Reviews

The fault in our stars by John Green

cover image

Penguin, 2012. ISBN 9780143567592.
(Age: 13+ years) Highly recommended. John Green, author of Looking for Alaska and Will Grayson, Will Grayson, writes about teenage sufferers and survivors of cancer in his latest novel The Fault in our stars. The narrator, sixteen year old Hazel, has thyroid cancer which is being held at bay by a miracle drug. However, intelligent, clear-eyed and iconoclastic, she knows and accepts that the remission is temporary. Through Support Group, which provides her and the reader with some black humour, she meets other sufferers, one of whom is Augustus, a survivor of bone cancer. Hazel, knowing that her life will be short, does not welcome love and resists accepting it. However, Augustus is attractive, amusing, smart and consequently irresistible. Together Hazel and Augustus reject the glib assurances and encouragements offered by well-meaning but ignorant non-sufferers. They experience as much of life as they can, initially through reading. Hazel's favourite book is about a cancer family; she wants to find out what happens to the survivors, and the reader realizes that this is a central concern of her life. What will her mother, her very caring and loving mother, do when Hazel dies? Augustus uses his Wish (from a Cancer charity) to find the author who has no answers for them. However the trip to Amsterdam, complete with Augustus's prosthetic and Hazel's oxygen tanks, to find him becomes a memorable time for them as they experience happiness and have to accept its transience. Hazel, accepting of her future, unexpectedly has to be clear-eyed and resolute about another's suffering. Hazel learns that survivors must provide their own answers, and sufferers their own happiness, however fleeting. The word-play in the novel is a pleasure, and the insights into the lives of cancer victims seem perceptive and convincing. Ultimately the novel is very sad, but it is also very funny, and without being didactic offers some wisdom about what is important in life. It is highly recommended.
Jenny Hamilton

Try! by Sharon McGuinness

cover image

Ill. Tom Jellett. Self published flipbook and ebook. 2012.
"Jesse Baxter was crazy about football.
Not soccer.
Not AFL.
Not even rugby union. "
For Jesse, football meant league. Rugby league. Whenever he talked about football, Jesse's palms grew sweaty, his feet itched and his heart beat faster."
All Jesse wanted to do was play real football. But Jesse's mother did not agree - like most mums, she was concerned that he was too small for such a rough-and-tumble sport, particularly when Jesse's nickname was 'Flea'. But persistence (and taking out the garbage) pays off and Jesse gets to join a team. However, he soon learns that while being little can be a barrier, it's just a detour not a roadblock if you are really focused on your goal. His story of triumph over adversity will resonate with many.
Our very own Sharon McGuinness (of Mrs Mac's Library fame) has published this book just in time for the rugby league season when hundreds of Jesses will be signing up for their local league teams and watching their idols play on television. Using her teaching experience and teacher librarian expertise, Sharon has written it for those who are emerging readers ready for novels with short chapters interspersed with terrific illustrations, and is ideal for those boys who are looking for stories about their favourite game that they can read for themselves. It comes complete with links to follow that give more information about the sport, and teaching notes including an interactive whiteboard game and being able to colour the cover in your favourite team colours.There's even an opportunity to submit a book trailer which might be featured on the site.
Try! comes in two formats - a flipbook which is a pdf file that reads like a book for $5.00 or an ebook compatible with a variety of devices for $6.95. All the purchasing details are available from Sharon's new site, Mrs Mac's Books.
I've been anticipating the release of this book for quite some time now, and I'm so glad that it is finally here, because it will fill a gap and a need that will mean that the teacher librarian is just as much a hero as Jesse is. Congratulations, Sharon.
Barbara Braxton

A Midsummer Tights Dream by Louise Rennison

cover image

HarperCollins, 2012. ISBN: 9780007156849.
Tallulah Casey arrives back at Dother Hall Performing Arts College, excited about being reunited with her recently acquired friends Flossie, Honey, Jo and Vaisey. Amidst much hugging and hand knitted garments, she receives a warm welcome from her stand in parents, Mr. and Mrs. Dobbins and the twins, Max and Sam. In her 'squirrel room', Tallulah continues to write in her diary and measure the growth of her 'corkers'. Boarding in a private home and not at school, she enjoys having the freedom to visit Ruby, her bulldog Matilda and the baby owls. School resumes and she is immersed in the daily life. This is not without its ups and downs with regard to 'boy interests' of Tallulah and her group of friends. With a new musical to rehearse and family issues with which to contend, life is never dull and boring.
As with the Georgia Nicholson titles, Rennison has created a likeable, hilarious and endearing character in Tallulah and girls will be clamouring to read this series. With themes of friendship, crushes and snogging, acceptance of others no matter what their differences and a smattering of somewhat eccentric teachers and interesting vocabulary, this is another entertaining title. There are certain parallels between this and Sue Townsend's title The Secret Diary of Adrian Mole. I laughed out loud at the main characters in each book as they measured various parts of their anatomy to gauge their movement into adolescence. An easy read for girls in Upper Primary and early secondary school, I can see they will always be on loan and never on my library shelves!
Jo Schenkel

The alchemy of forever by Avery Williams

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2012. ISBN 9780857076816.
(Age: 12+) Seraphina was only 14 years old when she turned immortal. Her boyfriend Cyrus shared his father's formula for immortality with her, which enabled their souls to move from one body to the next for eternity, ending the life of the body's original soul in the process.
Nevertheless, Sera became tired of murdering innocent people once six hundred years passed. She came to a final decision to die and leave her controlling boyfriend behind, until she came across Kailey. Seraphina couldn't perform another murder on a young girl, even if Kailey's life was almost gone . . . But when she falls in love with Kailey's world, she realises that for the past few decades, she may have something to live for. But does it mean that Cyrus is ready to let her go?
The Alchemy Of Forever is written in the first person and is a fast paced novel. The style in which the author writes is likable from the beginning, especially when it came to the action bits, but the actual book is cold and expressionless. It's written in a diary form and not many descriptions were made of particular characters and settings. The Alchemy Of Forever is a somewhat interesting book, but I wouldn't suggest reading it more than once.
The characters didn't develop with the book, as they stayed the same for the whole story without changing, so it was quite boring when it came to dialogues. However when it came to action, such as the bit where Sera was running for her life, it was interesting to read. In fact the way Avery Williams was writing about it, the whole bit was quite fascinating.
This book will definitely not become a bestseller, but it is a good novel to read in your spare time, as it includes many interesting plot twists, with the main one at the end.
Nika Aroutiounian

Go Girl: Sink or swim by Thalia Kalkipsakis

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2012 ( first published 2008 ). ISBN 978 174297138 4.
(Age 7-10) The Go Girl books have been around for a few years but the recent publications are new stories with a new jacket style. This series is Australian and according to the publisher's website 'provide(s) simple, real-life stories about characters experiencing and exploring new situations . . .'
Bec in Sink or Swim is excited about being promoted to a new swimming group. She goes from being the best swimmer to the least experienced in her group. Everything is going fine until the big race when Bec becomes nervous about her performance.
Bec has to learn to deal with her anxiety and to trust her own abilities. This would be a situation that many children encounter and it gives them an insight into dealing with their own worries and stress.
Thalia Kalkipsakis has made Bec a believable character and girls will be able to identify with her problems.
I would recommend this book to girls aged 7 to 10 years.
For the earlier books go to this site but for this new series visit here (the students will need to log in with a password for this site).
Jane Moore

Literature to support the Australian curriculum: History by Fran Knight

cover image

Pledger Consulting, 2012. ISBN 978-1-876678-26-5.
(Age: Teacher reference. Primary and secondary) Recommended. In the best traditions of teacher/librarianship, Fran Knight has produced another aid to supporting, extending and enriching the curriculum for teachers and students. Good literature can offer much in developing students' understanding of situations they cannot experience themselves, such as historical contexts. This book provides annotated lists of a wide range of books covering all topics in the Australian Curriculum: History from Personal Histories for the Foundation Year students to the Shogun Japan for Year 8 and Vietnam and the Environmental Movement of the 1960's. One of the challenges for many teachers in tackling the Australian Curriculum: History is their own personal knowledge of the topics they need to teach. Using the books listed provides an exciting approach to developing a rich understanding for teachers and students alike. For many teachers, developing their own understanding of the historical concept will be a necessary precursor to teaching it. Reading some of the titles on the list will be a wonderful aid for teachers to get the pick up some of the 'back-story' to a historical period. Who wouldn't want to read about Krakatau or the Indian mutiny during the English Empire? Alternatively you might be interested to read about the Feathered soldiers: an illustrated tribute to the Australian wartime messenger pigeon. Maybe a graphic novel of Auschwitz or a child-friendly Canterbury tales would be of interest. Reviewing this resourceful list, I found myself wanting to grab a pile of books and get reading. Fran's knowledge of literature spans a significant time. Her annotations are reliable and thoughtful. She understands how classrooms work and the variety of students within each class and so each section contains a variety of reading levels and styles of books - including graphic novels and picture books for senior students. She also includes links to Teacher Guides for books when available. Many titles are recent releases although a few are a little older, the majority being published after 2004. Some titles may require a little finding - for example in online booksellers offering second hand editions. Some may need to be accessed from specific organisations such as a regimental bookseller rather than your favourite bookseller but the search will be worth it. Some titles are also available in Google Book editions.
Diana Warwick
Editor's note: This is available from http://www.readplus.com.au/resources.php

Do not forget Australia by Sally Murphy and Sonia Kretshmar

cover image

Walker Books Australia, 2012. ISBN 978 1 921529 86 3.
(Ages: 6+) Warmly recommended. Picture book. World War One. In France Henri missed Australia as one of the continents in the class quiz, prompting him to comment, 'who cares about Australia', but as this book shows the people of the village in which he lived still remember Australia today because of the efforts of the Australian 13th, 14th and 115th brigades which took the place back from the German army in 1918. The place, Villers-Bretonneux, still commemorates the efforts of the Australians who fought and died there, as well as the efforts of countless Victorian school children, who after the war, collected money to rebuild their school.
Told through the tale of young Henri, displaced from his home and village by the German advance, and Billy in Melbourne, waiting for a letter from his father on the Western Front, the two lives intersect as Henri and his mother take food to the Australians camped outside their town, and Billy's father writes to his family about the townsfolk who have treated them so well.
Today the school in Villers-Bretonneux still boldly flies an Australian flag, with the motto, 'Do not forget Australia' in each classroom, and services held every Anzac Day.
This is a different story to add to the growing number of picture books about Australia's efforts during the two world wars, and will be well used by teachers and librarians to augment the interest shown in our deployment overseas.
A page of information at the end of the book will intrigue readers and impel them into further research and involvement in the new Australian curriculum with its emphasis on History.
Fran Knight

Pandemonium by Lauren Oliver

cover image

Hodder and Stoughton, 2012. Trade Paperback ISBN 9789 1444722932. Hardback ISBN 978 1 4444722925.
Despite the setting of a harsh, dystopian world where people are 'cured' of emotion, living almost as automatons, Lauren Oliver's story is ultimately satisfying, and, more importantly, for its teenage audience, uplifting.
The setting is the United States of America that is no longer united - a bleak fenced world of cities rather than states, outside of which no-one lives as the countryside was bombed and the inhabitants annihilated. In a modern Orwellian world, it seems that the worst fears of the 20th century have become reality in the area of the wintry north-eastern countryside where the story opens. Lena, afraid, bruised and terrified, is recovering in a ramshackle house, trying to keep warm and fed along with the rag-tag community who have rescued her from the beating that appears to have killed her boyfriend, Alex.
The story opens to a young woman, Lena, who finds people who are willing to help her provided that she works alongside them to stay alive and to migrate when the weather becomes intolerable. This community has a few leaders, and one, Raven, is demanding and secretive, in response to trying to survive and to avoid the purging of their kind, called so ironically, the Invalids. These are people who refuse to be deadened by the 'cure', wanting instead to live freely, and to work to restore the world that has been lost.
Lena is torn by loyalties to her earlier love, having experienced disillusionment with her own family and life, finally making some important discoveries about herself, her family and her friends. This heroine is a good model for young readers, clinging, as she does, to the human yearning for love and the desire to help others to live a good life with real care and concern for others.
Elizabeth Bondar

Ghost Club: The New Kid by Deborah Abela

cover image

Random House Australia, 2012. ISBN 978 1 74275 080 4.
(Ages: 8-12) 'Who ya gonna call?' Ghost Club. Like the 80's film Ghostbusters, Ghost Club is called in to deal with pesky and downright dangerous ghosts.  Young Angeline and Edgar are two of the best ghost catchers the club has and we follow them on a variety of ghostly pursuits. Competent and well equipped with many ghost busting gadgets, the brother and sister duo deal with frightening spectres with calm and aplomb.
As the title suggests, a new kid named Dylan joins the Ghost Club and is teamed up with Angeline and Edgar.  Dylan does not show the excitement or fearlessness the other long term members have and he (as would I) is horrified and fearful of the ghostly activities around him.  
This is a fun, ghostly romp with a mystery to solve at Castle Koszmar, where a very angry ghostly figure is causing havoc. It seems ghosts have feelings too you know!
There are a variety of bizarre and entertaining characters in this novel and to add to the drama the children are being secretly filmed and watched by a disapproving eye.
This is a slightly spooky read for 8 to 12 year olds and students who have enjoyed the novel will be happy to know there is another book on the way.
Jane Moore

A monster calls by Patrick Ness

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 978 1 4063 1152 5
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Horror. Death.
From the start, the creeping menace of the Yew tree outside Conor's window invades the imagination of the reader. The amazing illustrations by Jim Kay storm through the book, evoking the shadow world that the monster lives in, paralleling the world now inhabited by Conor as he tries to care for his mother. The threat  evoked by the malice of the monster's presence is palpable, but Conor derides its ability to make him cower in fear, as he knows something far worse. He has lived with his nightmare for a while, waking at 12.07 each night with a thuddering heart and sick dread. His mother sometimes stirs from her own disturbed sleep, vomitting in the basin, or awake with the aftermath of chemotherapy.
In this phenomenal tale begun by the late Siobhan Dowd, and written by Ness, we are treated to a superlative horror story, one that will ensure that word of mouth impels its speed around any group of young people from 10 to 15. Fenced in by the cancer which affects his mother, Conor finds that he is invisible at school, his one time friends avoid him, the bullies eventually giving up on him, bringing his resentment to the surface. All the time, the monster calls at 12.07, telling his stories which impel him to action. His destruction of his grandmother's front room brings no respite. Beating up the bully, finds only compassion from the school, not expulsion. Everywhere he turns he is pitied, not punished and it is only with the last story that the monster makes him understand what he has kept hidden from everyone else as well as from himself.
Death makes its way into every family and this is the story of how one boy deals with it in the most extraordinary way, transferring his feelings to the Yew Tree outside the house, using it as a prop for his emotionally charged life, coping with an absent father, a grandmother he does not care for, and ultimately his dying mother.
What began as a horror story, pulling in the reader through its breathtaking illustrations and storytelling, ends as an acceptance of the reality of death and the coming together of the boy and his mother.
Fran Knight

Three summers by Judith Clarke

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012. ISBN: 978-1-74237-827-5.
A charming story Three Summers is a tender novel about fascination, letting go and of love. Set over the course of three generations, the fictional town of Barinjii, Victoria still observes the practices of the parish throughout the years. Full of moral codes and life lessons the novel, told in three parts, follows Ruth Gower's through her life of uncertainties and documents the impacts of four essential characters.
Ruth is on the cusp, a child set to become an adult as she leaves secondary school and passes into the next stage of her life. Ruth is different from her mother and her grandmother in the way that she has choices and opportunity beckons her to Sydney. With a town opposed to her going, Ruth's Gran is determined that her granddaughter will escape the backwards town of Barinjii and be free to travel the world. But leaving means leaving Fee, pregnant and happily engaged and the elusive Tam Finn whose actions continue to raise questions in Ruth's mind. But Ruth's leaving isn't the end of her dealings with Tam Finn, not entirely at least. Tam Finn might be missing but his suspected child is found when, by an odd choice of the fates a girl with Tam's dark hair and grey eyes who just happens to share her name with Tam's infamous peacock Dancy is fostered by Ruth.
The novel deals with loss, lust, and love making for a quiet lesson about relationships, trust and the observing of tradition. I would recommend this book for girls aged thirteen and up.
(Kayla Gaskell, Student, age 16)

Bunheads by Sophie Flack

cover image

Atom, 2012. ISBN 9781907411274.
(Age: 15+) Recommended. This is an entertaining story about 19 year old ballet dancer, Hannah Ward. As a youngster she dreamed of being a ballerina, leaving home at the tender age of 14 to become a member of the Manhattan Ballet Company. Hannah knows all too well the rigours of the ballet dancer's life: the many hours of rehearsal, the nightly performances, not to mention the hours in the gym, toning and strengthening the body. Whilst many of the performers have a shared history - having joined the company as young teens - they are nevertheless all competing for similar roles, particularly the coveted solo. Competition is fierce, discipline is vital.
This is brought into sharp focus for Hannah when she meets Jacob Cohen, a musician and college student. Sophie's commitment to her ballet career prevents them from spending much time together and she becomes increasingly aware of what she is giving up in her dedication to dance. Sophie realises that most girls her age are at college, spreading their wings, having fun at parties; she rues the fact that even though she has lived in New York for the last five years she really doesn't know the city - having had little spare time to explore beyond the boundaries of the theatre where she rehearses and performs seemingly all year round.
As a former ballet dancer herself, the author (Sophie Flack) clearly has first-hand experience of the trials and tribulations as well as the joys of dance. And she presents a warm and well-rounded portrait of Hannah and her fellow ballet dancers. We see both the dedication that is needed to perform at the highest level but also the rewards; the joy of soaring as a ballerina, the thrill of performance.
Lovers of ballet are sure to enjoy this novel with its frequent use of dancing terminology but equally, those who do not have a dance background will enjoy the human story behind the dance: the struggle to find one's place in the world and the courage needed to change tack.
Deborah Marshall

Professor Fred Hollows by Hazel Edwards

cover image

New Frontier Publishing, 2012. ISBN 9781921042751.
(Age 7+) According to the Macquarie dictionary, a hero is 'a person of distinguished courage or performance'. Professor Fred Hollows qualified on both counts and is a fitting subject for a series about 'Aussie heroes'. He used his skills as an ophthalmologist to treat people around the world, and refused to accept that the cost of medical treatment should deny anyone the gift of sight.
Hazel Edwards is an experienced and able story teller. In her biography, the issues that drove Fred Hollows are as apparent as the course of his extraordinary life. Technical information is interwoven with the story, so that readers are aware of major eye diseases and the medical procedures used to alleviate or cure them. With the glossary incorporated into the text, its absence at the end of the book is not noticed. The story is driven along in a conventional manner. Each compact chapter has a well-defined purpose and each paragraph begins with a topic sentence. The author's use of these techniques reminds us why they are so effective in historical narrative.
One drawback to 'heroic' history is that its subjects can seem one dimensional. Hazel Edwards has avoided this pitfall by mentioning some of Fred Hollows' idiosyncrasies, without being judgmental or detracting from his achievements. She has also emphasised that Fred and Gabi Hollows were partners in work as well as in life, and has ended the story with Gabi's tireless efforts to continue her husband's legacy.
The large font, clear, explicit writing style and timeline, make this text suitable as a story for younger children and as a source of information for older primary students. While the illustrations are realistic and sympathetic, the absence of an index and photographs gives the book the appearance of an unassuming reading text rather than a work of non-fiction. Any student or teacher, who is unaware of the value of Hazel Edward's biography, could miss an opportunity to learn about the life's work of a true 'Aussie hero'.
Elizabeth Bor

The baby that roared! by Simon Puttock

cover image

Ill. by Nadia Shireen. Noisy Crow, 2012. ISBN 978 0 85763 018 6.
(Ages: 6+) Picture book. Humour. Poor Mr and Mrs Deer have no baby, and wish they had. They want something to play with, to cuddle and love, to read stories to. One day a baby is left on their doorstep with a note, asking them to do just that. They are enthralled, but once the baby begins to roar they are perplexed as to what to do. They enlist the help of friends, who make various suggestions, but each time one of their friends stay with the baby, they disappear. A whole range of reasons for the roaring baby is given by each of the friends before they disappear, until Granny Bear comes along and suggest the baby needs burping with very funny results.
This is a very funny introduction to the needs of a baby, told in a humorous and enticing format, with illustrations that will enchant and delight the readers. Children will hear for themselves the range of needs a baby has, from being cuddled, loved, given milk to drink, having nappies changed and so on. This can be read on many levels, as an amusing story to share with a class, or for individual reading, the characters will delight the reader. In a class where babies and their needs is under discussion, this will form a very neat introduction to the topic, providing a marvellous opening to discussion about the needs and wants of a baby through a picture book with animal characters.
Fran Knight

The weight of water by Sarah Crossan

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2012. ISBN 978 1 4088 300 2.
(Ages: 12+) Recommended. Verse novel. A verse novel told in first person, of a woman and her daughter, Kasienka, who emigrate to Great Britain from Poland in their search for her husband and the girl's father who left two years before.
Through the one and two page chapters we read of the girl's anguish at leaving all she knows to go to a country where she finds herself isolated by her lack of English, relegated to a lower class to learn the language, friendless and alone. Her mother, similarly is isolated, despite finding work in the local hospital, where patients ask for someone who can speak English. Their next door neighbour becomes their only friend, an African doctor, forced to work at a menial job in a hospital to keep himself alive.
Mother has an amazing idea, to ask at every house for knowledge of her husband, and so a map of Coventry is used to work out their progress. Each day they take one street and knock on all the doors, as well as using their meagre funds to have copies of a notice with his details on it made, posting them up in the streets.
All the while, Cassie is putting up with bullying at school, as she tries to make friends, and develops a relationship with a boy, William, who she meets at the swimming pool. Swimming keeps her afloat in more ways than one. Her secret life is at odds with her mother's presumption that she is a good girl, and this all changes when their neighbour finds Tara, Cassie's father.
In small bites we are led into Cassie's world, fighting discrimination and bullying, coping with a distracted mother, ignorant teachers and an alien world. The brief lines encapsulate her feelings and emotions as we see all that happens through her eyes. The power of these short phrases to expose this young girl's life is extraordinary and will intrigue secondary girls, who will delight in taking this beautifully presented little hardback book with its wrap around cover to their hearts.
Fran Knight