Reviews

About a girl by Joanne Horniman

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2010. ISBN 9781742371443
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Relationships, Same sex relationships, Love, Depression. You know that feeling you have when you come across a book so well written that you want to read it again - straightaway? Well this is one of those, so I was very surprised to turn to the publication page and see that it was first published in 2010. How did I miss it?
Anna's father has left the family without warning, moving in with his much younger lover, a girl to whom Anna is physically attracted. This combined with the instability at home as her abandoned mother tries to rebuild her life with her two daughters, reduces Anna's belief in herself.
And then something happens which further undermines her confidence, causing her to suffer a serious bout of depression. She drops out of uni and finds a job in a bookshop in Lismore. Here she begins to get her life back on some sort of even keel, and despite not looking for love, finds it in Flynn. The story of their relationship is achingly real, tender and all encompassing, as Anna slowly reveals her past to her lover. But Flynn also keeps herself close, so much so that Anna can never be sure that she will still be there, and when she invites her to move in with her in her small apartment, Flynn is forced to reveal her secret.
The girls share their lives, the stray cat that insists on sleeping on Anna's bed when Flynn is there, the teapot called Lavinia, the sharing of bathers when they go to the beach, the meeting of Anna's mother and disabled sister when they visit. And when they split, Anna is more certain, more sure that life holds meaning and a future.
This is a wonderful story of two girls, their shared love and what happens when love is gone and set against a background familiar to many readers.
Fran Knight
Editor's note: This is still in print.
Shortlisted, 2011 Prime Minister's Literary Awards, Young adult fiction
Shortlisted, 2011 Children's Book Council of Australia Book of the Year - Older Readers

Summer harvest by Georgina Penney

cover image

Penguin Books Australia, 2016. ISBN 9780143797081
(Age: Adult) Romance. Illness. Beth Poole is a dog trainer, whose life has been turned upside down after a life threatening illness and the desertion of her husband. Her grandmother, obsessed with Australian soaps, sends her off on a holiday to Australia, but it is not to the east coast of her TV shows, rather it is to Western Australia. Beth decides to make the most of it and books an extended holiday at Margaret River, hoping to rest but the Hardy clan make it difficult for her to retreat and Clayton Hardy is the most interesting of all. Can she overcome the doubts that her past experiences have given her and learn to trust and love again?
This was a romantic story that flowed beautifully and was easy to read. Beth's dilemma arising from her past illness grabbed at the heartstrings as she gradually regained her self-confidence, started to wear attractive clothes and broke her self-imposed isolation by making new friends. Clayton Hardy is also an engaging character, who has hidden depths and fears that he too has to overcome before he finds his true love. Penney sensitively delves into the ways that people cope with serious illness and how buried grief can affect relationships.
The setting of Margaret River, the beach, the wineries with their delicious sounding wines, the food and moments set in the vineyards under the moon, brought back memories of a lovely holiday spent there. Penney's description of the area will certainly give readers who have never visited the area a desire to do so.
This is an engaging romance that is sure to entertain with its romance and family bickering, and its underlying serious theme will also engage the emotions. It reads well as a stand-alone, and people who enjoyed it will be pleased to know that Penney's previous book, Fly in Fly out, also features the Hardy family.
Pat Pledger

Goblin mafia wars by DC Green

cover image

Ford St Publishing, 2016. ISBN 9781925272208
(Age: 12+) You would think that as a royal hume dude your life would be one of complete luxury not to mention stressfree. Think again! PT (Prince Thomas of Monstro City) and his Dead Gang friends are embroiled even deeper in nasty situations and deadly - or is that undeadly? - circumstances; their quest to find the eggs of the last dragon, Kalthazar, as well as trying to avert complete goblin civil war and annihilation of all other species, thwarting the evil plans of the horrendous Dr Franken, removing the usurper Prince Robbie and just a few other issues.
Following the toxic altercation at Fire Mountain with the goblins' attack and Kalthazar's limping escape to the Isle of Giants, the Gang minus friend Zorg begin a trek which first of all sees them navigating through the Dead Zone. Yowsers! This is one extremely bogus territory where even monsters like the Dead Gang are in very real danger of being exterminated not least of all by their erstwhile compadre Scarab, the super-strong mummy gal. She's kind of ticked off about Zorg and decides that PT in particular is totes responsible.
Surviving this and then a very unnerving train ride back to Monstro City, the Dead Gang faces yet more monstrous mayhem. While PT manages to conduct some very delicate negotiations and some highly skilful bluffing with the rival goblin factions (think Sopranos style goblins!), his plans are sabotaged by the appearance of a chocolate popcorn gobbling older/younger idiot savant (without the savant) brother Prince Robbie. Rumour has it he has been cryogenically preserved by famous Dr Franken for the past ten years and not in fact stolen by the Vampire Queen. Looks like vampiric Stoker is not PT's brother after all... or is he?
And just what is Dr Franken's dastardly involvement with the goblin factions and the mentally deranged Prince Robbie? How did he get that dragon egg? And what the web is with all those freaky arms? Trapped in small cages in the evil doctor's 'hospital' things look grim for this grimmest - and often grimiest - of gangs, with no apparent hope of escape. Spoiler alert - yet they do along with an about-to-hatch dragon egg!
DC Green has provided readers with another rip-snorter yarn about these highly idiosyncratic monster teens who have their own methods of solving problems. Their combined abilities and wacky take on situations along with their staunch support of each other prove more than a match for their adversaries. High humour rating and all the excitement of fast-paced action will prove yet again to be a winner with readers from around 12 and up. If you missed the first volume you MUST go and get it! Can't wait for the next instalment - write faster DC! *
Oh and PS completely buzzed about that quote on the back cover!!
Sue Warren

The grumpy lighthouse keeper by Territzita Corpus

cover image

Ill. by Maggie Prewett. Magabala Books, 2016. ISBN 9781925360189
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Humour. Lighthouse. Beach. Broome. Sea creatures. When the lighthouse keeper goes out to check that his light is still shining brightly on a cold blustery night, several animals crawl from the beach and into his warm snugly bed. As each comes from the beach, the same format on each page is used, encouraging children to predict the words that will follow as another animal appears. Cassius the crab, Trev the turtle, Jacob the jellyfish, Olena the octopus and Bruce the bluebone take their place inside the lighthouse keeper's cottage.
The bright, vivid illustrations show the readers each of the animals and will encourage the readers to try their own skills at representing these sea creatures.
When the lighthouse keeper returns of course, readers again will predict his possible response, laughing merrily at his insistence that the animals leave his bed, then finding it too damp to now sleep in himself. A solution is found however, although readers will know that he has missed out on his comfortable bed on such a cold night.
Readers will laugh out aloud at the antics of the animals, knowing that a bed is probably the last place they would want to be but seeing the humour in these creatures taking shelter. All the while students are reminded of the sorts of sea creatures to be found in Broome and the history of a local historical spot. I loved it.
Fran Knight

Out for the count by Anne Fine

cover image

Ill. by Vicki Gausden. Barrington Stoke, 2016. ISBN 9781781125076
(Age: Emerging readers) Like many children, Hugo would really like a pet - in his case, a gerbil. He raises the issue again with his dad just as he is finishing the repainting of Hugo's room. Even though his father acknowledges that Hugo would probably look after it very well, he is not a fan of keeping things in cages and so the answer continues to be 'no'. However, there may be a compromise. Hugo works out that the gerbil would only be in the cage for seven hours during the time he is at school, so his father suggests that Hugo experiences that by staying alone in his now empty room for the same time.
Hugo accepts the challenge and at midday with just the newspaper already spread on the floor, a snack, three chosen toys (a ghost puppet, a bucket of bricks and a monkey on a stick) and his watch, he enters the room to stay alone for seven hours. And even though he also has what gerbils don't - an imagination - the time creeps by so slowly it seems like it stands still. Will Hugo last the seven hours?
This is an entertaining short story for emerging readers written some time ago but repackaged for the Little gems series which is deliberately designed to support students with dyslexia. The font is 'dyslexia-friendly' helping those who confuse letter shapes to see them more clearly and spaced to minimise confusion; the pages are tinted and the paper thicker so illustrations are not 'shadowed' on previous pages; the stories short but engaging; and the book is just right for small hands to hold and read alone. Plots are linear and the language and its structure less complex than in other stories for a similar age group. 'This process was developed by dyslexia and speech and language experts in response to research and feedback from thousands of readers on hundreds of Barrington Stoke manuscripts over the years.'
Dyslexic or not, Out for the count is entertaining, witty and wise and will spark lots of conversations about people's need to confine animals to cages and the 'rightness' of this.
Barbara Braxton

Dreaming the enemy by David Metzenthen

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760112257
In what appears to be based on the Battle of Coral which took place during the Vietnam War, Johnny Shoebridge, a conscripted Australian infantryman endures unspeakable terror defending a 'Firebase' of artillery and mortars. The Firebases enabled significant targets such as supply routes to be shelled and also offered support to infantry if powerful enemy forces were contacted.
When hordes of North Vietnamese soldiers and Vietcong guerrillas attack a newly positioned and inadequately prepared Firebase on the first night after it was set up, Johnny and his mates Barry and Lex must fight desperately in their infantry units which were placed to defend the guns.
I liked this story for many reasons, not least because the reader is transported to a place where the gut wrenching fear is almost palpable and the crescendo of explosions and screams is overwhelming. Most important however, is the fact that this is achieved without any glorification of war.
The story is told in a series of flashbacks in civilian life when Johnny is trying to adjust to being an ordinary person after returning from military service. The flashbacks not only recount the experiences of Johnny and his mates but he also displays an acute awareness of the service and suffering of the enemy in his dreams about a wounded and traumatised soldier 'Khan'.
In trying to connect with people, Johnny has no control over the memories and dreams which flood his waking moments, to a point where at times he loses track of what is real. The theme of mateship is omni-present in Australian war literature and the concept of soldiers having a far greater fear of letting their mates down than dying themselves is clearly very real. Metzenthen has created an authentic story which I feel would meet with approval from those who served, on the grounds that the detail is accurate, the humour is realistic and there is a profound respect for the soldiers from both sides which is unwavering even when pointing to the insanity of the war itself.
The author emphasises that what the Australian, New Zealand and American service men endured was so immense and significant that it was literally life changing, often permanently and all too often being terribly destructive in terms of physical and psychological injury. Without insulting these individuals in any way however, the author questions this terrible suffering against the outcome of the war. Metzenthen also reveals the war and post-conflict experience of the North Vietnamese people, who saw only that their country was invaded. The unequal nature of warfare between lightly armed guerrillas and the almost unbelievable might of Western firepower is considered with great sensitivity. The reader is left with the sense that after all the civilian and military deaths, all the injuries and the unspeakable destruction and poisoning of the environment, the outcome was pretty much the same as it would have been if the war had not been waged.
Rob Welsh

Big hug books by Shona Innes

cover image

Ill. by Irisz Agocs. Five Mile Press, 2016.
Worries are like clouds. ISBN 9781760400729
You are like you. ISBN 9781760400712
(Age: 4+) Mental health. Depression. Identity. Two more in the series, Big hug books gives us a book about worrying and one about identity. As with the others in the series, they aim to give teachers and parents a starting point of discussion with a class or children at home. Simply told, they are all obvious in their themes, and clear about their aim. A page of information about how to use the books appears at the end of each story.
Worries are like clouds tells the reader that many days are happy, filled with laughter and are carefree, while others are dark and gloomy and sometimes they would prefer to stay in bed with the bedclothes over their head. The gentle text tells the reader that this is normal, that everyone has good and bad days, happy and sad days, bright sunny days and days with clouds. It goes on to tell the reader that there are ways to overcome these gloomy days and then a number of pages are devoted to outlining strategies to deal with a cloudy day. These would make a great discussion point in the classroom.
You are like you takes the same approach as the others in the series, with half of the pages devoted to positive images of what make you, you. Then a number of pages give the negatives sides of life, people may annoy you, you may feel out of sorts, and so on, and the author then gives strategies to overcome the negatives. Again this provides a starter for discussion amongst children, in the classroom or at home with a simple direct text and accompanying illustrations.
Fran Knight

I went to the supermarket by Paul Howard

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408844700
(Ages: 3-6) This book is based on the popular memory game of the same name (I went to the supermarket and I bought... ) and shows a young boy and girl competing to remember everything they add to the shopping list. However, they don't buy chocolate, chips and chicken at the supermarket... they buy dancing aliens, fire-breathing dragons and fearsome Granny pirates. As happens in the real-life game, someone forgets an item and the game comes to an end (in this case with a mountain of jelly going SPLAT!).
The sparkly, fantastical cover featuring a boy with underpants on his head pushing a flamingo and a dragon in a shopping trolley will draw children in. The larger-than-life, crazy illustrations inside, packed with characters, colour and interesting and varied fonts, will keep them engaged. This will stimulate the imagination of young children, many of whom will love reading along and trying to remember everything on the shopping list. It might even become a favourite game for them to play themselves.
Nicole Nelson

Baxter's book by Hrefna Bragadottir

cover image

Nosy Crow, 2016. ISBN 9780857635211
(Age: Preschool - Yr 2) Baxter adores books. Books about scary wolves, brave lions, cuddly bears, cute little rabbits. He loves stories so much his greatest wish is to be in a one too. As he comes out of the bookstore laden with new purchases he spots a sign for an audition to be in a storybook. This is his dream come true! He is SO excited but when he joins the very long line of characters waiting to show their talents, he realises all have been in storybooks before - except him. But he is convinced of his talents - he can sing, dance, act and do gymnastics - so goes forth undaunted onto the stage as the first performer. Imagine his disappointment when the judges dismiss him because they just don't know what he is. He's not a scary wolf, a brave lion, a cuddly bear, a cute rabbit or even a hungry crocodile and when he tries to be like them, he fails. Why is being himself not enough?
This debut picture book from Icelandic author Hrefna Bragadottir is quite charming with its lovable main character (who is a totally original concept) who is prepared to follow his dream but finds himself not accepted because he's different and doesn't fit the stereotype of a storybook character. As a story in itself, with soft pastel pictures that take the edge off his rejection, it is a stand-alone but there is greater depth here than just a single read because it raises all sorts of questions about stereotypes - are wolves always scary and rabbits always cute? - as well as being true to oneself, tolerating difference and all those other relationship issues young children encounter when they step into the bigger world of preschool or big school for the first time. Venturing into the unknown always raises some questions of self-doubt and when things don't go as anticipated there can be all sorts of ramifications. The heart-warming ending to the story will bring reassurance and recognition and Baxter will never be an oddity again! Young readers will delight in identifying the characters they know like the three little pigs, but there's also scope to investigate other stories that feature the creatures - perhaps make lists and displays to inspire wider reading - and compare and contrast each character with the stereotype. Character analysis in preschool!!! For those a little older it could lead to discussions about preconceptions and misconceptions we have about people and start to break down some of the barriers that are already in place even at this age.
Baxter's book is a perfect example of children learning about life through literature and why we need to keep sharing such wonderful stories.
Barbara Braxton

Raymie Nightingale by Kate DiCamillo

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2016. ISBN 9780763681173
(Age: 9-12) Recommended. Family breakdown. Friendship. Meaning of life. Loss. Kate DiCamillo is renowned as a two-time Newbery Medallist, as author of the Tale of Desperaux and Flora and Ulysses. In this, her latest book, she uses the inspiration of her own childhood memories to tell the enigmatic tale of Raymie Clarke who believes that if she wins the 'Little Miss Central Florida Tire competition' she might be able to entice her father back home (he has left town with a dental hygienist and is currently out of her life completely). With childish logic, she needs to add baton twirling and good deeds to her 'resume' for her competition entry, and meets two other girls who are also entangled in pursuit or sabotage of the Little Miss Central Florida Tire title. The challenges of friendship, and understanding the world around her and the wisdom of adults come to the fore as she grapples with life, loss and the big questions of existence. Keeping life's batons twirling can be very difficult. There are some curious adults within her circle of contacts, and her new friends are also extremely unique.
This is a quirky tale that highlights that children can sometimes feel that they need to solve the problems of their world or are unaware of the consequences of their choices; problems that from an adult or psychological perspective should never be borne by a child. It is a simply written tale, and the naivete of the children and their responses to poverty, marriage breakdowns, death and their own difficult circumstances are dealt with in a gently humorous way that makes the story entertaining and accessible for a young reader.
Carolyn Hull

Hugless Douglas and the great cake bake by David Melling

cover image

Hugless Douglas series. Hodder, 2016. ISBN 9781444919882
(Age: 5+) Recommended. Cooking. Humour. The series of Hugless Dougless books has created a large fan base, and this, the fifth in the stories about the bear, will be well received. Douglas is big warm and friendly, staring out at the reader as he involves himself in one adventure after another, adventures which all readers will recognise.
With a nod to the many cooking shows on our small screen, this time Douglas follows the trail of honey to find a group of sheep collecting the ingredients they need to make honey cakes. The black faced sheep don his apron for him, and pass down all the food they have collected, as he offers to be involved as well. The process for making the cakes is followed in the story and the mixture eventually made, with admonishments about not eating the mixture before it is cooked.
But as the group stands in line with their plates waiting for the cakes to be taken from the oven, a food fight beaks out and Douglas is so involved that he misses the cakes. When he realises what has happened they have all been eaten. Still hungry he must eat the rejects, the carrot and nuts, but finds them to his liking, even though they are not topped with honey.
This is an easily absorbed story of cooking cakes, of the process involved, of the etiquette of cooking and eating what has been cooked, of waiting your turn, and of the idea that vegetables and nuts can be as good as cake.
Fun filled illustrations will drag the readers' eyes along the pages, following the antics of the black faced sheep and Douglas.
Fran Knight

Hello! by Tony Flowers

cover image

NLA Publishing, 2016. ISBN 9780642278876
Look at your school population. Are all the children native English speakers? Or is there a mix of languages almost as diverse as the children themselves? In my Collection Policy for the school I was recently working in, under the heading Purpose and Role of the Collection I included the clause 'provide a wide range of materials on all levels of difficulty, with a diversity of appeal and the presentation of different points of view including those that reflect the lives of students in relation to their culture, ethnicity, language, religion and beliefs, community and family structure, sexual orientation and any other consideration' and this new publication from the National Library of Australia fits the language aspect of this perfectly.
Superbly illustrated in cartoon style by Tony Flowers and presented in a clear uncomplicated layout, we meet twelve Australian children, each of whom speaks a different language including Kala Lagaw Ya from Badu Island in the Torres Strait; Kaurna from Tarntanya in Adelaide; and Murrinhpatha from Wadeye in the Northern Territory as well as the more common languages of Italian, Thai, Korean, Greek, Vietnamese, Japanese, Indonesian, and Chinese. Even the Lebanese version of Arabic is included and there is a pronunciation guide at the back of the book to assist the reader but which has been dovetailed to meet needs rather than being a linguistic reference.
Each child has two double spreads so as well as introducing the reader to the word for 'hello' in each language, each then shares a little of their life including favourite foods, special days, costumes, musical instruments, games and activities and how to count to ten and each of these is then highlighted at the back of the book with photos available in the NLA.
As much as the children I was working with last year loved to practise and share their new skills in English, their faces always lit up when they discovered a resource written in their own language or which was about their own country. They were so happy to see something familiar amongst the unfamiliar and loved to show it to their friends and then take it home to share with their families. So this wonderful resource is sure to strike a chord with so many of those in our care. Apart from the familiarity it also demonstrates that we acknowledge and value their origins by having resources for them available. Seeing yourself in a book is such an affirmation of who you are.
There are so many opportunities within the Australian Curriculum and within the calendar to investigate and celebrate the origins of the children in our classes that this book could be in use all year. There are comprehensive teaching notes which include how to make some of the items featured by the children; but I can envisage it being a pivotal text for this year's Book Week theme - Australia: Story Country. Make it model for the children to tell their story by producing a poster and display for the library to be hung in honour of their country's national day. This was one of the most popular displays that attracted so much interest from parents and teachers as much as from the students. They really valued the recognition.
Barbara Braxton

The Lie Tree by Frances Hardinge

cover image

Macmillan, 2015. ISBN 9781447264101
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. Mystery. Lies. Truth. Fantasy. Costa Book Award for Children's Book (2015), Carnegie Medal Nominee (2016), Costa Book of the Year (2015), YA Book Prize Nominee (2016). When Faith's father is found dead at the bottom of a cliff, she is determined to find out what has happened to him. Her mother and uncle drag his body into the orchard, and Faith refuses to believe that he has committed suicide. She reads his journals and finds references to the Lie Tree that he has hidden in a cave, a tree that feeds off lies and reveals hidden truths when lies are fed to it. She begins to spread lies across the island and the truth begins to appear.
Dark and demanding, this is not a book that can be read in one sitting. Rather, it is one to savour over a period of time, think about and return to when ideas have begun to meld into understanding. Perhaps one of the most interesting themes of the book is its well-researched background about Victorian science and the gathering of fossils, the role of women in Victorian times and Victorian funeral customs, including taking photos of the dead. The reader is drawn into the lives of Faith and her mother, both constrained by attitudes to women of the time. Faith desperately wants to study natural science and to be recognised by her father, but that is not something that is acceptable for girls living in that time, while her mother is forced to act as the helpless lady, needing a man's protection, to get any stability for her family. The final chapter is a wonderful summary of the difficulties that Faith will face, but the effect that her efforts could have on 'some later girl'.
The idea of a Lie Tree is a compelling one, and the reader is dragged along into the consequences and nastiness that result from the lies that Faith feeds the tree in her efforts to find who has murdered her father. She not only lies, but attempts to scientifically and rationally analyse the physical and dream evidence that she finds in order to work out the mystery. She is helped along by Clay, whose photography skills not only let the reader know about funeral customs, but also help to uncover the truth.
Hardinge has an original voice and mature and intelligent readers will find much to savour in The lie tree.
Pat Pledger

Max by Sarah Cohen-Scali

cover image

Text, 2016. ISBN 9781922182852
(Age: 16+) Recommended. This book, first published in France, has won awards in Europe. It is well researched and covers a period in history marked with cruelty and evil.
Max is a product of the 'Lebensborn' (Fountains of Youth) program. This program was designed to produce perfect blonde, blue-eyed members of the Aryan race to regenerate the Reich. His story spans the years 1936 to 1945 and begins with Max in utero.
Max brings to life the ideals, thoughts and motivations of the Hitler Youth. He explains the atrocities and evil practices with a complacency and coldness that is at once confronting, brutal and illuminating.
At regular intervals the author calls to the attention of the reader the age of the narrator (foetus, 3 months old, or one year old). This at times interferes with the flow of the reading, jarring the reader, as the writing is infused with well researched historical information and adult perspectives.
The book is confronting as it portrays the complacency of some caught up in the holocaust, their moral choices and the battle waged by good over evil. The themes of friendship and identity are explored through the unlikely relationship that develops between Max and Lukas (a Polish boy). There is an adult insight into the moral dilemmas faced by everyday people as they grappled with a situation that was tumbling out of their control. There is a poignant section at the end of the book where Max is oblivious to an opportunity for love and redemption that will have adults reaching for the tissues.
Linda Guthrie

Red Professor: The Cold War life of Fred Rose by Peter Monteath and Valerie Munt

cover image

Wakefield Press, 2015. ISBN 9781743053720
(Age: 14+) Recommended. This book is written by historians based at Flinders University in South Australia. The work is extensively researched and leans heavily on the numerous primary sources that document the life of this relatively unknown player in Australia's history.
Fred Rose is a little like Forest Gump in that he seems to have popped up in a range of important times in history during his lifetime. The writing gives the reader the impression that Fred Rose is very impressed by his own importance. It may be this that lead Colonel Spry of ASIO to identify him as a Soviet spy who went by the code name 'Professor'.
Fred's life spans several continents and encompasses work as an anthropologist on Groote Eylandt, a meteorologist, an academic in Canberra and East Berlin, a champion of the rights of Australia's indigenous people and a father informing on his children to Stasi handlers. He is portrayed as a flawed human being who made interesting decisions that charted a life that has ultimately left more questions than answers. Would his life have been more positive and more productive had he made different decisions? Perhaps so.
The historical information is a real treat for those interested in more about those heady times during the Cold War and the Petrov Affair. Though brimming with historical facts (including diaries and archival material), this book is easy to read. The referencing style is cumbersome for those readers interested in identifying the source of information or quotations and this at times disrupts the reading.
This work is well suited as a resource for the Research Project and History students.
Linda Guthrie