Reviews

The comet box by Adrian Stirling

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 978 0 14 320610 1.
(Ages 12+) Recommended. Life in the 1980's is stunningly recreated for this story of suburban life, surmounted by routine and expectations adhered to, of problems hidden under the carpet and never spoken of, of boys wanting more than the life being offered. Andrew and his nuclear family live in the outer suburbs, where the fields ver the road are being remodelled for a new suburb and supermarket, the trees torn down, large tracts of land reshaped, and tunnels dug for huge cement pipes. It is the year of Halley's Comet, and Andrew's teacher asks the students to make a wish and place it in the Comet Box in the room, to be reveled next year. Andrew steals the box, wanting to know the secrets of his classmates and finds things about many of them that he has never noticed before.
But one day, after a loud argument at home, his sister, Amelia, disappears, and this changes the way people speak to him and his family, and the way the family operates. Loaded down with a lack og knowledge of what is happening within his family, Andrew seeks refuge with his best friend, Romeo, and together they become aware of other things in their suburb which have been kept secret.
A story overflowing with the sights and sounds of suburban Australia, languishing under its own vision of Nirvana, the veneer of respectability and contentment is eroded away by the ugliness underneath. Andrew is not told anything, he must work things out for himself, adding pieces of information together to eventually understand why his sister disappeared and why when brought home by the police, she runs off again. All the while the comet is drawing closer, and the secrets Andrew knows about his classmates must be returned to the box before anyone knows. The comet signifies change in the community, and while many of the issues which the children see as important to them remained unresolved, Andrew's family at least brings things to the surface.
Fran Knight

The grasshopper's run by Siddhartha Sarma

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2011. ISBN 978 1 408809402.
When the Japanese army invades India in 1944, self obsessed and deranged Colonel Mori orders the wholesale slaughter of the entire population of an innocent and unsuspecting village. Justifying the massacre on the pretext that the village could be hiding units of the British Army, Mori is in reality driven by vicious cruelty and a lust for military power and recognition.
Uti, a village youth who survives the initial attack, lies in wait and kills soldiers before being subdued and then horrendously tortured.
Siddhartha Sarma then introduces the character Gojen who has been Uti's close companion throughout his life, to the degree that they considered themselves brothers, having shared tribal ceremonies, education and family interaction.
As a gifted sportsman and academic, Gojen has enjoyed great success whilst studying at a European college in Bengal and is not troubled by any sense of inequality amongst his Colonial peers.
When he learns of the village's fate and the death of his soul brother, Gojen returns home traumatised and seeks to assist in avenging Ut's death by providing information gathered from British Military Intelligence. The boy practices target shooting and the reader appreciates that he is an accomplished long distance marksman who naturally desires to apply his skills against the Japanese. Gojen's father is relatively wealthy as an indigenous noble and forbids his son to join the foray into a battleground where the defending British are frantically mustering reinforcements against the seemingly unstoppable Japanese might.
Defying his father, Gojen sneaks out and joins other villagers intent on seeking revenge. The journey to find Mori is slow and many cultural relationships and local references are introduced, making the narrative difficult to follow for those unfamiliar with Indian social history.
In the turmoil of battle, the story gathers pace and the reader understands that the local Indians act in spite of, rather than in support of, the British who they still regard as an occupying force, albeit a more benign and constructive one compared with the Japanese.
Gojen wrestles with his own fear and Uti's spirit as events unfold.
Rob Welsh

Share by Anthea Simmons and Georgie Birkett

cover image

Random House Australia, 2011.  ISBN 978 1742750996.
(Ages 3-5) A board book for the very young is aimed specifically at teaching younger children to share. The young girl and her baby sibling are separate entities at the start of this tale, as the girl tells us how she loves her fluffy teddy, and her books of animals and her puzzle, but so does the baby and so mum's voice off page calls out that she must share her things, despite what happens to them as a result. Many children will identify with the young girl dismayed at her younger sibling's messing her things, and identify the voice calling out for them to share. After a few pages, the girl asks her mother whether she should share, changing the premise for the story. So the two begin to share things, her drink and her paints and her bath, and the girl begins to lessen her resistance to her sibling's interference.
At the end, the two are in bed together, and the baby asks the girl to share his bed, with the pair sharing their mother's hugs at the end.
This is a wholly delightful little tale, teaching the idea of sharing, and making it easier for the adult reading the book to the children to introduce the idea of sharing and pointing out the ways of sharing that can happen in a family.
Fran Knight

How I stole Johnny Depp's alien girlfriend by Gary Ghislain

cover image

Chronicle, 2011. ISBN 9780811874601.
(Age 12+) Recommended. David meets Zelda when she becomes a patient of his father, a renowned psychiatrist, looking after troubled youth. Zelda, who believes she comes from the planet Vahalal, is on a quest for the perfect mate and the picture she shows David is one of Johnny Depp. David, immediately smitten by her green eyes and mean ways, follows her on a frantic chase to find Johnny, jumping across the rooftops of Paris, stealing his mother's clothes and going to a weird shrine which would take then to Vahalal, if the tattoo key is used.
This is an absolute scream of a book. I was hooked from the moment I started reading it and laughed my way through the smart dialogue and action packed adventure. Ghislain takes a hilarious look at male celebrities with such comments as 'Brad Pitt, Johnny Depp, Robert freaking Pattinson! I don't care. We will abduct every single Hollywood stud if it will bring us back to Vahalal'. He also makes some very funny observations about how girls get hooked by celebrity looks and the impact of designer clothes and furnishing of the wealthy. David's mother is a very high powered woman whose designer clothes, in particular, a little bikini, proves too much of a temptation for Zelda the warrior woman. David trails behind her, trying to pick up the pieces at his mother's beautifully appointed apartment, and finally enlists the aid of his stepsister Malou in their quest to track down the elusive Johnny Depp.
David is no pushover. Zelda may come from a planet where men are not valued at all but David is smitten and is determined to get the girl and he takes the reader on a wonderful romp while he tries to figure out how he can do that. There are over the top ideas and action in this book, but it so amusing, fast paced and engrossing that I was happy to accept even the most improbable things and just enjoy the ride. I also loved the setting, first in the countryside of France and then in the wonderful city of Paris.
I think that it would make an excellent suggestion for reluctant readers, who are after something fairly short and easy to access, while eager readers who are after something different and amusing will really enjoy it.
Pat Pledger

Olivia's first term: Stage school by Lyn Gardner

cover image

Nosy Crow, 2011. ISBN 9780857630162.
(Age 11+) Recommended. Olivia and her younger sister Alicia, who is known as Eel, are free spirits. Their childhood so far has been spent as members of a circus family. Their father Jack is a famous highwire walker, and Olivia joins him in the performance. Tragedy had struck several years earlier when the girls mother died in an accident, and tragedy strikes again when Jack is injured. Jack's only option is to place the girls with their maternal grandmother - a woman who blames him for taking her only daughter away. Olivia and Eel discover their grandmother runs a well known and highly regarded performance school called Swan Academy. While Eel embraces the school and all it has to offer, Olivia pines for her old life and her father.
Olivia's first term is a delightful story with believeable characters. Olivia's strong personality is displayed in various situations, and her angst at being away from her father is clearly presented. The secondary characters have been fleshed out enough for the reader to feel a connection with them. There is the 'typical' group of characters which are often found in books aimed for this market. The mean girl is a bully and a showoff, but because of her good looks and wealth is fawned over by the other students. Gardner also has the poor but talented girl trying hard to fit in, and willing to do almost anything to achieve popularity. Olivia's first term explores the issues of family, loss, harrassment, bullying and ostracism. This book would appeal to upper primary students, although Gardner at times uses quite sophisticated language, which may mean it was intended for an older age group.
Sharon Kretschmer

The pout-pout fish by Deborah Diesen

cover image

Ill. by Dan Hanna. Scholastic, 2011. ISBN 9781 74283 006 3.
Picture book. The pout-pout fish with its very 'botox' filled lips, lies at the bottom of the ocean disconsolate. His lips are big and glum looking, putting other fish off. He asks many fish, his friends, about what to do, but they all ask him to smile, not to be so glum, turn his lips upside down. Fish ask him not to greet him with a scowl, but he cannot help it, it is the way his lips just are. Eventually he lies upside down on the bottom of the sea and a fish going by, seeing his lips upside down, kisses him, on his beautiful kissable lips. This turns his life around.
Told in rhyme, the story will entice younger readers to predict what will happen with the rhyming lines and offer suggestions for words that rhyme with the line before. The illustrations will prove enticing for curious readers, seeking out all the sea creatures shown on each page. And of course, all end up kissing the glum looking fish, encouraging the students to talk about the value of appearance and judging people by their appearance.
Fran Knight

Literature to support the Australian curriculum: annotated lists of fiction and poetry by Fran Knight

cover image

Pledger Consulting, 2011. ISBN 978 187667825 8.
Recommended. Once again Fran Knight lends us her prodigious knowledge of children's and young adult literature to support and extend our students' experiences of quality literature. It is well nigh impossible for busy teachers and teacher-librarians to keep pace with the publishing scene. We rely on wonderful people such as Fran Knight to guide us through the myriad of works published. She lets us into the secrets of which books are worth us exploring with our students.
In this publication Fran has collected together many of her favourite titles and sorted them into the Cross-Curriculum Priorities of the Australian curriculum- Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander histories and cultures; Asia and Australia's engagement with Asia and
Sustainability. Each category is sorted again into 3 age bands: Entry level - Year 3; Year 4-6 and Year 7-10. Also included are very useful chapters on Poetry, Class Text suggestions and Read Alouds for Entry level- Year 6.
In this way she enables teacher-librarians to be ahead of the pack and encourage teachers to pick up on the Cross-Curriculum Priorities which may be overlooked in the initial flurry of preparation to teach the new curriculum topics. Similarly the chapter on poetry supports the strengthened emphasis on poetry in the English curriculum. Given one of the English curriculum's underpinning foci, 'the close analysis of literary works' and thus the need for schools to access class texts, the chapter on class texts is very timely.
The publication, which is well designed, being clear and easy to access, includes a useful index of authors. It will prove a real 'boon' to busy teacher-librarians and teachers.
Diana Warwick
Editor's note: A sample of the book and order form is available at http://www.readplus.com.au/resources.php

Interview with Dawn Meredith by Fran Knight

cover image

Interview with Dawn Meredith by Fran Knight
Meeting an author in a bookshop leads to all sorts of discussions about books and their future, and so talking to Dawn Meredith at Mary Martin's on the Parade, Norwood, led us in quite different directions surrounded by the end product of the work done by people such as she.  I am grappling with all the ideas about the future of books, now that the digital age is here, but not so Dawn. She is adamant that there will always be a place for books, the tactile and intimate awareness of the book cannot be replaced by an electronic gadget. I am hopeful that she is right, and looking at her blog tells me that this belief is heartfelt, as her mission statement confirms: her desire is to get kids away from computers and back into reading. Armed with a concern such as this cannot be easy when faced with the array of computers and electronic devices now attached to modern kids, but she espouses the view that while these are necessary they need to be tempered in their use.
A special eduction teacher, Dawn is now training to be a counsellor, as she feels that much of her work with remediation of kids' learning is dependent upon counselling. Between writing and studying, she works at a writers' centre and offers writing workshops herself, while working at the Springwood Children's Learning Centre. Through these she sees the end result of kids who have lost their way with reading and so spends a lot of time teaching reading and writing. This is reflected in the workshops she has taken while in South Australia with schools at Victor Harbor and in Adelaide. A gig at Victor Harbor Primary School saw her workshopping 23 classes during the week, and her open door policy at lunch time meant that many more children were able to spend time on a one to one basis, sharing their writing and ideas.
Dawn has had a number of books published, some in the wonderful Livewires Real Lives series, telling the stories of some of our foremost citizens in an easy to read, direct style suitable for those readers who find reading more difficult. These include those by Dawn, Sir Donald Bradman and Tony Lockett, and although out of print, are likely to be reprinted soon, so popular is this series. Pearson Education has also published The Wobbly Wombat, by Dawn and several other books in the successful Blueprint series by Pearson, feature her work. The Wobbly Wombat is about bullying and the way to overcome it, as wombat, small for his age and a little wobbly on his short legs is derided by others. He retreats to the forest where he meets a variety of animals who tell him how to overcome the intimidation he receives. Their sage advice helps him achieve this, and in a smart resolution learns that he has friends. Her story, The Anything Shop is soon to be released by Wombat, a relative newcomer to the publishing industry in Australia.
Her two books in the Livewires Real Lives series espouses another of her missions, that of creating books for boys. She believes that many boys do not have a significant male in their families to mentor their reading and so it is important for boys to be targeted in schools. A display which caught her eye at one Adelaide school, had an array of photos of the male staff reading, a promotion by the library to encourage boys into its doors (scroll down to June 16 on her blog for more information. )
Armed with such resolve to encourage boys reading and focus her books on the needs of those within the school community to overcome bullying, there will be more books on the shelves by Dawn Meredith, so watch out for them.
Dawn has been in South Australia as a recipient of the May Gibbs Fellowship, allowing her to stay in an apartment at Norwood for a month to enable her to write. This venture has seen a number of authors who are now well known staying in South Australia. Past recipients include Shaun Tan, Karen Tayleur, Lorraine Marwood and John Nicholson.
More about the May Gibbs Fellowship can be found here.
While in South Australia, Dawn has been working on several projects for publishers and we wish her well.
28/6/11

The House of 12 Bunnies by Caroline Stills and Sarcia Stills-Blott

cover image

The House of 12 Bunnies by Caroline Stills and Sarcia Stills-Blott
Ill. By Judith Rossell. Little Hare, 2011. ISBN 9781921714405.
(Age: Preschool to Yr 2) In the house of 12 bunnies, it is nearly bedtime but Sophia has lost something. Unfortunately, this is not an orderly, organised household and Sophia has a difficult time finding what she is looking for. But Sophia needs it if the bunnies are ever to get to bed to sleep peacefully so she perseveres.
And the young reader perseveres with her, having the most delightful time finding all the other items mentioned in the text, and, at the same time, trying to work out what it is that Sophia is looking for.
Miss 5-on-Sunday and I had a great time with this book, not only finding the items but also thinking about the sorts of places we could look in the kitchen, the dining room, and even outside as well as the sorts of things we might find there. (This sort of classifying and categorising is the very beginning of information literacy - putting like with like to be organised.) We did get distracted when we searched the piano though, because maybe the item was inside it and the only way to find that out is to sit down and play a few notes! But, because Grandma had had a sneak peek at the last page, eventually we were able to find just what we (and Sophia) were looking for, right where we left it.
This book works on so many levels. Its storyline is engaging and intriguing because the readers doesn't know what Sophia has lost so has to predict; its illustrations are rich and detailed and as well as finding all the items, they have to be counted to ensure they are all there; there's scope to explore colours, patterns and designs; and each page has a different preposition of position (maths and mapping) to explore. It's very clever and reflects a sound understanding of the needs of this age group, so while it entertains it subtly educates. It can be read over and over with something new to focus on each time, and just cries out for all sorts of follow-up activities, both at home and at school.
Linking literacy, numeracy and information literacy can be a challenge but this book nails it. It's a great opportunity to show our classroom-based colleagues that information literacy is integral to everything and that we can offer more than literature appreciation.
Barbara Braxton

The wide-awake princess by E.D. Baker

cover image

The wide-awake princess by E.D. Baker
Bloomsbury, 2010. ISBN 978 1408807576.
(Age 11+) The wide-awake princess can be described as a magical journey with twists and turns on every page and it will make the reader think twice about the many fairytales they have read as younger children. This novel is aimed at girls, aged 11+, who are independent readers but adults alike will enjoy it too (I know I did). The author, E.D. Baker, incorporates a variety of fairytales, from Hansel and Gretel to Rapunzel, as we follow the story of Sleeping Beauty.
Our main character is Annie, the younger sister of Sleeping Beauty (or Gwendolyn as she is known in the text). She is the only one in her land who is not affected by magic - a handy gift to have as she and her friend Liam search the lands for princes, hoping one of them will have the power to wake her sister and her kingdom from a deep sleep. It was a joy to read a story with a strong female lead who rescues the boys rather than having to be rescued by them!
Annie and Liam invite many princes to come but who will be the one whose kiss will wake Sleeping Beauty - spoiled Clarence, Digby who spends too much time in the tavern or maybe Emilio who used to be a frog? And what about Liam? It's only on this journey that Annie starts to learn more about him. What is his secret and will it affect Annie forever? Could he be the one with the magical kiss?
Kylie Kempster

Red glove by Holly Black

cover image

Curse Workers Book 2. Orion Books, 2011. ISBN 9780575096769.
(Age 14+) Recommended. The second in the series, following White cat, lives up to the promise of the first and is another compulsive read from Holly Black. Cassel Sharpe is having problems. He has discovered that he is a transformer, a powerful curse worker who can transform anything he touches into something else. His brothers have manipulated his memories and he doesn't realise what he has done. When Philip, his older brother is murdered, the FBI recruits him to find the killer. He has one clue, a picture of a woman in red gloves who entered his brother's apartment. While investigating he is confronted with more visions of what he had done while under the influence of his brothers and worse of all, Lila, the girl he loves, has been placed under a love spell by his mother and he knows he can't trust her emotions.
After a slightly slow start, as I didn't have White cat on my shelves to refresh my memory about preceding events, the pace picked up and I found myself engrossed in Cassel's dilemmas. I really like the character of Cassel and the fact that it is told from the point of view of a boy, who tries to be good, but is surrounded by the Mob and his dodgy family. But being good by Cassel's standards usually means a con of some sort and Cassel has the ability to con the best of them.
The idea of someone having the ability to transform objects is fascinating and I loved the gory descriptions of what Cassel had transformed. It's also thought provoking to imagine just how much self-control a worker who could transform needed to have. Imagine if you lost your temper easily! Whether curse workers should be protected is also explored with Daneca, Cassel's friend, waving banners and her lawyer mother being prepared to help Cassel (after a small con on his part!)
The love interest was also handled really well. It was refreshing to see a young man trying to do the right thing and not take advantage of Lila, and the surprise conclusion will have me coming back for the next episode in their relationship. But the love interest, while very important, is not the central focus of the book. It is whether Cassel can resist the lure of becoming an assassin, and try to remain true to the goodness in his character.
Holly Black has written a unique and fascinating book, with enough twists and turns to appeal to both boys and girls. I can't wait for the next in the series.
Pat Pledger

The opposite of Amber by Gillian Philip

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2011. ISBN 9780747599920.
(Age: 15+) Recommended. 'Words are powerful': Ruby tells us this at the beginning of the novel but it takes time to fully realize the truth of this statement. Ruby is careful with words, she uses them sparingly. Words change lives, words cause harm; silence is safer.
After their mother died, Ruby and her sister Jinn lived together in their council home. Although Jinn was only 19, she was caring and competent, and capably adjusted to running the household and caring for Ruby; at least she did, until Nathan Baird arrived on the scene.
One by one girls are taken. Murdered. The police know it is the same perpetrator, but he is clever. He leaves the girls in water, destroys all evidence. Ruby notices the girls, remembers reading the newspaper articles, knows how close to home the murders occur. She isn't scared: he murders prostitutes.
The Opposite of Amber is a powerful and absorbing novel. Ruby is a strong and self-reliant character who takes life seriously. She understands the impact one life can have on another. She understands the importance of choosing her words carefully and choosing when to stay silent.
Sue Mann

The Throne of Fire by Rick Riordan

cover image

The Kane Chronicles. Puffin, 2011. ISBN 978 0141 335667.
The Throne of Fire is the much awaited sequel to The Red Pyramid. The extraordinary adventures of Carter Kane and his sister Sadie whose Egyptian roots have come forward in time to thrust them into the perennial war between good and evil. The Kanes and their cohorts gallop at break neck speed as the forces of evil build to threaten the existence of Earth itself. The powers of the ancient Egyptian gods have to be learned, as does the use of the mysterious conduit of the duat. They achieve their goals by the skin of their teeth but leave the reader wondering what will happen next - and when will the third in the Kane Chronicles be ready. The young teen readers (and older ones too) who enjoy a complex adventure with an Egyptian flavour will love this carefully crafted read.
Sue Whittaker (Primary teacher librarian)

Code Lightfall and the Robot King by Daniel H. Wilson

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2011. ISBN 978 1408814192.
Code Lightfall is the unlikely name of a shy boy whose best friend, his grandfather, is missing presumed dead. During a school excursion to the place where his grandfather was last seen, he falls (like Alice in Wonderland), down a hole to an amazing place of metal and robots. Wilson has created a novel land where grasses, bugs, walls transport - everything is made of metal, but has individual personality. Code adapts to this world quickly learning that everything has recently been programmed to disassemble. With the help of a quirky Slaughterbot he unwittingly created, and Peep, a robot bee like creature who befriends him, Code is drawn to the centre of the robot world with the twin desires of stopping the disassembly and maybe finding news of his grandfather. An unusual, surprising ending with hints of more to come. This very readable, linear style novel will appeal to students in years 4-6.
Sue Whittaker (Primary teacher librarian)

Stormasaurix by Mac Park

cover image

Boy vs Beast: Battle of the Mutants. Pop and Fizz/Scholastic Australia, 2011. ISBN 978 1921684296.
First thought - this reminds me of a computer game! A good tactic to encourage young boys to read!
Beast vs. Boy Stormasaurix is aimed at independent readers aged 7 to 9 years and uses short sentences to help make keep meaning clear and to give a sense of excitement. The large font is also a good way to encourage young readers to try reading a short novel as it makes it seem like there isn't a lot to read. Pop and Fizz and Scholastic have used black and white illustrations which show the cards of different beasts as well as other computer style images such as controllers, communication devices and secret lairs. Part of the text even uses a comic strip to explain what happens.
Our story begins with a prologue, introducing any new readers to the background information they might need to help understand the storyline of the series. We meet young Kai Masters, a border guard who defends the human world against the different beast worlds. In this book, he  is headed for the Wind Land. Kai is in training to become a border captain and the more battles he wins, the more battle gear he collects (hence my computer connection). Kai and his dogbot, BC3, head off on this mission to stop the chaos in the Beast Worlds but let's hope he has chosen the correct battle gear as he flies in to confront wild dust storms, rock birds and a new mutant beast - the Stormasaurix.
Kylie Kempster