Reviews

Winter siege by Ariana Franklin and Samantha Norman

cover image

Bantam Books, 2015. ISBN 9780857501479
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. Medieval England, Crime, Redemption, Civil war. When Ariana Franklyn died in 2011, she left behind a small body of work set in medieval times involving a woman trained as a physician solving crimes through forensic investigation always a step in front of those who wanted to kill her as a witch. These four novels, Mistress of the art of death, The death maze, Relics of the dead and The assassin's prayer were mesmerising in their Medieval setting, showing attitudes to women and medicine at the time. But she had a last novel in progress, and her daughter, Samantha Norman has completed it and it is now published.
This story takes a slightly different route from the previous four, detailing the lives of Gwil, a mercenary who rescues a young girl raped and left for dead by a monk known for his cruelty. It is the time of civil war between the forces of King Stephen and his sister Matilda, involving much of southern England.
Gwil and Pen take refuge in a castle where Maud is the one in charge, but her enforced marriage sees her relinquish control to an older man, now her husband, and his whore, Kingva. When he has a stroke, the only person Kingva turns to is a monk who arrives in the castle with King Stephen's men, on the lookout for a piece of parchment taken by Pen, the girl he raped. When Maud refuses to submit to King Stephen's men after sheltering and then helping his rival, Matilda, escape, a siege lays the castle open to treachery.
This is a powerful historical crime story set in turbulent times where lives are often lost for little or no reason. The callousness of wondering mercenaries is appalling, and Gwil seeks to redeem himself by caring for Pen. The narrator of the story evokes a change of heart from his scribe, who is at first condemning of the participants in the story but by the end learns compassion and empathy.
The episodes detailing the siege are just wonderful, laying before the reader the extremes of life lived during such a time.
A wonderful thriller, following the development of Pen and her protector Gwil, the shadow of the monk is always there, even though Pen fortunately has no recollection of the incident. A menacing read right to the last.
Fran Knight

Freedom Ride by Sue Lawson

cover image

Walker Books, 2015. ISBN 9781925126365
Recommended age: 8-12 years. Sue Lawson examines the racial tensions of 1965 in Freedom Ride. Written for an 8-12 year old audience, it is set in the fictional town of Walgaree. For young Robbie, life is bleak living as he does with his nagging grandmother and silent father . . . doing all the jobs around the house for his grandmother and when that's done, for all her friends too. His father ignores him most of the time, although he's surprisingly supportive of Robbie's holiday job at the Walgaree Caravan Park. Much is written about Robbie's work experience at the park, and of his budding friendship with the owners - all of which might hold the key to Robbie's freedom.
Soon however, trouble comes to Walgaree: broken windows at the Station school and a fight at the waterhole results in the Aboriginal children getting the blame. However, a handful of white townie kids know the truth is a different story. Then, to cap it all off, Barry, Robbie's employer, takes on another helper - Micky, the young Aborigine accused of attacking one of the local white lads. When a death near the Station is 'covered up' and the freedom riders come to town things reach boiling point. How will things sort out for Robbie who already has issues with his father and grandmother, and yet he puts his neck on the line to defend his Aboriginal friend Micky?
Freedom Ride is a work of fiction based on true events and introduces young readers to the racial tensions of the 'mid-60's. In Australia the Freedom Ride movement (Student Action for Aborigines: SAFA) loosely based on the American Freedom Ride movement of the early '60's, was initiated by a group of Sydney University students. Attracting much national and international media attention, SAFA achieved much in its short life, and this novel brings the history of that era to modern young Australians.
Colleen Tuovinen

Our Class Tiger by Aleesah Darlinson

cover image

Oxford University Press, 2014. ISBN 9780195589726
Class 3M has adopted a tiger cub living in a sanctuary on the Indonesian island of Sumatra. Berhaga was rescued after his mother had been shot when he was just five months old and the children do all sorts of fund-raising to get the money needed to send to the World Wildlife Fund each month so he can continue to be supported until he is old enough to be transferred to a national park.
Accompanied by stunning photographs the students of 3M explain the adoption as well as retelling the story of Berhaga's development. Fascinating facts about tigers are interspersed with the "speech bubble" text providing a unique insight into one of the world's most endangered creatures and helping the young reader understand why such magnificent animals need to be protected for the future. Apart from its important context which fits in perfectly with a sustainability theme, it is a model of a non fiction book for young students with all the essential elements that we teach students about at that age. Features such as contents, headings, captions, a glossary and an index are all there to help students understand the cues and clues of navigating an information text. It could also be used as inspiration for a class to write their own book providing a platform for their continued development in the information literacy process giving them both a context to put it into practice and a product to display their learning.
Ms Darlison was awarded the 2015 Environment Award for Children's Literature and the inaugural Puggle Award (Children's Choice Award) from the Wilderness Society for Our Class Tiger and it is richly deserved.
Barbara Braxton

The Healthy Harvest by Emma Martin

cover image

Ill. by Graeme Compton. Little Steps Publishing, 2014. ISBN 9781925117134
Picture book. Meet Harry Harvester who wants to help our very youngest readers learn about the food they buy in the shops so they can learn about the five food groups and make healthy choices and "keep sickness away." His friend Alfie Apple introduces fruit - where it grows, how much we need each day and why it's good for us - while Carly Carrot does the same for vegetables. Charlie Cheese tells us about dairy products and Harry's best friend Wally Wheat introduces grains and cereals. Sammy Salmon has the big job of teaching about proteins in all their guises and finally there is Tommy Takeaway with a message about the "sometimes foods".
With childhood obesity on the rise and a recent survey in the ACT showing that over 80% of all food advertising aimed at children is for those "sometimes foods" http://bit.ly/1D6HxaT the message about healthy eating has never been more important. While it is not the children of the target age range who buy the food, they do have "pester power" so encapsulating such an important message in rhyme and with fun characters who could become household names this is an important book to have and promote both to teachers and students. It could form the core component of a unit of work on healthy eating as well as an investigation about where our food comes from. Eggs don't magically grow in cartons in the supermarket chilled foods section. The final two pages show the recommended amounts of each food group each age group should have each day and many might find it interesting to keep a food diary and track just what goes into their mouths. They may be surprised!
The author, Emma Martin, is well qualified to write this book and accompanied by charming illustrations which will appeal to the children, it is a refreshing and welcome addition to a topic that has been covered so often already.
Barbara Braxton

How the sun got to Coco's house by Bob Graham

cover image

Walker Books, 2015. ISBN 9781406359008
(Age: all) Highly recommended. Interconnectedness, Sun's journey, World view
Graham takes the most simple of everyday occurrences to create a subtle and rich picture book extolling the interconnectedness of mankind. The sun's appearance in the horizon opens a new day for everyone as it climbs its way across the Arctic Circle, uncovers the barrenness of northern Canada, lights up Japan, then China, the Middle East and the cities of Europe until it barges through the window of Coco's bedroom.
Along the way the sun illuminates small pockets of the natural world: a polar bear and her two cubs, a trawling ship on heavy seas, a whale, a panda, a snow leopard, a fox and hen, a donkey taking his owner and his wares to market, camels trekking across the desert, an eagle high above. Each represents the vastness of the natural world, while interspersed with these, we see a child and his mother walking in the snow, a family in a yurt, a child in a plane, a Japanese street, a woman asleep in her tiny room, a boy putting his toe through the ice as the shawled women look on, and then we get to Coco. The sun marks each activity, shows the way for them to travel or seek out their world, communicate with each other, interact with their surroundings, bask in its rays.
The sun is the common thread for everyone and everything on this earth and its warmth enables us to live.
As Coco wakes to the sun, Graham brings his story from the world wide to the particular, as anyone familiar with his work will know. His sublime whittling down of major themes always makes me gasp as he distills the monumental to the specific. From the wide world we are taken to Coco and her family, waking with the sun, eating breakfast together, as Coco runs outside to greet he new day with her friends and neighbours.
Graham includes lots to look at in his watercolour illustrations, detail not missed by younger readers. I love the toy panda and polar bear on the floor of Coco's bedroom, duplicating the animals earlier in the book, or the theme of snow all the way through, of cold and ice. Many pages have birds still flying south for the winter, while some people are still snuggled up in bed. The detail of the old woman in her small room will encourage readers to ask questions about her and her lifestyle. Every page is littered with questions begging to be discussed and readers will overflow with observations and thoughts.
Again, this work is endorsed by Amnesty International 'because it reminds us that this world belongs to all of us, and we all have the right to enjoy life, freedom and safety'.
Fran Knight

Being a girl by Hayley Long

cover image

Ill. by Gemma Correll. Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBN: 9781471403903
(Reading Ages: 12 -13+) Highly recommended. Parental discretion, may be needed as some of the content requires the reader to be emotionally mature. Subjects: Health, Puberty, Adolescents, Girls, Life Skills, Personal Grooming, Dating, Social Relations, Psychology. Author Hayley Long has read the entire internet and gathered everything you need to know about being a girl. She celebrates life, she encourages the sisterhood with a really open and insightful dialogue. Nothing is off limits, she tackles a plethora of topics with humour, insight and honesty. Gender identity, including being transgender is presented with comments, questions and opportunities to fill in fun quizzes - are you any good at being a girl? Herstory includes discussion on gender inequality, being transgender, the Suffragette Movement, sexism and introduces six women who have stamped their mark on the world.
Each chapter explores another social, emotional or physical issue. Raging hormones and the cattiness of a high school classroom, turns into a table of cats - cattiness combined with Gemma Correll's witty cat sketches. There's Top Cat, Scally Cats right down to Strays and the girl who tries to be invisible - Cat Food. Bloody Periods are the most realistic chapter covering everything a girl needs to know. Crushes, friendships and dating, health and hygiene are explored and the reader is treated as a friend without being talked down to or given too much irrelevant information. This is an important contemporary book written with sincerity and sensitivity. Hayley Long's text with her honest and open comments, combined with the use of bold texts, different fonts, diagrams, tables, cartoons make this a socially relevant book, just right for girls on the brink of adolescence.
Rhyllis Bignell

The wishing seed by Anna Branford

cover image

Lily the Elf series. Walker Books, 2015. ISBN 9781925081060
(Age: 5+) Themes: Overcoming disappointment; Solving problems. Lily the Elf has a broken dress-up crown, and she wishes upon a passing dandelion seed for a new one. She is despondent when her wish does not appear to be answered, but the skills of her fix-it father, and creative Granny help her to realise that wishes can be answered in ways that she doesn't expect.
This is a very simple early chapter book (predominantly simple sentences and no language complexities) that will appeal to very young independent readers or struggling readers. There are simple black and white illustrations by Lisa Coutts scattered through the book.
Carolyn Hull

Goodbye Stranger by Rebecca Stead

cover image

Text Publishing, 2015. ISBN 9781925240320
(Age: 11+) Highly recommended. Bridge, Tabitha and Emily swore that they wouldn't fight but now that they are in Grade 7, things are beginning to change. Emily has connected with the soccer team, Bridge has taken to wearing cat's ears all the time and Tab is obsessed with a feminist teacher. Then Emily begins to text pictures of herself to Patrick and the girls find themselves with problems. At the same time, another teen is skipping school and going through pangs of remorse because she has betrayed her best friend.
This is a stunning read about making mistakes, the joys and tribulations of friendships and growing up by a wonderful author who writes in a very sympathetic and compassionate way. The reader knows that Emily will get into trouble when she starts sending photos of herself to Patrick and receiving ones from him. Even though Bridge and Tab try to persuade her of the folly of doing it, Bridge still helps her take a photo. The way the girls handle this misstep and the consequences of the mistake make for spell-binding reading. At the same time an unnamed girl is relating the mistake she has made about telling a secret to a friend who can't be trusted, and the reader is kept guessing just who this might be.
The relationships between Emily and Patrick and Bridge and Sherm are handled with a deft touch. Sherm is angry with his grandfather, who has left his grandmother after 50 years of marriage, and the reader finds out about this in a series of letters that he writes but doesn't post. It is unusual to read about divorce between an older couple and Stead shows how a marriage break-up can affect people of all ages. Tab too comes to realise that she must act responsibly within her feminist beliefs. Stead also subtly shows the physical differences that can occur as girls grow up. Emily's body has matured and she is becoming much more interested in boys, while Bridge is still looking young.
Utimately this is an unforgettable book about young girls coming of age written with wit and compassion. It would make an interesting Literature Circle book engendering discussion about the appropriateness of sending photos, what makes a good friend and how to overcome the consequences of a bad decision.
Pat Pledger

Platypus by Sue Whiting

cover image

Ill. by Mark Jackson. Nature Storybooks series. Walker Books, 2015. ISBN 9781922077448
(Age: 6+) Recommended. Platypus, Australian animals, Fiction and non fiction. Alongside each page of the fictional tale of a male platypus going about his daily tasks, is an information paragraph with facts about this unusual animal. Each of the texts is given a different font and so a canny reader will quickly understand that there are two stories here, one a story, the other facts. To underline this the index at the back has a line underneath telling the reader to look for both as they read, while the brief index gives younger children easy access to the material in the book and teaches how to use an index to gain information.
The platypus peeps out of his burrow on the first double page, its duck bill contrasting with the dark undergrowth. Information is given about the platypus and its unusual shape and characteristics, while the factual paragraphs tell us how at first, scientists could not believe the animal first discovered in 1799 was real.
The animal forages finding food, while the factual text tells us how each of its characteristics help it swim, dive, forage and survive. Children will love reading of the platypus' night time forage and appreciate the inclusion of factual information making the story much richer.
The beautiful illustrations serve to place the platypus in his environment and the browns and greens swirl together to give a marvellous impression of where he lives.
An information page at the end reiterates the facts given, underlining its oddness in the animal world.
The language is wonderful, using the correct terminology and not talking down to the audience, making the reader ask questions.
This is the second book I have seen in this series called Nature Storybooks and I can see it well used in the classroom, both by children wanting a storybook about one of Australia's strangest animals, and also for gathering facts.
Fran Knight

Izzy Folau: Chance of a Lifetime by David Harding and Izzy Folau

cover image

Random House Australia, 2015 . ISBN 9780857986610
Izzy Folau: Reality Check. ISBN 9780857986634
(Age: Independent readers) This series featuring champion Israel Folau will be just what younger rugby fans will adore to tide them over the football season.
Its two stars, Daniel and Sione have both been picked for the Valley rep team to play at the State Championships. But they couldn't be more different with Daniel from an affluent family, attending sports-mad Barker College and having all the confidence in the world while Sione is from the other side of the tracks where his school holds a mufti day to raise the funds for him to attend the selection camp and he's so lacking in self-confidence that he doesn't go to school that day. But both have been picked and are off to camp to be coached by Izzy Folau.
As the series follows them through their training to the final match, as well as great tips about playing football there is also a strong undercurrent of sportsmanship, friendship and what it means to be a team member as well as believing in yourself, even when you're angry and frustrated and you don't reach the heights you were sure you could. Folau tells the boys, "I've changed sports a few times and every time I did there were people who weren't happy. Without meaning to I upset fans, the media, and, worst of all, my teammates. Each time I had to walk into a change room filled with people I didn't know to play a game I wasn't too sure about. I found it hard to be happy and relaxed sometimes, but I did my best to make it work. I trained, I was nice to people, I was a good teammate. You know why? . . .  If I didn't, I might as well have gone home. It's the same for you guys. If you can't chill out, have fun and be proud of your achievements, then you might as well think about going home."
With episodes three and four in the series being released on the eve of the World Cup, this is a series for the young fan who is an independent reader who wishes they had the opportunities that Daniel and Sione and their teammates have. But even if they don't realise the dream of having Izzy Folau as their coach, there is much to learn and enjoy from this series.
Barbara Braxton

Vietnam by Deborah Challinor

cover image

My Australian story series. Scholastic, 2015. ISBN 9781743628003
Highly recommended. This brilliantly crafted story is a realistic depiction of life in Australia in the late 1960s using authentic characters and historical events. Davey Walker is twelve years old and carefree, enjoying surfing every day on Newcastle beaches with his mates Pete and Johnno when his older brother Tom is selected for National Service. Davey records his and Tom's experiences over the next year in a series of diary entries.
It was delightful to read a captivating story which is historically accurate and which avoids judgement and slavish presentation of views more palatable to a modern perspective. There is however nothing inappropriate or unsuitable to an early teen readership in this book. The harsh truths of the war - death, physical and psychological injury, fear, even the My Lai massacre are all covered in a manner which presents the facts without glamour or unnecessary detail. Challinor deserves credit for crafting a robust, worthy story which includes a bewildering amount of historical information and accurate micro details which is suitable for the readership in terms of content and level of understanding.
I particularly liked that a range of authentic figures interplay to put forward points of view on the validity of conscription, the involvement of Australia in the war, the protest movement and international relations in exactly the way that people did at the time. I was thrilled to read the explanation of the origins of the conflict and Australia's role through the words of Davey, his school mates and a new teacher as they discussed the topic in a social studies class. A complex matter was summarised clearly for modern readers and the author is to be commended for not endorsing one point of view (with child characters parroting their parents' ideology) over another.
The story is so good because whilst the war is central to the narrative and important events like the Moon landing are included, it principally emphasises family relationships and friendship. Mateship is associated too frequently with the battlefield in Australian folklore and this novel emphasises the value of caring friendships in all walks of life in a profoundly moving way.
Rob Welsh

Bob the railway dog by Corinne Fenton

cover image

Ill. by Andrew McLean. Black Dog Books, 2015. ISBN 9781922179890
(Age: 4-adult) Highly recommended. Dogs, Loyalty, Independence, Steam trains, Railways, Historical story, Nineteenth century. Transport. Living in Peterborough for twenty years, it was impossible not to hear the story of Bob the railway dog, and to see it now memorialised in several books, a statue in the main street of the town, with an information board in Terowie where it was known as Terowie Bob, is wonderful.
Several years ago a book was published about the animal, (The Railway Dog by Olwyn Parker) and now a picture book adds another level of interest. And of course there is a Facebook page for people to add photos of themselves with the statue in Peterborough.
This picture book takes the reader into the reasons for the railways to exist in the outback regions of South Australia, and throughout the story the impact of the railways on small communities is neatly observed, while readers will have an overview of the size of Australia and the distances travelled by the dog.
At Carrieton Station in 1884, a train carrying a load of dogs destined for the cattlemen in the north of the state, arrived and one dog piqued the interest of the guard, Ferry.
He took the dog, naming him Bob, and soon they travelled together on the trains in the Mid North. But when the intercolonial between Adelaide and Melbourne was opened, he climbed aboard. Several stories of Bob travelling even further were known, but he was certainly well known on the trains around South Australia.
This delightful story of Bob will melt the hearts of the readers and McLean's wonderful illustrations add to the development of the tale. His watercolour, charcoal and black pen illustrations bring the last part of the nineteenth century to life, as we see the sparse landscapes of the mid north of South Australia, the growing wealth of the cities, the detail of the stations now closed, the finely observed porters' rooms, and the steam trains chugging through the saltbush. Text and illustration create a beautiful picture book evocative of times past, but extolling the virtues of independence and loyalty.
Fran Knight

Glenn Maxwell series by Patrick Loughlin

cover image

Random House, 2015.
Glenn Maxwell: State Showdown. ISBN 9780857986115
Glenn Maxwell: World Domination. ISBN 9780857986139
(Age: Yr 3-4) The interest in cricket at my school is very high with the Ashes series. With the women also competing in their Ashes series, that interest is widespread. So it has been with delight that when several have asked me if I had the latest in this series that features the world's leading T20 player, I've been able to hand them over or put their names on the reserve list.
The series continues Will Albright's journey from local team to state representation which is his dream. But a crisis in confidence threatens his success and so Maxwell steps into help. And finally, in World Domination his team is off to England to take on the best of the best in the T20 Youth World Cup. Each book includes Maxwell's Top Tips for T20 batting and a full glossary of cricket terms and colleague Sue Warren has a Q&A with Glenn Maxwell himself at https://losangzopa.wordpress.com/2014/12/08/qa-glenn-maxwell/ Even though the books themselves are written for an independent reader about Year 3-4 level, a number of the names on my reserves list are both older and younger, showing that the subject is the key ingredient and that having enjoyed the first two it is the storyline that brings them back, not any degree of difficulty with the text.
If you haven't got the first two - Lucky Break and Academy All-Stars - then it is worth seeking them out so when students' thoughts turn to playing cricket as summer comes (they say it is coming) you will have a complete series to offer them.
Barbara Braxton

Alex as well by Alyssa Brugman

cover image

Curious Fox, 2014. ISBN 9781782020899
(Ages: 13+) Recommended. Growing up. Sexuality. Now a teenager, Alex feels more female than male, and refuses to take the medication which suppresses his femininity. Born without specific gender alignment, Alex has been brought up as a boy by sometimes caring but often confused parents, but is determined to make his own decisions. He leaves school where he has been bullied, and enrolls in another school as a girl, wearing a dress and drawing her hair extensions back into a pony tail. She is amazed at how differently she is treated as a girl, and the underlying values attributed to one sex over the other. It is fascinating to see Brugman playing around with sex roles through this novel, exposing for us the different traits credited to each gender through the body of the sometimes capricious Alex.
But things do not go as she expects. Her new life is at odds with the old, she is lonely and unsure of herself. She makes friends but is attracted to one of the girls, while one of the boys is attracted to her. Going to a solicitor to gain a new birth certificate telling the world she is female, she makes her only friend, one who believes her, explores the issues for her and protects her when her parents become cloying.
It is the scenes with his parents that disturb. They come across as totally confused, their relationship in tatters because of Alex and their treatment of him, and they feel that life has treated them unfairly. At times I wanted to yell at them, they never see Alex in terms other than their failed male child, they never sit down with her to talk things through, nor allow Alex to explain how she feels, there is never a counsellor visited or doctor consulted, but the internet and the rubbish advised by 'friends' seems to take precedence, particularly where her mother is concerned.
I was enthralled with Alex's story, wanting her to make it in the end, find her feet and make a stand. This she does, but in accepting that her parents will never be wholly supportive she realises in the end that we are all flawed, especially when it comes to gender and what is expected of us.
Fran Knight

My amazing Dad by Ezekiel Kwaymullina

cover image

Ill. by Tom Jellett. Little Hare, 2015. ISBN 9781921894862
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Families, Fathers, Difference. What a delightful story. Having just read Fly-in fly-out Dad (Sally Murphy) this story compliments the other like a hand in a glove, both reflecting the diversity of arrangements that make up Australia's families.
In My amazing Dad, the children reflect upon the things that their father does with them. He is different as Jellett shows in the opening picture of the two children on Dad's back, all still in their pyjamas. The stage is set for a Dad who stays home with his children. Overleaf, he does not like mowing lawns, but loves to make a mess. He never gets the two children to school on time, but gets there in the end. He cannot bake a cake but they all eat happily what he buys at the bakery. Each pair of two double pages presents Dad and something he doesn't like doing, but overleaf shows what he does instead. He may not be the 'typical' Dad but has many other wonderful qualities ensuring the lives of his children are happy, safe and full of humour.
The subtle inclusion of Mum returning from work at the end underscores the stay at home Dad theme, and adds to the love filled story.
Jellett's illustrations fill the pages, bringing a sense of fun and excitement to the children's days as Dad does things in an unexpected way. Jellett's expressions are priceless and his ability to make a flat painted face reflect so much expression will amaze the readers as they can read what each character is feeling with ease.
I just love the humour, from the toys the children have, appearing on most pages, to the frog cakes in the bakery window, the tool kit in the bathroom and the bathroom full of bubbles. Readers will readily recognise each stage of daily events and laugh out loud at Dad's antics.
Fran Knight