Reviews

Rapunzel's revenge by Shannon Hale and Dean Hale

cover image

Ill. by Nathan Hale. Bloomsbury, 2008. ISBN 9780747587439
(Age 9+) Highly recommended. If you like feisty heroines, adventure and a touch of humour then the graphic novel, Rapunzel's Revenge is the book for you. In an unique take on the fairytale Rapunzel, Shannon and Dale Hale have produced a wonderful story about a girl who has lived in a walled castle with Gothel, the woman she thought was her mother. She has a happy life, learning rope tricks from the guards and swinging from trees. When she discovers that her real mother works as a slave in the mines and questions the evil Gothel; she is imprisoned in a hollowed-out room at the top of a tall tree for her insubordination. Finally she escapes using her long locks as a rope. And then her adventures begin as she sets off to rescue her mother and save the country from the cruel Gothel.

The authors haven't portrayed a beautiful princess waiting in her tower for the handsome prince to come and rescue her. Instead Rapunzel is a hair-toting cowgirl who uses her braids as lasso and whip and manages to outwit guards, outlaws and ornery old codgers out to get her. With her companion, Jack and his goose, she uses her long locks as a weapon to ward off evil doers.

Nathan Hale's illustrations are a visual feast that make the heroine come alive and give a vivid background to the story which is full of witty asides and laugh aloud humour. Combine this with a droll retelling of the fairy tale, lots of action and a touch of romance and you have a winning combination.
Pat Pledger

I'd tell you I love you, but then I'd have to kill you by Ally Carter

cover image

Cammie goes to the Gallagher Academy for Exceptional Young Women, but it's not your usual run of the mill elite school. On the curriculum is kickboxing, learning how to disarm bombs and plan covert operations. Yes! It's a school for spies. Cammie thinks she's got it all under control until she falls for a regular town boy, Josh. Action packed adventure follows with forbidden late night excursions, spying on the local townspeople, and keeping her cover as a home-schooled girl because the Academy isn't held in high regard in the town.

It is a light hearted spy adventure story but it contains enough strong themes to keep the reader interested. Cammie is a feisty heroine dealing with the trauma of her father's death and being in a school where her mother is the headmistress. The romance contains enough angst to move the story forward and there are great action scenes.

This is good escapist reading that girls will enjoy. Fans will be happy that there is a sequel, Cross my heart and hope to spy.

Themes Spies, School.

Pat Pledger

The resistance by Gemma Malley

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2008.
At the end of The declaration, the stunning thriller set in a dystopian future world where people take longevity pills and live forever, casting aside the need for children, Anna and Peter, two Surplusses, have escaped and joined the underground movement. But they are discovered, and Peter, the grandson of the company CEO which develops the pills, is taken in by him to join the company, Pincent Pharma Corporation. But Peter and Anna cannot forget their pasts, and so their new lives are entwined with the underground movement and the detractors of the new order.
The sequel, The resistance details their lives as they try to resolve what their next moves will be and work out who they can trust. Peter, working for his grandfather must sign the Declaration to prove his loyalty to the company. Anna on the other hand, at home caring for her baby brother, is befriended by a woman with photos of children, some of whom she knows. But where can they turn for help? Into this mix comes Jude, a computer nerd with attitude, intent on using his skills for the underground, but again, his plausibility wears thin, and even the underground movement does not trust him.
A creepily real world, the links to our world are everywhere; disenchanted children, poverty of the underclass, age denial, women cracking the glass ceiling because they do not have to take time out for child bearing and rearing, disapproval shown to people with children taking up more resources, energy crisis, disapproval of refugees and so on. Molloy has cleverly tapped into the 21st century spectres, and used them to weave a tale wholly credible and convincing, one that is hard to put down.
The climax sees all strands of this startling story come together, as Peter has been blackmailed by his grandfather to sign the Declaration in front of an audience, but the underground is in the building, causing havoc, with Jude hacking into the system to close it down, and Peter and Pip searching for the girls imprisoned upstairs for their stem cells. With all the adrenalin pumping bravado of a fast paced film, this is a story not to be missed.
There is an amazing rash of books around this theme at the moment. Readers will love the ideas and notions presented in these books, questioning medical experimentation and the use of stem cells and body parts. Books such as Unwind by Neil Shusterman, the prequel to this one, The declaration by Gemma Molloy, as well as The other side of the island by Allegra Goodman all expose a misuse of medical science.
Fran Knight

The trouble with dogs by Bob Graham

cover image

Walker 2007.
(Ages 3-7) A must for all dog lovers or for those who would like to own a dog, Bob Graham's sequel to Let's Get a Pup! is full of warmth and quiet humour. 'The trouble with dogs,' said Dad 'is that they take over your life.' With two dogs in the house Dad should know, especially as one of the dogs, Dave, is small and wild and exuberant. After many misadventures the family decides that Dave needs some training so they bring in the Pup Breakers. The Brigadier, a man with a loud voice and a choker chain, comes to help, but the family isn't sure that he has the answers.

The illustrations are gorgeous. With vibrant watercolour pictures, Bob Graham has brought the little family and its two dogs to life. Each person and animal is so well drawn that readers will feel that they know the characters. Mum has a tattoo and a nose ring; Dad lazes in a chair and little Rosie is very industrious. Rosie is so placid and little Dave is a dynamo of a dog that the reader can't help loving them both.

This is a warm hearted story that will resonate with dog owners and appeal to children because of the subtle messages that it sends about the joy of life and family love.
Pat Pledger

Ghostscape by Joe Layburn

cover image

Frances Lincoln, 2008.
(Ages 8+ ) Highly Recommended. This is a gem of a book - a short novel with a big impact. Modern day Aisha, a Somali girl finds herself face to face with 1940s schoolboy Richard when she travels back in time to war torn London during the Blitz. Aisha herself is no stranger to war. Her own father was killed by soldiers in her native Somalia and her relationship with her mother has clearly suffered as a result. School life is difficult too thanks to the school bully. Aisha is tough - she has to be, but meeting Richard gives her the possibility of friendship and the welcome relief of being looked after. When she discovers the horrifying events that took place in her school during World War Two she sets out to save her new friend and his grandfather from certain disaster.

Joe Layburn, himself a teacher, clearly understands children and schools. Ghostscape has a strong sense of place, but Layburn eases off on description in favour of plenty of action and dialogue. The link between Aisha's experiences and Richard's is understated and it is a clever ploy to connect the horrors that Aisha has witnessed with the turmoil of World War Two. The twist at the end will leave you with a lump in your throat.

In just over a hundred pages Ghostscape may not have the depth of Goodnight Mr Tom, or The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas but Layburn has created a story that will capture children's interest and give them plenty to think and talk about. I would promote this among able but reluctant readers.

Claire Larson

The minister for traffic lights by Tony Wilson and Andrew McLean

cover image

Lothian, $28.99 hb, ISBN 9780734408075.
(Ages 3-7) In a beautifully illustrated picture book, Tony Wilson has created a story about a warm and loving family. It has a most unusual theme: Dad is the government Minister for Traffic Lights but is never heard of because traffic lights 'hardly ever make the news'. He is obsessed with traffic lights and has six traffic light ties in red, green and amber; his house is decorated in the same colours and a flag of Cameroon hangs in the bedroom because it has the same colours as traffic lights. When road rage becomes a problem, Dad comes up with a new colour and law to solve the dilemma.

The strength of this book is its portrayal of family life. McLean has drawn a loving family with all the accoutrements of family living and a bespectacled father that many children will be able to identify with. There are pictures of Dad cuddling his two children on the couch, a messy living room with papers and socks littering the floor and even a cat drinking out of the toilet. Close examination of the illustrations with their touches of gentle humour will bring smiles to the faces of the reader.

The whimsical story, with its original premise, is not easily forgotten: Tony Wilson, on his website , says that it is 'a personal crusade to teach kids about the colour mauve and the way parliamentary bills enjoy passage into law'. It could also be useful when discussing careers and families with young children.
Pat Pledger

The fatal fire by Terry Deary

cover image

Terry Deary's Roman tales. A and C Black, 2008. ISBN 978071368970 9
(Ages 6-10) The Horrible Histories writer is now targeting younger readers with a series of short novels telling a fanciful story of some aspect of ancient times. In this, Mary, the slave to Master Tullus, is waiting for him to finish watching the games from which she is excluded. From her vantage under the table, she sees a familiar man throw a frying pan of fat against the wall setting it alight. She hurries to tell her master and together they flee Rome as the buildings burn around them. As he leaves she sees Nero, the emperor and recognizes his face as that of the arsonist.
A story which gives its readers a huge amount of information about Nero and his place in Rome's history, Deary speculates on how Rome began to burn, thus making Nero's plans to build a new palace able to be put in place. Deary gives the readers titillating facts about Nero's life and times, and by making Mary the focus of the story, allows the reader to empathize with the fate of some of the poorest of Rome's population.
Fran Knight

Nocturne by Diane Armstrong

cover image

Fourth Estate, 2008
ISBN 9780732284305
(Ages 14+) There is no doubt that Diane Armstrong has the ability to capture and hold the reader engrossed, as she relates her story of courage and cruelty set in one of the most horrendous periods of our history. The overall quality and design of this paperback, with good sized print, makes reading this 560 page book fairly easy. Readable with a clear continuity of plot and setting, Armstrong brings us a story which remains embedded in our memories.

Nocturne is based on historical events which took place during and immediately after the Second World War. Part 1 takes the reader from the start of war in Poland to the end of the Warsaw Ghetto uprising, with the heroine Elzunia emerging safely, after losing most of her family and so many of her friends to the Nazi onslaught.  She has met Adam, a young Polish pilot, at the beginning of the war - indeed he rescues her in an ambush - and it is this memory which drives her ambition to make it through to the end of the war. In Part 2, Adam, now a valuable member of the Resistance, goes to London to petition for help, meeting words of acknowledgement and empathy, but not action on the part of the Allies. In the final section of the novel the two characters meet after months of hardship and adversity.

Armstrong is the author of two powerfully written non-fiction works and a novel, Winter Journey, each based on Polish history and heritage.
She brings to Nocturne, a wealth of meticulous research, part of her family's background and stories of real players in this country's past.

There is a strong sense of political feeling running through the novel - Armstrong believes that all nations denied the Jews in Poland their freedom, closing their eyes to the unfolding disaster.  She explores this issue, revealing to her readers the courage and independence of a people determined to fight for freedom. The world of the Ghetto is real, and we become emotionally involved in the lives of its inhabitants.  The human qualities of loyalty, bravery, sacrifice and endurance emerge as the people face insurmountable odds.  

At times the language is clumsy and overly wordy - it may be that Armstrong is better placed as a writer of memoir, for she frequently includes historical details in the narrative which seems contrived; however, the strong sense of place and authenticity of subject excuse her from this weakness.

Here too is a valuable addition to the field of reads for 'connected texts' work in Years 11 and 12.
Julie Wells

If you're reading this, it's too late by Pseudonymous Bosch

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2008
(Ages 10+) Highly recommended for boys and girls. Part of The Secret Series with a third title promised shortly, this book follows The Name of this Book is Secret. Cass the survivalist and Max Ernest, her faithful side-kick, partner up again; this time to search for an ancient terrifying creature - a homunculus. Cass is the keeper of the Sound Prism, a role which both mystifies and excites her. The dangerous Ms Mauvais and evil Dr. L relentlessly pursue them both, resulting in some very exciting chases and captures.

While not essential that the first in the trilogy be read, the continuity between the two books works well. One becomes accustomed to the intrusions of the narrator as he keeps an ever present eye on the young ones, frequently commenting on the action and probable resolutions. This interaction provides extra opportunities for negotiating the storyline, and adds great humour to the story. This style reminded me a little of Lemony Snicket's voice in The Series of Unfortunate Events.

The plot is fast-paced throughout, with a wonderful range of entertaining, likeable characters and wicked, criminal types. The action is tightly controlled with a good feel for place. We follow Cass and Max-Ernest from home to school, to the Magician's Museum, and to sharks at sea; followed by camp sites to graveyards - it's all part of finding the secret!

This is a most enjoyable read, and bound to appeal with its action-packed episodes and author interjections.
Julie Wells

Coraline by Neil Gaiman

cover image

Adapted and illustrated by P. Craig Russell. HarperCollins, 2008.
Highly recommended. I came to the graphic novel adaptation of Coraline with trepidation as I had enjoyed the original so much. Could the illustrated version match up to the story that lingered in my mind? Would pictures enhance the story or spoil the images from my imagination? Would it be able to send chills up my spine? The answer is yes to all three questions. It is a totally engrossing and powerful read that will captivate the reader who comes across it first, and enhance the experience for those who have enjoyed the novel.

Coraline is an intrepid heroine who discovers a strange door in her new home when exploring. She opens it and enters an alternative world, with an 'Other mother' and 'Other father'. At first she enjoys 'all the remarkable things in there she'd never seen before' but eventually decides to go home. However, her 'Other mother' is evil and when Coraline's real parents disappear into the other world she decides that she must try and rescue them. What an adventure she has!

Russell's illustrations perfectly complement the story. Coraline is portrayed realistically as an ordinary girl dressed in shorts or jeans. This contrasts with the horrendous pictures of the black button eyes of the people, and the red eyed rats that inhabit the 'other world'.

There are enough thrills to please the fans of horror. It is great to see a feisty heroine discovering that being courageous is doing something when you are really scared, and then having the ability to come up with brilliant and tenacious solutions to her problems.
Pat Pledger

The way of the warrior by Chris Bradford

cover image

(Young Samurai 1) Puffin, 2008.
What an unusual but original book! No wonder it has been long listed for the Carnegie.
I picked this up because I was lucky enough to meet the author recently, and as I used to play Judo, we began to chat. His book sounded so interesting that I bought a copy as soon as I could lay my hands on one, and have since bought a few more!
Jack is the only survivor when a group of Ninja pirates attack his dad's ship. He is taken in by Masamoto Takeshi, and, after saving his son's life, is treated as his son, and sent to warrior school. However, he's an outcast there, and his new 'brother' treats him in the same way as all the other students - as a foreigner, someone who cannot be a real warrior, and give him a hard time.  However, Jack brought something with him from the ship. Something the ninjas are trying to get hold of and will quite happily kill for. Can Jack keep hold of his 'treasure' and finally win the respect of his peers?
This book is brilliant, and teaches you much of Japanese culture and martial arts. It's a story that mixes fiction and history together beautifully. Book 2 is already being advertised on his website, and the trailer for book one is absolutely awesome!
Nikki Heath

The sweet life by Rebecca Lim

cover image

When I was given the book to read, I thought that it would just be like all the other books aimed at teenage girls, but as soon as I started to read the novel, it had a really intense story line about a girl growing up, drastic changes and tragedies she had to face and learning to trust people. Right from the beginning, although I started with a negative approach, it had me intrigued and I really had no idea where the story line was going, it kept me guessing and I honestly couldn't put it down. It was intense and the way that the book was written, it really gave you details in a way that gave you the ability to really feel as though you were there, feeling the intensity of her situations.
The story line was really in depth and because of my age was one I could really relate to, especially when she was out travelling the world alone.
Bec White, student

Themes Cyberbullying, Friendship, Stalking.

Necropolis by Anthony Horowitz

cover image

Walker, 2008.
This book seems a long time coming, but boy, was it worth the wait! It continues the tale of Matthew Freeman and the Guardians, a good versus evil saga that began 4 books ago.
The last of the Guardians is discovered in the shape of Scarlett, a year 11 girl, who is totally unaware that she has powers and that people are trying to kill her, until she goes through a door into another world and goes 'missing' for almost two days. Once both sides become aware of her and who she is, there's a  race to get to her - but will Matt and crew beat the Old Ones? Why are they trying to lure the Guardians to Hong Kong and can they do anything to halt the horror and destruction that awaits them? Read on to find out, and prepared to be reading by torchlight as this is one book you will NOT want to put down!
Nikki Heath

My candlelight novel by Joanne Horniman

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2008.
(Age 15-18) This novel is written as a companion to Secret Scribbled Notebooks and gives an insight into the life of a teenage single mother and the challenges that face her in her quest for a life of her own.

Sophie lives in a boarding house with her sister Kate and Lil, the woman who took them in when their mother and father could no longer cope. She has an almost one year old daughter Hetty. When Kate heads to university Sophie decides to continue her education and because she has a love of books enrols in a literature course at a local university. The novel explores the people Sophie meets and the experiences she has as she ventures back into the wider world having been sheltered from it whilst caring for Hetty.

The novel is written in two parts and although not equal in length help the reader to explore in greater depth Sophie's life and experiences.
Tracy Glover

The First Escape by G. P. Taylor

cover image

(Dopple Ganger Chronicles 1). Saltriver, 2008.
WOW! WOW! WOW! This is such an amazing book!!
The story itself is fabulous - mischievous twins Saskia and Sadie Dopple cause chaos yet again at Isambard Dunstan's school for Wayward Children and are split up, seemingly forever. One is sent to live with Muzz Elliott, a woman who doesn't seem to be very nice at all, whilst the other is left behind at school. Upon arrival at her now 'home' Saskia discovers that previous children have disappeared. It turns out that Muzz Elliott has an evil twin, thought dead, and that there is some long 'lost' treasure hidden somewhere in the house. However, her evil twin sister isn't dead at all, and has infiltrated the house, working with the staff, intending to find the treasure, murder the nice twin and take her place. Meanwhile, Sadie, along with Erik, the dogsbody at the school, escape, and set off to rescue Saskia. Sounds great, eh?
The story itself is fantastic, but what really complements this book it its layout. It's a 'marmite' book - you will either LOVE it or HATE it. (I'm sure which side I'm on, which is strange as I HATE marmite!)
Every page is set out differently. The pages all have a black edging to them, and you get a mixture of words, pictures, some black and white, some colour, and then you'll have a few pages of MANGA like drawings, then back to words. Some swirl, some fall, and some are white on black. It's as fascinating as the story itself, as you genuinely do not know what you will get when you turn the page. The text is at the same level as that of the Philip Pullman's Northern Lights series, yet it's accessible by ever the most reluctant of readers due to the way your eyes dance all over the page! The layout has been deliberately been designed to be dyslexia friendly.
How popular has it been in my library? Well, I bought my own personal copy after meeting the author last month. I read it on the hour long journey home. I took it into school to show a few of the students and had 10 reservations for it within 30 minutes. So I am now lending out my own copy to keep up with demand.
Nikki Heath