Reviews

The wombats at the zoo by Roland Harvey

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743319048
(Age: 5+) Recommended. Zoos, Animals, Wombats. The twelve students in a class known as the Wombats go to the zoo with their teachers, Mrs Nott and Miss Anabel. The endpapers show the reader the children's favourite animals with the reasons the animals are so well liked while adding a few extra bits of information such as collective nouns, the scariest animal and their task for the day. Each outline reveals some of the children's characteristics. I particularly liked Ava with her predilecton with the apostrophe, exposing its misuse which will be enlightening for some and hilarious for others.
Harvey's wonderfully detailed illustrations allow the readers to discover the students' personalities, quirks and abilities as they find their way into the exhibits of the animals they like. Double page spreads are devoted to each of the twelve students, with an illustration of their favourite exhibition space for their animal, and funny details of what happens there, along with information about the animal and the students. A list of the information each child collects is given, while now and again, one of the students writes a poem of their experiences.
Reading aloud each page and thoroughly exploring the minutiae of the illustrations will keep readers amused for some time, and along the way learn some interesting facts about the animals, models for their own poetry writing and a few hints about what to do and not to do when going to the zoo.
Fran Knight

Funny homes by Dr Mark Norman

cover image

Black Dog Books, 2014. ISBN 9781922179982
(Age: 6+) Recommended. Animals, Habitat. The habitats of two dozen animals ranging from rock wallabies to crabs, cactus wrens and moles, a ray and a sea cucumber, each is given a spectacular photograph to show its environment as well as its place of residence, and a paragraph of information suggesting why it lives in such a place.
So we see the sloth, hanging from its favourite branches in the tree tops by its amazing claw, so well adapted that it has difficulty walking on the ground, or the oxpeckker, a bird which lives on the zebra's back, picking off the fleas, or the two animals without eyes that lives far beneath the surface of the ocean. Readers will love reading of these odd creatures finding a home which suits them best. And the stunning photographs will draw them to look more closely at the animal and its place of residence.
At the end are two pages with information about eleven of the animals mentioned, giving their correct name and where they are to be found in the world, followed by a brief glossary and serviceable index.
The third in the series by Dr Mark Norman, this book follows Funny bums and Funny faces, and will be eagerly sought out in libraries and classrooms where animals are under discussion. Dr Mark Norman is a marine biologist who works at the University of Melbourne and Museum Victoria, and has won significant acclaim for his books for younger readers. The Great Barrier Reef book : solar powered won the Environment Award for Children's Literature from the Wilderness Society in 2010, amongst others.
Fran Knight

River Boy by Elizabeth Frankel

cover image

Ill. by Garry Duncan. Jane Curry Publishing, 2014. ISBN: 9781922190864
Recommended. Picture book. Themes: Sustainability; Environmental change; Australia - Geography; Family Relationships. The River Boy is taken for a camping trek on the River Murray in a tinnie, camping on the river banks and living from the produce that the river harbours. His grandfather shares the changes that have occurred over time and the delights of living carefully in partnership with the River that is the lifeblood of Australia. The boy's connection to the river grows as his grandfather shares his own love of the place.
The absolute delight of this wonderful picture book is in the illustrations by Garry Duncan. The boy and his grandfather are realistic drawings superimposed on the stunning impressions of the River Murray, shown with an incredibly accurate portrayal of the changing light and colours. These illustrations take this reviewer on her own memory journey down the Murray. They are spectacular.
This book is recommended.
Carolyn Hull

Winterkill by Kate A. Boorman

cover image

Faber & Faber, 2014. ISBN 9780571313693
(Age: 12+) In a past world not unlike to ours, Emmeline carries a burden and a title that has stuck with her since the day of her birth. Winterkill is coming and while the walls surrounding her village are supposed to make her safe, Emmeline can't help but feel apprehensive about those around her. Feeling like an outcast, Emmeline trudges through her not so eventful life until one day, she hears whispers from the trees in the woods and at that moment, her life will never be normal again. So when Emmeline begins to discover secrets hidden within the woods, will she risk it all to find out about her history?
Kate A. Boorman's Winterkill delivered a creative plot and an intriguing mystery into one novel. When reading the book, my liking for the main heroine, Emmeline grew as she was a character that I could admire and relate to. The writing is of good quality, with great imagery and similes included throughout, especially from a first-time author. But did this book fulfil my desire for story that will leave me wanting more? Sadly, it did not hit the mark with me regardless of the imaginative plot.
An aspect of this tale that I did enjoy was the surprising plot twist nearing the conclusion as well as the secrets and hidden agendas. The author delivers well-written characters that I either loved to hate or simply liked.
Samantha May

Romeo & Juliet retold by Jim Pipe

cover image

Ill. by Penko Gelev. Graffex series. Book House, 2014. ISBN : 9781906714406
If, as I have just experienced, you have students who struggle with Shakespeare, this series could prove a valuable complement to your collection. My Year 10 boys have just done a unit on Romeo & Juliet and while we steered clear of reading the play in full, instead selecting passages, watching the film, live performance from Grin & Tonic and so on, many still had some problems.
I took this slim graphic volume in for them to look at, and several commented that they now understood a particular part or made notes using the book.
Firstly, the graphic format breaks the play down in a storyboard type format which is easy to follow. Secondly, while the 'speech' is still Shakespearean, there are footnotes to 'translate' into modern day language. This running glossary is probably the most beneficial aspect of this version. Additionally there are several pages at the back with information about Shakespeare, his work and his times plus an index. A useful page as a frontispiece, pictures the characters with their names and relationship to Romeo and Juliet.
The only disconcerting note for me is the illustrator's tendency to have the characters look like muddy-faced trolls - Juliet is far from attractive as she scowls with her troll-face to swallow her potion. In fact, they all look very unpleasant - whether they are the good guys or not!
That being said I think this would be very handy for those students who need a simplified version and visual connection to help them grasp the main ideas and themes of Shakespeare. Others in this series included A Midsummer Night's Dream, Hamlet, Julius Caesar and The Merchant of Venice. There are also other classic stories published in the same format - see the publisher's page here.
Sue Warren

The Incredible Adventures of Cinnamon Girl by Melissa Keil

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2014. ISBN 9781742978307
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Melissa Keil has written a lively narrative of a vibrant community in country Victoria. She has set her heroine as a feisty, intelligent, artistic young woman who is torn between keeping things as they are in her home town, and leaving to study in Melbourne. This tension informs the action but there is a second challenge to the people of the small community!
In an online post, Original Ned predicts the end of the world and the centre of the co-ordinates for its implosion is Alba's town. The arrival of hundreds of doomsday 'followers' creates havoc in the town, but also enlivens the townspeople's businesses and lives.
Keil's protagonist is quirky, deeply concerned for everyone's well-being, loyal, artistic, and relishing the possibilities of life after Year 12. The disruption of this is the core of the narrative, and we witness her challenges, discovering whether she is ultimately still attracted to the third member of their primary school trilogy, Daniel, currently starring in a hit television show. Grady, the other 'third', seems to be waiting for Alba to really 'see' him, and this awakening is watched avidly by all of their young friends, and her mother.
Delightfully true to the vernacular of her characters, yet able to capture and retain an audience of any age, Keil's writing is wonderfully uplifting, touching as it does on adolescent angst, how to find out who you are, and how to find out if someone actually does really love you. Writing with an honesty and attention to detail, capturing a warm sense of the goodness of the characters, particularly the lovely Alba, who, after all, is the 'cinnamon girl' of her comic strip, Keil has written an uplifting story that leaves the reader with a deep sense of well-being.
Coming-of-age novel, fairly sophisticated interactions, and language appropriate for 14, years and older. Not limited to adolescent readers!
Liz Bondar

The Monster who ate Australia by Michael Salmon

cover image

Ford Street, 2014. Hb. ISBN 9781925000542. pbk. ISBN 9781925000559.
(Age: Pre-school - Yr 3) 'The boggabri is an extremely rare Australian mammal. Like its cousin the bunyip, it eats a lot and is very shy. But, unlike the bunyip, it has peculiar teeth that grow longer each day. To keep them trimmed, the boggabri chews rocks and other hard objects . . .'
Burra the boggabri lives peacefully at Uluru with nearby Kata Tjuta providing nice tasty rocks to eat that kept his teeth in shape. But as the tourists come in threatening his peace of mind and food supply, he is driven out looking for new fodder. And so begins his quirky journey around Australia, beginning with eating the America's Cup in Perth and continuing on to some of the nation's most recognisable man-made landmarks, unaware of the havoc he creates. Finally trapped in the thick gooey mud at the bottom of Sydney Harbour, trapped and placed on display in the elephant house at Taronga Zoo, Burra is viewed by many more tourists than those he ran away from . . .
This is the 30th anniversary edition of this Michael Salmon classic and it maintains all the appeal of the original as it takes its readers on a journey around Australia, introducing them to places, familiar and new. Michael Salmon recently visited Miss 8's school and she was so excited and engaged that she still tells me about it. You can imagine her thrill when she discovered that I had a collection of his books right here on the shelf and she spent hours reading them and immersing herself in the illustrations that are such an integral part of the stories, a reaction I often see when I suggest his stories to younger readers. Then I showed her his website which has always been my inspiration, and kerpow!!! My next surprise is to take her to the statue of Burra's cousin, Alexander Bunyip, who now stands outside the Gungahlin Library in Canberra after having eaten all the other city landmarks in The Monster that ate Canberra in 1972!
Michael Salmon's stories and artworks have delighted children for 40 years and I'm thrilled that publishers are re-releasing titles like The Monster who ate Australia so that yet another generation can enjoy them.
Barbara Braxton

Sacrifice by Brigid Kemmerer

cover image

Elementals Bk 5. Allen and Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743318621
(Age 14+) Highly recommended. Paranormal. Earth. Fire. Air. Water. Michael Merrick has been looking after his brothers for years after the death of his parents. He is an Elemental, who has the power to control Earth, but who can also destroy if he doesn't get it right. He has needed to be the steady brother, the one in charge, the one who takes care of things. Hannah his girlfriend, is a single mum, and her job as a firefighter puts her at risk as well. When an Elemental Guide comes to town hoping to kill the Merricks, Michael is put under enormous pressure.
Michael has been my favourite of the brothers in this very good series. His sense of responsibility and fairness, his ability to help and communicate with his siblings has made him a standout character and Sacrifice is his story as well as the final in the series. The reader is taken on a roller coaster ride as the unknown Guide creates havoc and death all around the Merricks, who are separated by the chaos. Michael seems to lose everything, but still manages to retain his sense of justice and right under very difficult circumstances. Hannah's sense of self too is tried as she watches what is happening around Michael, and her relationship with her father becomes even more difficult as he carries out his job as Fire Marshal. Michael gradually comes to realise that the people around him are there to help and that it is not always his job to be strong.
Sacrifice is a very poignant final book in the series and its title says it all. Michael has sacrificed his life as a young man, giving up what others would have had: study, college, a job, parties and girlfriends, all to look after his brothers. But others make sacrifices too, and there are a few tears to be shed in this book as Kemmerer brings the series to a close.
Fans of the previous books won't be disappointed. I read this is a single sitting and was engrossed for all of it.
Pat Pledger

Once upon a Dork: Tales from a not-so-fabulous life by Rachel Renee Russell

cover image

Dork Diaries Bk 8. Simon & Schuster, 2014. ISBN 9781471122781
(Age: 8-11) Nikki Maxwell is back in the eighth installment of this much-loved series, a fan favourite right across the globe. Nikki records her life openly and at times is a little too honest, her diary is filled with cartoons, exclamations, emoticons and funny incidents.
Nikki attracts trouble. Imagine Brianna her sister's lunch - a peanut butter, jelly and pickle sandwich adhered to her new sweater on display on the first day of school. Even Sassy Sasha perfume can't remove the smell. When Nikki's class play Dodgeball for P.E. class of course she is the target, Mackenzie the mean girl, hits her hard in the face. Instead of waking up in a familiar environment, Nikki has a wild dream all her friends, classmates, her crush Brandon and Mackenzie have turned into fairy tale creatures. As Nikki travels through Fairy Tale Land she encounters all the Rogues, Renegades and Regals. She meets characters from the Wizard of Oz, hinders Goldilocks, is chased by the bears and attends Cinderella's ball - of course Brandon is the handsome prince.
Some of the funniest scenes are Nikki's encounters with Rapunzel, Snow White and Sleeping Beauty who are tired of being princesses and want to escape their fairy tale lives.
Rachel Renee Russell has created a likeable character whose crazy family, friends and school life provide great enjoyment for fans from 8-11.
Rhyllis Bignell

Grug the Superhero by Ted Prior

cover image

Simon & Schuster, 2014. ISBN: 9781925030501
Highly recommended for 1-5 year olds and fans!Ted Prior's Grug series has been a much loved part of early childhood reading since 1979, now parents and grandparents can share a new Grug adventure with their young ones.
When Grug wakes up, he decides he wants to be a superhero. Using his imagination he makes a stick sword and a simple cape and mask. Cara his best friend dresses up as well, making their costumes from scraps of material and yarn. Superheroes need a super car and the friends make over the Grugmobile, turning it into the Zoom Zoom Car.
Cara informs Grug that superheroes need to save someone, so the friends zoom off to look for someone who needs help. Unfortunately the Zoom Zoom Car zooms them down the slope and into a tree. Who needs to be rescued now?
A great new addition to the Grug series, simple, colorful illustrations, easy to read text and an activity that families could participate in together, making superhero costumes and building a simple go kart.
Rhyllis Bignell

Alfie in the Garden by Debi Gliori

cover image

Bloomsbury Children's Books, 2014. ISBN: 9781408839515
(Age: preschool) Theme: Imagination. This is a very simple story for pre-schoolers with a little rabbit called Alfie who leaves the side of his mother to explore in the garden.  Imagination gets a chance to play, and Alfie is shown playing in the garden in simplified illustrations, with toys and insects as companions. A fold-out page is also used to demonstrate the wider world that Alfie is entering via his imagination.
The language used is uncomplicated with a smattering of onomatopoeia and occasional rhyme and assonance.
Carolyn Hull

The Bear Said Please by Jacque Duffy

cover image

Wombat Books, 2014. ISBN 9781921632945
(Age: preschool) 'Growl,' said the bear. 'Growl,' said his tummy. 'Hmmmm,' thought the bear. I need some honey. ' And so he sets out to find some through a series of rhymes whose meaning is made clear through clever text positioning and delightful watercolour pictures. Eventually he finds what he is looking for, but it is guarded by angry bees for Bear has forgotten his manners.
Getting little ones to say please and thank you is a struggle known to all parents and this sweet story is a great way to demonstrate what might happen if you forget. You certainly don't get what you want! But apart from that, it's also a great book to engage our youngest readers because the rhymes make it a predictable text which makes it so easy for them to join in in a shared reading session, and then, together with the clear, engaging pictures encourage them to try reading it to themselves. Even the size of the book (23omm x 200mm) is just right for their hands as they start to learn about the joy of story, concepts about print, and early reading behaviours.
I can't wait to share it with Miss 3.
Barbara Braxton

Malini by Robert Hillman

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743312551.
(Age: Yrs 5-8)
'Malini watched the Tamil Tiger intently. She was standing with the other students under the six hemlocks that had been planted by the British half a century earlier. 'This year', the commander said, 'the war will be won. The soldier-martyrs of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam will tear the hearts from the chests of our enemies. In fire and blood, our homeland will be born. And you will play your part.' He extended his hand towards a group of six boys standing together under one of the hemlocks, the youngest, Malini knew, just eleven years old. 'Come to me', he said. After some hesitation, the six boys walked to the front of the gathering and lined up beside the commander. He only ever took six boys at a time..Tears found a path down Malini's face. She would never see these boys again. They would fight the enemy and they would die.'
This is not the first time that Malini has seen this and so when the soldiers come to her home at dawn and order the family outside, they go, knowing that to disobey will mean they will be killed. They are to be part of a human shield protecting the defeated soldiers as they make their way to the coast as this war between the Hindu Tamils and the government-backed Buddhist Sri Lankan Army winds down after 30 years. But on the march, Malini's father sees an opportunity for Malini and her sister Banni to escape and, pushing a mobile phone into her hands, shoves them into the forest and urges them to make their way to their grandfather's village in the north-east away from the fighting.
And so begins a remarkable tale of danger, adventure, hardship, and friendship as Malini, at just 14 becomes 'mother' and protector to Banni as well as a rag-tag crew of others as they make their way across a landscape which poses enough problems without the added peril of being caught by soldiers of either side or wandering into a village where culture dictates they will have to stay.
In an account that is balanced between Hindu and Buddhist perspectives, as well as Tamil and SLA, the author provides an amazing insight into the life of children in a war zone that, at the very least, should help our students appreciate what they have here. Malini is a strong protagonist but even she buckles at times, giving her a real personality that make her credible and the reader is compelled to read on to find out whether she will reach safe haven.
Malini is the latest is a series called Through My Eys  which 'invites young readers to enter the fragile worlds of children living in contemporary war zones' and includes Shahana set in Kashmir; Amina in Somalia; Naveed (Afghanistan); Emilio (Mexico); and, in March 2015, Zafir set in Syria. While it is tragic that conflict continues to engulf the children of the world so that there is always a story to be told, nevertheless the stories do have to be told and our students need to read them.
There is an interview with and information about Robert Hillman as well as teachers' notes for 'Malini' at the publisher's website. The book itself offers a brief history of the war and a timeline of Sri Lankan history as well as links to sources for more information. Teachers' notes and other resources for the entire series are available through the main website.
When Malala Yousafzai was asked which book she thought everyone should read, she replied Parvana (also available through Allen & Unwin) but I believe she would also recommend this series if she knew about it.
Barbara Braxton

One Minute's Silence by David Metzenthen

cover image

Ill. by Michael Camilleri. Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743316245
(Age: Yr 5+) One minute's silence is the traditional way of honouring the memory of those who have died, particularly military personnel. And during that one minute's silence, we are urged to think about those who have fallen and the sacrifice they have made for their country. But what do you really think about? Are you like the bored, disinterested Year 12 students who open this story? Do you think about the feats and fears of our soldiers and what they did? Do you ever think about what it was like for those on the other side of our bullets and bayonets? For, in this powerful picture book, we are encouraged to do just that, to consider what it was like both for those who made that fateful landing on the shores of Gallipoli in 1915 and those whom they were fighting against.
'In one minute's silence you can imagine the grinding in your guts as the ironbark bows of the Australian boats bumped the stony shore of Gallipoli on the twenty-fifth of April 1915, when twelve thousand wild colonial boys dashed across the shivering Turkish sand in the pale light of a dairy farmer's dawn lashed with flying lead. But can you imagine, in one minute's silence, lines of young Turkish soldiers from distant villages, hearts hammering, standing shoulder-to-shoulder in trenches cut like wounds.firing on strangers wading through the shallows intent on streaming into the homeland of the Turkish people.'
This remarkable retelling of the events that will form the focus of the centennial commemorations in 1915 starts with a picture of that group of senior students who have been asked to observe one minute's silence on the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month - Remembrance Day in Australia. Their expressions of here-we-go-again-we've-been-doing-this-for years have been captured perfectly in the pencil strokes of Michael Camilleri and one might wonder what this book has to offer that has not been done before. But then the narration begins and as the events unfold the students are drawn into them, gradually realising the youth and ordinariness of those who were embroiled in this conflict 100 years ago. These were kids just like them. They can put themselves in the picture, as Camilleri has. However, not only do they see themselves in the Australian uniform, but their attention is also drawn to the youth and the ordinariness of those on the other side and their perspective. They are no longer just a faceless enemy responsible for the deaths and maiming of these students' bygone family members. The futility of war is apparent.
Barbara Braxton

Golden Boys by Sonya Hartnett

cover image

Penguin, 2014. ISBN 9781926428611
(Age: Senior secondary - adult) Sonya Hartnett has crafted a story that glistens with sunlight, like the 'golden boys' of the title, yet behind the light is the dark shadow that lingers over the town with the arrival of a new family whose swimming pool, toys, and luxurious home, is the envy of the locals. Yet it is the smiling, glossy father who weaves his way sinuously into the lives of the locals, the man who showers his children with toys that are so enticing to the local boys, who is the most disturbing.
Amidst a story of boys, Hartnett focuses on Freya, the clever adolescent daughter of the Kiley family: who is lost in admiration of the glorious Rex; who sees him only as the foil to her drunk father; who beats her mother and throws his dinner plate at the wall; who fails so badly that his daughter wants to die to avenge his existence. She cannot see anything but Rex's silken charm, so at odds with her own father, and in her fearful belief that she is at the heart of her family's misery, she blames herself for their lives.
Garrick, the tough boy whose family we never see, except for his gentler brother, Avery, is the one who wants to exact vengeance for Rex's actions. Both Colt, who knows what his father is, and lives in sustained dread, and Bastian, who does not want to know anything, who has sought refuge in a world of eternal child-like innocence, are to be punished too.
Set in the sleepy indolence of a country town, this Australian story brings no solace - only an underlying sense of dread and disquiet, handled with the sure deft touch of the writer, who does not let the tension slip for an instant.
It is not a pleasant story, but it is one that soars above the mundane narrative that suggests all is well with the world. Hartnett addresses questions that most fear to raise, and above all, sadly, suggests that finding the answer is even harder. Other than Garrick's answer, there is no release from the issues with which the characters live, and no answers to the children's questions.
I would recommend Golden Boys for older adolescent readers, but with caution, because it is a deeply disturbing novel, revealing truths that could be deeply disturbing, and vibrating with the tremulous whirr of summer insects that seem harmless but sting painfully.
This is not a novel to be read and lightly forgotten. Sonya Hartnett's characters simmer and her narrative resonates with emotion, as we anticipate and sense their responses with empathy and awe.
Liz Bondar