Reviews

The fabulous Finola Fox by Carmel Bird

cover image

Ill. by Kerry Argent. Penguin/Viking, 2013. ISBN 9780670029488.
(Age: 4+) Warmly recommended. Picture book. Shoes. Family. Finola Fox is a shoe fetishist. Whenever she sees shoes, she must have them, so spirits them away in her capacious handbag, taking them home where she stores them in rows in her cellar.  She hopes one day to be able to open a museum to display them all, but until then, she busies herself arranging them all. She notices that one shoe is alone. It was a glamorous jewelled and feathered shoe that she found in an alleyway last summer.
She sets out to find its pair. She goes to the wonderful hotel, the art gallery, the Botanic Gardens and the Opera House, all to no avail. Outside the Opera House, she notices a pair of green sandals getting into  a limousine. About to follow the car, she is stopped by another fox who introduces himself as Frederick, who asks her what she is searching for. He surprises her by telling her that he thinks he knows just where to look. Together they find the missing shoe and return to her house which Frederick thinks is an ideal place for the museum.
This is a charming tale of coming together, like a pair of shoes. The two foxes find each other in the streets of Sydney, and together find the shoe Finola is searching for. The pair of shoes parallels the two foxes in finding a friend, a mate, a companion.
Argent's illustrations are just wonderful. She has an amazing collection of people and animals on each page, reflecting the text in the foxes' search for the missing shoe. The bold, colourful pages will entice the reader to look more closely, following the fox as she searches under counters, along the rows of seats in the Opera House, through the shrubbery in the gardens.
Fran Knight

Stardines swim high across the sky by Jack Prelutsky

cover image

Ill. by Carin Berger. HarperCollins, 2013. ISBN 9780062014641.
(Age: 5+) Recommended. Poetry. Humour. With verses about animals that are made up using the roots of several words, these poems are simply fun. Star and sardine, for example is an amalgam that produces a fish like thing in the night sky, swimming in giant school, lighting up the night sky. The sobcat is a very very sad feline, while the slobbster is a very messy lobster, so messy in fact that it is a slob.
Each of the animals has a poem about it, explaining its virtues and possibly its disadvantages as well. The poems are short, easy to read, but do not pander to a younger audience, using an array of wonderful words like lachrymose, preposterously and copious. I found myself thinking how to use it in the classroom, not merely as a wonderful read a loud, but as a model for poetry lessons, encouraging children to make up words from known animals, and then using the technique to make up a poem. Most of the poems use the basic four line stanza of alternatively rhyming lines, while some use nursery rhymes as the basis of the rhythm, and so are easy to emulate.
The illustrations will engage the children's interest immediately. Berger builds dioramas, using a huge range of things to build up the images which are then photographed for the book. Children will love picking out the found objects, the pieces of note paper, he music paper, wool, cloth, ribbon, cut up paper and so on. Each page is absorbing to look at as the poem is read. It is a lovely book to hold and read, full of possibilities, humour and fun, begging to be shared.
Fran Knight

Lulu Bell and the Cubby Fort by Belinda Murrell

cover image

Ill. by Serena Geddes. Random House Australia Children's, 2013. ISBN: 9781742758794.
Themes: Family Life, Farm Life, Holidays.
Lulu Bell and the Moon Dragon by Belinda Murrell
Ill. by Serena Geddes. Random House Australia Children's, 2013. ISBN: 9781742758817.
Themes: Vietnamese Moon Festival, Whale watching, School Life, Bullying, Conflict Resolution, Friendship.
(Age: 7-9) Highly recommended. Lulu Bell is a fun-loving, friendly eight-year-old girl with honey-blonde plaits. Her family lives next door to her dad Dr. Bell's vet hospital. Her Mum is an artist, her six year old sister Rosie wears angel wings and sparkly shoes and her three year old brother Gus loves to wear his superhero Bug Boy suit. Of course they have a large menagerie of animals, two dogs called Asha and Jessie, two ginger cats called Pickles and Pepper, some ducklings, and a rabbit. Lulu Bell and her family were introduced in Lulu Bell and the Birthday Unicorn where the family has trouble at Rosie's sixth birthday with a runaway pony. In Lulu Bell and the Fairy Penguin, the family is going for a swim when a runaway dog chases a little penguin down the beach and Lulu involved in the rescue.
The adventures continue in Lulu Bell and the Cubby Fort with her family spending an exciting Easter holiday at her Uncle's farm with lots of their cousins. They enjoy the freedom of the farm, building and setting up a cubby fort in the bush, swimming in the creek, riding horses and rescuing a calf stuck in the mud. Campfires and sleeping in tents add to the holiday excitement.
Lulu Bell and the Moon Dragon is another well written story celebrating the Vietnamese Lunar Festival with the Lulu's friends and family, making costumes, lanterns and moon cakes. Belinda Murrell portrays school life vividly from a class excursion to watching the whales migrating, to dealing with bullying and sharing cultural diversity.
This series is a great class read-aloud and I would highly recommend them for readers from 7-9 years. The quirky family are very relatable and funny. Serena Geddes black and white sketches support the narrative and add an exciting emotional quality to the novels.
Rhyllis Bignell

Alfie's search for destiny by David Hardy

cover image

Magabala Books, 2013. ISBN 1 92114241 5
(Age: 4+) Picture book. Aboriginal themes. Survival. Family. In searching for his destiny, Alfie wanders away from home, looking under rocks, and into the sky, looking behind trees. He runs from the croc rearing up beneath the river, and escapes from the snake hanging down from the tree, until he finds a group of animals. He asks them what his destiny is, but they are unable to answer. Eventually the boy returns home and hearing the voices of his mum and dad, realises that his life is with them, his destiny is at home.
In rhyming text, the tale of Alfie searching all the while for his destiny, and finally realising his place is at home, represents us all in our search for the question about the meaning of life and why we are here. The story reflects the need of all children to be given space but within the context of a warm loving, family.
The background illustrations show the range of territory that Alfie wanders over, exposing the Northern Australian environment to another audience, and Hardy's time spent in the studios of Walt Disney clearly has influenced his work. A touch of Manga will also appeal to the younger readers, eager to pick up a book which exemplifies the stability and base that a loving family offers all children.
Fran Knight

Star cursed by Jessica Spotswood

cover image

Penguin, 2013. ISBN 9780141342139. 367p.
Star Cursed is the sequel to Born Wicked, making it the second volume of the Cahill Witch Chronicles. Jessica Spotswood's alternate history of New England, USA, chronicles the secret society of witches. We follow Cate's recruitment to the big city convent school, but the religious order is a front for the 'Sisterhood' of witches in the same manner that 'Hogwarts' is really a school for English witches and wizards.
Cate could be the witch prophesied to lead the Sisterhood next when Sister Cora passes away. Or is it one of her sisters - Maura or Tess? When all sisters are forced to join the Sisterhood, Maura plots to overthrow Cate as the favourite candidate.
The puritan society of New England is a dangerous place for these witches who are capable of illusions, erasing minds and healing. These skills cannot be used haphazardly without arousing suspicion because the brotherhood is arresting and torturing any innocent woman suspected of witchcraft or visions.
Finn is still Cate's romantic interest and he has joined the Brotherhood. Will he understand why she ran away to the convent instead of accepting his marriage proposal?
Maura's alliances and attacks threaten to incite the Brotherhood to persecute witches like never before, whereas Cate and Tess prefer less risky resistance and rescue operations. The next instalment should see the conflict resolved and a true leader emerge.
Deb Robins

Spy for the Queen of Scots by Theresa Breslin

cover image

Corgi, 2013. ISBN: 9780552560757.
Highly recommended. Award winning author Theresa Breslin provides insight into the tragic life of history's obscure Scottish regent Mary Stuart who faced sexism and religious discrimination from all those of her age whilst she struggled to unite a warring nation.
Born into royalty and crowned as a baby, Mary Stuart Queen of Scots is surrounded by agents of deceit throughout her life, never knowing quite who to trust, however there is one person who has always remained loyal, Jenny. Childhood friends who were nursed together in France away from their Scottish homeland, Jenny is the confidant and friend that Mary needs throughout the persecution she faces on her return to her Scottish homeland after the murder of her first husband, King Francis. While Mary relies upon her friend the Lady Ginette, Jenny in turn relies upon her protector Sir Duncan Alexander, a man who she has always loved, although surrounded by the deceit and ill-intent towards her queen Jenny distrusts the man who always seems to be in the right place at the right time. In her role as spy for the Queen of Scots, her suspicions drive a wedge between the two.
I would highly recommend this novel to all lovers of historic fiction, the simple presentation of the complex dramas of 1500's monarch life is easy to understand and provides for a very exciting read. Sophisticated and engaging, this novel is a sure representation of great historic fiction. It brings the drama of court life, the stress of political problems and the treachery of nobles and lords of old. This novel has everything any good novel should, a dramatic plot filled with subterfuge, believable characters and of course a brilliant writer.
Kayla Gaskell (Student)

Archie's holiday by Domenica Gordon

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 978 1 4088 2932 5.
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Picture book. Dogs. Holidays. When Archie decides to go on a holiday, he begins to pack his suitcase. He packs his sunglasses and Panama hat, but on sleeping that night, dreams of thunderstorms and heavy rain. The next day he adds his raincoat, umbrella and hot water bottle to the suitcase. That night he dreams of all the food that he might have on his holiday, and so the next day packs all the things he might need for indigestion and tummy troubles, packing pills and lotions and creams along with his first aid box. The suitcase is getting bigger!
The very next night he dreams of swimming at the beach, and so packs swimmers, rubber tubes, bucket and spade and all the things he might need at the beach. All the while the wonderful script is full of single words telling what he is packing, as the suitcase gets bigger and bigger. Both Archie and his dog keep adding things to the case, until the middle opening pages show what happens to the poor case. After this disaster, Archie comes up with a neat solution of what to take on his holiday.
Lively illustrations accompany the charming story, inviting readers to seek and find the array of things shown on each page. They will laugh with glee at the increasing size of the suitcase, predicting what may happen, and laugh again at Archie's solution.
What a wonderful story, beautifully illustrated. This could be part of any discussions at home or in the classroom about holidays, what to pack, what is appropriate at different destinations, and how to choose what to take.
Fran Knight

Julius and the Watchmaker by Tim Hehir

cover image

Text, 2013. ISBN: 9781922079732.
Recommended for readers from 12-14 years of age. Subjects: Time travel, Clocks and watches, Fantasy, Steampunk, Victorian England, Science Fiction, Adventure. Tim Hehir's first novel set in 1837 London is complex and intriguing, taking young Julius Higgins on unbelievable escapades, fighting villains, making new friends, time-travelling into alternate worlds and meeting literary and historical figures.
Julius works in his grandfather's bookshop in Ironmonger Lane, until Jack Springheel a mysterious clock collector comes looking for John Harrison the famous watchmaker's diary. Quickly Julius is drawn into the adventure becoming a runaway and a thief stealing the diary, making a regretful deal with Springheel. Fortunately he also meets the professor and Mr Flynn who come to his assistance with another time piece that allows time travel.
The cast of characters add richness to the plot's complexity, Emily and her band of street urchins, the fierce Grackacks who inhabit an alternate London, to Christian Machine and the clockmen, the rich and poor of Victorian England. Hehir's attention to detail is evident, from the housing, architecture, historic events even using the vernacular of the day all adds depth and interest to the novel.
Julius is thrown into alternative worlds that are frightening, confronting and strange. London controlled by the power hungry Grackacks is preparing for a war with amazing flying machines zettmalins in the sky and huge wheeled steel ships docked at the river. Each chapter is titled with a date and time to allow the reader to follow Julius forwards and backwards in Victorian England. Tim Hehir's captivating time travel novel is the first in the Watchmaker series.
Rhyllis Bignell

Colour for curlews by Renee Treml

cover image

Random House, 2013. ISBN 9781 74275 921 0.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Picture book. Australian birds. Colour. Two curlews take paint and an artist's paint brush and proceed to use the colours in unexpected ways. With tubes of paint tucked under their wings, they paint each other's eyes with yellow. The bowerbird spies the tube of blue and paints himself with the colour he so admires. The brolga grabs the red, the quails the red and yellow and make orange the lorikeet the yellow and blue to make green, while the doves mash many colours together to make purple. Each set of birds grabs a different colour to adorn themselves with and some use two colours to make another. In the end the wombat rolls around in a maze of colours making brown, his favourite colour and he goes to sleep.
Told in verse form, the rhymes and rhythms of the words will keep children and parents reading, as the story of the birds and the colours mixes to a absorbing story of colour. Readers will love to read of the variety of Australian birds and one animal, and the colours they already are, comparing them with the colour they attach to themselves after taking the paintbox. Various bird prints splash across the pages as they tramp in the different colours. For a book extolling the variety of colours and their names, along with information at the end of the book about the birds presented, this will be a well used addition to the class or home library.
Fran Knight

All our yesterdays by Cristin Terrill

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 978 14088 35197.
(Age: 15+) Em and Finn suffer terribly from their decision to travel back in time to ensure the destruction of Cassandra, a device originally designed to avert disaster and tragedy.  Altering the sequence of time and the resultant paradoxes which are produced are thought provoking and compelling concepts to construct a story around and this novel had great potential.
Described in split character narratives from the heroine's future and past, the complex alternate realities are difficult to comprehend at times, however this is a feature of the subject and the challenge to the reader is reasonable. An interesting device is used to distinguish the older Em from her younger self which enables the reader to appreciate which aspect is speaking as the complexities and sinister outcomes from Cassandra are revealed.
Clever character and plot developments are features of this story which in its latter stages draws events and relationships together in mind bending parallel histories. Explaining further runs the risk of spoiling the story which hinges on a significant twist which, whilst evident very early, maintains the framework until conclusion.
My criticism of this novel is that whilst the concept is intelligent, the opening chapters are written as if the novel was a later book in a series, relying on a reader's prior knowledge of characters and events. This may be a device to prompt readers to persist, in order to discover what the start was about. It is boldly different to traditional chronological narratives and makes sense when sequences are explained later, however some readers might understandably abandon the novel in frustrated bewilderment.
Strong characters eventually bind this story which sadly loses momentum with the excessive portrayal of teenage social posturing. The characters are not always pleasant as they display flaws and attitudes appropriate to the alternate realities of the time shift. The precocious younger version of Em, a spoiled brat with witless attitudes and juvenile romantic obsessions, later shines as a brave young woman enduring cruelty and torment.
Torture scenes are skilfully implied, effectively conveying fear and prompting revulsion without overt description. Violence is not described excessively but swearing in keeping with the context occurs on a couple of occasions and I would suggest this novel suits 15+.
Rob Welsh

Killer Ute by Rosanne Hawke

cover image

UQP, 2013. ISBN 9780702249600.
(Age: 10+) Recommended. Thriller. Adventure. Family. Stereotypes. While in court giving evidence against Scott, his bikie father, Joel is warned by him to watch out. Fearing what could happen, his grandmother sends him off with Dev his foster father to hide out on a remote farm. At first Joel thinks it is just a holiday but when a ute with enormous bullbars runs them off the road, he realises that he is in danger. As the attacks mount the suspense becomes unbearable and Dev and Joel, with his friend Mia, go deeper into hiding.
The third book following The keeper and Sailmaker, this is an ideal adventure story to tempt boys into reading. It has all the ingredients to get children excited - a chilling adventure, big cars, scuba diving, fishing and motor bikes, all put together in a very well written package. The series would also be a good read aloud, starting with the first book and letting children read the next two themselves.
What I particularly liked in this series was the breaking down of stereotypes that Hawke does so subtly and effortlessly. The reader will discover that not every bikie is bad, indeed the members of the Longriders are shown to be helpful and honest. Joel has learning and behavioural difficulties but his efforts at self discipline are shown in a sympathetic light, as are single parent families. Joel wishes that Dev could be his real father and has gradually come to understand why his very young mother left him with his grandmother to raise.
It is a pleasure to see this excellent series in print.
Pat Pledger

Superkid by Claire Freedman

cover image

Ill. by Sarah McIntyre. Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9781407124063.
Recommended for 4-6 years of age. Themes: Heroes, Stories in rhyme, Bullying.
'There's a boy quite ordinary, He looks like me or you, but in secret . . . he is SUPERKID - There's nothing he can't do! '
Superkid's special powers assist him in all sorts of tricky situations, in the classroom, dealing with bullies in the yard and helping at home. Claire Freedman's rhyming text provides an exciting jumping off point for Sarah McIntyre's crazy over the top cartoon style drawings. Each page is jam-packed with action and there are so many little surprises to be found before the reader turns the page. The broccoli tree at dinner-time is an absolute winner, a very relatable page for kids who have difficulty eating their vegetables.
Superkid fights the school bullies, assists in the dramas of bedroom cleaning and in the unfortunate capture by a pirate crew. His skills and powers prove to be a handy tool. The messy bedroom scene is one of the funnier double page spreads. There is so much to take in right down to Mum's bunny slippers.
Author Claire Freedman is a well known British picture-book author, here she shows her understanding of encouraging a young audience to face up to their challenges. Sarah McIntyre's illustrations are colourful, fun and full of life, they really add the pizzazz to the rhyme.
Rhyllis Bignell

Zac and Mia by A.J. Betts

cover image

Text, 2013. ISBN 9781922147257.
(Age 14+) Highly recommended. Winner of the Text Prize, 2012. Zac is in hospital undergoing another round of cancer treatments when he hears the girl in the next room. She is loud and feisty and plays her music very loudly. Zac makes contact with Mia by tapping on the wall and from there a friendship grows that neither expects.
With a family history of cancer, I usually avoid books about the topic, but decided to read this one as it had won the Text Prize and I had enjoyed other Text Prize winners. I am pleased that I did as it was not a tear jerker, but rather a story that showed the enormous courage and resilience that cancer sufferers must have, not just when in hospital getting treatment, but also when they go home and face a future that is different to what they had planned. It was an uplifting and emotional journey for me, with the compassion and humour of the writing making it a wonderful reading experience.
Zac is a character who is easy to like. He is funny and straight forward and manages his fears by quoting all sorts of statistics about cancer and trying to be positive. (The reader learns a lot about cancer on the way). He is surrounded by an overprotective but very loving mother and family. Mia on the other hand is angry, angry about her cancer, furious with her mother and bitterly disappointed in her boyfriend. She is careless about her health and her relationships. Both come to need each other at different times, relying on each other's strengths. The book clearly showed the importance of support for cancer sufferers from family and friends, even if it is shunned at the time.
A.J. Betts has spent years as a hospital teacher, and her research, knowledge of hospitals, patients and their routines shines through, giving the story a feeling of depth and authenticity. I can highly recommend this book as a possible literature circle or class set book in schools and a must have in libraries.
Pat Pledger

Not for turning: the life of Margaret Thatcher by Robin Harris

cover image

Transworld Publishers, 2013. ISBN 9780593072868.
(Age: 17+) Margaret Thatcher overcame many challenges to become not only the Leader of the Conservative Party but also Britain's first female Prime Minister, and the longest serving British Prime Minster in the twentieth century. These challenges included the Falklands war, a terrorist attack on the British Cabinet and economic woes within Britain whilst in power. Robin Harris delves into Margaret Thatcher's personal life as well as her political career in portraying her as a driven and passionate individual. Her entry into the male dominated British Parliament is one of the fascinating aspects of this book, highlighting her intellectual strengths and courage. Despite being her speechwriter and close advisor Robin Harris has written a balanced and objective account of Margaret Thatcher's successes and failures as a politician and person. Her interactions involving international affairs and with other world leaders as British Prime Minister were comprehensively highlighted and in the case of General Pinochet, a united Europe and Bosnia, demonstrated her commitment to truth and justice and overwhelming loyalty to those causes she strongly believed in. Margaret Thatcher remained involved in politics after leaving office in 1990, however sadly her intellectual drive and passion to bring about change were severely curtailed not only by opposition from within the party she once led and personal money worries but also due to her Alzheimer's. The only downside to Not for turning: the life of Margaret Thatcher was the demanding vocabulary used which detracted somewhat from the overall flow of the writing itself. Recommended for university or senior school students studying politics and women's studies as a thought-provoking introduction to Margaret Thatcher; a formidable presence in British and world politics.
Tara Burton

Dangerous girls by Abigail Haas

cover image

Simon & Schuster Childrens Books, 2013. ISBN 9781471119149
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. Anna, her boyfriend Tate, her best friend Elise and a group of close friends, are off holidaying in Aruba to celebrate before they all go to college. But the holiday is cut short when Elise is found brutally murdered, and no one knows who killed her.
Anna is swiftly arrested and stands trial for the murder of her best friend. As the trial continues, everyone starts to question her innocence, even those closest to her. To the rest of the world, she isn't just guilty, she's dangerous. But as the truth begins to come out, it will be even more shocking...
At a first glance this book seems to be a formulaic, young-adult whodunit murder mystery. First looks have never been so deceptive. What begins as a simple teenage novel quickly grows into a fascinating, intricate murder mystery, one that envelops the reader completely in its complex web of lies, deceit and murder. The book is fast-paced and exciting, making the reader want to turn the pages at a feverish pace. The characters, although seeming somewhat stereotypical at first, end up being developed very well. Subtle hints are shown throughout the novel as to who the killer is, but many won't become obvious until the end of novel, when the murderer is finally revealed. This is one of those books that will keep readers guessing right until the end.
Dangerous girls is a brilliantly suspenseful, intricate murder mystery that will be remembered long after it's been finished.
I highly recommend this book.
Rebecca Adams