Reviews

That's not a daffodil by Elizabeth Honey

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 9781742372488
(Age 3-6) Recommended. When Tom sees the bulb that Mr Yilmaz, his gardening neighbour gives him, he is convinced that it is not a daffodil. It looks like an onion to him. But Mr Yilmaz convinces him to plant it and wait and see what grows.
Tom is an imaginative child and as the plant grows he visualises many different things. The bare soil is a desert, a single stork is a beak and as the five leaves of the daffodil grow, he thinks that it is Grandpa's hairs blowing in the wind. Children, too, will have fun imagining different things as they watch the emergence of the daffodil.
Adults who enjoy gardening will love reading this book to children. Mr Yilmaz is obviously such a wonderful gardener and each time he comes in he brings another delicious vegetable or fruit for the family to consume. The story would stimulate children and adults to plant a bulb or some other flower or vegetable and watch it grow. Children can also learn very easily the basics of how to grow and look after plants. I can imagine using this book as the basis for a classroom activity and reading it again and again to stimulate children's imagination and knowledge of plants.
Most of all, though, it is a beautifully written and illustrated book that is a joy to read.
Pat Pledger

Girls at Sea by Sue Lawson

cover image

Black Dog Books, 2011. ISBN 9781742031729.
Girls at Sea is part 6 of an 8 book series. It does mention events from past books but readers don't need to
have read them to understand this as it is independent. We meet fun-loving Mickey and Skye and snooty Coco who are hosts of Girl's Stuff T.V. They are filming their show from a resort and Skye is excited as they head out on a whale watching trip as part of their filming. Readers will learn interesting facts about whales and will love it when Coco is highly embarrassed - everyone loves it when the 'evil' character gets what they deserve!
This is a short novel and while the text is mainly told through conversation, it is easy to read and follow.
Girls aged 7-11 will enjoy this story and I'm sure they will want to read the set and check out the adventures the girls get up to.
Kylie Kempster

A rose for the ANZAC boys by Jackie French

cover image

Harper Collins, 2008. ISBN: 9780732285401.
This novel is simply stunning. I first read A rose for the ANZAC boys in year eight for The Readers' Cup and since then it has kept a special place in my mind and heart. It is a perfect example of brilliant teenage fiction. A story inside a story. The prologue and the epilogue tell us about Lachie and his ancestry of war heroes and their tribute to the Anzac Boys.
The main story is set though 1915 to 1920 and follows the journey Margery McPherson takes to find her twin brother Tim. She and her friends Anne and Ethel, desperate to help, go to France to set up a canteen for the poor soldiers going home. They tend to the desperate men some nursing fatal injuries as they wait for the train to take them to be treated properly. As the years pass Midge sees for herself the true horrors of war. She serves as an ambulance driver for the duchesses for a brief time before going on to work in Casualty Station number fifteen as an unofficial nurse with her Aunt Lalie. Each chapter begins with the inspirational piece, a letter either received or sent by Midge. The letters show us a wider view of the trauma of WW1 and the types of things soldiers would have thought and felt during that time of crisis.
This story is stunning, the text creates a feast of authentic images that will stay with you long after you've finished. I recommend this novel as it is written spectacularly and is in most cases it tells of what war in 1915 was really like in a much more condensed version than is common. Jackie French conducted years of research before she started working on this novel - and sometimes even she didn't know whether she could finish it but I'm glad she did complete it as I'm sure that anyone could both benefit and enjoy this story no matter your age.
Kayla Gaskell, 15

Hattie and the fox by Mem Fox and Patricia Mullins

cover image

Scholastic, 2011. ISBN 978 1 74169 8206.
(Ages 4+) Highly recommended. A reprint of this classic story will have toenails curling all over Australia as a new generation of children follow Hattie's attempts to warn her fellow barnyard creatures of the impending attack by a fox. Each page is wonderful as the group of animals respond in the same way to Hattie's fears, pulling the reader into predicting what will happen on each subsequent page and eventually singing along with the refrains.
The humour in the story of the disinterested farmyard animals is reflected in the stunning illustrations, in which Mullins has used torn paper to create a visual splash of colour and line. A lovely touch to watch out for is the change in pace of the illustrations from the dreamy animals at the start to the frightened animals moving quickly to escape on the last few pages as the fox attacks. And I loved Hattie's concern for her fellow animals, despite their disdain, with her looking around and warning them, until finally she is resting in her chookhouse, her lookout work completed.
I heard Mem Fox read this aloud to an audience of children and adults at a Premier's Reading Challenge reception, and was thrilled to see the adults so engrossed. This makes a wonderful read-a-loud book.
Fran Knight

Guardian of the dead by Karen Healey

cover image

Allen and Unwin 2010. ISBN:978-1-74175-880-1
A fantastic first novel! Karen Healy has employed several classic concepts to create a work of pure fantasy. The story follows Ellie Spencer, an overweight year thirteen Mansfield College student who is completely 'normal' - or so it was until she ran into mystery boy Mark Nolan. Between falling in love and stressing about the coming exams something bigger is taking place around her and occupying her thoughts; the fate of New Zealand's North Island. Maori Faeries are plotting to regain their immortality from Hine-nui-tepō, the guardian of the dead. Enlisted in a war she didn't know existed, armed with nothing but her new found powers and a magical mask, does this ordinary girl stand a chance?
I have to say, The Guardian of the Dead is one of the most mythology- rich fantasy book I've read to this day. I confess I'm not familiar with Maori mythology but this book has inspired my interest in their legends. I loved how Greek and Maori legends were compared in this book if only in scraps. The comparisons are in perfect alignment with the plot. I highly recommend that any fantasy lover who has a thirst for legend join the characters in this dark adventure to save the North Island; just don't let the mask fool you!
Kayla Gaskell (Student, 15)

Poisoned House by Michael Thomas Ford

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2010. ISBN: 978-14088044506.
(Ages: 10 +) Set in 19th Century England, Poisoned House follows a young servant girl's quest to solve the unexplained death of her mother. Abigail Tamper works to overcome her draconian master and housekeeper Mrs Cotton to get in touch with the spirit of her late mother who has been haunting Greave Hall since her death. Along the way Abigail has familiar teenage relationship issues with her close friend Lizzy, who is mourning the break-up with her boyfriend. After the visit from an exorcist Dr Reinhardt, Abigail establishes a communication method with the spirit of her late mother using a Ouija Board, which she keeps secretly hidden in the basement. Abigail's suspicion that her mother was murdered becomes clearer when the hierarchy of Greave Hall changes when the son and heir of Greave Hall Samuel Greaves returns injured from war and Abigail is required to nurse him. In the theme of murder mystery, Poisoned House has some unexpected twists that occur at the end right at the end of the book. It would be recommended for students in upper primary to lower secondary with these students being attracted to themes of overcoming authority.
Adam Fitzgerald

Ember and Ash by Pamela Freeman

cover image

Orbit, 2011. ISBN 9780733624223.
(Age 15+) Recommended. A fantasy set in the Last Domain of the Eleven Domains, Ember and Ash is a companion volume to the Castings Trilogy and is set some twenty years later. Ember is going to marry a young lord to join two warring lands and hopefully bring peace. At her wedding, the ceremonial fire changes into the elemental Fire God, roaring into huge flames and murdering her husband to be. Ember vows revenge and refuses to accept the Fire King's act of putting out every fire over the land. Instead she enlists the aid of Ash and a group of young people, and sets off on a quest of retribution to find a spark that will light the fires again. Their task is monumental and will involve more than tracking down the Fire King. They will also have to struggle against the Ice King who is determined to take over the world.
This was an engrossing story of a young girl coming of age. Ember demonstrates great strength and courage as she tracks the elusive fire spark that she needs to save her people. She is prepared to put everything on the line in the name of duty. Ash is a worthy companion who champions her and their bittersweet love for each other is slow and gradual. All the secondary characters were vividly described and also came alive, battling the elements and domestic problems, in the case of Arvid and Martine, the rulers of the Last Domain and Ember's parents. I was thrilled to learn about the original Ash, beloved by Water, and see a younger Ash, brave and determined set his own course. In fact I became so immersed in some of the stories of the minor characters that I wished that Freeman had written several books instead of one with these people in it!
A wonderful world and atmospheric setting make this novel come alive. The idea of warring elements, Fire, Ice, Water and Wind, is not new but here was given a depth and originality that kept my interest. I became engrossed in the cold, harsh environs of the North and the customs that the people had developed to survive the climate. The supernatural nature of the link between the gods and humans and rituals like stone casting were fascinating.
These books written for adults by Freeman are also perfect ones for the older teen, and will be enjoyed by both boys and girls. Readers who like these could move onto adult books by Juliet Marillier, Kate Forsyth and Trudi Caravan.
Pat Pledger

Diamond Spirit by Karen Wood

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 9781742373157.
Diamond spirit by Karen Wood is a well written novel about a girl and her horse, Diamond. When Diamond bolts through a cattle grid she breaks both of her front legs and is failing to recover, Jess comes to a hard decision, painful life or death. Jess wants to know how and why Diamond was down by the cattle grid that day when the horse's yard was way further up river. Only one person can tell her and give her half of the answer to the mystery, Shara, Jess's best friend, the same best friend who is moving to an agricultural school far, far away. Nothing can heal Jess's broken heart except a beautiful filly, born where Diamond lay, could there be a spiritual connection to the two? Jess wants to own such an important foal but she's in a race for the bid, will she succeed in getting the one horse made for her?
Diamond spirit was such an exciting novel, I couldn't stop reading. It opened my eyes to new events and I would recommend this book to anyone who likes animals. I could relate to all the characters perfectly well and this book was easy to understand. The age rating for this book would be from twelve year-old onwards but I would say roughly anyone would enjoy this book.
Sarah Filkin (Yr 9)

Two bad teddies by Kilmeny Niland

cover image

Little Hare, 2010. ISBN 978-1921541865.
(Age 2-5) Recommended. 'Gruffy Ted and Tilly Ted loved Mollie-Sue. And Mollie-Sue loved her teddies.' But one day Grandma sent Mollie-Sue a new toy to play with. Bendy Bill has long stretchy arms and a silly grin. Mollie-Sue loved this new toy and even tucked him into her bed. Gruffy Ted and Tilly Ted were extremely jealous and did lots of bad things to try and get rid of Bendy Bill. One day, though, Bendy Bill uses his long arms to rescue Gruffy Ted and they all become good friends.
Niland explores a familiar theme of jealousy when a newcomer becomes the centre of attention and old loves seem to be forgotten. Through the humorous actions of the teddies, she is able to show that doing bad things is not the best way to get the attention of those we love and that cooperation is much the best thing.
Niland's illustrations are delightful. Vivid greens, reds and purples abound and little details like a blue bowtie for Gruffie and a red bow for Tilly make the illustrations stand out. I loved the grumpy expressions on the two bad teddies as they watch Bendy Bill become the centre of attention for their beloved Mollie-Sue. Other emotions, bewilderment, determination and finally happiness, came alive with each episode of the bears trying to oust Bendy Bill.
This is a perfect story to read when there is a new addition to the family. Best of all read it out loud to a toddler and enjoy the fun!
Pat Pledger

That Dirty Dog and Other Naughty Stories for Girls and Boys by Christopher Milne

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2011.
Short, quick and funny are the three words that best describe the stories in That Dirty Dog and Other Naughty Stories for Girls and Boys. There are 6 short stories that use descriptive language and black and white illustrations to help engage the reader. Boys and girls aged 9+ will enjoy the humour.
One of the characters wishes his dad was nicer and gets a great surprise. Another character has lost his dad and the author handles the topic with tact and humour. What kid doesn't like talking (and reading) about bad smells? Meet Stinky Adams, the king of smell making! Lots of giggles for all and the quick moving stories make it easy and enjoyable.
Kylie Kempster

Remember Me Volume 1 by Christopher Pike

cover image

Hodder Children's Books, 2010. ISBN 9781444901269.
(Age: 13+) When Shari Cooper went out onto the balcony for some fresh air, she didn't expect to die. But now she is dead, and a spirit in between worlds. Still on Earth, but invisible to humans, she discovers that her family and friends believe she committed suicide. But Shari knows otherwise. She knows that she was pushed that night, and now she has to find her murderer, before they strike again.
This story is well-written and imaginative. I loved it because it was very original. I've read plenty of ghost stories and this was one of the most unique so far. It manages to combine fantasy, murder, mystery, and humour into one fantastic book.
At times this book turns from a dark, brooding atmosphere to bright humour. This is a great example of how good a writer Christopher Pike is. With some authors this type of abrupt change would be disjointed, but here the book continues smoothly and enjoyably throughout.
I love the description and the imagination in this book. Description is a big factor in how good a book is, and in Remember Me it was fantastic. Christopher Pike always painted a very clear picture of the scene in my mind. As for imagination, I always love it when authors attempt to stretch you.
This is a great book for anyone who enjoys the fantasy/paranormal genre. It is clever, unique, and a thoroughly engaging book.
I highly recommend this book.
Rebecca Adams (Student)

Chill by Carol Thompson

cover image

Little Hare Books, 2011. ISBN 9781921541735.
Picture book. Dolly the pig and Jack the rabbit are best of friends. They do everything together, playing in the playground, listening to music together, climbing trees, exercising and just laughing. But one day when painting together, they decide to draw each other, and neither likes the other's portrayal. They argue, and leave each other. But each on their own place gets mad, then realises that without their friend they are lonely and sad.
They each return to the tree they climbed and tell each other how much they missed them, and so resolve their differences and become friends once again.
A charming story of resolution and friendship, this book is a great read a loud, and be most useful in the classroom when discussing friendship and how to resolve differences.
Fran Knight

Embrace by Jessica Shirvington

cover image

Hachette Australia, 2010. ISBN 9780734411846.
(Ages 13+) Violet is dreading her seventeenth birthday dinner; after all it is the anniversary her mother's death. The only good thing about it is Lincoln will be there. Lincoln is her idea of perfect. She loves him but he only wants to be friends or at least that's how he acts. After he walks her home then leaves her at her front door after giving her the best kiss of her life she is determined to get some answers. Then she learns the truth. He had lied to her the whole time she had known him. The truth is they are both Grigori, half human, half angel and Lincoln is her partner it is for that reason they can never be together. When she learns this she hates him. She can't think anything nice about him. Then there is Phoenix an exiled angel who is always there for her and has never lied.
But is Phoenix really who Violet thinks he is? And is her hate for Lincoln real?
Caught up in a battle between light and dark she must make the right decision because not only could the wrong cost her life it could cost her destiny as well.
This book was amazing. I didn't want to put it down. I would definitely highly recommend that you read this book.
Tahlia Kennewell (student)

The Valley of Blood and Gold by Tony Palmer

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 9780143008972.
(Age: 12+) Highly recommended. The year is 1854. Miners are rebelling against soldiers at Ballarat, but Fintan Donovan, a young Irish boy, is fighting battles of his own. The Irish and English are enemies, and one of the greatest enemies of Fintan's family is Joseph Ward, a local wealthy preacher who hates the Irish. As the situation in Ballarat reaches breaking point and Fintan struggles to keep his friendship with Joseph Ward's son, Matthew, he discovers things about himself that he never thought he would.
The Valley of Blood and Gold is a wonderful book that is richly descriptive, surprising and thoroughly enjoyable in many ways. It was fascinating to read about Australia in 1854 and what was happening during that time, especially about the Eureka Stockade battle. The actual story begins some time before that, and it was exciting, seeing the tension slowly building up in the story, until suddenly everything happened at once.
I thought this story was original, and quite clever. The main theme of the Irish and the English hating each other was a good theme to write about, and it certainly made for some engaging reading, especially when two warring characters confronted each other. As for the atmosphere of the story, the author did a good job of making it feel like 1854, with the description, the dialogue, and so forth.
On the blurb, it says 'vivid and powerful, The Valley of Blood and Gold evokes a moment in history that is entrenched in national heritage.' And that basically sums it up.
I highly recommend this book.
Rebecca Adams (Student)

Maisy goes to the city by Lucy Cousins

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 9781406327366.
(Ages 5 +) Picture book. A Maisy first experiences book has Maisy and her friend, Charley, going by bus to the city to visit their friend, Dotty. Each stage of their journey is told, the busy road traversed, the large buildings looked at. When Dotty meets them at the station in the city, he takes them to all the sights, the shops, busy streets, up the escalator and the lifts, and helps them buy a present. They then go to a cafe in the square where they eat pizza, and then play in the park. Going back to Dotty's house means finding their way around the underground, and when they return home, they thank Dotty for allowing them to stay.
This cute little book in bold, bright colours, gives an outline of what children can expect when going somewhere to stay. They learn the procedure of what to do when staying with someone and what to expect, what they will see and do. The book will encourage student discussion about travel and going somewhere other than home, and they can share some talk of their own travels. This book would be a good adjunct to a lesson on holidays or living with someone else for a while.
Fran Knight