Reviews

The perfect present by Sally Rippin

cover image

Egmont, 2010. ISBN 978 1921859277.
Series: Billie B Brown
(Ages: Junior primary) Recommended. A seemingly simple tale, charmingly told, puts this series in the forefront of the groups of books being offered for newly confident readers. Exuberant Billie (the B stands for Bursting) is making gingerbread biscuits for Christmas. She and her friend from next door, Jack, have a problem leaving some on the plate for others to eat. Billie and Jack talk about presents and Billie shows Jack what she thinks is her Christmas present - a bicycle hidden in the shed. Jack is saddened because that is what he has asked for and the pair quarrels, which Billie later regrets. Her bubble is burst when her parents tell her to leave the shed door closed because that is where the people next door have hidden Jack's present. So the stage is set for a surprising Christmas Day.
Full of the warmth of family and friends around Christmas time, the story is delightful in resolving the quarrel between the two children. And the bubbly Billie B is a lovely character for children to read about. They will have fun answering the questions that Sally Rippin poses through the text, flagging what may be about to happen and asking children to make predictions. All wrapped up in a neat easy to hold, stiff covered book the illustrations by Aki Fukuoka add to the humour of the text.
Fran Knight

Last tree in the city by Peter Carnavas

cover image

New Frontier Publishing, 2010. ISBN 978 1921042218.
(Age 4-8.) Picture book, Recommended. The power of one is stunningly illustrated in this story of a young boy re-treeing the city. Dismayed when his one tree is cut down, he finds a discarded piece of it, and plants it in some soil in the carriage of his tricycle. He has always had fun on that tree, climbing it, playing in it and appreciating its greenness in the grayness of the surrounding city. But to find it cut down is devastating. His solution is carried around on his tricycle for all to see, and so many other people in the city, follow his example, making the city greener than it has been before.
The illustrations meld with the words as the reader views the colourless outlines of the city in the first few pages, contrasted with the vibrant green tree which fills the following pages, overshadowing the pale buildings. The middles pages of the book when the tree is cut down are stunning, showing mainly white pages with a short sentence in small print in the centre of the page and a despairing boy. The sad face and pages of white space change when he works out what to do, and the face gets happier and the pages fuller until the last double page is full of colour, people and life. The designer and illustrator have worked hard to use the white space with great effect.
This is a wonderful book with which to start talking to students about their environment.
Fran Knight

Odd and the frost giants by Neil Gaiman

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2010. ISBN 9780747598114.
(Ages 10+) Myth. With his father dead and a new man and his children taking his place, Viking boy, Odd, feels rejected, and has no choice but to leave his once happy home. He meets a bear, an eagle and a fox, who tell him of their home now beset by the frost giants, who have stolen spring and summer, making everything cold, snowbound and frozen. They implore Odd to help them rid their place of the frost giants, but Odd, crippled when a tree he was felling crushed his leg, finds it hard to believe that he can. But try he will, always carrying his father'[s unfinished piece of wood sculpture with him.
Through cunning and bravery Odd carries out their wishes and returns in summer to the people of Asgard, finding that his three companions are more than they seem.
This is a wonderful tale of courage in the face of overwhelming failure, tenacity in the face of fear, and home in all its variations. Kids will love to read of Odd, and feel close to him as he uses his crutch to climb massive mountains and slippery ravines in his quest. The illustration on the front cover will surely encourage the readers to delve into the trials of the unflappable Odd.
Fran Knight

Mortlock by Jon Mayhew

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2010. ISBN 978 14088 0392 9
Suggested reading age 13. Whilst much of this tale is set in Victorian England, the narrative commences in Abyssinia in 1820 with an exploring party led by Sebastian Mortlock searching for a magical plant called the Amarant. His companions on this expedition are Thurlough Corvis and Edwin Chrimes and after locating the plant but finding that it has evil powers, the trio swear a blood pact to never return or reveal its location.
Little more is explained and the story proper opens with teenaged Josie Chrimes performing as a knife thrower alongside her guardian 'The Great Cardomom'. Josie is happy living amongst the entertainment community yet this is all destroyed when her guardian and benefactor is visited and killed by sinister women acting for the Lord Corvis.
It is revealed that Cardomom is actually Edwin Chrimes and Mortlock has mysteriously disappeared with the Amarant which Corvis is prepared to recover at any cost. The Amarant gives the power to revive the dead and control or destroy people. The holder of this plant may rule the world.
Josie is forced to flee, pursued by the women who morph into horrific giant crows which skewer people and dismember them with their beaks. In making her escape, Josie meets a twin brother of whom she was unaware and the two seek to survive and destroy the Amarant whilst untangling the mystery of their family origin.
Pitched at young teenagers, the story will appeal to those who enjoy Gothic horror and the chapters of this sparse narrative are extremely short which will appeal to those who find extended description challenging. The theme of death permeates every aspect of this story, from the desire to achieve immortality to the involvement of undertakers, grisly murders, frequent appearances by zombies or walking dead and the use of graveyards as settings.
Younger readers will not be overly critical of implausible events or the simplistic narrative style and are likely be intrigued to discover the truth of the twins' parentage and the unpleasant motives behind the quest to hold the Amarant.
Rob Welsh, Xavier College

Girl Saves Boy by Steph Bowe

cover image

Text, 2010. ISBN: 978-1-921656-59-0
Recommended. Jewel has spent the past 10 years living with her grandparents, now she has come home. Sasha had leukaemia as a kid, now it's back and it's terminal this time. When Sasha receives this news he tries to end it, Jewel finds him and she saves him. Has Sasha found a new reason to fight the cancer? Read on, the answer awaits you...
The plot of this story, although not straight forward, a good book never is, is complex and well written. It is the sort of book you just simply cannot put down. The book leaves you thinking about it long after you have finished reading it and is told from two different people's perspectives. The story and its characters are quite believable, however most people would not encounter anything like the story in their lifetime, only a select few. Most of the characters you would expect to bump into in the street, but they are unlikely to be like Jewel and even less likely to be like Sasha. It is set in the suburbs a slight distance from a city, there is no evidence to conclude where this area is though.
The author, who is 16 year old, uses a fairly high level writing style for that age. She uses a fair amount of sensual imagery to depict the story and uses it well.
This novel deals with some more serious themes; they are depression, suicide, fighting to live, cancer, terminal illness and death, as well as love and a minor theme of starting year 12. Because of the serious nature of the themes, this book is not recommended for the faint-hearted and under 14's. I would recommend it for ages 17 and up, male or female. However, although it can be read by 14 to 16 year olds, I would recommend only those of this age group with a higher degree of maturity should read it for it to be best understood. I would rate this book 9.5/10 stars.
Amelia Kelly (17 years old)

Hold Me Closer, Necromancer by Lish McBride

cover image

Penguin Books, 2010. ISBN 9780143204961.
Meet Sam, just your average guy rocking the fast-food career. Meet Douglas, not just your average guy, but a powerful and violent necromancer, who immediately recognises the threat Sam poses.
When one Sam's friends dies and comes back as a head, Sam's life will never be the same. Jumping into the-world-of-the-dead, Sam finds a hidden family blood-trait that will change the way he looks at them forever. With the help of his new-found talent, Sam will have to battle it out to a world shaking end.
Aimed at teenage readers, this supernatural fantasy book is likely to set the imagination into overdrive. Set in a first person text it will leave you wanting more. Lish McBride has left the window open for a sequel, fingers and toes crossed, because Hold Me Closer, Necromancer is spilling over the edge with action and deserves a follow-up.
Zoe Pfeiffer (aged 14)

Persistence of memory and Token of darkness by Amelia-Atwater Rhodes

cover image

2 books in one. Random House Australia, 2010. ISBN: 9781742750774.
The book Persistence of Memory is a strange story of how a girl with schizophrenia has, what the hospital and her dad like to call 'Episodes'. When Erin has one of these episodes a vampire named Shevaun ends up in Erin's body. The hospital calls it multiple personality but Erin's supernatural boyfriend thinks there could be more to this than just schizophrenia. One night during a dream Erin wakes to find she is in a completely different room and finds herself for once the opposite way round and in Shevaun's home and body. Shevaun's lover happens to come into the room sensing Shevaun is not herself. Adjila, the Triste witch finally sees what's wrong here and fixes the problem.
This book had tons of great characters in it and I found it so easy understand, for age recommendation I would think probably young adults.
This truly was a good book and I wish it could go on but sadly it can't.

Token of Darkness by Amelia Atwater-Rhodes
Random House Australia, 2010. ISBN: 9781742750774.
Token of Darkness is a book about a teenage boy who was a lucky survivor in a horror smash on a highway and is haunted by a ghost girl called Samantha.
Samantha doesn't have a past and doesn't know why Cooper is the only one who can see her. Things get a little strange when Cooper meets a guy, Brent, who knows quite a lot about ghosts. Things get even stranger when Brent tells him to go to a sorcerer named Ryan to figure out who or what Samantha is.
I felt I could relate to most of the characters in this book and feel what they felt. Sometimes when I read it and stopped reading, it felt like I was in the story. This was a very good book.
Sarah Filkin (Student)

The Project by Brian Falkner

cover image

Walker Books, 2010. ISBN 9781921529795.
(Age 12+) Recommended. Falkner, award winning author of The tomorrow code and Brainjack, both of which I thoroughly enjoyed, has written another fast paced adventure story that is sure to appeal to boys in particular. Tommy and Luke think that the book they are studying at school is the most boring book in the world, but then they discover an old book that is the most boring book in the world, a perfect place to hide a terrible secret. When a flood enters the basement of the library where old and valuable books are stored, Luke and his friend Tommy help to move them to safety. Luke, with his amazing memory, thinks that he sees the treasure that could change the course of history forever. When he goes back to check the boys run into danger and the race is on to save the future.
This is a fast paced adventure that manages to combine gadgets, bike rides, time travel and evil Germans all in one thrilling story. At the same time readers will gain some insight into Leonardo da Vinci, Nazism and spying as they follow Luke and Tommy in an exciting race to rescue the secret in the most boring book in the world.
Falkner has the happy knack of writing engaging characters that you immediately like. Both Luke and Tommy grabbed my interest from the start. Their pranks were very amusing but they were also willing to help out in the community when there was a need. Tommy's obsession with gadgets is also fascinating. Their vibrant personalities carry the plot along.
The Project is definitely not a boring book and is sure to be grabbed up by anyone who likes a thrilling combination of mystery, history, action and science fiction.
Pat Pledger

The tall man and the twelve babies by Tom Niland and Kilmeny Niland

cover image

Ill. by Deborah Niland. Allen and Unwin, 2010. ISBN 9781742371153.
(Age 2-6) Recommended. A zany picture book that will get children asking questions, The tall man and the twelve babies tells the story of six baby boys all called Alistair, and six baby girls all called Charlene. They all live with a very tall man in a tiny apartment in a big city. When they are happy they laugh at the same time and when they are angry they all yell at the same time. One day when the tall man stepped outside with the Charlenes the door slams shut. How will he get back to the Alistairs?
This is a hilarious tale of being a parent, but in this case, the tall man is the sole carer for the twelve babies and what antics they get up to. It is told in simple prose and short sentences with the use of bold print, large letters and capitals to emphasise words.
Beautifully illustrated by Deborah Niland, the little round faces of the twelve babies are a joy to look at. The drawings of the tall man, with his long skinny legs and expressive face, wonderful multicoloured curls, spotted scarf and striped shirt give him a very distinct character. The humour of the story really comes to life with the drawings of the tall man when he tries to get back into the apartment through a tiny flap. Looking at the Charlenes pulling on his legs and the Alistairs pulling the other way made me laugh out loud.
The delightful illustrations and the unique story make this a very memorable book to read aloud and talk about.
Pat Pledger

Wereworld: Rise of the Wolf by Curtis Jobling

cover image

Puffin, 2011. ISBN 9780141333397
(Ages 12+) Wereworld is about 16 year old Drew. When a beast invades his home and kills his mother who he loved very much his father blames him and he is forced to leave his home. Drew seeks refuge in the Dyrewood one of the most dangerous places in all of Lyssia. When he is captured by Lord Bergan's men he has to prove he is not the enemy. Through many events he meets new friends, makes many enemies and learns about the animal within. But will he be able to stop the werecreatures out to destroy him and master the animal within before its too late?
At first this book isn't very interesting; it's good but not very interesting. But when I got to part VI (6) it became extremely interesting and went from good to great. I would recommend this book to people that like fantasy, adventure and don't mind waiting awhile to get to the best part of the book.
Tahlia Kennewell (student)

Editor's note: There is a website for the series.

Row Row Row Your Boat by Angie Lionetto-Civa

cover image

Ill. by Serena Geddes. New Frontier, 2010. ISBN 9781921042539.
(Age 3-5) Two children are having fun rowing down the river. One rows while the other uses a telescope to spy out what he can see. They see a frog that leaps on board and sails with them. Next they come to a chimpanzee that joins them, then a parrot eating a carrot and so on.  The boys and their boatload of animals finally see a snapping crocodile that they mange to evade. They land safely and have lots of fun dancing and playing on the riverbank.
The story is based on the familiar Row, row, row your boat song and its rhythm makes it an ideal book to read aloud or for children to sing along with. The repetition of the Row, row, row your boat chorus is sure to have young children chiming in with the reading and anticipating what's coming next.
The soft water colour cartoon like illustrations by Serena Geddes will appeal to children. The emotions on the faces of both the children and animals are delightful and add to the humour of the story.
This is a simple lift the flap book with the flaps disguised to blend in with the background of the illustrations on the second hand of each double spread. They fit in so well with the colours that young children will have fun trying to find them as well as guessing what animal is behind the flap. They could even trying their hand at making a rhyme.
Pat Pledger

Maudie and Bear by Jan Ormerod and Freya Blackwood

cover image

Little Hare, 2010. ISBN 9781921541407.
(Age 5-7) Highly recommended. In a wonderful collaboration Jan Ormerod, who is an outstanding illustrator in her own right, has joined with award winning illustrator Freya Blackwood, to produce a stunning picture book that could well become a classic of the future.
Maudie and Bear are best of friends. Bear cooks and cleans and is always there when Maudie needs him. The book is divided in very short illustrated chapters, each showing the personality of exuberant and demanding Maudie and patient, loving Bear. Each chapter is humorous and illustrates the themes of love and friendship. In chapter one the pair go for a bike ride after Maudie decides she needs some exercise. After taking an age to get her sunglasses, scarf, sunscreen, and bug spray, Maudie gets into the basket and Bear pedals away, with Maudie remarking that 'exercise is good for you.' Chapter 2 is a funny retelling of The three bears while Chapter 3, The snack, sees Bear labouring over food preparation while Maudie stands by idly and gives instructions.  Making up shows the nature of true friendship, even if Maudie is very offended when Bear laughs at her dancing.  The final chapter, Telling stories, is a heart-warming look at staying awake when a story is being told.
I adored the character of the stalwart Bear, who is like the most patient of parents or carers. He is warm and untiring in his love for Maudie. Maudie on the other hand, is a typical demanding child, self-centred and troublesome but loving as well.
The illustrations are just fabulous. The imaginative details that Blackwood has conjured up are amazing. I loved the scarf that was a fox, the little frilled bloomers that peeped out from under Maudie's dress, and the drawings of little toys and household utensils.
It is an unusual picture book in that it contains five chapters, each with a different story. Beginning readers who are almost ready to move onto chapter books will enjoy the easy vocabulary and beautiful layout of the story and will feel comfortable with the picture book structure.
This book is a keeper and deserves a place on all library shelves.
Pat Pledger

Bink and Gollie by Kate DiCamillo and Alison McGhee

cover image

Ill. by Tony Fucile. Walker Books, 2010. ISBN 9781406329681.
(Age 6-8) Recommended. Bink, short and exuberant and Gollie, tall and thin, are the best of friends, although they like different things. Bink loves goldfish and brightly coloured socks, and Gollie likes to use long words like 'bonanza' and 'compromise' and to dream about travel. She hates Bink's new socks. They do have one thing in common - they both love to roller-skate.
Told in three chapters where they share different adventures, the story of the Bink and Gollie's friendship evolves. The humour of the story stands out as Bink insists on wearing her outrageously bright socks and Gollie ventures out to conquer the Andes Mountains. The vocabulary may be demanding for a beginning reader, who would however relish new words after the story was read aloud.
Tony Fucile's cartoon-like characters are a delight and add to the humour and depth of the story. Bink's hair stands on end and she is so full of life. Her little pleated skirt is gorgeous, as is the little tongue that hangs out when she is concentrating. Golli's more reserved character also comes alive as she plans adventures and saves the life of Fred the goldfish. The expressions on the faces of both girls are exquisite and really show how they are feeling.
The themes of friendship, compromise, adventure and imagination, are all wrapped up in a story that is entertaining and thought-provoking.
Pat Pledger

Editor's note:
Bink and Gollie was a New York Times Best Illustrated Children's Book for 2010 and won The Geisel Award for the most distinguished American book for beginning readers published in English in the United States during the preceding year

Low Red Moon by Ivy Devlin

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2010. ISBN 9781599906188.
(Age 13+) Avery Hood is an orphan. Her parents were brutally murdered and she is the only witness. But she is so traumatised by it that she can barely remember what happened, except that she saw 'silver, deadly silver, moving inhumanly fast'. Then she meets the new boy at school, Ben, who she finds out is a werewolf. They fall in love and she trusts him, at first. Then she sees his eyes sometimes flash silver, and she isn't the only one who can't remember the night her parents died.
This story is how she tries to find out what really happened, part murder-mystery, part grief-narrative, and part headlong romance.
I loved this book for many reasons. It is original in one sense, but sometimes it echoes faintly of Twilight by Stephanie Meyer. The language is evocative and rich and the plot and characters really pull you along on a breathtaking ride of murder and romance. The characters are mostly realistic, but, like most books, they still manage to have a few small flaws. The little things that Avery remembers are well thought out by the author, because although they seem to be meaningless to start with, they all tie together to reveal who the killer really is. And who the killer is found out to be, is a great twist at the end of the story.
The book isn't as long as I would have liked, because it didn't seem to build enough suspense. It is also surprisingly violent; during Avery's flashbacks there is often a lot of blood and gore. One thing I really liked about Low Red Moon was that whenever the word 'moon' is written in the book, it is printed in red, which added to the spooky atmosphere.
Low Red Moon stands out from all other supernatural romances because it has an element of murder in it. It is original, scary, beautifully crafted, gripping and it kept me on the edge of my seat.
Rebecca Adams (Student)

Behemoth by Scott Westerfeld

cover image

Viking, 2010. ISBN 978 067907394.
(Ages 11+) Recommended. Pursued by the German ironclads, the beastie powered Leviathan's captain must make some brave decisions to avoid capture. He knows that Alek is more than he seems, and although Austrian, has saved them twice, despite his pre Darwinian philosophy. Unbeknownst to the British captain and crew, Alek is indeed the son of the assassinated archduke and his wife, and their murders have set in train a series of events which will spiral the world into World War 1. But this is an imagined past, Westerfeld has taken a significant time in history and given it a Steampunk twist, with animal powered airships, the Darwinians and their knowledge of evolutionary change set against the Clankers, those who hold on to the past, abhorring the evolution of animal powered machines. (Check out the message lizards on page 82 or the Clanker walkers on page110! Wow!)
Sumptuously illustrated with adventure piled on adventure, Behemoth is fascinating reading with its array of mesmerising machines with animal behaviours, and the continued sparring between the Clanker Alek and the Darwinist Deryn, a commoner he meets on the ship who is more than he seems. Alek and, Derryn must fight for their lives against the German foe intent on killing Alek even though they are not on the same side. One night Alek and his entourage escape from the Leviathan, but in so doing, Alek takes one of the newly hatched beasties, because it has bonded with him and will not be quiet if Alek leaves it. The boffin, Dr Barlow will not be pleased, or will she?
Now in Istanbul, the group is aware that the Germans are exerting a hold over the Ottomans, and so the stage is set for Alek and his men, along with the Darwinists and Deryn to cause some significant damage to their designs.
Sub plot and counter plot, subterfuge and strategies impel the reader's brain to work enjoyably overtime following the deeds and misdeeds of all the protagonists. The groundwork of history makes for an ultra exciting read with its overlay of fantasy drawing the reader into this mind-boggling but wholly credible world, so well written and illustrated that you feel you can step into it at any time. This is the second in this new series by Westerfeld, following on from Leviathan.
Fran Knight