Reviews

Hansel and Gretel by Neil Gaiman

cover image

Ill. by Lorenzo Mattotti. Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408861981
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Fairy tale, Witchcraft, Graphic novel. With brooding black and white illustrations covering every second double page, the familiar text between is permeated with ominous dread as the children are duped into going into the forest with their parents. There they are left, the first time finding their way back home using small white stones dropped to show them the way, and the second time using breadcrumbs which when eaten by the birds, leaves them stranded. They discover a gingerbread house in which lives an old woman who cages Hansel to fatten him up to eat, forcing Gretel to cook and clean the house for her. But she eventually outwits the old woman, killing her, releasing Hansel and so finding their their way back home.
Gaiman has added to the original story, ensuring that modern readers will equate the situation of the woodcutter and his family to the plight of many children living with war in our world. Famine forces the family to make this appalling decision, and today's readers will have seen instances on television news of families deciding to send their children to another country in the hope of keeping them alive or children sold into slavery to save the remainder of the family.
The illustrations are outstanding, shadowing the story with an overwhelming feeling of disquiet. The black threatening forest wraps the pages, highlighting the small figures of Hansel and Gretel, easily overshadowed by its ominous presence.
This is a book to read and reread, to ponder and discuss. It will send readers back to the original story and its many rewritings, and encourage readers to discuss the different versions available. An article on Wikipedia will help here, and it is worth the while to check library shelves to find other versions which can be read aloud and shared with the class.
And Gaiman includes an outline of the history of the story and its retellings at the end of the tale which adds another level of interest and information. In reading this with a class, it maybe helpful to encourage children to share what they know of the story before this version is read, so there is some common understandings of what the story is about, and when it was originally written, and readers will clearly see the additions and changes made by successive authors. This book is an absolute treat.
Fran Knight

Cooper Bartholomew is dead by Rebecca James

cover image

Allen & Unwin 2014. ISBN 9781743319239
(Age: 15+) Nineteen-year-old Libby has just lost her new boyfriend, Cooper, to an apparent suicide. In a series of flashbacks we learn of their romance, which began after meeting again post-high school. Libby slowly learns that Cooper is far more than the popular boy she believed didn't notice her. Thrown into the mix are two other Cooper admirers, popular, catty ex-girlfriend Claire and rich best friend Sebastian.As the romance develops we are also transported to the present and drawn into the fallout of Cooper's death and the possibility of foul play. Libby is searching for the truth and clues are slowly, if not subtly, revealed. Learning more about the characters and their respective feelings and secrets draws readers into Cooper's world. Friends and family members become suspects in the mysterious death and incidents from Cooper's past also muddy the waters.
Realistic characters and a sweet love story at the heart of this mystery provide much appeal. The final revelation is satisfying, if a little anti-climatic. The fact that Libby alone believes Cooper did not commit suicide beggars belief, but her determination to find the truth makes for a good story. Rebecca James does succeed early on in creating a compelling read in the whodunit style. Chapters told from different characters' perspectives add to the empathy and also work well to create, and then solve the mystery for readers. Also delving into themes of popularity and 'not judging a book by its cover', the combination of romance and suspense will appeal mostly to girls aged 15 and over.
Jessica Smith

Dreamers by Ezekiel Kwaymullina

cover image

Ill. by Sally Morgan. Fremantle Press, 2014. ISBN 9781922089700
(Age: 3+) Aboriginal themes, Dreaming. Children run, jump, dance and sleep across every page as the vibrant colurs swirl around them, cocooning them, and at the same time, making us more aware of their creativity and enticing the young reader to look more closely at their various poses. The images of the children at play in a multitude of situations are infectious, making the reader marvel at the variety. Sally Morgan's illustrations bring movement to the book, showing kids in all sorts of poses, making readers take note of the few words and what they mean.
Each nine syllable sentence is full of imagery, often an unusual one which readers will love to think about and discuss as they read the book. Where else have they come across children described as animal talkers and river runners, or rainbow dancers and night callers. I had to stop at the end of each phrase to muse on the range of meanings implied.
Full of fun and the joy of living, the book is a treat to read a loud and read alone. The luminous illustrations will grab the readers' attention and easily lure them into the fun and happiness of life. I can imagine lots of classes using this book as a model for their art and dance, acting and movement
I was surprised that so little information was given in the book about Ezekiel and Sally as this always gives clues about the background of the author and illustrator and perhaps point to where the ideas came from.
Information on Fremantle Press website, gives more information about this partnership of author and illustrator and teacher notes can be found here.
Fran Knight

Jake in Space: Moon Attack by Candice Lemon-Scott

cover image

New Frontier Publishing, 2014. ISBN 9781925059090
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. The opening chapter of this story should engage its readers - driving at age 11, telepathy, living on a space station, going to the moon . . .
Our main character, Jake, has struggled to pass his space car driving test and is now being sent to remedial driving school. To say he is embarrassed is probably an understatement! The story continues as Jake starts to make new friends but there is something strange about Henry. He talks funny, seems to know everything and Jake is sure he saw Henry going outside without a space suit. Impossible! Who is Henry? Is he a robot? Is he the good guy? Why is he always sneaking around?
Jake in Space: Moon Attack moves quickly, is full of all things 'spacey' and will take readers on an imaginative journey to the impossible. It is highly recommended for readers aged 9+. The vocabulary used is descriptive but easy to read, it is full of whizz bang technology we see in the movies and will have readers engaged from beginning to end.
Kylie Kempster

The talkative tombstone by Ursula Dubosarsky

cover image

Ill. by Terry Denton. The cryptic casebook of Coco Carlomagno series. Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743319529
(Ages 6-9) Highly recommended. This is the sixth book in the popular Coco Carlomagno series. Alberta the guinea pig is very excited to receive a card from her cousin Coco, the chief of police in Buenos Aires. She travels to South America where together they must solve the mystery of why the tombstone of a beloved tango singer has started to talk. Once again Alberta's practical nature helps the anxious Coco to remain calm when his nerves threaten to get the better of him.
Containing puzzles, codes to break and amusing illustrations by the wonderful Terry Denton, this book will delight children as they help the characters to solve the mystery. There are some great examples of amusing word-play to engage the imagination, and as with the other titles in the series, readers are also introduced to some Spanish words via a glossary.
Donella Reed

The Awesome Book of Awesomeness by Adam Frost

cover image

Bloomsbury Publishing, 2014. ISBN 9781408851180
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. The Awesome Book of Awesomeness is a fun filled fact book with eye catching illustrations. Find out how big the largest donut is. Find out how many hours of sleep different animals need compared to humans. Do you want to find out how long the longest roller coaster is?
Highly recommended for all readers aged 8+. It would be great for reluctant readers due to the small amounts of text and a different topic on each page.
Kylie Kempster

Look and See by Shane Morgan

cover image

Magabala Books, 2014. ISBN 9781922142221.
Highly recommended for emerging readers or your kids who may be struggling with reading. What a delightful Early Reader book this is! Apparently first released 1999, this a super picture book with simple text and striking illustrations for beginning readers. Earthy colours and an array of Australian native fauna are combined to give the developing young reader a resonant reading experience. This is the Australian version of those wonderful PM Early Readers my Year 1s thrived on many years ago. The rhyming text is not complex but also never dull.
Shane Morgan, can you please do some more?
I love the simple and repetitive but not 'same' text and I adore the stylised illustrations with the echoed colours.
If you have Preppies, children challenged to read or young disengaged readers, this is a terrific book - and I do hope to see more.
Sue Warren

The unexpected crocodile by Kim Kane

cover image

Ill. by Sara Acton. Allen and Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781760111731
(Ages: 5+) Recommended. Picture book, Paperback edition, Cautionary tale. The glorious scene of the unexpected crocodile turning up to Peggy's place to join the family for dinner, will entice readers into this book. With his bright red umbrella and jaunty red bow tie, the crocodile almost swaggers into the house. It has rained for weeks, and mum and dad have been frantically getting the sodden house ready for their neighbours, but when answering the doorbell, Peggy is surprised by the crocodile asking if the Dawsons have already arrived. 10 minutes later, they do arrive, complete with their three rather unlovely boys and a croquembouche that Mrs Dawson has made for desert, telling everyone that the boys made it. The boys each reject the food offered and the crocodile eats their mother, boots and all. Later, when looking at the clock, he eats Mr Dawson, and when the odious boys ask for croquembouche rather than the coleslaw, he eats them too. A wonderful end to an obnoxious family.  This story will bring whoops of laughter from its audience as the crocodile does the most unexpected things. Readers will laugh as the crocodile dressed in his best bow tie turns up to dinner, and whoop with delight when he eats the lying mother, the timid father and the three nasty boys. Salting them first of course.
The wonderful illustrations will beguile the most diffident of readers into the story, adding another level of humour to the words, and acquainting them with a wide vocabulary as they read.  Sara Acton's website gives further illustrations which children will love, particularly the one of her on the home page, burrowing away with her drawing. Kim Kane's other books include Pip, the story of Olive and The vegetable ark, both of which are award winners. This is a paperback edition of the book first published as a hardcover in 2012. It is great to see it once more, and I laughed out loud all over again, as will the readers.
Fran Knight

Rooms by Lauren Oliver

cover image

Hodder and Stoughton, 2014. ISBN 9781444760774
(Age: Adult - Senior secondary) Recommended. 'People, Caroline thought were like houses. They could open their doors. You could walk through their rooms and touch the objects hidden in their corners. But something - the structure, the wiring, the invisible mechanism that kept the whole thing standing - remained invisible, suggested only by the fact of its existence at all' p310. This is the premise behind Lauren Oliver's latest book. A premise she explores through the creation of a house in Coral River which is initially inhabited by the ghosts of Margaret and Alice. But their tenuous peace is rudely interrupted when the current owner of the house, Richard Walker dies and his somewhat estranged and definitely dysfunctional family return to 'clean up'. The reader is introduced to Richard's alcoholic ex-wife Caroline, her sex crazed daughter, Minna and barely functioning son, Trenton. As the family cleans out each room the reader is given background commentary of events that have taken place both in the lives of the living and the dead: some that are shocking and others that are just sad. As the traumatic days before Richard's Memorial service pass secrets and lies are revealed. To add to the mix another ghost arrives and a strange girl enters Trenton's life who in the end could be his saviour.
While the story is a jigsaw of events in its structure it is bound together by the remembrances of all of these personalities and the reader's desire to know the truth behind their apparently dysfunctional lives. Yet despite their behaviour it is difficult to really dislike any of the characters especially as more and more of their history is revealed. The death of a family member, as always, evokes memories of forgotten times, both pleasurable and disturbing.
A bright light of the narrative is Minna's young daughter Amy, who while being aware of the ghosts is innocent in her perception.
While this novel is 'disturbing' it is not the supernatural that makes it so. It is the tragedy of these people's lives and the truth of what Trenton says at the end that, 'The past 'comes' along with you whether you want it to or not' p336.
Barb Rye

Tim and Ed by Ursula Dubosarsky

cover image

Ill. by Andrew Joyner. Penguin, 2014. ISBN 9780670074631
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Siblings, Twins, Similarities, Difference, Independence. Twin koalas, Tim and Ed are the same. they have the same faces, arms, legs and noses. They look at their father and wonder why there is only one of him, and the ducks when there are so many ducklings. When Tim falls into the pond he is pulled out by Dad, and Ed jumps in as well. After a noisy bath time Dad tells the boys that Auntie Pim is taking Ed to stay with her for one night. Tim is rather dismayed but Dad says they will do lots together. At each house, Tim is shown with Dad having a good time on their bikes, while Ed is enjoying his stay with Auntie Pim, playing trains. But at night when they go to bed, a little wistfulness occurs, as Tim looks over at the empty bed in their bedroom, and Ed looks sadly at his image in the mirror.
The following day when Ed returns, Auntie Pim says that she will take Tim for an overnight stay next time. The three go down to the pond again and see that the ducklings are no longer there. They have grown up and flown away.
In four line stanzas, Dubosarsky tells her story of difference. Tim and Ed may be the same, looking the same, but they are different beings, and in this story they are growing up, like the ducklings, soon to fly on their own, but with a strong family and sibling bond behind them. This is a lovely story of difference, of accepting difference and similarity, of a child's place in the family, of growing up. With its wonderful vibrant illustrations, showing the two being together, of doing all sorts of things together, then staying apart for one night, Joyner ensures that the readership will empathise with the two little boys and their developing independence.
Fran Knight

Deadly D and Justice Jones: Making the Team by Scott Prince and Dave Hartley

cover image

Magabala Books, 2014. ISBN 9781922142184
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Dylan is 11 and has moved from Mt Isa to Brisbane as a result of his mum's new job. On his first day of school, Dylan tries to help a boy being bullied when he is attacked as well. Unfortunately, Dylan is cursed and the bullies get a bit more than they bargained for. When Dylan gets angry, he changes into a huge, hairy man creature. Thankfully, Dylan still manages to make a friend - Justice Jones. There is also another good thing that comes from this curse - he is seen by the Broncos rugby league team and asked to join them as a player.
Deadly D and Justice Jones is an easy to read, quick moving story. The main character is Aboriginal and his best mate is from New Zealand, giving all boys who love reading a positive role model no matter their cultural background. The book has a definitive Aussie flavour, from the slang used by Dylan to the towns it is set in. It would be great for reluctant readers who are a little bit sport mad and the fact this was co-written by a rugby league player is another drawcard. Highly recommended for boys aged 8+.
Kylie Kempster

Santa's Outback Secret by Mike Dumbleton

cover image

Ill. by Tom Jellett. Random House, 2014. ISBN 9780857982254
(Age: Preschool - Yr 3) It is just a couple of weeks before Christmas and Santa is very busy carefully reading his Christmas mail. But when he opens a letter from Ben, he pauses and thinks and reads it again and again. For Ben has requested something really special . . . something that makes Santa interrupt his Christmas preparations, put on a disguise and leave the North Pole.. Dressed in some torn blue jeans stained with dirt, a snake-skin belt and an open shirt, old boots, a hat, a waterbag, a stockman's whip and a canvas swag, he has his reindeer fly him to the outback where he finds an old homestead and knocks on the door . . . (if I say much more I will give away the secret!)
This is another fun story in rhyme from Mike Dumbleton and Tom Jellett who brought us Santa's Secret a couple of years ago and which was such a hit with young students. They really liked the idea that they might meet a stranger on the beach and I'm sure many spent their Christmas holidays in anticipation! Finding Christmas stories that are a bit different can be a difficult task but I really enjoyed this one because it focuses on the giving side of Christmas rather than the getting. Santa is struck by the unselfishness of Ben's request and it opens up the possibilities of what we can do for someone as a gift rather than what we can buy.
If you are looking for a new Christmas story to add to your collection, this would be an ideal addition.
Barbara Braxton

Cartboy goes to camp by L.A. Campbell

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743317754
(Ages: 8-12) Hal Rifkind, a.k.a. Cartboy, returns in this second title in the series. Hal's dad is sending him to summer camp at Camp Jamestown, the only problem being that this is a history camp, where nothing has changed for 400 years. Of course, the school bully is also at the camp, tormenting Hal and generally making life even more miserable. At least Hal and his new friends have something to keep their minds off their worries - a treasure map!
The book is written as a series of letters to a futuristic being (Hal is hoping they will find a way of travelling back through time to save him from camp) and it feels too contrived, playing to the Diary of a Wimpy Kid format. While some of the time-line illustrations are amusing, many of the other photos and pictures don't really add anything to the book other than breaking up the text. The stereotyping of the major characters and too many coincidences and story-leaps may be annoying for many readers, and Australian children won't relate to the American idea of summer camp.
Donella Reed

Frozen by Melissa de la Cruz and Michael Johnston

cover image

Heart of dread series, bk 1. Orchard, 2014. ISBN 9781408334669
(Age: 15+) Post-Apocalyptic fiction. Gambling. Dystopia. Adventure. Natasha Kestal is trying to get out of New Vegas, a city now covered in ice, but still a place where crowds come to the casino in a desperate bid to win. Nat is a blackjack dealer who longs to go to 'the Blue' a mythical place where the sky is still blue and the sun shines. She bets on a little group of mercenaries led by Ryan Wesson to get her there, but can she keep the mark showing her magical nature a secret from this ragtag group?
This is a strange blend of fantasy and science fiction. There are the usual features of fantasy: dragons and little men, but the world that is inhabited is one that has been taken over by ice and fits into a scenario usually found in Science Fiction. This interesting world provides the background for the action that is the predominant feature of the book. Thrills and spills galore, chases through the countryside and danger at sea and evil pirates all keep the reader engaged.
Natasha, the main character is likeable and it is easy to become engrossed in her struggle with her magical nature and her dream of arriving in a safe place. The budding romance between her and Ryan is secondary to the action, but there is enough to keep those who enjoy romance keen to find out how it progresses.
Short sentences would make it a relative easy read for less able and reluctant readers. However the gambling background of Las Vegas and the age of the protagonists lends itself to older adolescents. A cliff-hanger will ensure that those who enjoyed the story will pick up the next in the series.
Pat Pledger

Chu's First Day at School by Neil Gaiman

cover image

Ill. by Adam Rex. Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408847039
It is Chu's first day at school, and like every new-starter he is worried that the others won't like and they won't be friendly. He is somewhat dismayed when his teacher asks them all to share their names and something they are really good at. One by one, she writes their names and special talents on the board - so many that she has to keep rubbing them off and starting again. All the while Chu says nothing but at last it is his turn and suddenly everyone finds out what he is good at - with catastrophic results.
I've been holding this book back until schools start thinking about next year's new entrants as transitions to Kindergarten start to happen and 'big school' is really in the picture. This is lovely blend of the anticipation and nerves that beset every child who is starting this new adventure, delightfully offset by Gaiman's humour and Rex's illustrations.
Barbara Braxton