Reviews

Fool's girl by Celia Rees

cover image

Bloomsbury, London, 2010. ISBN 9781408803325.
(Age 12+) Historical. Recommended. When Feste and Violetta arrive in London, finding refuge with Sir Toby, now fallen on hard times, they seek out Will Shakespeare and begin to tell him their tale. Feste is taken on by Will to replace the clown now gone over to the Rose, but not before they get Will to promise to help them in return. The time is about 1600, Will is making his name in London at the Globe Theatre, Queen Elizabeth 1 is on the throne of England, with the remarkable Robert Cecil as her secretary and master spy. Violetta and Feste have escaped Illyria, now in ruins, a haven for pirates attacking Venetian traders.
For Shakespearean buffs, the names Violetta and Feste will spark remembrances of the play, Twelfth Night, but for those not familiar with the play, they will soon learn all about it. The story told by Violetta and Feste parallels the play written in 1601, which tells of twins, Viola and Sebastian, falling in love with the Count Orsino and the Duchess Olivia. Violetta's story takes up the thread after the marriages, when the pairs of lovers become bored with each other, and disaster ensues, leaving their respective kingdoms in tatters.
All the main characters from Twelfth Night are included, Sir Toby Belch, Sir Andrew Agnew, Malvolio and so on, which enables the reader to learn more of the play, as well as become deeply immersed in the story presented by Rees. And deeply engrossing it is too, as the pair roams London's streets, taking refuge where they can, looking for Malvolio who has stolen the icon of Illyria, which Violetta, as the new Duchess, wants to retrieve, so setting her country on its rightful path. Surprisingly Shakespeare hatches a plan with Cecil, taking his troupe on tour to Stratford, while following the progress of Malvolio and the Venetian ambassador, intent on inciting an uprising in Protestant England. Fool's girl is an entertaining and enlightening read, full of memorable characters placed against a marvelous setting and will engage lower secondary readers.
Fran Knight

Kisses for Daddy by Frances Watts and David Legge

cover image

(Age 2-5) Recommended. A reissue of the book first published in 2005, this story will be a hit at bedtime. A grumbly Baby Bear refuses to give his father any bedtime kisses, although Daddy imagines all the different types of kisses that baby animals give their fathers. There are many types of kisses including bear kisses, long tall giraffe kisses, and cuddly koala kisses, but Baby Bear's answer each time is 'No kiss for Daddy'. This is a beautifully illustrated story that clearly shows the love between father and child. Daddy Bear is gorgeous and patient, using things around the house to come up with ideas for different animal kisses.Children will have fun finding the animal on each page, the drawings often carefully hidden in a shadow or as an everyday utensil. It's a book that could lead to a lot of fun at bathtime and bedtime, with father and child reciting the words and having lots of kisses and closeness. There is enough repetition of key phrases like 'No! ' said Baby Bear. 'No kiss for Daddy', for the parent and child to remember the story as they prepare for bed, or for them to make up other animal kisses and action.
Pat Pledger

I spy mum by Janeen Brian

cover image

Illustrated by Chantal Stewart. New Frontier, 2010.
(Ages 3+) Recommended for children under five. A little boy out at sea is searching for his mum and on his search he finds lots of mums doing different things. The story is based on I spy and is beautifully rhyming so ideal for reading out loud.
The illustrations are full of movement and mums doing energetic things!
Kathryn Pledger
Editor's note: This is a companion volume to I spy Dad.

Sports Stories Series by various authors

cover image

Raintree, 2010.
Each book in this series offers a senario where the main character finds a way to overcome a seemingly difficult personal situation. All the situations are resolved peacefully and without conflict. The language is modern and simple with lots of direct speech and short chapters. The text style may well appeal to non readers or those who find reading difficult. The modern black and white illustrations are large and bold and help interpret the text. Many sports not usually given space in the media pages are represented in these books and it's refreshing to see them brought into prominence, a little like the main characters in these stories. Each book gives a paragraph about the author and illustrator; an informative glossary plus two pages of words and phrases particular to that sport so that someone reading the book will have practical and useful information about that sport. Discussion questions and some writing prompts follow. A page of resources, both print and web based conclude this particularly well presented section. These books are written to entice the reader to believe in themselves and encourage discussion. It seems the series would be a useful teaching resource for incidents encountered outside school, where young people may experience awkward situations and may not have anyone to help them through the situation.

Skateboard save by Eric Stevens ISBN 978 1 406 21393 5.
Here it's the bully Tony, who threatens Joe not to enter the skateboarding competition. He and his friend Rob discuss the actions of Tony and his hanger-on friends, helping the reader to sift through the possible ways of reacting to the situation.

Record run by Eric Stevens ISBN 978 1 406 21400 0.
Harry learns that the best opposition is to run against the clock and this inspires him to continue running rather than being chased by Paul the running captain, who cleverly convinces Harry to join the team and become the youngest member.

Half-pipe prize by Eric Stevens ISBN 978 1 406 21411 6.
Tess is returning to Winterton to surprise her two best friends and to enter the annual snowboarding competition.Anna is delighted to see her but Sofie's behaviour worries Tess.; Is winning again more important than friendship? Tess discusses her dilemma with Anna and her parents and resolves her problem in an appropriate way.

Board rebel by Bob Temple ISBN 978 1 406 21395 9.
Mason has moved to a new school and there is nowhere to skateboard. When he finds the Curves he also encounters Benjamin the local bully and his family who seem to run the affairs of the town. With his friend Billy, he returns to his old skateboard area and meets Will, one of Benjamin's friends. An interesting situation ensues when Mason devises a scheme which enables him to skateboard and make friends.

Free throw by Anastasia Suen ISBN 978 1 406 21399 7.
Jason is giving Theo a hard time for the coach has chosen Theo rather than Jason, to play centre. Pressure is mounting on Theo for he just can't seem to gain the points from the free throws. Jason's unkind asides are very off-putting, so Theo works hard to find a way to succeed.

BMX bully by Anastasia Suen ISBN 978 1 406 21394 2.
Alex's father has bought the BMX track from Matt's Dad and Alex and his Dad ignore the BMX racing rules by which Matt abides. Matt's dream of making the Evergreen team is threatened but the resolution is appropriate and justified.

Skater's secret by Lisa Trumauer ISBN 978 1 406 21408 6.
Maggie and Shannon are sisters who love figure skating. Shannon would love to score over her sister. The plot is well developed for Shannon secretly finds the perfect music to skate to, only to find that Maggie has chosen it. The twists and turns of sibling rivalry are well explored to both sisters' satisfaction.

Ballet bullies by Emma Berne ISBN 978 1 406 21412 3.
Marissa loves ballet but her growth spurt is embarrassing her to the extent that she no longer wants to dance. She tries all sorts of subterfuges but finally the derisive laughs from Kelly and Alice are resolved and with her friend Rachel's uncompromising support, Marissa dances the Star Fairy role with joy and all the talent she has.

Horse-riding hopes by Diana Gallagher ISBN 9781406214093.
Molly desperately wants to learn to ride. Her best friend Kari encourages her when she sees 'Riding Lessons, Low prices'. Molly learns to ride, saves Gabrielle and her horse. Gabrielle and Lily rode 'sleek' horses making Mollie feel awkward and embarrassed. Mollie and Kari gain confidence and enjoy their new found recreation.

Tennis trouble by Chris Kreie ISBN: 9781406214109.
Alexis is thirteen and thrilled to make the under eighteens team for the first time. Olivia, Morgan and Rachel expected to make the team, but with the inclusion of Alexis Rachel this is a problem. As a much younger girl in the team, Alexis has many headaches, but with the support of Ellie and Miss Taylor the school coach, and eventually Olivia, Alexis is able to contribute to the team effort. Even Morgan acknowledges Alexis' position on the team.

Back on the beam by Eric Stevens ISBN: 978 1 40621 406 2.
Nadia is nervous about being back in competition after an ankle injury and her rival, Claire, makes comments that don't help

Storm surfer by Lisa Trumbauer ISBN: 978 1 40621 404 8.
Abby and Sarah think surfing in a storm will be amazing but who is to rescue them when the waves get too big?

Team spirit by Eric Stevens ISBN: 978 1 40621 403 1.
Will Anna, Bethany and Jasmine feel at home on their new girls' football team?
Sue Nosworthy

Beatle meets Destiny by Gabrielle Williams

cover image

Read by Felix Gentle. Louis Braille Audio, 2009. ISBN 9781742123783. Penguin, 2009. 9780143011491.
(Age 14+) Recommended. One night at a tram stop in Melbourne, Beatle, so called because his real name is John Lennon, notices a girl wearing sunglasses and reading a book. Her name is Destiny and it almost seems as if they were fated to meet. There is an immediate attraction, but problems loom, as Beatle already has a lovely girlfriend who stood by him as he pulled through the aftermaths of a stroke. Every day at Destiny's home, horoscopes are read and tarots are often consulted. Beatle's home is chaotic; his mother never getting over the fact that her husband had left her for a younger woman. To make matters even more complicated, Winsome, Beatle's non identical twin sister, has begun to date Destiny's brother, Frank, who is a teacher at their school.
I had read this book before I listened to the tape. I had thoroughly enjoyed it, especially liking the humour and the witty dialogue between all the characters. I found that Felix Gentle's reading brought all the smart conversations alive and I found myself laughing out loud at the funny situations the pair got themselves into. Williams has an excellent ear for the way teenagers speak and Gentle was able to modulate his voice so well that the characters came alive and the word play and repartee was just wonderful when read aloud.
Beatle meets Destiny has many situations which teenagers will identify with. Crushes on teachers, falling in love with someone else while having a perfectly good girlfriend, sibling rivalry and friendship are all themes that are relevant to their lives. Wrapped up in a humorous package and read with zest, this audio would be a perfect reading for teens.
Pat Pledger

My Dad thinks he's funny by Katrina Germein

cover image

Ill. by Tom Jellett. Black dog books, 2010. ISBN 978174203121 7.
Picture book. Kids will love the literal meanings of the words and phrases used in this very funny picture book. Each thing the boy says to his father is turned around by dad taking the meaning as implied by the words, not the meaning as we all recognise. So when someone asks his father, 'How are you going?', father replies 'By bus', instead of the response to a question about his well being. The humour comes thick and fast, as the boy asks his dad for help, because he 'doesn't know how', dad replies, 'I know How, he's What's brother', parodying the famous dialogue between Abbott and Costello about a baseball game with How, What and Who on each diamond.  
Tom Jellett's individual style of illustration adds a new level of comedy to this already funny story. The black line drawings seem to have been done on a variety of resources, wallpaper, material, brown paper, graph paper, crumpled paper and so on, all stressing the ephemeral nature of the words and their use.
The illustrations provide a great model for work in the classroom, and the children's work on new phrases which can be taken two ways added to their efforts.
All very tongue in cheek and showing a delightful family setting underlining the humorous dialogue which occurs everyday between parents and children, siblings and friends. Children will squeal with delight as they recognise the differences between how words are used in our language, and will attempt to add some of their own. ESL students in particular will be puzzled and delighted at finding out how English is used in their new home.
Fran Knight

The three musketeers retold by Pauline Francis

cover image

Evans Brothers Ltd, 2010. ISBN 978 0 237 53911 5.
Recommended for Upper Primary and early Secondary students. An old favourite, well written for young audiences. The original, written by Alexander Dumas, was published in 1844. It was 1625 and d'Artagnan an eighteen year old had come to Paris to make his fortune. He had a letter of introduction to Monsieur de Treville, the Captain of the Musketeers - the men who guarded King Louis of France. D 'Artagnan wanted more than anything else to be a musketeer. The introduction is very useful as a quick historical background to the story. It's a fast moving story which still excites readers today.D'Artagnon meets three musketeers called Athos, Porthos and Aramis and together they frustrate a plan against King Louis and his Queen. Written with humour and wit, the story evokes the eternal pull of history and intrique.
Sue Nosworthy

The rebel prince by Celine Kiernan

cover image

The Moorehawke Trilogy, book 3. Allen and Unwin, 2010. ISBN 9781741758719.
(Age 15+) Highly recommended. The concluding volume in The Moorehawke trilogy, The rebel Prince does not disappoint. Wynter, Razi and Christopher finally reach the camp of the exiled Prince Alberon where they are embroiled in the intricacies of the political plots that Alberon has hatched and his desire to keep the kingdom safe by using the death machine that Wynter's father invented. Razi has to use all his diplomatic powers to convince Alberon that he is not after the throne, while Wynter is forced to look at her relationship with Christopher and all its complexities. The complex diplomatic ties that Alberon is trying to forge with traditional enemies are also a source of dismay. When the Wolves, led by David le Garou, arrive as envoys, it takes all of Christopher's loyalty to Razi, not to enact revenge on them for their evil enslavement of children and disfigurement of his hands. Finally it is up to Wynter to make decisions that will either preserve the kingdom or plunge it into chaos.
After a slow start in the first chapters, where background details about the exiled Prince's allies and camp are given, The rebel prince moves into some of the most gripping action scenes and emotional tension of the series. I loved the way Wynter had to decide whether she wanted to be a woman of the court and help decide the future of the realm or remain true to Christopher, who just wants them to go on their way and be happy. Razi, too, is faced with a complex diplomatic task, reassuring Alberon that he is the heir to the throne, while plotting a way to get the prince back to his father. The action packed finale, with its cliff-hanger battle is breath taking and I had to re-read the last chapter to finally make sense of the denouement.
This series is fantasy at its best. If you have an older teen who wants something with werewolves in it, give them this - the romance between Wynter and Christopher is gripping and demonstrates the values of loyalty, trust and caring. Full of emotion, action and beautifully developed characters, this is one series I will not be lending to anyone for fear of not getting it back!
Pat Pledger

Grimsdon by Deborah Abela

cover image

Random House Australia, 2010. ISBN 9781741663723.
(Age: 8-11) Isabella, heroic and resourceful, heads a small band of children on the seaward edges of Grimsdon. She leads the twins Bea and Raffy, Griffin and Fly (who doesn't talk, but has other special abilities), on exploring and scavenging forays into the deteriorating buildings. They collect enough to keep them well fed and safe.
Grimsdon, a thinly disguised London, is a nearly submerged, decaying city three years after the sea waters have risen and flooded the low lying areas. The only inhabitants of Grimsdon are adults who choose to live there away from regular society (like pirates who exploit children), or children who were stranded after the rescue attempts ceased. Water separates the buildings requiring boats and ropes to navigate. Tides and rogue waves have to be taken into account and there are vague fears of sea serpents.
Life for the children is interesting and limited until Xavier comes into their lives. Their world broadens, becomes more dangerous and interesting as Xavier takes them further a field using the incredible Aerotrope.
I found Grimsdon an easy to read novel and could imagine the students who would enjoy reading it. This narrative is an engaging, easy little read for middle primary readers, although it might appeal to a few upper primary students, especially those who like an imaginary land, strong predictable characters and a bit of fantasy.
Although Grimsdon touches on issues of independence and belonging, and introduces the concept of changes in the environment being brought about by the actions of humans, the subjects are not followed through to a depth strong enough to provoke serious discussion.
S. Whittaker

Look out, Leon! by Jez Alborough

cover image

Walker Books, 2010. ISBN: 9781406319927.
(Ages 2+) Recommended. Leon the chameleon is learning fast how to change his colour to blend in with his surroundings. Dad keeps a watchful eye on Leon as he goes out to explore the scary jungle with lots of hungry animals to hide from.
This pull the tabs book lets the reader change the picture and text and follows Leon through the jungle on his adventure. Under fives will love the colourful Leon.
Kathryn Pledger

Me and my dad by Sally Morgan and Ezekiel Kwaymullina

cover image

Ill. by Matt Ottley. Little Hare, 2010. ISBN 9781921541810.
(Age 3+) Recommended. At the beach, the boy is amazed about Dad's courage. He is not afraid of sharp shells, falling sandcastles, crazy crabs, giant waves or hungry sharks. He is brave and fearless, but there is one thing that scares him and the boy and his dog can help him out. Dad says that they can be heroes together.
This story, with its carefully chosen short text, is ideal to illustrate the loving attachment between father and son. The son is afraid of many things at the beach, but Dad is intrepid, happily facing the dangers of many seaside animals. The young reader will be able to identify with the boy's fear and the awe he feels when his father bravely faces each obstacle. I loved the section where the boy discovered that there was one thing that he could rescue his Dad from and the warmth and love of the two heroes together is heart-warming.
Matt Ottley illustrations are vivid and compelling, enhancing the text and adding an element of humour. The opening double page spread of Dad's elongated leg and huge foot wrestling with pointed shells was my favourite and is sure to delight young and old. The fear on the faces of the young boy and his dog and the heroic expression on his Dad's face are very expressive, as are the wicked looks on the faces of the sea gulls found in each illustration. The bright blue of the sky, yellow of the sand and blue green of the sea are gorgeous.
This is a wonderful book for families to have to show the love between father and son, and would be useful for displays for Father's Day and for units of work on families in the classroom. It certainly deserves a place in the library.
Pat Pledger

Cows in the Kitchen by June Crebbin

cover image

Ill. by Katherine McEwen. Walker Books, 2010. ISBN 9781406326321.
(Ages 1+) Highly recommended for under fives. Farm yard animals cause havoc in the farm house and have a great time waking up Farmer Tom while he snoozes in the haystack and then again in his armchair.
The story has a singsong quality and is best read aloud with all the animal noise effects. The illustrations are humorous with a lot of detail and one cheeky little mouse hidden on each page to find. Children who love animals will love this book and the mischief the farmyard animals get up to.
Kathryn Pledger

The golden scarab by Ian Trevaskis

cover image

Hopscotch. Walker Books, 2010. ISBN 9781921529252.
(Age 9-14) Hannah and Jake are not content to stay quietly in Pelican Bay after their exciting adventures in Ancient Greece, in the first book in the Hopscotch series, Medusa Stone. Instead they play the hopscotch game again and find themselves in ancient Egypt, on a quest to replace a shabti in the tomb of Pharaoh Thutmose the Third, and collect the sorcerer's sceptre and the Pharaoh's flail to give to the evil Kostas. They have numerous adventures, meeting local rulers and fighting off foes.
Right from the first sentence, the reader is plunged into non-stop action, as Hannah and Jake show their warrior prowess and sword skills, fighting off tomb raiders and impressing the local dignitaries. Trevaskis keeps up the tension with quite a few scary moments when it is uncertain whether the pair can survive all the trials and tribulations, including the loss of the golden scarab, their only means home.
Information about the ancient civilisation, its burial rituals and life is faithfully rendered, giving the reader an opportunity to learn while being engrossed in the action. Further information and a glossary also provide an opportunity for the reader to learn more about Egypt.
It would be an advantage to read the first in the series, Medusa Stone, before tackling this book, as the hopscotch game and the Playground of the Gods is fully explained there.
This book will appeal to both boys and girls with its action driven plot, adventure and information about ancient Egypt.
Pat Pledger

The boy/friend by R. M. Corbet

cover image

Girlfriend fiction. Allen and Unwin, 2010. ISBN 9781742372860.
(Age 13+) Recommended for a lighthearted read. Lou (short for Louis, after Louis Armstrong) and Maude, have lived on the same street forever, and have been best friends forever. But things are being to change. Maude is transferring on a scholarship to an all-girls school and Lou is busy setting up new punk-rock band. When Lou asks Maude to go to the movies, their friendship starts to unravel as Maude inadvertently hurts his feelings. Then Maude has to contend with two new gorgeous girl members of the band and suddenly she is viewing Lou in a different light.
This is an extremely entertaining read, which I read in one sitting. I laughed along at the predicaments that Maude found herself in and sympathised with her as she sorted out what she was looking for in a boy and discovered just how much she missed the friendship that had sustained her for so long. Many girls will identify with the best friend, boy friend scenario and will enjoy the journey that R.M. Corbett takes them on. Best of all, is the snappy dialogue and humour. I loved the introduction of the hairy bikies and the band scenario was hilarious.
It's great to read a book that is funny, well written and happy.
Pat Pledger

Burke and Wills: Expedition off the map by Karen Tayleur

cover image

Our Stories series. Black dog books, 2010. ISBN 9781742031392.
(Ages 7+) Recommended. Non fiction. The 150th anniversary of one of the most celebrated failures in Australian history is sure to spawn a collection of books and articles, reprising the expedition and its consequences. How apt then that the highly skilled and awarded specialists of non fiction books for primary students should produce a book in time for the celebrations.
Presented in black dog book's impressive Our Stories series, this book will rarely be seen in the library once students and staff become aware of it.
Each double page spread expounds a different aspect of the expedition: Ships of the Desert, Heading to Cooper's Creek, Dig and What went Wrong, and all presented chronologically with a timeline across the bottom of each page with the camels rather significantly looking back.
One of these spreads which thrilled me was that entitled, Dig, and told the story of that icon of the Australian bush, the dig tree. On this spread is 5-6 paragraphs of information, supplemented with a photo of the tree, a small map to show where it is, a painting of the area around the dig tree, some information about the local Aboriginal people and the time line on the bottom of the page which follows through the whole book, giving the dates for the events surrounding the tree. The double page is enlightening, inviting and easy to access, interesting and colourful to look at, and redolent of the isolation of this expedition.
Some of the explorers who accompanied Burke and Wills take up one double page spread at the start of the book, and at the end is a list of all the expeditioners with a small amount of information about each. The book is rounded off with a list of books and websites which could be used to gain further information. An explicit contents page will make it easy for younger researchers to find what they are looking for, and this is supported with an excellent index and glossary. The overall map of the expedition at the start of the book is supported by smaller maps throughout the text highlighting just where the group had got to. The use of colour adds to the appeal, as does the relevant pictures and newspaper articles used to augment the text.
I listened to the Louis Braille audio version of Sarah Murgatroyd's The Dig Tree several years ago, and was astonished and delighted over again reading this book for younger readers. It is a must for every school library.
Fran Knight