twist on the usual survival story. Inside the front cover is a Conspiracy Card asking readers to log on with their own number, so enabling them to be in the draw for prizes, and inside the back cover is a lsit of all 12 books coming out in 2010. Boys will pick this up because of the story and the details, while girls will go for the dishy picture of Callum on the front cover. Whatever else this will be a hit.
Fran Knight

Beach break by Meredith Badger

cover image

Go Girl! Besties 1. Hardie Grant Egmont, 2009. ISBN 9781921502989.
(Age 8-10) Beach break is the first book in the Go Girl! Besties and will be welcomed by fans of other Go Girl! series. Mia is thrilled because her two best friends are coming to stay at the beach house with her during the holidays. She is certain that they will have a wonderful time and has lots of beach fun planned. But when Shae and Michiko begin to act strangely she begins to worry that they may not stay her best friends.
Meredith Badger has written a book about the familiar theme of a beach holiday and what happens when more time than usual is spent with friends. Young girls will be sure to identify with the exploration of friendship and its pressures. They will sympathise with Shae who is homesick and Mich who is having trouble telling her friends her secrets.
Mia's parents are portrayed in a very sympathetic light, caring and understanding but firm about rules for Mia's older sister who wants to go to a bonfire on the beach. Mia's character develops as she has to come to some hard decisions about whether she should tell her parents about Rose's decision to sneak out. With some creative planning by the threesome, all turns out well.
Girls will be sure to like this series with its well organised chapters, likeable characters and engaging illustrations by Danielle McDonald.
Pat Pledger

The Graveyard Book by Neil Gaiman

cover image

Illustrated by Chris Riddell. Bloomsbury, 2009. ISBN 9780747594802.
(Ages 11- 15 years) This book is highly recommended but probably not for the faint-hearted. What an unexpected, exciting and intriguing read. The beginning of the story is possibly the creepiest I have read! A toddler narrowly escapes the murderous intent of a stranger to the house and finds himself in the safe hands of a community of ghosts in the town's graveyard. Adopted by these memorable residents, Bod (short for Nobody) grows up in the graveyard, learning about life and death, yet struggling to discover facts about his family and background. His adventures are exciting and scary, but, though it is implied, the violence is not directly shown. Bod's world is fantastical but recognisable too - he is just like any other child finding his way in the world. There is humour in the graveyard - inscriptions on the grave stones are amazing - and there is wisdom. Enhanced by Riddell's wonderful illustrations, Gaiman's language is often striking. Consider the description on page 95: 'In the twilight of the graveyard there was a silent implosion, a flutter of velvet darkness, and Silas was gone.' Silas is Bod's protector and teacher, a mentor, and one of the most memorable of players in this great adventure.
The Graveyard Book won the 2009 Newbery Award.
Julie Wells