Reviews

If I were you by Richard Hamilton

cover image

Ill. by Babette Cole. Bloomsbury, 2008. ISBN 9780747552499
(Ages: 4-8) Recommended. Hamilton has written an amusing, affectionate tale of a father-daughter relationship that is not to be missed. Daisy is all tucked up in bed and weary Dad says 'If I were you, I'd snuggle down and go to sleep.' This sets Daisy imagining what it would be like to change places with her father. She dresses him in a pink tutu, feeds him porridge and then gives him a ride in her stroller down Main St. She does all the things that she likes such as eating chocolate fromage frais and going to the zoo. In turn, Dad decides that he can watch TV and play while Daisy does the household chores. What does Daisy think of this exchange?

The rhyming couplets are very enjoyable and will have young children predicting what will come next. Hamilton has Daisy and her father using language that they would have heard each other use like Daisy telling her father that she will take him to the zoo if he 'were very, very good'. This appealing style keeps the story rolling along.

Babette Cole's illustrations are a delight. Children will find the pictures of a stubbled-faced Dad, with his hairy chest and skinny legs sticking out of a pink tutu, really amusing. Daisy is portrayed as a happy-go-lucky little girl who enjoys having fun. The small, often humourous details in the pictures such as the plump cat and untidy toys add a lovely dimension to the story and attentive children will gain endless pleasure looking at them.

This book with its zany illustrations and great rhythm would be great fun to read aloud and a follow up activity could be to have the children decide what they would do if they changed places with their father or mother and how their parent might behave as a child.
Pat Pledger

30 Australian sports legends by Loretta Bernard and Gregory Rogers

cover image

Random House, 2008. ISBN 978174166286 3
(Age 10+) In 30 short chapters, Loretta Bernard gives bite sixed chunks of information about sports and their participants in Australia. Supported by a sound index with an easily read contents page and illustrations by Gregory Rogers, the book will find a place in primary libraries where students will want to read about sports and sportsmen and women, either for class work or leisure.
Each chapter gives a potted history fo the sport at hand. In the chapter on hockey, for example, is a paragraph detailing where Australian hockey stands in the world, followed by a summary of their success at the Olympic Games. Several paragraphs outlining specific hockey players then follow, and the chapter is finished off with snippets of information which younger readers would find interesting.
With chapters on AFL, hockey, paralympics, speed skating and sailing, there is enough information for most students. Whether they be reading for information or just using the book at home to dip in for interest, the book will please many.
Fran Knight

The curious case of Benjamin Button by F. Scott Fitzgerald

cover image

HarperCollins, 2008.
(Ages: 10+) Poor Benjamin Button was born an aged man, much to the embarrassment of his parents, living in Baltimore in the 1860's. His father did not know what to do with this stooped, 70 year old with a long straggly beard, hobbling beside him. Passing the slave market he thought he should sell him, but he took him home instead. As father aged, Benjamin became younger, and at a ball in 1880, he saw a woman and fell in love. She accepted his proposal, despite the loud cries from those around him, but she wanted an older wiser man, not realising that Benjamin, looking 50, was really 20. Initially successful, their marriage became strained when Benjamin became more agile and youthful looking as she aged. Tied to a docile wife, he joined the American army and served in the Spanish American War, where he was decorated for bravery. Returning home, he was faced with the sad realisation that his wife no longer cared for him, so he attended university, but as his brain became younger, so did his attention span and his ability to take in new ideas. Eventually he went to school, then kindergarten, and finally was cared for by a nanny.
An unusual short story by one of the world's greatest writers, this tale turns the normal progression of man on its head. As he gets younger, Benjamin experiences the sorts of things younger men experience, but the reader sees it all from a totally different perspective. There are digs at American society along the way, prejudice, social climbing, disparity between old and young, universities, self made millionaires. Fitzgerald quietly mocks some of the accepted institutions and precepts as he looks at youth and age.
This handsomely produced hardcover, designed to intrigue and delight the readers of the 70 odd pages, has been published to coincide with the release of the film.
Fran Knight

Tales of terror from the Black Ship by Chris Priestley

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2008.
(Ages: 11 +) Recommended. I'm so relieved that I read this before buying it for my primary school library. This is definitely NOT suitable for primary children and even at 11+ I would add a proviso that it's not for the sensitive or faint-hearted. I feel the front cover is a little deceiving: depicting two small children holding hands and looking rather anxious and with a cartoon spider hovering overhead. I predicted something fairly innocuous - nothing could be further from the truth. However with the age caveat in mind, this is a fantastic book and Priestly the master of terror.
Set during an unspecified time in history when smugglers and pirates abound, Ethan and Cathy are unwell. Their widowed father has set off to fetch the doctor and during his absence both children suddenly feel better and are able to welcome a mysterious visitor to the coastal inn where they live. To while away the time the stranger spins them a yarn, and then another, and then another. Each chapter is a complete story in itself, ideal for a ghostly bedtime read. The tales he tells are full of menace, all the more so because they are about the everyday turned foul - the terrible repercussions of a child's laugh, the horror of flesh eating snails. There's a fair bit of gore and plenty of sinister suggestion that will leave many readers feeling unsettled, this one included!
The true identity of Ethan and Cathy and their mysterious visitor is revealed in a marvellous twist. This is traditional, eerie storytelling at its best. Priestly does not talk down to his readers and I had to use the dictionary more than once to look up an unfamiliar word.
Just one further point, I have always been against the idea of 'recommended ages' being printed on books, but I think somewhere on this book should be a warning that younger readers may be frightened by the content, or perhaps I'm just reinforcing the nanny state? I would be interested to know what other readers think!
Claire Larson

The boy who could fly by Laura Ruby

cover image

HarperCollins, 2008. ISBN: 9780007210107
(Age 10+) Sequel to The wall and the wing, this is another original fantasy set in New York. Gurl is now living with her long lost parents, The Richest Couple in the Universe, and her friend Bug is busy making advertisements and doesn't seem to have time for her. Gurl's classmates at the posh school make her life a misery, and she can't even turn invisible to get away from them because she has promised her parents not to use her skill. But when a vampire appears outside her window, Gurl just has to do something!
There is action and adventure galore in this off-beat story. A fearsome octopus and a giant sloth are two of the fabulous monsters that Gurl and Bug have to contend with, as well as a strange artist called the Chaos King and scary vampires. While all the action is going on, Gurl, or Georgie as she is now known, has to contend with the rich bullies in her class, and yearns for her old friend Bug who seems to be totally engrossed in gaining publicity for himself.
Ruby has combined an engrossing mix of adventure and an insightful look at the meaning of friendship and the complexities of being rich and famous.
Pat Pledger

Cookie by Jacqueline Wilson

cover image

Random House, 2008. ISBN 9780385613972
(Age 10+) When Beauty's father becomes even more abusive and critical of the girl and her mother, Dilly, the pair decides to leave their 'happy home'. Dilly and Beauty have put up with derision and nastiness all their lives with Mr Cookson, the owner of a development company. He treats them as if they were his servants, expecting Beauty to live up to the name he gave her, expecting Dilly to be the subservient wife and mother he needs to advertise his houses. All should be happy, to parallel his ads, but it is not. Beauty would dearly love a pet, and when a friend gives her a rabbit for her birthday, her father leaves the hutch open and the bunny is killed.
Mr Cookson is unrelenting in his victimisation and bullying of his small family, and this all comes to a head at Beauty's birthday party, where her class mates, invited by her father, see his behavior first hand. The girls from the private school her father insisted she attend, reflect Beauty's father's bullying, and it is a relief to her when she and her mother leave.
I found the constant bullying overwhelming, and it was a relief to me when the pair reached the sea, and fell under the wing of a kindly older man for whom Dilly began to work. The story resolves itself happily and will be most pleasing to the readers to see the girl and her mother finally develop some independence. Beauty and her mother are almost indivisible in their lives with Mr Cookson, and while younger readers will sympathise with Beauty, older readers will feel for Dilly, a young woman who relied on her attractiveness to marry almost as soon as she left school, rather than develop her talents.
Fran Knight

Sleep tight, my honey by Lisa Shanahan

cover image

Ill. by Wayne Harris. Hachette, 2008.
(Ages: 3+) Alice is a gorgeous bunny, but she just won't go to sleep at nights. Lily and Monty do everything they can think of to get her to sleep. They consult Grandma who advises them to sing a lullaby, Tortoise, who suggests putting her into a shell, and Possum who thinks she needs a big hairy pouch. Butterfly believes that a cocoon would do the trick and Bat is convinced she needs to sleep upside down. Nothing works, until Lily finds the perfect solution!
Young children who have a baby in the house will know about the noise that can keep everyone awake at night. Shanahan has written a story with a memorable refrain: 'Sleep tight, my honey, You gorgeous bunny'. Children will enjoy repeating this as well as making the crying Waaa waaa noises that baby Alice makes. Along the way they will incidentally learn about the nocturnal habits of many animals.
The illustrations by Wayne Harris are a delight, with beautiful lavender, blue, yellow and pale orange colours. Alice has an engaging grin on her little face during the day and a wide-open mouth to show her displeasure about being left alone at night. The Rabbit family is portrayed as a warm and caring extended family, where love is very evident.
This is a book that pre-schoolers will enjoy, and that adults will love to read aloud.
Pat Pledger

Heir to Sevenwaters by Juliet Marillier

cover image

PanMacmillan, 2008.
(Age 15+) Recommended. What a thrill to find a new book, which can be read as a stand alone, from the Sevenwaters series. It comes after the books, Daughter of the forest, Son of the shadows and Child of the prophesy. If this is the first book that a reader tries from Marillier, its strong storyline, courageous heroine and wonderful setting of medieval Ireland and the Otherworld will be sure to entice the reader to sample more from this author.

This is the story of Clodagh, the third daughter of the lord of Sevenwaters. She a practical, domesticated young woman who supervises the household when her ageing mother is pregnant. At her sister's wedding celebrations, she meets taciturn Cathal, who guards many secrets. When her infant brother is replaced with a changeling creature and Cathal disappears, she must gather together all her courage and determination to rescue her brother from the Fair Folk.

Clodagh's talents appear to be ordinary but when she has to act, her selfless love gives her the ability to be brave and to find a way into the Otherworld, the kingdom of the amoral king, Mac Dara. She is willing to find a way to help the lonely Cathal, and to see beyond his curt manner and difficult childhood. In an interview Marillier talks about the big themes of love, loyalty, courage, faith, honour, which all abound in this book.

I couldn't put Heir to Sevenwaters down: I was so engrossed in the emerging characters of the book, its forest setting and the sheer adventure and peril that faced Coldagh and Cathal. I loved the story of the changeling, Becan, the love that Clodagh had for him, and the developing romance between Coldagh and Cathal with all its difficulties and misunderstandings. Marillier's flowing language brought her world to life for me, and I hope that there will be more books in this series.
Pat Pledger

The wanderings of Odysseus by Rosemary Sutcliff

cover image

Frances Lincoln Children's Books, 2008.
ISBN 978 1 84507 828 7
(Ages 10+) This reprint of Rosemary Sutcliff's retelling of The Odyssey will have new followers as the readers dip into the stories they may have heard or tales of names that are vaguely familiar. The Odyssey tells the story of Odysseus as he and his men returned to Ithaca after the Trojan Wars. The men have not seen their families for ten long years, years which have taken their toll on their friends and allies. The 15 stories presented here include many that are familiar, Cyclops, the Enchantress, and the Isle of the Dead, for example, but many are not so familiar and will thrill readers anew.
Sutcliff, who died in 1992, was an award winning writer of historical fiction, and this book underlines why she was held in such high esteem. The writing is flawless, uncomplicated and flowing. Even when the reader knows some of the story, it is like reading it anew. Sutcliff adds gravity and a world view in her retelling which gives the reader a wider perspective of the tale at hand.
Fran Knight

Nyuntu Ninti (What you should know) by Bob Randall and Melanie Hogan

cover image

ABC Books.
(Age: Primary school) A stunning book of photographs for younger children, Randall shows how the Anangu people of Uluru related to their land as he was growing up. The book was produced in conjunction with a documentary film, Kanyim, an Aboriginal word which ties love and responsibility. These twins of life in the desert ensured that the land was cared for and now Randall is hoping that the negative attitudes of today can be erased with Aboriginal and non Aboriginal people working together showing love and responsibility for their environment.
Each double page spread shows an old photograph, taken a generation or two ago, paralleling the culture today. So we have a wonderful photo of an arid landscape coming alive with everlasting daisies, small shrubs and trees after some rain has fallen, while on the next page is a group of children taken several generations ago, showing how they use part of the land. Further on, an older picture of an Aboriginal family digging under a tree for food, is contrasted with a photo of Bob Randall holding some grubs and wild peach that he has collected. Today and yesterday are again contrasted. Each page shows the reader in some way about the struggle for existence then and now, and makes the dedicated reader look more closely at the land on which these people lived.
The book, with Randall's simply wise words on each page underlines the ancient culture that is at the heart of Australia, and impels those who spend time reading and thinking about the book, to seek a better future for all.
Fran Knight

Bog Child by Siobhan Dowd

cover image

David Fickling Books, 2008.
(Ages: 12+) Fergus is 17, in the middle of A-Levels and with his heart set on a place at Aberdeen University to study medicine. The only problem is that real life keeps getting in the way - namely his brother Joey's prison sentence at The Maze for his involvement with the IRA. Joey's decision to embark on a hunger strike in support of Bobby Sands and other 'prisoners of conscience' has a huge impact on Fergus and his family. Set in the Irish border town of Drumleash, Bog Child is the story of Fergus' incredible discovery, his first love affair and his desperate attempt to save his brother from starvation.

At first I was unsure how the discovery of a 2000 year old body, protected by the peat marsh, would link with an account of IRA activity and the troubles, but Dowd effortlessly weaves Fergus's incredible find with his anguish and fear for his brother. In an attempt to persuade the IRA to call off the hunger strike Fergus agrees to work for them, transferring small, anonymous packages across the border. As a keen mountain runner he can do this easily. During his fell runs Fergus meets Owain, the young Welsh soldier manning one of the border crossings, and the two form an uneasy friendship. Indeed both Owain and Fergus are called in to help move the Celtic body discovered in the peat.

Fergus christens the young girl he finds Mel and the gradual uncovering of her tragic story connects the reader to Joey's situation. I felt a little uneasy that Dowd was drawing parallels with Mel's plight to that of Bobby Sands and other hunger strikers. Memories of the Enniskillen, Omagh and Warrington bombings will still be raw for many people, but that is perhaps the greatest strength of Dowd's novel. She reminds us of the human cost of intense belief - people willing to die of starvation for a cause, and their mothers, fathers and brothers who have to suffer the anguish and bitterness that this involves.

There are flashes of humour. Fergus's discovery of the content of the packages he has been transporting for the IRA must be one of the most unexpected and funniest I've read in a long time.

As we have come to expect from Dowd this is a brilliant story, emotional but sparing, humorous yet brimming with anguish. However, I do wonder how today's teenagers will view a novel set during a period of history they will probably know little about. Will they truly understand the strength of feeling the Maze prisoners experienced? Perhaps thanks to the energy and power of Dowd's writing they will. This is a fascinating story with characters that leap off the page. Try it with your keen, sensitive readers. They are certainly in for a treat.
Claire Larson

High crime in Milk Bay by Moya Simons

cover image

Walker Books, 2008 ISBN 978 1 921150 60 1
(Ages 10+) The second in the series, The Walk Right In Detective Agency, has David and Bernice intrigued by the new family which has moved in across the road form David's house. It seems a little bizarre that David saw a child when the family moved in, but on enquiring at the house, was told no child existed. His antenna works overtime.
In the meantime, Bernice and David have been asked to find Mr Butterworth's missing goats, find out who has been pinching the flowers in the municipal gardens, and try and work out who gave Cherry a note asking her to the dance. All makes very funny reading, and when most crimes seem to dissolve into each other, the detectives easily solve the case.
Upper primary readers will enjoy the thrill of the chase, and see the clues left by the author for the reader to arrive at the conclusion along with David and Bernice, although sometimes, they will beat David and Bernice to the end. A solid, funny and well written series, the distinctive covers will make the set easily recognizable. Fran Knight

Tamburlaine's elephants by Geraldine McCaughrean

cover image

Usborne, 2008.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. This reissue of the wonderful Tamburlaine's elephants in a paperback edition will encourage many more students to read this highly accessible historical story about two boys meeting in the heightened tension of Tamburlain's sweep across Asia. The warrior, Rusti, is determined to be the best warrior in the army, facing the enemy with determination and grit, until he meets an elephant, and the elephant's keeper, Kavi. Both boys learn new things about themselves as their lives intertwine, and their need for survival is paramount.
An incredibly exciting story, based on impeccable historic research, Tamburlaine's elephants will give the reader an insight into the armies of the Mongol invaders, and the use of elephants, and their training. And in the background; Kavi's marriage to his sister in law, the way armies moving across the landscape, the unbelievable organisation of these armies, the descriptions of the cities of the past, contrive to make the story seem absolutely real.
Fran Knight

Themes India - History, Friendship, War, Elephants.

Fred the croc by Matt Zurbo and Sarah Dunk

cover image

Hachette, 2008. ISBN 976-734410856
(Ages 5 -7) Fred, the show-off crocodile, decides that the attention from his adoring tourist audience who throw him peanuts and dead chooks isn't enough, so he snaps up two of them, leaving only a camera and a cap. The picture in the camera is developed and Fred is an instant success, with a TV spot, sports nights and ads. Eventually he becomes old news. What can he do to get back into the limelight?
The story flows along with plenty of zip to captivate a young audience who will delight in the evil antics of Fred and his many ways of getting attention. They will also appreciate the underlying theme of fame, how fickle it can be and what some people will do to achieve it.
Children will delight in the bright and colourful illustrations in this book, particularly the pictures of Fred's open mouth as he goes to chomp on his victims.
This is a great read aloud book. It is a lot of fun to listen to and look at, and has the added advantage of a theme to make young minds think.
Pat Pledger

A brief history of Montmaray by Michelle Cooper

cover image

Random House Australia, 2008.
(Ages 13+) Sophie Fitzgerald lives on the tiny island of Montmaray in a dilapidated castle. Hers is a small tight knit community. Her parents are dead, her uncle, King John is mad. Together with her 17 year old cousin, Veronica, who has been forced to take on the responsibility for the kingdom, and her sister Henry, who is a tomboy, she has to contend with a strange life. Contact with the outside world is restricted to letters from her aunt and brother in England, and occasional visits from Simon, the housekeeper's son. When Sophie receives a journal for her 16th birthday, she decides to keep a record of what is happening in her life. It is 1936 and things are changing in the world. When two strangers appear on the island, Sophie is forced to recognise that life is changing around her.

This is definitely a book that girls will enjoy. The romantic setting of a crumbling castle and decaying ideals of royalty will appeal as will the picture of an isolated family life, where the young girls have had to grow up with no real parental supervision. The characters are memorable, and the reader will become engrossed in the life that Sophie describes as well as the hints of danger and adventure.

The device of using the entertaining and descriptive journal entries of the fanciful Sophie gives the reader an easy and enjoyable entry into her eccentric family life. A picture of the decay of the castle, and the difficulties of receiving anything from the outside world because of the dangerous sea entry are all vividly brought to life. The book also contains literary references and quotes from such classics as Pride and Prejudice and The Tempest. These add an depth to the story and will appeal to those who love to read.

The historical background of the Nazi regime, Hitler and Mussolini also raise interesting issues. Reading group discussion questions at the end of the book look at truth and wisdom, the Spanish Civil War and the options for women.

The unusual blend of history and the romantic setting, combined with the coming of age of Sophie, will be sure to appeal to appeal to girls who want an imaginative and thoughtful read.
Pat Pledger