Reviews

A Lottie Lipton adventure: The scroll of Alexandria by Dan Metcalf

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781472911872
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. If you are looking for a new series to engage newly independent readers, you need look no further!
Imagine living in a museum full of rare and wonderful objects. Lottie Lipton, nine years old, lives in the British Museum with her Great Uncle Bert and absolutely adores the Great Library with its vast collection of rare and valuable books. Rapacious Sir Trevelyan Taylor, the new Head Curator of the museum, has other views and sees the disposal of the books as a prime money raiser, claiming that books have no place in a museum and no regard for the Royal Appointment that placed them there by King George - which came with unbreakable instructions that the collection must not be split.
But if Lottie and Great Uncle Bert can find the last remaining scroll of the ancient library of Alexandria, which would definitely constitute a museum artefact then the nasty Sir Trev's plot will be well and truly foiled.
Young readers will love helping Lottie with her puzzle and decoding secret messages as this determined girl follows the clues to find the missing scroll. Her fellow investigators, Great Uncle Bert and Reg the caretaker are fun characters adding humour to the story. A glossary of more difficult words is included at the end of the book along with a couple of additional brainteasers to solve.
Look for at least three more titles forthcoming in this terrific interactive series. Highly recommended for readers from around 7 years up.
Sue Warren

Clarrie's pig day out by Jen Storer

cover image

Ill. by Sue DeGennaro. ABC Books, 2016. ISBN 9780733334443
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Words. Dogs. Farm life. Humour. When Clarrie goes out to get some chickens for his hen coop, he tries to take his dog, Bert with him. But he mixes up his words, and instead of calling to his dog, calls instead to his dag. In putting on his hat, he puts on a cat which cost him a lot of funny. Of course, a huge hint about the exchange of letters is on the title on the cover, Clarrie's pig day out, so children will be forewarned about what may lie inside. And they will not be disappointed. All through this very funny book, we see Clarrie making elemental mistakes with his words, usually changing just one letter for another with funny results. Children will laugh out loud at the mistakes he makes, noticing the error almost immediately then calling out what the real word will be in the blink of an eye. Each word that needs a change is highlighted as if it is on a small piece of paper stuck to the page, while the rest of the sentences are in a thin pale font. For children reading the book, they will immediately see the problem words.
The humorous illustrations by DeGennaro will have the readers scanning the pages eagerly to look at the range of things shown. Clarrie's kitchen is full of interest and each page draws the eyes to something different illustrated there. I love the stylised trees and plants, the price tag on Clarrie's new gum boots and the flag atop the hen house. What an enjoyable book for young and old.
Fran Knight

Hello, goodbye and everything in between by Jennifer E. Smith

cover image

Headline 2016. ISBN 9781472235565
(Age: 12+) Recommended. If, like me, you have often struggled to find a romance for tweens without graphic or inappropriate content, this is one to put on your list.
From the author of The statistical probability of love at first sight and The geography of you and me this is the thoroughly enjoyable story of Clare and Aidan and a list. These two seniors have been an item for the final years of high school and along with their best friends, Stella and Scotty, are about to embark on the thrilling but anxiety-making adventure of college.
The conflict lies in the fact that these two are bound for colleges on opposite sides of the country and their last night is one of very mixed emotions. Clare has made a list (that's something she is very good at) and the pair re-visit their favourite haunts, the scenes of firsts, catch up with their friends and toss the problem of whether to break up or not, back and forth. The very thought of being apart after their two years of being virtually inseparable is completely distressing for both and they postulate on whether it might be less painful to break up rather than let the relationship die away from long distance constraints.
Along with their own personal dilemma the night holds many other complications as tensions run high while they hang out with each other and others. Of all the events that impact on the pair probably the most confounding is that Stella and Scotty who have sniped at each other incessantly since kindergarten have suddenly become a couple. And it is this that influences their respective thoughts as much as anything else.
All in all this is a really engaging novel with very likeable characters for which the reader can really care. One cannot help but wish them the happiest of endings as they are such funny and endearing people. Recommended for your romantically inclined readers from around 12 years up.
Sue Warren

I just couldn't wait to meet you by Kate Ritchie

cover image

Ill. by Hannah Sommerville. Random House Australia, 2016. ISBN 9780857989703
(Ages: 3-7) Family. Babies. Love. Kate Ritchie, of 'Home and away' fame, began work on this as a letter to her infant daughter. It talks directly to the reader, reminiscing on what it was like waiting for her baby to be born ('Would you grow up big and strong? What would be your favourite toy?') before reflecting on life with her baby ('and although you challenge me, I know we will be okay'). The sex of the baby, through the use of neutral colours and careful wording, is unidentified. This means that all young children will be able to relate to the baby in the story.
The text rhymes and flows quite well. The verse only occasionally seems clunky - particularly the last page ('I am so lucky that I met you. I just couldn't wait to meet you!'), or not reflective of how a parent actually speaks to a child ('Each day my glad heart sings'). Otherwise, it is tender, reassuring and well phrased ('So I'll be here to watch you grow, and guide you on your way').
Hannah Sommerville has done a wonderful job illustrating this with warm, earthy tones and rounded, comforting lines that add to the welcoming, caring feel of the story. The front endpapers have illustrations of things that might be stuck in a baby scrapbook: ultrasound photos, lists of names, baby shower invitations and belly photographs and the back endpapers show artefacts and photographs of the new baby's milestones: first smile, footprint, lock of hair, first painting, etc. These will provide talking points for parents and children as they discuss these things within their own family context (What would I have been called if I was a boy/girl? When did I first smile?). It might even prompt the pulling out of their baby book or photo album.
This book, to be shared between parents and children, could be used to reinforce how special and loved a child is, particularly if a new sibling has or is joining the family. It will also be reassuring and touching for new parents and seems to be written as much for them as for children.
Nicole Nelson

Crabbing with Dad by Paul Seden

cover image

Magabala Books, 2016. ISBN 9781925360158
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Aboriginal themes, Family relationships, Crabbing, Fathers. The simple act of doing something with Dad is shown in this delightful new book from Magabala Books. The universal story of families working together is infectious and all children, indigenous and non indigenous will enjoy the trip to the creek to catch a crab. The warmth of the family outing, the closeness between Dad and his children, the inclusion of the fellows fishing on the beach, the addition of a cousin, all make the day a marvellous success.
Sam and his brother, Mahli, put on their life jackets and speed off with Dad along the creek to their secret spot. They throw over their crab pots (judiciously we are told the laws about crab netting in Australia at the start of the book) and watch the fish swimming beneath them. When the pot is pulled from the bottom of the creek they have caught the biggest crab ever and need to do things to it to stop it from nipping their fingers. We are shown aspects of culture through this story, and the respect shown to the fish in the creek, as well as respecting the laws of the land: lifejackets, sunscreen, safety on the water and wearing hats. And I particularly like the illustration on the front cover: young readers will quiver with excitement at the thought of being nipped by those large claws looming out at them and eagerly turn the pages to find out what the boys do on their day with Dad.
This lovely story, richly showing a day out with Dad that all kids can read and admire, underlines the importance of the father in all our societies giving a man's perspective to young boys growing up. The way the excellent Paul Seden has told this seemingly simple story stressing the role of men, as well as giving a procedural account of going crabbing, makes the reader look for more. Supported by luminous illustrations, I hope that Paul Seden has many more stories up his sleeve to share with us all. A Darwin based author illustrator, Seden's work first appeared with Kick with my left foot (Allen and Unwin, 2014).
Fran Knight

Spooks and scooters by Elen Caldecott

cover image

The Marsh Road Mysteries bk 3. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408852736
(Age: 9+) Recommended. Themes: Mystery; Adventure; Industrial espionage. The Marsh Road Mysteries revolve around a group of English friends who seem to keep finding mysteries that need their combined talents to help solve the problems that adults are incapable of unravelling. In this adventure, Flora and Sylvie, who are twins with very different personality traits, attempt to rescue their father from disaster when his business becomes the target of intellectual theft and industrial espionage. The consequences will be catastrophic for his business prospects and he is at risk of losing everything. The twin's parents are separated and the girl's father has a new girlfriend who has not yet won Sylvie's affection. She too becomes embroiled in the mystery. Is she the thief? The twins' other friends assist them to outwit the bumbling Personal Investigator that has been hired by the business, and together they use their talents to piece the puzzle together.
This is a crime mystery for young readers and will satisfy the needs of those young readers who like mystery and intrigue. The child characters use their talents and brain power, and young readers will enjoy the way they problem solve (and bend the rules) to enable them to pursue their investigations. Caldecott manages to write in such a way that a young reader will not feel patronised. Perfect for a school library collection, it can be recommended to young capable readers and older readers who like an intriguing tale.
Carolyn Hull

Get in trouble by Kelly Link

cover image

Text, 2015. ISBN 9781922182630
(Age: 16+) Recommended. Short stories. 'Be bold, be bold. But not too bold - lest that your heart's blood should run cold.'
This book is an Indies Choice Book of the Year Finalist for 2016.
You will need to be bold to encounter the nine short stories included here for the reader to enjoy. The writing is captivating and the stories are weird, engrossing, surprising and at times alarming or disturbing.
These stories encompass a range of characters that include: a young girl, a middle-aged movie star, a spoiled birthday girl, astronauts, evil twins, bootleggers, The Wizard of Oz and superheroes.
Some of the stories require the reader to really slow down and collect all the clues in the writing for there to be real understanding and appreciation of the intricacies in the telling. The stories unfold in a dreamlike stream of consciousness where the connections seem logical in that space and time but, at the end of the story, the reader marvels at the creativity and imagination that created the journey to an unexpected destination.
The Summer People is a compelling first story in this collection. It has teenage Fran caring for the 'summer people'. These people are holiday makers that visit for the summer. There are also 'summer people' to look after and they are always at home. This story is a cautionary tale of the dangers of making agreements with fairies.
While these are short stories, they are for sophisticated readers able to suspend belief and enjoy the ride.
Linda Guthrie

My family is a zoo by K A Gerard

cover image

Ill. by Emma Dodd. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408869406
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Humour. Zoos. Families. Birth. Verse. The family is going on a journey. Dad's elephant is packed into the car, after all he has had him since he was three, then the story teller's big brown bear, sister's whale, and big brother's dinosaur. Each person gets into the car with their animal, and the reader will read the story told in a four line stanza telling of the new arrival in the car. By now the readers will be intrigued about just how these people and their animals are fitting into the car, and the humorous illustrations by Emma Dodd, show the car getting very full. A seemingly few simple strokes of her pen give priceless expressions on each of the family members as well as the animals, as they stop again for uncle and his penguin, the cousin and her kangaroo, aunt and her monkey. Adding a dog and his pet as well as a pair of polar bears means the car is absolutely stuffed full. There is truly not enough room for a pin. But the surprise ending means room will have to be found for the extra passengers.
Young readers will love reading this out loud, looking at the bright breezy illustrations, working out just where everyone will fit in the station wagon, and be amazed at the surprise at the end. Discussion will follow about zoos and the animals that are there, why the family owns all these animals, if indeed they are real animals, and where to go to from here with their extra luggage.
A great way to talk about happy involved families, owning a pet and the responsibilities involved, and the introduction of a new sibling or two to an already full family.
Fran Knight

Pugly bakes a cake by Pamela Butchart

cover image

Ill. by Gemma Correll. Nosy Crow, 2016. ISBN 9780857635990
(Age: Yr 1 - Yr 4) I guess we all know that pugs are pretty cute (and pretty fashionable) right now. If I hadn't got a toy poodle myself I probably would have got a pug - although my eccentric teaching colleague who had a wardrobe of outfits for hers and attended all the 'pug parties' in Brisbane at one time did kind of put me off a little.
Moving right along, newly independent readers are going to love this book. It's a HOOT! Last night I read this aloud straight through to The Divine Miss M who is having a sleepover and she thought it was great! She was able to predict and infer as I read which was pretty impressive as well.
Pugly and his rival Clem (Clementine) the cat are rivals for the undivided attention of their owner Maddy who is eight years old. Being a pug (no offence to pug owners), Pugly is not the sharpest knife in the drawer and Clem can very easily put it over him. Especially as Pugly's only ally is Clive the fish - and Pugly doesn't speak or understand fish-bubble. Inspired Pugly decides he is going to the first dog to ever bake a cake and thus win paws down 'The Great British Bake Off', be on TV and meet the Queen (as you do when you're famous). This plan will seal his status as Maddy's favourite pet he is sure. However, with Clem 'advising' him chaos reigns in the kitchen and elsewhere, as Pugly heeds all Clem's ideas, goes mental at the Evil Squirrel outside on the fence and more.
This is a laugh a minute book and not only proved a terrific read aloud (took about half an hour or so) but perfect for those readers beginning their individual reading journeys. Lots of capitalised words and extra large fonts give them the opportunity to incorporate tone and expression into reading as well. Get onto this one - it will be a great favourite with Year 1 to around Year 4 for sure!
Sue Warren

Something wonderful by Raewyn Caisley

cover image

Ill. by Karen Blair. Viking, 2016. ISBN 9780670078455
Sam lives in the country - way out in the country where the air is fresh and clean and he and his dog have room to run and chase feathers, climb trees, spin around on the Hills Hoist and build things from all sorts of old stuff lying around. Pulling things apart and putting them back together is what he loves best - so much so that he sometimes forgets his chores like feeding the chooks, collecting the eggs and making sure the goat is in its paddock. This frustrates his dad who thinks he should be more focused, but his mum understands and knows that his distractedness means a brain is very busy at work. For all that he seems to be playing, Sam is learning, learning, learning.
One day while chasing a shadow across the paddocks it starts to rain and after momentarily stopping to think whether a raindrop is round, Sam makes a dash for shelter in the shed. And in the shed are all the bits and pieces that Sam needs to make something wonderful. Raewyn Caisley and Karen Blair have once again combined to create something wonderful, their first since the delightful Hello from Nowhere. The book is dedicated to the real-life Sam who now 'works at a famous university in Europe, where he is trying to work out what is in-between the smallest things' and demonstrates that his mum was right - all that pulling apart and putting together, the curiosity, the wondering of it all was just the lead up to what he is doing now.
So even though not all tinkerers will end up at 'a famous university' those makerspaces we offer in city libraries could just be the breeding ground for a new Sam as they play and plan and dream. Just as Sam learns about pulling and pushing and pulleys (in the most hilarious way ever) so too could one of our students albeit it in a more artificial situation.
Karen Blair's illustrations are superb - you can feel the wind in your face and breathe the fresh country air, sense dad's frustration and Sam's sense of wonder - they are as wonderful as that which Sam creates. The final textless page and endpapers are divine!
Threaded throughout the joy in this story (which shines through like a mother's love) is a powerful message about the importance of play and discovery. THIS is what childhood is about - not academic competition and grades and being ICT savvy. Academic things should just be the means to an end - the vehicle on which children can make their own discoveries as they explore and explain and not only make sense of their world but make it better.
A very serious contender for my favourite book for a while.
Barbara Braxton

One thousand hills by James Roy and Noel Zihabamwe

cover image

Omnibus Books, 2016. ISBN 9781742990750
(Age: 15- Adult) Themes: Genocide; Historical events - Rwanda; Innocence; Discrimination; Children in a time of conflict; Refugees; Family. Knowing the ultimate outcome of the Rwandan Genocide in 1994 creates an underlying tension throughout the reading of this book. This narrative is essentially a counselling session - but it is also a horrible and slowly unfolding catastrophe. The young man, Pascal, retells his experience to a school counsellor in explanation for an incident that he was involved in at school. Slowly and painfully he reveals the events of his life at the time of the genocide and his survival after the incredible unspeakable tragedy. Should it remain unspoken? Or does speaking it out loud release the tension or bring it to mind again? For the reader, it is important to know how tragic this experience was for the people involved, and the innocent voice of the young Pascal, as his 10 year old self, creates added anguish. The boy comes from a mixed tribe family (both Hutu and Tutsi) and small snippets of the civil unrest filter to him through scattered threads of conversation until the events of the massacre impact violently into his normally gentle and religious family. The author slowly takes us on the journey from the tender and normal family life of the Rwandan family, with its normal sibling rivalries and chores, to the final explosive scenes of betrayal and genocide. In a manner similar to The Boy in Striped Pyjamas by John Boyne, the innocent voice of the central character magnifies the horror of the atrocities inflicted.
This is an extremely moving, but atrocious story. And it is an account of the reality of experience for co-author Noel Zihabamwe. This is a compelling narrative, but I would be loath to put this into the hands of a reader too young to understand this part of history or one who is vulnerable to violence or is traumatised by news accounts of bloody conflict. The added horror of the involvement of some from the church in assisting in the tragedy will also be difficult for some readers. How humans can be so cruel to one another and lose sight of their common humanity is a huge unspoken question from the young Pascal. Even though this is written in a simple and 'youthful' style it is suited for mature readers aged 15+ and adult readers.
Carolyn Hull

The Trap by Melanie Raabe

cover image

Trans. by Imogen Taylor. Text, 2016. ISBN 9781925240870
(Age: Secondary+) Melanie Raabe is a young German writer of screenplays, scripts and blogs. This, her first novel, is a thriller for which the film rights have already been secured. The main character, Linda, is a successful author who has lived in seclusion since the murder of her sister Anna. Linda found her sister's body and details of the scene are unforgettable, the sight of her sister's bleeding body, the sound of the Beatle's song 'Love me do' repeating incessantly on the CD player and most significantly, the glimpse she has of the killer fleeing from the room. The police at the time were sceptical at best and disbelieving at worse about her evidence. Unable to face the world she writes and remembers and is alienated from even her parents, until she sees again the face of the murderer on television. He is a well-respected journalist and Linda recoils from approaching the police. She feels they would be unlikely to believe her, and an interrogation would alert him to suspicion. She decides to find proof herself.
She writes a book, a thriller, in which the victim and the murder parallel her sister's murder. She undergoes desensitisation training to help her face her fears. She consults an expert on interrogation techniques. She wires her house with cameras and recording systems. She invites the news outlet that employs her suspect, Lenzen, to send him to interview her. She chooses a day when her staff are not at work and has a caterer provide food. The interview begins; Lenzen is an attractive and clever man, who she senses is aware of her suspicions. She gains the upper hand, she thinks, after a number of mind games and tries to force a confession by pointing a gun at him. However, she thinks she can hear the Beatles song 'Love me do' repeating and becomes confused. Is she going mad? Lenzen protests his innocence and takes the gun. He persuades her that she was the killer herself, and that was what the police had always suspected. Linda remembers childhood antagonisms and interprets her parents' cool behaviour as being based on suspicion. She has always been a story teller; has she invented her sighting of the murderer to provide herself with a cover? Lenzen seems to be off the hook until Linda has a chance meeting which causes her to again reassess, and to take further risky action which leads to a resolution and a life-affirming renewal.
The novel is tightly and simply written with believable characters, though slightly drawn, and a suspenseful and unpredictable plot. Though a thriller the story concerns the psychological reactions to events rather than the violence of events and so has more depth than many crime novels. It is suitable for secondary readers.
Jenny Hamilton

Wicked's Way by Anna Fienberg

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN: 9781743319901
(Age: 9-12) Highly recommended. Themes: Pirates; Love; Choices; Magic; Adventure; Transformation; Good and Evil. A young boy, Will, raised in a loving island home with his mother, learns tightrope walking and believes that one day he will be a circus star. Unfortunately his mother disappears, and although briefly he discovers that life goes on with new opportunities and a new friend despite his loss, eventually disaster strikes and he is stolen by pirates. The gentle Will is broken by the harshness of the tyrannical pirate captain, and renamed Wicked. The life on board a pirate ship is not pleasant, and the relationships that are formed are difficult. Wicked slowly becomes a shadow of his former self, and his desire to rediscover his mother and his friend slowly become a distant hope. A mutiny and some poor choices eventually lead Wicked to a solitary island existence with a talking parrot who shares pithy sayings and adages, and then there is an unfortunate re-encounter with someone who could not be trusted. This ultimately leads Wicked to rediscover himself and to be reshaped back into the trusting and open-hearted person from his past.
This is a story of restoration (and redemption) and the transformation from gentle Will to Wicked and back again is an interesting journey told within the medium of a Pirate adventure with a small dose of magical influence. With the reappearance of Horrendo from Fienberg's Horrendo's Curse there is also a rediscovery of the power of the friendly and amiable Horrendo.
Highly Recommended. This tale would make a great read-aloud story within a school context for ages 9-12. There is much to discuss about Will's emotional journey and Horrendo's influence. The metaphor of the tightrope journey - just place one foot in front of the other, and stay focused on the prize; plus the wisdom of a parrot could lead to many discussions.
Carolyn Hull

Rockhopping by Trace Balla

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760112349
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Themes: Bushwalking; Natural environment; Exploration. This is the companion text to the book Rivertime and in this book Clancy and Uncle Egg explore the Grampians and look for the source of the River. They pack for a walking trek through the Grampians region, trekking up craggy rocks and through the delight of the natural environment. The long arduous walk carrying heavy packs and a dangerous cliff top near-accident does not dampen their enthusiasm for the way the natural environment reveals itself to those who have time to look. Balla's Cartoon style, graphic novel includes a wealth of small captioned details that give the reader an insight into the variety of life within the environment and some of the historical perspectives of the region, including its Aboriginal history and view of the world. Clancy demonstrates incredible resilience as he overcomes difficulty, but he also discerns the joy of discovery as the world unfolds before him.
Balla's beautiful and simple illustrations are enchanting. The narrative is also delightful, telling of the journey, but also revealing the wonderful relationship between Clancy and his uncle and the simple pleasures of being outdoors.
Carolyn Hull

Six of Crows by Leigh Bardugo

cover image

Six of Crows bk 1. Henry Holt, 2015. ISBN 9781627792127
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Fantasy. Heists. Goodreads Choice Award Nominee for Young Adult Fantasy and Science Fiction (2015), YALSA's Best Books for Young Adults (2016). Kaz Brekker has been offered the chance to pull off the heist of a life time and he gathers around him five dangerous specialists, most from the Dregs, thieves of Kerch's underworld. There is Inej the Wraith, who can silently scale walls, Nina the girl who has betrayed her friend Matthias and is desperate to get him out of gaol, Jesper the gambler who cannot resist wagers and the rich runaway Wylan who hates his father. Led by Kaz, a superb thief and strategist, they are aiming to invade the Ice Palace in a seemingly impossible quest.
For those who enjoyed the Grisha series, Six of crows is the first book in another series set this time in Ketterdam, which is in a fantasy land similar to the Netherlands. Bardugo's world building is immaculate - her vivid descriptions make it easy to smell and see the slums, the canals the docks and the cold lands that the six traverse.
Then there is her outstanding character building. Each of the six main characters, who tell their own stories in separate chapters, have distinct voices and often heart-rending tales about their backgrounds that gradually emerge as the story unfolds. They are all compelling people with separate skills and together they must begin to trust each other and form an effective team to get the job done. There are subtle hints of romance, but this is not what stands out, rather the complexity of the personalities and their pasts is what holds the reader's interest.
Fans of Leigh Bardugo will really enjoy this, but readers new to this author and indeed, the fantasy genre, will find a fascinating world, irresistible action and feisty characters to entertain them.
Pat Pledger