Reviews

The fire sermon by Francesca Haig

cover image

Harper Collins, 2015. ISBN 9780007563067
(Age: 13+) In a post-apocalyptic world set hundreds of years in the future, all births are twins, one an Omega always with a deformity, limbless or worse, and an Alpha, a normal desirable twin. When one twin dies the other will also die no matter the distance or lifestyle they are leading at the time. The story starts with twins Cassandra the Omega and Zach the Alpha. Normally separated at birth Cassandra has hidden her ability to see into the future, creating the two twin as outcastes by others because they can't tell who the Alpha twin is. When they finally are split from each other Cassandra is sent to live with other Omegas while Zach decides to work for the Council where he starts his climb up the corporate ladder. Cassandra is kidnapped and locked into a cell where she is interrogated on how strong her skills really are. She finally escapes the cell only to find a room full of tanks with Omegas suspended in a liquid. One of the tanks holds a boy who makes eye contact with her. She rescues Kip by breaking the tank and together they escape for a mysterious island where Omegas are treated not like outcastes and Alphas are desperate to find them. The power to change the world lies in both Cass and Zach's hands but if they are not careful both will die in the struggle for power.
Francesca Haig has built a bleak and troubled world based on fear and prejudice. Her characters feel fear, insecurity and are not born equipped to wage war, but when push comes to shove, and the heart is involved heroes rise, take risks and learn to believe in the possibility of a better world for everyone. The story is fast paced and quite easy to follow along with. If the reader likes The Hunger Games and The Maze Runner they will enjoy this first book of the series.
Jody Holmes

Eve and the Fiery Phoenix by Jess Black

cover image

Keeper of the Crystals series. New Frontier Publishing, 2015. ISBN 9781925059441
(Age: 7+) Themes: Fantasy adventure; Environmental concerns. This is the second in the Keeper of the Crystals series and the young central characters Eve and Oscar are again magically drawn into a rescue adventure. This time they need to rescue the fiery phoenix and rescue the jungle land of Griffid from destruction due to darkness. The magic is gentle and Eve displays the ability of hearing the Phoenix's calls for help. The rescue is exciting, but without anxiety-inducing detail. The children display clever solutions to the problems they face.
This is an entry level fantasy adventure for young readers wanting something more exciting from an early chapter book. Teachers may also appreciate this series for its 'read-aloud' potential. There are nine short chapters, which could be read to children in years 1-3 over a short time. References to environmental issues might also raise discussion about our own world's dependence on the sun for our survival.
Carolyn Hull

The boy, the bear, the baron and the bard and other dramatic tales by Gregory Rogers

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781760112394
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Historical, Elizabethan times, Shakespeare, Medieval knights, Wordless picture book. Gregory Roger's award winning picture books, The boy, the bear, the baron and the bard, Midsummer knight and The hero of Little Street, are offered together in one volume for his fans and devotees and will attract a new range of readers as children are introduced to these breathtaking wordless picture books.
I loved rereading them, recalling discussions with classes in the past, filling in the detail of Elizabethan England while watching the boy escape from William Shakespeare. The first story brims over with enthusiasm for that time in history and children will adore finding small images which will engender so many more questions, adding to their historical knowledge. All the trappings of Elizabethan London are there: bear baiting, the Globe Theatre and the others on the south side of The Thames, the Queen and her barge on the river, the man in the tower waiting execution, monkeys in the street, fashion, housing and so on, a whole world to enjoy as the boy escapes the Bard's chase.
And with the next story in this mesmerising volume, Midsummer knight, again held my attention, continuing the story of Bear and his foray into the castle in the middle of the forest where he rescues a queen from the dungeons and overcomes her enemies, restoring her to the throne. Again the detail is glorious; the background superb in presenting before a young audience the times of castles and knights, of queens and dungeons, of power struggles. Bear has been lured into the forest by Puck, the fairy from A Midsummer knight's dream, and so readers will love deciding to what extent this is Bear's dream.
The same boy appears in the last story, The hero of Little Street, where he plays in Trafalgar Square before going into the National Gallery. Here he falls into a Vermeer panting and lands in seventeenth century Amsterdam, where he is chased by a pack of dogs. All the excitement of the chase is there as he evades his pursuers only to have one follow him out of the painting at the end with hilarious results. The lustrous illustrations reveal Amsterdam of the times, and readers will love picking out breadth of the detail Rogers includes. Historical illustration at its best, I have enjoyed rereading them immensely and I'm sure new readers and old will as well.
Fran Knight

Seahorse by Bruce Pascoe

cover image

Magabala Books, 2015. ISBN 9781921248931
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Themes: Fishing, Family Life, Boating, Mysteries, Adventure. Jack's family, dad Vince, mum Carla and sister Tania love to spend time camping, fishing, diving and exploring Seahorse Bay. Carla is content to sit on the rocks, catching fish for their tea while Vince dives out on the ocean side of the reef looking for crayfish. Eight year old Tania is ready to practise her snorkelling skills, ably looked after by her big brother as they search for abalone on the rocks. They love their time spent together in this idyllic setting, however, things change when Jack discovers a deliberately sunken boat nearby. Who is the man dressed in black, watching them with binoculars, from a hiding spot at the top of the cliffs?
Father and son decide to salvage the boat after checking with the local police officer. Jack rescues a little seahorse caught in the cabin and that's how the boat is named. Mum notices the mysterious man and his old rusty Falcon hanging around. The family is even threatened and forced to take the bloke into town. With the help of the police, the mystery is resolved and Jack, his parents and sister Tania are free to take the repaired boat exploring the nearby islands and coves around Seahorse Bay.
Bruce Pascoe's narrative is rich in description, interwoven with historical facts about Aboriginal life in the region. There's the story of an escaped convict who settled down with an aboriginal wife to a resilient life on the coast, and many Tasmanian descendants can be traced back to them. He shares his love of fishing and outdoor activities in Jack's story. This junior novel is suited for readers with a higher interest age and lower reading age.
Rhyllis Bignell

The good girls by Sara Shepard

cover image

Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBN 9781471404320
(Age: 16+) Themes: Murder-mystery genre; Relationships; Trust; Teen-age drama; Bullying. A coterie of 'perfect girls', while in a Film Studies class in a Washington suburban High School, create a list of a number of people who they believe deserve to die. When these same people begin to be killed in exactly the circumstances described in the 'wish list' the 'good girls' are thrust into a psychological thriller and become afraid that they are responsible. Trust and relationships are stretched and tortured as more of their complex lives and affiliations are revealed to the world. With interesting twists and boyfriend/girlfriend and other teenage issues coming to the fore, this book feels like a novelisation of a Teenage Chick-flick Murder-Drama or Soap Opera. The family lives of the main characters cover an array of 21st Century dramas - loss of a sibling, loss of a parent; same sex parents, step-parent dilemmas, parent in jail, hoarding; and amongst the teenagers and their classmates - suicide, bullying, sexual exploitation, psychological abuse, competitiveness, under-age drinking and partying are also part of the dramatic background within the narrative. When these are listed, it becomes obvious that perhaps the author has tried too hard to weave all of these personal trials into the one murder-mystery. The solution to the mystery is worth waiting for!
Not great literature and not unreservedly recommended, but it will be read by the television generation (Sara Shepard is the author of Pretty Little Liars) and those who like the Teen 'Chick-flick-style' Murder-mystery genre - Aged 16+ .
Carolyn Hull

The marriage of opposites by Alice Hoffman

cover image

Scribner, 2015. ISBN 9781471112102
(Age: Adult/young adult) Recommended. Alice Hoffman is a highly successful author with more than thirty works in her manifest. In The Marriage of Opposites Hoffman paints her perspective on the family life of Rachel Pomie and her son Camille Pissarro. Camille Pissarro helped introduce the world to Impressionist painting and is widely viewed, along with Claude Monet and others, as one of the shapers of Impressionism.
Hoffman's impression of Pissarro's family focuses attention on Pissaro's mother - her rebellious childhood, her forbidden love, two marriages, and her life on the Island of St Thomas. However through Hoffman's study of Rachel, the reader begins to understand the man Camille, his journey, and what led him to become the great painter widely recognised today as the Father of Impressionism.
Rachel Pomie began her life on the island of St Thomas. Her grandparents had fled to the New World from France during the Inquisition. Finally in 1754 after the King of Denmark passed an edict allowing Jews to do business with non-Jews, Rachel's parents arrived on the colourful Island of St Thomas, Island of Turtles. It was here that Rachel grew up and where she married Camille's father, Frederic. Rachel and her best friend Jestine, the daughter of her mother's maid, roamed the jungles on the island, dreamed dreams and watched for turtles and pelicans. Yet Rachel always longed for Paris, the city of her ancestors. A city she had not experienced . . . a city that seemed to elude her.
Hoffman's attention to detail is both astounding and captivating. For readers who like to lose themselves inside the poetry of storytelling, this novel is a must. Her prose is flecked with folklore and colour - from the vibrant environment of St Thomas, to the neutrals of the Paris winters. Throughout, there is the intrigue of family secrets kept dark, rebellion against beliefs and rules held by a small Jewish island community, and the overwhelming desire to travel abroad. This novel is a must for adults who enjoy a lyrical narrative and their fiction spiced with historical elements.
Colleen Tuovinen

Fearless with my Dad by Cori Brooke

cover image

New Frontier Publishing, 2015. ISBN 9781925059403
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Fearless with my Dad is a beautiful picture book, following a young boy and his dad. Together they are pirates, flying like an eagle and travelling to the moon. The underlying theme is a child can be anything and do anything as long as they have their dad there to support them.
The beautifully illustrated text will engage younger readers and encourage new vocabulary as children and their carers discuss all the amazing adventures of this boy and his dad. Older readers could create their own version and the main character could be changed to a girl.
It would make a great gift for a father on Father's Day - no matter their age - but would be a great gift for a first time dad.
Highly recommended for all readers - whether they read it independently (aged 6+) or with a parent.
Kylie Kempster

Something's amiss at the Zoo by Jen Breach

cover image

Lothian Children's Books, 2015. ISBN 9780734416223
The zookeepers at this crazy, mixed-up zoo really don't seem to know what's best for their animals. Who ever heard of Kitty Litter for Catfish?
Could a shark be happy in a tiny jungle pool? Does a spider monkey really want to eat flies and spin a web? And, LOOK OUT elephant beetle! Look out for the elephants!
The expressions on the faces of the animals on this book's front cover can only leave the reader wondering what COULD be amiss at this zoo.
Happily a small, clever boy comes and helps to salvage the situation for the bewildered zoo animals, so they can all reside happily.
This amusing, beautifully illustrated book is sure to appeal to younger readers.
J. Smith

Birdy by Jess Vallance

cover image

Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBN 9781471404665
(Ages: 14+) Some strong language. 'Frances Bird has been a loner for so long that she's given up on ever finding real friendship. But then she's asked to show a new girl around school, and she begins to think her luck could finally be changing. Eccentric, talkative and just a little bit posh, Alberta is not at all how Frances imagined a best friend could be. But the two girls click immediately, and it's not long before they are inseparable. Frances could not be happier. As the weeks go on, Frances finds out more about her new best friend - her past, her secrets, her plans for the future - and she starts to examine their friendship more closely, is it, perhaps, just too good to be true?' (Publisher)
An interesting read. The protagonist is very snarky and sarcastic, much like many teens today, appealing to the audience greatly. Vallance shows true friendship with all the tension and problems that take place in school. Throughout the whole of the novel the suspense made me want to keep reading and not put it down just so I could know why Frances Bird had to write it down. A great read for anyone that loves a bit of dark, moodiness and a creep factor in their life.
Cecilia Richards

The Rapunzel dilemma by Jennifer Kloester

cover image

Penguin Books, 2014. ISBN 9780143571087
(Ages: 12+) Modern interpretations of familiar fairy tales can be fascinating to read. I recall those of Robin McKinley and Gail Carson Levine - cleverly told with a touch of something magical, which stays with the reader long after the story has been read. Jennifer Kloester's modern day version of Rapunzel (a companion novel to The Cinderella Moment) lacks the skilled approach, which brings the fairy tale to the fore. Rich girl, Lily, longs to join the London Drama Academy, and when successful for a trial period, meets fellow students who do not believe that she has been granted a place entirely due to her talents. Ronan Carver, a talented but mysterious art student, seems to understand her. They begin meeting in the old tower room, which was previously providing a haven for her. Now her world is split between her drama studies and her love for Ronan, and real life is very different from being on stage. The author is said to have been inspired by the stories of Georgette Heyer - but I can't help thinking that the influence of other historical romances has made this novel rather light and silly, relying heavily on teenage angst and envy. The Rapunzel Dilemma is readable and gives some insight to life in a competitive world for aspiring youngsters but it lacks a strong and contemporary storyline.
Julie Wells

Suri's wall by Lucy Estela

cover image

Ill. by Matt Ottley. Penguin, 2015. ISBN 9780670077755
(Age: 7+) Recommended. Resilience. Determination. Children in war. Belief. Measuring her height against the wall Suri is surprised to find that she can now see over the top. The children come to her eager to see what she sees, forgetting their differences. She describes the rolling hills, the golden bridge, the harbour filled with ships, one resplendent with its red sails and ornate carvings.
Ottley has given this story of children in war an historical look: the ships are galleons, the people dressed in Medieval garb, buffalo pull large carts of grain, encouraging the reader to think about the timelessness of the impact of war on children.
Questions will keep popping into readers' mouths as they survey the scene Suri describes, asking when the story is set, where the children are, why they are in such a place, where are their parents and so on. Readers will accept what Suri sees but the last image of a war torn city and sunken ships will encourage readers to view the whole story from a different perspective and turn to the start of the book and reread it.
The character of Suri rejected at first because she is so tall, is now a necessary part of the children's days as she describes what is over the wall. Their belief in her stories keeps them hopeful reflecting what people do all over the world, to keep children safe from the vicissitudes of life during war.
Each question will raise others and so groups of children reading this book will widen their understanding of homeless children around the world. Their view of the world is not the one so beautifully described by Suri but a harsh cruel one reminiscent of the image Suri really sees.
Each child in Ottley's illustrations is different, their bleak situation, living in rows of dormitory beds, eating at a long table, the browns and grays contrasting with the scene described by Suri, serve to underline the predicament they are in and will further endear them to the reader. Their faces will stay with the reader as the book is closed.
Fran Knight

Harvey Drew and the Junk Skunks by Cas Lester

cover image

Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBN 9781471403347
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. In the first few chapters of Harvey Drew and the Junk Skunks, there is an explosion of toxic slime, a hatching alien egg and the ship's cook/doctor announces they are all going to die! Just another crazy day on this intergalactic garbage collection ship called The Toxic Spew. It is captained by 11 year old Earthling, Harvey Drew. No food means time to panic as this motley crew start to feel the hunger and pain of no food. Their plan is to head for a space store called Waitless. On arrival at Waitless, the superstore, things don't seem quite right. It looks like the store has been abandoned and in quite a hurry! What is going on?
Harvey Drew and the Junk Skunks is aimed at boys aged 9+ but anyone who loves a giggle will enjoy reading this book. The text is quick moving and full of gross stuff, making it appealing to children. The use of nonsense words - such as spaghettification which occurs when you travel through a black hole and other space themed objects and events - will engage readers and encourage them to keep reading. It is easy to read, the characters are hilarious and the accompanying cartoon style images add to the hilarity.
Kylie Kempster

Three moments of an explosion. Stories by China Mieville

cover image

Macmillan, 2015. ISBN 9780230770188
(Ages:15 +) Obviously well known for his forays into speculative fiction, China Mieville has written a fascinating and challenging collection of short stories, beginning with the brief and startling tale, which gives the collection its title. Each story entices the reader to explore and deliberate but never to assume. He plays with ideas, indeed teases the reader on a number of levels - things are just not what they seem. With speculation, there is theorising, and the revelation of abstract ideas. This collection of stories is thought provoking and interesting but, at the same time, perplexing and confronting. For these reasons the stories are limited in their appeal to a young audience, probably attracting those already converted to the genre. Some tales are so strange that their meaning evades. The language is amazing; descriptions are stark and observant even though the ideas testify to something strange and elusive. Polynia and Sacken are two tales which stay with me - low lying icebergs floating above London, and a lake which has taken life without mercy. Extraordinary!
Julie Wells

Wesley Booth Super Sleuth by Adam Cece

cover image

Ill. by Michel Streich. Omnibus Books for Scholastic; 2015. ISBN 9781742991016
(Age: 8-12) Highly recommended. Themes: Mystery; Friendship; Family and family breakdown. Adam Cece, a local South Australian author has written a delightful tale for young readers aged 8-12. Wesley Booth is an eccentric boy who is a self-proclaimed 'Super Sleuth' who enthusiastically tells of his skills. His detective abilities rely on an efficient system of recording clues and he relies on a faithful side-kick to support him as he attempts to solve unusual problems. His family are 'interesting'! His mother creates gift baskets (with limited financial success), his geologist father tells exceptionally lame Dad-jokes with a Rock theme and his older brother is attempting to become a Rock Star (of the musical variety) with extremely limited talent! Financial strain puts pressure on the family, with the risk of a major rift, but this is not the main drama of this story. Wesley (the legend in his own case book) is surrounded by an equally peculiar friendship group, but their harmony is disrupted when the new girl, Cassidy Strong arrives at their school. Her competitive detective skills put Wesley at risk of losing his Super Sleuth status, and a major crime spree at their school puts them all into concentrated competitive sleuthing-mode at the expense of their school work. A major explosion and a clever revelation eventually lead to Wesley's restoration to the role of 'Super Sleuth' at school. However despite this success, we realise that Wesley is far from self-aware, and is likely to get himself into plenty of strife as he solves other people's problems.
This book contains more text than The Diary of a Wimpy Kid series, but the humour is similar and will be enjoyed by many in the target age group. The cartoon-style illustrations by Michel Streich are scattered throughout the chapters, adding to the text, but not dominating.
This can be highly recommended, and will be enjoyed for its humourous view of life told from a child's perspective.
Carolyn Hull

Voicing the dead by Gary Crew

cover image

Ford Street, [2015]. ISBN 9781925272055
Gary Crew is known for his interest in confronting historical events which form the basis for novels. In this tale, the author revisits a topic covered in an earlier work, being the true story of the wreck of the Charles Eaton on a reef in the Torres Strait in 1834.
A bold technique, described in the text as 'Lit tripping' enables the narrator, 14 year old Jack Ireland, (the voice of the dead) to time skip through centuries of literature, quoting passages to better describe the terrifying events which befall the crew and passengers from the vessel. Interestingly, whilst recounting events from the past, the character references authors writing long after his death, a style emphasising ghostly, tormented afterlife which may confuse some readers in this overly long story.
In a similar break from tradition, Crew reveals in the initial pages that the ship is wrecked and the crew and passengers are murdered by head-hunters. Together with an orphaned toddler William D'Oyley, ship's cabin boy Jack survives to tell his tale in a monstrously edited version produced by a London publisher in 1845.
Having revealed the plot and conclusion, the author skilfully entices the reader to accompany Jack from his appearance on the vessel whilst loading in London to undertaking the arduous journey to Tasmania where cargo and poor Irish orphans are delivered to Hobart's docks. During the passage, Jack struggles to establish his place in the ship, enjoying a privileged position as Captain's boy which causes tension with the seamen as he tends to both his master and the orphans who have endured grim suffering. Importantly, Jack comes to hero worship the thoroughly decent and brave First Mate, Mr. Clare, who will have great influence over the lad and the crew following the wreck.
Sailing North, the vessel passes into the Torres Strait, heading for Java when it strikes a reef, becoming so damaged that it has to be abandoned. A range of curious circumstances concerning the order of departure occur but the end result is that the passengers and most of the crew save themselves by building rafts which are washed up on shores inhabited by head-hunters.
The murderous savagery which follows is confronting and disturbing, to the extent that whilst admiring Crew's capacity to move and influence through words, I struggled to identify an appropriate readership given that the novel lacks depth for senior literary study. The plight of baby William, seeing his parents brutally beaten and beheaded is awful, but just one element amongst many hideous aspects which are sadly true. The passage of time should not inure the reader to suffering, especially in works designed for amusement and entertainment.
Rob Welsh
Editor's note: The publisher recommends it as Age 15+. Teacher's notes are available.