Reviews

Frankie and Joely by Nova Weetman

cover image

University of Queensland Press, 2015. ISBN 9780702253638
(Age: 13-14) Themes: Friendship, boyfriends, first love, family, small town life Australia. Best friends Joely and Frankie don't have much in common but they recognise in each other some shared need and they have become close as only 15 year old girls can be. Joely invites Frankie to spend a week of the summer holidays at her aunt and uncle's outback farm. Joely's mum is overprotective and anxious but agrees to let them go, while Frankie's mum hardly registers if Frankie is around, let alone if she is ok, and sometimes she is not OK when her mother's sleazy boyfriends get too close.
The drought affected farm and Joely's boy cousins hold a special place in her heart and she can't wait to show Frankie around but typically Frankie does her own thing and gets to know everyone without Joely's help. Miffed that she has lost control of the situation Joely accepts a ride on her cousin's motorbike and they crash into a kangaroo resulting in the death of the roo. Best friends can't be mad at each other for long and the girls set out to see what the small country town can offer, Joely hoping to see local boy Rory, unaware that Frankie has already met him and he is attracted to her.
The heat and isolation seem to intensify everything and the mix of jealousy, boyfriends, first love and ultimately the importance of friendship and loyalty forged through shared experience gives this story its strength. The intense focus on the girls' relationships leaves the rest of the characters sketchy and one dimensional but this book's audience of 13 to 14 year old girls will love it.
Sue Speck

Hush, little possum : an Australian lullaby by P Crumble

cover image

Ill. by Wendy Binks. Scholastic, 2015. ISBN 9781743626436
(age: 3+) Humour, Poetry, Singing, Australian animals. The prolific P Crumble or Paul Dumble is at it again, using an old song and changing the lyrics to suit a modern audience, or perhaps simply presenting an old song in a smart new version. Recently there has been a plethora of these published by Scholastic, with the junior primary class in mind. Brightly illustrated, a CD in the front cover and energetic verses on each page, they must be read and re read, read out loud, hummed, sung and drummed to enhance the words on the page, and I can imagine groups of kids doing this with gusto and lots of laughs.
This one has used the verse of Hush little baby, don't you cry to produce a similar song about the strength of maternal love. Easy to sing along to, easy to read with its bold illustrations helping the younger reader, and lovely to listen to Deborah Mailman's voice on the CD, the whole will be a useful addition to the classroom where verse and music are used. The illustrator, Wendy Binks has used the Australian landscape with effect, promoting the discussion of things recognisably Australian, such as the tractor in a galvanised iron shed, the eucyalypt and mallee forest, a windmill, along with the various Australian animals.
Fran Knight

Bystanders by Valerie Volk

cover image

Wakefield Press, 2015. ISBN 9781743053799
(Age: Senior secondary) Aptly named Bystanders, Biblical stories in this collection are told from the perspective of minor characters and witnesses to events. Some will be familiar to those with even an elementary Christian or general education, however I suspect that many will be completely unknown.
The author's detailed knowledge of and careful research into Biblical and historical events is clear from the text, however I fear that the complexity and obscurity of the tales will limit potential readership. The technique of recounting events through the eyes of individuals who are otherwise ignored is a good one, yet the book could not avoid becoming a compilation of impassioned monologues to an unknown listener.
The historical, geographic and cultural details are very interesting, however lineage and family relationships can be confusing. The messages conveyed will give cause for reflection and consideration of how fortunate we are to live in enlightened society. Power structures are evident in almost every depiction of ancient life and the modern reader will despair at the misery endured by most of the female characters. The harrowing lives of slaves is revealed whilst servants and concubines are seen to have been at the mercy of their masters. Even wives are shown to have been almost powerless to object to outright maltreatment by their husbands and women in general had no form of protest against bombastic dismissal of their views and desires by male relatives.
My recollection of the Old Testament stories having limited value due to cruelty, violence and blinkered intolerance of the religious views of others was not altered. Transitioning in the latter half to the New Testament was refreshing as Jesus' teachings such as notions of forgiveness, understanding and love for fellow human beings promise hope. This contrasts starkly with the vengeance of the Old Testament.
References and discussion notes are provided which may make this text useful for senior students undertaking Biblical study and analysis.
Rob Welsh

Thirst by Lizzie Wilcock

cover image

Scholastic Australia, 2015. ISBN 9781742839660
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Survival. Australian outback. Foster care. When the car that is taking Karanda and 8 year old Solomon to their next foster home crashes in Central Australia, and their social worker is killed, Karanda is determined to be free of the foster care system that she believes has been terrible for her. With just her backpack and a bottle of water, she sets off into the desert to escape her old life, the misery and the mistakes she has made. There is only thing holding her back - Solomon, the solemn kid who has barely said a word to anyone. When she discovers that he has followed her, she decides that his survival skills are important to keep them alive and together they trek across the desert.
I was immediately reminded of Hatchet by Gary Paulsen, and thought that this would be a great companion novel to that popular classic. Instead of facing the Canadian wilderness where water was plentiful, Karanda and Solomon face the Australian desert, where water is scarce and precious, and food is virtually impossible to find. Fortunately Solomon has been a great fan of the TV show, The Bush Tucker Man, and is able to find and identify some native food sources for them and their struggle to survive makes for fascinating reading. A quick Google search will bring up reports of survival in the desert, so their feat doesn't seem to be too implausible and the reader is carried along by their adventures.
Equally engrossing are the personal stories that gradually come to light as the reader gets to know the characters. The foster care system hasn't worked for these two children who have suffered devastating personal loss. The themes of the importance of being loved and belonging to a family and having friends loom large in this book, as do the inadequacies of the foster care system and the children's lack of ability to communicate their needs to their foster parents.
Karanda's growth as a person and her gradual understanding of the impact of what she says to Solomon is also central to the story. I loved the dialogue, especially the nicknames that Karanda gives Solomon: 'fire boy' when he makes a fire, 'fall boy' when he falls down a cliff, and other humorous tags.
I read this book in one sitting and I am of the opinion that younger readers would find it very engrossing. Teacher notes are available.
Pat Pledger

The Scandalous Sisterhood of Prickwillow Place by Julie Berry

cover image

Piccadilly Press, 2015. ISBN 9781848124370
(Age: 10+) Recommended. Humour. Mystery. When their headmistress and her brother are murdered, Smooth Kitty and her six fellow students decide to keep it a secret. They bury the bodies in the vegetable garden and dress up Stout Alice in the headmistress' place. But there is still a murderer on the prowl.
This is very funny take on a murder mystery and on the tradition of the farce genre. Each of the seven girls are named in such a way that the reader can keep in touch with their personality and appearance - although the amusing illustrations on the front cover and inside the book help as well. Smooth Kitty is the ring leader of the plot and she is the one who comes up with the ideas while having the ability to smooth over difficulties and tell smooth lies. Disgraceful Mary Jane is very pretty and loves to flirt madly with any young boy or man nearby. Stout Alice is plump but has the ability to act really well and to mimic other people's voices so she is perfect to pretend that she is Constance Plackett, the headmistress that the girls disliked. Pocked Louis has been marked by small pox when young, but she makes up her appearance with her brains and scientific ability. Dour Elinor always thinks the worst and is quite interested in death, while Dear Roberta is kind hearted and Dull Martha is not the brightest of children.
Set against a background of 1890, when young girls were expected to be prepared for marriage, even if they yearned to do more with their lives, the book romps along as the seven girls find their feet without adult supervision. Amid many moments of hilarity each girl displays her strengths and weaknesses, learning a lot about themselves and each other in the process. Underlying this is a thread of tension, as the reader tries to work out how the murders were committed and who might have a motive, all the while knowing that Stout Alice masquerading as the headmistress has been placed in grave danger.
A very enjoyable, feel good book that celebrates the different types of personalities of the girls and the friendships that hold them together The Scandalous Sisterhood of Prickwillow will be appreciated by readers who like a historical mystery with unusual in-depth characterisation.
Pat Pledger

The worst pain in the world by Nicky Johnston

cover image

Arthritis Foundation of Victoria, 2014. ISBN 9780992545215
Bella is just like every other little girl with a birthday on the horizon. She's so excited preparing for it doing all the things that other little girls do. This is going to be a VERY special day for her.
On birthday morning, Bella wakes up really excited, like all other little girls, but unlike other little girls Bella's body is wracked with pain. Her legs ache, her arms are stiff like rusty robots - it even hurts to brush her hair! Yesterday she could do anything she wanted, today she can scarcely move and all those things she was looking forward to will be impossible. While everyone else comes and has a fabulous time, she will only be able to sit and watch. For Bella has arthritis, a disease that strikes at least 1 in 1000 kids in Australia, particularly girls.
Arthritis is an invisible pain, so while her guests need bandaids, and ice and sign Ethan's cast on his broken arm, no one sees Bella's pain, particularly as she tries to hide it because even worse than the physical pain is the pain of missing out on the fun and NOT being like all the other girls. Even though she is in too much pain to eat her birthday cupcakes, to play the games or even open her presents no one notices until she bursts into tears when Dad takes the group party photo. That changes things.
Arthritis is an insidious, invisible chronic disease with many symptoms but it is characterised by pain and tiredness, and sometimes the meds for it can be as horrible as the disease itself. And the invisibility wears two cloaks - firstly there are no outward signs of it, no marks or rashes or bruises or deformities and that then makes it invisible to teachers, friends and sometimes families. So often it is not treated as seriously as more obvious things like cuts, breaks, diabetes, asthma and so forth. Yet it is very real and debilitating. This book, which is an essential in any collection and which should be brought to the attention of teaching staff, shines a light on this cruelty giving it visibility and validity.
But as Bella shows, even worse than the physical pain is the pain of being different, of being left out, of not being like all the other kids and so at the end there are suggestions for how schools can seek help to help students with the disease as well as ideas for individuals to manage it. Many of these are adaptable to the school situation such as wearing a badge so that others recognise the day's pain level and having worthwhile, fun activities available as alternatives to activity when necessary. Having arthritis is tough enough without being marginalised because of the pain.
Seek out the Bellas in your school and talk to them, their parents and their healthcare worker to make the library a welcoming and safe haven for them on the days when the jumping castle is a bar too high.
Barbara Braxton

Afterlight by Rebecca Lim

cover image

Text Publishing, 2015. ISBN 9781925240498
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. Ghosts. Murder. Mystery. Supernatural. Sophie's world has fallen apart with the death of her parents in a freak motorbike accident. After embarrassing herself with a boy who lives in her street she has made a new start in a different school, crushing on Jordan, an aloof boy. Then she begins to get frightening nightly visits from a beautiful ghost who looks eerily like her dead mother and she finds that she is fixing up things that the ghost Eve wants finished. Sophie is plunged into a dangerous world of drugs, motorbike gangs and an old love story. Together with the reluctant Jordan, she sets out to uncover the mystery of Eve's murder.
This is a thrilling mystery with the added suspense of a ghost who is directing much of the action. Sophie is such a special heroine - tall, gangly and lacking in self-confidence - she just wants to be unnoticed, except that Eve is determined that this won't happen. Once Sophie starts unravelling the secrets surrounding what is going on, she finds that she cannot stop until everything is worked out - and what a spine-tingling and unexpected ending that is!
Afterlife has all the ingredients that make up an enthralling read. Lim carefully lays down questions and hints about what is going on, in a gripping way if the reader is one who enjoys following a trail to try and solve the mystery. For those who just like an exciting read that pulls at the heartstrings and ensures some terrifying moments, Lim has ensured that the action is fast paced and the characters are really believable. The ghostly apparition of Eve and the notion of Guardians is also so well developed that the reader is carried along with their supernatural nature. The slight romance between Sophie and Jordan is just enough to tantalise those who enjoy a love story.
I thoroughly enjoyed this action packed suspenseful story with its Melbourne setting, reading it in a couple of sittings and the ending will engender lots of discussion if it was used in a literature circle or book group.
Pat Pledger

The Mapmaker Chronicles: Prisoner of the Black Hawk by A.L.Tait

cover image

Hachette, 2015. ISBN 9780734415790
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Themes: Adventure, Sailing, Cartography, Pirates, Monsters, Friendship. Set sail on the Libertas with Captain Zain, mapmaker Quinn, adventurous Ash and all the crew in another swashbuckling adventure. This second, welcome addition to The Mapmaker Chronicles is filled to the brim with monsters, sailing perilous seas, mapping uncharted waters, fighting scurrilous pirates and evil villains and narrow escapes.
Three ships leave their homeland Verdania in a year-long race to map the unchartered world, thus far they've encountered many dangers and survived four and half months away from home. The rigorous daily training undertaken by Quinn and Ash (disguised as a boy) comes in handy when they land on an exotic island. They meet Mr Frey a Verdanian (with an interesting past) and are welcomed into his home, tasting cacao for the first time. Tomas his son soon becomes a friend. Quinn and Ash are caught up in a hazardous escapade, there's an encounter with a giant serpent, being captured and trapped in a pit and attacked by small piranha-like fish - pescarn. Quinn is separated and forced into a cage aboard a rival ship, where the Gelynion captain demands the young mapmaker continue to chart their course on his map stolen by Kurt the Northern boy from the Black Hawk.
When pirates invade the Black Hawk Quinn uses his skills, courage and initiative to break free of his cage and escape from the clutches of his captors and the raiders. The fight scene is extremely gripping and readers will be drawn into the drama.
Author A. L. Tait delivers another fast paced and exciting fantasy adventure.
Rhyllis Bignell

Scream: The human flytrap by Jack Heath

cover image

Scholastic Australia, 2015. ISBN 9781760152086
The rather loud screaming cover, covered in caution tape and decorative black edged pages sets the tone for the story.
The mysterious town of Axe Falls holds many spooky, terrifying and unusual secrets. Josh, a 12 year old inquisitive boy, has just moved into a spooky looking house with his family. A creepy looking old lady from next door instantly approaches and screams for him to 'get out'. Josh is a little spooked and things begin to get weird.
At school even the teachers sound a little strange and spooky. After Josh and his friends conduct a science experiment that goes horribly wrong, their adventure into the terrifying and unusual begins.
Very much a similar style to the eternally popular Goosebumps series, this new Scream series will surely engage those slightly reluctant readers that prefer their stories a little spooky and mysterious. This is the first book in the series and very nicely sets up questions about what would be next in the adventures of Josh and his friends. The characters are likeable and relatable for the target audience. The suspense builds in the story as small clues and questions are exposed and posed requiring readers to make predictions and engage in the plot.
Zana Thiele

Liberty's fire by Lydia Syson

cover image

Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBN 9781471403675
(Age: Middle to upper secondary) Highly recommended. A grim tale indeed! Set in Paris in 1871 during the siege when Paris was captured by Prussian forces, the novel immediately draws the reader to the tragedy of the poor Parisians. This defeat led to the rise of the Paris Commune. Zephyrine's grandmother has just died, and as she is destitute, sets out to get enough money for the funeral. She almost succumbs to becoming a prostitute when Anatole, a musician, saves her. Her passionate belief in the Commune's strength to free Paris leads to Anatole supporting and loving her and she him. Jules a photographer, with whom Anatole shares a flat, and Marie, a singer with the Opera, find Zephyrine's strong belief in the Commune difficult to understand. They both have a love for Anatote but he is obsessed with Zephryrine. The violence and utter despair of the ordinary Parisians is heart-breakingly described, but the voices of Zephyrine, Anatole and Marie are realistic and believable and so personal, that the ultimate horror of the suppression of the socialist group is softened by their accounts. The descriptions of the barricades are sympathetically described.
This history is told with fire and love and encourages the reader to find out more. Interestingly, Zephyrine was exiled to New Caledonia. Later, the ship berthed in Sydney, when many were granted amnesty.
Written with passion, strength and inspiration, the reader is drawn into the brutish conditions of the ordinary Parisian. Historical fiction at its best, it's fascinatingly and carefully crafted making it well worth reading and discussing. A wonderful novel to supplement a history unit of France around that time.
Well recommended for middle to Upper Secondary students.
Sue Nosworthy

Lara of Newtown by Chris McKimmie

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781760112324
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Animals, Survival, Naive art. With an eclectic mixture of ephemera as well as illustrative materials including pastels, coloured pencils, masking tape and newspaper, along with a jacaranda flower and a paper bag, McKimmie creates a charming story of finding a home. Kids will melt as they read of the cat, Misty, being left at the Care4Cats centre at Newtown by an elderly owner who can no longer look after her. She sits in the window waiting for a carer when a family takes her home for Christmas.
They name her Nigella after she eats their crackling and custard. But things become very quiet when the family sees that their budgie has also gone, so they dump the cat in a street where she takes cover in a cardboard box, and eats scraps.
But one day she meets the Kafoopses trawling through the second hand shop. They take her home and call her Lara and here she stays, eating her bowl of crumbly biscuits, putting up with the sound of a bagpipe, staying on the roof to escape the noise, having friends over when the family goes out shopping, and roaming the nights, but always coming back to her own home where she is safe and loved.
Readers will love looking at Mckimmie's particular style of illustration, joining in with the fun on each page as Lara's life is outlined from being Misty, to Nigella to Lara.
Each page holds a fascination as people look at the details and work out how McKimmie produced that image. I loved reading the list on the publications page of the materials he used and readers will be able to look more closely to find where he has used each of them.
The background on each page, so redolent of city life, particularly Sydney adds another level of discussion for children reading the story. They will be heartened that Lara's early sad life ends happily with the Kafoopses and be satisfied that the cat's needs are now all met, reflecting perhaps on the plight of others, animals and people, discarded by society.
For older students a picture book like this will provide a platform for looking at incisive writing and illustration. Each time I read this book, I see another level of meaning, another small picture that I missed before, another piece of writing that makes my mind whirr. Teacher notes are available from the Allen & Unwin website.
Fran Knight

Dragon Rebels by Nazam Anhar

cover image

Lore of Fire Book 2. Amazon Digital Service, 2015.
(Age: 10-14+) Highly recommended. Dragon Rebels by Nazam Anhar continues the story of the boy Baran, from book 1 Dragon Hunter.
Baran was chosen by Hajur, a Dragon Warrior, to learn the ways of the dragon hunters after dragons viciously attacked his village in the first book.
Another villager, a girl named Tyan, had shadowed and then joined the pair to try to also become the first female dragon slayer in revenge for the death of her family.
Dragon Warriors must honour the call for help by answering the signal of the red smoke. This signal leads the trio to the city of Samara, where dragons have attacked and the outlying villagers have moved into the crowded city walls.
After meeting the king, it becomes evident the call for assistance had been answered earlier by a rogue group who kill dragons for payment. They have a dubious collection of members including several unsuccessful Dragon Warriors. Hajur is ineffective in recommending that the King and his councilors use only true Dragon Warriors so both groups have to work together.
The honourable Hajur is pitted against both the dragons and the rogue group and there is constant conflict and danger throughout the dragon battles but it is after the combat that the situation becomes even more dangerous.
The values, integrity and reputation of the Dragon Warriors and their principled behaviour are constantly clashing with the self-interest and baseness of the scoundrel dragon slayers.
Personally, Baran continues to struggle with the idea of becoming a Dragon Warrior and with his growing attraction to the young, valiant princess Alima.
This is an action book and the dragons never disappoint as a cold, deadly and persistent enemy. As stated in my review of book one, this story will appeal to fantasy readers especially dragon devotees.
10 to 14 + year olds will enjoy reading this novel themselves or listening to the story read aloud. I highly recommend this sequel, Dragon Rebels and book 1, Dragon Hunters and I hope there are more to come.
Jane Moore

The Porridge of Knowledge by Archie Kimpton

cover image

Ill. by Kate Hindley. Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBN 9781471402807
(Age: 8-10) Themes: Good and Evil, Magic, School Life. Milk lives with her Granddad in a small seaside town Slopp-on-Sea. She was found abandoned as a baby by the milkman and adopted by a a loving couple she calls Grandma and Granddad.  After her grandma passes away, she is left to look after her grandfather whose mind is going and he is often seen wandering around the town. When he discovers an old book with an unusual recipe THE PORRIDGE OF KNOWLEDGE things rapidly began to change in Milk's life.
Milk's school life is terrorized by her vindictive teacher Ms. Cerise, who sets an impossible maths test for the class and demands all the students study hard over the weekend. With Carp her friend and cafe owner, Milk decides to cook a batch of the special porridge. The ingredients are truly gross: dandruff, a pig's kidney, large limp limpets are added to the oatmeal and stirred. The resulting concoction is foul smelling and difficult to swallow, but amazing things happen when you do! Even the cafe ants who taste the goo become amazing builders making amazing replicas of the Leaning Tower of Pisa in mashed potatoes.
Milk becomes the cleverest person in town, Carp's restaurant becomes the mecca for bus tours wanting to taste the best food in town and even Grandpa changes from confused to normal behaviour. After tasting the porridge, the class answers every question correctly in the advanced Maths test.The porridge has a magical quality. Milk and Carp save the day when Mr. Blanket poisons the beach with toxic waste from his toothpaste factory.
This is a funny, quirky story quintessentially English, just enough grossness, suspension of belief and triumph of good over evil to engage the reader.
Rhyllis Bignell

Big book of Australian history by Peter Macinnis

cover image

2nd edition. National Library of Australia, 2015. ISBN 9780642278722
(Age: 8-Adult) Highly recommended. The 2nd edition of the CBCA Notable book Big book of Australian history will be a boon for teachers and school libraries as well as the avid history fan. Although this edition is a paperback it is sturdy and will prove to be an invaluable reference book for the researcher and a fabulous book to dip into for the casual reader who enjoys learning about interesting bits of Australian history.
The books covers the major sections of Australian history, starting with Ancient Australia, The Dreaming, Voyages of Discovery and continuing through early settlement, Federation, The Great Depressions and the world wars and culminating in a section about Embracing multiculturalism and On the world stage. The latter section of the book has been updated and the extensive piece on Cricket will be enjoyed by sporting enthusiasts.
The book is amply illustrated with original images that are held in the National Library. These have been carefully selected for their interest and historical relevance and greatly add to the reader's understanding of the history and social implications of the period. There is a page reference to them and the user can go to the National Library's website to get more details.
I love this book. Every time I open it I come across some fascinating bits of information that expand my knowledge and incite an interest in history and I am certain that it will do that for other readers as well
Pat Pledger

An ember in the ashes by Sabaa Tahir

cover image

HarperCollins, 2015. ISBN 9780007593279
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended. In the same vein of teenage dystopian novels that flooded bookshelves in the wake of The Hunger Games, comes another such novel, An ember in the ashes. One might be forgiven for thinking that this book is just another cheap attempt to cash in on the latest craze, but that person would be sorely mistaken, as this is a wonderful, highly engaging novel.
It tells the story of two people living very different lives in the same world; Laia, a Scholar-born girl, has lived in fear of the ruthless 'Empire' and its formidable soldiers since she was born. When her brother is taken by them, she has to enlist the help of the mysterious Resistance to get him back, but to do so she must first spy on the Commandant, the ruthless overseer of Blackcliff Academy.
Elias is in training to become a Mask - one of the Empire's most elite and dangerous soldiers - at the same Blackcliff Academy, but he is horrified with what he has had to do as a Mask-in-training and plans to escape. However, nothing goes to plan for either of them...
Sabaa Tahir has created an absolute gem of a book with An ember in the ashes - it rollicks along at a fierce, engrossing pace, yet never feels rushed; the characters are fully fleshed out and deeply intriguing; even the romantic tension between certain characters - which can often feel forced if done badly - feels realistic and captivating here. It's hard to find an authentic page-turner that also manages to be a smart read, but An ember in the ashes accomplishes it all. Apparently it became an instant New York Times bestseller upon its release in April, but that's no surprise - the book's exciting premise and broad appeal is perfect for both teenage and adult audiences. Thankfully, there is a sequel in the works, which will be released next year, but for now, I can't recommend this first instalment enough.
I highly recommend this novel.
Rebecca Adams