Reviews

Are you sitting comfortably? by Leigh Hodgkinson

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408864821
(Ages: 3-6) Reading. Books. Leigh Hogkinson's distinctive patterned illustrations take centre stage in this story about a young book lover searching for the perfect place to sit and read. On each page he is sitting on a chair, but the chair itself and the page background changes. The colour palette on each page also changes, with the background and the chair showing similar patterns and tones. The boy wants somewhere not too buzzy or too fuzzy, without hoots or giant stomping boots, not too grimey or slimey and not too hot or cold. Eventually he decides that it doesn't matter where he sits, any chair is fine, because 'A book is best anywhere... A book is best when you SHARE'
Varied fonts and font size add emphasis to the reading and makes the words look interesting and appealing to young readers.
Overall, this is short and simple, the rhyme is pleasing to the ear and the illustrations, featuring a cast of beautifully coloured animals, are quite striking. Book lovers will enjoy sharing this book about the joy of sharing a book! A perfect bedtime story.
Nicole Nelson

There is a tribe of kids by Lane Smith

cover image

Two Hoots (Pan Macmillan), 2016. ISBN 9781509812882
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Wordplay. Curiosity. Belonging. Adventure. Readers will be introduced to the words which signify a group of things through this imaginative and joyous book about finding where you belong. From the title page, readers will see the plural for a group of kid goats, tribe, and be encouraged to think about why this word suits the animal so well, although it also suggests another group which children may understand. As the young girl leaves the kids, she sees a penguin and this small motif at the bottom of the page heralds the animal that is overleaf. And sure enough, a group of penguins is called a colony. This delightful way of introducing the group word for many things in our plant and animal world will encourage thought and discussion amongst the readers. So we see a smack of jellyfish, an unkindness of ravens, a bed of clams, a turn of turtles amongst the twenty or so phrases, coming in full circle to a tribe of kids at the end, with not a goat in sight. Readers will ponder too, the use of past tense on all pages except the last. An enigma to get their teeth into.
Children will delight in seeing the words and what makes up these groups and see for themselves where they belong. The wonderful illustrations keep pace with the writing as each scene is depicted using mixed media: coloured pencil, oil and acrylic paint as well as digital imaging creating a mottled appearance to the pages. Each page will cause sighs and wonder from the audience as the images appear before their eyes. I can imagine a class trying out some of the methods themselves, using different group words after reading the book.
Fran Knight

The Special Ones by Em Bailey

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2016. ISBN 9781742976280
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. Cults. Abduction. Coming of age. Thriller. Esther is one of the Special Ones, four teens who live in an isolated farmhouse and who aren't allowed to leave. They are watched by an unseen man, who knows their every movement and who punishes them for the slightest transgression from their allotted roles. He broadcasts their lives to an eager following on the outside and they are forced to give advice that fits in with the personalities that have been given them. Will there ever be a chance for Esther to escape, or will she be renewed as others have before her?
This is a highly addictive read that will keep the readers glued to the page as they follow the fortunes of the four teens, the Special Ones. The story is narrated first in Esther's voice and the reader will find that a compelling one as she paints a horrific picture of how she and the other Special Ones have to behave in their non-toxic life. At the same time the reader is kept in suspense about what has happened to the children who have been sent away to be renewed and there is always the question mark hanging over Harry - why is he free to bring back new victims to replace those sent away? In the latter part of the book, the narration is in the voice of the man who holds them in the farmhouse, and it is a frightening portrayal of someone who appears to be very normal but who really is insane.
The portrayal of Esther's character was a highlight. The reader is taken through her life as a young teen who is forbidden to leave the house - the verandah is as far as she is allowed to go - to the formidable young woman who is determined to find the other children who have been sent away for renewal. Bailey clearly brings to life what it could be like for a victim to return home and face the endless media and questioning, but Esther manages to stay true to what she believes in.
This was a very clever, scary and challenging book that is sure to be popular with teen readers.
Pat Pledger

My mum's special secret by Sally Morgan

cover image

Ill. by Ambelin Kwaymullina. Omnibus Books, 2016. ISBN 9781742991368
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended, Australian animals, Aboriginal themes, Parents, and parenting, Kookaburra
An absolutely delightful rhythmical story of the love between a baby bird and its mother is told with bright gouache illustrations reinvesting the special bond between mother and child with a singular importance. Each page has the baby bird asking his mother a question, one which is answered on the next page. Children will love listening to the warm-hearted story being read to them and learn to predict the questions and answers as each uses the same format.
'Will we see the stars? Mum'
for example, is followed by
'My mum shows me the stars
through the leaves,
Twinkle, twinkle, twinkle'
Each one line question of five or six words is ended with the word, Mum, and the response is always one long sentence followed by three words describing the object, begging the child to repeat those words as they are read out. In this way the repetition becomes easy for children to follow and practice for themselves.
The communication between mother and her offspring, reinforce the maternal bond with a child, and reflect what parenting is about to the listener and reader. The last four pages add a little piquant to the mix as the format changes, encouraging the child to see the deeply reciprocal nature of the relationship between mother and child.
And of course the luminous illustrations teach the reader about the life of the kookaburra: where it lives, what it eats and how it survives in the Australian bush, giving another level of learning to this lovely book.
Fran Knight

Beetle Boy by M.G. Leonard

cover image

Chicken House, 2016. ISBN 9781910002704
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Darkus Cuttle's dad is missing. He has to live with his uncle, change schools, make new friends and work out why he can understand a huge rhinoceros beetle who has become his friend by chance. Thanks to this beetle (he names him Baxter) rescuing Darkus from some bullies, Darkus becomes Beetle Boy. Darkus knows his dad would never leave him so sets out with some help from his uncle and a lot of help from his new friends, Virginia and Bertolt, to find out what happened. Who knew it would lead to some amazing bugs and an amazing adventure.
Darkus encounters Lucretia Cutter, an avid bug collector and fashion designer as well as the antagonist for this story. She is willing to pay for the deaths of the amazing bugs Darkus has found and while he is trying to save them, uncovers another secret or two. Who is this Lucretia Cutter and does she know Darkus's dad? Was that a claw instead of a foot? Did Lucretia just try and shoot him? Does Lucretia hold the key to his dad's disappearance?
Beetle Boy is a wonderful story full of hope, adventure and total belief in one's father as well as oneself. The author has captured the everyday issues of a young boy who dares to be different and not conform to the expectations of the bullies while creating a wonderful mystery and adventure for any reader who loves bugs. It is highly recommended for readers aged 10+ but will especially appeal to boys.
Kylie Kempster

Australian Bushrangers series by Jane Smith

cover image

Big Sky Publishing, 2014
Captain Thunderbolt. ISBN 9781922132574
Ben Hall. ISBN 9781922132697
Captain Starlight. ISBN 9781922132710
Frank Gardiner. ISBN 9781922132673
Captain Moonlite. ISBN 9781922132581
Themes: Bushrangers; Australian History. This series is written in a simple style with some sidebar excerpts to fill in detail. The index would enable the text to be used by young students for research, but the books in this series are easy to read from cover to cover and could even become teacher-shared texts during a unit of work on early Australian History during the mid-1800s. Inferences about what life was like during this period could also be made (in connection with Year 5 Australian Curriculum History content.)
Captain Thunderbolt
This short biography and detail of the exploits of 'Captain Thunderbolt' (Frederick Wordsworth Ward) gives an overview of his life and his career on the wrong side of the law. Thunderbolt is represented as a 'gentleman' rogue who enjoyed support from the wider public despite his attempts to improve his own circumstances by thieving. Smith gives brief accounts of the chronology of his life and deeds and the book includes some evidence of Primary sources for the historical account.
Ben Hall
Ben Hall, another 'gentleman' bushranger, who despite being the child of ex-convicts, appeared to have a more promising future until he met up with the notorious bushranger Frank Gardiner. This book details the robberies of Ben Hall and the changing faces in his gang in the 1860s. The circumstances that led to his notoriety and the ultimate outcome of his life of crime are well detailed by the author, with sketches, primary sources and photographs used to illustrate the text.
Captain Starlight
This book focuses on two bushrangers, Frank Pearson and Harry Readford, who might potentially have inspired the character Captain Starlight from the Rolf Boldrewood book Robbery Under Arms (published in 1888 after first appearing as a serial in a Sydney newspaper). Both bushrangers were well read, and may have been successful if they had not sought an 'easier' route by breaking the law and attempting to make easy money via criminal means. Although the author does not speculate about society at the time, it is apparent from their crimes, that the two 'Captain Starlight' characters sought to exploit the wide and poorly policed areas of New South Wales and Queensland in the 1800s. The legal system also was well exploited by these lawbreakers. The author has made brief comparisons between Pearson and Readford, but has also indicated how they pursued their crime path in some detail.
Frank Gardiner
Frank Gardiner was notorious, leading a life of crime that involved theft, highway robbery and attacks on the police who came to arrest him. Mid-19th century life was tough in the rural regions of NSW, and even those who were attempting to live honestly were tempted to make their way by illegal means. The police were not well-respected because they represented the authority of the government which was a target for many who had come to hate taxes and their impoverished existence, and the added influence of convict heritage may have had its own impacts. Into this environment, the well-spoken and affable Gardiner (aka Christie) was easily able to draw a collection of the disaffected and pursue a career of crime. This book details his pursuits and explores why he was respected and protected by many of the local citizens of NSW despite his illegal activities. This is an interesting stand-alone book, but together with the rest of the series gives an insight into early life in the colony.
Captain Moonlite
Andrew George Scott became known as 'Captain Moonlite', who despite coming from a good family and having a religious background, ended up on the wrong side of the law. Scott was educated and had prospects for a career in the developing colony (after migrating from Ireland via New Zealand). A hold-up in the local bank implicated Scott and a pathway of lies and deceit revealed Scott as a complicated man with a tendency to performance. The web of intrigue tightened around him and his prison experiences impacted his life. He had a complicated and high view of his own opinions (he would defend himself in court with dramatic fervour and went on a speaking tour to promote prison reform) and was also able to convince others to follow his instructions. Although a 'gentleman', he was not as amiable in his approach as other bushrangers in this series and there could also be some conjecture about his mental stability and his possible homosexuality. The fact that jobs were hard to find for those who had served jail sentences created a desperation that led to his short-lived bushranging career which ended on the gallows. This book reveals a complex character and a complicated set of circumstances and although the social context is not examined in detail, gives hints about how bushranging became a choice for Captain Moonlite and his less well-known companions. This is perhaps less likely to be used as a read-aloud text for Year 5 students as part of the Australian Curriculum - the behaviour of Captain Moonlite is harder to fathom for a younger audience.
Carolyn Hull

Where's the starfish? by Barroux

cover image

Egmont, 2016. ISBN 9781405280082
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Hide and seek. Oceans. Fish. Pollution. A seemingly simple game of find the starfish, the clownfish and the jellyfish amongst the double pages bright with different colours, shapes and varieties of fish, soon turns into a subtle look at the pollution in our oceans as the fish, big and small, find that their habitat is being crowded out by the litter clogging their world. It starts small, with a bottle and can on the sea floor, but as each page is turned the mound of discarded rubbish grows, the number of fish lessens, until finally most of the fish have gone. Children will laugh at the ingenious solution reached by the whale to rid the sea floor of human rubbish, putting it back in their corner of the world, leaving their environment free. And they will be made more aware of the sort of rubbish that is tipped into the sea, or finds its way there through unthinking human activity. They will love spotting the fish, especially the three mentioned, as they keep turning up on most pages, and they will like looking at the variety and scope of the rubbish found in the sea.
Barroux found inspiration for the story when on one of his dives, he saw a plastic bag that he thought was a jellyfish. His illustrations will enthrall younger readers, using the Where's Wally style of search to get them hooked. A teacher could use this technique asking the children to find the three fish, starfish, jellyfish and clownfish, then spread the search wider to search for a telephone, a TV set, a washing machine and so on. And what a wonderful mobile could be made in the class using this story as its base.
Fran Knight

Nathalia Buttface and the totally embarrassing bridesmaid disaster by Nigel Smith

cover image

HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9780008167097
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. If the title Nathalia Buttface and the totally embarrassing bridesmaid disaster doesn't make you laugh then the hilarious events in the first 50 pages will! Nathalia doesn't want to be a bridesmaid in her stupid cousin's, who she really doesn't know, wedding and is trying hard to be removed as a bridesmaid. The humungous fairy dress is only one terrible part of the whole thing but worse is yet to come - meeting the other bridesmaids, going to the day spa, someone losing their hairpiece and getting a promotion to 2nd bridesmaid!
Nathalia Buttface is as hilarious as it is descriptive. Highly recommended for girls aged 9+. Every word leaves a funny image in your mind as you read about Nathalia's antics. Meet the bridegroom and his big personality. Watch Dad, the unorganised, organise a wedding. Can Nathalia, as the 2nd bridesmaid, uninvite uncle Ernie without hurting his feelings? How will Darius, Nathalia's best friend, get her out of this crazy wedding? Will Nathalia make it to the big day?
Kylie Kempster

The butcher's hook by Janet Ellis

cover image

Two Roads Books, 2016. ISBN 9781473625129
(Age: Adult - Mature readers) Georgian England. Gender roles. Sexual maturation. Violence. Murder. Grief.
This is not a Jane Austen-style gentle and romantic exploration of life in Georgian England, but the voice of the central character Anne is full of the pain of a young and intelligent girl who lives in a patriarchal world and lives with limited opportunity - except that offered by a man. The 'butcher's hook' catches her, whichever way it, or she, is turned, and as we read we feel the slow and inexpressible pain of powerlessness at the hands of others. Anne's early family life is scarred by the repeated loss of her siblings, either in miscarriage or early death, and there is a heaviness that pervades her family life. In a world before good medical knowledge and care, and even less psychological support for the grieving, we are led into a series of overwhelming situations and potential problems as Anne matures into a woman of marriageable age and attempts to independently explore her growing interests. Her intelligence was at one time fostered by a family 'friend', who displayed interesting methods of arousing her curiosity about the world, but his means of explaining her questions about life and birth change her direction for the future and awaken more than understanding. A connection to the local butcher's apprentice rapidly escalates, and her means of clearing her path to enable her desires to be fed reveals more than just her lust for the young lad. The story is tragic and macabre, and displays none of the lightness of an Austen tale.
The background of the Georgian world, with its distinct social and gender class separations and the mire of poverty always in the background, is a fascinating setting for this absorbing tale of the unfolding carnal and worldly sensibilities of an adolescent woman who transforms in a way that we wish we could halt. This is not a gentle coming-of-age book for teenagers. And for those who might be squeamish and a little uncomfortable in a 21st century butcher's shop, there is a raw and visceral unpleasantness in imagining the equivalent literary dismembering of life in the 1760s. The quality of the prose will keep you reading though, despite some unpleasantness along the route.
Recommended for Mature readers only. (Adult text)
Carolyn Hull

Grandma wombat by Jackie French and Bruce Whatley

cover image

Wombat series. Angus and Robertson, 2016. ISBN 9780732299590
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Wombats. Grandparents. Each day sees similar things happening in the lives of grandma and her grandson wombat. Sleeping makes up much of each day, but some days there are carrots to be had, or small naps to be made, or itches to scratch. While grandma sleeps more soundly her grandson watches the world go by. The kangaroo that hops over the pair sometimes wakes grandma wombat, but one day as grandma lies sleeping, the kangaroo's joey is replaced by the smaller wombat. He bounces away, taking a ride in the ute on top of the bales of hay, then onto the back of a motor bike, then into a parcel truck which delivers baby wombat to the airport. There he joins a rather startled looking group of skydivers and sits on one as they sail to the earth.
Once again he is back with grandma, sleeping, scratching and eating but with a little eye that looks out at the reader, sharing what he has done with the audience.
Grandma is impervious to her grandson's outing, saying what a well behaved grandson she has, but the audience knows what he has done, and laughs along with him and his loving grandma.
French's pared back text gives all that is needed, and the illustrations by Bruce Whatley add another level of humour to an already funny tale. This is the fifth in the series of books about wombats by these two and will be very welcome in all libraries.
Fran Knight

Granny's Place by Allison Paterson

cover image

Ill. by Shane McGrath. Big Sky Publishing. ISBN 9781925275636
(Age: 4-6) Highly recommended. Themes: Grandparents; Family Life; Australia - Social Life and Customs - Twentieth Century. Granny's Place is a nostalgic story that celebrates the loving relationship between a young girl and her grandparents. Memorable visits to the family farm are beautifully described; the simple joys of bouncing on the springy beds, sharing freshly baked bickies and cakes around the wooden kitchen table and stamping through carpets of pine needles. Packing up the farm and moving to the city after Pa's passing, brings new challenges. When Granny's welcomes the family to her purpose-built red brick bungalow, the mood changes, no pine needles, ducks, hens or geese, no shrieking metal gates. Granny's love is constant, she still bakes for her family and welcomes her grandchildren.
Shane McGrath's engaging illustrations encapsulate rural and city life in the 1960's. The evocative narrative is enlivened by the earthy palette of greens, reds and browns, energetic characters, detailed vignettes and large sweeps of white space that focus the eye. Take time to explore in the old mudbrick farmhouse, there's Pa's World War 1 memorabilia, the old pump organ ready to be played and treasures hidden in old suitcases.
Alison Paterson's sensory descriptions bring these warm memories to life. This is a delightful picture book to share with grandparents and great grandparents. A great resource for the Early Years History and Social Sciences, comparing how family life and places change over time.
Rhyllis Bignell

A very normal man by Vincenzo Cerami

cover image

Translated by Isobel Grave. Wakefield Press, 2015. This is an English translation of Un Borghese piccolo piccolo, 1976. ISBN 9781743053713
(Age: 17+) Highly recommended. Themes: Revenge; Italian Society; Purpose; Hope and hopelessness.
A Very Normal Man is a translation of the first novel of Vincenzo Cerami who is also renowned for his co-authorship of the screenplay for Life is Beautiful (La vita e bella) with Roberto Benigni. With the same deft touch, he lightly deals with a harsh topic as he tiptoes through the tragedy of a normal life that sinks to extreme measures to grasp at retribution for a terrible family disaster. At the beginning of this carefully crafted story we enter the humble circumstances of the central character and his less than stellar career as a civil servant. His pre-retirement drudgery is brightened by the prospect of providing more for his son than was possible in his own life. In order to facilitate this rise above drudgery and relative working servitude he is enticed to explore a position within the local Masonic charter and the reader sees the implicit corruption that follows. On the brink of hope for his son, tragedy falls and the 'Normal man' sinks into functioning despondency and a whirlpool of despair that drags him down and plants the smallest of seeds of revenge into the heart of the simple man. From this point the black tragedy of the normal life takes on a secret existence that is almost quirkily humourous, and yet is in essence, darkly evil. The heart of this story is to reveal the very easy path that a normal or average man might take in becoming the worst kind of man. There is irony in the title that this is not a 'normal man'; even though to the world he is a small, insignificant, 'good' man. To the reader who is capable of self-examination, there is an opportunity to consider their own hidden potential. The characterisation within this text is subtly revealed, but incredibly powerful.
The translation of this text has brought this cleverly crafted story to our attention and this is worthy of study, despite its macabre aspects, and the journey into Italy in the period post- 1969, with its potential for corruption at even the most basic level is intriguing.
Highly recommended for Mature readers aged 17+ (predominantly an adult novel, but accessible by younger readers.) Note: some macabre detail included - a 'black' text!
Carolyn Hull

Choosing Xaverique by Karyn Sepulveda

cover image

Vivid, 2016. ISBN 9781925442281
(Ages: 11+) Fifteen year old Gabby Valis has an ordinary life, just like any other. Until she is catastrophically hit by a swerving van, and her heart stops beating . . . at least, it does for several minutes. Gabby is a Xaverique, a non-human species who are bestowed with powerful abilities. A Xaverique's powers can be used for good or for evil, and it just so happens that the most powerful Xaverique to have ever lived, Zlanythe, is concocting a hideously evil plan that Gabby finds herself (and her newly awakened powers) tangled up in.
Gabby, and the love interest, Noah's relationship is unfortunately, completely insta-love. After knowing each other for only a few weeks, they are professing their love for each other. Yes, they are both teenagers but even teenagers do not fall in love that quickly. After their very first meeting, Gabby thought she was in love with Noah. This definitely impacted on my enjoyment of the novel.
A second issue I had with the novel was the length. At only 149 pages, insta-love is going to be imminent and the climax of the story seemed both rushed and anti-climactic. Choosing Xaverique definitely would have benefitted from being a longer novel and therefore having more time to explore the relationships of the characters and strengthen the storyline.
Unfortunately, the novel also proved to be predictable in some aspects. However, the ending, whilst it did not surprise me, left me interested to know what would happen next. Overall, Choosing Xaverique is an easy, quick and light read that young teenagers (who can handle mature content including descriptions of blood and injuries) can enjoy.
Breanne F. (Student)

Princess of the Sands by Karen Wood

cover image

TrickStars series, bk 6. Allen and Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781743319093
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Themes: Courage; Overcoming difficulties; Horse-riding; Television acting.
In this next instalment in the life of the TrickStar triplets - Ruby, Lexie and Kit, the girls become Television extras in an episode of Princess of the Stars. With the wonderful ponies who allow them to demonstrate their trick-riding skills (and their slightly magical) personal characteristics they also solve the problems of the main child star whose horse is causing problems in the shooting schedule. While this is a story about all the triplets, it focuses on Lexie's battles with overcoming her fears as well.
This is a gentle, easy chapter book for a young female audience who enjoy reading about horses, trick-riding and girls as they express themselves within a supportive family. The series is worthy of a place in a school library.
Highly recommended for aged 7+.
Carolyn Hull

Maresi by Maria Turtschaninoff

cover image

Red Abbey Chronicles. Pushkin Children's Books, 2016. ISBN 9781782690917
(Age: 12+) Highly recommended. Fantasy, Dystopian story, Women. Maresi is sent to the Abbey when her sister dies during the HungerWinter, her parents no longer able to feed her. Here her thirst for knowledge comes to the fore as she is able to go to the Knowledge House after she finishes her chores. Here she learns of the place where she lives, the Red Abbey, first settled by the sisters many generations ago, to protect them from the violent male dominated world outside. And she learns of the ancient skills and feels the power of the Crone, one of the three that make up the core of the Abbey, the Crone, the Rose and the Mother.
Her idyllic life is interrupted by Jai, a waif brought to the Abbey for protection, after a brutal father kills her sister. Her mother has risked death herself to get the girl away, and she finds peace within the walls, with Maresi to guide her.
But Jai's position within the walls attracts her father's revenge and he and his friends come to get her back, forcing the women to use the ancient skills to keep them all safe.
Allegorical in tone, the first in the The Red Abbey Chronicles impels readers to see parallels in their own world, the brutal nature of the world outside the walls similar to any regime which aims to keep women subservient, using brute power and fear to keep them repressed. The religious basis of the Abbey is fascinating again encouraging readers to see parallels with religions within their own communities. The island keeps out invaders, the walls and gates make impregnable with magic but Jai's father is more determined than most and the women must take greater risks in defending their island.
This is one of those reads that grabs you and drags you along, wondering what will happen next, all the while hoping they will survive. The background from the arrival of the First Sisters, setting up the Abbey and the way they live earning money from harvesting the bloodsnails, develops a strong base for the story.
Translated from Finnish, there are two more books to be published: one a prequel telling how the First Sisters set up the Red Abbey and the next, a sequel, showing Maresi out in the world. The Red Abbey Chronicles has been sold to thirteen countries, while an American publishing house has brought the rights to the trilogy for a six figure sum. The book has been awarded the Swedish YLE Literature prize for Young Adult works by a Swedish-Finnish author.
Fran Knight