Reviews

Other brother by Simon French

cover image

Walker Books, 2012. ISBN 978 1 971720 83 3
(Ages 11+) Highly recommended. Family. Seeing a new book by Simon French is enough to give me goosebumps as I recall with gratitude his earlier stories, Change the locks and Cannily cannily, which gave a sympathetic voice to those children rarely seen in children's book, the itinerant and neglected. In many books these children are presented as stereotypes, rarely are they seen as characters in their own right. The other brother, Bon, in this superb book, is a neglected child of a mentally unstable woman, who leaves him with her mother and sister in a small country town, where everyone knows each other's business.
The story revolves around the boy fitting in to his new family, especially his cousin, who rejects him out of hand, wanting to keep cool with his friends at school, and dismissing Bon's oddities as weird. His parents and sister, as well as his grandmother, are very sympathetic and supportive of Bon, and the reader feels from the start, that the adults know more than they are telling the children.
The school yard is most effectively shown, with its gangs of kids, places where some feel safer than others, kids looking to hurt, manipulate and undermine, while others show compassion and support. Bon and Kieran move around each other for a while, until the bullying by Kieran's friends puts him in a position where he must do the same to keep his friends. He is instantly sorry and his attempts to apologise to Bon see him following the boy into the night when he attempts to run away.
This is the sort of story all kids will read and discuss. It is the tale of an outsider, a neglected child who has looked after himself for many years, skirting around his mother's moods, then thrust into a family where even to sit down together is a different experience.
It is the story of being rejected, of fitting in, of changing attitudes, of things kept beneath the surface. But overall it is the story of a family, responding to the needs of another member, helping the child adapt to a calmer environment and helping their own son accept the new boy for what he is. The parents are marvellously drawn, so much so that several times, I reread passages to see how French had made me so involved in their lives. The minor characters too all have a face and background, each is individual, while the background of Bon's friend Julia is slowly revealed to the reader and we learn about it along with Kieran.
Fran Knight

Total recall by Philip K Dick

cover image

Gollancz, 2012. ISBN 9780 575 10029 9.
(Ages 12+) Recommended. Science fiction. Published to coincide with the release of remake of the 1990 Arnold Schwarzenegger film of the same name, now a cult classic, this book showcases many of Dick's well known stories. It includes those that have been made into successful films, We can remember it for you wholesale (Total recall), Do androids dream of electric sheep (Blade runner), as well as Minority report, A scanner darkly, The adjustment bureau and Paycheck. Dick often plays around with the idea of what is real, and in Total recall, the idea that a company can sell you fake memories is the starting point for factory worker Quaid, to question what he is and why he is there.
Each of the 24 stories included in this volume are questioning and unlike any other. The book has an introduction by Thomas M Dasch which is well worth reading, and the notes at the end of the book allow a peep into the mind of the creator when he wrote the stories.
For students of scifi, interested in where some of the big ideas first came from, or interested in the chronology of scifi, or simply interested in these stories, then this is a sound read. My only quibble is the size of the print. 44 lines to a page makes a dense text which is not easy to read, and means only the determined scifi fan will stick to the reading, which is a shame when this book offers such a breadth of fascinating stories and commentary.
Fran Knight

Possum magic - Numbers by Mem Fox

cover image

Ill. by Julie Vivas. Scholastic, 2012. ISBN 9781 86291 972 3.
(Ages: 1+) Recommended. Counting book. Australian animals. For the very young, this beautifully produced counting book, using never before seen pictures by Julie Vivas for the award winning Australian classic, Possum magic, will be a treat for all newly arrived children. The strong board book will be used over again in the bedroom, lounge and kitchen, wherever parents and older siblings treat their child to time out with a book. Eventually the children will grab hold of it themselves, immersing their faces in the sweep of recognised characters and the numbers going from 1 to 10.
This does not follow the strict pattern of other counting books, instead making things a little more interesting, with two numbers on the one double page being part of the same picture. So with a picture of nine lamingtons, for example, we also have the number ten included, with ten bites. So the humour will entreat both the listener and the reader, looking for the number of items given in print in the beautifully rendered, familiar illustrations.
Again the well known Australian animals take a bow, adding an extra level of learning for the younger reader, teaching them not only their first ten numbers but also a little about the flora and fauna of this country. Presented are possums, kookaburras, koalas, and an echidna, amongst the gum blossoms. The one sad thing is that it only goes to ten, but parents will be able to dig out their old childhood copy of Possum magic to read and share again with their children.
Fran Knight

Give us a goal! Football poems by Paul Cookson

cover image

Frances Lincoln Children's Books (Harper) 2012. ISBN 978 1 84780 341 2.
(Ages 9+) Football. Poetry. Lifetime football fan and poet in residence at the National Football Museum in England, Cookson is well known for his funny poems about football, and this is a collection of about 50 of them. Begging to be read out loud, they are often short, pithy and sometimes poignant. These poems are divided, cunningly, into groups reflecting a football match. So we have several in Warm up, another bunch in the First half, then Second half and finally Extra time. Each grouping of poems makes sense in the division in which it is placed.
Several I loved and laughed out loud, knowing how a class might respond when read to them. 'When the wasp flew up my brother's shorts' is one such poem. The title says it all, and the poem goes on to show how the others ignored his plight, thinking his behaviour resulted from his kicking a goal. Read out loud this would cause hilarity in the classroom and with all listeners.
Many more are just as funny, poking fun at Mum who has volunteered as the trainer for Dad's team so that she can rub down one of the men, or the things that Dad has said in the past about playing football. Several display the way some men change once they are at a football match, and so 'Werewolf Dad', and 'Dad don't shout at the ref!' are presented. There are a number about the poor referee, and more about the audience that go to the games, while the whole is rounded off with the final poem,'We believe in football'.
All the poems display different poetic techniques so may be useful int he classroom to model things like haiku, picture poems, list poems and the like. The illustrations add to the fun of the small volume of poems.
Fran Knight

Alice-Miranda shows the way by Jacqueline Harvey

cover image

Random House, 2012. ISBN: 9781742751177.
Highly recommended for ages 8 and up. As the delightful Alice-Miranda celebrates her eighth birthday, excitement is building for both the girls and the staff of Winchesterfield-Downsfordvale Academy. The village show is about to occur, complete with events for everyone, as well as providing an extra day off of school. Whilst Alice-Miranda and Millie are practicing their horse riding skills, others are completing needle work pieces and perfecting their baking skills. When Evelyn Pepper, the trainer of Rockstar, the Queen's favourite horse, is admitted to hospital, Alice-Miranda becomes involved. Her pony, Bonaparte, is the only thing which can calm Rockstar and encourage him to race, thereby leaving open the Aunty Gee's chances of winning the Queen's Cup. Into the mix, add the carnival people, who are much maligned by the locals and held accountable for anything which goes wrong or missing during their time in the Village.
Harvey has created some eminently likeable characters, almost certainly too good to be true, yet whom one would be happy to class as friends. Similarly, any child reading these books would undoubtedly fall in love with the idea of attending Alice-Miranda's school. The girls seem spend little time in class but many hours on pursuing their own interests. They appear to have a great deal of freedom, allowing them to visit various other people and locations, seemingly without restrictions. As with the other titles in this series, there are some predictable turns of events for older readers, yet younger children may not find this to be the case. The key characters are believable and demonstrate the ability to change and grow. There is the inevitable 'baddie' as well, yet, thanks to the ingenuity of Alice-Miranda, the reader knows that there will always be a happy ending.
Jo Schenkel

The twelve days of Aussie Christmas by Colin Buchanan

cover image

Ill. by Glen Singleton. Scholastic, 2012. ISBN 9781 74283 367 5.
(Ages 4+) Picture book, Christmas. The familiar Christmas Carol, The twelve days of Christmas, is here reprised with an Australian flavour, using iconic characters and animals to build up the fun of the twelve days. Children familiar with the carol will get the point immediately, but others may have to have it played a few times, and perhaps compared with the original to understand it more completely. All in all, though, it is good fun and enticing to small children who love rhyme, reading aloud, learning new songs and reading along with others. The repetition of the song builds as it goes along and makes it an easy one to learn. The accompanying CD will be put to good use in the classroom and at home.
Each day is represented by a different Australian image, starting with one platypus up the gum tree, then two jackaroos, three meat trays, four footy fans, five rusty utes, six snags, seven chooks, eight jumbucks, nine dingoes, ten swaggies, eleven cricket legends and twelve surfing Santas. Alliteration is used profusely helping the words to stay in the mind, and the stress on Australian slang, makes this a useful tool to talk about words and their meanings. For an overseas audience a different level of language education can be pursued.
On each page is hidden, well almost, a number of Australian animals for the children to look for, so that by the end of the book, there are 150 items to be found, adding yet another level of fun at Christmas time.
Fran Knight

Pearlie and the flamenco fairy by Wendy Harmer

cover image

Random House, 2012. ISBN 9781 74275 540 3
(Ages: 5+) Early chapter book. Pearlie series. Another in this series which has now grown to 14, sees Pearlie traveling on a ladybird to Spain, where her friend, Florentina is throwing her a flamenco party. Going to the Royal Botanic Gardens where her friend lives, she is amazed to be able to learn the flamenco, and many Spanish words while preparing for the party. Spanishisma abound as the girls try on their new clothes, learn their steps, eat Spanish food and put on the flamenco for the guests. But Pearlie falls over her wand, and a neat resolution makes her win even more friends.
Easy to read with the bright bold coloured illustrations as with all the stories in this series this book continues the tales of Pearlie and her friends. For early primary people setting out reading chapter books, this will not cause much difficulties as the print is reasonably large, and there is not much print to each page. Sometimes I felt the colour interfered with the print, and some chapter breaks may help early readers, but all in all this series is an easy introduction to more strenuous chapter books.
Fran Knight

Blood Brothers by Carole Wilkinson

cover image

Black Dog Books, 2012. ISBN: 9781742031897.
Highly recommended for ages 10 and up. Tao, happily ensconced as a novice Buddhist monk in the Yinmi Monastery, is intent on translating ancient scrolls and working diligently to ensure that he and his much loved brother will gain grace and favour in their future lives. When he is confronted by a dragon whilst carrying out his labours, Tao decides not to tell anyone of what he has seen and soon becomes involved in helping and healing Kai. The dragon, Kai, now 465 years of age, is merely a teenager, set on finding his new dragon keeper. Despite Tao's disbelief that it is he who has been chosen to fulfil this role, Kai seems determined that he is correct and demands that the young man take on the task. Against his better judgement, Tao temporarily leaves the Monastery and heads off on an adventure with the dragon.
Despite Wilkinson having previously sworn that she would not be writing any future books in this series, she will undoubtedly have created a very happy bunch of fans by continuing the story of Kai's adventures. Due to Kai being a familiar character, with distinctive methods of communication and behaviour, it was very easy to pick up this new tale and feel I'd almost read parts of it before. Nonetheless, it is very much a new story and I enjoyed meeting Tao and his family. I revelled in seeing him squirm as he began to question his calling as a monk, or become less able to follow their demands strictly. For example, the loss of the special cloth which had been used for straining his water to ensure he could avoid consuming any small living creatures saw a loosening of his beliefs or practices. Through such instances, the author has made this into something of a coming of age novel as well as an enjoyable fantasy. Death, family relationships, duty, responsibility and the following of one's calling are all themes which appear in this most enjoyable story.
Jo Schenkel

Tree: A little story about big things by Danny Parker

cover image

Ill. by Matt Ottley. Little Hare Books, 2012. ISBN 9781921714412.
(Ages: 5+) Recommended. Picture book. Environment. Subtitled 'a little story about big things', this tale will be a boon for those teachers wanting to introduce the topic of environment and sustainability in their classrooms, as it depicts a tree growing within the protective roots of another, which when the older tree is blown down, grows on its own, despite the encroaching city, then nurtures another seedling within its roots. The themes of sustainability, caring for the environment, nurturing the young, sit well with this tree, its rings on the back cover elucidating more of the themes possible in this book. The development of the sapling, growing as each season passes, will intrigue younger readers as they watch its progress to a mighty tree, under which people and animals shelter.
The illustrations are breathtaking. Ottley's tree on the front cover invites the reader into its dense foliage, benignly calls the young reader to climb its roots, and its life as more than a tree is replicated on the back cover's rings. Each page offers a different perspective using Ottley's incredible eye. The front cover shows a tree from a child's point of view, later from that of the animals which hide in its roots, then the sky as the wind blows the tree savagely and again from on high as we see the city taking over the area in which the tree stands. The city seems to appear very suddenly, but just as quickly changes from a stark, smoke belching environment to one which seems calmer and is surrounded by trees.
Readers will look at trees differently after falling into this worthy book.
Fran Knight

Tom Gates: Everything's amazing (sort of) by Liz Pichon

cover image

Scholastic, 2012. ISBN 1407124412.
Recommended for 8-12 years. Tom Gates is back in the third novel of his adventures. Fans of Tom Gates will love that the format is the same. Lots of line illustrations, a few sentences on each page and Tom's eternal struggle with his older sister Delia.
In this novel Tom and his mate Derek enter Rooster the dog into the local dog show, Tom has a birthday, Granny Mavis still cooks exotic food combinations and plans are being made for the school disco.
Throughout the book Tom gets in and out of trouble and just tries to survive as a fifth grader.
These are highly sought after books at my school. They are easy to read but have an entertaining storyline and great little sketches. Wimpy Kid readers are particularly keen to read Tom Gates.
Jane Moore

Found: the art of recycling by Lisa Holzl

cover image

Walker Books Australia, 2012. ISBN 9781921720130.
Recommended. Reference. Art. Recycling. In this handbook introducing students to various art styles of the twentieth century and encouraging them to try them for themselves, the teacher will find lots of information to share with their classes as well as hints about how to encourage their students to try their hand at the styles shown. The idea of recycling is given in its broadest sense from the cover with many words which advance the idea of recycling, to the pages inside showing just how many artists have gone about their work. Using other medium for their work began in the early 1900's with Picasso using newspaper, Duchamp using a bicycle wheel, while Hausman used part of a wooden model.
Each double page introduces one artist, and after a potted history of the times, shows one of his or her works which reflects the idea of using found objects. Picasso is the first represented. A brief outline of his life and times follows, then an image of a painting done in 1913 is shown, briefly discussed then set in its time. At the bottom of the page is given an outline of an activity which could be done in the classroom, emulating the work by that artist. For people wanting more information there are references at the back of the book to other books and websites.
Each of the artists represented here reflects a different style of work done in the twentieth century, and range from Picasso at the beginning to Fiona Hall and others born towards the end of the century. A contents page is followed by a timeline of the major art movements of the twentieth century from Cubism to Installation art, and each artist represented fits one of these categories.
The whole is rounded off with a glossary, potted biographical notes about each of the artists and a detailed index. This is a wonderful teaching tool for primary classrooms and the look of the book, presented as a scrapbook with torn paper, newspaper scraps and sellotape, add to the interest the book will engender.
Fran Knight

Between the lines by Jodi Picoult and Samantha Van Leer

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012. ISBN 1743310927.
Delilah hates school, she would rather pretend she is somewhere else. That's why she loves books so much. Every time she opens one she can pretend she is someone else, somewhere else. But there is one particular book she can't get enough of. It's a lovely fairy tale she found sitting the library and if anyone knew how much she had read that book over and over again she'd be a social outcast forever.
When the main character of the book, a prince named Oliver, starts talking to Delilah she thinks she must be crazy. Oliver wants to be free of his story and Delilah will do just about anything to help him. But after a failed attempt to get a spider out of the book it looks like Oliver might be permanently stuck.
This book had my eyes glued to the pages until the very end; it was amazing. This book was definitely a different style for Jodi Picoult but was still just as good as all of her other books and an amazing first book for Samantha Van Leer. I would highly recommend this book to people who like fantasy stories and Jodi Picoult's books.
Tahlia Kennewell (Student)

Clementine Rose and the Surprise Visitor by Jacqueline Harvey

cover image

Clementine Rose series, no. 1. Random House Australia, 2012. 128 pages. ISBN 1742755410
(Ages: 7-10) Recommended. 5-year-old Clemmie is different to most young girls. She was delivered as a baby in the back of a mini-van in a basket of dinner rolls to Penberthy House, home of Lady Clarissa. A crumbling old mansion, Penberthy House is run by Lady Clarissa as a country hotel in order to keep the place in good repair. However the out of the way town of Penberthy Floss is not exactly on the tourist trail so it is lucky that Lady Clarissa has a special knack with winning nearly every competition she enters. As soon as Lady Clarissa laid eyes on the baby Clementine Rose she knew that she belonged at Penberthy House with her and the butler Uncle Digby. So sets the scene for a new series set in this quaint little village with endearing characters with sweet dispositions and a crumbling mansion filled with love, warmth and charm.
This first instalment in the series sees a surprise visitor, Aunt Violet, arrive at Penberthy House. Clementine Rose has never met Aunt Violet but she can tell that Lady Clarissa doesn't like her very much. Even more strangely Aunt Violet doesn't seem happy to be at Penberthy House at all. Clementine Rose soon realises that something fishy is going on. Why is Aunt Violet really here, and what is she carrying in her mysterious black bag?
The text is interspersed with very few pictures and the text on the pages is quite dense making it unsuitable for younger readers who may find the text too long and arduous. However the book could be a fantastic read aloud novel for younger girls who the character of 5-year-old Clemmie would appeal to. Even though Clementine Rose is 5-years-old the story will still appeal to children above this age who will appreciate the 'cuteness' of Clemmie and her sweet teacup pig named Lavender.
In the same vein as her fantastic Alice-Miranda series Jacqueline Harvey has created a character whose curiosity and sense of adventure can often get her into trouble and whose loveable traits will make her a favourite of young girls.
Nicole Smith-Forrest

Go Goanna by Justin D'Ath

cover image

Mission Fox series, no. 7. Puffin, 2012. ISBN 0143306944
(Ages 7-10) Recommended. Harry and Jordan are twins committed to the Mission Fox Animal Rescue agency. So when a giant goanna in the back of Mr Dalby's delivery van is being poked with a broom handle Harry and Jordan are under oath to step in under rule 1. 'Rescue animals that are in danger'. Being late for school is one things but missing the Pet Olympics being held at school would be terrible. Deciding it is the only option, Harry and Jordan set off to school on their FoxMobile being pulled by their humongous dog Myrtle and take the caged lizard with them. When the goanna is accidentally let loose the school, which is filled with pets of all kinds, turns to bedlam. It only gets worse when the Principal's son gets stuck up a tree while trying to rescue his kitten. Can Harry and Jordan use their animal rescue skills to help him before he falls six meters to the ground and redeem themselves for ruining the Pet Olympics? Just when everything is getting back to normal the goanna reappears. Can Mission Fox perform another wild rescue and get the goanna back to where it is safe?
These Mission Fox stories are perfect for younger readers and will appeal equally to boys and girls. The stories will be meaningful to children as they are set within the real world rather than a fantasy one and contain fast paced adventure as well as a good dose of humour. The larger text makes them a great novel for children moving from beginning reader chapter books into novels with only intermittent illustrations.
Nicole Smith-Forrest

Rumour has it: Girl heart boy by Ali Cronin

cover image

Razorbill. Penguin, 2012. ISBN: 9780141340630.
This is not a book I would normally read and I can't say it would be one I'd read again, however everybody has their favourite themes and styles and this novel may appeal to others through its complex and emotional plot centred around the worth of relationships and the importance of self respect.
Ashley is an open book and while her friends try to settle down and start relationships all she wants is a good time. But will she sing a different tune when Dylan shows up with Donna's cousin Marv? Rediscovering emotions is hard when you've lived a life sheltered and hidden from pain but what will Ashley do when she is forced to deal with all of life's problems at once? How is Ashley's sister so perfect and when did her little sister start to like boys? Her life is a bomb shell waiting to go off.
Rumour has it is an easy to read novel written for teenage girls and set in the UK based loosely around the themes of fitting in and learning to respect oneself and others. I would suggest that it should be read by a middle school age group as these lessons are important to young adolescents of today.
Kayla Gaskell (Year 11).

Editor's note: Explicit content warning on back cover.