Reviews

After Eden by Helen Douglas

cover image

Bloomsbury Publishing, 2013. ISBN: 9781408828694.
(Age: Teens) Highly recommended. Science fiction. Ryan Westland, mysterious foreign student, begins Perran School half way through term in year eleven, a novelty among the students he quickly becomes the gossip of the year eleven girls. Claiming to be from America Ryan is the perfect student and manages to be rebellious responsibly. Seemingly unaware of his growing fun club Ryan flirts unashamedly with Eden, a relatively plain vegetarian who lives just down the road from his house in Penpol Cove. He befriends first her and then her friends, accompanying her to a beach party for Amy's birthday; he is particularly interested in Connor, Eden's best friend, as they each share a passion for astronomy.
As Ryan falls for Eden he becomes less and less private, even allowing her into his home after she pays an unexpected visit. By accident Eden takes one of Ryan's books, a book that by all rights should not exist yet, it is the biography of her best friend, Connor Penrose's life after discovering the planet Eden. Eden demands an explanation and Ryan gives her one, putting them both at risk. Together they must prevent the discovery of Eden (the only life supporting planet other than earth) in order to save the human race from its future extinction.
After Eden is highly recommended for teenage girls with a passion for drama and science fiction. Aimed at a young adult audience the novel is engaging and easy to read as it well written using colourful descriptions that allow the reader to visualise the story.
Kayla Gaskell (age eighteen)

How they Met and Other Stories by David Levithan

cover image

Text Publishing, 2014. ISBN 9781922147769.
The last review I wrote was for another book written by David Levithan, the spectacularly moving Two Boys Kissing, and now I review How They Met and Other Stories.
Upon researching this author, it seems there is a theme of love that runs through his work, and in my experience reading his work, his meditation on romance is always fresh and intriguing. I am particularly glad to see that David Levithan is inclusive of same-sex relationships in his writing, which are often overlooked in popular fiction. This work is no exception of this socially aware approach.
This anthology sets out to chronicle love of all kinds, and the many other emotions this one can conjure. In doing so, as always, Levithan is beautifully honest and unpretentious, and it the truthful nature of this work that makes it so compelling - Mills and Boon this certainly is not! Here, love is unvarnished, unglamourised, and presented to us in the messy and wholly recognizable game that we play in our own realities. We can relate to the tales of trial and triumph, where we understand and relate to each character. Rarely has there been such a variety of characters that I have so profoundly connected with in a book.
This work is, as the title suggests, a collection of short romantic fiction, but unlike many other writers in this genre, Levithan strives to and seemingly prides himself on his socially inclusive approach. And he should be praised for this.
It is refreshing to see written work for young people that is accessible and avoids the tired and expected trite, cliched approach. I hope to see more work coming from David Levithan, as in my eyes he is the most in-touch, and emotionally touching, young adult fiction author of the moment.
Henry Vaughan (Student)

The Dark by Lemony Snicket

cover image

Ill. by Jon Klassen. Orchard Books, 2013. ISBN 9781408330029.
Picture book. Laszlo is afraid of the dark. But he lives in a big house with a creaky roof, smooth, cold windows and several flights of stairs so there are many places that dark can hide. But mostly, dark lives in the basement waiting in a distant corner during the day and then coming out at night to spread itself against the windows and doors of Laszlo's house. But Laszlo thought that if he visited the dark in its room, it wouldn't come and visit him in his room so each morning he would peek at it in the basement and say hello. Until one night, it did . . .
The power of this story lies in Snicket's ability to personify the dark as a real entity as it leads Laszlo on a journey through the house and down, deep into the basement. It talks to Laszlo as though it is a real character, and Laszlo's calm response, both expression and action, helps convey the message that there is nothing to fear. Then just as the climax is almost reached, Snicket provides an explanation of the need for creaky roofs and blank windows, almost as though he is trying to defuse the suspense to make it manageable for the young reader.
Jon Klassen's illustrations help build up the suspense - a limited palette, the use of shadow, shade and light, bare walls, uncovered windows and empty rooms all add to the atmosphere and feed a little boy's imagination - and, in the words of one reviewer, this is an 'inspired pairing'. This is a perfect example of a picture book where text and illustrations work so well that each would be diminshed without the other.
The Dark appeared regularly on the best-of lists for 2013, particularly those in the US, and it is a gentler Snicket at work than the one we are accustomed to. Both the US and UK publishers have book trailers and you can listen to an audio clip by Neil Gaiman.
This would be a great introduction to introducing the science concepts of light and day, day and night, the rotation of the earth and so forth so that young children begin to understand more and fear less - another way to support the curriculum beyond the traditional English perspective.
Barbara Braxton

A very singular guild by Catherine Jinks

cover image

City of orphans, bk 3. Allen and Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743313091.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Ned Roach is now Alfred's chief apprentice, luring out child eating bogles with his use of verse, so that Alfred can kill them. Before working with Alfred he was a mudlark, scavenging for a living in the mud along the Thames. Now he is employed alongside of Alfred who has been paid by the London Sewers Office to rid London of an infestation of bogles. As well as facing the evil bogles, Ned and his friends, Jem and Birdie, face deadly danger from an enemy from their past.
In this the final story in the City of Orphans trilogy, following A very unusual pursuit and A very peculiar plague, Jinks relates the tale of Ned, who is a very likeable hero. He is intensely interested in machines and is fascinated by the steam engines and new machinery that he encounters in his travels with the employees of the London Sewers Offices and would love to work with them. However, he is very loyal to Alfred who has taken him away from the insecurity of scrabbling for a living in the mudflats, and believes that he must help him to entice the bogles out even though he is really afraid of them. His loyalty and steadfastness even when terrified as well as his powerful curiosity about machines make the story very enjoyable.
The setting of Dickens' London and the beginning of the machine age are all cleverly mixed with the superstitions of a people who believe in strange creatures who capture children. Jinks subtly draws the reader into the life of poor orphans in the 19th century and will leave them empathizing with the drawbacks of not being able to read and having to earn a living at a very early age. The descriptions of London's underground tunnels and sewer systems, the wickedness of some of the slum dwellers, the contrast with the wealthy and the frivolity of the actors in the theatres of Drury Lane bring a wonderful feel to the story.
Beautifully written, Jinks manages to tie up the fates of her characters in a very satisfying and atmospheric conclusion to an outstanding series which should grace every library shelf and would be a great read aloud in the classroom as well.
Pat Pledger

Two trickster tales from Russia, retold by Sophie Masson

cover image

Ill. by David Allan. Christmas Press, 2014. ISBN 9780992283803. Audio book ISBN 9780992283810.
(Age: All) Highly recommended. Picture book, Folk tales. The illustrations in this beautiful book impelled me to open the book to read, the front cover indicating the style Allan has used to compliment Masson's words. He uses a combination of black and white, and sometimes coloured images. For emphasis some images coves a double page, but more often, images are smaller and framed, with the frame sitting in front of another image, giving a three dimensional effect. Panels are used at the top and bottom of the page, and sometimes down the side, which along with the black outlined pictures, gives a wood block printing effect harking back to books of old. The illustrations draw the eye in to look at the detail encased within the borders, and readers will love the effect given.
The two stories retold by Sophie Masson, one of a girl, Masha, outsmarting a bear and the other about a preening rooster. In the first Mash goes out picking berries but soon becomes lost, walking into a house where porridge sits on the stove. She eat some with her berries only to find the owner, the Bear comes in and keeps her there to do his cooking. Eventually she convinces him to take a basket of pies to her parents and hides inside the basket, she has become so thin.
In the second tale a fabulous rooster is tricked repeatedly by the fox. He is always rescued by his friends, the thrush and the cat, until one day he is almost eaten. The animals trick the fox and she runs away. Two well told stories made even more interesting with the stunning illustrations should make a useful addition to the school library. Christmas Press is a new publisher set up by Sophie Masson, David Allan and Fiona McDonald in Armidale NSW, more information can be found at christmaspresspicturebooks.com
My review copy came with a CD for listening to the two stories.
Fran Knight

The Great Fire of London Unclassified by Nick Hunter

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408193037.
(Age: 9+) Recommended. Picture book, Fire, History. Published under the auspices of the National Archives and filled with an array of photographic evidence, pictures, maps, drawings, copies of written documents and many other primary sources, this book will fit the History curriculum when children study the Modern World within the curriculum for years seven to nine.
Both the Plague of 1665 and Great Fire in 1666 fire children's imagination at the sweep of such things four centuries ago. They will gasp at the lack of communication, lack of equipment to fight each disaster, lack of knowledge and the unstoppable nature of the fire, ponder at a conflagration just waiting to happen.
With London built cheek by jowl, the small but tall wooden houses needed only a spark, and when a bakery in Pudding Lane was not quite dowsed for the night, the fire began. The Mayor of London, refused to pull down the houses which would have halted the fire for fear of being blamed for the loss of the buildings, and so the fire spread taking in the churches, waterfront, St Paul's and much more, until over the three days, over three quarters of the city was lost. With no fire insurance, people simply had to start again.
I loved reading every page, looking at every photograph and map, along with the primary source material, comparing this fire with the ones that have destroyed parts of Australia recently.
Kids in upper primary and lower secondary will enjoy reading of this time in Britain's history along with the last part of the book dedicated to its rise from the ashes to become what it is today.
A sound glossary matched with a compact index and further resources to peruse, make this a must for libraries.
Fran Knight

Fools' gold by Philippa Gregory

cover image

Order of Darkness, bk 3. Simon and Schuster, 2014. ISBN 9780857077394.
(Age 14+) Recommended. Historical. Counterfeiting. Philosopher's stone. Luca's master directs him to go to Venice to investigate a gold coin counterfeiting scheme. Together with his companions Isolde, Ishraq, Frieze and Brother Peter, they arrive in Venice at Carnival time. The city is aglow with masked revellers and speculators are frantically buying up gold coins. Isolde's brother has set men on her trail and Venice has its own laws that make it a dangerous place to be. When the group meet the Alchemist and discover that he plans to create the Philosopher's Stone and with the flood of gold coins appearing in Venice, it looks as if there is even more danger than they had imagined.
In this, the third in the Order of Darkness series, following Changeling and Stormbringers, once again provides an impeccable and fascinating glimpse into history. Her descriptions of Venice, its canals, palaces and churches and the celebrations of the Carnival provide a beguiling background to the mystery surrounding the appearance of gold coins into the financial world of the traders. The Alchemist and his assistant are strange figures and their laboratory and what is in it make for an gripping insight into the Middle Ages belief that ordinary objects could be turned into gold and that the Philosopher's Stone could give immortality.
The romantic interest between Isolde and Luca is ramped up in this book although both seem to realise that their circumstances will make their love for each other difficult to sustain in the world they live in. Luca is the son of a farmer who has been taken into slavery on the galleys, and is also bound to the Church, while Isolde is a lady of quality.
With a website to support the series and an author note at the end of the novel about Medieval Venice, the role of Jewish moneylenders and alchemy, readers will have much historical information to feast on.
Pat Pledger

Australian and world records 2014 by Jennifer Corr Morse

cover image

Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9781743622094.
(Age: 8+) Australian and world records is a companion volume to Scholastic's annual Book of World Records. The global publisher's decision to produce a title with an Australian focus enables children to learn about records that may not be recognised internationally but will open their eyes to aspects of life in their own country.
The first quarter of the book is devoted to Australian records. Both this section and the international section that follows, have a significant emphasis on sporting achievements. The remaining topics are money, pop culture and nature. While the mix may not satisfy readers accustomed to the broader range of similar titles, many children will enjoy this pared-down version because of its user-friendly format. With few exceptions, there is only one entry to a page. Large photographs, informative text and graphs of top record holders in each category, may encourage readers to investigate the information instead of skipping from picture to picture. Alliteration and word play in the headings helps to make this title a rewarding reading experience. Some of the records, such as those for the largest animals, have remained unchanged for understandable reasons, but others have been updated to the year of publication. The font is relatively small but clear and while there is no index, the brief table of contents is serviceable.
Jennifer Corr Morse and her Australian co-authors have created more than a collection of superlatives with pictures. Australian and World Records 2014 is an interesting and occasionally thought-provoking book, that is tailor-made for young readers who are keen to extend their general knowledge and curious about the world in which they live.
Elizabeth Bor

King Pig by Nick Bland

cover image

Scholastic Press, 2013. ISBN 9781742834955.
King Pig thinks he is just that - an autocratic leader who can get the sheep to do anything they want. But while he could make them do such things as strap boards on their backs so he has a ramp into his sheep-free palace or pull down the branch of the apple tree so he could pick the fruit, and scrub his castle he just couldn't make them like him. No matter how loudly he shouted, they didn't listen properly; no matter how hard he tried to get their attention, the more they ignored him. Viewing himself in the mirror one day, he decided that a fancier set of clothes might be the answer. So he invited them into his castle and there they set to work.
To discover whether this works and if there is any way this arrogant pig can make friends, you need to read this brilliant book by one of Australia's most popular authors. And you need to read the pictures as well as the words because the two not only work perfectly in harmony to tell the surface story, but they also tell a story of their own about power and bullying, making friends, arrogance and humility, do clothes maketh the man? - all great discussion starters that will help children reflect on the sorts of qualities that are shared and valued by friends.
Nick Bland has that unique gift of being able to tell a tale within a tale without being overtly didactic. The story can stand alone as entertainment without delving deeper and his appealing illustrations inject humour that tickle the fancy of even the youngest audience. With a growing body of work to his name, Nick is becoming a well-known name amongst our younger readers and new stories are greeted with delight and appeal across the board because of the levels at which each can be read.
Barbara Braxton

The spotty dotty lady by Josie Boyle

cover image

Ill. by Fern Martins. Magabala Books, 2014. ISBN 9781922142108.
(Age: 5+) Recommended. Loneliness, Aboriginal themes. A lady living alone has no friends beside her flowers and plants in the garden. One day she notices a different plant growing amongst those she knows and watches it as it grows. The spotty bud grows quickly, until one day it flowers with big, wonderful, spotty, dotty flowers. So taken with these that she decides to paint her kitchenware with spots, and she keeps on going until her whole kitchen is a maze of coloured dots and spots. And she does not stop there. She soon covers her whole house with spots and dots, causing a small sensation in the street.
The postie tells the neighbours and they tell their friends, so soon everyone in the street is outside her house. They soon begin to bring things for her to paint, and after that of course, they stay for a cup of tea. Soon the Spotty, Dotty Lady has many friends and when they hold a party at her place it becomes the happiest street in town.
A lovely tale of friendship developing out of the environment, reinforces the relationship between the natural world and people, an enduring theme amongst Aboriginal stories. But this modern tale has significance for us all.
Fran Knight

The day the crayons quit by Drew Daywalt

cover image

Ill. by Oliver Jeffers. HarperCollins Children's Books, 2013. ISBN 9780007513758.
One day, in class, Duncan went to take out his crayons and found a stack of letters with his name on them. Each letter was from a different-coloured crayon explaining why they didn't want to work anymore. Red feels overworked, constantly colouring in fire engines, apples and strawberries, even working in the holidays colouring Santas and Valentine hearts. Black is bored with just being used for outlines and craves things such as black beach balls while poor peach has had all the paper peeled off and is too embarrassed to leave the box! So Duncan decides to do something about it . . .and ends up making all the crayons happy!
The Day the Crayons Quit has consistently appeared on all the best-reads and must-haves lists that appeared at the end of 2013 and with good reason. It is delightfully original and has many layers to it, with each audience being able to take something from it at their level, whether it be 'What other things could Duncan colour purple?' to investigating whether it's OK to have an orange whale. I'm very much reminded of Flowers are Red by Harry Chapin. There are lessons to be learned about stereotyping - something we strive to make students aware of but modern literature doesn't readily allow it because authors strive to avoid it! You could also use it to explore emotions and feelings and how we can tactfully express that things are making us unhappy. So just as the crayons express why they are unhappy, perhaps this could be a model for each child to express why they are happy. Because this book has received such acclaim, there are many suggestions for how it might be used online accessible by a search.
Each letter is written 'by' a crayon using a font that might make this story difficult for the emerging reader to read alone, but it is a perfect read-aloud for many ages! Jeffers' illustrations have an authenticity about them - they look like they have been drawn and coloured by young children and the credits suggest that there has been significant input, either physical or intellectual, from them. And this provides another level to the book - my experience is that children start to believe that their drawings are not worthy because they don't have the realism they see around them or the professionalism of book illustrators, so seeing pictures that look just like theirs in such a popular book validates their efforts and hopefully encourages them to keep drawing.
I borrowed this book from my public library because I wanted to see what the fuss was about, but it is now on my to-buy list so I can share it with Miss Nearly 3 and Miss 7 because it will appeal to both. That's the greatest accolade I can offer.
Barbara Braxton

Australia's Greatest People & their Achievements by Linsay Knight

cover image

Random House Australia Children's, 2013. ISBN 9780857980205.
Recommended for Middle/Upper Primary. Here is one of those very useful books which can earn a place on the library shelves or for an award prize with equal ease.
Very attractively packaged and with loads of information on people from both historical and contemporary times, it's a perfect book for dipping into or for students to find the first 'kick off' for a biographical research project.
As well as both brief and fuller informational text, quotes, break out boxes and quick fact pages are interspersed throughout. Broken up into sections from Pioneering Australians to the Arts to Science to Social Justice and more, this covers a wide range of both well known Australian achievers as well as those not so well known - something I found particularly interesting.
Along with the companion book Australia's Greatest Inventions & Innovations, this comprehensive text would be a very useful addition to primary school libraries in particular.
Sue Warren

Ghetto Cowboy by G. Neri

cover image

Ill. by Jesse Joshua Watson. Candlewick Press, 2013. ISBN 9780763664534.
(Age: 10+) Recommended. When Cole's mother decides that she can no longer deal with him, she leaves him in the mean streets of Philadelphia with the father that he has never met. To his horror, there is a horse in the house, and a stable full of horses nearby. He never dreamt that there were black cowboys. Soon he is mucking out the stables rather than skipping school and getting into trouble. When the City decides that the stables should be shut down, Cole knows that it is time to fight back and save his father's way of life.
This clever and moving story comes from the 2011 Coretta Scott King Author Award Honor winner, whose ability to write a compassionate look at a young boy and his father getting to know each other for the first time is inspirational. It has been inspired by the real life urban black horsemen of North Philadelphia and the Brooklyn-Queens area, and a picture from Life magazine and information at the back of the book give added information.
Although the background is intriguing, it is the portrayal of father and son getting together, that is at the heart of the story. Cole is on the verge of getting into bad company and truanting from school when his mother decides she can't cope with him anymore. Cole's father has kept the stables going believing that looking after horses will keep the local kids away from danger but has no idea about how to act like a father. Together they get to know each other and their fight against the closure of the stables brings them together.
The setting and the real life background of the ghetto cowboys makes this an exceptionally interesting book to read and I really enjoyed Cole's journey as he began to know his father. It would make a great read aloud and provides a fascinating alternative for those who enjoy books about horses.
Pat Pledger

Sun and Moon, Ice and Snow by Jessica Day George

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 9781619631847.
(Age 10+) Recommended. Based on the legend East of the sun, west of the moon, the Lass, who doesn't have a name, agrees to go away with a great white bear to his castle when he promises her family treasure to make them rich. But of course the bear is not what he appears to be and his castle is made of ice. She is determined to find out what is happening when servants begin to disappear and sets out on a gruelling journey to rescue the bear when he disappears.
Jessica Day George has chosen to expand the fairy story, keeping faithfully to its origins, but giving it a very likeable heroine who grabs the reader's attention right from the beginning. Any reader could easily identify with the young girl whose mother has refused to name her and whose sad older brother, returned from mysterious adventures at sea, seems to be her only friend. When she frees a white reindeer trapped in the woods, it rewards her with a name and the ability to hear what animals are saying. The Lass cares deeply for her family and cannot refuse the large white bear's request to stay with him for a year in his castle. She is an intrepid girl whose naive curiosity leads to dire consequences, but also gives her the inspiration to find a solution to the spell that has been cast on the bear.
The bitter cold and the isolation of their home in woods, often deep in snow, is beautifully described. The grim poverty of her family and the desperate straits that they find themselves in provide a fitting background to the story. The addition of the heart broken brother Hans Peter and his link to the ice castle is a fascinating one and gives an extra dimension to the story.
This is a well written, timeless tale that is sure to please readers who enjoy retellings of fairy tales.
Pat Pledger

Mabel and me: best of friends by Mark Sperring and Sarah Warburton

cover image

HarperCollins, 2013. ISBN 9780007468362.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Picture book, Friendship. When her friend, the mouse tells Mabel that she is her best of friends, Mabel asks the simple question Why? Stuck for an answer, the pair is interrupted by a French photographer asking to take their photographs. He asks Mabel if he can take her photo as well as the little creature with her. Mouse thinks he is talking to her and calling Mabel a little creature and so is cross on her behalf, saying that they will go to the photo booth instead. There their feet are seen by a passing ballerina who tells Mabel that her feet are just right for learning to dance, but not the hairy feet of her companion. Mouse again takes umbrage and thinks the ballerina is referring to Mabel's feet and storms off. The confusion is resolved when Mabel explains what has really been meant by the two, but the mouse is stunned that now she knows why she likes Mabel. Its because of the crazy things she says.
Surrounded by whimsical illustrations, the story moves along with a variety of fonts and font sizes, a large pallet of colour and fascinating buildings and interiors. Every page is stacked with humour, be it in the illustrations, the background or the words. A lovely treat for discussions on friendship and working together, this book will be well used in the classroom and home, the front cover inviting a reader to pick it up. For an adult presenting the notion of irony with children, this is a most suitable example.
Fran Knight