Reviews

Pizza Cake by Morris Gleitzman

cover image

Puffin, 2011. ISBN: 9780143305989.
(Ages 8+) Highly recommended. Ten entertaining stories from one of Australia's most popular children's authors. My personal favourite is 'Saving Ms Fosdyke' a story in which teachers are paid huge salaries and are hero worshipped by the community. To quote, 'Only the smartest, cleverest, most brilliant, people get to be teachers.'
In some of the other stories lives are saved with a paper clip, an Australian idiom is misunderstood and two siblings compete about anything and everything. Gleitzman has an undoubted gift for writing authentic and funny prose about young people and these stories all showcase this gift. These imaginative stories would be ideal for reading aloud.
Chris Lloyd

The Anything Shop by Dawn Meredith

cover image

Ill. Lesley Vamos. Wombat Books 2011. ISBN 9781921633515.
(Ages: 6 to 9) Recommended. Dawn Meredith admits to having weird ideas in her head and this little story does have an odd starting point. However, the story is a satisfying one, initiating some interesting and thought-provoking ideas. Ten year-old Charlie is fascinated when he comes across a new shop which seems to have magically appeared, calling itself The Anything Shop, and inviting customers in to swap or buy anything they wish. Could a shop really give Charlie whatever he wanted? He has to find out. Charlie's inquiry seems to have been prearranged as Alfred and Meryl, the shop owners, know exactly why he is there. Charlie swaps those very embarrassing hugs he gets at home for an amazing cricket bat, which is the answer to all his dreams of becoming a champion player at school! It is not long before he realises that 'no hugs at home' cannot be replaced by cricket prowess; but he is locked into the swap for two years. How can he get back to what life was like and why do Alfred and Meryl what to take the joys of childhood away? As Charlie sets out to solve his dilemma, along with Sam his new friend caught up in the same swindle, he comes to an understanding of what is really important. There is plenty of action in this simple, but cleverly told story, and the interspersing of lively black and white drawings add to its accessibility.
Julie Wells

Chanukah Lights by Michael J Rosen and Robert Sabuda

cover image

Walker, 2011. ISBN: 9780763655334.
(Ages: 5+) Highly recommended.  This masterful combination of Rosen's lyrical poetry and Sabuda's intricate pop-up art work has created a book which I plan to treasure, hide away carefully and bring out each year to share with students! It truly is a keepsake book which reminds one of the trials and oppression of the Jews, as they refused to relinquish their faith. Each page tells of a different place where Jews have resided and reflected back upon the miraculous story of the Temple lamp which burned for eight days. Sabuda includes the lighted candles of the menorah cleverly within each of his illustrations. Apart from the candles on each page, the paper-craft is entirely white, with graduated shades of colour providing the backgrounds. The only exception is the final page spread, in which the candles are represented by the gold topped spires of the tall skyscrapers.
Although this book would be a wonderful asset in teaching Jewish children about their stories and history, it also contains universal truths, relevant to all who wish for peace, hope, freedom and the ability to openly express and practice their own beliefs.
Jo Schenkel

The Dovekeepers by Alice Hoffman

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2011, 9780857205438.
Recommended. Summer 70CE. Jerusalem has fallen to the Romans. Rael, the young daughter of a Jewish assassin, flees across the desert with a small group of other Jews seeking the refuge of the fortress Masada. She arrives pregnant and is set to work in the dovecotes, along with Shirah, known as the Witch of Moab, her daughters and other refugee women. The doves  are kept as indispensable food, sources of fertilizer and as messengers. The women's lives are simple but rich with Judaic tradition and complicated by love intrigues. Others who have found shelter in Masada include the Essenes, an early form of Christianity, and some Moabites who worshipped other gods, but who live together amicably. However, the Roman army's advance is inexorable, and as supplies within the fortress begin to fail the leaders prepare for the deaths of all. The book is written in simple poetic prose enriched by descriptions of the traditions of the Jewish faith. Each section is presented through the eyes of a different woman, Rael who sees herself as an outcast, Shirah, the beautiful and powerful 'witch', Revka, who has lost all in the Roman advance and Aziza who becomes a warrior. The reader is given a clear view of life as it was for women in Jerusalem and Masada before the Roman conquest. While some of the earlier passages seem forced, and some of the romantic elements are implausible, the writing accumulates in power. The historical research about the details of everyday life and Judaic traditions is sound, and a convincing view of the pattern of life at that time is presented. This novel is recommended for senior readers.
Jenny Hamilton

Wild whiskers and tender tales by Ute Wegmann with Dr Anthony Helman

cover image

Wakefield Press, 2011, S.A.
Wild whiskers and tender tales, sub-titled Close encounters with Australian wildlife rescue and conservation, is a fascinating behind-the-scenes look at the altruistic and hard-working individuals who care for our injured wildlife.
The main author entry is for Ute Wegmann, who is the photographer. Ms Wegmann has a very impressive and lengthy pedigree, so to speak, both as an animal photographer (Burke's Backyard Magazine, Dog's Life Magazine, Black and White), and in the wider commercial world (Luxury Homes, Australian House and Garden, Australian HiFi Magazine, Iron Man etc). The benefits of this professional expertise are immediately apparent in the extremely high quality photographs - beautiful to look at, informative and expressive, varied settings, and nicely framed. A wide variety of rescued wildlife is covered, including the Greater Bilby, Flatback Turtle, Platypus, Carpet Python, Swamp Wallaby and many others. We read about the situation in which the animal was found, and interesting information is provided about the particular carer.
The book contains a significant amount of text, written by Dr Anthony Helman, who has the added author entry. [I must declare an interest here, as Dr Helman is my brother, but rest assured, I would not be writing about the book in the first place if I did not think it warranted a favourable review!] The writing takes an interesting lateral approach to the study of wildlife, as we approach the topic firstly through the circumstances of the animal's rescue and their carer, and the focus then broadens out to a wider look at the animal's particular behaviour and ecology. This is done in a humorous and accessible manner, for example the section on Milsom the platypus:
The platypus was such a surprise to naturalists who received the first specimens sent back to England that they thought someone had played an elaborate hoax by stitching together the bill and webbed feet of a duck to the body of a mammal!
This exerpt brings me to the only point of caution I would make about Wild whiskers and tender tales, which is that although the pictures and layout appeal to a wide age range, the literacy, font size and text presentation would be more suited to secondary than primary readers.
Peter J Helman

Battle Files: Air by Mac Park

cover image

Boy vs Beast. Border Files. Scholastic, 2011. ISBN 978 1 92193 108 6.
(Age: Late junior and middle primary boys) Well recommended. The challenge is to win a Border Guard Wing Badge award. Kai Masters sets a challenging pace as each page unfolds the tasks to be undertaken in order to win a badge. He of course achieves this easily. This novel titled Air, details the environment to be encountered, the amazing yet familiar beasts to be overcome, the weapons to fight with and the strategies needed to win.& Reminiscent of the computer games so popular with young boys, this book sets out to challenge the reader to join the game. Intended to attract boys who can read and are fascinated with science fiction, the novel leaves no stone unturned in the fine detail of each beast, its evolution, weaknesses, and the best way to catch it with 'top tips'. It's a visual feast, cleverly set out with differing fonts to engage the young reader and black and white detailed illustrations which say it all! Font is large and easy to read with short, sharp sentences. The setting out is clear and strong. The invented language is amazing in itself. The Aquamaxitor, as the name suggests 'takes in water through its mouth. It stores this water in the bones of its wings. Then it blasts the water from its wings' p38. The illustrations leave nothing out. There are many in the series and young readers will keenly want to win all the badges.
Sue Nosworthy

Edsel Grizzler: Ghostly shadows by James Roy

cover image

UQP, 2011. ISBN: 978 0 7022 3881 9.
Having missed their train back to Verdada, Edsel and Jacq are digging a hole under the city of Widen, without fully understanding why they are doing so. With their water rations about to be consumed, they find a beacon which they believe may help them find their way out of the tunnel. By unraveling a jumper, hand knitted by Jacq's Gran, the pair leave behind a trail of wool to help them find their way back to their starting point. Journeying through the tunnel, they have some unnerving experiences in which they find it difficult to identify fact from fiction. When they meet an old friend, they believe they will be saved but not everything is as straightforward as they might hope.
Despite the adventure, interesting characters, settings, inventions and twists and turns in the plot, I found this a difficult title to read . . . due mostly to the fact that I have not yet read the first two books of the trilogy! Whilst some series seem to contain predominantly 'stand alone' titles, this did not. Having read the final book, I am now keen to read the previous books to learn more about the journey and characters in the series and make more sense of the events herein. With the themes of loyalty, friendship and the desire to atone for one's wrongs, this book has some positive aspects. I plan to revisit the series as a whole as it certainly seemed to be another entertaining and thought provoking read.
Jo Schenkel

Vicious little darlings by Katherine Easer

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2011. ISBN: 978-1-59990-628-7.
(Age: 15+) Vicious Little Darlings by Katherine Easer is a magical novel that will keep you spell bound till the last minute. The main character Sarah Weaver is looking for a place in an all-girls collage when she befriends two very strange characters:  Agnes, a control freak who is very protective of Maddy, and Maddy,  a beautiful blonde who always gets what she wants.
During Sarah's first day at the all-girls college, she meets her room-mate Maddy. Maddy is kind, caring and loves her friends. Her best friend, Agnes is like a sister to her and is at her beck and call.
During her period at the college, Sarah gets asked to move off campus with Agnes and Maddy. Living in a small town where there is hardly any suitable men to be with, she meets Reed, a cute artistic intellectual who loves Sarah deeply. Sarah wants to spend all her time with him but Maddy disapproves, more drama occurs in the solution to this problem.
A dramatic ending makes this book truly desirable to read. Perfect for people who love drama, romance and thrill. Age wise, this book would be more suited to fifteen year olds onwards, not a tween novel. A brilliant plot with a brilliant ending.
Sarah Filkin (Student)

Hal Junior : The Secret Signal by Simon Haynes

cover image

Simon Haynes, 2011. ISBN: 9781877034077.
(Age: Suitable for 9 -12 year olds) Set in the future, Hal Junior lives in a space station with his scientist mother and his dad who cleans air filters. The story begins with Hal trying to retrieve his homework from the space station recycling hatch with help from his clever friend, Stephen 'Stinky' Binn. Unfortunately Hal, who often gets into trouble despite his best intentions, has a near miss catastrophe trying to solve his homework dilemma. Hal has the ability to attract mayhem and has been described as a 'Dennis the Menace' in space. Yet it is Hal who discovers a sinister plot that would affect the whole space ship.
Simon Haynes has written a fun science fiction book for primary aged students. It has an exciting plot, humour and a likeable main character. I am not a Sci Fi fan but I enjoyed reading Hal's adventures and did laugh at some of his antics.
The book also contains small line drawings and some funny visual jokes.
Simon Haynes has published other science fiction books for teens / adults but this is his first venture into children's fiction. The book has been self published and lacks the cover appeal and paper quality of mainstream publishers but is worth reading.
Jane Moore

Kill all enemies by Melvin Burgess

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 978 0 141 33564 3.
Kill all enemies is the story of three teenagers, Billie, Rob and Chris all of whom have a number of problems. Billie is considered violent, Rob is thought to be a bully and Chris is lazy and not interested in school. However as the story progresses you learn more about each of them and what has caused them to appear this way.  Each chapter is headed by one of the characters and helps in the development of how we see them. All is not what it seems with any of them, clues are given along the way and this helps build up a larger picture of the three main characters. There is plenty of violence and strong language but it is hard not to become involved in the story. Each of the characters is flawed but have their redeeming features as well. Rob is fiercely protective of his younger brother and mother, Billie is trying to be calmer and to allow people to help her while Chris has dyslexia and goes to great lengths to disguise the problems that this causes him.
They all meet in the course of the story and their interaction is one of the key elements of the story along with dysfunctional families and all the normal problems of adolescence and growing up.
I liked the book, it had a ring of authenticity and their problems were not glossed over, but the story came to a satisfying conclusion. Supposedly based on real life experiences I would think older teenagers would be able to identify with the characters and their problems and perhaps learn from them.
David Rayner

The luck of the Buttons by Anne Ylvisaker

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2011. ISBN 9780763650667.
(Ages 8-12) Recommended. Set in a small town in Iowa in 1929, twelve-year-old Tugs Button has always just accepted her lot in life, being part of a family which seems quite proud of its misfortunes. But then popular and coordinated Aggie Millhouse asks her not only to be her partner in the Independence Day picnic three-legged race, but also invites her to her birthday party. Tugs wonders if perhaps you have to make your own luck, and after winning two blue ribbons and a camera at the picnic, begins to have more confidence to do so. When a stranger arrives in town claiming to be a newspaperman and taking money from many of the townsfolk, Tugs is the only person who seems to think his story does not add up. But will anybody listen to her? After all, she's just a scruffy Button in an old pair of overalls.
Tugs is a very likeable character who finds out much about herself by examining how her family and the rest of the town views her. While some of the language and the historical American small-town setting may leave younger readers a little bewildered, the characters and mystery of the story will appeal to many upper primary students, especially those who sometimes feel trapped by their own circumstances.
Donella Reed

Just right by Birdie Black

cover image

Ill. by Rosalind Beardshaw. Noisy Crow. 2011. ISBN 978 0 85763 030 8.
(Ages 4-7) Picture book. Humour. Christmas. An absolutely delightful story about giving a gift for Christmas has the king buying a large roll of beautiful red cloth for the dressmakers to make his wife a lovely cloak. The leftover cloth is then left by one of the maids on the doorstep where it is picked up by a kitchen maid. She uses some of it to make a jacket for her daughter, then leaves the scraps on her doorstep. Badger, spying the red cloth takes it home to make a red hat for his father. The scraps again are picked up and mittens are made for the squirrel's wife. The last little piece is found by the mouse and she finds it just right to make a scarf for Billy. Each present is wrapped or not, and left under the tree in each of the households, and on Christmas morning each is opened and appreciated. A beautiful double page spread at the end of the book shows all the givers and recipients proudly displaying their gift as they skate on the frozen lake.
This charming book shows the range of gifts given for Christmas and will elicit responses from the students listening or reading it themselves about what they receive and give for Christmas. That each piece of leftover cloth is used by the characters, makes a telling reminder that the giving of a gift is not about its monetary value but the impetus behind the giving of the gift. This book will be a valued inclusion in the Christmas stories used in classrooms and by parents at this time of the year, when discussing what the children will give for Christmas. It is a humorous look at what is important about giving, and incidentally a tale about recycling and making the best use of an object.
Fran Knight

Fury by Elizabeth Miles

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2011. ISBN: 978 0 85707 486 7.
(Age : 14+) Recommended. Em loves the winter holidays. And this year, things are really looking up: the guy she's been into for months has finally noticed her. But if she starts something with him, there's no turning back. Because he's going out with her best friend.
 On the other side of town, Chase's home life is stressful and his social life unravelling. But that's nothing compared to what's really haunting him. For Chase has done something cruel - something the perfect guy he pretends to be would never do. And it's only a matter of time before he's exposed.
Mistakes can be deadly. And three beautiful, mysterious girls are about to make them pay . . .
A very interesting book that puts a spin on why people have unexpected accidents. It show that when you do something wrong in your life, be quick to apologise and always tell the truth. Miles captured me with her writing skills and I was sucked into the story in no time at all.  A moving story that will truly make you think about the things you have done and whether they were really worth it or if they should have never been done.
Taylor Oxenham (Student)

The Wise Man's Fear by Patrick Rothfuss

cover image

The Kingkiller Chronicles: Day Two. Orion, 2011.
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended. He was once the most powerful wizard, feared swordsman and famed dragon slayer of his or any time. A man of myth and legend, Kvothe disappeared without warning. Now a quiet inn-keeper he wishes to live out his days in peace and pass on the knowledge of his life to those around him. Only his friend and assistant; Bast is aware of Kvothe's true identity. Believing that Kvothe is still the man he once was Bast wishes to wake Kvothe from his life of monotony. When a scribe passing through town recognises Kvothe he asks to record his story. Kvothe wanting to set the record straight agrees and begins telling the scribe his story, in three parts over three days.
In the space of two books Rothfuss has staked claim as one of the premier fantasy writers in recent years. The Wise Man's Fear surpasses its predecessor The Name of the Wind in most if not all areas. Substantially longer at 994 pages, many readers may choose to neglect it due to its sheer bulk. But upon reading the first few pages, setting the book down is the last thing on the reader's mind. The writing is detailed but never dull, the characters engaging and relatable.
The plot employs elements of action, drama, comedy and romance, ensuring that readers of all styles will be engrossed. The ending leaves the reader aching for the next instalment and if it is anything like The Wise Man's Fear it will be well worth the wait.
An original storyline, detailed characters and an engaging writing style make The Wise Man's Fear one of the better fantasy books to hit the shelves in recent years. Some readers may be deterred by its length but those who pick this book up will not be disappointed.
I highly recommend this book .
Michael Adams

What Comes After by Steve Watkins

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2011. ISBN 9780763642501.
(Age 14+) Highly recommended. Newly orphaned 16 year old Iris is forced to leave her home in Maine and live with unknown relatives in North Carolina. As an animal and vegetarian she is horrified by the way her callous aunt and cousin treat the animals on their small farmlet. When intervening to save the lives of two of the animals she is savagely beaten by her cousin on the orders of her aunt and both aunt and cousin end up in the county gaol.
This results in her being fostered and is a new beginning for Iris as she realises that that she must be the one to redeem her life and that there will be no fairytale ending for her. This novel is beautifully written and despite its negative subject matter it has a strong message of hope and resilience. All the characters  are believable and there are some engaging secondary characters.
Fans of Cynthia Voigt's writing will particularly enjoy the novel and it would be an interesting suggestion for girls you would like to move on from the Jenny Downham books.
Chris Lloyd