Reviews

Vulture's Gate by Kirsty Murray

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2009. ISBN 9781741757107.
(Ages 12+) With her grandfather dead, Bo lives alone in an abandoned opal dugout with her roboraptors, eking out an existence, keeping clear of outsiders, protected by a perimeter of landmines. She strives to remember all the things he told her, because they mean her very life. But when a landmine explodes, she knows someone has broken the perimeter and so takes her roboraptors out to investigate. She finds a young boy, who, like her, has to keep his wits about him to survive. He has been held by a brutal group of men and trained to do tricks on motorbikes as they tour the outland settlements. Together they form an uneasy bond, Callum telling her about the city where he once lived, and Bo telling him how they will survive.
Their journey takes them on a strange path, avoiding other people, but one encounter has them captured by an older man, who, discovering Bo is a girl, strives to keep her with him. Their escape lands them in further trouble, as Callum, convinced that he will find his fathers when they get to the city, takes them into this broken place. There the Festers take them as their own, but they too are captured and Bo, once her sex is discovered, is taken into a more secret space where the few women are kept.
A scary look at a future where society has splintered into disparate groups and most women have been wiped out by disease, Murray displays a society which is tangible and credible. The remnants of other times are still there, giving the reader a solid base of reality on which to judge the new society, while the behaviour of those they meet are real enough to be plausible and very frightening. With hints of Mad Max, and Z for Zachariah, the story is original and involving, with two very strongly delineated main characters, and I can see it working well as a class novel with middle school students.
Fran Knight

Hate that cat by Sharon Creech

cover image

Bloomsbury, ISBN 9780 747599807. 2009.
(Ages 8-12) Following the success of Love that dog, Creech has developed another story in verse form, set after Sky's death. Jack is in his old teacher's class again and Miss Stretchberry who loves poetry, asks the students to create a poem after telling them about metaphors and imagery and alliteration and onomatopoeia through the poems they read in class. Each of these words is modeled in the words Jack puts down on the page. He has an uneasy relationship with his Uncle Bill, a poetry teacher at a college, who insists that poems must rhyme and that what Jack is writing is not poetry.
But Jack persists. He tells the reader about some of the poems they read in class, TheRed Wheelbarrow by William Carlos Williams, The Eagle by Alfred Lord Tennyson and The Bells by Edgar Allan Poe, and these are emulated by Jack throughout the novel. As the story progresses, Jack tells how he hates cats, and is shocked when his teacher brings in her kittens. Little by little Jack's attitude to cats changes as he has more to do with the kittens and when his parents give him a kitten for Christmas, he is happy. A cloud appears however when the door is left open and the kitten escapes, only to be returned by the old stray who lives in the neighbourhood.
A delightful story, imbued with some well known and not so well known poems, this little book will be a hit with primary teachers looking for a model to use with their students. Students will easily fall for Jack and his dislike of cats and grow with him as he finds that they are not so bad after all. The modeling of the styles of poetry of Myers, Williams, Poe and Tennyson is a lovely touch, making their poetry more accessible to the young audience but also giving a neat way of teaching poetry in the middle primary to lower secondary classroom.
The last 20 pages of the book are filled with the poems talked of, including some by Jack, and the last 4 pages has a list of the poetry books kept in Miss Stretchberry's classroom. Both make a most useful addition to the book.
Fran Knight

Lock and key by Sarah Dessen

cover image

Penguin, 2009. ISBN 9780141324944.
(Ages 14+) Recommended. The test for me for a really good story is when I reach the end of a book and feel bitterly disappointed that I'm not continuing to follow the paths of the characters that I have gotten to know so well, and when I know that I will have to reread the book because I loved it so much. Lock and key is one such book. Ruby has been abandoned by her alcoholic mother and manages to survive for several months on her own. When her landlords discover that she is living in squalor by herself, Social Security is brought in and she is sent to live with her older sister Cora and brother-in-law Jamie in their luxurious house. Ruby is an independent girl who has built up many defences to ensure that she isn't disappointed by abandonment, and it's tough for her to break down these barriers, make friends and perhaps allow love into her life.
Sarah Dessen is an author who has a wonderful understanding of teenage girls, relationships, family and friendship. She manages to sympathetically delve into the life of Ruby, almost 18, who is determined that she will make it on her own, when she can legally leave her sister's house. I was engrossed as I followed Ruby's path, gradually letting some people into her life and making tentative friendships and the beginning of a romance with Nate, the amiable boy whose philosophy about adversity in life is that Uswim.
Ruby has a school project to complete about what it is to be a family and Dessen explores how diverse the meaning of family can be and how it means different things to different people and how it is always evolving. By the end of the book, Ruby has come to understand the complexity of the family, from a large supportive one like that her brother-in-law has, to the single parent one brought on by divorce and abandonment. She has begun to care about people and to tentatively trust some friends, and the reader has grown with her on the way.
The themes of family, domestic abuse, friendship and trust are beautifully handled. Dessen is an author whose books I will actively seek for their compelling writing and deft touch with relationships.
Pat Pledger

The Land of Mirthful by Sally Morgan, Ambelin, Blaze and Ezekiel Kwaymullina

cover image

Walker Books, 2009. ISBN 9781921150784. Stop Watch: Book 2,
(Ages 7-9) Each of the second markings on the stop watch Tom's grandfather has given him is the gateway to a different world. As the book begins, Tom and 'Bilby' are headed a mission, set by Grandpa, to 'a funny and sunny place' to find Finglethorn Underwood. Mirthful's rightful Queen, Jeromarni, and her family have disappeared and the self appointed Queen Mavis has taken over. Things are not as they should be and all appears to be doomed. The task of the heroes is to restore the Queen to her throne and save the kingdom of Mirthful.
An easy read novel, with traces of C.S. Lewis's Narnia and Garth Nix's Keys to the Kingdom, this series could provide a simple introduction to the fantasy genre. The double spacing makes it readily accessible to younger readers and there is enough action to make the story appealing. With sixty second markings on a stopwatch, this could prove to be a very long series! Given that Bilby, the Bridalon, was transported back via the first doorway and Tom allows him to take the bird back with him, the question arises as to whether or not there will be a stowaway from each of the lands. There will undoubtedly be many readers keen to continue on with the series, although possibly it may hold more appeal for the boys.
Jo Schenkel

60 classic Australian poems for children edited by Christopher Cheng

cover image

Ill. by Gregory Rogers. Random House Australia, 2009. ISBN 9781741664140.
(Age 9+) Recommended.
'Hist! Hark!
The night is very dark,
And we've to go a mile or so
Across the Possum Park.'
Did Australian rhyming verse really lose its appeal or do we just need new editions to replace the tired poetry books in our libraries? The second scenario is the more likely. Children are still enthralled and delighted by the drama, humour and wit of poems by such writers as C.J. Dennis, Banjo Paterson, Henry Kendall and Henry Lawson.
Christopher Cheng recalls the pleasure of reading and reciting Australian verse as a child. He has chosen 60 poems for a hard cover volume which is aptly named. Adults will recognise most of the titles and remember many of the opening lines by heart. Award winning artist Gregory Rogers has provided the pencil and wash illustrations.
The editor has restored lines which are often omitted because they speak of the hardships of life in the past. He has also included brief 'Poet biographies', an 'Index of first lines', an 'Index of poets', a list of sources in which the poems were first published and occasional notes about the history of the poems.
Most of the collection dates from the turn of the last century. It encapsulates the best of a tradition of storytelling through the medium of performance poetry. Christopher's Cheng's book will help to ensure that the tradition lives on.
Elizabeth Bor

Feather and bone by Laslo Strangolov

cover image

Walker Books, 2009. ISBN 9781406316005.
(Age 12+) This very strange novel poses some very challenging issues, not the least of which is human flesh as meat for a starving community. Kamil's father has disappeared in the woods and his mother has become a shadow of her former self. Kamil now has to walk Solace the dog each morning and evening. People do not go into the woods after dark for an unknown fear pervades the community. The poacher's daughter Lori and Kamil become involved in the mysterious business of the former poultry farm around which rabbits fit to burst live. It's a dark tale with Mr Petri centre of the darkness.
It's not a tale for the light hearted and the black and white sketches add atmosphere to the tale. As Matt Whyman says in the forward 'The book in your hands is a curious discovery. It has been penned by an author with a life story as odd and compelling as the tale to follow' pv. As Alice said, 'Curiouser and curiouser'. Not for the faint hearted.
Sue Nosworthy

Interview with Gabrielle Williams by Fran Knight

cover image

1. I admire the way no pat answers to central problems are given. Many adolescent novels are just so predictable in giving the easy answer. So why did you change the formula?
I think formulas are lazy - unless you're a scientist, in which case they're very clever. I wanted to write a book that was true to itself, not something that had to be shoehorned onto a pre-existing formula. I think that teenagers are pretty savvy and will pick up quite quickly if something is being cynically written to a formula in an attempt to appeal to them. So I got rid of all vampires in my novel.
2. Reading this novel made me feel like I was in Melbourne, my second favourite city, so just how real are the settings used?
Your second favourite city!!! What the hell! Which one's your first?
3. How hard was it to avoid using the sexual relations between young adults of this age as a platform for the story?
I think that sex is only one aspect of any relationship - it's important, but it's not the sole reason to be with someone. I wanted my characters to be with each other because they connected on an emotional level as well as a physical level. To have one without the other is to be out of balance.
4. Have you an ear for language? I found many of the sayings and shorthand sayings and responses so recognizable from kids in the street. The omigods made me laugh out loud. So where do you hear this language?
Here's the secret - I eavesdrop a lot. In cafes, on public transport, wherever I am, whoever I'm with, I'm usually eavesdropping in to the conversation that's happening at the table next to me. Is it something I'm proud of? No. Is it a handy habit to have? If you're an author, yes.
5. The emphasis on words and their meanings, the wit involving words and their meanings and usage were thrilling. How well do you think this emphasis will be received by today's young adults?
I think teenagers and young adults today have a very witty way with words. They twist the language so that it is colourful and memorable, and I love that about them. Admittedly their spelling leaves a little to be desired, but the fun they have with words is skillful, so I think they'll love the word plays in Beatle Meets Destiny.

Questions from Pat Pledger
6. What were your favourite books as a child?
When I was a kid I loved Enid Blyton and Agatha Christie. I think my ideal book would have been one in which The Saucepan Man did it!
7. Have you got any books that you could recommend to your readers?
I recommended the Tales of the City series by Armistead Maupin to my daughter who is 19, and she loved them because of their colourful characters and interwoven plots. Also, The Child's Book of True Crime by Chloe Hooper is great and Hi Fidelity by Nick Hornby. And The Lovely Bones is brilliant.

Beatle meets Destiny by Gabrielle Williams

cover image

Penguin, 2009. ISBN 9780143011491.
(Ages 13+) Recommended. Beatle, so named because his name is John Lennon, meets Destiny at a tram stop in Melbourne one Friday night. She is attracted to him because of his name, he to her because she is wearing sunglasses at 9 pm. So begins an off relationship, as they skirt around each other, sensing each other's interest. But Beatle already has a girlfriend, one who he cherishes, although their relationship is not what it was. A smart funny dialogue between the 2 is kept up throughout the book, as Williams gives vent to some of her dislikes of the deterioration of the spoken word.
Destiny's family is obsessed with tarot cards and horoscopes, the paranormal and coincidence, so her day always begins with readings to start the journey. Her brother, Frank a teacher at the local school, is seen by Beatle with his own sister, Winsome, and struggles with the information as Frank teaches them both in their year 12 English studies class. Someone is ringing Destiny and one night she has her underwear stolen, and much of the evidence falls on Beatle. Meanwhile their relationship is in a vacuum, as Destiny finds out about the girlfriend, and thinks Beatle is two timing them both. Destiny has answered an ad in the hope of making money, and her sister, Matilde has taken a chair found on the side of the road for hard rubbish collection.
A load of believable characters, mixed up with each other and their friends, wonderful scenes where things happen which are not outlandish or contrived, wrapped up with some smart dialogue and very funny word play, make this a great read for middle secondary students. Word jokes, plays on anything to do with the Beatles, mockery and repartee all add to the fun in this story. It is refreshing to read a book where the usual cliches of boy meets girl do not happen, where all the scenes are fresh and new, and where things are discussed which are relevant and involving.
Fran Knight

Confessions of a liar, thief and failed sex god by Bill Condon

cover image

Woolshed Press, 2009. ISBN 9781741664546.
(Ages 14+) Bill Condon has set this coming of age story in the 1960s. Australia is involved in the Vietnam War and the country is still deeply conservative. Neil is in his final year at a Christian Brothers school in Sydney, a year that will see many changes for this boy on the cusp of manhood.
Neil's life revolves around his family; Dad, Mum and brother Kevin, and his best friend Troy, who is always up for a dare and is afraid of nothing. Some of the certainties of life that Neil has known begin to crumble. Troy shows he's just as vulnerable as anyone else when he steals a wallet and allows Zom (short for Zombie), a quiet unassuming classmate take the blame. Zom shows a very different side to his character when he declares his innocence and punches the much feared Brother Michael right in the middle of the quad.
Zom is not only expelled from school but ejected from home as well and has to live in a small flat with his sister Sylvia. Neil, feels no great friendship for Zom, but thinks he's been treated very harshly because of Troy's actions. Zom promises to get back at Brother Michael while Neil finds Sylvia very attractive.
Things get worse at school with the arrival of a new lay teacher, Delaine, who introduces himself on the first day by giving the whole class six cuts with the strap just to show who's boss. But Troy is singled out for special treatment and cries when he goes back to his seat. This wouldn't have been so bad if Neil hadn't seen his tears and loss of face. On the way home just as they've said goodbye Troy is hit by a car and killed. Neil lies to the police and says Troy was his usual happy self.
It seems that it's the beginning of a series of lies to his family, Zom and Sylvia. When he sees Sylvia to thank her for saving him from drowning (even though it was Zom that saved him) things go further than either of them had planned. He also discovers that Zom is going to act on his plan to seek revenge on Brother Michael. Neil tries to talk him out of it and even persuades Zom that he'll try and sort it out with Brother Michael. But there is no change in either the attitude of Zom or Brother Michael.
The results aren't those expected but there are resolutions. The problems of the protagonist seem enormous and earth shattering, but life does move on. Things are not as bad as they seem. Conlon has written a book that will appeal to a wide audience, but particularly boys of middle school age. It's an easy read and a compulsive one at that.
Mark Knight

Bang, bang, you're dead by Narinder Dhami

cover image

Corgi, 2009.
(Age: 12+) Highly recommended. Mia and her twin brother Jamie have much to contend with. Their mother suffers from bipolar disorder and refuses to seek help. When the twins' beloved grandfather dies their Mother's condition spirals out of control. Mia copes as best she can, but Jamie, filled with anger and resentment, seems to be going off the rails. Then one morning Mia's school is subjected to a siege and she is convinced that the crazed gunman holding class 9D hostage is her own brother. Mia discovers depths she never knew she had in an effort to reach Jamie and end the siege peacefully.
This is a tense, smouldering novel that switches between past and present to gradually reveal the events that have set Jamie on this disastrous path to self destruction. However all is not as it seems and from the start Mia continually doubts whether the gunman is actually Jamie. Would her beloved twin brother really be capable of such evil?
Just as we are nearing the explosive finish Dhami lifts the whole plot to a higher plane with a superb twist that makes the reader re-evaluate everything they have just read.
With believable characters and fast moving cinematic action, this is first class writing that will grip you round the jugular and leave you both exhausted and exhilarated. I always find it a challenge to suggest an age range for a novel, as twelve and thirteen year olds vary so much (just as forty year olds do I suppose! However, with the bleak subject matter of major depressive illness and a school siege you may want to recommend this to older readers.
Claire Larson

The hunger games: Catching fire by Suzanne Collins

cover image

Scholastic, 2009. ISBN 9781407109367.
(Ages 13+) Recommended. After the thrilling first book in the series, The hunger games, comes an equally riveting action driven sequel. Catching fire follows the story of Katniss and Peetar, as they return victorious to their village. Life has changed for them. They are no longer hungry and living in poverty. Katniss finds it difficult to settle down. She still continues to break the law and hunt illegally for food for her friends and is torn about her feelings for Gale, her hunter friend, and Peetar. When she inadvertently becomes the focus of a rebellion in Panem, things begin to hot up for her and she is faced with going into the Arena again to fight to the death.
Although some of the action scenes feel a bit like a rerun from the first novel, they were still exciting enough to keep me reading and certainly on edge for the sequel. The romantic interest seesaws between the two young men, Peetar, who often appears to be too good to be true and Gale who has had a thin role in the action.
However Katniss is a most appealing heroine - she is brave and loyal to her friends. Her daring feats in the Arena and her encounters with the evil President kept me on the edge of my seat and I can't wait to see what will happen next.
Pat Pledger

The last knight by Hilari Bell

cover image

HarperTeen, 2007. ISBN 9780060825058. A knight and rogue novel.
(Age: 12+) Chosen as one of ALA's 2009 Best Books for Young Adults, The last knight is a hilarious story about Sir Michael, bent on doing chivalrous deeds, even though the idea of the knight errant is years out of date. He has acquired for his squire the criminal Fisk, saving him from the hangman's rope. On their quest to rescue damsels in distress, they release the Lady Ceciel who has been imprisoned in a tower. However, in their impetuous rush to do daring deeds, they don't investigate just why she is imprisoned and find to their horror that she has been charged with poisoning her husband.
Told in the voices of both Sir Michael and Fisk, the reader sees the story unfolding from different points of view: Sir Michael is an idealistic optimist while Fisk has a cynical viewpoint of life in his role as 'squire to a hero'. The contrast between Michael who never lies and Fisk who is a conman, leads to many laughs. The humour is laugh out loud delightful as the pair blunder from one disaster to another, trying to work out the mystery of Lady Ceciel and the intricate workings of Magica, the magic of sensing things.
Both Michael and Fisk are likeable characters, and Lady Ceciel is a most satisfying villain. Even the horse, Tipple, who likes to have a drink or two, provides amusement.
In amongst the chaos of their adventures, the pair begin to trust each other and learn a great deal about friendship, loyalty and honour. This is the first book in the series and I look forward to following the adventures of the knight and the rogue.
Pat Pledger

Marsh Island by Sonya Spreen Bates

cover image

Orca Echoes, 2009. ISBN 9781554691173.
On their first ever camping trip with their father, Jake and Tommy go exploring. Jake is annoyed at having his younger brother tag along and needing to entertain him. As they venture further from camp, they become lost. When they see a stranger in the woods, Jake's bravado disappears; they cut their adventuring short and race to trace their path back to camp. Is he the mysterious Alfred Marsh, the man whose story has been revealed by their father, and is there truly a lost fortune?
This novel would suit several audiences. It could work as either a text for emergent readers who wish to read not-too-scary adventure stories themselves or reluctant male readers in the middle primary looking for something short to hold their attention. Written by a Canadian author, now living in Australia, and containing a similar setting to the Hatchet series, the tale is short and simply told. Bates has worked in speech pathology with children with communication disorders. Both the number of pages and the vocabulary of this text indicate that the series should be easily accessible to younger or struggling students. The full page illustrations match the text and could be used to support the reader as they set the scene and create atmosphere.
Jo Schenkel

The Magician's Elephant by Kate diCamillo

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2009. ISBN 9780763644109.
(Ages 9+) Highly recommended. This beautifully written fable, the story of Peter, brought up by an old, befuddled soldier, but all the time dreaming of his sister, will tug at the heart strings of all readers. Peter's mother died at the birth of his sister, and he remembers holding the baby and promising his mother he would look after her. But the soldier, an army friend of his dead father, reminds him that his sister was still born. Peter cannot shake off the idea his sister is alive, and when a fortune teller comes to the town, he uses the florin given him by the soldier for their meager tea, to ask the fortune teller about his sister. He is told she is alive and will find her through an elephant.
This extraordinary piece of news, the first of many extraordinary things which occur through this story, has Peter reeling at the news that an elephant has dropped through the ceiling of the local opera house, causing pandemonium. The magician who conjured the elephant has been thrown into jail, and when Peter visits the elephant, he is touched by her sadness of being separated from her family. So Peter acts, bringing all the protagonists together in a final act which sees the elephant returned, the magician released, Peter and Adele reunited and both the children with a loving family.
A superbly told story of imaging the unimaginable, of hoping against all hope for your dreams to come true, this is one of those stories that will pass from hand to hand, rarely left on the shelves.
Fran Knight

The loblolly boy by James Norcliffe

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2009. ISBN 9781742371160.
(Ages 9+)Recommended. What would you do if you were desperately unhappy and were given the opportunity to soar away using beautiful green wings? The loblolly boy can fly wherever he wants and has eternal youth. He also has the power to Exchange - to swap places with others who are Sensitive and can see him. But why would he want to change identities with children who are often very miserable? These children soon discover that there is danger flying above the earth and that there are many things they miss from their old lives.
A unique and original fantasy, complete with adventure, magic and appealing characters, this is a tale that was hard to put down. The first chapter sucked me in with its grim portrayal of a young boy who has lost his mother and has to deal with a very unpleasant stepmother, and went on to tantalise me with the story of Michael who had been left in a home for abandoned children.
The descriptions, particularly of flying, are beautiful and will fire the imagination of the reader. Thought provoking and often scary themes of identity, freedom, immortality and whether the grass is greener on the other side of the fence are challenging and the action driven plot engrossing.
Pat Pledger