Reviews

Kick with my left foot by Paul Seden and Karen Briggs

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 978174331344.
'I pull the sock on my left foot
I pull the sock on my right foot
I lace up the boot on my left foot
I lace up the boot on my right foot . . .
It's time for footy!'
This is a charming story of a little boy who loves his footy and can do everything well with his right and left hands, except for when it comes to kicking. When the tries to kick with his right foot, the results are less than great. But kicking with his left foot is a totally different matter! In a place where footy is an integral part of life, being able to kick well is an important skill and there is great excitement when his left foot kicking is the clincher.
Accompanied by illustrations that depict the emotions of both the boy and his dog perfectly, this story really appealed to the younger readers in my family who are struggling with left and right, as well as with throwing and kicking. In fact, Miss 3 and a half immediately went outside and practised with both feet to see which one worked best for her. Many times the results were those shown in the pictures but with practice she began to improve, and now has also sorted out that left/right confusion.
The book is one of the Emerging Indigenous Picture Book Mentoring Project a partnership between the Little Big Book Club and Allen & Unwin in which six previously unpublished Indigenous writers and illustrators will have their work showcased in four picture books during 2014. Each creator has been partnered with a renowned mentor in children's publishing including Nadia Wheatley, Ken Searle, Nick Bland, Ann James, Bronwyn Bancroft, Boori Monty Pryor and Ali Cobby Eckermann to share ideas, techniques and inspiration for their first published work. The project has been funded by the federal government through the Australia Council and it means that not only will our cohort of children's writers be enriched but our students will have access to authentic texts that will work towards the understanding and harmony between our cultures that is at the heart of so many of the Australian Curriculum outcomes. Even though it is written for an early childhood audience, there is a lot that offers scope for comparing and contrasting lifestyles and landscapes that would enable younger students to continue the development of their critical thinking skills. Even determining which code of football is being played requires observation and justification!
Barbara Braxton

Alice-Miranda at camp by Jacqueline Harvey

cover image

Random House Australia Children's Books, 2014. ISBN 9781742757612
Recommended. This is the tenth in the incredibly successful Alice-Miranda series. This is my first time reading an Alice-Miranda and I have enjoyed the experience. Jacqueline Harvey places her characters and series in the timeless void inhabited by Milly-Molly-Mandy, The naughtiest girl in the school and the Chalet stories. These are comfort reads of the highest order.
In this adventure Alice-Miranda and her friends go on a hastily arranged school camp organised at the orders of Queen Georgiana, as it turns out the camp is right next door to Alice-Miranda's father's home. This has since become a retirement home for workers from the estate.
Of course mystery and mayhem of a most enjoyable type occurs. The author's visits to schools obviously correspond to 'research' and I found myself chuckling at the way she portrays the teachers in the book. I also admired the way that Jacqueline Harvey weaves in aspects of previous adventures so that a new reader such as myself can follow the back story.
I was taken by the sub-plot of the new girl Caprice and the subtlety of her bullying of Millie. The issues this raises of trust with the teachers and Alice-Miranda provide interesting moral lessons for the young readership.
This is a lovely written book for younger readers, with lots of fun and humour to be enjoyed. Well plotted, with acute portrayals and characterisation, I can see why this is a very successful series. Rest assured that the novice reader can pick up this title and have no difficulty at all becoming immersed in the world of Alice-Miranda, and will immediately seek to track down the entire series and join the eager crew of young readers anxiously awaiting the next instalment.
I will leave the last word to my Primary TL colleague Kim who says 'Alice-Miranda is a great role model for girls - a strong and independent child with a beautiful heart'.
Michael Jongen

The Summer of Kicks by Dave Hackett

cover image

University of Queensland Press, 2014. ISBN 9780702253362
Recommended for readers aged 13+. Themes: Relationships; Family; Friendship; Teen coming-of age. With a central character with a burdensome name - 'Starrphyre', this book relates the love and pain-strewn path of this teenage boy as he juggles new love and old passion disastrously. Helped and hindered by his family and friends - his mother, an on-air Radio sex and relationship therapist; her former partner - a one-hit-wonder 80's band member; his sister, who is dating the ultimate loser boyfriend; his Gran - who attempts to predict the future; and his friendship group which is stereotypically full of outcasts. The misadventures for Starrphyre include starting a band with his friends in order to persuade girls to see them as above-ordinary. Unfortunately Starrphyre and his friends have little more than a disputed playlist. There is certainly no great musical talent amongst their number, and a chance meeting with a potential guitarist lands Starrphyre with a part-time job in a record store selling old-time vinyls and an accidental girl-friend. Accidents continue to litter his path, and kissing and poor choices send him on the relationship roller-coaster. This is not an unfamiliar plot, and is very definitely told from the point of view of a young male suffering the early doubts of his role in romance.
The author of this book will be well known to young TV viewers because of numerous roles on children's television as a presenter and cartoonist.
This is mostly an inoffensive tale (even with his Mother's unusual occupation sometimes providing advice) and provides some amusing moments.
Carolyn Hull

Snail and Turtle are friends by Stephen Michael King

cover image

Scholastic, 2014. ISBN: 9781743620236
Despite their differences, snail and turtle are friends who do almost everything together. From their shared activities including walking, running, hiding and being quiet together, they nonetheless enjoy different foods, parts of the day and creative styles. Although they prefer to go about things in different ways, they accept one another's choices and enjoy one another's company without question and, at the end of the day retreat to their shells, side by side, to sleep. Theirs is an almost perfect friendship, lived in harmony and based on mutual trust and respect.
Stephen Michael King's illustrations utilise his easily identifiable cartoon like style with the colour palette containing predominantly earthy shades of the garden plants and water. On the cover and throughout the book is a shiny 'trail' showing where the snail has travelled. Having already shared the book with a number of classes, the children love following the path and tracing the trail with their fingers.
This is a joyous and gentle story, simply showing the importance of people who don't have to be exactly like us to be true friends. Junior primary teachers will find this title to be a useful discussion starter about friendship and individual differences.
Jo Schenkel

Princesses are not just pretty by Kate Lum

cover image

Ill. by Sue Hellard. Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408824252
(Ages 3-5) Recommended. Princess Allie, Princess Mellie and Princess Libby love dressing in beautiful gowns, having their hair done in lavish styles, and being generally very pretty. The trouble is, each thinks they are the prettiest, so it is decided they must have a beauty contest to find out who really is the prettiest princess. Luckily at this point the book takes a change in direction, as none of the characters seemed very likeable. Suddenly, though, each princess is faced with a problem which involves them putting another person's needs before their own, and each steps up valiantly.
This book would provide a great starting point for many discussions about stereotypes, selflessness and appearances. The illustrations are colourful and comical, making it an enjoyable book for reading aloud to young children. There are two other titles in the Princesses series.
Donella Reed.

We were liars by E. Lockhart

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781760111069.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Wealth and power. Greed. Psychological injury. Truth and lies. Poignantly powerful and full of suspense, this book takes the reader through the distress of a major psychological incident to uncover the truth and lies at its heart. The central characters are born to wealth and privilege in USA, living in wealthy Boston and spending indolent summers on the family island near Martha's Vineyard. The greed and self-focus that hides underneath the impeccable outer veneer of lies, gives a view to the world of aspirational perfection which is, in fact, far from perfect. The reader is introduced to this world through the eyes of the psychologically damaged teenager, Cadence, who is struggling to remember her past. Her story and the unveiling of her 15th summer lost in the fog of amnesia, is woven with fairy-tale and literature stories of comparison. This weaving creates a beautiful association, leaving the reader aware of the dark and light of the narrative in the completed tapestry of We were liars. As is the case with all good suspense stories, the ending should only be known by those who are prepared to get to know the whole story and read the book. This would make an excellent film script.
I can highly recommend this book for mature readers. It is beautifully written, with a coming of age undertone, and also a moral tale with an unstated but implicit criticism of the consequences of great wealth within a family. I especially enjoyed the simplicity of sentence structure at the end of many chapters. This writing style choice is intelligent and perfect in revealing inside the mind of the central character.
[There is a small section within the book with swearing that may make this difficult for more conservative school libraries, but for readers 15+, this language choice is not surprising in context.]
Carolyn Hull

Billy is a dragon: Shadow shifter by Nick Falk and Tony Flowers

cover image

Random House, 2014. ISBN 9780857983152.
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. Billy is a dragon: Shadow shifter is the second book in the series and picks up where the first book finished. Our main character, 10 year old Billy, is able to turn into a dragon. His sister was kidnapped by werewolves in the first book and Billy and his friends are searching for her.
Billy faces all the same issues as other children - cranky teachers, bullies, teachers who are really werewolves and werewolf knights! (Well maybe not quite the same problems as others!) His parents believe his sister has run away and they don't know whether to be concerned or happy (they aren't your typical parents) but despite this, Billy is worried about telling them he is a dragon. Billy believes he can find his sister on his own, he is a dragon after all, but is he too inexperienced? Can he battle the werewolf knights and win? Will he find his sister?
Billy is a dragon: Shadow shifter is full of action, comedy and adventure. It is highly recommended for boys aged 9 and older. There are black and white images scattered throughout the novel making it an appealing read. The text is descriptive and quick moving and the use of different-sized fonts for adjectives and keywords emphasises what is going on.
Kylie Kempster

Mummy goes to work by Kes Gray

cover image

Ill. David Milgrim. Hachette Children's Books, 2014. ISBN 978144921410.
(Age: 3-6) Recommended. Families. Mothers. When his mother goes to work, the narrator of this story tells us the sort of things mummy thinks about doing with him while she is at work. These range from being tickled, to roller skating, to cuddling and playing games. Each is outlined on a page with bold, bright illustrations of the curly headed boy and his dog. The reader has a little sympathy with the child listing the things she wants to do with him, until the last part of the book shows that she does do these things with him when she gets home each night.
A neatly told story, first published in 2006 as My mum goes to work, this will have broad appeal in homes and classrooms. Readers will love to hear it read aloud, and marvel at the way the story turns on its head, making for a funny ending. They will love to read it themselves, thinking about how they know they are loved at home and what they do with their parents. They will enjoy the depiction of the lad and his dog, the focus on each page until Mum returns, and it could open a discussion in classrooms where the talk is about what the students' parents do with their days.
Fran Knight

Newts, lutes and bandicoots by Mark Carthew and Mike Spoor

cover image

IP Kidz, 2009. ISBN 9781921479335. ebk ISBN 9781921869792.
(Ages: 6-10)
'In a gourmet cafe by the Bay of Biscay.
The seafood buffet was well on its way
When a curried satay
Caught fire on a tray
And flambeed the moustache of a waiter named Ray!'
This is the first rhyme in this unusual book which focuses on the multitude of ways that a particular sound can be spelt in English. It is accompanied by a riddle - 'This creature crawls beneath the bay, Searching for rocks and sand each day' - and hidden amongst the rich full-page illustration is the answer to that riddle. But as the students search they will also discover a host of other items that have that 'ay' sound even though their spelling might be different. In this instance they could find archway, bay, beret, birthday, bray, buffet and more than 20 others! Each page features a different sound combination and takes the explorer on a journey through their imagination as they examine a trolls' lair, a magician's cave, a circus, a castle, ski slopes and the outback.
Given the popularity of books like Where's Wally that have even the most reluctant readers poring over pages to spot the hidden items, this book is a winner on many levels because it teaches as the children search and encourages them to think and discuss and focus on the inconsistencies of our language. Also hidden on each page is a tiny newt or bandicoot playing a lute enabling even those not yet ready for the spelling aspect to participate.
Once the basics of letter/sound recognition have been mastered, the most commonly used skill in determining the correct spelling of a word is whether it looks right, and so developing visual perception and discrimination are critical skills. So combining the elements of rhythm, rhyme and riddle and accompanying them with complex, colourful and quirky pictures makes this a great book that will provide for hours of entertainment and learning. And then there is the next one, Witches, britches, itches and twitches.
Barbara Braxton

Lisa absolutely loves art by Sophie Norsa

cover image

New Frontier Publishing, 2014. ISBN 9781925059045.
(Ages: 3-6) Lisa and her cat, Picasso, are sitting at a cafe outside the art gallery, when Picasso suddenly runs into the gallery and disappears. Lisa searches through the paintings of the gallery, discovering famous artists while searching for her cat.
This is the first book written and illustrated by young artist Sophie Norsa. While the illustrations are very clever and introduce the reader to several important paintings and artists, the story itself is really just there to show off the art. The text feels too contrived and obvious. My 6 year old was also bothered by the fact that Lisa is smiling in most of the pictures, but if her beloved cat was missing she should be worried. At the back of the book we get to see the original paintings, but unfortunately they are not in the same order they appear in the book, making it harder for children to discover which belongs on which page.
Donella Reed

Meet... Douglas Mawson by Mike Dumbelton

cover image

Ill. by Snip Green. Random House Australia Children's, 2014. ISBN 9780857981950.
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. What a fabulous series this has proven and many of you will be familiar with the titles so far such as The Anzacs, Ned Kelly and Mary MacKillop.
Again focusing on a truly outstanding Australian, Mike Dumbelton recounts the story of Douglas Mawon's ill-starred Antarctica expedition with simplistic elegance. Mawson led the first Australian expedition to the Antarctic surviving many dangerous challenges, the cruel fate of his comrades and bravely survived against extreme odds. In 2013 'The Australian' listed the Top 50 Australians and Sir Douglas Mawson, honoured by his inclusion on our currency and lending his name to suburbs and streets around the country, was ranked at Number Eight 'for his brilliant brain as a scientist [and for] making one of the most courageous solo journeys by any Australian adventurer'.
However, as with all outstanding picture books, it is not just the author's well crafted text but the astonishing illustrations which bring this book into what surely must be a strong award contender. Snip Green uses his considerable background in graphic art to give the reader a powerful impression of the isolation, barrenness and stark reality of the Antarctic landscape. By using tones of blue/grey/white combined with uncompromising geometric patterns Green more than ably conveys the frightening stillness of this frozen continent. The placement of the text in framed white panels in the amazing double page spreads allow the reader's eye to focus on the illustration while giving the caption-like information.
Though all the 'Meet...' series has been a worthy inclusion for any library, I think this one is undoubtedly my favourite so far given this wonderful collaboration of text and illustration.
Highly recommended for readers aged around 8 and up - a must-have for your library in my opinion.
Sample the book at Random House or visit Mike Dumbleton's webpage or see more of Snip Green's work online.
Sue Warren

The last king of Angkor Wat by Graeme Base

cover image

Viking/Penguin, 2014. ISBN 9780670077151.
Amongst the ruins of Angkor Wat, the 'City of Temples' built hundreds of years ago by the Khmer people in the north of what is now Cambodia, Tiger, Gibbon, Water Buffalo and Gecko look at the ancient stone carvings and muse on what it would like to have been a king.
Tiger believes he would have been a fine king because he is strong but Gibbon declares he would have been better because he would have ruled with compassion and kindness. Water Buffalo says he would have never given up, no matter what, while tiny Gecko proclaims he would have been a fearless warrior. And so an argument about who would have made the best king ensues. Their talk is interrupted by Elephant. 'It takes many qualities to be a good king', he says. 'Strength, compassion, resilience and courage.' He then challenges them to find out if they are worthy by going to the temple at the top of the hill. And so begins a race during which each creature encounters Snake and other obstacles, dealing with them accordingly, not realising what their decisions and actions are saying about them as potential rulers. When they reach the temple at the top of the hill Elephant is waiting, but rather than giving the title to the victor, he forces them to examine their journey and learn from it. Who will be crowned king? Will any of them make the grade?
Set against a backdrop of opulent, evocative scenes detailed in the way that we associate with Graeme Base's illustrations, this is a tale with a message about humility that would be a perfect adjunct to a values-based program. Often, Base embeds either a textual or visual puzzle into his books but this time, the puzzle is in the meaning of the words. But even with the story told and retold and understood, the young reader will be drawn again and again to the elaborate, exquisite illustrations searching for the riches within, perhaps discovering the butterfly who also makes the journey or the author's signature. Such is Base's reputation, his fans have learned to look for more than meets the eye.
Another magnificent masterpiece.
Barbara Braxton

I want my mummy by Tracey Corderoy

cover image

Ill. by Alison Edgson. Little Tiger Press, 2014. ISBN 9781848955387
(Age: Preschool) It is a big day in Arthur's life. Today he is going to spend the day with his grandmother, the first time he has been parted from his mummy. But rather than being excited, he is very apprehensive. Even his favourite dragon onesie and his toy dragon Huffity don't give him quite the courage he needs. When Mummy finally says goodbye, he feels very lost and no matter what Granny offers, he is not interested. Even though he plays along for a little while, as soon as the doorbell rings he races off to see if it is his mummy. But Granny, being a true granny, comes up with a game that makes him forget his woes until...
This is a lovely picture book that explores a common issue that preschoolers face, and it's perfect for a parent to share with their child before they leave them for the first time. The bright pictures are very eye-catching and so beautifully drawn that you can just feel the softness of Arthur and his onesie, Grandma and Huffity. Who knew that a tea-towel and a feather duster could be so formidable???
When I was school-based, the preschool was part of 'big school' and each week the children would come for storytime, to browse and then later bring their parents in to borrow from the special collection I had for them that would encourage them to read aloud and begin their child's reading journey. This title would have made a charming addition to that collection.
Barbara Braxton

The big book of Old Tom by Leigh Hobbs

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743318447.
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Who doesn't love the TV series 'Old Tom'? The big book of Old Tom is 5 stories combined into one huge novel-sized book. It uses black and white drawings and minimal text to tell each story, helping engage readers in the stories of a spoiled cat called Old Tom. It is highly recommended for all readers due to the large amount of images but would be especially appealing to girls and boys aged 7+. As a teacher, I am always looking for novels to engage reluctant readers as well as those who struggle to read. This book will make struggling readers look like they are reading like their peers.
In book 1, we find out how Old Tom came to live with his owner Angela. We see how he is not a typical cat and is usually in the middle of the trouble, not looking on from the fence! The other stories continue to tell us about Old Tom and his mischievous adventures - the drawings helping create the comical side of the TV series.
Kylie Kempster

I have a dog (an inconvenient dog) by Charlotte Lance

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743317815.
(Age: Preschool) 'When I wake up my dog is inconvenient.
When I'm getting dressed, my dog is inconvenient.
And when I'm making tunnels, my dog is really inconvenient...'
But there are some times when the dog is not inconvenient and sometimes when there is no other source of comfort, particularly as the day draws to a close and dinner is disgusting, television is scary and it's time to snuggle down to dream.
This is a quintessential picture book where neither text nor pictures can make sense without the other. As we follow the child through the day, the text is minimal but the pictures tell the story so well, creating lots of laugh-out-loud moments as scenes familiar to anyone with a dog, particularly a young one, are played out with a detail that means there is no need for additional words. This would be a great bedtime read-aloud where parent and child could share it together, talking about their own experiences. (My dog is inconvenient when it's bedtime and I want the pillow but she is very convenient when we need to put the chooks away at night!)
But as well as its entertainment value, it also has an educational one particularly for the early reader because it encourages them to search the pictures for clues, interpret and explain them so the story make sense and forms a whole... Putting on my reading teacher's hat of days gone by, I can picture myself using this delightful book with some of my little characters who were struggling with sorting out this reading thing. As well as the value with the text/illustration relationship and having them talk and draw about their own dogs, it would also help them understand that they CAN read 'real' books just like their friends, overcoming the negative thoughts they impose on themselves about never succeeding. Imagine the thrill of being able to take it home and really read it so your listener listens, not to mention having mastered a roll-off-the-tongue word like 'inconvenient'!
One to promote to your early childhood teachers as well as your parent body.
Barbara Braxton