Reviews

The Shattering by Karen Healey

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 9781741758818.
(Age 13+) Recommended. I love a good mystery and when I read the blurb on the back of The Shattering I knew that I was going to read something different. Keri has a plan for what to do if a member of her family was murdered. 'It went:
1. Find the killer.
2. Make sure that they were guilty.
3. Destroy them. Completely.'

Keri's older has committed suicide and Keri is devastated. She just can't believe that Jake would do that. When Janna and rich boy Sione, who have also lost brothers through suicide, come up with a theory that young boys are being murdered she is all too ready to accept it. Together they start researching and a pattern that indicated foul play, begins to emerge. But what happens when they get too close to the truth?
The idyllic setting of Summerton, in the South Island of New Zealand, provides a beautiful but occasionally sinister background as Keri and her friends investigate the increasingly frightening events that unfold. Why does no one ever leave Summerton? How does it survive when other coastal towns face financial disaster?
Healey's first book, Guardian of the dead was a fantasy, but in this one, although she has some paranormal elements, including witchcraft, she concentrates very successfully on the murder mystery. Janna has dabbled in witchcraft, but the local coven wouldn't accept her. When she suggests that magic may play a part in the mystery, Keri is sceptical, but is willing to search out the truth.
An array of characters and descriptions of family life enrich this novel. Healey portrays a family almost coming apart from the stress of a suicide: Keri's mother is over-protective and can't bear to face Christmas. Keri copes by having a plan for every eventuality even though she knows objectively that that can't work. Sione has lived in the shadow of his brother and is struggling to emerge and Janna opts for a high profile to hide any inadequacies.
Woven throughout the mystery story are the themes of suicide, living in a sibling's shadow and grief. These and other teen issues are handled well by Healey who is certainly an author whose work I will continue to seek out. Links to information about suicide are given at the end.
It is recommended for teens who like mysteries with authentic characters and plenty of suspense.
Pat Pledger

The mole hunt by Paul Collins

cover image

The Maximus Black Files. Book 1. Ford St, 2011. ISBN: 9781921665264.
(Age 13+) Highly recommended. Wow, what a high speed, action packed science fiction adventure story! Maximus Black is handsome, highly intelligent and out to bring RIM down and take over the world. Anneke Longshadow is a brilliant RIM operator who is determined to find the mole in the organisation, before he does irreparable damage. Together they speed across the universe in a spate of high action chases that take the breath away. Combine that with a lot of high tech gadgets, wicked weapons and intriguing disguise programs, and the book is a winner. (A longer synosopsis of the plot, written by Paul, can be read here.)
It's a pleasure to read a novel by an Australian author that is full of action, adventure and intriguing characters. I was swept along by the competition between Maximus Black and Anneke. Although I knew that Maximus was the baddie, Collins managed, with skilful characterisation, to make him into a strangely likeable character and I can't wait for the next two installments in the series to find out about his motivation for taking over the world. Anneke is a wonderful character, and I just loved her strength and fighting powers.
Readers who enjoyed the Alex Rider series will be happy to find another book to go on with. Older teens who liked the television show, Dexter, will also enjoy this portrayal of a seriously flawed but compelling character as he manipulates the world around him. I also think that this would be a good choice to be promoted for reluctant readers, especially boys, but girls will love it too, as Anneke Longshadow is a great character.
A blog post by Paul, who talks about his journey as a writer is also available.
Pat Pledger

Trash by Andy Mulligan

cover image

David Fickling Books, 2011. ISBN 978038561902 8
(Ages 12+) Highly recommended. Thriller. When two boys find a wallet with a key, some money and a letter on their morning trawl through the rubbish heap called Behala, they are stunned. Not the usual shuppa, paper filled with shit, or the leavings of the city, the rotting food, rags and paper, but money. They seek out Rat, who they know will be able to hide their find while they work out what to do. They are the lowest of the low, the poorest of people, the ones who reuse rubbish for a living Illiterate, relying on food and a smattering of education from the local Catholic priest, they are emaciated, smelly and fast.
When the police swarm over Behala asking if anyone has found something, they are quiet, it's never a good idea to be mixed up with the authorities. But Gaudo's mother calls out that the boys have found something and almost swallows her words. The boys try to explain that it was nothing, but they become targets, and one is taken by the police and brutally questioned.
The boys begin to realise that they have found something quite significant, and so begin to piece together the information they have about the wallet and its contents. Furtively, using their skills learnt on the streets, they collect what is in the locker belonging to the key they found, from there they seek out the owner of the letter, a man in jail, near death. They find that he was the servant to a wealthy embezzling senator who lost a great deal of money, and the boys work through the clues given to finally unravel the mystery of where the money was hidden.
A fascinating story of the boys using their learnt skills surviving in this the poorest of places, to outwit the authorities and find the hidden money, ensuring their own futures, will have kids eagerly reading to the end. Along the way they will learn of how some other children in the world live, those on the streets in Manila, a stunning contrast to the wealth of that place, and the ease in which we live.
Fran Knight

Haunting Violet by Alyxandra Harvey

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2011. ISBN 9781408811313.
(Age 13+) Recommended. Harvey is the author of the Drake Chronicles, one of my favourite paranormal series, so I was intrigued to find that she had written a ghost story set in Victorian times. I discovered that this talented author can transfer her writing skills to another period and type of book to make a very engrossing read.
'Violet Willoughby doesn't believe in ghosts but they believe in her'. (Back cover). Daughter of a fraudulent medium, Violet knows all about the tricks that make credulous people believe in spirits. When she is visited by the ghost of a drowned girl at the house of the wealthy Lord Jasper, a Spiritualist, she is at first disbelieving and then determined to find the girl's murderer. Colin, the boy her mother took in when he was orphaned, is around to help.
Part ghost story and part murder mystery, with a hint of romance thrown in, Haunting Violet is a compulsive read that I finished in one sitting. I felt I was really familiar with the historical period of the late 1880's by the time I was finished the book. The inflexible class structure, belief that loved ones wanted to communicate from beyond death, the plight of women and the fear of poverty provided a colourful background to the story. Harvey described lots of interesting snippets about the obsession that many Victorians had with reaching out to the spirits of their loved ones using seances. The stigma of illegitimacy touches Violet and the heart wrenching treatment she receives from both her father and her suitor as well as society reflects the rigid attitudes of the times. Violet, however, is a resilient girl, who is conscious of her own worth and is determined to do the right thing regardless of what other people think of her. She accepts that she does have unique gifts and puts them to good use to discover the murderer, while fighting her mother's wishes to exploit her.
The murder mystery aspect is also handled really well, with lots of red herrings thrown in to misled the reader. Harvey has the happy knack of being able to write prose that is humorous as well, so I had many chuckles as I read this book.
This is a book that will be enjoyed by those who enjoy a mix of mystery, ghosts and humour.
Pat Pledger

Thyla by Kate Gordon

cover image

Random House Australia, 2011. ISBN 9781864718812.
(Age 13+) Recommended. Tessa was found in a cave in the bush, dirty, ragged and with her memory gone. 'My name is Tessa. I am strong. I am brave. I do not cry. These are the only things I know for certain.'(Back cover). Connolly, a policewoman found her a place in a boarding school. Connolly's daughter, Cat, had disappeared from there and Tessa is convinced that there is a connection between Cat and herself. As her memory gradually comes back and the strange stripes on her back begin to darken, Tessa begins to make connections with the cruel mysteries that have brought her to this place.
Gordon has made a fascinating foray into the paranormal fantasy genre. Her Australian setting of the mountains and bush in Tasmania, of thylacines and convicts, gives it a unique flavour and will certainly appeal to readers who enjoy the vampire story. I started this book thinking that it may be about the adventures and feelings of a feral girl found in the wilderness, but Gordon gave me many surprises as she led me on a exciting read of people with incredible powers in a fight against evil predators. To say more would spoil the story!
Gordon's use of Australian history made this an original story that kept me reading. I loved the information about the Female Factory in Hobart and the plight of women in convict times. I also loved the descriptions of the cliques in the modern boarding school and how girls can manipulate and bully. But most of all I enjoyed Tessa's coming of age as she discovers who she is and what she is capable of. There is a slight hint of romance, which no doubt will be explored more in Vulpi, the next in the series.
With its accessibility and Australian setting, it should make a good contrast to all the American paranormal romances that are around at the moment. It is certainly worth having on the library shelf or using in the classroom.
Pat Pledger

Super diaper baby 2: The invasion of the potty snatchers by Dav Pilkey

cover image

Scholastic 2011. ISBN 9780 54511 533 6.
(Ages 8+) Humour. By the author of the Captain Underpants series, now numbering 12 and just as popular as when the first appeared, a younger version has been published to tempt the lower primary aged students, using a comic style format. With its emphasis on poo/bum/toilet jokes the book is designed to please that range of kids and make them yearn for more.
Dr Dilbert Dinkle the antihero, started out as an ordinary evil person, but he woke finding himself transformed into a puddle or pee and so vowed to demolish every toilet in town. From this inviting yet very strange premise the story begins, with our heroes, Super Diaper Baby and Diaper Dog hot on the trail of the toilet smashers. A page turner, with clearly written script and invitingly funny illustrations, kids will love following the antics of Dr Dinkle as he tries every scenario to demolish every toile that he and his crazy cat, Petey, can find.
Kids who loved the Captain Underpants series will find much to love in this new series, using the graphic novel style to grab kids' attention.
Fran Knight

The encyclopedia of my immaturity by Klutz

cover image

Scholastic Australia, 2011. ISBN 9781591749233.
(7-11) Recommended.This book is more of an activity book than a reading book but is still fun to read the writing that is there with lots of quirky and cheeky activities that parents would probably not what their kids to do in real life, such as defacing pictures etc (but nothing too bad). It's filled with fun activities to keep children happy through the school holidays or on weekends.
Although most of the activities were fun and I enjoyed doing them, I did find that parts of the book were not very interesting and it sort of felt like schoolwork. It was also a bit childish in parts because it was written by adults trying to relate to kids, which doesn't always work. Also, some of the terms used are very 'American', such as Candy Corn and bouncy house which I found a bit annoying, and at first I was not sure what they meant, but apart from that it is good.
I think that the pictures are interesting and explain the activities very well. I feel that the authors have created this book to entertain you and get you thinking about silly situations while encouraging kids to express their thoughts in writing. I would definitely recommend this book to my friends.
Jessica Marnie (Student)

The Scourge of Jericho by Stuart Daly

cover image

The Witch Hunter Chronicles. Random House Australia, 2011. ISBN 9781742750521.
(Ages 13+) In 1666 the Scourge of Jericho has been found after over 100 years of being missing and Jakob von Drachenfels is in the group going to retrieve it. He has always wanted to be part of the Hexenjager, a group of Witch Hunters in the Holy Roman Empire, but when he does get in it is because of lies on a letter of introduction from his uncle that he forged. Now he is on his way to Schloss Kriegsberg, a castle in the foothills or the Harz Mountains deep in the heart of witch country. The castle is home to the Blood Countess, hundreds of witches and is the lying place of the Scourge of Jericho. Jakob is terrified. He has never used a gun or a sword. The only things he has learnt with a sword were from a book he brought and the closest he has been to a battle field is reading books with battles in them yet on his first encounter with witches he takes down three.
This book was great, just when you think it is finished and they are safe something else will happen that yet again puts their lives in danger. I would recommend it to people who like books about witch hunting with heaps of twists. There are a lot of things in this book based on real things eg. the Blood Countess in this book is also known as Countess Gretchen Karus. She is completely fictional but is based on the real-life Countess, Elizabeth Bathory.
Tahlia Kennewell (Student)

Mary Hoffman, guest blogger

cover image

It is a thrill to have Mary Hoffman, author of the new historical book David, as the ReadPlus guest blogger. I loved her Stravaganza sequence and Stravaganza: City of Secrets was nominated for the Carnegie Medal. Troubadour was another favourite and it was nominated for the 2010 Carnegie Medal and shortlisted for the Costa Book Award. The Falconer's Knot was shortlisted for the Guardian Fiction Award and winner of the French Prix Polar Jeunesse 2009.
Here is a thought provoking article from Mary on versatility:

Michelangelo was immensely versatile - a sculptor, painter and architect - he even wrote poetry! That was not considered so unusual in Renaissance Florence, where Lorenzo de'Medici, Michelangelo's patron, known as 'the Magnificent,' had set the bar pretty high.
More importantly, the arts as we know them had not separated out into the distinctive disciplines we recognise today. Indeed the terms 'artist' and 'work of art' had not been invented. Leonardo da Vinci was another versatile man of what we now call 'genius,' who might be engaged on a painting one day and designing fortifications the next.
The more specialised the separate branches of the arts have become, the less likely is it that anyone will excel in more than one. I've tried to think of twenty-first century examples and failed. But in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries they were not so unusual:
William Morris was a writer, painter and designer; John Ruskin a critic and an artist too; David Jones a poet and painter; Wyndham Lewis a painter and novelist; Mervyn Peake an artist as well as a fantasy writer. Just a handful of names and all male, but it's hard to think of anyone so versatile across the arts today. (Oh, but Philip Pullman and J.K.Rowling can both draw - rather well).
At some point in the history of European culture, and specifically British culture, a mistrust of too much versatility crept in: a horror of dilettantism, leading to that most ungenerous of appellations - 'Jack-of-all-trades, master of none'. We are supposed to learn how to do one thing and stick at it. Hence the focus on 'specialising' in schools by taking 3 or 4 A levels, as opposed to the European system of the Baccalaureat.
Would a Michelangelo or Leonardo be welcome among us today? Or would he or she suffer from 'Tall Poppy Syndrome' - a desire by other people to cut the outstanding down to the same size as everyone else? I remember this happening to Kenneth Branagh, the actor, when he started his own theatre company as director and dared to write his autobiography in his twenties.
Even within the small cultural subsection that is children's literature, I have noticed a mistrust of those who don't stick to one genre or age-group. They often have to use pseudonyms, especially if they are prolific. Whereas my heroine and role-model is Margaret Mahy, a writer who excels in picture books, junior fiction and wonderful teenage novels like The Changeover and is as at home in poetry as prose. Dammit, she even wrote a reading scheme and made it funny and memorable!
I interviewed her once and praised her for her versatility. She said that if she was lucky, when she had an idea, it brought with it a sense of the length and genre that it would fit into - a marvellous answer.
I think versatility will make a come back; it's no good being a one-trick pony in a recession. People will have to turn their hands to lots of things and the world might end up being a better place for it.
Mary Hoffman

You can find Mary at the following places:
Website: http://www.maryhoffman.co.uk
Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/@MARYMHOFFMAN
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/maryhoffman.fanpage
Blog: http://www.bookmavenmary.blogspot.com

Pat Pledger (Editor)

One small island by Alison Lester and Coral Tulloch

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 978 0 670 072363.
(Ages 8+) Highly recommended. Picture book. Environment. A stunning portrayal of the Southern Aurora greets the reader as they pick up this inviting book, containing information about Macquarie Island while telling the story of the place and how it has survived the ravages of our invasion.
The endpapers welcome the readers with a beautiful map alongside the factual tale of the island's history from tis geological past to the present day.
Opening and ending with a stunning vista of this isolated island from the perspective of the albatross, the book implores us to help save this precious place, and so all such places. Each double page spread separated by these endpapers alternates between pages seemingly from a note book with snippets of hand written information gathered in the field, with drawings and sketches of things seen, and paintings that fill the double page, with a single clear message. About half way through the book, for example, is a double page of information about the penguin oil industry taken from accounts at the time, with drawings of the places this was carried out, pictures of the penguins and of the ships involved in the trade. A gruesome read. Following that is a double page of penguins resting on their rocky shore, albatross in the deep grey sky, and seals beside them on the beach, with the information that the island became a wildlife sanctuary in 1933. The comparison between the two double pages will entreat readers to stop and give thought to the scale of that announcement and what it meant for the island. Other pages are similarly comparable. One about the arrival of people on its shores, and the next the destruction caused by the cats brought with them. Another showing the range of new wonders to be found on the island, the next the settlement by the sealers, with blood along the beach.
Each invites the reader to think further, to give thought to the fate of places such as this and hence to the wider world under threat from our encroachment. The last few pages tell the reader of some of the projects underway limiting the destruction caused, and the results of this, while the end comes back to the albatross in the sky looking down on an island somewhat different from the one at the start. A timeline, glossary and another map with climate statistics rounds off a spectacular book, a homage to Macquarie Island that will be sought after by teachers and students to use as part of their discussions about their environment, sustainability, conservation and rehabilitation.
Fran Knight

The comet box by Adrian Stirling

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 978 0 14 320610 1.
(Ages 12+) Recommended. Life in the 1980's is stunningly recreated for this story of suburban life, surmounted by routine and expectations adhered to, of problems hidden under the carpet and never spoken of, of boys wanting more than the life being offered. Andrew and his nuclear family live in the outer suburbs, where the fields ver the road are being remodelled for a new suburb and supermarket, the trees torn down, large tracts of land reshaped, and tunnels dug for huge cement pipes. It is the year of Halley's Comet, and Andrew's teacher asks the students to make a wish and place it in the Comet Box in the room, to be reveled next year. Andrew steals the box, wanting to know the secrets of his classmates and finds things about many of them that he has never noticed before.
But one day, after a loud argument at home, his sister, Amelia, disappears, and this changes the way people speak to him and his family, and the way the family operates. Loaded down with a lack og knowledge of what is happening within his family, Andrew seeks refuge with his best friend, Romeo, and together they become aware of other things in their suburb which have been kept secret.
A story overflowing with the sights and sounds of suburban Australia, languishing under its own vision of Nirvana, the veneer of respectability and contentment is eroded away by the ugliness underneath. Andrew is not told anything, he must work things out for himself, adding pieces of information together to eventually understand why his sister disappeared and why when brought home by the police, she runs off again. All the while the comet is drawing closer, and the secrets Andrew knows about his classmates must be returned to the box before anyone knows. The comet signifies change in the community, and while many of the issues which the children see as important to them remained unresolved, Andrew's family at least brings things to the surface.
Fran Knight

The grasshopper's run by Siddhartha Sarma

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2011. ISBN 978 1 408809402.
When the Japanese army invades India in 1944, self obsessed and deranged Colonel Mori orders the wholesale slaughter of the entire population of an innocent and unsuspecting village. Justifying the massacre on the pretext that the village could be hiding units of the British Army, Mori is in reality driven by vicious cruelty and a lust for military power and recognition.
Uti, a village youth who survives the initial attack, lies in wait and kills soldiers before being subdued and then horrendously tortured.
Siddhartha Sarma then introduces the character Gojen who has been Uti's close companion throughout his life, to the degree that they considered themselves brothers, having shared tribal ceremonies, education and family interaction.
As a gifted sportsman and academic, Gojen has enjoyed great success whilst studying at a European college in Bengal and is not troubled by any sense of inequality amongst his Colonial peers.
When he learns of the village's fate and the death of his soul brother, Gojen returns home traumatised and seeks to assist in avenging Ut's death by providing information gathered from British Military Intelligence. The boy practices target shooting and the reader appreciates that he is an accomplished long distance marksman who naturally desires to apply his skills against the Japanese. Gojen's father is relatively wealthy as an indigenous noble and forbids his son to join the foray into a battleground where the defending British are frantically mustering reinforcements against the seemingly unstoppable Japanese might.
Defying his father, Gojen sneaks out and joins other villagers intent on seeking revenge. The journey to find Mori is slow and many cultural relationships and local references are introduced, making the narrative difficult to follow for those unfamiliar with Indian social history.
In the turmoil of battle, the story gathers pace and the reader understands that the local Indians act in spite of, rather than in support of, the British who they still regard as an occupying force, albeit a more benign and constructive one compared with the Japanese.
Gojen wrestles with his own fear and Uti's spirit as events unfold.
Rob Welsh

Share by Anthea Simmons and Georgie Birkett

cover image

Random House Australia, 2011.  ISBN 978 1742750996.
(Ages 3-5) A board book for the very young is aimed specifically at teaching younger children to share. The young girl and her baby sibling are separate entities at the start of this tale, as the girl tells us how she loves her fluffy teddy, and her books of animals and her puzzle, but so does the baby and so mum's voice off page calls out that she must share her things, despite what happens to them as a result. Many children will identify with the young girl dismayed at her younger sibling's messing her things, and identify the voice calling out for them to share. After a few pages, the girl asks her mother whether she should share, changing the premise for the story. So the two begin to share things, her drink and her paints and her bath, and the girl begins to lessen her resistance to her sibling's interference.
At the end, the two are in bed together, and the baby asks the girl to share his bed, with the pair sharing their mother's hugs at the end.
This is a wholly delightful little tale, teaching the idea of sharing, and making it easier for the adult reading the book to the children to introduce the idea of sharing and pointing out the ways of sharing that can happen in a family.
Fran Knight

How I stole Johnny Depp's alien girlfriend by Gary Ghislain

cover image

Chronicle, 2011. ISBN 9780811874601.
(Age 12+) Recommended. David meets Zelda when she becomes a patient of his father, a renowned psychiatrist, looking after troubled youth. Zelda, who believes she comes from the planet Vahalal, is on a quest for the perfect mate and the picture she shows David is one of Johnny Depp. David, immediately smitten by her green eyes and mean ways, follows her on a frantic chase to find Johnny, jumping across the rooftops of Paris, stealing his mother's clothes and going to a weird shrine which would take then to Vahalal, if the tattoo key is used.
This is an absolute scream of a book. I was hooked from the moment I started reading it and laughed my way through the smart dialogue and action packed adventure. Ghislain takes a hilarious look at male celebrities with such comments as 'Brad Pitt, Johnny Depp, Robert freaking Pattinson! I don't care. We will abduct every single Hollywood stud if it will bring us back to Vahalal'. He also makes some very funny observations about how girls get hooked by celebrity looks and the impact of designer clothes and furnishing of the wealthy. David's mother is a very high powered woman whose designer clothes, in particular, a little bikini, proves too much of a temptation for Zelda the warrior woman. David trails behind her, trying to pick up the pieces at his mother's beautifully appointed apartment, and finally enlists the aid of his stepsister Malou in their quest to track down the elusive Johnny Depp.
David is no pushover. Zelda may come from a planet where men are not valued at all but David is smitten and is determined to get the girl and he takes the reader on a wonderful romp while he tries to figure out how he can do that. There are over the top ideas and action in this book, but it so amusing, fast paced and engrossing that I was happy to accept even the most improbable things and just enjoy the ride. I also loved the setting, first in the countryside of France and then in the wonderful city of Paris.
I think that it would make an excellent suggestion for reluctant readers, who are after something fairly short and easy to access, while eager readers who are after something different and amusing will really enjoy it.
Pat Pledger

Olivia's first term: Stage school by Lyn Gardner

cover image

Nosy Crow, 2011. ISBN 9780857630162.
(Age 11+) Recommended. Olivia and her younger sister Alicia, who is known as Eel, are free spirits. Their childhood so far has been spent as members of a circus family. Their father Jack is a famous highwire walker, and Olivia joins him in the performance. Tragedy had struck several years earlier when the girls mother died in an accident, and tragedy strikes again when Jack is injured. Jack's only option is to place the girls with their maternal grandmother - a woman who blames him for taking her only daughter away. Olivia and Eel discover their grandmother runs a well known and highly regarded performance school called Swan Academy. While Eel embraces the school and all it has to offer, Olivia pines for her old life and her father.
Olivia's first term is a delightful story with believeable characters. Olivia's strong personality is displayed in various situations, and her angst at being away from her father is clearly presented. The secondary characters have been fleshed out enough for the reader to feel a connection with them. There is the 'typical' group of characters which are often found in books aimed for this market. The mean girl is a bully and a showoff, but because of her good looks and wealth is fawned over by the other students. Gardner also has the poor but talented girl trying hard to fit in, and willing to do almost anything to achieve popularity. Olivia's first term explores the issues of family, loss, harrassment, bullying and ostracism. This book would appeal to upper primary students, although Gardner at times uses quite sophisticated language, which may mean it was intended for an older age group.
Sharon Kretschmer