Reviews

Titanic: death on the water by Tom and Tony Bradman

cover image

A and C Black, 2012. ISBN 9781408155813.
(Age: 12+) At the age of thirteen, Billy is forced to join his father in Belfast constructing the 'unsinkable' Titanic. Billy finds the ship yards and the men employed there very intimidating, especially after a work accident claims his father's life. He decides that working as a bellboy on the big ship will be a much safer place for him than the construction yards.
At sea, Billy has to adapt to life away from his family and learn how to stand up for himself. His job involves looking after the first class passengers but he is also concerned with the welfare of less fortunate travellers.
2012 is the 100th anniversary of the sinking of the Titanic and this has rekindled public interest in the catastrophic event. Although this is a fictional account by a father and son team, it is based on research held in the UK National Archives. It is a well written story and an exciting introduction to the Titanic story for the younger reader.
Tina Cain

Andy Roid and the superhuman secret by Felice Arena

cover image

Penguin Australia, 2012. ISBN 9780143306030.
This is Book 1 of a new series by Felice Arena, remembered by many Primary school boys especially for his very popular Specky Magee books as well as the easily accessible Boyz Rule and Girlz Rock books.
Andy Roid is a 12 year old whose life is turned upside down when he is almost kidnapped on the way home. He luckily escapes on his bike, pursued by the kidnappers, only to run head on into a Mack Truck.
This should have been the end of Andy but, fortunately for him, his parents do not run a bakery and invent new muffin recipes as he believed, but are scientists who specialize in robotics and have just made a breakthrough in Biorobotics.
At his point I was with Andy. How could they reconstruct their son as a robot?  While I pondered this for some time, I am sure the intended audience will pass over the ethics of the operation without a blink and be as thrilled as Andy as he discovers the cool apps he has been given and how to turn them on. Welcome Andy Roid the android, a 12 year old modern version of the old 6 Million Dollar Man.
Andy finds it is not all fun and games as he heroically saves Molly, but has to keep his identity secret, think Superman, Spiderman and Co. The threat posed by the kidnapping crew of Dr Sylvester Baffi and the Triple S is ever present and will continue to play a part in future stories.
As fast paced as a cartoon this series is sure to appeal to those reluctant readers who will enjoy the action packed modern references.
Sue Keane

Erebos by Ursula Poznanski

cover image

Translated by Judith Pattinson. Allen and Unwin, 2012. ISBN 978 1 74237 953 1.
(Ages: 14+) Computer games. Sharp eyed Nick Dunmore sees small parcels being exchanged amongst the students at his school. His best friend, Colin is out of reach, will not speak to him at school, avoids any eye contact, does not answer his email or phone and seems to be creating a relationship with the two geeks in their class. Others are acting oddly as well, but when he corners one of them, he realises that they are all playing a game, a computer game with bizarre rules about communication, a game which seems to intrude on real life. When he is passed the disc, he too sees just how addictive the game can be, and from the start, the reader gets the feeling that these kids are being manipulated. Wishing to move from level two to three, the messenger offers him this option as long as he introduces another person, and gives him details about another boy in his class. The alert reader is aware that more is going on, but Nick is flattered and involved. Nick, now Sarius, must choose weapons, a name and skills to go into the game, and he finds that fighting to create a foothold on the next level requires some daring and skill. At times he must fight to the death. With the energy and seduction of a serial seen every Saturday at the local picture theatre (yes, I am that old!) this becomes an exciting read as Nick moves from one level to another, following the instructions and requests from the messenger.
When Nick is asked to put a drug in his teacher's thermos, the teacher who is asking questions and raising concerns, Nick baulks and in so doing is kicked out of the game. He desperately tries to get back into the game but when his best friend, Jamie is knocked off his bicycle and almost killed, Nick begins to see something sinister is happening, and so takes action, joining others to find the evil behind the game.
Slow to start, the book builds quickly into an absorbing thriller. Just like the game we are led down different paths, some dead ends, some red herrings, but all the while being led on to a stunning conclusion.
Smoothly translated, this book won the Youth Jury Award in the 2011 German Youth Literature Prize.
Fran Knight

Melody Burning by Whitley Strieber

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012. ISBN: 978 1 74237 913 5.
(Ages: 14+) Recommended. 'A girl rock star who's never been alone enough to fall in love. A boy runaway who's grown up so alone he doesn't even know what love is. A pyromaniac with a dangerous secret. An explosive romantic thriller. In the chutes and crawlspaces of an LA hotel lives a young runaway named Beresford. He has no idea who his parents were, but he does know that he's in love with rock superstarlet Melody McGrath. When she checks into Beresford hotel with her manipulative stage mother, a fatal secret is brought to light. Death is coming for Beresford and Melody. Will the wild child and the It Girl be able to keep their lives - and love - intact?'
As you can tell from the blurb, this book is very intriguing from all aspects. Strieber is known for his bestsellers in science fiction, most of which have become movies. Melody burning is his first book for young adults and in my opinion he has done a wonderful job, with a gripping story that has you enthralled until the last page and wanting more of the story. At the start of the story Beresford loses his father and nearly his own life; through the years that pass he forgets who he is, his name, age and life. He has no one until he meets the love of his life, Melody. He basically stalks her; he climbs into her room using the crawlspaces of the hotel just to know more about her. It is a wonderful love story with a terrifying peak of intensity where they nearly lose their lives and each other forever. A brilliant book by a breathtaking author, I hope to read more of his work in the future.
Taylor Oxenham (Student).

Frontier magic series by Patricia C. Wrede

cover image

Scholastic Press.
(Age: 11+) Recommended. The Thirteenth child and Across the Great Barrier are the first two books in a trilogy set in the wild west of an alternative America where magic is used as a natural part of the world. I loved the setting in this series. The idea of an alternative America, with pioneers getting land grants, and facing the dangers of strange wild animals, grabbed me and kept my interest through the two books. Wrede's magic, and the learning of the spells, is all set in a commonplace school, and seemed to me as the reader, to be as real as normal school lessons. (Apparently the fact that Native Americans do not feature as part of her world caused some controversy in the US).
Eff, short for Francine, is an engaging heroine, and it is her story of gradually being able to shed the stigma of being the 13th child, that is at the heart of the stories. Although she doubts herself, her goodness and compassion shine through the book. The relationship Eff has with her twin, Lan, and with William, a school friend, form a thread that keeps interest alive. Wash, a circuit guide, is also a fascinating character, and the interactions of members of such a large family were well written.
I await the third installment in the series to see just how much Eff comes of age and how she uses her magic powers.
Thirteenth child. Scholastic, 2009. ISBN 9780545033459. Eff is the 13th child and twin to Lan, who is the seventh son of a seventh son. Being the 13th is supposed to bring bad luck, and Eff has grown up believing that she does bring bad things to her family and town. When her family move to a school near the magical divide that keeps out the beasts of the wild, Eff begins to believe in herself.
Across the Great Barrier, Scholastic, 2011. ISBN 9780545033433. Eff, now almost grown up, goes out past the magical Great Barrier, as an assistant to a Professor, who is studying the effect of a magical bug on the countryside. The land is full of dangers, and Eff must come to grips with her magical powers to keep herself and the pioneers communities safe.
Pat Pledger

Not bog standard and other peculiar stories by Mark Pardoe

cover image

Omnibus, 2012. ISBN 978 1 86291 863 4.
This book is great fun. The stories have a twist and there are not always happy endings. Mark Pardoe will undoubtedly be compared to Paul Jennings as the format and stories are reminiscent whilst still being highly original. They have more of a darker flavor such as Message in a bottle and Fish out of water, both of which show the consequences of bad choices. Others have almost a supernatural element such as Clairvoyant canine and Get lost.
My favourite is Flu past about two boys who live in the same house on a farm but are separated by about ninety years. Hopefully there will be others to follow as they will appeal to readers who want variety in their stories and especially primary school boys.
David Rayner

Elephant alert by Jackie French

cover image

Ill. by Terry Whidborne. Animal Rescue series. Scholastic, Australia: 2012. ISBN 9781741698480.
Recommended for readers 8+. Jackie French has taken the plight of endangered animals as the theme of her new Animal Rescue series. With her easy to read style and engaging if unusually talented characters, her environmental message is conveyed with humour and action. Elephant facts at the end add to the veracity of the message.
Leo wishes something cool would happen as he sits talking with his guinea pig one hot afternoon. He is friendless and considered weird by his school mates. Then a robot gorilla arrives with an invitation to tea from Mozz, granddaughter of Dr Drizzsock, local scientist. Just a normal Sunday really!
This is the beginning of an amazing adventure to rescue elephants from a tsunami threatening to engulf their island home off of Sumatra. Leo's talent for speaking animal, rather than his friendship with Mozz, is the reason he finds himself in the Sky Tiger, a jet made entirely of recycled material, with Mozz and Fuzz, a jealous 3 legged woof pup, flying faster than the speed of sound.
With the occasional illustration to add to the narrative, this is an engaging series for the young adventurous environmentalist who will gain some information about endangered animals whilst enjoying the developing friendship between Mozz and Leo.
Sue Keane

Oh, No, Monster Tomato by by Jim Helmore and Karen Wall

cover image

Egmont, 2009. ISBN 9781405247412.
It was the time for the Great Grislygust Grow-Off when the residents tried to grow the biggest and best. This year, Marvin planned to grow the tastiest tomatoes in town, much to the disgust of brother and sister Boris and Prunella who mocked and bullied him. Motivated and showing remarkable resilience, Marvin plans and plants and waits and watches, while all around him the people of Grislygust seem to be having great success. Marvin is bamboozled, until he tries something very different. The results are quite magical and the ground begins to grumble and shake until Marvin has more than he bargained for.
This is a lovely story with bright, quirky illustrations, lift-the-flaps and humour that will delight the younger age group. Because the text is in handwriting interspersed with other fonts to provide emphasis, I think it is more a read-aloud or read-along rather than a read-alone. Throughout the story there are a number of opportunities to entice the children to predict what might happen next that will also keep them engaged. Miss 5, who adores tomatoes, really enjoyed the story and we are going to try to grow our own next spring - I do hope we don't have quite the dramatic results that Marvin did.
Barbara Braxton

Marngrook : A long ago story of Aussie Rules Football by Titta Secombe and Grace Fielding

cover image

Magabala Books, 2012. ISBN 9781921248443.
(Ages: 6+). Warmly recommended. Aboriginal stories. Australian Rules Football. I was initially surprised to receive another book detailing the Aboriginal origins of Australian Rules Football but upon reading this one found that the two books I have recently read fit well together.
Marngrook, subtitled, A long ago story of Aussie Rules Football, outlines the story of Wawi, who walking in the bush around the Grampians in Western Victoria, comes across a possum. Killing it with his boomerang, he skins it and uses the meat for a meal for his family. After eating, he carefully uses a sinew from a kangaroo tail, sewing up the possum skin into a roundish ball, stuffing it with emu feathers. When the last hole is sewn up, the shape resembles an emu egg, and the children run off playing with it, practicing their kicking and having fun despite their mother's call to collect wood.
This is a fascinating story of how the football came to be, and blends well with the picture book, Kick it to me by Neridah McMullin recently published by One Day Hill. This story tells the tale of Tom Wills, who growing up in Western Victoria played the game of marn-grook with his Aboriginal friends, later being able to suggest it as a new Australian sport.
The two stories sit well together, one from an Aboriginal perspective, and one from a European perspective, but both telling the tale of how Aussie Rules came to be, a subject dear to the hearts of many Australians, regardless of their origin.
In this book, Marngrook, the tale also shows Aboriginal family life, the skills of the hunter, the environment in which they live and their use of it as a place for food, clothing, weapons and playthings. Tucked within the story children reading it will also have a sense of the close knit community of Aboriginal people and their strong association with the land around them.
The naive painting style suits the book as it includes dots and traditional Aboriginal painting styles, not only telling the story through the illustrations, but also detailing the life and times of the people in the area.
Author, Titta Secpmbe is a descendant of the people who lived around the Grampians in Western Victoria, the Gunditj-marra-Jard-wa, and was brought up hearing this story, while illustrator, Grace Fielding grew up at the Wandering Mission near Perth and has won awards for her children's book illustrations.
Fran Knight

Ten Scared Fish by Ros Moriarty

cover image

Ill. by Balarinji Studio. Allen and Unwin, 2012. ISBN 978-1-74237-912-8.
(Recommended age: 2 years +) Ten scared fish is an excellent book for children because of the bright colours and large writing which is clear and easy to read.
The author and illustrators have worked well together as the pictures and text are very well matched . The simple text, complimented by the stylized graphics are very descriptive as well, as beautiful. The illustrations combine aboriginal symbols along with vivid colours and traditional patterns.
The animals in the story are turtles, snakes, shark and fish. The personality of the animals shine through despite the use of such simple drawings.
At first reading the book seems to be a simple counting book, as the animals are introduced one by one: the turtles, snakes, fish and finally shark. On closer inspection another layer of the story is revealed, as the environmental setting changes, flowing from the waterhole through the wetlands, to the river and finally to the ocean, where the fish are surprised and become scared.
Why would they be scared?
Reviewed by Year 6/7, Dunstan 2, Parkside Primary School, SA.

The Messy Mother's Day by Lucie Billingsley

cover image

Lothian Children's Books, 2012. ISBN: 987-0734412430. (Recommended ages: 3 year old listeners up to 6 year old readers). Everyone wants to give their mum the best Mother's Day, even Baxter the dog. In this fantastic rhyming book, a family tries to give their mother a great Mother's Day but Baxter the dog does a great deal of helping. What starts as a normal Mother's Day turns out to be a real mess.
The Messy Mother's Day uses rhyming and repetition, in a similar way to many picture books, to encourage young readers. Throughout the book the text is written creatively with some difficult words, used to build the children's vocabulary, written in a large bold font. The text fits in well with the descriptive and detailed pictures.
The Messy Mother's Day has really good illustrations. It is a wonderful, water-colour picture book. The book is colourful and helpful for young children learning to read. The creative pictures match the story line. There is an incorporation of mess throughout the pictures of the book.
Overall, an excellent picture book, good for young children, this book shows how families come together in times of need. Despite all the misery and mess, do you think mum will enjoy her Mother's Day?
Year 6/7 - Dunstan 1, Parkside Primary School, SA.

My marvellous Mum by Susannah McFarlane

cover image

Ill. by Lachlan Creagh. Little Mates (Series). Scholastic, 2012. ISBN 978 1 74283 224 1.
Picture book. Mother's Day. For the very young, this homage to mothers in the animal world has parallels to mothers in the human world, as two small animals have words to say about their fabulous mothers. The repetition of words beginning with M, is infectious, and listeners will have a fun time thinking what the next adjective might be in describing the attributes of the mothers portrayed. Max's Mum is miraculous because she is able to mend machines, while Matilda's Mum never misses a match, and can make her hurts go away. Each page has a positive attribute of the two mothers, ending with the annual Mother's Day picnic where, of course, all the things to eat begin with M.
The illustrations of the koalas and possums and their M words are cutely drawn and will encourage readers to look and laugh and predict, adding another to the Scholastic series of alphabet books for the young.
Fran Knight

Advent by James Treadwell

cover image

The Advent Trilogy: Book 1. Hodder, 2012. ISBN 9781444728477.
(Suited For: 16+) Recommended. Gavin Stokes is a regular city kid from London who thinks that his parents want nothing to do with him. Ever since he was a child, Gavin has seen things that no one else will believe. Sent to Cornwall to stay with his peculiar aunt, Gavin begins to uncover the source of his visions and the magic that surrounds them. An ancient magic, lost for centuries, which is only now returning to the world once more.
With the recent conclusion of the Harry Potter series still fresh in their minds, many readers could be forgiven for being somewhat tentative to delve straight back into the realm of fantasy and magic. Though Advent contains a boy-wizard of sorts, that is where the similarities stop. Treadwell has skilfully managed to breathe some much needed air back into the genre.
With an array of colourful characters combined with Treadwell's natural story-telling ability, Advent is an enjoyable read for all ages. At times it can be perhaps slow, which may disinterest younger readers, but the reader's attention is never entirely lost. Directed at a slightly older audience than that of the Harry Potter series, Advent has the potential to attract new readers to the genre whilst fans of the fantasy-magic variety will find themselves engaged in the originality of the story.
Advent is one of the better books of the fantasy-magic genre to come along since the inception of the Harry Potter series. The originality of the story combined with Treadwell's ability to keep the reader engaged throughout the entirety of the book make Advent an enjoyable read for all ages.
I recommend this book.
Michael Adams

Rama and Sita by Malachy Doyle

cover image

Ill. by Christopher Carr. Bloomsbury Books, 2012. ISBN 9781408139516.
(Ages 6+) Folk Tales. India.  With large, colourful and bold illustrations, the Indian folk story of Rama and Sita is given life in short, easy to read sentences and brief but vivid descriptions. The tale is of Sita, stolen by the Demon King and taken to his inaccessible island. Rima searches for her and being good and true, enlists the help of the monkey king who tells his followers to build a bridge to allow access to Rima and the demon king's army. They overpower the demon and his followers returning Sita to her rightful place.
This story reflects that goodness will overpower evil, just like the little oil lamp brings light to the darkness, and this story is remembered each year at the festival of Diwali, where lamps are lit to recall the story.
This book is one in a new series, Stories from World Religions, published by Bloomsbury in England, and would be a sound addition to a school library.
Fran Knight

Meet Nellie by Penny Matthews

cover image

Our Australian Girl (series). Penguin, 2012. ISBN 978 0 14 330623 8.
(Ages: 9+). Historical. Nellie has lived in the workhouse in Ireland, since the deaths of most of her family during the Great Hunger which struck Ireland in the middle of the nineteenth century when the potato crop failed. Unable to feed himself, let alone his daughter, her father placed her there, knowing she would have food and shelter. From there she was put aboard a ship bound for South Australia to work in the new colony.
So begins the story of Nellie, the fifth in the series of stories about girls throughout Australia's history, adding another 4 books to the 16 already published. She remains at the Depot where she is taken by a woman to be a helper in the kitchen at her boarding house. From Nellie's vantage point we see the colony and the new migrants who have come out to make a new life for themselves. Mrs Thompson who runs the boarding house has a husband working in the mines at Burra, several of the young men boarding with her work in places in Rundle Street, the centre of commerce, and we hear of the Governor, and the Aboriginal people on the streets. When the boarding house is destroyed in a fire, Nellie must fend for herself, as the family moves to Burra, and there is no room for Nellie.
Girls reading of Nellie will read of the perilous journey to Australia and the lack of protection these young girls had coming to a new colony, alone and without a family to support them.
For the 600 Irish workhouse girls who came to Adelaide, their lives must have been grim and Matthews' book will encourage its readers to think about this.
This is the first in the series of four books about Nellie, the second, being Nellie and the secret letter. As with all the others in this series, there is information about Nellie's time, facts about the date in Australia's history, an introduction to the next book, and an outline of the others in the series. The cover shows bits which have a significance to the story inside, and the charm at the top of the cover shows the date in which this book is set.
The whole series brings history alive for middle primary readers, and the books are supported with an extensive website.
with teacher notes.
Fran Knight