Reviews

The geography of you and me by Jennifer E. Smith

cover image

Headline, 2014. ISBN 9781472206299.
Well recommended for upper secondary students. A cleverly contrived plot where the main characters are able to express their inner thoughts, which closely ally a reader's own view of the situation at the time. Lucy lives on the 24th floor of an apartment in New York and when the power goes out on an incredibly hot day she meets Owen, who lives in the basement, not that Lucy is aware of that. They get stuck in a lift and talk. This leaves each of them with a yearning to see more of each other. Owen's mother has died and he and his father are trying to sort out their lives and so after an unsuccessful stint at mending the pipes in the hotel they set off to 'drive out west, find some place better suited for them, a place with more sky and fewer people. Maybe, in that way, Owen would be able to say goodbye too' p78. They do. Lucy's rather casual parents finally insist she joins them in Paris and onto Scotland. And so starts an exchange of irregular postcards to each other. The genuine feelings each expresses about their relationship is heart-warming, amusing and tender as first love blossoms. It's an engaging easy to read story of young people finding their voice and creating a world where they can share their thoughts and hopes. The font is clear and well-spaced. It focuses on young people's fragile relationships while learning about each other.
Sue Nosworthy

Running on a Patchwork of Earth by Jonny Zucker

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781472905345.
(Age: 8-11) It is not often that a sport such as middle distance running features in novels for 8-11 year olds. We may have to thank the Olympics for sparking the idea and giving us an insight to this sport and the reality that change brings new opportunities if you are willing to take the chance.
AK attends a boy's boarding school in Iten Kenya where the best runners are trained and mentored by the best running coach Brother Colm. As an aspiring 800 m Olympic runner AK relishes the opportunities he has to train and learn. In fact he feels running is his destiny and devotes all his energy and time to it despite his parents and teachers urging him to focus as fully on his school work.
AK's immediate focus is on trials for the school Athletics Team and just as he makes the cut his father arrives and announces that the family are moving immediately to London for at least a year due to his work as a scientist. Naturally devastated AK finds accepting his new life difficult despite making friends with two girls in his form. His dreams of becoming a great runner are shattered however as athletics training is not available at the school and the local clubs are not open to new members.
Eventually AK begins running alone at the local park and attracts the attention of Frank, the unkempt, depressed and out of work father of the school bully. Frank was destined to have a future as a runner when he broke his leg and his career prospects were over. Frank offers to train AK who accepts, despite some misgivings, and they both gain from the experience.
This is a story about acceptance and adapting to change. Taking responsibility for his own training opens a new opportunity for AK whilst Frank makes changes to his own life and relationships moving on at last from his past disappointments.
Sue Keane

Adorable Alice by Cassandra Webb

cover image

New Frontier Publishing, 2014. ISBN 9781921928017.
Adorable Alice is a beautiful picture book highly recommended for children aged 3+. Whether reading it with an adult or trying on their own, children will wonder at Alice, a young girl who explores her house by using her different senses. A great book to support learning the days of the week, who is in a family and our different sense and how we use them.
The pictures are detailed and colourful and I like how the author doesn't explain Alice's reasons for acting like she is. This means there are a lot of chances for discussion and interpretation.
Kylie Kempster

Howler by Michael Rosen and Neal Layton

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408846179.
(Age: Pre-school - Year 2) Have you ever considered what it must be like to follow a pregnancy through the eyes of the family pet? In this very funny take on a common situation, Dog introduces us to his pet girl, Rover and her family and provides a running commentary of the changes he notices in Rover's mum as her tummy gets bigger and bigger. It takes him a while to realise it's not just because she's swallowed a big dinner and he doesn't understand why he can't sleep in the big new basket Rover's dad brings home or gets into strife for trying to catch the animals hanging from the mobile on the ceiling. Finally, it becomes clear when a very small human appears on the scene although he is puzzled when Rover tries to eat it and it tries to eat Rover's mum. He calls the baby Howler because that what it does, yet no matter what he does he is ignored or in BIG trouble.
So he starts to spend time with the dog next door, Ruff-Ruff and it's not long before she starts to get bigger and bigger . . . and gradually his understanding of the phenomenon develops.
This new edition of this story by the author of We're Going on a Bear Hunt is very funny and gives a totally new take on that classic pre-school theme of a new baby joining the family. Neal Layton's illustrations appear to be quite simple but they convey so much meaning and expression that they are the perfect accompaniment, creating a fresh, lively and entertaining story. As well as showing the young child who is also awaiting a new brother or sister that 'someone' empathises with their bewilderment, if can also that can be used to help them understand the concept of perspective and our view of an event depends on our position within it. Discussing the book from the point of view of rover, her mum her dad, even Ruff-Ruff's owners, would all enrich and enhance the experience.
Barbara Braxton

Waterfire saga: Deep blue by Jennifer Donnelly

cover image

Hodder Children's Books, 2014. ISBN 9781444921182.
(Age: 11+) Recommended. Deep Blue is the first thrilling instalment in the Waterfire saga which follows the perilous adventure of six teenage mermaids are they endeavour to save their ocean home from an unknown terragogg enemy. The story starts by following princess Seraphina as she prepares her songspell for her dokimi, a coronation and betrothal ceremony. The ceremony is interrupted however and her homeland of Miromara is laid waste by enemy mermen from Ondalina. With the sea-people preparing for war Seraphina's life and that of her betrothed's cousin, Neela, are in danger. The girls must do all that is in their power to get away, even if that means stepping into the mirror realm and facing down dangerous terragoggs. Drawn together by dreams of river witches and a terrifying monster the girls must choose to embrace their talents and either fight or take flight from their enemy, for they are the descendants of the six greatest mages who ever lived.
A full blown fantasy with rich details and a portrayal of everyday environmental concerns for marine life and pollution, this novel is the perfect fantasy for the modern girl. I would highly recommend for girls ages eleven and up who love fantasy. The novel is filled with strong female characters, in a matriarchal setting, who are both beautiful and smart. The reader is thrown into an enjoyably foreign new world with a multitude of historical and mythological references. The novel deals both directly and indirectly with issues of teenage rebellion, body image, trust, the importance of obedience and of facing one's problems.
Kayla Gaskell (Student)

Chu's first day at school by Neil Gaiman

cover image

Ill. Adam Rex. Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408847039.
(Age: 6+) Recommended. Picture book. School. Anxiety. A sequel to the highly successful, Chu's day, this book has the little bear going to school for the first time. He is anxious about making friends and fitting in. He is worried that the others will not like him. His parents try to reassure him but he is still concerned.
We see him in the classroom where he meets his teacher who has a friendly face. She shows them where the toys are and gets them to sit in a circle and tell each other what they can do. Several of the others do this, the giraffe can lift things down from high places, the monkey can climb trees and the parrot can sing, but Chu cannot think of anything and so stays silent.
But suddenly he does show them what he can do. A gigantic sneeze erupts and throws the roof off the school, sending the classroom into chaos, upturning desks and chairs, throwing everyone around the room. He can do something, and is very pleased with himself, and the others think so too.
He goes home happily.
The bright illustrations follow Chu's story throughout the day, drawing in the background to the story, showing the kind teacher and the range of animals in the class. The standout images of the children doing the things they can do are wonderful as are the last few pages showing the results of Chu's sneeze. This will be a comforting and funny story to read out loud to new arrivals in a classroom or those about to go to school.
Fran Knight

Fossil by Claire Ewart

cover image

Walker, 2014. ISBN 9780802737373.
(Age: 6+) Recommended. Picture book. Fossils. Archaeology. First published in 2004, this is a handsome picture book. Claire Ewart once lived near a lake which had been dredged from a stream bed, so uncovering a myriad of pieces of brachiopods, mollusks and corals, each a fossil.
This story relives all the excitement of finding a fossil, that once was a bone. The story imagines the life of the bird, a pterosaur, as it lives its life cycle. Flying freely in the pale blue skies, scooping squid from the seas below, wearily heading for home, feeding its young from the food it has partly digested, then folding its wings around the young to sleep. The next day sees the same routine until, one day, its living days over, it becomes bones in the sand, buried beneath many millions of days to become a fossil, which is then found.
Beautifully told in poetic words, the story tells smaller children the life cycle of these ancient dinosaurs, talking about their lives form birth to death, showing through the illustrations that they were simply birds, and followed the same life cycle as all of them, finally becoming a fossil for a child to uncover. This celebration of the science that tracks down these fossils and explores them for our better understanding, is an amazing book. Its illustrations in watercolour depict the animal's day from flying high to catching food, avoiding predators and bringing up its young.
I was surprised that I was given two books at the same time. One, Fossil, and the other, Edward and the great discovery (Rebecca McRitchie) deal with parallel topics, one finding a fossil and imagining that animal's life story, the other, following the story of a family of archaeologists. Each compliments the other, and could be well used in a classroom where science is under discussion, and introducing fossils, dinosaurs, endangered species, or archaeology could be done using these books as a starting point. But all that said, Fossil is a wonderful introduction for younger readers of a rich part of our lives.
Fran Knight

Nowhere boys by Elise McCredie

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2014. ISBN 9781760120160.
Recommended for middle years readers. Nowhere boys, which has been serialised for television, tells the story of four very different boys in Year 10 who become friends in difficult circumstances. Felix is a punk songwriter, Andy an Asian science nerd, Jake a bully with a disadvantaged background and Sam the all-round popular sports hero. When the four are thrust together on a school excursion it seems unlikely that there will be a productive outcome. However, Felix, who feels responsible for his brother's paralysis and hopes to invoke the help of supernatural powers to reverse the past, manipulates the situation so that he can make contact with forces in the forest. The boys become lost and do attract the attention of otherworldly powers. When they make their way home they find that they are 'nowhere'. They either do not exist or have been replaced. Their parents do not recognise them, their homes have changed, even their girlfriends have moved on. Tired, hungry and unhappy they are forced to look after themselves, while trying to find out exactly what has happened. When Felix borrows a spell from Phoebe, the owner of the local magic shop, their troubles worsen when the supernatural powers are antagonised even more. The boys are attacked by swarms of bees, then crows and finally dogs. Specific humans seem to respond to them manically, and it becomes clear that a demon has become disturbed and is attempting to destroy them. Felix realizes that a talisman borrowed from Phoebe can protect them if all four are present. Each of the four represents either earth, fire, water or air, and all four elements are needed. The boys realise that, despite their differences, they do need each other, and they develop a grudging respect for all their different talents. They are restored to their former lives with the help of the talisman, but there are clearly more adventures to follow as the temporarily defeated demon reappears in a new form on the last page. The story is quite simply written though the plot has a number of complexities. The characters are believable, even though each of the boys represents a 'type' and the minor characters are also stereotypes. It is recommended for middle years readers.
Jenny Hamilton

Big pet day by Lisa Shanahan

cover image

Ill. by Gus Gordon. Lothian, 2014. ISBN 9780734412416.
(Age: 5+) Recommended. School. Animals.
Each of the children in the class brings their pet to school for Pet Day. They are all excited, especially knowing that their principal, Mr Fisher will come in and judge whose pet is the best.
Mrs Dalton is a little flustered when Glen's ferret escapes his box, and is a little perturbed when Jodie's horse does a poo just outside the classroom door. After all, she is trying to keep the classroom neat and tidy for Mr Fisher's visit.
Lily has brought along her dragon, and each behaviour shown by the other pets is one that her dragon does not do, as she delights in telling the class. But Courtney always has the last word, telling them all that dragons do not exist. As the day wears on, the illustrations show Mrs Dalton becoming more and more flustered, cleaning up the horse poo, trying to keep the ferret in its cage, stopping the children feeding the puppy red cordial at recess time. When they assemble back in the classroom, a nice calming activity of drawing their animal occurs while after lunch the children line up with their animals for Mr Fisher's scrutiny.
Of course, chaos reigns and it is up to Lily and her dragon to save the day, a lovely resolution to a delightful story which will intrigue and engage younger readers. All the fun of being at school with your peers is shown, with a hint of some of the snide remarks made by one of the children. School is presented so clearly, the frazzled teacher having to use all of her skills to make the day successful for everyone, the principal strolling in at the end, unaware of the chaos that has reigned during the day, the little cameo sketches of the classmates: all is charming, heartwarming and very real.
The wonderful illustrations by Gordon enhance the story, showing a group of kids having fun with their Pet Day. He has used a range of media to create his illustrations for the book, including line drawing, crayon, cut-outs and watercolour. All is engrossing as I loved looking at all the detail on each page, working out how each page was done, as I am sure younger readers will as well.
Fran Knight

While we run by Karen Healey

cover image

When we wake Bk 2. Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743435458.
(Age 14+) Highly recommended. Science fiction. Dystopian. Following When we wake, this story looks at what life was like for Abdi Taalib and Tegan Oglietti, the girl who had died in 2027, frozen and then brought back to life, a 100 years later. The Government has a cryonics project that is experimenting with young refugees and the pair are forced to be the public voice for Project Ark. Forced apart and closely supervised by their cruel handlers, Diane and Lat, Abdi and Tegan's feelings for each other are manipulated and each is tortured to ensure that the other complies with their demands.
While When we wake was told in Tegan's voice, this is narrated by Abdi, a young man who had won a music scholarship to Australia. The reader is pulled through the awful plight of the pair as their handlers torture them to ensure that they comply with the Government's publicity demands. They can only see each other on a TV screen and have no way of knowing if either has completely given into the Government's belief system. Healey pulls no punches here, the torture is explicit and it is all too believable that a political party would resort to torture to ensure that they get what they want.
Healey brings a diverse set of characters to the stage, ranging from the evil Diane who sexually abuses Abdi to Lat, who threatens to rape Tegan, but who is painted as less evil than Diane. Abdi and Tegan's friends, Bethari and Joph, feature again in this book each bringing their own unique personalities and skills to the movement to stop Project Ark.
The themes of the ethics of regeneration of frozen children, the plight of refugees, of destruction of the planet and the hope of a new life are all dealt with in a thought provoking way that make this an outstanding book for teens (and adults). There is plenty to think about and the cleverly constructed plot, exciting sequencing and fabulous character studies make it a stand out read.
Pat Pledger

Calypso Summer by Jared Thomas

cover image

Magabala Books, 2014. ISBN 9781922142122.
(Ages: Mature senior secondary students) Kyle Summer is a young Nukunu man who lives near Henley Beach in Adelaide. He's known to all as Calypso because of his dreadlocks, love of Bob Marley and reggae music and the West Indies cricket team. His Rasta persona masks his own insecurities. After leaving school and failing to get his dream job in a sports store, he is at a loss and spends a lot of time smoking dope and not much else. Then things start to look up, he ends up with a job in a health food store and really has a knack for it, gets on well with his boss and starts to turn his life around. He moves out of home and into a little flat and feels proudly independent. The blight on this is a cousin, Run, moving in to bludge. When his boss suggests getting some native bush remedies to sell as products in the store, Calypso's mother directs him to his mob in the Southern Flinders Ranges and this urban Indigenous man begins to develop an affinity with his country and culture.
Ensuing troubles with some less than welcoming cousins, and the deadbeat Run, who is thieving and dealing dope, result in some major drama for
Calypso, but the support of his new girlfriend, a smart Ngadjuri girl who happens to share his passion for cricket, and the newly found family circle, prove the right medicine for his woes.
Winning the State Library of Queensland award in 2013 Black & Write competition, Jared Thomas has tried to provide a realistic view of the struggle for young Indigenous people and their conflicts with cultures.
Personally I found the novel a bit hard-going at times and found it difficult to connect with the characters or be sympathetic. I have Koori and Murri family and friends, have spent years teaching Indigenous kids, young adults, and adults, and worked in Indigenous units and while lots of these friends use the word 'deadly' their vocabulary does also embrace other adjectives. There was a point when I thought if I read the word 'deadly' one more time I might just scream. The novel seemed rather heavy-handed in its heaping upon the reader every conceivable Indigenous issue.
That being said, I believe that young people would relate to it and non-Indigenous readers would gain some understanding of the challenges facing Indigenous culture.
The novel is marketed as YA but I would suggest that it is only suitable for mature senior students. The frequent profanity and emphasis on drug usage would make me hesitate about making it generally available.
Sue Warren

The edge of the water by Elizabeth George

cover image

The edge of nowhere bk 2. Hodder & Stoughton, 2014. ISBN 9781444720013.
(Age: 14+) Mystery. Thriller. Supernatural. The sequel to The edge of nowhere finds Becca hiding from her stepfather in a location in the woods which Seth her close friend has helped her find. She has to keep the hideaway secret from everyone she knows, including Derric the Ugandan orphan with whom she had formed a close relationship. Meantime strange things are happening on Whidbey Island, centred around a coal black seal named Nera that returns to the same place each year and a mute girl who has appeared on the island.
George has put together an intriguing mix of realistic crime and the supernatural in this gripping thriller. The first chapter, Cilla's World, introduces the reader to the strange girl, Cilla who reports:
'I don't speak. I only walk and point and observe. I get along by doing what I am told. But I fear things that other children don't fear' pg 3.
As would be expected from such an experienced author, George immediately gains the reader's attention and fear for the fate of the abandoned Cilla, and this suspense is kept up right to the final denouement in the closing chapters with the reader desperate to know the fate of the girl and the black seal.
The character development of several adults in the story and the clever dialogue all combine to make a well-rounded whole. Jen MacDaniels, introduced briefly in The edge of nowhere, a girl who hates Becca because she destroyed her friendship with Derric, is a main protagonist in this story. George brings to life the poverty that Jen faces every day, and her intense desire to make it into the All Island Girls Soccer team and a chance to leave the island. Teenage sexuality is a minor theme and is handled very well. Jen's relationship with Squat Cooper makes her think about her sexuality while the character of Derric too is developed as he works through his feelings for Courtney, the very popular teen.
While the mystery of the seal is resolved neatly, it is the combination of mysteries and secrets of many of the characters, both teen and adult, an environmental thread and the issues that face teens all the time that made this a very satisfying book to read.
Pat Pledger

Edward and the great discovery by Rebecca McRitchie and Celeste Hulme

cover image

New Frontier, 2014. ISBN 9781925059007.
(Age: 6+) Recommended. Dinosaurs. Archaeology, Dodo.
All Edward wants to do is make a big discovery. After all his parents and grandparents have all made discoveries in their lives as archaeologists, and he expects to follow in their footsteps. But try as he might, digging holes in the garden, he does not find anything of significance. But one night he digs up an egg. He loves his egg. He wraps it up and cuddles it in bed, and eventually it hatches. It is a bird, but not like any bird he has seen. He examines it closely and realises that its wings are not quite right. He is despondent, he feels his discovery is broken.
He goes to his favourite place, a museum of ancient things and there finds himself in a room devoted to birds. He spies a dodo, and reading about it shows him that his bird is special. He has indeed made a great discovery, one which warrants his photo on the family wall.
For a class being introduced to a unit of work on archaeology and dinosaurs this is a wonderful opener. The back endpaper jumps out at the reader with images of all the things that Edward needs to ply his trade. Kids will thrill at the work Edward does in digging up his garden, and will watch eagerly as he finds out what his bird really is. Adults will be able to discuss the demise of the dodo and easily open the discussion about what we have done to kill off so many species around the world, and discuss just how the dodo evolved and why it was so precarious when it came to be threatened. This beautifully illustrated book will lead the class in a whole range of discussions and research into topics such as science and environment. The illustrations are fascinating, with a myriad of things to look for in the background, all redolent of the nineteenth century when archaeology was world news.
Fran Knight

There's a lion in my cornflakes by Michelle Robinson

cover image

Ill. Jim Field. Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408845608.
(Age: Preschool-Yr 2)This book starts in a most unusual way - a warning to ignore any messages the reader might see about collecting cereal packet coupons! And the warning is based on experience because after making umpteen trips to the supermarket and spending a whole year's pocket money, and even though it meant they had to eat cornflakes for breakfast lunch and tea until there were no cornflakes left, Eric and his brother Dan finally had enough coupons to qualify for the lion on the packet. Oh, the things they could do with a free lion... if it ever arrived! They waited and waited and waited and even though it seemed everyone else had received theirs, by Sunday they were still waiting.
Come Monday, it looks like their waiting is over - but it is just the start of the problem!
Told from Eric's point of view, this is a very funny story that really amplifies the meaning of 'Be careful what you wish for.' Who knew that something as innocent as collecting coupons and cards could have such an outcome! Accompanied by illustrations that are as wacky as the text, this went from a first-read to a favourite with Miss 8 and Miss 3 (who are avid collectors of supermarket cards) literally overnight! They loved the punchline at the end, and then went into hoots of laughter when we turned the page and saw what was happening!! Miss 8, who is now such an avid reader that she will even read the cornflakes packet, asked me if I had any other stories by the same author so we checked out the website and now have some on order!
Barbara Braxton

The Bow by Catherine Mayo

cover image

Walker Books, 2014. ISBN: 9781925081015.
(Age: Year 8+) Recommended. Themes: Ancient Greece; Historical Epic drama; Adventure. Catherine Mayo has allied Ancient Greece with its Gods and heroes to a story of conflict, family honour and drama that is compelling even for readers that know nothing of the Ancient Greek realm. The main character Odysseus faces many challenges as he attempts to recover the family wealth from under the nose of a powerful potential thief and then protect it in order to return it to his father, Laertes the King of Ithaka. The young man proves to be a worthy and honourable son, and his coming to maturity in this adventure is epic.
Young readers who have discovered the ancient world from reading Rick Riordan's Percy Jackson adventures, and those who have loved the John Flanagan Ranger's Apprentice and Brotherband series will equally enjoy this story. The quest and adventure, combined with the physical combat required in the face of threats to life and friends makes this an exciting read. (And there is even a little romance included for female readers!)
(Note: Includes violence and references to attempted rape, and female servants sexually abused, but in the context of the historical Ancient world.)
Carolyn Hull