Reviews

Bear's best friend by Lucy Coats and Sarah Dyer

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 978 1 4088 2726 0
(Age: 3+) Picture book. Topiary. Animals. Friendship. Bear has many friends, but no best friend and is concerned about this. He makes lovely animals by clipping back trees and each of the animals is impressed with what he has done, so much so that other animals come along and request a tree be clipped for them as well. His tree pictures are well known for miles around, and stand as a testament to his hard work, but he still does not have a best friend.
His tears fall onto his snipping scissors and suddenly he hears a voice ask why he is crying. Turning he spies another bear and they become best fiends, doing things together just as best friends do.
The bear continues his special skill at making tree pictures and the new word, topiary is introduced at the end of this story of friendship. While a slight story, the book would well suit a class looking at the theme of friendship and would be useful in a classroom where new words are introduced, especially those that are a little out of the ordinary, but children will have no doubt about the meaning of the word topiary at the end of this story.
Fran Knight

A very unusual pursuit by Catherine Jinks

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2013 ISBN. 9781 74331 306 0
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Fantasy. Historical. The wonderful Birdie is a bogler's assistant in murky Dickensian London. Her master, the clever and brave bogler, Alfred Bunce, uses her as bait to draw the bogles out of their lairs: sewers, fireplaces, wells and the like, from whence they erupt to take away children to eat. Birdie's beautifully clear voice and small size attracts their interest and so lured, find they are surrounded by salt and as Birdie quickly escapes, Bunce pounces. The sometimes sticky end of the bogle will absolutely delight the readers of this delicious story, the first in a new series (City of Orphans) by this clever writer.
But Birdie is a little fearful of her position. Miss Eames, an academic interested in the bogles of London, has done some research and found that there may be other ways of capturing them, rather than let Birdie be the bait. The possibility of losing her work fills Birdie with dread, as the poorhouse and workhouses of London loom large. Jinks' research is obvious as she describes these places with malicious detail.
But it is not just Miss Eames that Birdie must be careful of, the nasty Sarah Pickles, a female version of Fagan from Oliver Twist, wants Birdie to join her warren, and this too Birdie views with fear and suspicion. And one night, after breaking into a doctor's house because of some missing children, repercussions of that night teach Birdies that not all people around her can be trusted.
A fascinating tour of Victorian London, Catherine Jink's impeccable research and interest in this period shines through. She beguiles us with the sights and sounds of the back streets where bogles and bogle hunters live, insinuating so much detail into the narrative, that no reader can have a doubt about the evil that lurks there. The second in this fine series cannot come soon enough.
Fran Knight

The Convent by Maureen McCarthy

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012. ISBN 9781742375045. 419 pages
(Ages: 15+) I was particularly attracted to this novel, as I believe Maureen McCarthy talks to teenagers with great purpose and understanding. Her novels highlight teenage tension and disorientation, but they also conclude with both honesty and optimism.
Having been educated at a Catholic girls' school, with the convent of nuns set amongst our school buildings, and, in the light of the recent church controversies, I was keen to see where McCarthy's story was to take me.
The subject, and indeed the title, may not initially attract many readers.  Today there are many young people who would not understand the term 'nun' or 'convent'. The picture of modern day Peach, however, on the front cover, walking towards the Abbotsford buildings works well, producing just the right amount of intrigue. Hopefully there will be many readers who will take up the invitation and read further.
Abbotsford becomes the centre stage for the lives of four women, each related by generation. Sadie, mainly through poverty is driven to give up her child to be cared for by the convent nuns. Ellen marries a farming man and nurtures seven children and her experiences at Abbotsford remain dear to her. Her only daughter, Cecilia, enters the convent and stays for ten years. Peach is her illegitimate daughter who is adopted soon after her birth. The storyline relies considerably on coincidence but McCarthy's realistic approach to the subject and the life she breathes into each of these women makes for great reading. She reveals the individual experiences of the women, highlighting the varying perspectives on religious life throughout the decades. What is important is that the modern day Peach is given the opportunity to learn about the past, acknowledging the pressures and prejudices which affected the women in her family.Choosing the religious life is by not means mocked in this book - it is put into perspective for the time. Ironically, Peach's friend, Det, in the modern day story feels similar pressures experienced by Cecilia, when she finds herself pregnant and believes that there is no one to help her.
With an interesting array of characters, a well structured set of four stories moving from a rather bewildering past to the modern day, and a great story line, The Convent is a good read.
Julie Wells

Meet Ruby by Penny Matthews

cover image

Ill. by Lucia Masciullo. Our Australian Girl series. Penguin, 2013. ISBN 978 0 14330742 6.
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. Historical novel. When Ruby goes to the Adelaide Zoo with her parents, she notices the humpies along the River Torrens, and men making tea and cooking food over camp fires. This along with one of her friends disappearing from their private school, the dismissal of their housekeeper, and her parent's beaten expressions, alerts the reader to the facts of the Great Depression and its impact on families in Australia.
Eventually Ruby's father, a builder, loses his business, and now unemployed, must sell their house and the possessions they no longer need. Ruby and her mother will be moving to the country to stay with an aunt and uncle and the odd cousin May, while he searches for work both in South Australia and Victoria.
Through this story of one young girl, as with the rest of the series, readers are able to assimilate the feeling of the times with ease. The front cover tells the readers that the story is set in 1930, and images shown on the covers alert the readers to snippets of information making the times loom large.
The very successful series, with four books in each set about one young girl, has teacher notes on the website, and each novel has information at the end of the book about the times, and two pages which whets the appetite for the next story. An extensive website accompanies this fine series.
Fran Knight

The wicked and the just by J.Anderson Coats

cover image

Harcourt, 2012. ISBN 9780547688374. Hardback.
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Historical. Middle Ages. 2013 ALA Best Fiction for Young Adults. Kirkus Best Teen Book of 2012. Cecily's father has taken her to Wales in search of cheap land. Gwenhwyfar works as a servant in the house where she thought she would be lady of the manor. Instead Cecily takes over and her treatment of Gwenny is not kind. Indeed Gwenny describes her as a brat. Tensions are rising as the impoverished Welsh struggle to keep alive in their land.
Told in alternating viewpoints by Cecily and Gwenhwyfar, this is a poignant, thought provoking examination of two characters set against the violence of Welsh oppression in the Middle Ages. I learnt much about each character, their needs and thoughts as I read this book as well as the period in history. It is not a quick escapist read, there are no mythical creatures or strong romance, just the story of two young women who are struggling to survive, each in her own way. Cecily is often very selfish and thoughtless, although she does have a sense of justice. Gwenny' plight as a servant who is struggling to keep her mother alive and look after her brother is heart rending.
It is a wonderful piece of writing that will stay with me for a long time. I was left wishing that I could follow Cecily and Gwenny on the next stage of their coming of age, at the same time knowing that the times would make it extremely difficult for both of them.
Pat Pledger

Tiddles by S. Carey

cover image

Eerie series. Puffin, 2013. ISBN: 9780143307372. Paperback, 72 pages. RRP:$9.99.
I love cats. I love my Aunty Shirley. I love little holidays away from my family. How about you?
Brother and sister, Ben and Cathy, have to stay with their Great-Aunt Pam for a week while their parents are busy organising a new house and new job. Poor Aunty Pam has lost both her husband and her much loved cat. So far, a pretty normal regular storyline you might think.
But wait . . . Great-Aunt Pam resembles Jabba the Hutt and is twice as nasty. She certainly does seem to miss Tiddles, and Tom as well. But if her beloved cat is dead, then why does she still put out a cat tray and why does the cat bowl have fresh blood around it . . . . . . . and why, oh why, are there dead maggots all around the cat door which keeps flapping in the night.
Trapped in Aunty Pam's house, with doors and windows chained and bolted and no means of communicating with their parents, Ben and Cathy are faced with a horrible realisation and even more terrifying situation.
'They stayed huddled together, only aware of the own racing hearts as the black, dead thing pulled itself relentlessly towards them.'
The Eerie series, written by S. Carey (just think about that name for a moment, folks) is going to be a huge hit with independent readers especially of the zombie-loving kind. Mister 10 is going to eat this series up - oops, perhaps the wrong turn of phrase!
Sue Warren

Pirates Love Underpants by Claire Freedman and Ben Cort

cover image

Simon Schuster Children's Books, 2013. ISBN 9780857072658. Paperback 32 pages.
Reading Age: 4-6 years. Themes: Pirates. Humour. Rhyming story. This is a fun new addition to the Underpants books; pirates love underpants just as much as Aliens, Dinosaurs and Panta Claus! The endpapers are filled with weird and wacky y-fronts, skull and crossbones bloomers, wooden plank undies, and ghostly briefs, quite a talking point.
The Pirates board their ship the Black Bloomer searching for the Pants of Gold treasure. They have to sail past sharks in fancy underpants before landing at Big Knickers Bay. Of course there are problems and difficulties along the way and underpants play an important role on every page. Of course the Captain's funny idea saves the day.
Claire Freedman has continued to follow the same rhyming patterns with her text. Ben Cort's bright comical paintings with bold splashes of colour add depth to the story. There are many styles of underpants pictured throughout and these make this a humorous story.
Claire and Ben's website http://www.aliensloveunderpants.com/ is a great resource with biographies, downloads, games and book information.
This is a great read-aloud book for sharing with children from three to six. Beginning readers will also enjoy the rhythm and rhyme.
Rhyllis Bignell

Big Nate flips out by Lincoln Peirce

cover image

Big Nate series no. 5. HarperCollins, 2013. ISBN13: 9780061996641. 216 p.
Recommended for readers from 8-11 years of age. Themes: Middle School, Friendship, Cartooning. This is the fifth Big Nate novel written and illustrated by cartoonist Lincoln Peirce. Big Nate has been a syndicated newspaper cartoon since 1991. His work inspired Jeff Kinney to write and illustrate The Diary of a Wimpy Kid.
Big Nate and his best friend Frances are once again finding middle school life difficult. Nate's problems stem from his untidiness; his locker, schoolwork, homework, clothes and his bedroom are always messy. Francis however is a neatnik; Nate calls him Captain Tidypants. He's an only child and a trivia buff. They have been best friends since kindergarten.
This time problems escalate when the boys decide to be on the school yearbook committee. Their aim is to make it better than last year's because the photos were truly awful. There is a lot of fun and drama as they take the school camera to capture candid shots of classmates and teachers. An unfortunate event occurs with the camera and this leads to Nate visiting Teddy's Uncle Pedro for help because he's an inventor, magician and hypnotist. The change in Nate is truly amazing!
This a book filled with American school life humour, friendships, class stereotypes, overbearing teachers and bullies. The cartoons seamlessly work with the text and add humour to the story.
This story would appeal to those students who enjoy The Diary of a Wimpy Kid by Jeff Kinney. Reluctant readers would enjoy these stories as they can find much of the text written in the cartoons.
A sneak peek of the next Big Nate novel, Big Nate: In the Zone! Is included as well.
This series is supported by the Big Nate website  where readers can find Lincoln Peirce's blog, books, games, videos and downloads.
Rhyllis Bignell

Spark by Brigid Kemmerer

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012. ISBN-13: 978-1-74331-074-8
(Age: 13+) Spark is book number two in the Elementals series by Brigid Kemmerer. This book is done in third-person and follows a segment of both Gabriel Merrick and Layne's lives, the two main characters of the book and like the book's prequel Storm there is a male and female main character, their stories just as important as the others.
Gabriel Merrick is a hot tempered teen who likes to play with fire, he is rash and quick to get into a fight but he has the ability to think when adrenaline comes calling.
His family life is hard enough having lost his parents a few years ago and to be in his older brother's care along with his twin and younger brother, but failing his classes is something that will not be tolerated, the only reason Gabriel cares about school is for his sport but when his grades start to slide he is very close to losing his place on the team. This results in Layne tutoring Gabriel.
Layne is a quiet, intelligent sophomore and is in a few of Gabriel's classes. Her whole life is wrapped in mystery and isolation; she keeps to herself but finds it hard when she starts to tutor Gabriel.
Mysterious fires start to appear all over town and most of the evidence points to Gabriel and his elemental ability. His brothers suspect him and the Guides suspect but there is no proof for Gabriel to use to stop these accusations.
The characters are realistic to relate to and the language used by the author is very understandable and gives a good overall picture of the story. Thoroughly enjoyable and keeps you actively enchanted until the very end.
Sarah Filkin (Student)

Vietnam diary by Mark Wilson

cover image

Lothian, 2013. ISBN 9780 7344 1274 4.
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Picture book. Vietnam War. Historical story. Mark Wilson's rendering of the war in Vietnam is astonishing. The pencil sketches, like the one on the front cover, instill in the reader that frozen moment of war, a sketch done by a war artist similar to those we see at the Australian War Museum in Canberra or in books about war.
The frozen moments build to a crescendo of feeling, which explodes on about page 30, when a young man's eyes peer out at the reader, fearful, shocked and horrified. This full page pencil drawing is truly momentous, and stands out amongst the other brilliant pieces of drawing and painting that Wilson presents. His use of watercolour and crayon, pencil drawing and other mixed media are astounding, rendering the mix that is war often softening it with the quiet of home.
In this book we see two stories side by side, on the one hand these brothers are very alike, but when it comes to the Vietnam War, one, at university, protests, while the other, still at home, is conscripted and agrees to go to Vietnam. Through the images and spare writing we see the two, not understanding each other, but in the end the objector comes to see his brother's gallantry and sense of duty in what he is doing.
All the while in the background we see and hear of the Vietnam War, a war in which Australia was part, forty years ago, but having repercussions today. For classes studying the Vietnam War, or war in general, or Australia's part in the history of this region, this book will prove to be a valuable addition to the library.
This book compliments his other books about war: My mother's eyes, and Angel of Kokoda, and you will see other examples of his fine illustrative techniques in the Extinction series (I saw nothing etc), The castaways of the Charles Eaton, and Yellow-eye.
Fran Knight

Anthem for Jackson Dawes by Celia Bryce

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 9781408827116
(Age: 12+) Megan Bright is a thirteen year old facing a big challenge. She has a brain tumour and needs several hospital admissions for chemotherapy. Her parents and grandfather are trying to put on a brave face and Megan feels she should do likewise, even though the experience is frightening. The ward to which she is admitted seems more suitable for little children with cartoon pictures on the walls, toys and crying babies. She is relieved to find there is at least one other teenager also having chemotherapy, Jackson Dawes.
Every body seems to love Jackson Dawes. He charms the young children and the nurses with his mischievous stories and rebellious disregard for rules. At first, Megan is determined to have nothing to do with him but it's lonely on the ward, away from friends. They share a common bond as cancer patients who are exposed to experiences that other teenagers never have to contemplate. Megan's world of school, football and friends fade into the background as she undergoes treatment and is replaced by life on the cancer ward. Gradually she learns to appreciate Jackson and comes to rely on his friendship and optimism.
Eventually Megan needs surgery while Jackson's cancer is so unusual the doctors are running out of treatment options. The challenges they face will change them forever.
This book is a sensitive and realistic portrayal of the lives of those suffering from chronic illness and the impact on family and friends. It is neither sugar coated nor maudlin leaving readers with a sense of hope, despite acknowledging the inevitability of loss. A story about first love under the most challenging circumstances, it will suit younger teens.
Tina Cain

Enchanted by Alethea Kontis

cover image

Woodcutter Sisters bk 1. Harcourt, 2012. ISBN 9780547645704
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Sunday is the seventh daughter of a seventh daughter and has to be careful what she writes as it could come true. When she kisses a frog, it changes into Prince Rumbold, who is despised by Sunday's family.
One of my favourite genre is that of a fairy tale retold and I was hooked right from the beginning with this funny, witty, romantic story of Sunday who is 'blithe and bonny and good and gay'. Of course she has the handicap of having everything she writes down come true so she has to be very careful. After she kisses the frog to whom she has been telling stories, unbeknown to her he turns back into Prince Rumbold. He is determined to woo her but his courtship doesn't go easily and Kontis takes us through the stormy path of true love.
Kontis is amazing, retelling many fairy stories in a fabulous mix of complex ideas and events. The old rhyme about children who are named after the days of the week is particularly apt and weaves its way through the story, helping the reader understand the natures of Sunday's seven sisters. Great characterisation and plot make this a very readable story.
However what stood out for me was the humorous dialogue that often brought a smile to my face. This is a feel good book that would be a wonderful lift for anyone looking for interesting, well written fantasy. It is worthy of the awards that it has garnered, including an Andre Norton Award Nominee (2013) and YALSA Best Fiction for Young Adults (Top Ten) (2013) and it looks as if there will be more books to follow.
Pat Pledger

Sidney, Stella and the moon by Emma Yarlett

cover image

Lothian, 2013. ISBN 978 0 7344 1409 0.
(Age: 5+) Recommended. Picture book. Moon. Siblings. Sharing. Twins Stella and Sidney do everything together but when it comes to sharing, they are impossibly divided. One night fighting over a bouncy ball, the toy slips from their grasp and bounces out of the window, high into the sky, where is smashes into the moon, causing it to break into a million pieces. They are distraught, the sky has a black hole, how can the world exist without its moon?
They must work together to find a solution, trawling the house for something yellow and round to fill the space in the sky. Readers will love following the search for a replacement moon, spying all the different things on each page which are roundish and yellow.
When the one thing is found to put into the sky, a catapult is needed to propel it skywards, but the pair differ over who will shoot the machine. An argument known only too well to both children is neatly resolved as they work together.
The mixed media illustrations will draw the eager reader's eye to the detail presented on each page. Each page is presented differently, allowing the reader to be surprised as each page is turned, particularly when they reach the centre with its pair of doors ready to be opened to reveal the effects of the lack of a moon. The font is that of an old styled typewriter adding another level of interest to an already bold inviting book.
For teachers and parents looking for a book about sharing, or to introduce the sky to a child or group of children, this this book will be a must have.
Fran Knight

Killer App by S. Carey

cover image

Eerie Series. Puffin, 2013. ISBN: 9780143307365. Paperback, 72 pages. RRP: $9.99.
(Age: 8+) Roma and her friend are totally into their iPads and their apps. When a sinister man called Roderick offers the group a free app that downloads to each their own personal dream, Roma thinks it seems too good to be true. And Roma proves right when the five friends find themselves whirled out of their dreams and into a dangerous and deadly nightmare.
Not only is Roderick one seriously creepy nerd, he is a deeply disturbed one and his revenge for past rejections is about to impact on Roma and her mates. The only way to escape Roderick's hynoptic snare is to turn his plan back onto himself -and Roma has just what it takes to do that.
Clearly Dead Boring, the mysterious free app, is not quite as boring as it sounds.
Each of the Eerie series is cleverly enhanced with tiny 'flip' animations in the page corners and a new instalment of an additional story 'Monster Me' at the end of each book.
The series will comprise thirteen super spooky stories (Thirteen? Coincidence? I think not!) that will delight those 8+ years readers who savour the supernatural. There will be a rush on these when they hit your bookshelves - stand back and let the stampede begin!
Sue Warren

The treasure box by Margaret Wild

cover image

Ill. by Freya Blackwood. Penguin, 2013. ISBN 978 0 670 07365 8
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Picture book. Reading. Children in war. From the stunning cover to the words which follow Peter's journey from his war disrupted home to a new life, returning to retrieve the treasure box left him by his father, this book will resonate with all readers, young and old. Shadows of stories of people seeking refuge, of disrupted lives, of people fleeing their homes, of leaving all they love; crowd behind this tale, as Peter digs up the treasure box, buried for safe keeping years before.
All the while, the background begs the reader to touch each page, wondering at the three dimensional images presented by Freya Lockwood. Her illustrations from cut out paper, fill the pages, giving a shadowy effect to the story, impelling the reader to look behind the words at the people and their lives as they trudge away from war, die on the road to safety, find refuge in a new country, but still have ties to their homeland.
The first double page presents a bombed street, showing that the library has been bombed. Over the page pieces of pages from books float across the paper, as we see Peter's father has the one book that survived, the one he loved to read. As each page is turned, the muted colours contrast with the bright red colour of the cover of the book, shown to the son, kept safely in a box, and then passed on to Peter as father dies. The little figures of the refugees huddled into their blankets along the road is just one of the many haunting images presented in this book. In a new city, Peter grows up, eventually returning to the town and the tree where he buried the box containing the book. Its importance becomes clear as he places it on the library shelves where others will be able to borrow and read it.
Blackwood's use of smaller images against which a cut out is placed draws the eye in to look more closely at each image: her use of the floating pieces of paper remind us of the indiscriminate nature of war, the sepia colours of the houses and villages passed by the refugees underline the displacement of so many people, her contrasting images of the town and countryside when Peter is seeking refuge and when he returns an older man, reflect the ephemeral nature of war and that people survive, as do stories, the developing colour reflecting people's optimism and hope for the future. Blackwood has used torn pages from translated versions of Gleitzman's Once series, and Hartnett's The Silver Donkey, to fill the endpapers, using these again as the sky and some of the foreground in the book.
For teachers looking at the impact of war on children, of the importance of story and books, of passing on stories form one generation to another, of resilience and determination, then this is a stand out contribution to the books read in the classroom.
Fran Knight