Reviews

The keeper by Rosanne Hawke

cover image

University of Queensland Press, 2013. ISBN 9780702249730.
'Gran used to watch me like a one-legged gull at a picnic' is one of the brilliant expressions from The keeper. Set in a small seaside town on the Yorke Peninsula, this marvellous story centres upon Joel, a young boy without parents who lives with a loving Grandmother. Having a learning disability and a tendency to respond to taunting bullies with his fists, Joel is frequently in trouble at school and is frustrated and angry, except when fishing or playing with his friend Mei, the daughter of a local fisherman.
Fed up with not having a Dad, Joel places an advert in the newspaper to offer the position and is impressed when tough looking biker Dev arrives on a Harley to try out for the job. The pair establish a friendship with shared experiences, conversation and intuitive understanding which is developed by the opportunity to compete in the annual fishing competition, a chance previously denied to the fatherless Joel.
This is a genuinely enjoyable novel and wholesome but realistic life lessons are delivered within a captivating story and polished narrative. Hawke presents a flawed individual with a shady past who has learned from his mistakes and seeks to teach a youngster to avoid conflict and violence. The author is to be commended for including such a character whilst avoiding gushing sentimentality or diminishing the threatening nature of bikies, drugs and crime.
The basis of the relationship may be implausible to adults, especially in the context of stranger danger and child protection, however the story's development feels natural, especially given Joel's loner behaviour and tendency to keep quiet about what he gets up to.
The arrival of other significant characters from the past could be considered too contrived, however the story works satisfactorily towards an acceptable conclusion.
Written for children of 9 years onwards, Primary school librarians can be confident that the content and language is age appropriate. This story also serves the needs of older struggling readers who require less demanding text but still enjoy well-crafted narrative with a solid plot.
Rob Welsh

The Perplexing Pineapple by Ursula Dubosarsky

cover image

The Cryptic Casebook of Coco Carlomagno and Alberta series. Allen and Unwin, 2013. ISBN 9781743312575.
(Age: 9+) A strange pineapple floats by at the same time everyday followed by a scream and then laughing. That's enough to scare anyone! When the Chief of the Buenos Aires police is scared who does he call? He calls his very smart cousin, Alberta, because she has a very big brain.
Alberta and Coco (the Chief of police) are guinea pigs by the way and their story is a quick paced, easy read for independent readers aged 9+. It is especially good for those readers who don't like large novels and as part of a series, children can follow these guinea pig cousins as they crack more mysteries.
As Alberta and Coco get to the bottom of the strange pineapple, Coco ends up solving another police issue. Maybe he is not that silly after all.
The book includes illustrations to help solve the mystery and it asks the reader questions along the way, helping involve them in the mystery.
Kylie Kempster

The first third by Will Kostakis

cover image

Penguin, 2013. ISBN 9780143568179.
Billy Tsiolkas loves his Yiayia (Grandmother) openly, without embarrassment and he endures her ethnic idiosyncrasies with good humour and respect. In his final year at school, with two estranged brothers and a mother who is saddened by her single status, Billy becomes fearful when Yiayia is hospitalised by complications from a kidney stone. The elderly woman clearly has a major influence in family affairs and Billy dares not decline when she submits to him a 'bucket list' or series of wishes to be granted before she dies.
Accompanied by an amusing best friend 'Sticks' who has cerebral palsy, Billy sets forth to try to bring about three seemingly impossible feats which Yiayia considers will fix his family. This story is all about relationships including friendships, familial interactions and romantic involvement. Sticks inveigles his way into Billy's negotiation of all three and shows a curious mix of compassion and kindness with a merciless attitude to dropping Billy in embarrassing situations.
This is a realistic portrayal of adolescent life and I liked the fact that everyday situations encountered commonly in families were presented in an entertaining manner and were completely adequate in framing the narrative.
The novel still has quirks however. Items on the bucket list include 'fixing' Peter, the aggressive, truculent younger brother with whom Billy no longer has any communication beyond grunts, and finding a girlfriend for the eldest brother Simon who lives interstate. The rift with Peter troubles Billy greatly and he agonises over its causes as he seeks to reconcile differences and restore the relationship, yet the reader never discovers why and how this has come about. Similarly, the amusing twist in finding Simon a girlfriend, given that he is gay (known by the family but an alien concept to Yiayia) becomes secondary in Billy's difficulty to fulfil this promise when he discovers a facade which is never explored in any depth.
The characters represented in this novel are familiar in an Australian context and the reader is caught up in Billy's quest to ease their pain and strengthen the bonds within his own family as its members negotiate the ups and downs of contemporary life.
Rob Welsh

Let's paint by Alborozo

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2013. ISBN 9781743313695.
(Age: 3+) Picture book. Art. Experimenting. This joyous colour filled book that will encourage and delight young readers to try something for themselves will be a hit amongst parents and early childhood teachers alike.
From the different coloured dog prints on the front endpapers through all the different experiments with paints and paint brushes and canvasses through to the endpapers showing coloured human foot prints, the book encourages children to try their hand at painting.
Faced with a blank canvas and a handful of paint, the question is what if I make a mistake. The answer that there are no mistakes in art can be very salutary to the young beginner. Then ideas crowd in as the reader is told that ideas come from anywhere, they can be big or small, uninvited or collected. From there the reader is shown a variety of different methods with some pages hinting at the artist who used this technique. The author then shows the reader that it can be scary or embarrassing, but whatever, it is important that the painter has fun!
The lightly sketched illustrations do not overwhelm, the colour is filled with fun and interest, inviting the reader to run out and get some paint and get painting.
Fran Knight

Doomsday by Chris Morphew

cover image

Phoenix Files Book 6, Hardie Grant Egmont, 2013. ISBN 9781921502446.
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Doomsday picks up with less than twenty-four hours until the end of civilisation as we know it. With Luke and Jordan desperately fighting to rescue humanity from the dire plans of the Shackleton corporation, it seems they have more enemies than ever before, with even Peter being out of control and seemingly about to destroy them. As war rages, they battle against the clock to put an end to the plans of their enemies. Who or what is Tobias and will he have the power to put things to rights?
This is one series which seems to appeal to girls and boys alike, despite its violence, bloodshed and the traumas faced by the population of Phoenix. Initially, it is only the children who are aware that something is seriously amiss within the confines of the town but slowly the adults come to realise that things are not as they should be. From book one in which the town reminded me of a children's version of The Stepford Wives to the final resolution, the action and excitement keep one on the edge of one's seat. The appeal of having a different narrator for each of the earlier books adds to the gender balance, helping to make the books accessible to all readers. Changing the narrator chapter by chapter in the final title gives one a multitude of different perspectives throughout Doomsday, thereby keeping the reader informed as to how each group of characters is feeling and how they are being occupied.
Personally, I felt reasonably satisfied by this final instalment, despite having had to suspend disbelief totally. Most of the loose ends were tied up sufficiently and I continued to be intrigued by the characters that underwent major changes toward the end of the series. I found the ultimate battle between good and evil to be powerful and engaging. Not a read for the fainthearted, however!
Jo Schenkel

One day: Around the world in 24 hours by Suma Din

cover image

Ill. by Christina Engel. Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 9781408180235.
(Age: 6+) Picture book. Time. World travel. In one day, fifteen different children around the world are shown in their own houses, schools and towns. Each page reflects their variety and their similarities as twenty four hours passes. Starting with a double page map of the world and the faces and places of the fifteen children, the book map is divided into the time zones of the world, allowing some discussion before reading about the children. Using the twentyfour hour clock will also teach the readers a different way of telling the time.
Each double page thereafter contains one large page of illustrations alongside four smaller illustrations. Each of the five illustrates one child in one country and what they are doing. So each is occurring at the same time around the world, but in different times zones. So a child at school in the United Kingdom, playing soccer at 11 will be doing this at the same time as a child in the USA is eating breakfast, but there it is 8 in the morning, while in South Africa children are just going home from school, and India they are having dinner and in China, going to bed. Pages are crowded with images of children doing different things around the world, and can be a springboard for all sorts of discussion about similarities and differences, but above all about time. Two pages at the end give information about time zones, Greenwich Mean Time and Universal Coordinated Time.
Fran Knight

The whole of my world by Nicole Hayes

cover image

Woolshed Press, 2013. ISBN 9781742758602.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Shelley Brown is hoping for a fresh start; a new school brings the possibility of new friends and new interests, the possibility of a new life. Since the loss of her mother, Shelley and her dad are drawing a line between the past and the present, so Shelley jumps at the chance to attend footy training with her new friend, Tara. After all, football has always been Shelley's passion especially her beloved Glenthorn Football Club. Attending Thursday night training also gives Shelley a chance to befriend the new player, Mick Edwards. They have a lot in common: he is new to the club and is trying to put together a good season to keep his future in football alive. Shelley is the newbie in the Cheer Squad, trying to put together a new future
Shelley and Tara are obsessed by their footy team and this novel is cleverly structured to reflect this passion: every chapter and section references the game, from 'The Draft' to the 'Pre-Season' to 'The end-of-season Trip'. Author Nicole Hayes has also cleverly structured the plot development. Whilst most readers will accept Shelley's lingering grief at losing her mother, midway through the novel the full story behind Shelley's loss is revealed in a manner which will make readers empathise with the deep pain behind her journey of rebirth.
In a sports mad country like Australia it is always intriguing to shine a light on that obsession and Nicole Hayes does this thoughtfully, as her novel explores the importance of football in so many fans' lives: the euphoria when their team wins, the despair when they lose and the relationship they have with the players themselves.
However, this is more than just a football yarn; set against the football background is a bigger story about grief and loss, about family ties and family breakdown, of burgeoning love and the resilience needed not only to face another football season but also to face life's many ups and downs. Even those who don't love football will find a lot to enjoy in Shelley Brown's world.
Deborah Marshall

The Cloud Road by Isobelle Carmody

cover image

Penguin Books, 2013. ISBN 9780075188. 289p
Well recommended for young readers. The Cloud Road is the second in The Kingdom of the Lost series. Written for younger readers, this fantasy-adventure takes Bily and Zluty and Redwing their navigating bird away from their home after the 'arosh', a storm of red stones destroyed their home and all around them. That strange storm had brought Monster into their cellar. It was half dead, an 'enormous beast (with) long, deadly, claw-tipped paws and a red maw full of teeth as long and sharp as daggers' p6. They placed the Monster in the wagon and set off to find water, which the Monster said would be beyond the desert they needed to cross.
Carmody entices the young reader to wonder what the 'arosh', 'whiteout', 'the Makers', the 'Monks' and the 'diggers' might really be. Perhaps there's a lesson for everyone when Bily says, 'Now I think we must live by the rules of the places we come to' p143.
It's an intriguing tale of brotherly love, friendship and trust with good triumphing almost over evil. That's left to book three. Her use of descriptive and unusual language formations enriches the fantasy. Carmody encourages her readers to think about the visual images and to use the language that inspires. As adults we might use snow but here they are 'coldwhites'. Readers will be keen to read The Velvet City.
Sue Nosworthy

Life after theft by Aprilynne Pike

cover image

HarperCollins, 2013. ISBN 9780007515561.
(Age: 14+) Recommended as an easy to read, light story. Ghosts. Theft. Romance. How would you feel if you came face to face with a ghost? That's the dilemma that faces, Jeff, who is confronted by Kimberlee Schaffer, who dropped dead the previous year. She has come back to haunt him because she needs his help with her unfinished business. In real life Kimberlee may have been gorgeous and popular, but she was a kleptomaniac and she wants Jeff to help her return all the things that she stole.
I enjoyed this story that was told from the point of view of Jeff, who was a positive male voice. He doesn't want to be haunted by Kimberlee so he agrees to help her, especially when she tells him that the things that she stole had real value for the people concerned. Faced with the huge hoard of stolen goods that Kimberlee has secreted in a cave on her parent's property, Jeff has to come up with some innovative ways of getting stuff back to its original owners and this propels the plot forward in often amusing ways.
The character development is great and we see Kimberlee grow from a selfish teen, albeit a ghost, to a girl who can see other points of view. Jeff is believable as the boy who helps her out and his growing romance with Sera, who is the girl Kimberlee has really hurt, adds some tension to the plot.
This is a fun read that will appeal to girls in particular and will have the added bonus of some dark moments as the reader ponders why Kimberlee has stolen so much and whether she will be able to understand her actions enough to stop haunting Jeff.
Pat Pledger

A bear and a tree by Stephen Michael King

cover image

Penguin, 2012. ISBN 9780670075829.
(Age: 4+) Warmly recommended. Picture book. Friendship. Change. When Ren is upset that her loved tree has lost all of its leaves, Bear stops collecting the leaves for his den for the winter, and sits with her until she is calmer. They then spend the day together, Bear answering Ren's questions about the snow as best as he can. They play together in the snow, looking at the patterns in the snow, the icicles and simply dancing. They meet Mouse who is waiting for the night so that he can catch the first winter stars. They spend the night watching the stars, and when morning comes, Bear realises that he must sleep. He attaches some of the leaves he has collected to the tree, adding some of the things they have made together and goes to his den to sleep.
A tale of friendship and change, this story is seemingly simple, but has many layers to reveal as it is read and reread. The idea of change permeates the book, from the leafless tree, to Bear needing to sleep, so leaving his friend, to the change in the patterning of the sky, to the increasingly cold landscape. The blue and white of the pages, the lack of leaves on all the trees, the change from rainy landscape to one covered in snow, all point to the fact that Bear must soon retire to bed.
For parents and teachers simply looking at weather patterns and seasonal changes then this is a wonderful introduction, and for those wanting to look at friendship and change, then this book will provide a masterful springboard.
Fran Knight

Bakir and Bi by Jillian Boyd

cover image

Ill. by Tori-Jay Mordey. Magabala Books, 2013. ISBN 9781921248863.
I read this book from a teaching point of view, and found it useful for comparing Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal cultures. For example: attitudes towards conservation and drought, interpretation of dreams, beliefs. It could be used for some topics in Aboriginal studies in the middle primary, such as the traditional use of resources and the naming of children and places. I think it would also be good for use in discussions about relationships, such as what causes good friends/family to become estranged and sometime enemies.
Rhoda Jenkin

A Royal Fairytale: Kate and William by Ink Robin and Adam Larkum

cover image

Egmont, 2013. ISBN 9781405268431. pbk.
While the world waits and the souvenir factories go into overdrive, Ink Robin brings us this picture book for littlies that tells the true story of a prince and his princess, how they met, fell in love, had a wedding that the whole world watched and then kept waiting for THAT announcement.
Written really well with the traditional 'once upon a time' start and the 'happily ever after' ending in a style that echoes 'handsome prince meets and marries beautiful commoner girl' stories of a bygone era, this tale not only tells the story of he who will be king when our little people are old enough to understand what that means (even though he might not be king of Australia then) but it also keep every little girl's dreams of becoming a princess alive. Two Miss 7's who shared it with me had very satisfied smiles on their faces at the end.
Apart from its connections to the events in London that have the media in a frenzy (and the bookies making a mint), this book could also be used as an introduction to biography genre and a creative teacher librarian could construct a curriculum of rich investigations ranging from exploring the nature of biographies and their essential elements; seeking ideas for collection development through identifying who the students would like to know more about and writing these stories; delving into the history of the monarchy and its relationship to and impact on Australian lives; to considering and debating whether Australia should become a republic. Rich pickings indeed which begin with 'Once upon a time' for the reader and lead to 'happily ever after' for the teacher and teacher librarian wanting something a little different.
Barbara Braxton

The disgrace of Kitty Grey by Mary Hooper

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 978 1 4088 2761 1
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Historical novel.Convicts. Set in the time of Jane Austen and Regency England, Hooper has her main character, Kitty Gray, one of the servants in a wealthy household, go to London to buy a book for her mistress. Kitty is a milkmaid, running the kitchen dairy which supplies the milk for the household, and so in a trusted position within the servant community. She is friendly with the local ferrryman, and he has been left with the charge of his younger sister, Betsy, following the deaths of his parents. But he has plans to improve himself, and so sets off to London to gain employment on the ferries on the Thames River, leaving Betsy with the distraught Kitty.
Given the task of going to London to buy a book for her mistress, the innocent Kitty sets off, with Betsy in tow, hoping to find Will. We see her traveling to the city on a coach, but once there she is tricked out of the money given her to buy the book, and is alone, penniless and with a sick child to care for.
She takes lodgings where she can, avoiding the suggestions that she can earn money in other ways, and eventually, using an old chair to light a fire for the sick child, is taken to Newgate and sentenced to seven years' transportation. But she is able to escape. Hooper can certainly recreate the times well. The reader will be in no doubt about the gravity of her situation in London, where a girl in her situation can be easily persuaded into a life of prostitution. The cruelty of other poor around her adds to the feeling of the decay of the place, the scavengers in the street, the poor houses, the unwanted attention of men, the prison and finally the ship where she is held prior to leaving for the colonies. All are described in such detail, that readers can be in no doubt about the gravity of people in her situation.
While some of the plot is perhaps a bit of a stretch to believe, it is an exciting and involving read, strongly evocative of the times, and girls particularly will read this book with pleasure.
Fran Knight

Not for turning: The life of Margaret Thatcher by Robin Harris

cover image

Transworld Publishers, 2013. ISBN 9780593072868.
(Age: 18+) Margaret Thatcher broke through the glass ceiling of British politics to become the first woman to lead the Conservative Party and the country's first female Prime Minister. When she resigned in 1990, she had held the office for longer than any other British Prime Minister of the twentieth century. Readers wanting to find out how one person could achieve so much will find many answers to their questions in Not for turning: The life of Margaret Thatcher by Robin Harris.
The author was Margaret Thatcher's speechwriter and advisor but although he agreed with many of her policies, he has carefully weighed her weaknesses as a political leader against her strengths. The result is a sympathetic but not uncritical account of the former Prime Minister's rise and fall. It explains how Margaret Thatcher's steely determination took her from a modest home to 10 Downing Street, sustained her as she confronted opposition to her policies and survived a terrorist attack, then contributed to her downfall when she refused to withdraw the Community Charge, also known as the Poll Tax. Although readers will learn much about her personal life, Not for turning is essentially a detailed political biography which assumes that its audience has a sophisticated knowledge of British society and politics. A chronology, an extensive bibliography and photographs are provided, but there is no glossary. Meticulous source notes and a challenging vocabulary mark this title as the work of an academically trained author, who anticipates that his book will be selected by university and public libraries.
Not for turning is one person's interpretation of a remarkable if controversial career. It will be of interest to students of politics and economics, as well as those who want to learn more about the life of a leader whose name became synonymous with the ideology she endorsed: Thatcherism.
Elizabeth Bor

Truly Tan Jinxed by Jen Storer

cover image

Ill. by Claire Robertson. ABC Books, 2013. ISBN 9780733331220.
(Age: 8+) Chapter book. The second in the series, Truly Tan, this funny, lighthearted look at rural life will engage middle primary readers with ease.
Tan and her sister swimming in their dam, cannot help but talk about their father's latest sale purchase, an old tram. It sits forlornly near the dam, and the children have strict instructions not to go anywhere near it. Of course, a rule like that is red rag to a bull, so they are beset with stories about what could possibly be so bad that they are not allowed to go inside. They enlist the help of classmates who tell them it came from a deceased estate, and it even has a name, Miss Havisham. The children then take stock of other things in their house, most of which came to them from other sales in the neighbourhood, many from deceased estates.
Through Tan's diary, pages of which break up the storyline and give us a different perspective, we see how the children react when one sees the curtain flutter on the old tram.
Tan has plans to be a girl detective and armed with the accoutrement of a detective, a tape recorder, pens and pencils, she and the others plot their course of action. They camp one night near the dam, and encounter a ghost, and this is enough to keep readers hooked in this highly entertaining tale. Fun ensues with all coming out right in the end.
Fran Knight