Reviews

The matchbox diary by Paul Fleischman

cover image

Ill. by Bacham Ibatouline. Candlewick Press, 2013. ISBN 0 7636 4601 1.
(Age: 5+) Warmly recommended. Picture book. Immigration. With a finely detailed illustrative technique, Ibatouline enhances the story of one man's journey to the United States of America. With his family he left impoverished Italy, going to join their father in the USA, who had gone ahead. They wanted to provide opportunities for their children, opportunities they would not have had staying in Italy. His story is retold to his granddaughter, but not through a diary but through the match boxes, each of which has an object inside which elicits a story from the old man. Unable to read or write he collected objects from his old life, his journey, his home in the USA and his eventual success. Inside the old cigar box are dozens of match boxes, each with a story to tell.
We hear of the olive pip, given by his mother to suck to alleviate the hunger pains in the children. A small brooch fell from the upper deck on the ship bound to Ellis Island, and this was kept to remind him of the voyage with its separation of rich and poor. In another is a ticket to a baseball game, a sport they did not understand at first, but went along to better fit themselves for their new life. A tale is told of suffering, of privation, of finding a home and success in their new home. With hints of prejudice, the family succeeds.
The almost monochrome illustrations cover the pages, drawing the eye to the amazing amount of detail, and supporting the text beautifully, colour coming into the pages when the man is with his granddaughter, passing on the family stories to her.
The setting of the USA and its post war migration is a different slant on the theme of new arrivals and one which will find a home in schools where migration, immigration and new arrivals is a topic to be discussed. The pages where prejudice is shown to the family will resonate with many who have left their home to come to a new land, and will too be a discussion point in classrooms. The award winning author and artist duo have produced a book which will be picked up by students in the library and taken to classes where these themes are discussed.
Fran Knight

In the wings by Elsbeth Edgar

cover image

Walker, 2013. ISBN 9781922077325.
(Age 12+) Recommended. Acting. School productions. Ella Jamison has always wanted to act but she really suffers from stage fright. Instead she works backstage for the school play, A Midsummer Night's Dream , and watches the new boy Sam and her friends play out their parts. At home things are difficult as her actor grandfather has moved from London and is staying with them. He is flamboyant and strange but her friend Jeremy really seems to like him as does Sam who forms a bond with him. However all is not well with Sam and he may put the whole production into jeopardy.
Ella is a girl whose caring character is easy to like. Although she has stage fright she is prepared to work behind the scenes and comes up with interesting and original ideas for the sets. She gradually comes to accept her grandfather and is prepared to learn from his acting experience and begins to trust his advice and to believe that eventually she may be able to perform on the stage. Sam's reasons for being aloof are handled very well and the gradual romance will appeal to girls.
The reader is left with the opportunity to think about some big issues in the context of an engrossing story. There is the theme of forgiveness and tolerance as Ella's mother begins to know her father again after he left here as a very young child. The frailty of old age is explored very well as is the idea that people can make very bad mistakes but can also be forgiven for them by both young and old alike.
This is an easy to read story that will delight its readers, especially girls and those who are interested in acting and stage production.
Pat Pledger

The snake who came to stay by Julia Donaldson

cover image

Scholastic Australia, 2013. ISBN: 9781742837093.
Another fantastic read for the younger students and definitely one to share with Miss Small - who is crazy about all animals but especially reptiles! I can easily imagine her doing exactly the same as Polly, the main character in this delightful story about a very entrepreneurial young lady who opens up a Holiday Home for animals - much to her mum's consternation. Guinea pigs, a mynah bird and the goldfish next door are all a bit stressful in their own ways, but when Polly takes on her best friend Jack's snake Doris, Polly's mum really starts to get agitated. As you can easily imagine, Polly realises that looking after other people's animals is not always smooth sailing - and when Doris goes silently missing, she has to do some very fast problem-solving. Fortunately, all has a happy ending - with a safe return of all the animals to their owners - plus a few extras in the case of the guinea pigs!
Another great addition to your shelves for your 'easy reading' fiction titles - and a very funny read aloud.
Sue Warren

Vocal Violet by Susannah McFarlane

cover image

Ill. by Lachlan Creagh. Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 978 1 74283 788 8.
Unique Una by Susannah McFarlane
Ill. by Lachlan Creagh. Little mates. Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 978 1 74283 739 0.
(Age: 3+) Australian animals, Alphabet. Another two books in this series of stories about Australian animals, each book concentrating on one letter of the alphabet, will add to the 19 already published. All of the books are listed in the back cover of each title, adding to the idea of the collection of the whole set. Within a classroom or pre school, the whole set would make a neat introduction to the alphabet, and even at home, parents could use the books in this way. At $4.99 each, the cost makes buying the set within reach. Their presentation makes them sturdy with the harder cover of the small paperback books, and the fold in ends adding to their long life .
Each book, Unique Una and Vocal Violet uses alliteration to emphasise the letter under consideration. So Una the caterpillar has several friends, Usher, Ursula, Ulrik and Ulla who are all unusual, Una wearing Ugg boots. Eventually the four caterpillars grow up to be the most beautiful Ulysses Butterflies. While with Vocal Violet, the most vocal vampire bat in Victoria, attempts are made to curb her voice. With a preponderance of 'v' words, younger children will be excited by the little bat trying to understand why her voice is like it is.
Fran Knight

Diary of a rugby champ by Shamini Flint

cover image

Ill. by Sally Heinrich. Allen and Unwin, 2013. ISBN 978 1 74237 359 6.
Diary of a taekwondo master by Shamini Flint
Ill. by Sally Heinrich. Allen and Unwin, 2013. ISBN 978 1 74237 360 2.
(Age: 7-10) Recommended. Sport. Humour. 9 year Marcus Atkinson writes his diaries about his sporting prowess, but it is his father who thinks he is good at sport. Marcus knows he is not. He has already tried and failed at soccer and cricket, proving to one and all that sport is not his thing. In the previous two very funny books, he made this abundantly clear, but his Dad still wants him to give it a go, with cliches coming from his mouth, like, 'seize the moment' or 'you are what you believe son'. Marcus records each sporting disaster in his diary with each page covered with simple line illustrations. Many of the misunderstandings are a play on words, such as 'duck' in cricket having Marcus imagining the bird. And in Diary of a taekwondo master, of course, having to wear pyjamas leads to all sorts of jokes, while Diary of a rugby champ delivers on the idea of the opponent actually aiming to hurt you. Surprisingly in all books, Marcus does have some wow moments and manages to succeed in the end. This is light hearted fun and an easy read for 7 to 10 year olds. Children who have enjoyed The Diary of a Wimpy Kid and books by Geoffrey McSkimming will pick up to this series readily. The diary format is always popular and the four books published will no doubt grow into a larger set. The appealing cover will also help this series be easily recognised by young readers.
Fran Knight

The Apothecary by Maile Meloy

cover image

Text, 2012
Recommended. For this reader The Apothecary is an old fashioned yarn and quite 'old school' which is in no way intended to undermine its charm and the sheer pleasure of the story. The story is set in 1952 and the action recalled by Janie who has had the memories of this year in her life erased for many years.
Prompted by the return of her diary from this year she recollects her time in London where she moves to with her parents when she is fourteen from Los Angeles. There she meets Benjamin at her new school, he is the son of the Apothecary and she is a little keen on him. The action starts quickly when the Apothecary disappears and Janie and Benjamin are left with the precious Pharmacopoeia which a host of unsavory characters are seeking.
Magic, spells and spies are involved and a cast of eccentrics, as Benjamin and Janie seek the truth and begin their journey which takes them to the wild seas off the Arctic Circle where the Russians are about to ignite a nuclear bomb. Using the powers from the Pharmacopoeia and showing great bravery Benjamin and Janie fight the spies above the wild seas, the action being worthy of any Hollywood blockbuster.
There are many bases covered in this 'fish out of water' story which features a blossoming romance between Janie and Ben, some great eccentric characters and is a wonderful adventure with a twist of fantasy. The reader needs to take care reading the 'note to the reader' and like me go back and read it again when they have finished this very enjoyable story.
While it may need some promotion I recommend this title for those who enjoy a good adventure story with a twist of young romance.
Michael Jongen
Editor's note: The Apothecary was a ALA Best Fiction for Young Adults 2012, CILIP Carnegie longlist 2013, E.B. White Read-Aloud Award - Middle Reader

The Debt. Instalment one: Catch the Zolt by Phillip Gwynne

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2013.
At last - an exciting, adventure series for teenage boys, set in Australia. Phillip Gwynne would have to be considered as one of Australia's pre-eminent authors for young adults. He experienced enormous success with Deadly Unna in 1998, which was made into a landmark movie Australian Rules. He has subsequently written a number of books which have been similarly well received, with 'a confetti of prizes'falling his way.
In this new series of 6 titles, Dom Silvangni, an elite athlete with dreams of success in running marathons, discovers a sinister family secret that dogs the male members of his family. It is, in fact, a debt to a secret Calabrian society 'like the Mafia, but not as nice,' and this debt requires six payments. As Dom learns his family history on attaining the age of 15, he discovers the reason for his grandfather's prosthetic leg - failure to complete his 'debt repayments'. It is now up to Dom to maintain his family's honour - and both his legs.
This series is a roller coaster of impossible tasks and improbable situations with many twists and turns. With some skill, more luck and the help of a few friends, Dom builds friendships and completes his task, but never in the manner anticipated. Cleverly written, with heavy doses of irony to keep readers amused, Phillip Gwynne creates a very authentic voice for his main character in a recognisably modern setting. Dom's sister is a teenage-hacker and his target uses Facebook to send coded messages. Evil characters are satisfyingly mysterious and evil and the young characters are nicely rounded and complex. This book is fresh, entertaining and very current. It is sure to be a hit particularly with young, particularly male, readers who are already reporting online that they are hooked early on and find it difficult to put down.
Diana Warwick

10 hooting owls by Ed Allen

cover image

Ill. by Simon Williams. Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9781 74283 698 0.
10 silly wombats by Ed Allen,
Il. by Simon Williams. Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9781 74283 638 6.
(Age: 4+) Picture book. Verse. Numbers. Humour. You feel like singing along with both these books, modelled on 10 green bottles, as the owls and wombats are counted from ten to one, with lots  of silly things happening along the way to keep the readers amused and engaged.
10 hooting owls are reduced as one eats a smoothie while watching a movie, another gets chicken pox while knitting winter socks, one goes down the wrong trail while delivering the mail, and so on until only one is left. The humour is infectious and I am sure the person reading the book to a younger audience will be able to get them to sing along as well. The strongly coloured illustrations too will intrigue the readers as they ponder just where the owls might be in some of the pages.
10 silly wombats are reduced in the same way with each wombat doing something silly. One makes a fuss getting on the bus, another has too much fun eating his bun, while another forgets to peek while playing hide and seek, counting down until only one wombat is left.
For teachers and parents introducing the idea of counting one to ten and back again then these little books will be useful. And the emphasis on Australian themes and animals is good to see.
Fran Knight

The moon and more by Sarah Dessen

cover image

Penguin, 2013.
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Luke and Emaline have been together all through high school and Emaline knows that not only is Luke gorgeous, he is kind as well. But when Theo arrives in town with a documentary film maker, she starts to wonder if Luke is the perfect boyfriend. Theo is different and sophisticated and understands just how smart Emaline is. Her absentee father too believes that Emaline should have a larger life than Colby, a seaside town, offers. However she is deeply attached to her mother, stepfather and sisters and somehow must find a balance between the familiar and the inevitable change that going away to college will bring.
Dessen consistently writes stories that are appealing and interesting to read but which explore issues that are very important to her teen protagonists and to her teen readers. In The moon and more Emaline is trying to work out who is the perfect boyfriend - someone that she has known forever, or someone who has seen and done much more than she has. She also has to come to terms with the behaviour of her absentee father, who promised to finance her to a prestigious university but changed his mind without telling her why. Emaline is clever and astute but she has a lot of issues to work through as she uses her organisational skills in the family business.
A keen exploration of the family ties that keep people together, whether it is overbearing siblings or a loving mother and the messy nastiness of divorce and its effects on children provide the background to Emaline's coming of age against a background of small town politics and employment.
Dessen's characters are wholly believable, each with strengths and weaknesses. Her descriptions of Emaline's father and his awful behaviour paint a picture of a man who can only communicate through emails. Her little half brother Benji comes alive on the page, and her best friends, Morris and Daisy are wonderful characters. Theo has moments of real empathy and others of being crass and unfeeling. However it is Emaline's voice that come through really strongly and kept me engrossed in this story set in one summer.
Pat Pledger

Clementine Rose and the perfect present by Jacqueline Harvey

cover image

Random House, 2013. ISBN 9781742755458
Recommended. Children's fiction. Fresh and original. Clementine Rose is a 7 year old girl and is extremely curious about everything. So when an immense tent appears in her backyard she just has to know why it is there. When she finds out that there is going to be a wedding, Clemmie is thrilled because a wedding is just the thing her mother needs to help pay for a much needed roof for their house. She wants to help the workers but she is not allowed, so she goes and watches them, she even sings to them! But amidst the excitement, her Uncle Digby falls ill and an invitation goes astray. To everyone's horror (especially Clemmie's), Aunt Violet is left in charge. All the presents gave Clemmie an idea, but will she find the perfect present in time?
Clementine Rose and the Perfect Present is a finely written story. Jacqueline Harvey's fable illustrates Clementine and her pet pig Lavender as two lively friends always on the lookout for mysteries. Clemmie's Aunt Violet does not approve of such excitement, but when Uncle Digby falls ill and an invitation goes astray Aunt Violet simply gives in and lets Clemmie figure out the puzzling mystery. Over all I think that Clementine Rose and the Perfect Present is a fantastic story and every school in South Australia should have a copy of this book in their library.
Amelie Meinel (student)

Destroying the joint edited by Jane Caro

cover image

UQP, 2013. ISBN: 978 0 7022 4990 7. Paperback, 295 pps. RRP: $29.95
Highly recommended. Jane Caro has gathered a thought-provoking assembly of Australian women's responses to Alan Jones's comment on August 31, 2012 that 'women are destroying the joint'. The collection consists of essays, analysis, social comment, memoir and fiction combined with a healthy dose of humour.
Carmen Lawrence takes issue with destruction of the environment, arguing that it is fair to file responsibility with the 'privileged, powerful, Western white males' who across history have made crucial economic and societal management decisions.
Entertaining and engaging examples includes Jenna Price highlighting that Destroy the Joint put feminism on the front page, Catherine Fox protesting against the paucity of women in executive roles and Wendy Harmer's short and scathing description of how women are excluded from the radio industry joint. Other contributors present the perspectives of a teenage girl, parenting in a patriarchal society, and a nine year old trying to understand the abortion debate.
Covering double standards, oppression, a letter to a feminist (from a man who knows better) and the misogyny debate with the sombre words of Penny Wong, 'my realisation yet again that we still have so much more to do', this book provides much socio-political commentary for Women's Studies students to discuss and analyse. Highly recommended.
Cate Telfer

Lick by Matthew Van Fleet

cover image

Simon & Schuster, 2013. IS 9781471116254.
(Age 2-5) Recommended. Board book. Read aloud. Matthew Van Fleet has created a fun interactive book that is perfect for young children. All sorts of tongues and what they can do are explored in this very sturdy board book that is sure to please toddlers and amuse the adult who is reading to them.
Starting with the front cover, the book grabs the interest of the child with its easy-to-grip pull tab that has a bear with a pink tongue enthusiastically licking honey. From then on there are tactile experiences like a scratchy tiger tongue and a sticky frog tongue, as well as more pull tabs, culminating in a final one where a baby tiger's tongue makes a razz with an accompanying sound.
The language is great to read aloud, with lots of alliteration and humour interspersed throughout:
'Daddy tongue tickles,
Teasing tongue Nyah!'.
Cartoon like characters, coloured in warm tones, have a range of funny expressions that will delight the child who likes to examine details as well as manipulate tabs. Not only will young children experience the senses of taste and feel when reading this book they will also learn about the very different tongues that animals have.
Pat Pledger

The fearsome, frightening, ferocious box by Frances Watts and David Legge

cover image

ABC Books, 2013. ISBN 9780733328916.
(Age: 4+) Warmly recommended. Picture book. Humour. Poetry. A box falls fromm a truck and is left on the roadside, where a variety of animals comes and inspects the box, saying that they would look inside. But as each animal comes by, bragging that they will not be frightened, they are. First a monkey looks inside and hears the thing inside moan and tell a little tale of its life. The following double page shows the area in which it lives, and the reader is invited to search for the six things hidden on the two pages. Then a crocodile happens along and he hears the thing inside groan with a similar poem over the page inviting the reader to find the six things hidden this time in an arctic landscape. And on it goes, each animal being scared off by the thing inside and the reader invited to find six things in a different environment, until finally the lid of the box is lifted.
This fun involving story, with things for the reader to do on each page, will entertain those who pick up the book. Legge has successfully shown each animal in distress as it peers inside and the environments shown with their hidden animals will entice younger readers to be involved.
Fran Knight

Big Nate flips out by Lincoln Peirce

cover image

Harper Collins, 2013. ISBN 9780007478279.
(Ages: 10+) Highly recommended. Big Nate flips out is a funny, comic-style novel featuring two friends, Nate and Francis. It includes text and comics to tell the story and is funny and engaging. Reminiscent of the popular Diary of a Wimpy Kid, Nate tells his story with a lot of humour and the author uses descriptive language to help engage the reader. I would highly recommend it for boys aged 10+.
Nate and Francis take over the Yearbook Committee and as usual, Nate, the messy one, gets his best mate, Francis, the organised one, in trouble. Nate has lost the camera? Nate needs to fix it and to fix it he needs to change. How? With hypnotism of course! Nate becomes a tidy freak overnight while another friend investigates the missing camera. But, is being neat all the time going to help him get his friendship with Francis back on track? Who knew being so neat could be so boring!
Kylie Kempster

Too many elephants in this house by Ursula Dubosarsky

cover image

Ill. by Andrew Joyner. Penguin, 2012. ISBN 9780670075461
(Age: 4+) Warmly recommended. Picture book. Humour. Problem solving. Eric has simply too many elephants in his house. There are some in the kitchen, some in the hallway, the bathroom and his bedroom. He plays hide and seek with them, the one in the bathroom helps him brush his teeth at night, and the one in the kitchen is an excellent toast maker. One night Mum tells him that there are too many elephants in this house and that they must go. So Eric has the problem of moving his friends out of the house, and he tries a few different methods to do just that.
The joyous illustrations will make readers smile as they recognise the friendship between Eric and his playmates. The elephants peering out of the windows on the cover are enough to entice any reader to open the book and look inside, and then the parade of elephants will keep their interest as Eric's problem is finally solved.
The idea of imaginary friends will take hold of the readers as they recognise the ideas behind the story and puzzle with Eric on just how to consolidate the elephants in the house. His neat solution will appeal to the readers. A great book to read aloud, I would imagine that some teachers and parents will be able to use the idea to begin discussions with their charges about imaginary friends.
Fran Knight